{
  "schema_version": "source-computed-hypothesis-catalogue/1.0.0",
  "version": "2026-10-07-source103-v1",
  "published_on": "2026-10-07",
  "publication_status": "public_unscored_research_hypotheses",
  "default_sort": "formula",
  "download_url": "/research-hypotheses/source-computed-candidates-2026-10-07.json",
  "scope": "Previously private source-model screening is now published as unscored source-computed material-design hypotheses. Historical private-screening wording is retained as context. These predictions are new to this reviewed catalogue only; experimental confirmation, worldwide first discovery, formal RPS and human scientific review are not claimed.",
  "source_tc_scope": "Source isotropic Eliashberg Tc in K at mu*=0.1 is a model result, not experimental Tc. It is a separate source product and is not associated with an individual Gaussian width or a numerical uncertainty interval.",
  "pairing_response_scope": "Retained ten-width lambda contrasts and independent source Tc products support bounded source-model comparisons. Chemical, mass, volume, sampling, spin and SOC effects can co-change; no universal causal or error-bound interpretation is assigned.",
  "risk_tag_scope": "Attention labels support browsing. Element labels are not measured magnetic ground states, rejection criteria or calibrated potential scores; no label does not mean no risk.",
  "evidence_scope": "Public record IDs, archive directory locators, scientific summaries and artifact digests are retained. Digest-only references are not represented as public downloads. Full source data are available from the cited Materials Cloud record; exact per-material URLs are not invented.",
  "counts": {
    "composition_groups": 103,
    "formal_RPS_scored": 0,
    "human_reviewed": 0,
    "experimental_confirmed": 0,
    "room_temperature_supported": 0
  },
  "pathway_status": {
    "geometry_construction": 103,
    "quantified_physical_bandwidth": 0,
    "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": 0
  },
  "dataset_source": {
    "title": "Sampling the materials space for conventional superconducting compounds",
    "version": "Materials Cloud 2023.163 v1",
    "authors": [
      "Tiago F. T. Cerqueira",
      "Antonio Sanna",
      "Miguel A. L. Marques"
    ],
    "url": "https://archive.materialscloud.org/records/3kbt5-r3n56",
    "doi": "10.24435/materialscloud:qv-bq",
    "license": "CC BY 4.0",
    "license_basis": "metadata.rights from primary record API",
    "license_url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/",
    "attribution": "Source data: Tiago F. T. Cerqueira, Antonio Sanna and Miguel A. L. Marques, Sampling the materials space for conventional superconducting compounds, Materials Cloud 2023.163 v1, DOI 10.24435/materialscloud:qv-bq, CC BY 4.0. This catalogue is a derived projection with additional source-state screening commentary."
  },
  "risk_tag_labels": {
    "technetium": "Technetium follow-up practicality",
    "hydrogen_anharmonicity": "Hydrogen zero-point / anharmonic response",
    "magnetic_model": "Spin-model sensitivity",
    "metastable_phase": "Phase / ordering competition",
    "residual_force_stress": "Residual force / stress sensitivity",
    "sampling_method": "Sampling / method sensitivity"
  },
  "projection_provenance": {
    "source_index_sha256": "591c01a4b3b91a808698a07ef6cb1436749467483dfd2e33a0b3f4b4e8b0829b",
    "frozen_catalogue_sha256": "851ee6814b5201cb337ef566c3f00acde928849a1298908d1b1c680cba3ceae1",
    "publication_eligibility_sha256": "0e3a11c37594feafc6d9cdab398112c8980955777257ccb049779a6ccb526f3a",
    "frozen_sources_changed": false,
    "new_scientific_calculations": 0,
    "public_wording_corrections": [
      {
        "formula": "Nb2HfTa",
        "field": "seven_criteria.novelty",
        "reason": "Replace the unrelated Nb2TiMo precedent with the different-composition HfNbTa precedent; numerical and frozen source records unchanged."
      }
    ]
  },
  "candidates": [
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003195936",
      "formula": "Be4AlRe",
      "reduced_formula": "Be4AlRe",
      "composition": {
        "Al": 1,
        "Be": 4,
        "Re": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Al:1|Be:4|Re:1",
      "elements": [
        "Al",
        "Be",
        "Re"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003195936",
      "control_state": "agm003202332",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Be4AlRe_agm003195936",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Be4AlTc_agm003202332",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "CIF_source_record": 13409,
        "CIF_payload_pin": {
          "bytes": 591661,
          "sha256": "93c3ce21c362fc36392db6d13f4555d76cce96122769d1212414bbc770f81541"
        },
        "SCF_coarse_source_record": 13421,
        "Gamma_source_pin": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/Be4AlRe_agm003195936",
          "bytes": 18614,
          "sha256": "44e392980aab18fb0620f00957c8c26fba9fd4105c38bf7b3b093670db5d73f8"
        },
        "source_input_volume_difference_relative": 8.383249650023572e-11,
        "occupancy_model_all1": true,
        "bounded_signed_axis_and_translation_mapping": {
          "signed_axis_U_CIF_fractional_to_SCF": [
            [
              1,
              0,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              1,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              0,
              1
            ]
          ],
          "determinant": 1,
          "origin_shift_fractional": [
            -3.322038977238151e-09,
            5.513520084932111e-09,
            -3.322038977238151e-09
          ],
          "species_bijection_CIF_to_SCF": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            3,
            4,
            5
          ],
          "maximum_site_distance_A": 4.392476979625943e-08,
          "relative_Gram_residual": 8.056982346555717e-10,
          "proper_signed_axis_solution": true
        },
        "attempts": 1,
        "general_GL3_or_chiral_equivalence_asserted": false,
        "CIF_site_precision_A_tolerance": 1e-05,
        "physical_model": "source finite neutral scalar EPC; no SOC transfer certificate"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 12.18,
        "control_K": 11.632,
        "delta_K": 0.548,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.2127000000000001,
          0.05740000000000001,
          0.04479999999999995,
          0.04730000000000001,
          0.05249999999999999,
          0.05740000000000001,
          0.06030000000000002,
          0.0615,
          0.0615,
          0.06059999999999999
        ],
        "range": [
          0.04479999999999995,
          0.2127000000000001
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Light Be framework with Re/Tc mass, chemistry and scalar-SOC approximation coupled; source gain is not a universal 5d or bandwidth effect. Fine residual force is 0.01375 eV/A, so fine-grid equilibrium and any SOC shift remain refinement uncertainties.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse force 6.32365997844544e-05 eV/Å, pressure -0.0 GPa; fine force 0.013753515124951335 eV/Å, pressure -0.134 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
      "route_response": "Re-for-Tc Be4Al role substitution. coupled chemical/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
      "next_action": "At the same source SG216 Be geometry, resolve saved orbital-resolved EPC and Re/Tc mode contributions. Favorable: the observed gain survives method-matched active modes; adverse: it reverses under independently justified integration/Coulomb treatment; ambiguous: mode/orbital association unavailable.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact source CIF/SCF/Γ state association; CIF source record 13409. Experimental occupancy/P/T and physical magnetic ground state remain unknown; source scalar model only.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Re-for-Tc Be4Al role substitution. coupled chemical/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
        "pairing_relevance": "direct published source EPC and independent source isotropic Eliashberg result. 1 favorable comparator(s); bounded source model, not experiment.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse force 6.32365997844544e-05 eV/Å, pressure -0.0 GPa; fine force 0.013753515124951335 eV/Å, pressure -0.134 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Light Be framework with Re/Tc mass, chemistry and scalar-SOC approximation coupled; source gain is not a universal 5d or bandwidth effect. Fine residual force is 0.01375 eV/A, so fine-grid equilibrium and any SOC shift remain refinement uncertainties.",
        "novelty": "Exact Be4AlRe/AlBe4Re query found no primary experimental exact phase. Closest retrieved Be experimental study contains ReBe2 and WBe13, different compositions/prototypes; current object is an already published computed SG216 source state, new only to this reviewed catalogue.",
        "decision": "At the same source SG216 Be geometry, resolve saved orbital-resolved EPC and Re/Tc mode contributions. Favorable: the observed gain survives method-matched active modes; adverse: it reverses under independently justified integration/Coulomb treatment; ambiguous: mode/orbital association unavailable."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "residual_force_stress",
        "sampling_method"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 8,
          "control": "batch-a/Be4AlTc_agm003202332",
          "target": "batch-a/Be4AlRe_agm003195936",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.04479999999999995,
            0.2127000000000001
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            6.0418071476736275,
            25.725689404934702
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 12.18,
          "Tc_control_K": 11.632,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 0.548,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.005203180604073,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 6.2577879324726515e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.04479999999999995,
            0.2127000000000001
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-01-ten-specific-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 381754,
          "sha256": "5d05478212c4d22080ab1b7bf22d92b784de6c0f8a99590d0758f9cdbfdafb32",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-remaining-transition-owned-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 5381838,
          "sha256": "62f4910578c7b65392d26619cf81b31afd6142f38aa49834a70bb147e7ab222d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to the reviewed candidate mechanism catalogue, source prediction already published; not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003204399",
      "formula": "Be4ZrRh",
      "reduced_formula": "Be4ZrRh",
      "composition": {
        "Be": 4,
        "Rh": 1,
        "Zr": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Be:4|Rh:1|Zr:1",
      "elements": [
        "Be",
        "Rh",
        "Zr"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003204399",
      "control_state": "agm001171196",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Be4ZrRh_agm003204399",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Be4NbRh_agm001171196",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "CIF_source_record": 1261,
        "CIF_payload_pin": {
          "bytes": 591661,
          "sha256": "93c3ce21c362fc36392db6d13f4555d76cce96122769d1212414bbc770f81541"
        },
        "SCF_coarse_source_record": 1273,
        "Gamma_source_pin": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/Be4ZrRh_agm003204399",
          "bytes": 18614,
          "sha256": "c88b4457b6f30ce67f99f4e4753b8389d949bbbaf17f31c80732143f78a16217"
        },
        "source_input_volume_difference_relative": 4.826339328189988e-11,
        "occupancy_model_all1": true,
        "bounded_signed_axis_and_translation_mapping": {
          "signed_axis_U_CIF_fractional_to_SCF": [
            [
              1,
              0,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              1,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              0,
              1
            ]
          ],
          "determinant": 1,
          "origin_shift_fractional": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species_bijection_CIF_to_SCF": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            3,
            4,
            5
          ],
          "maximum_site_distance_A": 6.242651888380239e-08,
          "relative_Gram_residual": 1.67948954662245e-09,
          "proper_signed_axis_solution": true
        },
        "attempts": 1,
        "general_GL3_or_chiral_equivalence_asserted": false,
        "CIF_site_precision_A_tolerance": 1e-05,
        "physical_model": "source finite neutral scalar EPC; no SOC transfer certificate"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 21.779,
        "control_K": 13.859,
        "delta_K": 7.92,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.2804,
          0.2882,
          0.3369,
          0.3576999999999999,
          0.34030000000000005,
          0.30099999999999993,
          0.2551,
          0.21089999999999998,
          0.17189999999999994,
          0.1391
        ],
        "range": [
          0.1391,
          0.3576999999999999
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "All three frozen neighbors retained. More nominal electrons is already opposed by Nb comparison: Zr state pairs more strongly. ROOT finite native envelope is also lower for Zr than Nb; physical W/mobile n is not claimed. Versions differ across neighbors and fine force is 0.02809 eV/A; this is source finite scalar pairing support, not independent method certification.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse force 0.00022400006825056733 eV/Å, pressure 0.0 GPa; fine force 0.02809263679016012 eV/Å, pressure 0.020999999999999998 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
      "route_response": "coupled Hf-to-Zr or Ir-to-Rh role construction in Be4XRh. coupled chemical/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
      "next_action": "Read existing Be/Rh/X mode/orbital-resolved evidence to distinguish the large Ir→Rh and Nb→Zr pairing changes. Favorable: coupling gain persists on matched NC/scalar conditions; adverse: a relevant spin/SOC or numerical control reverses it; ambiguous: band envelope alone or missing projections cannot identify cause.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact source CIF/SCF/Γ state association; CIF source record 1261. Experimental occupancy/P/T and physical magnetic ground state remain unknown; source scalar model only.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "coupled Hf-to-Zr or Ir-to-Rh role construction in Be4XRh. coupled chemical/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
        "pairing_relevance": "direct published source EPC and independent source isotropic Eliashberg result. 3 favorable comparator(s); bounded source model, not experiment.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse force 0.00022400006825056733 eV/Å, pressure 0.0 GPa; fine force 0.02809263679016012 eV/Å, pressure 0.020999999999999998 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "All three frozen neighbors retained. More nominal electrons is already opposed by Nb comparison: Zr state pairs more strongly. ROOT finite native envelope is also lower for Zr than Nb; physical W/mobile n is not claimed. Versions differ across neighbors and fine force is 0.02809 eV/A; this is source finite scalar pairing support, not independent method certification.",
        "novelty": "Exact Be4ZrRh/Be4RhZr queries found no primary experimental exact phase. Closest named computed SG216 reference is Be4NbRh in the primary source paper high-precision table; Hf and Ir neighbors are actual independent source states. No worldwide first-discovery claim.",
        "decision": "Read existing Be/Rh/X mode/orbital-resolved evidence to distinguish the large Ir→Rh and Nb→Zr pairing changes. Favorable: coupling gain persists on matched NC/scalar conditions; adverse: a relevant spin/SOC or numerical control reverses it; ambiguous: band envelope alone or missing projections cannot identify cause."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "residual_force_stress",
        "sampling_method"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 10,
          "control": "batch-a/Be4NbRh_agm001171196",
          "target": "batch-a/Be4ZrRh_agm003204399",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.1391,
            0.3576999999999999
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            21.61616161616162,
            43.1743212382644
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 21.779,
          "Tc_control_K": 13.859,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 7.92,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": false,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.0629927503842318,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.8687371762052771e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.1391,
            0.3576999999999999
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 11,
          "control": "batch-a/Be4RhHf_agm001171244",
          "target": "batch-a/Be4ZrRh_agm003204399",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.012699999999999934,
            0.20520000000000005
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            1.6495648785556478,
            17.187369126392497
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 21.779,
          "Tc_control_K": 21.202,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 0.5769999999999982,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.0170597972869821,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 2.367440548061379e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.012699999999999934,
            0.20520000000000005
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 13,
          "control": "batch-a/Be4ZrIr_agm003202351",
          "target": "batch-a/Be4ZrRh_agm003204399",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.08960000000000001,
            0.3429
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            12.92929292929293,
            37.191925950708146
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 21.779,
          "Tc_control_K": 14.238,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 7.541,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.0020748851931374,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 2.654113598498635e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.08960000000000001,
            0.3429
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-01-ten-specific-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 381754,
          "sha256": "5d05478212c4d22080ab1b7bf22d92b784de6c0f8a99590d0758f9cdbfdafb32",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-remaining-transition-owned-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 5381838,
          "sha256": "62f4910578c7b65392d26619cf81b31afd6142f38aa49834a70bb147e7ab222d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to the reviewed candidate mechanism catalogue, source prediction already published; not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm002664904",
      "formula": "Cr2MoTc",
      "reduced_formula": "Cr2MoTc",
      "composition": {
        "Cr": 2,
        "Mo": 1,
        "Tc": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Cr:2|Mo:1|Tc:1",
      "elements": [
        "Cr",
        "Mo",
        "Tc"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm002664904",
      "control_state": "agm002145097",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Cr2MoTc_agm002664904",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Cr2MoRe_agm002145097",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 225. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "symprec_A": 0.0001,
        "mode": "color_aware",
        "status": "completed",
        "SG_number": 225,
        "hall_number": 523,
        "input_wyckoff_letters": [
          "c",
          "c",
          "b",
          "a"
        ],
        "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
          0,
          0,
          2,
          3
        ]
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 18.783,
        "control_K": 14.195,
        "delta_K": 4.588000000000001,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.2175999999999999,
          0.20489999999999997,
          0.18730000000000002,
          0.17220000000000002,
          0.15959999999999996,
          0.1492,
          0.14049999999999996,
          0.13319999999999999,
          0.12739999999999996,
          0.12260000000000004
        ],
        "range": [
          0.12260000000000004,
          0.2175999999999999
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "L21-style Cr2(Mo)(Tc) colored occupancy vs Re substitution has matched grids/cutoff and ten-sign-consistent EPC gain. Cr-Cr network2.9614A differs from dense Laves Cr networks; no experimental magnetic label is inherited.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
      "route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
      "next_action": "Spin susceptibility/site moments under two seeds and common-grid orbital response; lowered magnetic branch or disappearance of common-sigma benefit reverses.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "CIF lattice/sites to both SCFinputs andGamma atomicheader via speciesbijection/wholetranslation; 1e-6A observationaltolerance, not physicaluncertainty",
        "novelty": "Bounded exact formula/prototype primary search; published source calculations not claimed as first discovery. New-to-reviewed exact ordered hypothesis only. Literature-wide novelty unproved.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
        "pairing_relevance": "All ten raw printed lambda values andseparate mu*=.1 sourceEliashberg/McMillan products retained; representative common-sigma response isnotrenamed Tc_uncertainty. Spinfluctuations/anisotropy omitted.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "L21-style Cr2(Mo)(Tc) colored occupancy vs Re substitution has matched grids/cutoff and ten-sign-consistent EPC gain. Cr-Cr network2.9614A differs from dense Laves Cr networks; no experimental magnetic label is inherited.",
        "decision": "Spin susceptibility/site moments under two seeds and common-grid orbital response; lowered magnetic branch or disappearance of common-sigma benefit reverses."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "magnetic_model",
        "sampling_method",
        "technetium"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr2MoRe_agm002145097",
            "batch-a/Cr2MoTc_agm002664904"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr2MoRe_agm002145097",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr2MoTc_agm002664904",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.2175999999999999,
            0.20489999999999997,
            0.18730000000000002,
            0.17220000000000002,
            0.15959999999999996,
            0.1492,
            0.14049999999999996,
            0.13319999999999999,
            0.12739999999999996,
            0.12260000000000004
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.12260000000000004,
            0.2175999999999999
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              14.195
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              18.783
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 4.588000000000001,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 16
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr2MoTc_agm002664904",
            "batch-a/Cr2TcW_agm002665225"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr2MoTc_agm002664904",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr2TcW_agm002665225",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.1614,
            -0.1591999999999999,
            -0.13849999999999996,
            -0.12460000000000004,
            -0.11639999999999995,
            -0.11170000000000002,
            -0.1089,
            -0.10739999999999994,
            -0.10660000000000003,
            -0.10599999999999998
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.1614,
            -0.10599999999999998
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              18.783
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              15.24
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -3.543000000000001,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 18
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr2MoTc_agm002664904",
            "batch-a/Cr3Tc_agm002145239"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr2MoTc_agm002664904",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr3Tc_agm002145239",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.2550999999999999,
            -0.2025999999999999,
            -0.18079999999999996,
            -0.16769999999999996,
            -0.15649999999999997,
            -0.1472,
            -0.1402,
            -0.13480000000000003,
            -0.13049999999999995,
            -0.12649999999999995
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.2550999999999999,
            -0.12649999999999995
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              18.783
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              15.804
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -2.979000000000001,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 19
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr2MoTc_agm002664904",
            "batch-a/Mo3Tc_agm003165329"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr2MoTc_agm002664904",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Mo3Tc_agm003165329",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.12630000000000008,
            0.08309999999999995,
            0.05669999999999997,
            0.04200000000000004,
            0.03660000000000008,
            0.03539999999999999,
            0.035700000000000065,
            0.03639999999999999,
            0.036599999999999966,
            0.03600000000000003
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.03539999999999999,
            0.12630000000000008
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              18.783
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              17.722
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -1.061,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": null,
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 20
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "coarse": {
          "source_record": 3231,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 12May2023 at 17:53:48"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 5,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000000     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 4,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 0.0,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.0,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.0,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                0.0,
                -0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              "atom_index": 1,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": 0.05,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "0.05",
              "GPa": 0.005
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=        0.05"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    3.2e-07,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.05,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    3.2e-07,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.05,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    3.2e-07,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.05
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  0.005,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.005,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.0,
                  0.005
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": 0.05000000000000001,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.005,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -674.23765839,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-674.23765839"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": 1.814e-05,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "0.00001814"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -674.2376765299999
        },
        "fine": {
          "source_record": 3232,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 12May2023 at 17:46: 8"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 7,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 2,
              "last": {
                "value": "c_bands:  1 eigenvalues not converged"
              }
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000000     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 4,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 0.0,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.0,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.0,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                -0.0
              ],
              "atom_index": 1,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": 0.6,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "0.60",
              "GPa": 0.06
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=        0.60"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    4.07e-06,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.6,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    4.07e-06,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.6,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    4.07e-06,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.6
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  0.06,
                  -0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  0.06,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.06
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": 0.6,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.06,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -674.23713164,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-674.23713164"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": -0.00018776,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-0.00018776"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -674.23694388
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "Gamma_optical_sign": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "Gamma_optical_minimum": 7.743678394179404e-07,
          "Gamma_printing_bound": 1.3753161217936882e-12,
          "Gamma_native_signed_modes": [
            {
              "number": 1,
              "THz": -0.748666,
              "cm_inverse": -24.972796,
              "line": 86
            },
            {
              "number": 2,
              "THz": -0.748666,
              "cm_inverse": -24.972796,
              "line": 91
            },
            {
              "number": 3,
              "THz": -0.748666,
              "cm_inverse": -24.972796,
              "line": 96
            },
            {
              "number": 4,
              "THz": 2.897371,
              "cm_inverse": 96.645902,
              "line": 101
            },
            {
              "number": 5,
              "THz": 2.897371,
              "cm_inverse": 96.645902,
              "line": 106
            },
            {
              "number": 6,
              "THz": 2.897371,
              "cm_inverse": 96.645902,
              "line": 111
            },
            {
              "number": 7,
              "THz": 6.916008,
              "cm_inverse": 230.693188,
              "line": 116
            },
            {
              "number": 8,
              "THz": 6.916008,
              "cm_inverse": 230.693188,
              "line": 121
            },
            {
              "number": 9,
              "THz": 6.916008,
              "cm_inverse": 230.693188,
              "line": 126
            },
            {
              "number": 10,
              "THz": 7.876864,
              "cm_inverse": 262.743908,
              "line": 131
            },
            {
              "number": 11,
              "THz": 7.876864,
              "cm_inverse": 262.743908,
              "line": 136
            },
            {
              "number": 12,
              "THz": 7.876864,
              "cm_inverse": 262.743908,
              "line": 141
            }
          ],
          "Gamma_ASR_relative": 0.007560324171147499,
          "Gamma_source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/Cr2MoTc_agm002664904",
            "bytes": 8994,
            "sha256": "327005f147415cc1721008d3b6cd045f7b151e89af7709fe4a82cce181487b53"
          }
        },
        "finite_path": {
          "raw_header_lines": [],
          "negative_printed_values": 0,
          "minimum_printed_mode": {
            "value": -0.0,
            "column_index_zero_based": 1
          },
          "frequency_unit_header": null,
          "fullBZ_coverage": null,
          "dynamical_stability": null,
          "state_link_verified": null
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm002664904",
          "dyn0_source_record": 3215,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                4.0,
                4.0,
                4.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                8.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 3222,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 3223,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 3224,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 3225,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 5,
              "source_record": 3226,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 6,
              "source_record": 3227,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 7,
              "source_record": 3228,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 8,
              "source_record": 3229,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 8,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "composition-assessments.json",
          "bytes": 1863044,
          "sha256": "5fc901f5f4a90b41e807722d92f39d81714b70091a189cdb5eba13367624350b",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "numeric-review.json",
          "bytes": 4542684,
          "sha256": "c4fae01d3d67f774429114902a6b39f5b133de48ea81d3d9773ba40ff4419ce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-two-PH-actual-complete-response-products-readback-v1.json",
          "bytes": 77119,
          "sha256": "434c5fe7a590607adbc104dd75d126497457317bc20f37973b5013491e9fdce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Published source predictions already known; exact matched mechanism new to reviewed catalogue only, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003203668",
      "formula": "Cr2Re",
      "reduced_formula": "Cr2Re",
      "composition": {
        "Cr": 2,
        "Re": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Cr:2|Re:1",
      "elements": [
        "Cr",
        "Re"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003203668",
      "control_state": "agm003295867",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Cr2Re_agm003203668",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Cr2Re_agm003295867",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 227. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": [
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.0001,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 227,
          "hall_number": 525,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "d",
            "d",
            "d",
            "d",
            "a",
            "a"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            4,
            4
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.0001,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 227,
          "hall_number": 525,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "d",
            "d",
            "d",
            "d",
            "a",
            "a"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            4,
            4
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.001,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 227,
          "hall_number": 525,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "d",
            "d",
            "d",
            "d",
            "a",
            "a"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            4,
            4
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.001,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 227,
          "hall_number": 525,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "d",
            "d",
            "d",
            "d",
            "a",
            "a"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            4,
            4
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.01,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 227,
          "hall_number": 525,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "d",
            "d",
            "d",
            "d",
            "a",
            "a"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            4,
            4
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.01,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 227,
          "hall_number": 525,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "d",
            "d",
            "d",
            "d",
            "a",
            "a"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            4,
            4
          ]
        }
      ],
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 22.142,
        "control_K": 14.726,
        "delta_K": 7.415999999999999,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.11769999999999992,
          0.21909999999999996,
          0.2824,
          0.3134,
          0.3186,
          0.30580000000000007,
          0.2844,
          0.2619999999999999,
          0.2427999999999999,
          0.22819999999999996
        ],
        "range": [
          0.11769999999999992,
          0.3186
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": [
        0.913082082908054,
        0.9113194167317342,
        0.9097592533008122,
        0.9051717715182049,
        0.9001227736786652,
        0.8959986586125003,
        0.8927571174642265,
        0.8901957847853071,
        0.8882216611783081,
        0.8867984942849549
      ],
      "risk_summary": "Known Cr–Re σ competition and a PBE study finding no ordered stable binary compound are contrary priors, not a transfer of their phase energetics to this NC/PBEsol C15 state. Exact C15 magnetism and the experimental realization of this ordered composition remain unknown.",
      "ambient_scope": "Exact model force/full stress, converged electronic outputs, reported finite-q workflow and raw Γ optical evidence provide a bounded near-ambient source-model screen. Source residual stress/metastable alternatives remain explicit; this is not proof of synthesizeability, full BZ or global equilibrium.",
      "route_response": "C15 A versus tetragonal B supplies a genuine different species network: mean Cr–Cr distance 2.34856 versus 2.44756 Å. λ favors A across all ten rows, and Eliashberg improves by 7.416 K; fine F is lower for A by 15.86 meV/atom. Complete species-channel geometry differences and computed all-σ pairing response are saved against the frozen controls. Cell/grid/method sensitivity prevents a pure geometry-only causal claim; no bandwidth/carrier quantity is substituted.",
      "next_action": "Use C15 exact-state spin seeds and the closest σ ordering as the discriminating competitor, keeping the same phase-specific EPC control. A magnetic C15 phase that suppresses the benefit reverses the present nonmagnetic hypothesis.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Source-specific full-species CIF→both SCF inputs→Γ coordinate/cell association, actual atom order and origin, within 1e-6 Å observational matching policy. Original experimental occupancy and measured P/T unknown; configured QE neutral/nonmagnetic/no-SOC model is distinct from a magnetic ground-state claim.",
        "novelty": "One exact reduced composition/ordered phase-design group, new to the frozen reviewed cohort. Published computed source is acknowledged, known experimental chemistry remains a comparator. Bounded primary phase search has not tied the exact target order to an established SC sample; no global absence claim.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "C15 A versus tetragonal B supplies a genuine different species network: mean Cr–Cr distance 2.34856 versus 2.44756 Å. λ favors A across all ten rows, and Eliashberg improves by 7.416 K; fine F is lower for A by 15.86 meV/atom. Complete species-channel geometry differences and computed all-σ pairing response are saved against the frozen controls. Cell/grid/method sensitivity prevents a pure geometry-only causal claim; no bandwidth/carrier quantity is substituted.",
        "pairing_relevance": "All ten source λ/ω rows retained with original units/nulls, and μ*=0.1 source McMillan, Allen–Dynes and Eliashberg products kept separate. Source Gaussian EPC broadening is distinct from explicit MP electronic SCF smearing. No product maximum or selected σ defines the recommendation.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Exact model force/full stress, converged electronic outputs, reported finite-q workflow and raw Γ optical evidence provide a bounded near-ambient source-model screen. Source residual stress/metastable alternatives remain explicit; this is not proof of synthesizeability, full BZ or global equilibrium.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Known Cr–Re σ competition and a PBE study finding no ordered stable binary compound are contrary priors, not a transfer of their phase energetics to this NC/PBEsol C15 state. Exact C15 magnetism and the experimental realization of this ordered composition remain unknown.",
        "decision": "Use C15 exact-state spin seeds and the closest σ ordering as the discriminating competitor, keeping the same phase-specific EPC control. A magnetic C15 phase that suppresses the benefit reverses the present nonmagnetic hypothesis."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "magnetic_model",
        "metastable_phase"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "control_directory": "batch-a/Cr2Re_agm003295867",
          "lambda_target_minus_control_all10": [
            0.11769999999999992,
            0.21909999999999996,
            0.2824,
            0.3134,
            0.3186,
            0.30580000000000007,
            0.2844,
            0.2619999999999999,
            0.2427999999999999,
            0.22819999999999996
          ],
          "omega_log_target_over_control_all10": [
            0.913082082908054,
            0.9113194167317342,
            0.9097592533008122,
            0.9051717715182049,
            0.9001227736786652,
            0.8959986586125003,
            0.8927571174642265,
            0.8901957847853071,
            0.8882216611783081,
            0.8867984942849549
          ],
          "source_Eli_mu01_target_control_K": [
            22.142,
            14.726
          ],
          "separate_Eli_target_minus_control_K": 7.415999999999999,
          "target_control_q_mesh_match": false,
          "target_control_q_meshes": [
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ]
          ],
          "q_comparison_scope": "Different cells can have different configured physical sampling. Actual meshes retained as confounds; source-paired products do not establish convergence or isolated geometry causality.",
          "original_frozen_pair": {
            "original_contrast_index": 6,
            "composition": {
              "Cr": 2,
              "Re": 1
            },
            "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr2Re_agm003203668",
            "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr2Re_agm003295867",
            "lambda_B_minus_A_all10": [
              -0.11769999999999992,
              -0.21909999999999996,
              -0.2824,
              -0.3134,
              -0.3186,
              -0.30580000000000007,
              -0.2844,
              -0.2619999999999999,
              -0.2427999999999999,
              -0.22819999999999996
            ],
            "lambda_direction": "A",
            "separate_Eli_A_B_K": [
              22.142,
              14.726
            ],
            "separate_Eli_B_minus_A_K": -7.415999999999999
          },
          "control_source_q_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003295867",
            "dyn0_source_record": 8634,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 8641,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 11,
                "source_record": 8642,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 12,
                "source_record": 8643,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 13,
                "source_record": 8644,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 8645,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 8646,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 8647,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 8648,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 8649,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 8650,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 8651,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 8652,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 8653,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.11769999999999992,
            0.3186
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "SCF_stages": {
          "scf_coarse.out.bz2": {
            "source_record": 1415,
            "explicit_program_start_headers": [
              {
                "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on  8Oct2022 at  7:18:53"
              }
            ],
            "last_printed_convergence_event": {
              "value": true,
              "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
            },
            "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
            "routine_error_count": 0,
            "warning_patterns": {
              "pattern_selected_count": 5,
              "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
              "BFGS": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
                }
              },
              "negative_charge": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "eigen_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "failure_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "SCF_correction_text": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Total force =     0.000000     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
                }
              }
            },
            "last_force": {
              "header": {
                "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
              },
              "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "printed_site_rows": 6,
              "ordered_atom_indices": [
                1,
                2,
                3,
                4,
                5,
                6
              ],
              "reported_max_abs_component": {
                "value": 0.0,
                "unit": "Ry/bohr",
                "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
              },
              "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
              "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
              "max_component_eV_A": 0.0,
              "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.0,
              "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
              "conversion_constants": {
                "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
                "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
              },
              "unit_conversion_valid": true,
              "max_norm_site": {
                "value": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                "atom_index": 1,
                "type_index": 1
              },
              "reported_component_agrees": true
            },
            "last_stress": {
              "last_pressure_print": {
                "value": -0.02,
                "unit": "kbar",
                "raw_value": "-0.02",
                "GPa": -0.002
              },
              "last_stress_block": {
                "header": {
                  "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.02"
                },
                "complete_3x6": true,
                "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
                "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
                "rows": [
                  {
                    "value": [
                      -1.3e-07,
                      -0.0,
                      -0.0,
                      -0.02,
                      -0.0,
                      -0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      -0.0,
                      -1.3e-07,
                      0.0,
                      -0.0,
                      -0.02,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      -0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -1.3e-07,
                      -0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -0.02
                    ]
                  }
                ],
                "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                  [
                    -0.002,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    -0.0,
                    -0.002,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.002
                  ]
                ],
                "trace_mean_kbar": -0.02,
                "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.002,
                "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
              }
            },
            "last_total_energy_print": {
              "value": -1075.26640535,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-1075.26640535"
            },
            "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
              "value": -0.00028852,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-0.00028852"
            },
            "native_exit_status": null,
            "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
            "PH_all_irreps_complete": null,
            "fullBZ_dynamical_stability": null,
            "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1075.26611683
          },
          "scf_fine.out.bz2": {
            "source_record": 1416,
            "explicit_program_start_headers": [
              {
                "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on  8Oct2022 at  7: 9:27"
              }
            ],
            "last_printed_convergence_event": {
              "value": true,
              "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
            },
            "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
            "routine_error_count": 0,
            "warning_patterns": {
              "pattern_selected_count": 11,
              "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
              "BFGS": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
                }
              },
              "negative_charge": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "eigen_text": {
                "count": 6,
                "last": {
                  "value": "c_bands:  1 eigenvalues not converged"
                }
              },
              "failure_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "SCF_correction_text": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Total force =     0.000000     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
                }
              }
            },
            "last_force": {
              "header": {
                "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
              },
              "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "printed_site_rows": 6,
              "ordered_atom_indices": [
                1,
                2,
                3,
                4,
                5,
                6
              ],
              "reported_max_abs_component": {
                "value": 0.0,
                "unit": "Ry/bohr",
                "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
              },
              "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
              "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
              "max_component_eV_A": 0.0,
              "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.0,
              "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
              "conversion_constants": {
                "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
                "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
              },
              "unit_conversion_valid": true,
              "max_norm_site": {
                "value": [
                  0.0,
                  -0.0,
                  -0.0
                ],
                "atom_index": 1,
                "type_index": 1
              },
              "reported_component_agrees": true
            },
            "last_stress": {
              "last_pressure_print": {
                "value": -0.51,
                "unit": "kbar",
                "raw_value": "-0.51",
                "GPa": -0.051000000000000004
              },
              "last_stress_block": {
                "header": {
                  "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.51"
                },
                "complete_3x6": true,
                "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
                "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
                "rows": [
                  {
                    "value": [
                      -3.47e-06,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -0.51,
                      0.0,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      -3.47e-06,
                      -0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -0.51,
                      -0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      -0.0,
                      -3.47e-06,
                      0.0,
                      -0.0,
                      -0.51
                    ]
                  }
                ],
                "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                  [
                    -0.051000000000000004,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    -0.051000000000000004,
                    -0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.051000000000000004
                  ]
                ],
                "trace_mean_kbar": -0.51,
                "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.051000000000000004,
                "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
              }
            },
            "last_total_energy_print": {
              "value": -1075.2676453,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-1075.26764530"
            },
            "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
              "value": 0.00024168,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "0.00024168"
            },
            "native_exit_status": null,
            "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
            "PH_all_irreps_complete": null,
            "fullBZ_dynamical_stability": null,
            "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1075.26788698
          }
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/Cr2Re_agm003203668",
            "bytes": 18568,
            "sha256": "150d5595ce1bb4e81a35ac9f5a8c1dce5d2cad1c90c816099c8f2cba124cf1e2"
          },
          "raw_header": {
            "ntyp": 2,
            "nat": 6,
            "ibrav": 2,
            "celldm": [
              12.5529202,
              0.0,
              0.0,
              0.0,
              0.0,
              0.0
            ],
            "basis_alat": null,
            "species": [
              {
                "index": 1,
                "element": "Cr",
                "header_mass": 47391.546009102,
                "header_mass_halfwidth": 5e-11,
                "raw_mass_token": "47391.5460091020",
                "line": 4
              },
              {
                "index": 2,
                "element": "Re",
                "header_mass": 169717.298176534,
                "header_mass_halfwidth": 5e-10,
                "raw_mass_token": "169717.298176534",
                "line": 5
              }
            ],
            "atoms": [
              {
                "index": 1,
                "type": 1,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.625000009,
                  0.625000009,
                  0.625000009
                ],
                "line": 6
              },
              {
                "index": 2,
                "type": 1,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.625000009,
                  0.3750000054,
                  0.3750000054
                ],
                "line": 7
              },
              {
                "index": 3,
                "type": 1,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.3750000054,
                  0.625000009,
                  0.3750000054
                ],
                "line": 8
              },
              {
                "index": 4,
                "type": 1,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.3750000054,
                  0.3750000054,
                  0.625000009
                ],
                "line": 9
              },
              {
                "index": 5,
                "type": 2,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                "line": 10
              },
              {
                "index": 6,
                "type": 2,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.2500000036,
                  0.2500000036,
                  0.2500000036
                ],
                "line": 11
              }
            ],
            "q": [
              0.0,
              0.0,
              0.0
            ],
            "matrix_header_line": 13
          },
          "optical_sign": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "minimum": 9.354199701839832e-07,
          "printing_bound": 2.0404459103340138e-12,
          "ASR_relative": 0.002221932193016508,
          "native_signed_modes": [
            {
              "number": 1,
              "THz": 0.388198,
              "cm_inverse": 12.948899,
              "line": 167
            },
            {
              "number": 2,
              "THz": 0.388198,
              "cm_inverse": 12.948899,
              "line": 174
            },
            {
              "number": 3,
              "THz": 0.388198,
              "cm_inverse": 12.948899,
              "line": 181
            },
            {
              "number": 4,
              "THz": 3.18184,
              "cm_inverse": 106.134762,
              "line": 188
            },
            {
              "number": 5,
              "THz": 3.18184,
              "cm_inverse": 106.134762,
              "line": 195
            },
            {
              "number": 6,
              "THz": 3.18184,
              "cm_inverse": 106.134762,
              "line": 202
            },
            {
              "number": 7,
              "THz": 5.03134,
              "cm_inverse": 167.827453,
              "line": 209
            },
            {
              "number": 8,
              "THz": 5.03134,
              "cm_inverse": 167.827453,
              "line": 216
            },
            {
              "number": 9,
              "THz": 5.03134,
              "cm_inverse": 167.827453,
              "line": 223
            },
            {
              "number": 10,
              "THz": 6.143341,
              "cm_inverse": 204.919785,
              "line": 230
            },
            {
              "number": 11,
              "THz": 6.143341,
              "cm_inverse": 204.919785,
              "line": 237
            },
            {
              "number": 12,
              "THz": 6.143341,
              "cm_inverse": 204.919785,
              "line": 244
            },
            {
              "number": 13,
              "THz": 8.538855,
              "cm_inverse": 284.825552,
              "line": 251
            },
            {
              "number": 14,
              "THz": 8.538855,
              "cm_inverse": 284.825552,
              "line": 258
            },
            {
              "number": 15,
              "THz": 10.227219,
              "cm_inverse": 341.143308,
              "line": 265
            },
            {
              "number": 16,
              "THz": 10.227219,
              "cm_inverse": 341.143308,
              "line": 272
            },
            {
              "number": 17,
              "THz": 10.227219,
              "cm_inverse": 341.143308,
              "line": 279
            },
            {
              "number": 18,
              "THz": 13.317343,
              "cm_inverse": 444.218736,
              "line": 286
            }
          ],
          "native_negative_outside_lowest3": []
        },
        "finite_path": {
          "source_record": 1404,
          "observations": {
            "kind": "qe_freq_gp_source_path_table",
            "raw_header_lines": [],
            "path_rows": 128,
            "column_width_counts": {
              "19": 128
            },
            "mode_column_values": 2304,
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "column_roles_conditional_on_file_schema": true,
            "fullBZ_coverage": null,
            "dynamical_stability": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          }
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm003203668",
          "dyn0_source_record": 1403,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                3.0,
                3.0,
                3.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                4.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 1410,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 1411,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 1412,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 1413,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 4,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "composition-assessments.json",
          "bytes": 2036037,
          "sha256": "87a3759b8bb3bd9985bd6537220b4ea8fa427be6672204f9010e300e647c284a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "numeric-review.json",
          "bytes": 2556012,
          "sha256": "a0e7a487691b01ab8f0a4ea02eab40af649a455b97dc9ebdfdcabc4cd2453000",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Exact ordered-state mechanism new to reviewed catalogue only; source predictions/known chemistry acknowledged, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003197109",
      "formula": "Cr2Tc",
      "reduced_formula": "Cr2Tc",
      "composition": {
        "Cr": 2,
        "Tc": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Cr:2|Tc:1",
      "elements": [
        "Cr",
        "Tc"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003197109",
      "control_state": "agm003203668",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Cr2Tc_agm003197109",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Cr2Re_agm003203668",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 227. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "symprec_A": 0.0001,
        "mode": "color_aware",
        "status": "completed",
        "SG_number": 227,
        "hall_number": 525,
        "input_wyckoff_letters": [
          "d",
          "d",
          "d",
          "d",
          "a",
          "a"
        ],
        "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          4,
          4
        ]
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 22.923,
        "control_K": 22.142,
        "delta_K": 0.7809999999999988,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.055400000000000116,
          0.05730000000000013,
          0.03160000000000007,
          0.01429999999999998,
          0.008199999999999985,
          0.008099999999999996,
          0.010999999999999899,
          0.015000000000000124,
          0.01980000000000004,
          0.02520000000000011
        ],
        "range": [
          0.008099999999999996,
          0.05730000000000013
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Choose C15 state with no negative finite-path entries; retain P-3m1 sibling with eight negative entries as grade2. C15 control has small but ten-sign-consistent Re-to-Tc EPC benefit and positive sampled phonon evidence.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
      "route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
      "next_action": "Exact C15 NM/FM/AF moment test plus common q/mesh sensitivity; the adverse result is a magnetic/structural branch that removes the small Re-to-Tc benefit. Do not double-count the polymorphs.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "CIF lattice/sites to both SCFinputs andGamma atomicheader via speciesbijection/wholetranslation; 1e-6A observationaltolerance, not physicaluncertainty",
        "novelty": "Bounded exact formula/prototype primary search; published source calculations not claimed as first discovery. New-to-reviewed exact ordered hypothesis only. Literature-wide novelty unproved.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
        "pairing_relevance": "All ten raw printed lambda values andseparate mu*=.1 sourceEliashberg/McMillan products retained; representative common-sigma response isnotrenamed Tc_uncertainty. Spinfluctuations/anisotropy omitted.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Choose C15 state with no negative finite-path entries; retain P-3m1 sibling with eight negative entries as grade2. C15 control has small but ten-sign-consistent Re-to-Tc EPC benefit and positive sampled phonon evidence.",
        "decision": "Exact C15 NM/FM/AF moment test plus common q/mesh sensitivity; the adverse result is a magnetic/structural branch that removes the small Re-to-Tc benefit. Do not double-count the polymorphs."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "magnetic_model",
        "technetium"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr2Mo_agm003197051",
            "batch-a/Cr2Tc_agm003197109"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr2Mo_agm003197051",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr2Tc_agm003197109",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -1.8767999999999998,
            -1.732,
            -1.5771999999999997,
            -1.4372999999999998,
            -1.3094,
            -1.1967999999999999,
            -1.1002,
            -1.0186000000000002,
            -0.95,
            -0.8926000000000001
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -1.8767999999999998,
            -0.8926000000000001
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              28.839
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              22.923
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -5.916,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 22
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr2Re_agm002145124",
            "batch-a/Cr2Tc_agm003158087"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr2Re_agm002145124",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr2Tc_agm003158087",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.6280999999999999,
            0.5763,
            0.5485000000000001,
            0.5285,
            0.5121000000000001,
            0.49740000000000006,
            0.4838,
            0.4707000000000001,
            0.45830000000000015,
            0.4467
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.4467,
            0.6280999999999999
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              16.915
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              24.32
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 7.405000000000001,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 25
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr2Re_agm003203668",
            "batch-a/Cr2Tc_agm003197109"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr2Re_agm003203668",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr2Tc_agm003197109",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.055400000000000116,
            0.05730000000000013,
            0.03160000000000007,
            0.01429999999999998,
            0.008199999999999985,
            0.008099999999999996,
            0.010999999999999899,
            0.015000000000000124,
            0.01980000000000004,
            0.02520000000000011
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.008099999999999996,
            0.05730000000000013
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              22.142
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              22.923
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 0.7809999999999988,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 28
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr2Tc_agm003158087",
            "batch-a/TcW2_agm003158383"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr2Tc_agm003158087",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/TcW2_agm003158383",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.19619999999999993,
            -0.1511,
            -0.11220000000000008,
            -0.08939999999999992,
            -0.07990000000000008,
            -0.07689999999999997,
            -0.07709999999999995,
            -0.07850000000000001,
            -0.0806,
            -0.08309999999999995
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.19619999999999993,
            -0.07689999999999997
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              24.32
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              17.309
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -7.010999999999999,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 35
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "coarse": {
          "source_record": 1179,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.6.8 starts on 27Jul2022 at 18:29:20"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 5,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000000     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 0.0,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.0,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.0,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              "atom_index": 1,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": -0.03,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "-0.03",
              "GPa": -0.003
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.03"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    -2e-07,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.03,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -2e-07,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.03,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -2e-07,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.03
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  -0.003,
                  0.0,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.003,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  0.0,
                  -0.003
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": -0.03,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.003,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1067.39387623,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1067.39387623"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": -0.00060259,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-0.00060259"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1067.39327364
        },
        "fine": {
          "source_record": 1180,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.6.8 starts on 27Jul2022 at 16:47:41"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 10,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 5,
              "last": {
                "value": "c_bands:  3 eigenvalues not converged"
              }
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000000     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 0.0,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.0,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.0,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              "atom_index": 1,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": 0.66,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "0.66",
              "GPa": 0.066
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=        0.66"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    4.49e-06,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.66,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    4.49e-06,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.66,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    4.49e-06,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.66
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  0.066,
                  -0.0,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  0.066,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.066
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": 0.66,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.066,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1067.39510378,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1067.39510378"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": -0.00027539,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-0.00027539"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1067.39482839
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "Gamma_optical_sign": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "Gamma_optical_minimum": 1.552120647277793e-06,
          "Gamma_printing_bound": 2.2654482920894675e-12,
          "Gamma_native_signed_modes": [
            {
              "number": 1,
              "THz": 0.322062,
              "cm_inverse": 10.742844,
              "line": 167
            },
            {
              "number": 2,
              "THz": 0.322062,
              "cm_inverse": 10.742844,
              "line": 174
            },
            {
              "number": 3,
              "THz": 0.322062,
              "cm_inverse": 10.742844,
              "line": 181
            },
            {
              "number": 4,
              "THz": 4.098621,
              "cm_inverse": 136.715283,
              "line": 188
            },
            {
              "number": 5,
              "THz": 4.098621,
              "cm_inverse": 136.715283,
              "line": 195
            },
            {
              "number": 6,
              "THz": 4.098621,
              "cm_inverse": 136.715283,
              "line": 202
            },
            {
              "number": 7,
              "THz": 5.412598,
              "cm_inverse": 180.544851,
              "line": 209
            },
            {
              "number": 8,
              "THz": 5.412598,
              "cm_inverse": 180.544851,
              "line": 216
            },
            {
              "number": 9,
              "THz": 5.412598,
              "cm_inverse": 180.544851,
              "line": 223
            },
            {
              "number": 10,
              "THz": 5.474514,
              "cm_inverse": 182.610144,
              "line": 230
            },
            {
              "number": 11,
              "THz": 5.474514,
              "cm_inverse": 182.610144,
              "line": 237
            },
            {
              "number": 12,
              "THz": 5.474514,
              "cm_inverse": 182.610144,
              "line": 244
            },
            {
              "number": 13,
              "THz": 8.243073,
              "cm_inverse": 274.959311,
              "line": 251
            },
            {
              "number": 14,
              "THz": 8.243073,
              "cm_inverse": 274.959311,
              "line": 258
            },
            {
              "number": 15,
              "THz": 10.118685,
              "cm_inverse": 337.523005,
              "line": 265
            },
            {
              "number": 16,
              "THz": 10.118685,
              "cm_inverse": 337.523005,
              "line": 272
            },
            {
              "number": 17,
              "THz": 10.118685,
              "cm_inverse": 337.523005,
              "line": 279
            },
            {
              "number": 18,
              "THz": 13.658507,
              "cm_inverse": 455.59876,
              "line": 286
            }
          ],
          "Gamma_ASR_relative": 0.001702961421935394,
          "Gamma_source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/Cr2Tc_agm003197109",
            "bytes": 18568,
            "sha256": "1cfce16c2d80d7042d87e4c7d766a01aaa57b5f83a0748dd0fea2e09b5465c9f"
          }
        },
        "finite_path": {
          "raw_header_lines": [],
          "negative_printed_values": 0,
          "minimum_printed_mode": {
            "value": -0.0,
            "column_index_zero_based": 1
          },
          "frequency_unit_header": null,
          "fullBZ_coverage": null,
          "dynamical_stability": null,
          "state_link_verified": null
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm003197109",
          "dyn0_source_record": 1167,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                3.0,
                3.0,
                3.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                4.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 1174,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 1175,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 1176,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 1177,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 4,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "composition-assessments.json",
          "bytes": 1863044,
          "sha256": "5fc901f5f4a90b41e807722d92f39d81714b70091a189cdb5eba13367624350b",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "numeric-review.json",
          "bytes": 4542684,
          "sha256": "c4fae01d3d67f774429114902a6b39f5b133de48ea81d3d9773ba40ff4419ce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-two-PH-actual-complete-response-products-readback-v1.json",
          "bytes": 77119,
          "sha256": "434c5fe7a590607adbc104dd75d126497457317bc20f37973b5013491e9fdce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Published source predictions already known; exact matched mechanism new to reviewed catalogue only, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003199657",
      "formula": "Cr4MoOs",
      "reduced_formula": "Cr4MoOs",
      "composition": {
        "Cr": 4,
        "Mo": 1,
        "Os": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Cr:4|Mo:1|Os:1",
      "elements": [
        "Cr",
        "Mo",
        "Os"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003199657",
      "control_state": "agm003199671",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Cr4MoOs_agm003199657",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Cr4TcOs_agm003199671",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 216. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "symprec_A": 0.0001,
        "mode": "color_aware",
        "status": "completed",
        "SG_number": 216,
        "hall_number": 512,
        "input_wyckoff_letters": [
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "c",
          "b"
        ],
        "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          4,
          5
        ]
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 20.543,
        "control_K": 16.298,
        "delta_K": 4.245000000000001,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.025600000000000067,
          0.10880000000000001,
          0.1533,
          0.1694000000000001,
          0.17320000000000013,
          0.16679999999999995,
          0.15380000000000005,
          0.13760000000000006,
          0.12090000000000001,
          0.1049
        ],
        "range": [
          0.025600000000000067,
          0.17320000000000013
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Ordered Mo/Os sites in a C15-derived Cr network; controls show both gain versus Tc/Os and losses versus several other roles. Dense Cr network2.3320A is assessed against Cr-Laves Pauli precedents, not bareCr SDW.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
      "route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
      "next_action": "Common-grid spin-polarized branch and Mo/Tc substitution comparison; reverse if moments or q softening remove the source gain.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "CIF lattice/sites to both SCFinputs andGamma atomicheader via speciesbijection/wholetranslation; 1e-6A observationaltolerance, not physicaluncertainty",
        "novelty": "Bounded exact formula/prototype primary search; published source calculations not claimed as first discovery. New-to-reviewed exact ordered hypothesis only. Literature-wide novelty unproved.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
        "pairing_relevance": "All ten raw printed lambda values andseparate mu*=.1 sourceEliashberg/McMillan products retained; representative common-sigma response isnotrenamed Tc_uncertainty. Spinfluctuations/anisotropy omitted.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Ordered Mo/Os sites in a C15-derived Cr network; controls show both gain versus Tc/Os and losses versus several other roles. Dense Cr network2.3320A is assessed against Cr-Laves Pauli precedents, not bareCr SDW.",
        "decision": "Common-grid spin-polarized branch and Mo/Tc substitution comparison; reverse if moments or q softening remove the source gain."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "magnetic_model"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4MoOs_agm003199657",
            "batch-a/Cr4MoRe_agm003199659"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4MoOs_agm003199657",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4MoRe_agm003199659",
          "three_symprec_supported": false,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            1.1323,
            0.9888000000000001,
            0.9181999999999999,
            0.8566,
            0.7914999999999999,
            0.7287000000000001,
            0.6720999999999999,
            0.622,
            0.5780000000000001,
            0.5401000000000001
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.5401000000000001,
            1.1323
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              20.543
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              27.376
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 6.833000000000002,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 46
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4MoOs_agm003199657",
            "batch-a/Cr4MoRu_agm003199662"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4MoOs_agm003199657",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4MoRu_agm003199662",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.017799999999999927,
            0.05469999999999997,
            0.03869999999999996,
            0.024399999999999977,
            0.016899999999999915,
            0.014000000000000012,
            0.013700000000000045,
            0.015000000000000013,
            0.017100000000000004,
            0.020000000000000018
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.013700000000000045,
            0.05469999999999997
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              20.543
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              20.693
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 0.15000000000000213,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 47
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4MoOs_agm003199657",
            "batch-a/Cr4MoTc_agm003199664"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4MoOs_agm003199657",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4MoTc_agm003199664",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.9674,
            0.8064,
            0.7364999999999999,
            0.6777,
            0.6199999999999999,
            0.5679000000000001,
            0.5226999999999999,
            0.4837999999999999,
            0.4508000000000001,
            0.4234000000000001
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.4234000000000001,
            0.9674
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              20.543
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              27.727
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 7.184000000000001,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 48
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4MoOs_agm003199657",
            "batch-a/Cr4NbOs_agm001173524"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4MoOs_agm003199657",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4NbOs_agm001173524",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.9707999999999999,
            0.7315,
            0.6285000000000001,
            0.5667,
            0.5184,
            0.4776,
            0.44269999999999987,
            0.4123,
            0.3858999999999999,
            0.36330000000000007
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.36330000000000007,
            0.9707999999999999
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              20.543
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              24.975
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 4.432000000000002,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 49
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4MoOs_agm003199657",
            "batch-a/Cr4ReOs_agm003199669"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4MoOs_agm003199657",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4ReOs_agm003199669",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.06159999999999999,
            -0.08560000000000001,
            -0.1442,
            -0.1635000000000001,
            -0.16830000000000012,
            -0.16269999999999996,
            -0.15050000000000008,
            -0.1352,
            -0.11919999999999997,
            -0.10409999999999997
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.16830000000000012,
            0.06159999999999999
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "mixed_or_unknown",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              20.543
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              16.009
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -4.533999999999999,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": null,
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 50
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4MoOs_agm003199657",
            "batch-a/Cr4TaOs_agm003199670"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4MoOs_agm003199657",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4TaOs_agm003199670",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.8817999999999999,
            0.6192,
            0.5399,
            0.4990999999999999,
            0.4652999999999998,
            0.4344000000000001,
            0.40649999999999986,
            0.3809999999999999,
            0.3576999999999999,
            0.3367000000000001
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.3367000000000001,
            0.8817999999999999
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              20.543
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              23.586
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 3.0429999999999993,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 51
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4MoOs_agm003199657",
            "batch-a/Cr4TcOs_agm003199671"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4MoOs_agm003199657",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4TcOs_agm003199671",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.025600000000000067,
            -0.10880000000000001,
            -0.1533,
            -0.1694000000000001,
            -0.17320000000000013,
            -0.16679999999999995,
            -0.15380000000000005,
            -0.13760000000000006,
            -0.12090000000000001,
            -0.1049
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.17320000000000013,
            -0.025600000000000067
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              20.543
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              16.298
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -4.245000000000001,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 52
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "coarse": {
          "source_record": 2157,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on  9Mar2023 at  1:26:29"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 5,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000002     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 6.3e-07,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 6.3e-07,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 1.0911920087683928e-06,
            "max_component_eV_A": 1.6197951255042653e-05,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 2.805567455225794e-05,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                6.3e-07,
                -6.3e-07,
                -6.3e-07
              ],
              "atom_index": 1,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "-0.00",
              "GPa": -0.0
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.00"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  -0.0,
                  -0.0,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  -0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  0.0,
                  -0.0
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": 0.0,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.0,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1070.99547338,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1070.99547338"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": 0.00102682,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "0.00102682"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1070.9965002000001
        },
        "fine": {
          "source_record": 2158,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on  9Mar2023 at  1: 0: 9"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 13,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 8,
              "last": {
                "value": "c_bands:  1 eigenvalues not converged"
              }
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.002693     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 0.00077735,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.00077735,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.0013464096952636668,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.019986472076360964,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.03461758510031382,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                -0.00077735,
                0.00077735,
                0.00077735
              ],
              "atom_index": 1,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": 0.75,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "0.75",
              "GPa": 0.075
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=        0.75"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    5.12e-06,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.75,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    5.12e-06,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.75,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    5.12e-06,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.75
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  0.075,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  0.075,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  -0.0,
                  0.075
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": 0.75,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.075,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1070.99619137,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1070.99619137"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": 0.00056833,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "0.00056833"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1070.9967597
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "Gamma_optical_sign": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "Gamma_optical_minimum": 1.0955569747030983e-06,
          "Gamma_printing_bound": 2.155403155695117e-12,
          "Gamma_native_signed_modes": [
            {
              "number": 1,
              "THz": -0.144103,
              "cm_inverse": -4.806748,
              "line": 168
            },
            {
              "number": 2,
              "THz": -0.144103,
              "cm_inverse": -4.806748,
              "line": 175
            },
            {
              "number": 3,
              "THz": -0.144103,
              "cm_inverse": -4.806748,
              "line": 182
            },
            {
              "number": 4,
              "THz": 3.44351,
              "cm_inverse": 114.863132,
              "line": 189
            },
            {
              "number": 5,
              "THz": 3.44351,
              "cm_inverse": 114.863132,
              "line": 196
            },
            {
              "number": 6,
              "THz": 3.44351,
              "cm_inverse": 114.863132,
              "line": 203
            },
            {
              "number": 7,
              "THz": 5.69034,
              "cm_inverse": 189.809321,
              "line": 210
            },
            {
              "number": 8,
              "THz": 5.69034,
              "cm_inverse": 189.809321,
              "line": 217
            },
            {
              "number": 9,
              "THz": 5.69034,
              "cm_inverse": 189.809321,
              "line": 224
            },
            {
              "number": 10,
              "THz": 6.003388,
              "cm_inverse": 200.251462,
              "line": 231
            },
            {
              "number": 11,
              "THz": 6.003388,
              "cm_inverse": 200.251462,
              "line": 238
            },
            {
              "number": 12,
              "THz": 6.003388,
              "cm_inverse": 200.251462,
              "line": 245
            },
            {
              "number": 13,
              "THz": 8.678535,
              "cm_inverse": 289.484782,
              "line": 252
            },
            {
              "number": 14,
              "THz": 8.678535,
              "cm_inverse": 289.484782,
              "line": 259
            },
            {
              "number": 15,
              "THz": 10.060696,
              "cm_inverse": 335.5887,
              "line": 266
            },
            {
              "number": 16,
              "THz": 10.060696,
              "cm_inverse": 335.5887,
              "line": 273
            },
            {
              "number": 17,
              "THz": 10.060696,
              "cm_inverse": 335.5887,
              "line": 280
            },
            {
              "number": 18,
              "THz": 13.670597,
              "cm_inverse": 456.002016,
              "line": 287
            }
          ],
          "Gamma_ASR_relative": 0.0014008142151154853,
          "Gamma_source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/Cr4MoOs_agm003199657",
            "bytes": 18614,
            "sha256": "b88317187e128e3707da6f99bb913de1487d9fa876735a36d076afdf66f93347"
          }
        },
        "finite_path": {
          "raw_header_lines": [],
          "negative_printed_values": 0,
          "minimum_printed_mode": {
            "value": -0.0,
            "column_index_zero_based": 1
          },
          "frequency_unit_header": null,
          "fullBZ_coverage": null,
          "dynamical_stability": null,
          "state_link_verified": null
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm003199657",
          "dyn0_source_record": 2145,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                3.0,
                3.0,
                3.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                4.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 2152,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 2153,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 2154,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 2155,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 4,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "composition-assessments.json",
          "bytes": 1863044,
          "sha256": "5fc901f5f4a90b41e807722d92f39d81714b70091a189cdb5eba13367624350b",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "numeric-review.json",
          "bytes": 4542684,
          "sha256": "c4fae01d3d67f774429114902a6b39f5b133de48ea81d3d9773ba40ff4419ce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-two-PH-actual-complete-response-products-readback-v1.json",
          "bytes": 77119,
          "sha256": "434c5fe7a590607adbc104dd75d126497457317bc20f37973b5013491e9fdce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Published source predictions already known; exact matched mechanism new to reviewed catalogue only, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003199662",
      "formula": "Cr4MoRu",
      "reduced_formula": "Cr4MoRu",
      "composition": {
        "Cr": 4,
        "Mo": 1,
        "Ru": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Cr:4|Mo:1|Ru:1",
      "elements": [
        "Cr",
        "Mo",
        "Ru"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003199662",
      "control_state": "agm003199657",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Cr4MoRu_agm003199662",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Cr4MoOs_agm003199657",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 216. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "symprec_A": 0.0001,
        "mode": "color_aware",
        "status": "completed",
        "SG_number": 216,
        "hall_number": 512,
        "input_wyckoff_letters": [
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "c",
          "b"
        ],
        "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          4,
          5
        ]
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 20.693,
        "control_K": 20.543,
        "delta_K": 0.15000000000000213,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.017799999999999927,
          0.05469999999999997,
          0.03869999999999996,
          0.024399999999999977,
          0.016899999999999915,
          0.014000000000000012,
          0.013700000000000045,
          0.015000000000000013,
          0.017100000000000004,
          0.020000000000000018
        ],
        "range": [
          0.013700000000000045,
          0.05469999999999997
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Ru-for-Os response0.0137-0.0547 lambda and0.150K Eliashberg is positive across all common sigmas but very small. Cell volume almost unchanged, Cr-Cr changes−0.00275A. No statistically significant physical error-bar claim.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
      "route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
      "next_action": "Matched seed/grid sensitivity must resolve this small effect; sign inversion is the immediate falsifier.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "CIF lattice/sites to both SCFinputs andGamma atomicheader via speciesbijection/wholetranslation; 1e-6A observationaltolerance, not physicaluncertainty",
        "novelty": "Bounded exact formula/prototype primary search; published source calculations not claimed as first discovery. New-to-reviewed exact ordered hypothesis only. Literature-wide novelty unproved.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
        "pairing_relevance": "All ten raw printed lambda values andseparate mu*=.1 sourceEliashberg/McMillan products retained; representative common-sigma response isnotrenamed Tc_uncertainty. Spinfluctuations/anisotropy omitted.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Ru-for-Os response0.0137-0.0547 lambda and0.150K Eliashberg is positive across all common sigmas but very small. Cell volume almost unchanged, Cr-Cr changes−0.00275A. No statistically significant physical error-bar claim.",
        "decision": "Matched seed/grid sensitivity must resolve this small effect; sign inversion is the immediate falsifier."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "magnetic_model"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4MoOs_agm003199657",
            "batch-a/Cr4MoRu_agm003199662"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4MoOs_agm003199657",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4MoRu_agm003199662",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.017799999999999927,
            0.05469999999999997,
            0.03869999999999996,
            0.024399999999999977,
            0.016899999999999915,
            0.014000000000000012,
            0.013700000000000045,
            0.015000000000000013,
            0.017100000000000004,
            0.020000000000000018
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.013700000000000045,
            0.05469999999999997
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              20.543
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              20.693
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 0.15000000000000213,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 47
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4MoRe_agm003199659",
            "batch-a/Cr4MoRu_agm003199662"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4MoRe_agm003199659",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4MoRu_agm003199662",
          "three_symprec_supported": false,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -1.1145,
            -0.9341000000000002,
            -0.8795,
            -0.8322,
            -0.7746,
            -0.7147000000000001,
            -0.6583999999999999,
            -0.607,
            -0.5609000000000001,
            -0.5201000000000001
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -1.1145,
            -0.5201000000000001
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              27.376
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              20.693
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -6.683,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 53
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4MoRu_agm003199662",
            "batch-a/Cr4MoTc_agm003199664"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4MoRu_agm003199662",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4MoTc_agm003199664",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.9496000000000001,
            0.7517,
            0.6978,
            0.6533,
            0.6031,
            0.5539000000000001,
            0.5089999999999999,
            0.4687999999999999,
            0.4337000000000001,
            0.4034000000000001
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.4034000000000001,
            0.9496000000000001
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              20.693
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              27.727
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 7.033999999999999,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 59
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "coarse": {
          "source_record": 2131,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on  9Mar2023 at  1:25:27"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 6,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 2,
              "last": {
                "value": "SCF correction compared to forces is large: reduce conv_thr to get better values"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 6.9e-07,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 6.9e-07,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 1.1951150572225254e-06,
            "max_component_eV_A": 1.7740613279332428e-05,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 3.0727643557234886e-05,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                -6.9e-07,
                6.9e-07,
                6.9e-07
              ],
              "atom_index": 1,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": 0.05,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "0.05",
              "GPa": 0.005
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=        0.05"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    3.1e-07,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.05,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    3.1e-07,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.05,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    3.1e-07,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.05
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  0.005,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.005,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.005
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": 0.05000000000000001,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.005,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1070.699757,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1070.69975700"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": 0.00111405,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "0.00111405"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1070.7008710500002
        },
        "fine": {
          "source_record": 2132,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on  9Mar2023 at  0:59:27"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 30,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 25,
              "last": {
                "value": "c_bands:  2 eigenvalues not converged"
              }
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.002507     Total SCF correction =     0.000001"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 0.00072378,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.00072378,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.001253623733502202,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.018609131999007576,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.03223196210703691,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                -0.00072378,
                0.00072378,
                0.00072378
              ],
              "atom_index": 1,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": 1.5,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "1.50",
              "GPa": 0.15
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=        1.50"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    1.017e-05,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    1.5,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    1.017e-05,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    1.5,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    1.017e-05,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    1.5
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  0.15,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.15,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.0,
                  0.15
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": 1.5,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.15,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1070.70023467,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1070.70023467"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": 0.00037245,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "0.00037245"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1070.70060712
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "Gamma_optical_sign": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "Gamma_optical_minimum": 1.5222000714193835e-06,
          "Gamma_printing_bound": 2.2633338404296657e-12,
          "Gamma_native_signed_modes": [
            {
              "number": 1,
              "THz": -0.23422,
              "cm_inverse": -7.81275,
              "line": 168
            },
            {
              "number": 2,
              "THz": -0.23422,
              "cm_inverse": -7.81275,
              "line": 175
            },
            {
              "number": 3,
              "THz": -0.23422,
              "cm_inverse": -7.81275,
              "line": 182
            },
            {
              "number": 4,
              "THz": 4.058927,
              "cm_inverse": 135.391238,
              "line": 189
            },
            {
              "number": 5,
              "THz": 4.058927,
              "cm_inverse": 135.391238,
              "line": 196
            },
            {
              "number": 6,
              "THz": 4.058927,
              "cm_inverse": 135.391238,
              "line": 203
            },
            {
              "number": 7,
              "THz": 5.658335,
              "cm_inverse": 188.741756,
              "line": 210
            },
            {
              "number": 8,
              "THz": 5.658335,
              "cm_inverse": 188.741756,
              "line": 217
            },
            {
              "number": 9,
              "THz": 5.658335,
              "cm_inverse": 188.741756,
              "line": 224
            },
            {
              "number": 10,
              "THz": 5.726751,
              "cm_inverse": 191.023836,
              "line": 231
            },
            {
              "number": 11,
              "THz": 5.726751,
              "cm_inverse": 191.023836,
              "line": 238
            },
            {
              "number": 12,
              "THz": 5.726751,
              "cm_inverse": 191.023836,
              "line": 245
            },
            {
              "number": 13,
              "THz": 8.551343,
              "cm_inverse": 285.242114,
              "line": 252
            },
            {
              "number": 14,
              "THz": 8.551343,
              "cm_inverse": 285.242114,
              "line": 259
            },
            {
              "number": 15,
              "THz": 9.916345,
              "cm_inverse": 330.773662,
              "line": 266
            },
            {
              "number": 16,
              "THz": 9.916345,
              "cm_inverse": 330.773662,
              "line": 273
            },
            {
              "number": 17,
              "THz": 9.916345,
              "cm_inverse": 330.773662,
              "line": 280
            },
            {
              "number": 18,
              "THz": 13.830519,
              "cm_inverse": 461.336459,
              "line": 287
            }
          ],
          "Gamma_ASR_relative": 0.0011653316627076203,
          "Gamma_source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/Cr4MoRu_agm003199662",
            "bytes": 18614,
            "sha256": "1d6394dc39eec8d05451c799926dccaad1371471bd10ff65550ee47b37e4aef3"
          }
        },
        "finite_path": {
          "raw_header_lines": [],
          "negative_printed_values": 0,
          "minimum_printed_mode": {
            "value": 0.0,
            "column_index_zero_based": 1
          },
          "frequency_unit_header": null,
          "fullBZ_coverage": null,
          "dynamical_stability": null,
          "state_link_verified": null
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm003199662",
          "dyn0_source_record": 2119,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                3.0,
                3.0,
                3.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                4.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 2126,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 2127,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 2128,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 2129,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 4,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "composition-assessments.json",
          "bytes": 1863044,
          "sha256": "5fc901f5f4a90b41e807722d92f39d81714b70091a189cdb5eba13367624350b",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "numeric-review.json",
          "bytes": 4542684,
          "sha256": "c4fae01d3d67f774429114902a6b39f5b133de48ea81d3d9773ba40ff4419ce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-two-PH-actual-complete-response-products-readback-v1.json",
          "bytes": 77119,
          "sha256": "434c5fe7a590607adbc104dd75d126497457317bc20f37973b5013491e9fdce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Published source predictions already known; exact matched mechanism new to reviewed catalogue only, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003199664",
      "formula": "Cr4MoTc",
      "reduced_formula": "Cr4MoTc",
      "composition": {
        "Cr": 4,
        "Mo": 1,
        "Tc": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Cr:4|Mo:1|Tc:1",
      "elements": [
        "Cr",
        "Mo",
        "Tc"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003199664",
      "control_state": "agm003199657",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Cr4MoTc_agm003199664",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Cr4MoOs_agm003199657",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 216. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "symprec_A": 0.0001,
        "mode": "color_aware",
        "status": "completed",
        "SG_number": 216,
        "hall_number": 512,
        "input_wyckoff_letters": [
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "a",
          "d"
        ],
        "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          4,
          5
        ]
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 27.727,
        "control_K": 20.543,
        "delta_K": 7.184000000000001,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.9674,
          0.8064,
          0.7364999999999999,
          0.6777,
          0.6199999999999999,
          0.5679000000000001,
          0.5226999999999999,
          0.4837999999999999,
          0.4508000000000001,
          0.4234000000000001
        ],
        "range": [
          0.4234000000000001,
          0.9674
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Tc-for-Os gain is sizable in all ten sigmas; a modestly expanded Cr network correlates with EPC but chemical/mass changes preclude pure geometry causality.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
      "route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
      "next_action": "NM/FM/AF exact ordered-cell comparison and mode-resolved softening; a new magnetic/structural branch overturns the nonmag benefit.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "CIF lattice/sites to both SCFinputs andGamma atomicheader via speciesbijection/wholetranslation; 1e-6A observationaltolerance, not physicaluncertainty",
        "novelty": "Bounded exact formula/prototype primary search; published source calculations not claimed as first discovery. New-to-reviewed exact ordered hypothesis only. Literature-wide novelty unproved.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
        "pairing_relevance": "All ten raw printed lambda values andseparate mu*=.1 sourceEliashberg/McMillan products retained; representative common-sigma response isnotrenamed Tc_uncertainty. Spinfluctuations/anisotropy omitted.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Tc-for-Os gain is sizable in all ten sigmas; a modestly expanded Cr network correlates with EPC but chemical/mass changes preclude pure geometry causality.",
        "decision": "NM/FM/AF exact ordered-cell comparison and mode-resolved softening; a new magnetic/structural branch overturns the nonmag benefit."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "magnetic_model",
        "technetium"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4MoOs_agm003199657",
            "batch-a/Cr4MoTc_agm003199664"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4MoOs_agm003199657",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4MoTc_agm003199664",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.9674,
            0.8064,
            0.7364999999999999,
            0.6777,
            0.6199999999999999,
            0.5679000000000001,
            0.5226999999999999,
            0.4837999999999999,
            0.4508000000000001,
            0.4234000000000001
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.4234000000000001,
            0.9674
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              20.543
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              27.727
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 7.184000000000001,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 48
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4MoRe_agm003199659",
            "batch-a/Cr4MoTc_agm003199664"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4MoRe_agm003199659",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4MoTc_agm003199664",
          "three_symprec_supported": false,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.16490000000000005,
            -0.18240000000000012,
            -0.18169999999999997,
            -0.17890000000000006,
            -0.17149999999999999,
            -0.16080000000000005,
            -0.14939999999999998,
            -0.1382000000000001,
            -0.12719999999999998,
            -0.11670000000000003
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.18240000000000012,
            -0.11670000000000003
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              27.376
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              27.727
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 0.3509999999999991,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": null,
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 54
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4MoRu_agm003199662",
            "batch-a/Cr4MoTc_agm003199664"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4MoRu_agm003199662",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4MoTc_agm003199664",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.9496000000000001,
            0.7517,
            0.6978,
            0.6533,
            0.6031,
            0.5539000000000001,
            0.5089999999999999,
            0.4687999999999999,
            0.4337000000000001,
            0.4034000000000001
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.4034000000000001,
            0.9496000000000001
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              20.693
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              27.727
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 7.033999999999999,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 59
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4MoTc_agm003199664",
            "batch-a/Cr4TcOs_agm003199671"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4MoTc_agm003199664",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4TcOs_agm003199671",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.9930000000000001,
            -0.9152,
            -0.8897999999999999,
            -0.8471000000000001,
            -0.7932,
            -0.7347,
            -0.6765,
            -0.6214,
            -0.5717000000000001,
            -0.5283000000000001
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.9930000000000001,
            -0.5283000000000001
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              27.727
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              16.298
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -11.429000000000002,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 60
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4MoTc_agm003199664",
            "batch-a/Cr4TcRe_agm003204438"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4MoTc_agm003199664",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4TcRe_agm003204438",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.8057000000000001,
            -0.6593,
            -0.5991,
            -0.5478000000000001,
            -0.49719999999999986,
            -0.45219999999999994,
            -0.41379999999999995,
            -0.3812,
            -0.3537000000000001,
            -0.3307
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.8057000000000001,
            -0.3307
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              27.727
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              22.557
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -5.170000000000002,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 61
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4MoTc_agm003199664",
            "batch-a/Cr4TcW_agm003199690"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4MoTc_agm003199664",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4TcW_agm003199690",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.06689999999999996,
            -0.01980000000000004,
            -0.00529999999999986,
            -0.0033000000000000806,
            -0.0039000000000000146,
            -0.005400000000000071,
            -0.006999999999999895,
            -0.008799999999999919,
            -0.011200000000000099,
            -0.014100000000000001
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.06689999999999996,
            -0.0033000000000000806
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              27.727
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              26.933
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -0.7940000000000005,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 62
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "coarse": {
          "source_record": 439,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on  9Mar2023 at  1:26:37"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 6,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 2,
              "last": {
                "value": "SCF correction compared to forces is large: reduce conv_thr to get better values"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 4.5e-07,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 4.5e-07,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 7.794228634059947e-07,
            "max_component_eV_A": 1.1569965182173324e-05,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 2.0039767537327097e-05,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                4.5e-07,
                -4.5e-07,
                -4.5e-07
              ],
              "atom_index": 1,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": 0.05,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "0.05",
              "GPa": 0.005
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=        0.05"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    3.1e-07,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.05,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    3.1e-07,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.05,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    3.1e-07,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.05
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  0.005,
                  -0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  0.005,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.0,
                  0.005
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": 0.05000000000000001,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.005,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1038.29298892,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1038.29298892"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": 0.00113524,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "0.00113524"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1038.29412416
        },
        "fine": {
          "source_record": 440,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on  9Mar2023 at  0:59:17"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 9,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 4,
              "last": {
                "value": "c_bands:  1 eigenvalues not converged"
              }
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000613     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 0.00017682,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.00017682,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.0003062612237943289,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.004546224985581972,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.007874292657667061,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                0.00017682,
                -0.00017682,
                -0.00017682
              ],
              "atom_index": 1,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": 1.59,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "1.59",
              "GPa": 0.159
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=        1.59"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    1.082e-05,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    1.59,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    1.082e-05,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    1.59,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    1.082e-05,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    1.59
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  0.159,
                  -0.0,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  0.159,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.159
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": 1.59,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.159,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1038.29372769,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1038.29372769"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": 0.00067692,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "0.00067692"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1038.29440461
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "Gamma_optical_sign": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "Gamma_optical_minimum": 6.439981273738836e-07,
          "Gamma_printing_bound": 2.2705476736540828e-12,
          "Gamma_native_signed_modes": [
            {
              "number": 1,
              "THz": -0.129513,
              "cm_inverse": -4.320091,
              "line": 168
            },
            {
              "number": 2,
              "THz": -0.129513,
              "cm_inverse": -4.320091,
              "line": 175
            },
            {
              "number": 3,
              "THz": -0.129513,
              "cm_inverse": -4.320091,
              "line": 182
            },
            {
              "number": 4,
              "THz": 2.640082,
              "cm_inverse": 88.06367,
              "line": 189
            },
            {
              "number": 5,
              "THz": 2.640082,
              "cm_inverse": 88.06367,
              "line": 196
            },
            {
              "number": 6,
              "THz": 2.640082,
              "cm_inverse": 88.06367,
              "line": 203
            },
            {
              "number": 7,
              "THz": 5.470435,
              "cm_inverse": 182.474059,
              "line": 210
            },
            {
              "number": 8,
              "THz": 5.470435,
              "cm_inverse": 182.474059,
              "line": 217
            },
            {
              "number": 9,
              "THz": 5.470435,
              "cm_inverse": 182.474059,
              "line": 224
            },
            {
              "number": 10,
              "THz": 5.846328,
              "cm_inverse": 195.012518,
              "line": 231
            },
            {
              "number": 11,
              "THz": 5.846328,
              "cm_inverse": 195.012518,
              "line": 238
            },
            {
              "number": 12,
              "THz": 5.846328,
              "cm_inverse": 195.012518,
              "line": 245
            },
            {
              "number": 13,
              "THz": 8.700072,
              "cm_inverse": 290.203163,
              "line": 252
            },
            {
              "number": 14,
              "THz": 8.700072,
              "cm_inverse": 290.203163,
              "line": 259
            },
            {
              "number": 15,
              "THz": 9.785306,
              "cm_inverse": 326.402666,
              "line": 266
            },
            {
              "number": 16,
              "THz": 9.785306,
              "cm_inverse": 326.402666,
              "line": 273
            },
            {
              "number": 17,
              "THz": 9.785306,
              "cm_inverse": 326.402666,
              "line": 280
            },
            {
              "number": 18,
              "THz": 13.42097,
              "cm_inverse": 447.675376,
              "line": 287
            }
          ],
          "Gamma_ASR_relative": 0.0014714282006661106,
          "Gamma_source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/Cr4MoTc_agm003199664",
            "bytes": 18614,
            "sha256": "03127c5ca7cdb3a6ec2541eedc232750635e215d57218d6a2ef2c6ca4231c88a"
          }
        },
        "finite_path": {
          "raw_header_lines": [],
          "negative_printed_values": 0,
          "minimum_printed_mode": {
            "value": -0.0,
            "column_index_zero_based": 1
          },
          "frequency_unit_header": null,
          "fullBZ_coverage": null,
          "dynamical_stability": null,
          "state_link_verified": null
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm003199664",
          "dyn0_source_record": 427,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                3.0,
                3.0,
                3.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                4.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 434,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 435,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 436,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 437,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 4,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "composition-assessments.json",
          "bytes": 1863044,
          "sha256": "5fc901f5f4a90b41e807722d92f39d81714b70091a189cdb5eba13367624350b",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "numeric-review.json",
          "bytes": 4542684,
          "sha256": "c4fae01d3d67f774429114902a6b39f5b133de48ea81d3d9773ba40ff4419ce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-two-PH-actual-complete-response-products-readback-v1.json",
          "bytes": 77119,
          "sha256": "434c5fe7a590607adbc104dd75d126497457317bc20f37973b5013491e9fdce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Published source predictions already known; exact matched mechanism new to reviewed catalogue only, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001173524",
      "formula": "Cr4NbOs",
      "reduced_formula": "Cr4NbOs",
      "composition": {
        "Cr": 4,
        "Nb": 1,
        "Os": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Cr:4|Nb:1|Os:1",
      "elements": [
        "Cr",
        "Nb",
        "Os"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001173524",
      "control_state": "agm003199657",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Cr4NbOs_agm001173524",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Cr4MoOs_agm003199657",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 216. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "symprec_A": 0.0001,
        "mode": "color_aware",
        "status": "completed",
        "SG_number": 216,
        "hall_number": 512,
        "input_wyckoff_letters": [
          "c",
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "b"
        ],
        "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
          0,
          1,
          1,
          1,
          1,
          5
        ]
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 24.975,
        "control_K": 20.543,
        "delta_K": 4.432000000000002,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.9707999999999999,
          0.7315,
          0.6285000000000001,
          0.5667,
          0.5184,
          0.4776,
          0.44269999999999987,
          0.4123,
          0.3858999999999999,
          0.36330000000000007
        ],
        "range": [
          0.36330000000000007,
          0.9707999999999999
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Nb-for-Mo gain accompanies volume increase and Cr-network expansion. Small residual force/P remain explicit; q/path-domain feasible, no global phase proof.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
      "route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
      "next_action": "Same magnetic seeds and denser common electronic/phonon mesh; determine whether enhancement survives chemistry/mass/sampling controls.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "CIF lattice/sites to both SCFinputs andGamma atomicheader via speciesbijection/wholetranslation; 1e-6A observationaltolerance, not physicaluncertainty",
        "novelty": "Bounded exact formula/prototype primary search; published source calculations not claimed as first discovery. New-to-reviewed exact ordered hypothesis only. Literature-wide novelty unproved.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
        "pairing_relevance": "All ten raw printed lambda values andseparate mu*=.1 sourceEliashberg/McMillan products retained; representative common-sigma response isnotrenamed Tc_uncertainty. Spinfluctuations/anisotropy omitted.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Nb-for-Mo gain accompanies volume increase and Cr-network expansion. Small residual force/P remain explicit; q/path-domain feasible, no global phase proof.",
        "decision": "Same magnetic seeds and denser common electronic/phonon mesh; determine whether enhancement survives chemistry/mass/sampling controls."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "magnetic_model",
        "residual_force_stress"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4MoOs_agm003199657",
            "batch-a/Cr4NbOs_agm001173524"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4MoOs_agm003199657",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4NbOs_agm001173524",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.9707999999999999,
            0.7315,
            0.6285000000000001,
            0.5667,
            0.5184,
            0.4776,
            0.44269999999999987,
            0.4123,
            0.3858999999999999,
            0.36330000000000007
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.36330000000000007,
            0.9707999999999999
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              20.543
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              24.975
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 4.432000000000002,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 49
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4NbOs_agm001173524",
            "batch-a/Cr4NbRe_agm001173527"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4NbOs_agm001173524",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4NbRe_agm001173527",
          "three_symprec_supported": false,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            1.2554000000000003,
            1.1492000000000002,
            0.9391,
            0.7711999999999999,
            0.6522999999999999,
            0.5681999999999998,
            0.5070000000000001,
            0.4605999999999999,
            0.42400000000000015,
            0.39470000000000005
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.39470000000000005,
            1.2554000000000003
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              24.975
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              27.745
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 2.7699999999999996,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 63
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4NbOs_agm001173524",
            "batch-a/Cr4NbW_agm001173535"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4NbOs_agm001173524",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4NbW_agm001173535",
          "three_symprec_supported": false,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.5070999999999999,
            -0.34820000000000007,
            -0.32130000000000014,
            -0.3396000000000001,
            -0.357,
            -0.36349999999999993,
            -0.36129999999999995,
            -0.35360000000000014,
            -0.34329999999999994,
            -0.3319
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.5070999999999999,
            -0.32130000000000014
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              24.975
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              20.333
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -4.642000000000003,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 64
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4NbOs_agm001173524",
            "batch-a/Cr4ReOs_agm003199669"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4NbOs_agm001173524",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4ReOs_agm003199669",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.9091999999999999,
            -0.8171,
            -0.7727,
            -0.7302000000000001,
            -0.6867000000000001,
            -0.6403,
            -0.5932,
            -0.5475,
            -0.5050999999999999,
            -0.46740000000000004
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.9091999999999999,
            -0.46740000000000004
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              24.975
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              16.009
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -8.966000000000001,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 65
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4NbOs_agm001173524",
            "batch-a/Cr4TaOs_agm003199670"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4NbOs_agm001173524",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4TaOs_agm003199670",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.08899999999999997,
            -0.11230000000000007,
            -0.08860000000000001,
            -0.0676000000000001,
            -0.05310000000000015,
            -0.043199999999999905,
            -0.03620000000000001,
            -0.031300000000000106,
            -0.028200000000000003,
            -0.026599999999999957
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.11230000000000007,
            -0.026599999999999957
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              24.975
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              23.586
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -1.389000000000003,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 66
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4NbOs_agm001173524",
            "batch-a/Cr4TcOs_agm003199671"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4NbOs_agm001173524",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4TcOs_agm003199671",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.9964,
            -0.8403,
            -0.7818,
            -0.7361000000000001,
            -0.6916000000000001,
            -0.6444,
            -0.5964999999999999,
            -0.5499,
            -0.5067999999999999,
            -0.46820000000000006
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.9964,
            -0.46820000000000006
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              24.975
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              16.298
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -8.677000000000003,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 67
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "coarse": {
          "source_record": 881,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on  9Mar2023 at  1:25: 6"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 6,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 2,
              "last": {
                "value": "SCF correction compared to forces is large: reduce conv_thr to get better values"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 8.3e-07,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 8.3e-07,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 1.4376021702821681e-06,
            "max_component_eV_A": 2.1340158002675243e-05,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 3.696223790218109e-05,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                -8.3e-07,
                -8.3e-07,
                8.3e-07
              ],
              "atom_index": 2,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": -0.01,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "-0.01",
              "GPa": -0.001
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.01"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    -8e-08,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.01,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    -8e-08,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.01,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -8e-08,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.01
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  -0.001,
                  -0.0,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  -0.001,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  -0.0,
                  -0.001
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": -0.01,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.001,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1054.95823418,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1054.95823418"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": -0.00096149,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-0.00096149"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1054.95727269
        },
        "fine": {
          "source_record": 882,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on  9Mar2023 at  0:59:54"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 19,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 14,
              "last": {
                "value": "c_bands:  1 eigenvalues not converged"
              }
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000968     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 0.00027939,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.00027939,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.00048391767512666865,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.0071834057161053455,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.012442023671675151,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                -0.00027939,
                -0.00027939,
                0.00027939
              ],
              "atom_index": 2,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": -0.23,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "-0.23",
              "GPa": -0.023
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.23"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    -1.58e-06,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.23,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    -1.58e-06,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.23,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -1.58e-06,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.23
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  -0.023,
                  -0.0,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  -0.023,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  0.0,
                  -0.023
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": -0.23,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.023,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1054.95937651,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1054.95937651"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": -0.0001189,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-0.00011890"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1054.9592576100001
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "Gamma_optical_sign": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "Gamma_optical_minimum": 3.206285799445562e-07,
          "Gamma_printing_bound": 2.1633243193242435e-12,
          "Gamma_native_signed_modes": [
            {
              "number": 1,
              "THz": -0.24927,
              "cm_inverse": -8.314761,
              "line": 168
            },
            {
              "number": 2,
              "THz": -0.24927,
              "cm_inverse": -8.314761,
              "line": 175
            },
            {
              "number": 3,
              "THz": -0.24927,
              "cm_inverse": -8.314761,
              "line": 182
            },
            {
              "number": 4,
              "THz": 1.86339,
              "cm_inverse": 62.156012,
              "line": 189
            },
            {
              "number": 5,
              "THz": 1.86339,
              "cm_inverse": 62.156012,
              "line": 196
            },
            {
              "number": 6,
              "THz": 1.86339,
              "cm_inverse": 62.156012,
              "line": 203
            },
            {
              "number": 7,
              "THz": 5.725989,
              "cm_inverse": 190.998418,
              "line": 210
            },
            {
              "number": 8,
              "THz": 5.725989,
              "cm_inverse": 190.998418,
              "line": 217
            },
            {
              "number": 9,
              "THz": 5.725989,
              "cm_inverse": 190.998418,
              "line": 224
            },
            {
              "number": 10,
              "THz": 6.280525,
              "cm_inverse": 209.495752,
              "line": 231
            },
            {
              "number": 11,
              "THz": 6.280525,
              "cm_inverse": 209.495752,
              "line": 238
            },
            {
              "number": 12,
              "THz": 6.280525,
              "cm_inverse": 209.495752,
              "line": 245
            },
            {
              "number": 13,
              "THz": 8.622226,
              "cm_inverse": 287.606506,
              "line": 252
            },
            {
              "number": 14,
              "THz": 8.622226,
              "cm_inverse": 287.606506,
              "line": 259
            },
            {
              "number": 15,
              "THz": 9.461149,
              "cm_inverse": 315.589954,
              "line": 266
            },
            {
              "number": 16,
              "THz": 9.461149,
              "cm_inverse": 315.589954,
              "line": 273
            },
            {
              "number": 17,
              "THz": 9.461149,
              "cm_inverse": 315.589954,
              "line": 280
            },
            {
              "number": 18,
              "THz": 12.699339,
              "cm_inverse": 423.604354,
              "line": 287
            }
          ],
          "Gamma_ASR_relative": 0.0016073357517457337,
          "Gamma_source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/Cr4NbOs_agm001173524",
            "bytes": 18614,
            "sha256": "601a114eaadaa290e8a23e8208658837e8cfe8bdfd7bb0be91ac55dfdc5614b8"
          }
        },
        "finite_path": {
          "raw_header_lines": [],
          "negative_printed_values": 0,
          "minimum_printed_mode": {
            "value": -0.0,
            "column_index_zero_based": 1
          },
          "frequency_unit_header": null,
          "fullBZ_coverage": null,
          "dynamical_stability": null,
          "state_link_verified": null
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm001173524",
          "dyn0_source_record": 869,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                3.0,
                3.0,
                3.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                4.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 876,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 877,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 878,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 879,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 4,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "composition-assessments.json",
          "bytes": 1863044,
          "sha256": "5fc901f5f4a90b41e807722d92f39d81714b70091a189cdb5eba13367624350b",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "numeric-review.json",
          "bytes": 4542684,
          "sha256": "c4fae01d3d67f774429114902a6b39f5b133de48ea81d3d9773ba40ff4419ce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-two-PH-actual-complete-response-products-readback-v1.json",
          "bytes": 77119,
          "sha256": "434c5fe7a590607adbc104dd75d126497457317bc20f37973b5013491e9fdce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Published source predictions already known; exact matched mechanism new to reviewed catalogue only, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001173527",
      "formula": "Cr4NbRe",
      "reduced_formula": "Cr4NbRe",
      "composition": {
        "Cr": 4,
        "Nb": 1,
        "Re": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Cr:4|Nb:1|Re:1",
      "elements": [
        "Cr",
        "Nb",
        "Re"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001173527",
      "control_state": "agm003199659",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Cr4NbRe_agm001173527",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Cr4MoRe_agm003199659",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 216. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "symprec_A": 0.0001,
        "mode": "color_aware",
        "status": "completed",
        "SG_number": 216,
        "hall_number": 512,
        "input_wyckoff_letters": [
          "c",
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "b"
        ],
        "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
          0,
          1,
          1,
          1,
          1,
          5
        ]
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 27.745,
        "control_K": 27.376,
        "delta_K": 0.3689999999999998,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          1.0939,
          0.8919000000000001,
          0.6494000000000002,
          0.48129999999999984,
          0.3792,
          0.3170999999999997,
          0.27760000000000007,
          0.2508999999999999,
          0.2319,
          0.21789999999999998
        ],
        "range": [
          0.21789999999999998,
          1.0939
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Nb-for-Mo gives strong sigma-dependent lambda gain but only0.369K separate Eliashberg benefit, with low omega range. Strong coupling is not ranked above frequency/coherence; softening and spin fluctuations are specific follow-up risks.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
      "route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
      "next_action": "Mode-resolved lambda/omega tradeoff and exact-cell moment sensitivity; disappearing small Tc gain is adverse.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "CIF lattice/sites to both SCFinputs andGamma atomicheader via speciesbijection/wholetranslation; 1e-6A observationaltolerance, not physicaluncertainty",
        "novelty": "Bounded exact formula/prototype primary search; published source calculations not claimed as first discovery. New-to-reviewed exact ordered hypothesis only. Literature-wide novelty unproved.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
        "pairing_relevance": "All ten raw printed lambda values andseparate mu*=.1 sourceEliashberg/McMillan products retained; representative common-sigma response isnotrenamed Tc_uncertainty. Spinfluctuations/anisotropy omitted.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Nb-for-Mo gives strong sigma-dependent lambda gain but only0.369K separate Eliashberg benefit, with low omega range. Strong coupling is not ranked above frequency/coherence; softening and spin fluctuations are specific follow-up risks.",
        "decision": "Mode-resolved lambda/omega tradeoff and exact-cell moment sensitivity; disappearing small Tc gain is adverse."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "magnetic_model"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr2Re_agm003203668",
            "batch-a/Cr4NbRe_agm001173527"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr2Re_agm003203668",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4NbRe_agm001173527",
          "three_symprec_supported": false,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            2.0820000000000003,
            1.7616000000000003,
            1.4507,
            1.2223,
            1.0607,
            0.9438999999999997,
            0.8565,
            0.7881,
            0.7330000000000001,
            0.6881000000000002
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.6881000000000002,
            2.0820000000000003
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              22.142
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              27.745
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 5.6030000000000015,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 30
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4MoRe_agm003199659",
            "batch-a/Cr4NbRe_agm001173527"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4MoRe_agm003199659",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4NbRe_agm001173527",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            1.0939,
            0.8919000000000001,
            0.6494000000000002,
            0.48129999999999984,
            0.3792,
            0.3170999999999997,
            0.27760000000000007,
            0.2508999999999999,
            0.2319,
            0.21789999999999998
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.21789999999999998,
            1.0939
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              27.376
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              27.745
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 0.3689999999999998,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 55
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4NbOs_agm001173524",
            "batch-a/Cr4NbRe_agm001173527"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4NbOs_agm001173524",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4NbRe_agm001173527",
          "three_symprec_supported": false,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            1.2554000000000003,
            1.1492000000000002,
            0.9391,
            0.7711999999999999,
            0.6522999999999999,
            0.5681999999999998,
            0.5070000000000001,
            0.4605999999999999,
            0.42400000000000015,
            0.39470000000000005
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.39470000000000005,
            1.2554000000000003
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              24.975
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              27.745
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 2.7699999999999996,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 63
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4NbRe_agm001173527",
            "batch-a/Cr4NbW_agm001173535"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4NbRe_agm001173527",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4NbW_agm001173535",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -1.7625000000000002,
            -1.4974000000000003,
            -1.2604000000000002,
            -1.1108,
            -1.0092999999999999,
            -0.9316999999999998,
            -0.8683000000000001,
            -0.8142,
            -0.7673000000000001,
            -0.7266
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -1.7625000000000002,
            -0.7266
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              27.745
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              20.333
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -7.412000000000003,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 68
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4NbRe_agm001173527",
            "batch-a/Cr4ReOs_agm003199669"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4NbRe_agm001173527",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4ReOs_agm003199669",
          "three_symprec_supported": false,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -2.1646,
            -1.9663000000000004,
            -1.7118000000000002,
            -1.5013999999999998,
            -1.339,
            -1.2085,
            -1.1002,
            -1.0080999999999998,
            -0.9291,
            -0.8621000000000001
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -2.1646,
            -0.8621000000000001
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              27.745
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              16.009
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -11.736,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 69
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4NbRe_agm001173527",
            "batch-a/Cr4TcRe_agm003204438"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4NbRe_agm001173527",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4TcRe_agm003204438",
          "three_symprec_supported": false,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -2.0645000000000002,
            -1.7336000000000003,
            -1.4302000000000001,
            -1.208,
            -1.0478999999999998,
            -0.9300999999999997,
            -0.8408,
            -0.7703,
            -0.7128000000000001,
            -0.6653
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -2.0645000000000002,
            -0.6653
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              27.745
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              22.557
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -5.188000000000002,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 70
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4NbRe_agm001173527",
            "batch-a/Cr4WRe_agm003199681"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4NbRe_agm001173527",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4WRe_agm003199681",
          "three_symprec_supported": false,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -1.2088,
            -0.9525000000000001,
            -0.6968000000000001,
            -0.5229999999999999,
            -0.4171,
            -0.35229999999999984,
            -0.31089999999999995,
            -0.2831999999999999,
            -0.2641,
            -0.2510000000000001
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -1.2088,
            -0.2510000000000001
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              27.745
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              26.673
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -1.0720000000000027,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 71
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4NbRe_agm001173527",
            "batch-a/Mn4NbRe_agm001179875"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4NbRe_agm001173527",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Mn4NbRe_agm001179875",
          "three_symprec_supported": false,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -2.4518000000000004,
            -2.2086,
            -1.9200000000000002,
            -1.6761,
            -1.4761,
            -1.3099999999999998,
            -1.1723,
            -1.0598,
            -0.9699000000000001,
            -0.9001000000000001
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -2.4518000000000004,
            -0.9001000000000001
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              27.745
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              12.782
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -14.963000000000001,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 72
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "coarse": {
          "source_record": 491,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on  9Mar2023 at  1:28:13"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 5,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000000     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 1.3e-07,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 1.3e-07,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 2.2516660498395406e-07,
            "max_component_eV_A": 3.3424343859611826e-06,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 5.789266177450051e-06,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                -1.3e-07,
                -1.3e-07,
                1.3e-07
              ],
              "atom_index": 2,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": 0.01,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "0.01",
              "GPa": 0.001
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=        0.01"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    4e-08,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.01,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    4e-08,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.01,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    4e-08,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.01
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  0.001,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.001,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.001
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": 0.01,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.001,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1026.19913758,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1026.19913758"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": -0.00201965,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-0.00201965"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1026.19711793
        },
        "fine": {
          "source_record": 492,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on  9Mar2023 at  1: 0:38"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 9,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 4,
              "last": {
                "value": "c_bands:  1 eigenvalues not converged"
              }
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000811     Total SCF correction =     0.000001"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 0.00023407,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.00023407,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.0004054211325276471,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.006018181667091799,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.010423796416582564,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                0.00023407,
                0.00023407,
                -0.00023407
              ],
              "atom_index": 2,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": -0.1,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "-0.10",
              "GPa": -0.01
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.10"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    -7e-07,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.1,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    -7e-07,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.1,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -7e-07,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.1
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  -0.01,
                  -0.0,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  -0.01,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  0.0,
                  -0.01
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": -0.10000000000000002,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.01,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1026.19978253,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1026.19978253"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": -0.00194113,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-0.00194113"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1026.1978414
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "Gamma_optical_sign": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "Gamma_optical_minimum": 6.832830187582979e-07,
          "Gamma_printing_bound": 2.1659676485153786e-12,
          "Gamma_native_signed_modes": [
            {
              "number": 1,
              "THz": 0.332069,
              "cm_inverse": 11.076646,
              "line": 168
            },
            {
              "number": 2,
              "THz": 0.332069,
              "cm_inverse": 11.076646,
              "line": 175
            },
            {
              "number": 3,
              "THz": 0.332069,
              "cm_inverse": 11.076646,
              "line": 182
            },
            {
              "number": 4,
              "THz": 2.719419,
              "cm_inverse": 90.710056,
              "line": 189
            },
            {
              "number": 5,
              "THz": 2.719419,
              "cm_inverse": 90.710056,
              "line": 196
            },
            {
              "number": 6,
              "THz": 2.719419,
              "cm_inverse": 90.710056,
              "line": 203
            },
            {
              "number": 7,
              "THz": 5.711796,
              "cm_inverse": 190.525014,
              "line": 210
            },
            {
              "number": 8,
              "THz": 5.711796,
              "cm_inverse": 190.525014,
              "line": 217
            },
            {
              "number": 9,
              "THz": 5.711796,
              "cm_inverse": 190.525014,
              "line": 224
            },
            {
              "number": 10,
              "THz": 6.343083,
              "cm_inverse": 211.582471,
              "line": 231
            },
            {
              "number": 11,
              "THz": 6.343083,
              "cm_inverse": 211.582471,
              "line": 238
            },
            {
              "number": 12,
              "THz": 6.343083,
              "cm_inverse": 211.582471,
              "line": 245
            },
            {
              "number": 13,
              "THz": 9.036198,
              "cm_inverse": 301.415137,
              "line": 252
            },
            {
              "number": 14,
              "THz": 9.036198,
              "cm_inverse": 301.415137,
              "line": 259
            },
            {
              "number": 15,
              "THz": 9.419378,
              "cm_inverse": 314.196641,
              "line": 266
            },
            {
              "number": 16,
              "THz": 9.419378,
              "cm_inverse": 314.196641,
              "line": 273
            },
            {
              "number": 17,
              "THz": 9.419378,
              "cm_inverse": 314.196641,
              "line": 280
            },
            {
              "number": 18,
              "THz": 12.703078,
              "cm_inverse": 423.729066,
              "line": 287
            }
          ],
          "Gamma_ASR_relative": 0.0017756419255039338,
          "Gamma_source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/Cr4NbRe_agm001173527",
            "bytes": 18614,
            "sha256": "722e6db3d85b50b0eff5ddbbfdb71a787b1452439013f98d3695de8e262efd48"
          }
        },
        "finite_path": {
          "raw_header_lines": [],
          "negative_printed_values": 0,
          "minimum_printed_mode": {
            "value": -0.0,
            "column_index_zero_based": 1
          },
          "frequency_unit_header": null,
          "fullBZ_coverage": null,
          "dynamical_stability": null,
          "state_link_verified": null
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm001173527",
          "dyn0_source_record": 479,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                3.0,
                3.0,
                3.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                4.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 486,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 487,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 488,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 489,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 4,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "composition-assessments.json",
          "bytes": 1863044,
          "sha256": "5fc901f5f4a90b41e807722d92f39d81714b70091a189cdb5eba13367624350b",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "numeric-review.json",
          "bytes": 4542684,
          "sha256": "c4fae01d3d67f774429114902a6b39f5b133de48ea81d3d9773ba40ff4419ce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-two-PH-actual-complete-response-products-readback-v1.json",
          "bytes": 77119,
          "sha256": "434c5fe7a590607adbc104dd75d126497457317bc20f37973b5013491e9fdce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Published source predictions already known; exact matched mechanism new to reviewed catalogue only, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003199670",
      "formula": "Cr4TaOs",
      "reduced_formula": "Cr4TaOs",
      "composition": {
        "Cr": 4,
        "Os": 1,
        "Ta": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Cr:4|Os:1|Ta:1",
      "elements": [
        "Cr",
        "Os",
        "Ta"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003199670",
      "control_state": "agm003199657",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Cr4TaOs_agm003199670",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Cr4MoOs_agm003199657",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 216. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "symprec_A": 0.0001,
        "mode": "color_aware",
        "status": "completed",
        "SG_number": 216,
        "hall_number": 512,
        "input_wyckoff_letters": [
          "a",
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "c"
        ],
        "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
          0,
          1,
          1,
          1,
          1,
          5
        ]
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 23.586,
        "control_K": 20.543,
        "delta_K": 3.0429999999999993,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.8817999999999999,
          0.6192,
          0.5399,
          0.4990999999999999,
          0.4652999999999998,
          0.4344000000000001,
          0.40649999999999986,
          0.3809999999999999,
          0.3576999999999999,
          0.3367000000000001
        ],
        "range": [
          0.3367000000000001,
          0.8817999999999999
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Ta-for-Mo source gain is all-sigma positive but cutoff132->144Ry and chemistry change are retained. Nb/Os competitor has higher source Eliashberg. No claim top-ranked/greatest potential.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
      "route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
      "next_action": "Common converged cutoff/mesh and moment seeds; gain that disappears at matched numerical accuracy is adverse.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "CIF lattice/sites to both SCFinputs andGamma atomicheader via speciesbijection/wholetranslation; 1e-6A observationaltolerance, not physicaluncertainty",
        "novelty": "Bounded exact formula/prototype primary search; published source calculations not claimed as first discovery. New-to-reviewed exact ordered hypothesis only. Literature-wide novelty unproved.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
        "pairing_relevance": "All ten raw printed lambda values andseparate mu*=.1 sourceEliashberg/McMillan products retained; representative common-sigma response isnotrenamed Tc_uncertainty. Spinfluctuations/anisotropy omitted.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Ta-for-Mo source gain is all-sigma positive but cutoff132->144Ry and chemistry change are retained. Nb/Os competitor has higher source Eliashberg. No claim top-ranked/greatest potential.",
        "decision": "Common converged cutoff/mesh and moment seeds; gain that disappears at matched numerical accuracy is adverse."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "magnetic_model",
        "metastable_phase",
        "sampling_method"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4MoOs_agm003199657",
            "batch-a/Cr4TaOs_agm003199670"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4MoOs_agm003199657",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4TaOs_agm003199670",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.8817999999999999,
            0.6192,
            0.5399,
            0.4990999999999999,
            0.4652999999999998,
            0.4344000000000001,
            0.40649999999999986,
            0.3809999999999999,
            0.3576999999999999,
            0.3367000000000001
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.3367000000000001,
            0.8817999999999999
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              20.543
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              23.586
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 3.0429999999999993,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 51
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4NbOs_agm001173524",
            "batch-a/Cr4TaOs_agm003199670"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4NbOs_agm001173524",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4TaOs_agm003199670",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.08899999999999997,
            -0.11230000000000007,
            -0.08860000000000001,
            -0.0676000000000001,
            -0.05310000000000015,
            -0.043199999999999905,
            -0.03620000000000001,
            -0.031300000000000106,
            -0.028200000000000003,
            -0.026599999999999957
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.11230000000000007,
            -0.026599999999999957
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              24.975
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              23.586
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -1.389000000000003,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 66
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4ReOs_agm003199669",
            "batch-a/Cr4TaOs_agm003199670"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4ReOs_agm003199669",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4TaOs_agm003199670",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.8201999999999999,
            0.7048,
            0.6841,
            0.6626,
            0.6335999999999999,
            0.5971000000000001,
            0.5569999999999999,
            0.5161999999999999,
            0.4768999999999999,
            0.4408000000000001
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.4408000000000001,
            0.8201999999999999
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              16.009
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              23.586
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 7.576999999999998,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 76
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4TaOs_agm003199670",
            "batch-a/Cr4TaW_agm003199689"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4TaOs_agm003199670",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4TaW_agm003199689",
          "three_symprec_supported": false,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.5626,
            -0.3053999999999999,
            -0.29069999999999996,
            -0.3296999999999999,
            -0.3604999999999998,
            -0.37450000000000006,
            -0.3766999999999998,
            -0.3719999999999999,
            -0.36419999999999986,
            -0.3546
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.5626,
            -0.29069999999999996
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              23.586
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              19.143
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -4.442999999999998,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 80
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4TaOs_agm003199670",
            "batch-a/Cr4TcOs_agm003199671"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4TaOs_agm003199670",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4TcOs_agm003199671",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.9074,
            -0.728,
            -0.6932,
            -0.6685,
            -0.6385,
            -0.6012000000000001,
            -0.5602999999999999,
            -0.5186,
            -0.4785999999999999,
            -0.4416000000000001
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.9074,
            -0.4416000000000001
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              23.586
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              16.298
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -7.288,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 81
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "coarse": {
          "source_record": 1019,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 26Mar2023 at  7:36:55"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 5,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000001     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 4e-07,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 4e-07,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 6.928203230275509e-07,
            "max_component_eV_A": 1.0284413495265177e-05,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 1.781312669984631e-05,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                4e-07,
                4e-07,
                -4e-07
              ],
              "atom_index": 2,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": -0.02,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "-0.02",
              "GPa": -0.002
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.02"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    -1.4e-07,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.02,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    -1.4e-07,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.02,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -1.4e-07,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.02
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  -0.002,
                  -0.0,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  -0.002,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  0.0,
                  -0.002
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": -0.02,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.002,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1578.74383499,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1578.74383499"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": -0.00094735,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-0.00094735"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1578.7428876400002
        },
        "fine": {
          "source_record": 1020,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 26Mar2023 at  7: 2: 4"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 9,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 4,
              "last": {
                "value": "c_bands:  1 eigenvalues not converged"
              }
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000027     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 7.75e-06,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 7.75e-06,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 1.34233937586588e-05,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.0001992605114707628,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.00034512932980952226,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                -7.75e-06,
                -7.75e-06,
                7.75e-06
              ],
              "atom_index": 2,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": -0.33,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "-0.33",
              "GPa": -0.033
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.33"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    -2.21e-06,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.33,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -2.21e-06,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.33,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -2.21e-06,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.33
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  -0.033,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.033,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.0,
                  -0.033
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": -0.33,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.033,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1578.74491262,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1578.74491262"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": -0.00014137,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-0.00014137"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1578.74477125
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "Gamma_optical_sign": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "Gamma_optical_minimum": 3.131493780418379e-07,
          "Gamma_printing_bound": 2.041435351747444e-12,
          "Gamma_native_signed_modes": [
            {
              "number": 1,
              "THz": 0.748401,
              "cm_inverse": 24.963986,
              "line": 168
            },
            {
              "number": 2,
              "THz": 0.748401,
              "cm_inverse": 24.963986,
              "line": 175
            },
            {
              "number": 3,
              "THz": 0.748401,
              "cm_inverse": 24.963986,
              "line": 182
            },
            {
              "number": 4,
              "THz": 1.857722,
              "cm_inverse": 61.966937,
              "line": 189
            },
            {
              "number": 5,
              "THz": 1.857722,
              "cm_inverse": 61.966937,
              "line": 196
            },
            {
              "number": 6,
              "THz": 1.857722,
              "cm_inverse": 61.966937,
              "line": 203
            },
            {
              "number": 7,
              "THz": 5.142418,
              "cm_inverse": 171.532617,
              "line": 210
            },
            {
              "number": 8,
              "THz": 5.142418,
              "cm_inverse": 171.532617,
              "line": 217
            },
            {
              "number": 9,
              "THz": 5.142418,
              "cm_inverse": 171.532617,
              "line": 224
            },
            {
              "number": 10,
              "THz": 6.686014,
              "cm_inverse": 223.021411,
              "line": 231
            },
            {
              "number": 11,
              "THz": 6.686014,
              "cm_inverse": 223.021411,
              "line": 238
            },
            {
              "number": 12,
              "THz": 6.686014,
              "cm_inverse": 223.021411,
              "line": 245
            },
            {
              "number": 13,
              "THz": 8.89905,
              "cm_inverse": 296.840357,
              "line": 252
            },
            {
              "number": 14,
              "THz": 8.89905,
              "cm_inverse": 296.840357,
              "line": 259
            },
            {
              "number": 15,
              "THz": 9.466405,
              "cm_inverse": 315.765276,
              "line": 266
            },
            {
              "number": 16,
              "THz": 9.466405,
              "cm_inverse": 315.765276,
              "line": 273
            },
            {
              "number": 17,
              "THz": 9.466405,
              "cm_inverse": 315.765276,
              "line": 280
            },
            {
              "number": 18,
              "THz": 12.816723,
              "cm_inverse": 427.519871,
              "line": 287
            }
          ],
          "Gamma_ASR_relative": 0.009342282829003045,
          "Gamma_source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/Cr4TaOs_agm003199670",
            "bytes": 18614,
            "sha256": "170fae82aae8ef45316b395b7f233273933c79b8ce99c236858613753a5779f6"
          }
        },
        "finite_path": {
          "raw_header_lines": [],
          "negative_printed_values": 0,
          "minimum_printed_mode": {
            "value": -0.0,
            "column_index_zero_based": 1
          },
          "frequency_unit_header": null,
          "fullBZ_coverage": null,
          "dynamical_stability": null,
          "state_link_verified": null
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm003199670",
          "dyn0_source_record": 1007,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                3.0,
                3.0,
                3.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                4.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 1014,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 1015,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 1016,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 1017,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 4,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "composition-assessments.json",
          "bytes": 1863044,
          "sha256": "5fc901f5f4a90b41e807722d92f39d81714b70091a189cdb5eba13367624350b",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "numeric-review.json",
          "bytes": 4542684,
          "sha256": "c4fae01d3d67f774429114902a6b39f5b133de48ea81d3d9773ba40ff4419ce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-two-PH-actual-complete-response-products-readback-v1.json",
          "bytes": 77119,
          "sha256": "434c5fe7a590607adbc104dd75d126497457317bc20f37973b5013491e9fdce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Published source predictions already known; exact matched mechanism new to reviewed catalogue only, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003204438",
      "formula": "Cr4TcRe",
      "reduced_formula": "Cr4TcRe",
      "composition": {
        "Cr": 4,
        "Re": 1,
        "Tc": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Cr:4|Re:1|Tc:1",
      "elements": [
        "Cr",
        "Re",
        "Tc"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003204438",
      "control_state": "agm003199669",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Cr4TcRe_agm003204438",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Cr4ReOs_agm003199669",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 216. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "symprec_A": 0.0001,
        "mode": "color_aware",
        "status": "completed",
        "SG_number": 216,
        "hall_number": 512,
        "input_wyckoff_letters": [
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "c",
          "b"
        ],
        "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          4,
          5
        ]
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 22.557,
        "control_K": 16.009,
        "delta_K": 6.547999999999998,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.10009999999999997,
          0.23270000000000002,
          0.28159999999999996,
          0.2934,
          0.29110000000000014,
          0.2784000000000001,
          0.2594000000000001,
          0.2377999999999999,
          0.21629999999999994,
          0.19680000000000009
        ],
        "range": [
          0.10009999999999997,
          0.2934
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Tc-for-Os on Re-bearing ordered C15-derived network has positive all-sigma response, same132Ry and grids. Mo/Tc and W/Tc controls can be better; all opposite outcomes retained.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
      "route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
      "next_action": "Magnetic branch and mode-resolved common-grid comparison; discriminate ordered-site/mass effects from pure lattice response.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "CIF lattice/sites to both SCFinputs andGamma atomicheader via speciesbijection/wholetranslation; 1e-6A observationaltolerance, not physicaluncertainty",
        "novelty": "Bounded exact formula/prototype primary search; published source calculations not claimed as first discovery. New-to-reviewed exact ordered hypothesis only. Literature-wide novelty unproved.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
        "pairing_relevance": "All ten raw printed lambda values andseparate mu*=.1 sourceEliashberg/McMillan products retained; representative common-sigma response isnotrenamed Tc_uncertainty. Spinfluctuations/anisotropy omitted.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Tc-for-Os on Re-bearing ordered C15-derived network has positive all-sigma response, same132Ry and grids. Mo/Tc and W/Tc controls can be better; all opposite outcomes retained.",
        "decision": "Magnetic branch and mode-resolved common-grid comparison; discriminate ordered-site/mass effects from pure lattice response."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "magnetic_model",
        "sampling_method",
        "technetium"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4MoRe_agm003199659",
            "batch-a/Cr4TcRe_agm003204438"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4MoRe_agm003199659",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4TcRe_agm003204438",
          "three_symprec_supported": false,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.9706000000000001,
            -0.8417000000000001,
            -0.7807999999999999,
            -0.7267000000000001,
            -0.6686999999999999,
            -0.613,
            -0.5631999999999999,
            -0.5194000000000001,
            -0.4809000000000001,
            -0.4474
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.9706000000000001,
            -0.4474
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              27.376
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              22.557
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -4.819000000000003,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 57
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4MoTc_agm003199664",
            "batch-a/Cr4TcRe_agm003204438"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4MoTc_agm003199664",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4TcRe_agm003204438",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.8057000000000001,
            -0.6593,
            -0.5991,
            -0.5478000000000001,
            -0.49719999999999986,
            -0.45219999999999994,
            -0.41379999999999995,
            -0.3812,
            -0.3537000000000001,
            -0.3307
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.8057000000000001,
            -0.3307
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              27.727
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              22.557
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -5.170000000000002,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 61
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4NbRe_agm001173527",
            "batch-a/Cr4TcRe_agm003204438"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4NbRe_agm001173527",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4TcRe_agm003204438",
          "three_symprec_supported": false,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -2.0645000000000002,
            -1.7336000000000003,
            -1.4302000000000001,
            -1.208,
            -1.0478999999999998,
            -0.9300999999999997,
            -0.8408,
            -0.7703,
            -0.7128000000000001,
            -0.6653
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -2.0645000000000002,
            -0.6653
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              27.745
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              22.557
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -5.188000000000002,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 70
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4ReOs_agm003199669",
            "batch-a/Cr4TcRe_agm003204438"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4ReOs_agm003199669",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4TcRe_agm003204438",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.10009999999999997,
            0.23270000000000002,
            0.28159999999999996,
            0.2934,
            0.29110000000000014,
            0.2784000000000001,
            0.2594000000000001,
            0.2377999999999999,
            0.21629999999999994,
            0.19680000000000009
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.10009999999999997,
            0.2934
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              16.009
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              22.557
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 6.547999999999998,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 78
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4TcOs_agm003199671",
            "batch-a/Cr4TcRe_agm003204438"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4TcOs_agm003199671",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4TcRe_agm003204438",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.18730000000000002,
            0.2559,
            0.29069999999999996,
            0.2993,
            0.29600000000000015,
            0.2825000000000001,
            0.26270000000000004,
            0.24019999999999997,
            0.21799999999999997,
            0.1976000000000001
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.18730000000000002,
            0.2993
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              16.298
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              22.557
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 6.259,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 85
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4TcRe_agm003204438",
            "batch-a/Cr4TcW_agm003199690"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4TcRe_agm003204438",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4TcW_agm003199690",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.7388000000000001,
            0.6395,
            0.5938000000000001,
            0.5445,
            0.49329999999999985,
            0.44679999999999986,
            0.40680000000000005,
            0.37240000000000006,
            0.3425,
            0.3166
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.3166,
            0.7388000000000001
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              22.557
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              26.933
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 4.376000000000001,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 87
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4TcRe_agm003204438",
            "batch-a/Cr4WRe_agm003199681"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4TcRe_agm003204438",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4WRe_agm003199681",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.8557000000000001,
            0.7811000000000001,
            0.7334,
            0.685,
            0.6307999999999998,
            0.5777999999999999,
            0.5299,
            0.4871000000000001,
            0.4487000000000001,
            0.4142999999999999
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.4142999999999999,
            0.8557000000000001
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              22.557
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              26.673
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 4.116,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 88
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "coarse": {
          "source_record": 1389,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.6.8 starts on 27Jul2022 at 22:55:17"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 6,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 2,
              "last": {
                "value": "SCF correction compared to forces is large: reduce conv_thr to get better values"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 1.5e-07,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 1.5e-07,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 2.5980762113533156e-07,
            "max_component_eV_A": 3.856655060724441e-06,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 6.679922512442365e-06,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                1.5e-07,
                -1.5e-07,
                -1.5e-07
              ],
              "atom_index": 1,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": -0.04,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "-0.04",
              "GPa": -0.004
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.04"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    -3e-07,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.04,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -3e-07,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.04,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -3e-07,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.04
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  -0.004,
                  -0.0,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.004,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.0,
                  -0.004
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": -0.04,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.004,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1071.33067033,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1071.33067033"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": -0.00036802,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-0.00036802"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1071.33030231
        },
        "fine": {
          "source_record": 1390,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.6.8 starts on 27Jul2022 at 21:43:22"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 6,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "c_bands:  1 eigenvalues not converged"
              }
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000936     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 0.00027011,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.00027011,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.00046784424363242947,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.006944807323015193,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.012028759132238718,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                -0.00027011,
                0.00027011,
                0.00027011
              ],
              "atom_index": 1,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": 0.17,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "0.17",
              "GPa": 0.017
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=        0.17"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    1.17e-06,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.17,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    1.17e-06,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.17,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    1.17e-06,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.17
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  0.017,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.017,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.0,
                  0.017
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": 0.17,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.017,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1071.33186886,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1071.33186886"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": -8e-08,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-0.00000008"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1071.33186878
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "Gamma_optical_sign": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "Gamma_optical_minimum": 1.1964051981197117e-06,
          "Gamma_printing_bound": 2.152947100874775e-12,
          "Gamma_native_signed_modes": [
            {
              "number": 1,
              "THz": 0.570462,
              "cm_inverse": 19.028574,
              "line": 168
            },
            {
              "number": 2,
              "THz": 0.570462,
              "cm_inverse": 19.028574,
              "line": 175
            },
            {
              "number": 3,
              "THz": 0.570462,
              "cm_inverse": 19.028574,
              "line": 182
            },
            {
              "number": 4,
              "THz": 3.598539,
              "cm_inverse": 120.03433,
              "line": 189
            },
            {
              "number": 5,
              "THz": 3.598539,
              "cm_inverse": 120.03433,
              "line": 196
            },
            {
              "number": 6,
              "THz": 3.598539,
              "cm_inverse": 120.03433,
              "line": 203
            },
            {
              "number": 7,
              "THz": 5.310179,
              "cm_inverse": 177.128491,
              "line": 210
            },
            {
              "number": 8,
              "THz": 5.310179,
              "cm_inverse": 177.128491,
              "line": 217
            },
            {
              "number": 9,
              "THz": 5.310179,
              "cm_inverse": 177.128491,
              "line": 224
            },
            {
              "number": 10,
              "THz": 5.841391,
              "cm_inverse": 194.847829,
              "line": 231
            },
            {
              "number": 11,
              "THz": 5.841391,
              "cm_inverse": 194.847829,
              "line": 238
            },
            {
              "number": 12,
              "THz": 5.841391,
              "cm_inverse": 194.847829,
              "line": 245
            },
            {
              "number": 13,
              "THz": 8.406231,
              "cm_inverse": 280.401689,
              "line": 252
            },
            {
              "number": 14,
              "THz": 8.406231,
              "cm_inverse": 280.401689,
              "line": 259
            },
            {
              "number": 15,
              "THz": 10.21696,
              "cm_inverse": 340.801115,
              "line": 266
            },
            {
              "number": 16,
              "THz": 10.21696,
              "cm_inverse": 340.801115,
              "line": 273
            },
            {
              "number": 17,
              "THz": 10.21696,
              "cm_inverse": 340.801115,
              "line": 280
            },
            {
              "number": 18,
              "THz": 13.511265,
              "cm_inverse": 450.687291,
              "line": 287
            }
          ],
          "Gamma_ASR_relative": 0.002961201143298145,
          "Gamma_source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/Cr4TcRe_agm003204438",
            "bytes": 18614,
            "sha256": "254c8c085a552bf1e6246114d45ce4c0647a622d6311783334a06908a3a58742"
          }
        },
        "finite_path": {
          "raw_header_lines": [],
          "negative_printed_values": 0,
          "minimum_printed_mode": {
            "value": -0.0,
            "column_index_zero_based": 1
          },
          "frequency_unit_header": null,
          "fullBZ_coverage": null,
          "dynamical_stability": null,
          "state_link_verified": null
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm003204438",
          "dyn0_source_record": 1377,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                3.0,
                3.0,
                3.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                4.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 1384,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 1385,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 1386,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 1387,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 4,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "composition-assessments.json",
          "bytes": 1863044,
          "sha256": "5fc901f5f4a90b41e807722d92f39d81714b70091a189cdb5eba13367624350b",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "numeric-review.json",
          "bytes": 4542684,
          "sha256": "c4fae01d3d67f774429114902a6b39f5b133de48ea81d3d9773ba40ff4419ce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-two-PH-actual-complete-response-products-readback-v1.json",
          "bytes": 77119,
          "sha256": "434c5fe7a590607adbc104dd75d126497457317bc20f37973b5013491e9fdce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Published source predictions already known; exact matched mechanism new to reviewed catalogue only, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003199690",
      "formula": "Cr4TcW",
      "reduced_formula": "Cr4TcW",
      "composition": {
        "Cr": 4,
        "Tc": 1,
        "W": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Cr:4|Tc:1|W:1",
      "elements": [
        "Cr",
        "Tc",
        "W"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003199690",
      "control_state": "agm003199671",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Cr4TcW_agm003199690",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Cr4TcOs_agm003199671",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 216. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "symprec_A": 0.0001,
        "mode": "color_aware",
        "status": "completed",
        "SG_number": 216,
        "hall_number": 512,
        "input_wyckoff_letters": [
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "c",
          "b"
        ],
        "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          4,
          5
        ]
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 26.933,
        "control_K": 16.298,
        "delta_K": 10.635000000000002,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.9261000000000001,
          0.8954,
          0.8845000000000001,
          0.8438,
          0.7893,
          0.7293,
          0.6695000000000001,
          0.6126,
          0.5605,
          0.5142000000000001
        ],
        "range": [
          0.5142000000000001,
          0.9261000000000001
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "W-for-Os on Tc network gains all sigmas; nearambient residual pressure+.114GPa is not silently changed to experimental ambient. Heavy-element/model limitations remain.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
      "route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
      "next_action": "Frozen-state spin/SOC and matched mesh response; optical softening or magnetic reconstruction that reverses pairing benefit is adverse.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "CIF lattice/sites to both SCFinputs andGamma atomicheader via speciesbijection/wholetranslation; 1e-6A observationaltolerance, not physicaluncertainty",
        "novelty": "Bounded exact formula/prototype primary search; published source calculations not claimed as first discovery. New-to-reviewed exact ordered hypothesis only. Literature-wide novelty unproved.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
        "pairing_relevance": "All ten raw printed lambda values andseparate mu*=.1 sourceEliashberg/McMillan products retained; representative common-sigma response isnotrenamed Tc_uncertainty. Spinfluctuations/anisotropy omitted.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "W-for-Os on Tc network gains all sigmas; nearambient residual pressure+.114GPa is not silently changed to experimental ambient. Heavy-element/model limitations remain.",
        "decision": "Frozen-state spin/SOC and matched mesh response; optical softening or magnetic reconstruction that reverses pairing benefit is adverse."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "magnetic_model",
        "technetium"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4MoTc_agm003199664",
            "batch-a/Cr4TcW_agm003199690"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4MoTc_agm003199664",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4TcW_agm003199690",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.06689999999999996,
            -0.01980000000000004,
            -0.00529999999999986,
            -0.0033000000000000806,
            -0.0039000000000000146,
            -0.005400000000000071,
            -0.006999999999999895,
            -0.008799999999999919,
            -0.011200000000000099,
            -0.014100000000000001
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.06689999999999996,
            -0.0033000000000000806
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              27.727
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              26.933
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -0.7940000000000005,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 62
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4NbW_agm001173535",
            "batch-a/Cr4TcW_agm003199690"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4NbW_agm001173535",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4TcW_agm003199690",
          "three_symprec_supported": false,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.4368000000000001,
            0.4033,
            0.42400000000000015,
            0.44730000000000003,
            0.4546999999999999,
            0.4483999999999999,
            0.43430000000000013,
            0.4163000000000001,
            0.397,
            0.3779
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.3779,
            0.4546999999999999
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              20.333
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              26.933
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 6.600000000000001,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 74
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4TaW_agm003199689",
            "batch-a/Cr4TcW_agm003199690"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4TaW_agm003199689",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4TcW_agm003199690",
          "three_symprec_supported": false,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.5813000000000001,
            0.4727999999999999,
            0.482,
            0.5049999999999999,
            0.5112999999999999,
            0.5025999999999999,
            0.4859,
            0.46599999999999997,
            0.44609999999999994,
            0.4272
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.4272,
            0.5813000000000001
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              19.143
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              26.933
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 7.789999999999999,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 82
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4TcOs_agm003199671",
            "batch-a/Cr4TcW_agm003199690"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4TcOs_agm003199671",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4TcW_agm003199690",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.9261000000000001,
            0.8954,
            0.8845000000000001,
            0.8438,
            0.7893,
            0.7293,
            0.6695000000000001,
            0.6126,
            0.5605,
            0.5142000000000001
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.5142000000000001,
            0.9261000000000001
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              16.298
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              26.933
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 10.635000000000002,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 86
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4TcRe_agm003204438",
            "batch-a/Cr4TcW_agm003199690"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4TcRe_agm003204438",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4TcW_agm003199690",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.7388000000000001,
            0.6395,
            0.5938000000000001,
            0.5445,
            0.49329999999999985,
            0.44679999999999986,
            0.40680000000000005,
            0.37240000000000006,
            0.3425,
            0.3166
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.3166,
            0.7388000000000001
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              22.557
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              26.933
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 4.376000000000001,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 87
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4TcW_agm003199690",
            "batch-a/Cr4WRe_agm003199681"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4TcW_agm003199690",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4WRe_agm003199681",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.1169,
            0.14160000000000017,
            0.13959999999999995,
            0.14050000000000007,
            0.13749999999999996,
            0.131,
            0.12309999999999999,
            0.11470000000000002,
            0.10620000000000007,
            0.0976999999999999
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.0976999999999999,
            0.14160000000000017
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              26.933
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              26.673
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -0.26000000000000156,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": null,
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 89
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "coarse": {
          "source_record": 517,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on  9Mar2023 at  1:31:10"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 6,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 2,
              "last": {
                "value": "SCF correction compared to forces is large: reduce conv_thr to get better values"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 2.9e-07,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 2.9e-07,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 5.022947341949744e-07,
            "max_component_eV_A": 7.456199784067253e-06,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 1.2914516857388574e-05,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                2.9e-07,
                -2.9e-07,
                -2.9e-07
              ],
              "atom_index": 1,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": 0.01,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "0.01",
              "GPa": 0.001
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=        0.01"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    5e-08,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.01,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    5e-08,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.01,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    5e-08,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.01
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  0.001,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.001,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.0,
                  0.001
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": 0.01,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.001,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1049.41008991,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1049.41008991"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": 0.00063848,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "0.00063848"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1049.4107283899998
        },
        "fine": {
          "source_record": 518,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on  9Mar2023 at  1: 1:10"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 12,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 7,
              "last": {
                "value": "c_bands:  1 eigenvalues not converged"
              }
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.001094     Total SCF correction =     0.000001"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 0.0003158,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.0003158,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.0005469816450302514,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.008119544454511856,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.01406346352952866,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                -0.0003158,
                0.0003158,
                0.0003158
              ],
              "atom_index": 1,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": 1.14,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "1.14",
              "GPa": 0.11399999999999999
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=        1.14"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    7.77e-06,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    1.14,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    7.77e-06,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    1.14,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    7.77e-06,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    1.14
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  0.11399999999999999,
                  -0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  0.11399999999999999,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.11399999999999999
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": 1.14,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.11399999999999999,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1049.41094261,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1049.41094261"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": 0.00071377,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "0.00071377"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1049.4116563799998
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "Gamma_optical_sign": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "Gamma_optical_minimum": 4.1572357480234e-07,
          "Gamma_printing_bound": 2.1545564058228584e-12,
          "Gamma_native_signed_modes": [
            {
              "number": 1,
              "THz": -0.242203,
              "cm_inverse": -8.079009,
              "line": 168
            },
            {
              "number": 2,
              "THz": -0.242203,
              "cm_inverse": -8.079009,
              "line": 175
            },
            {
              "number": 3,
              "THz": -0.242203,
              "cm_inverse": -8.079009,
              "line": 182
            },
            {
              "number": 4,
              "THz": 2.121216,
              "cm_inverse": 70.756149,
              "line": 189
            },
            {
              "number": 5,
              "THz": 2.121216,
              "cm_inverse": 70.756149,
              "line": 196
            },
            {
              "number": 6,
              "THz": 2.121216,
              "cm_inverse": 70.756149,
              "line": 203
            },
            {
              "number": 7,
              "THz": 5.089009,
              "cm_inverse": 169.751076,
              "line": 210
            },
            {
              "number": 8,
              "THz": 5.089009,
              "cm_inverse": 169.751076,
              "line": 217
            },
            {
              "number": 9,
              "THz": 5.089009,
              "cm_inverse": 169.751076,
              "line": 224
            },
            {
              "number": 10,
              "THz": 6.24192,
              "cm_inverse": 208.208035,
              "line": 231
            },
            {
              "number": 11,
              "THz": 6.24192,
              "cm_inverse": 208.208035,
              "line": 238
            },
            {
              "number": 12,
              "THz": 6.24192,
              "cm_inverse": 208.208035,
              "line": 245
            },
            {
              "number": 13,
              "THz": 8.917465,
              "cm_inverse": 297.454631,
              "line": 252
            },
            {
              "number": 14,
              "THz": 8.917465,
              "cm_inverse": 297.454631,
              "line": 259
            },
            {
              "number": 15,
              "THz": 9.753347,
              "cm_inverse": 325.33665,
              "line": 266
            },
            {
              "number": 16,
              "THz": 9.753347,
              "cm_inverse": 325.33665,
              "line": 273
            },
            {
              "number": 17,
              "THz": 9.753347,
              "cm_inverse": 325.33665,
              "line": 280
            },
            {
              "number": 18,
              "THz": 13.361891,
              "cm_inverse": 445.704698,
              "line": 287
            }
          ],
          "Gamma_ASR_relative": 0.002034852521327723,
          "Gamma_source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/Cr4TcW_agm003199690",
            "bytes": 18614,
            "sha256": "6014ddf93a561f1d8695405847d65ed9d2915c31007dfe4f7cc8bfa79abfb004"
          }
        },
        "finite_path": {
          "raw_header_lines": [],
          "negative_printed_values": 0,
          "minimum_printed_mode": {
            "value": -0.0,
            "column_index_zero_based": 1
          },
          "frequency_unit_header": null,
          "fullBZ_coverage": null,
          "dynamical_stability": null,
          "state_link_verified": null
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm003199690",
          "dyn0_source_record": 505,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                3.0,
                3.0,
                3.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                4.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 512,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 513,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 514,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 515,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 4,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "composition-assessments.json",
          "bytes": 1863044,
          "sha256": "5fc901f5f4a90b41e807722d92f39d81714b70091a189cdb5eba13367624350b",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "numeric-review.json",
          "bytes": 4542684,
          "sha256": "c4fae01d3d67f774429114902a6b39f5b133de48ea81d3d9773ba40ff4419ce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-two-PH-actual-complete-response-products-readback-v1.json",
          "bytes": 77119,
          "sha256": "434c5fe7a590607adbc104dd75d126497457317bc20f37973b5013491e9fdce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Published source predictions already known; exact matched mechanism new to reviewed catalogue only, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003199681",
      "formula": "Cr4WRe",
      "reduced_formula": "Cr4WRe",
      "composition": {
        "Cr": 4,
        "Re": 1,
        "W": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Cr:4|Re:1|W:1",
      "elements": [
        "Cr",
        "Re",
        "W"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003199681",
      "control_state": "agm003199669",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Cr4WRe_agm003199681",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Cr4ReOs_agm003199669",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 216. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "symprec_A": 0.0001,
        "mode": "color_aware",
        "status": "completed",
        "SG_number": 216,
        "hall_number": 512,
        "input_wyckoff_letters": [
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "c",
          "b"
        ],
        "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          4,
          5
        ]
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 26.673,
        "control_K": 16.009,
        "delta_K": 10.663999999999998,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.9558000000000001,
          1.0138000000000003,
          1.0150000000000001,
          0.9784,
          0.9218999999999999,
          0.8562,
          0.7893000000000001,
          0.7249,
          0.665,
          0.6111
        ],
        "range": [
          0.6111,
          1.0150000000000001
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "W-for-Os on Re network gives large source response; lower omega is retained. Tc/W competitor trades a slightly smaller lambda for higher Eliashberg Tc. Heavy-element SOC absent is a model sensitivity, not falsely inherited source absence.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
      "route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
      "next_action": "SOC/moment fixed-cell electronic check and common-sigma mode analysis; adverse outcome removes the benefit.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "CIF lattice/sites to both SCFinputs andGamma atomicheader via speciesbijection/wholetranslation; 1e-6A observationaltolerance, not physicaluncertainty",
        "novelty": "Bounded exact formula/prototype primary search; published source calculations not claimed as first discovery. New-to-reviewed exact ordered hypothesis only. Literature-wide novelty unproved.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
        "pairing_relevance": "All ten raw printed lambda values andseparate mu*=.1 sourceEliashberg/McMillan products retained; representative common-sigma response isnotrenamed Tc_uncertainty. Spinfluctuations/anisotropy omitted.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "W-for-Os on Re network gives large source response; lower omega is retained. Tc/W competitor trades a slightly smaller lambda for higher Eliashberg Tc. Heavy-element SOC absent is a model sensitivity, not falsely inherited source absence.",
        "decision": "SOC/moment fixed-cell electronic check and common-sigma mode analysis; adverse outcome removes the benefit."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "magnetic_model",
        "metastable_phase"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4MoRe_agm003199659",
            "batch-a/Cr4WRe_agm003199681"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4MoRe_agm003199659",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4WRe_agm003199681",
          "three_symprec_supported": false,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.1149,
            -0.06059999999999999,
            -0.04739999999999989,
            -0.04170000000000007,
            -0.037900000000000045,
            -0.03520000000000012,
            -0.033299999999999885,
            -0.032299999999999995,
            -0.032200000000000006,
            -0.03310000000000013
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.1149,
            -0.032200000000000006
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              27.376
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              26.673
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -0.703000000000003,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 58
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4NbRe_agm001173527",
            "batch-a/Cr4WRe_agm003199681"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4NbRe_agm001173527",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4WRe_agm003199681",
          "three_symprec_supported": false,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -1.2088,
            -0.9525000000000001,
            -0.6968000000000001,
            -0.5229999999999999,
            -0.4171,
            -0.35229999999999984,
            -0.31089999999999995,
            -0.2831999999999999,
            -0.2641,
            -0.2510000000000001
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -1.2088,
            -0.2510000000000001
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              27.745
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              26.673
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -1.0720000000000027,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 71
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4NbW_agm001173535",
            "batch-a/Cr4WRe_agm003199681"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4NbW_agm001173535",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4WRe_agm003199681",
          "three_symprec_supported": false,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.5537000000000001,
            0.5449000000000002,
            0.5636000000000001,
            0.5878000000000001,
            0.5921999999999998,
            0.5793999999999999,
            0.5574000000000001,
            0.5310000000000001,
            0.5032000000000001,
            0.4755999999999999
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.4755999999999999,
            0.5921999999999998
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              20.333
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              26.673
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 6.34,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 75
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4ReOs_agm003199669",
            "batch-a/Cr4WRe_agm003199681"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4ReOs_agm003199669",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4WRe_agm003199681",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.9558000000000001,
            1.0138000000000003,
            1.0150000000000001,
            0.9784,
            0.9218999999999999,
            0.8562,
            0.7893000000000001,
            0.7249,
            0.665,
            0.6111
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.6111,
            1.0150000000000001
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              16.009
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              26.673
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 10.663999999999998,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 79
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4TaW_agm003199689",
            "batch-a/Cr4WRe_agm003199681"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4TaW_agm003199689",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4WRe_agm003199681",
          "three_symprec_supported": false,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.6982000000000002,
            0.6144000000000001,
            0.6215999999999999,
            0.6455,
            0.6487999999999998,
            0.6335999999999999,
            0.609,
            0.5807,
            0.5523,
            0.5248999999999999
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.5248999999999999,
            0.6982000000000002
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              19.143
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              26.673
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 7.529999999999998,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 83
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4TcRe_agm003204438",
            "batch-a/Cr4WRe_agm003199681"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4TcRe_agm003204438",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4WRe_agm003199681",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.8557000000000001,
            0.7811000000000001,
            0.7334,
            0.685,
            0.6307999999999998,
            0.5777999999999999,
            0.5299,
            0.4871000000000001,
            0.4487000000000001,
            0.4142999999999999
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.4142999999999999,
            0.8557000000000001
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              22.557
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              26.673
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 4.116,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 88
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4TcW_agm003199690",
            "batch-a/Cr4WRe_agm003199681"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4TcW_agm003199690",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Cr4WRe_agm003199681",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.1169,
            0.14160000000000017,
            0.13959999999999995,
            0.14050000000000007,
            0.13749999999999996,
            0.131,
            0.12309999999999999,
            0.11470000000000002,
            0.10620000000000007,
            0.0976999999999999
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.0976999999999999,
            0.14160000000000017
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              26.933
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              26.673
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -0.26000000000000156,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": null,
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 89
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "coarse": {
          "source_record": 651,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.6.8 starts on 28Jul2022 at  0:22:22"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 6,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 2,
              "last": {
                "value": "SCF correction compared to forces is large: reduce conv_thr to get better values"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 1.4e-07,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 1.4e-07,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 2.424871130596428e-07,
            "max_component_eV_A": 3.599544723342812e-06,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 6.234594344946209e-06,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                -1.4e-07,
                1.4e-07,
                1.4e-07
              ],
              "atom_index": 1,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": -0.04,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "-0.04",
              "GPa": -0.004
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.04"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    -2.4e-07,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.04,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -2.4e-07,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.04,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -2.4e-07,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.04
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  -0.004,
                  -0.0,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.004,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  -0.0,
                  -0.004
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": -0.04,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.004,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1053.34897735,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1053.34897735"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": 0.00064752,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "0.00064752"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1053.34962487
        },
        "fine": {
          "source_record": 652,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.6.8 starts on 27Jul2022 at 23:11:44"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 14,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 9,
              "last": {
                "value": "c_bands:  1 eigenvalues not converged"
              }
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000814     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 0.000235,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.000235,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.00040703193977868616,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.006042092928468292,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.010465211936159707,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                -0.000235,
                0.000235,
                0.000235
              ],
              "atom_index": 1,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": 0.75,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "0.75",
              "GPa": 0.075
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=        0.75"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    5.12e-06,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.75,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    5.12e-06,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.75,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    5.12e-06,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.75
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  0.075,
                  -0.0,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  0.075,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.075
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": 0.75,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.075,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1053.3498697,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1053.34986970"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": 0.00077568,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "0.00077568"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1053.35064538
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "Gamma_optical_sign": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "Gamma_optical_minimum": 3.411355146686109e-07,
          "Gamma_printing_bound": 2.0420552154980922e-12,
          "Gamma_native_signed_modes": [
            {
              "number": 1,
              "THz": 0.547751,
              "cm_inverse": 18.271001,
              "line": 168
            },
            {
              "number": 2,
              "THz": 0.547751,
              "cm_inverse": 18.271001,
              "line": 175
            },
            {
              "number": 3,
              "THz": 0.547751,
              "cm_inverse": 18.271001,
              "line": 182
            },
            {
              "number": 4,
              "THz": 1.921595,
              "cm_inverse": 64.097495,
              "line": 189
            },
            {
              "number": 5,
              "THz": 1.921595,
              "cm_inverse": 64.097495,
              "line": 196
            },
            {
              "number": 6,
              "THz": 1.921595,
              "cm_inverse": 64.097495,
              "line": 203
            },
            {
              "number": 7,
              "THz": 5.077859,
              "cm_inverse": 169.379161,
              "line": 210
            },
            {
              "number": 8,
              "THz": 5.077859,
              "cm_inverse": 169.379161,
              "line": 217
            },
            {
              "number": 9,
              "THz": 5.077859,
              "cm_inverse": 169.379161,
              "line": 224
            },
            {
              "number": 10,
              "THz": 6.500191,
              "cm_inverse": 216.823047,
              "line": 231
            },
            {
              "number": 11,
              "THz": 6.500191,
              "cm_inverse": 216.823047,
              "line": 238
            },
            {
              "number": 12,
              "THz": 6.500191,
              "cm_inverse": 216.823047,
              "line": 245
            },
            {
              "number": 13,
              "THz": 9.157315,
              "cm_inverse": 305.455143,
              "line": 252
            },
            {
              "number": 14,
              "THz": 9.157315,
              "cm_inverse": 305.455143,
              "line": 259
            },
            {
              "number": 15,
              "THz": 9.839314,
              "cm_inverse": 328.204175,
              "line": 266
            },
            {
              "number": 16,
              "THz": 9.839314,
              "cm_inverse": 328.204175,
              "line": 273
            },
            {
              "number": 17,
              "THz": 9.839314,
              "cm_inverse": 328.204175,
              "line": 280
            },
            {
              "number": 18,
              "THz": 13.302417,
              "cm_inverse": 443.720873,
              "line": 287
            }
          ],
          "Gamma_ASR_relative": 0.0034667990040335374,
          "Gamma_source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/Cr4WRe_agm003199681",
            "bytes": 18614,
            "sha256": "77aedac2784405a07e1a2f6d882fdd58d927634bdd57efe5c185ba86406e0d52"
          }
        },
        "finite_path": {
          "raw_header_lines": [],
          "negative_printed_values": 0,
          "minimum_printed_mode": {
            "value": 0.0,
            "column_index_zero_based": 1
          },
          "frequency_unit_header": null,
          "fullBZ_coverage": null,
          "dynamical_stability": null,
          "state_link_verified": null
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm003199681",
          "dyn0_source_record": 639,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                3.0,
                3.0,
                3.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                4.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 646,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 647,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 648,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 649,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 4,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "composition-assessments.json",
          "bytes": 1863044,
          "sha256": "5fc901f5f4a90b41e807722d92f39d81714b70091a189cdb5eba13367624350b",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "numeric-review.json",
          "bytes": 4542684,
          "sha256": "c4fae01d3d67f774429114902a6b39f5b133de48ea81d3d9773ba40ff4419ce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-two-PH-actual-complete-response-products-readback-v1.json",
          "bytes": 77119,
          "sha256": "434c5fe7a590607adbc104dd75d126497457317bc20f37973b5013491e9fdce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Published source predictions already known; exact matched mechanism new to reviewed catalogue only, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003159377",
      "formula": "CrMoRe",
      "reduced_formula": "CrMoRe",
      "composition": {
        "Cr": 1,
        "Mo": 1,
        "Re": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Cr:1|Mo:1|Re:1",
      "elements": [
        "Cr",
        "Mo",
        "Re"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003159377",
      "control_state": "agm003159376",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/CrMoRe_agm003159377",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/CrMoRe_agm003159376",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 156. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": [
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.0001,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 156,
          "hall_number": 446,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "a",
            "b",
            "c"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            2
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.0001,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 156,
          "hall_number": 446,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "a",
            "b",
            "c"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            2
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.001,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 156,
          "hall_number": 446,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "a",
            "b",
            "c"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            2
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.001,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 156,
          "hall_number": 446,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "a",
            "b",
            "c"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            2
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.01,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 156,
          "hall_number": 446,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "a",
            "b",
            "c"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            2
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.01,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 164,
          "hall_number": 456,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "a",
            "d",
            "d"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            1
          ]
        }
      ],
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 18.902,
        "control_K": 16.375,
        "delta_K": 2.527000000000001,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.28800000000000003,
          0.24209999999999998,
          0.22609999999999986,
          0.21120000000000005,
          0.1964999999999999,
          0.18280000000000007,
          0.1702999999999999,
          0.15990000000000004,
          0.15149999999999997,
          0.14510000000000012
        ],
        "range": [
          0.14510000000000012,
          0.28800000000000003
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": [
        0.8677090386256242,
        0.8726758133234451,
        0.8753752723481422,
        0.8764888491431724,
        0.8769176299258712,
        0.8769263354806156,
        0.8766377879922143,
        0.8761725778932689,
        0.8756491044465041,
        0.8751656208539415
      ],
      "risk_summary": "The higher-λ A has fine F about 10.37 meV/atom above B and residual P −0.398 GPa. Cr/Re σ competition and a nonmagnetic-source model require an exact-phase spin comparison; neither is an elemental veto or a global-ground-state certificate.",
      "ambient_scope": "Exact model force/full stress, converged electronic outputs, reported finite-q workflow and raw Γ optical evidence provide a bounded near-ambient source-model screen. Source residual stress/metastable alternatives remain explicit; this is not proof of synthesizeability, full BZ or global equilibrium.",
      "route_response": "Source hexagonal ordered CrMoRe versus tetragonal comparator: the mean nearest like-species distance changes by 0.37698 Å. All ten λ contrasts and the separate Eliashberg product favor A. Complete species-channel geometry differences and computed all-σ pairing response are saved against the frozen controls. Cell/grid/method sensitivity prevents a pure geometry-only causal claim; no bandwidth/carrier quantity is substituted.",
      "next_action": "Compare the two exact ordered phases at converged common physical k/q sampling and several Cr spin seeds; a magnetic/structural response that reverses the pairing benefit is adverse.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Source-specific full-species CIF→both SCF inputs→Γ coordinate/cell association, actual atom order and origin, within 1e-6 Å observational matching policy. Original experimental occupancy and measured P/T unknown; configured QE neutral/nonmagnetic/no-SOC model is distinct from a magnetic ground-state claim.",
        "novelty": "One exact reduced composition/ordered phase-design group, new to the frozen reviewed cohort. Published computed source is acknowledged, known experimental chemistry remains a comparator. Bounded primary phase search has not tied the exact target order to an established SC sample; no global absence claim.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Source hexagonal ordered CrMoRe versus tetragonal comparator: the mean nearest like-species distance changes by 0.37698 Å. All ten λ contrasts and the separate Eliashberg product favor A. Complete species-channel geometry differences and computed all-σ pairing response are saved against the frozen controls. Cell/grid/method sensitivity prevents a pure geometry-only causal claim; no bandwidth/carrier quantity is substituted.",
        "pairing_relevance": "All ten source λ/ω rows retained with original units/nulls, and μ*=0.1 source McMillan, Allen–Dynes and Eliashberg products kept separate. Source Gaussian EPC broadening is distinct from explicit MP electronic SCF smearing. No product maximum or selected σ defines the recommendation.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Exact model force/full stress, converged electronic outputs, reported finite-q workflow and raw Γ optical evidence provide a bounded near-ambient source-model screen. Source residual stress/metastable alternatives remain explicit; this is not proof of synthesizeability, full BZ or global equilibrium.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "The higher-λ A has fine F about 10.37 meV/atom above B and residual P −0.398 GPa. Cr/Re σ competition and a nonmagnetic-source model require an exact-phase spin comparison; neither is an elemental veto or a global-ground-state certificate.",
        "decision": "Compare the two exact ordered phases at converged common physical k/q sampling and several Cr spin seeds; a magnetic/structural response that reverses the pairing benefit is adverse."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "magnetic_model",
        "metastable_phase"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "control_directory": "batch-a/CrMoRe_agm003159376",
          "lambda_target_minus_control_all10": [
            0.28800000000000003,
            0.24209999999999998,
            0.22609999999999986,
            0.21120000000000005,
            0.1964999999999999,
            0.18280000000000007,
            0.1702999999999999,
            0.15990000000000004,
            0.15149999999999997,
            0.14510000000000012
          ],
          "omega_log_target_over_control_all10": [
            0.8677090386256242,
            0.8726758133234451,
            0.8753752723481422,
            0.8764888491431724,
            0.8769176299258712,
            0.8769263354806156,
            0.8766377879922143,
            0.8761725778932689,
            0.8756491044465041,
            0.8751656208539415
          ],
          "source_Eli_mu01_target_control_K": [
            18.902,
            16.375
          ],
          "separate_Eli_target_minus_control_K": 2.527000000000001,
          "target_control_q_mesh_match": false,
          "target_control_q_meshes": [
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              5.0
            ],
            [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ]
          ],
          "q_comparison_scope": "Different cells can have different configured physical sampling. Actual meshes retained as confounds; source-paired products do not establish convergence or isolated geometry causality.",
          "original_frozen_pair": {
            "original_contrast_index": 0,
            "composition": {
              "Cr": 1,
              "Mo": 1,
              "Re": 1
            },
            "fixed_A": "batch-a/CrMoRe_agm003159377",
            "fixed_B": "batch-a/CrMoRe_agm003159376",
            "lambda_B_minus_A_all10": [
              -0.28800000000000003,
              -0.24209999999999998,
              -0.22609999999999986,
              -0.21120000000000005,
              -0.1964999999999999,
              -0.18280000000000007,
              -0.1702999999999999,
              -0.15990000000000004,
              -0.15149999999999997,
              -0.14510000000000012
            ],
            "lambda_direction": "A",
            "separate_Eli_A_B_K": [
              18.902,
              16.375
            ],
            "separate_Eli_B_minus_A_K": -2.527000000000001
          },
          "control_source_q_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003159376",
            "dyn0_source_record": 5860,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 5867,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 11,
                "source_record": 5868,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 12,
                "source_record": 5869,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 13,
                "source_record": 5870,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 5871,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 5872,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 5873,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 5874,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 5875,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 5876,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 5877,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 5878,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 5879,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.14510000000000012,
            0.28800000000000003
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "SCF_stages": {
          "scf_coarse.out.bz2": {
            "source_record": 2941,
            "explicit_program_start_headers": [
              {
                "value": "Program PWSCF v.6.8 starts on 11May2023 at 14:21:38"
              }
            ],
            "last_printed_convergence_event": {
              "value": true,
              "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
            },
            "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
            "routine_error_count": 0,
            "warning_patterns": {
              "pattern_selected_count": 5,
              "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
              "BFGS": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
                }
              },
              "negative_charge": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "eigen_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "failure_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "SCF_correction_text": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Total force =     0.000004     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
                }
              }
            },
            "last_force": {
              "header": {
                "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
              },
              "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "printed_site_rows": 3,
              "ordered_atom_indices": [
                1,
                2,
                3
              ],
              "reported_max_abs_component": {
                "value": 3.4e-06,
                "unit": "Ry/bohr",
                "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
              },
              "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 3.4e-06,
              "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 3.4e-06,
              "max_component_eV_A": 8.7417514709754e-05,
              "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 8.7417514709754e-05,
              "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
              "conversion_constants": {
                "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
                "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
              },
              "unit_conversion_valid": true,
              "max_norm_site": {
                "value": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  3.4e-06
                ],
                "atom_index": 1,
                "type_index": 1
              },
              "reported_component_agrees": true
            },
            "last_stress": {
              "last_pressure_print": {
                "value": 0.0,
                "unit": "kbar",
                "raw_value": "0.00",
                "GPa": 0.0
              },
              "last_stress_block": {
                "header": {
                  "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=        0.00"
                },
                "complete_3x6": true,
                "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
                "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
                "rows": [
                  {
                    "value": [
                      1e-08,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      1e-08,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -0.0,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -0.0
                    ]
                  }
                ],
                "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                  [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                ],
                "trace_mean_kbar": 0.0,
                "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.0,
                "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
              }
            },
            "last_total_energy_print": {
              "value": -496.13191485,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-496.13191485"
            },
            "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
              "value": -8.214e-05,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-0.00008214"
            },
            "native_exit_status": null,
            "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
            "PH_all_irreps_complete": null,
            "fullBZ_dynamical_stability": null,
            "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -496.13183270999997
          },
          "scf_fine.out.bz2": {
            "source_record": 2942,
            "explicit_program_start_headers": [
              {
                "value": "Program PWSCF v.6.8 starts on 11May2023 at 14:17:59"
              }
            ],
            "last_printed_convergence_event": {
              "value": true,
              "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
            },
            "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
            "routine_error_count": 0,
            "warning_patterns": {
              "pattern_selected_count": 5,
              "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
              "BFGS": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
                }
              },
              "negative_charge": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "eigen_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "failure_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "SCF_correction_text": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Total force =     0.000485     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
                }
              }
            },
            "last_force": {
              "header": {
                "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
              },
              "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "printed_site_rows": 3,
              "ordered_atom_indices": [
                1,
                2,
                3
              ],
              "reported_max_abs_component": {
                "value": 0.00038013,
                "unit": "Ry/bohr",
                "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
              },
              "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.00038013,
              "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.00038013,
              "max_component_eV_A": 0.00977353525488788,
              "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.00977353525488788,
              "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
              "conversion_constants": {
                "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
                "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
              },
              "unit_conversion_valid": true,
              "max_norm_site": {
                "value": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00038013
                ],
                "atom_index": 1,
                "type_index": 1
              },
              "reported_component_agrees": true
            },
            "last_stress": {
              "last_pressure_print": {
                "value": -3.98,
                "unit": "kbar",
                "raw_value": "-3.98",
                "GPa": -0.398
              },
              "last_stress_block": {
                "header": {
                  "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -3.98"
                },
                "complete_3x6": true,
                "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
                "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
                "rows": [
                  {
                    "value": [
                      -2.736e-05,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -4.02,
                      0.0,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      -2.736e-05,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -4.02,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      -0.0,
                      -2.645e-05,
                      0.0,
                      -0.0,
                      -3.89
                    ]
                  }
                ],
                "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                  [
                    -0.40199999999999997,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    -0.40199999999999997,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.389
                  ]
                ],
                "trace_mean_kbar": -3.9766666666666666,
                "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.40199999999999997,
                "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
              }
            },
            "last_total_energy_print": {
              "value": -496.13298037,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-496.13298037"
            },
            "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
              "value": -6.027e-05,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-0.00006027"
            },
            "native_exit_status": null,
            "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
            "PH_all_irreps_complete": null,
            "fullBZ_dynamical_stability": null,
            "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -496.1329201
          }
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/CrMoRe_agm003159377",
            "bytes": 5555,
            "sha256": "ca09e85b9b84adef831643ea92f2fa97a5fe160f293a6901ad34ce58a9e7f99f"
          },
          "raw_header": {
            "ntyp": 3,
            "nat": 3,
            "ibrav": 4,
            "celldm": [
              8.0543204,
              0.0,
              0.6195155,
              0.0,
              0.0,
              0.0
            ],
            "basis_alat": null,
            "species": [
              {
                "index": 1,
                "element": "Cr",
                "header_mass": 47391.54600910201,
                "header_mass_halfwidth": 5e-13,
                "raw_mass_token": "47391.546009102007",
                "line": 4
              },
              {
                "index": 2,
                "element": "Mo",
                "header_mass": 87443.96068384449,
                "header_mass_halfwidth": 5e-13,
                "raw_mass_token": "87443.960683844489",
                "line": 5
              },
              {
                "index": 3,
                "element": "Re",
                "header_mass": 169717.29817653357,
                "header_mass_halfwidth": 5e-12,
                "raw_mass_token": "169717.29817653357",
                "line": 6
              }
            ],
            "atoms": [
              {
                "index": 1,
                "type": 1,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.6187968991
                ],
                "line": 7
              },
              {
                "index": 2,
                "type": 3,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.500000005,
                  0.2886751317,
                  0.4187296489
                ],
                "line": 8
              },
              {
                "index": 3,
                "type": 2,
                "tau_alat": [
                  -5e-09,
                  0.5773502721,
                  0.2015045014
                ],
                "line": 9
              }
            ],
            "q": [
              0.0,
              0.0,
              0.0
            ],
            "matrix_header_line": 11
          },
          "optical_sign": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "minimum": 1.8837519230385276e-06,
          "printing_bound": 8.15199154559831e-13,
          "ASR_relative": 0.0024960932675163632,
          "native_signed_modes": [
            {
              "number": 1,
              "THz": -0.34084,
              "cm_inverse": -11.369204,
              "line": 57
            },
            {
              "number": 2,
              "THz": -0.34084,
              "cm_inverse": -11.369204,
              "line": 61
            },
            {
              "number": 3,
              "THz": -0.238955,
              "cm_inverse": -7.970689,
              "line": 65
            },
            {
              "number": 4,
              "THz": 4.515308,
              "cm_inverse": 150.614477,
              "line": 69
            },
            {
              "number": 5,
              "THz": 5.609694,
              "cm_inverse": 187.119246,
              "line": 73
            },
            {
              "number": 6,
              "THz": 6.13305,
              "cm_inverse": 204.57654,
              "line": 77
            },
            {
              "number": 7,
              "THz": 6.13305,
              "cm_inverse": 204.57654,
              "line": 81
            },
            {
              "number": 8,
              "THz": 7.568113,
              "cm_inverse": 252.445065,
              "line": 85
            },
            {
              "number": 9,
              "THz": 7.568113,
              "cm_inverse": 252.445065,
              "line": 89
            }
          ],
          "native_negative_outside_lowest3": []
        },
        "finite_path": {
          "source_record": 2923,
          "observations": {
            "kind": "qe_freq_gp_source_path_table",
            "raw_header_lines": [],
            "path_rows": 171,
            "column_width_counts": {
              "10": 171
            },
            "mode_column_values": 1539,
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "column_roles_conditional_on_file_schema": true,
            "fullBZ_coverage": null,
            "dynamical_stability": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          }
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm003159377",
          "dyn0_source_record": 2922,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                3.0,
                3.0,
                5.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                11.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 10,
              "source_record": 2929,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 11,
              "source_record": 2930,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 2931,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 2932,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 2933,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 2934,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 5,
              "source_record": 2935,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 6,
              "source_record": 2936,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 7,
              "source_record": 2937,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 8,
              "source_record": 2938,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 9,
              "source_record": 2939,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 11,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "composition-assessments.json",
          "bytes": 2036037,
          "sha256": "87a3759b8bb3bd9985bd6537220b4ea8fa427be6672204f9010e300e647c284a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "numeric-review.json",
          "bytes": 2556012,
          "sha256": "a0e7a487691b01ab8f0a4ea02eab40af649a455b97dc9ebdfdcabc4cd2453000",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Exact ordered-state mechanism new to reviewed catalogue only; source predictions/known chemistry acknowledged, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003163920",
      "formula": "CrTc",
      "reduced_formula": "CrTc",
      "composition": {
        "Cr": 1,
        "Tc": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Cr:1|Tc:1",
      "elements": [
        "Cr",
        "Tc"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003163920",
      "control_state": "agm003163891",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/CrTc_agm003163920",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/CrRe_agm003163891",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 129. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "symprec_A": 0.0001,
        "mode": "color_aware",
        "status": "completed",
        "SG_number": 129,
        "hall_number": 408,
        "input_wyckoff_letters": [
          "c",
          "c",
          "c",
          "c"
        ],
        "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
          0,
          0,
          2,
          2
        ]
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 17.431,
        "control_K": 11.969,
        "delta_K": 5.4620000000000015,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.3567,
          0.28979999999999995,
          0.24120000000000008,
          0.21209999999999996,
          0.1936,
          0.18159999999999998,
          0.17369999999999997,
          0.16849999999999998,
          0.1652,
          0.1632
        ],
        "range": [
          0.1632,
          0.3567
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Tetragonal Cr-Tc vs Cr-Re is an exact colored-site substitution with matched cutoff and coarse/fine grids. No exact magnetic contradiction found; source prior excluded magnetic entries. Short Cr-Cr2.3857A is descriptive, not a universal SDW threshold.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
      "route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
      "next_action": "Same-cell NM/FM/one commensurate AF seed: stable appreciable Cr moments and lower energy would reverse the nonmag EPC interpretation; otherwise retain and test finer sampling.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "CIF lattice/sites to both SCFinputs andGamma atomicheader via speciesbijection/wholetranslation; 1e-6A observationaltolerance, not physicaluncertainty",
        "novelty": "Bounded exact formula/prototype primary search; published source calculations not claimed as first discovery. New-to-reviewed exact ordered hypothesis only. Literature-wide novelty unproved.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
        "pairing_relevance": "All ten raw printed lambda values andseparate mu*=.1 sourceEliashberg/McMillan products retained; representative common-sigma response isnotrenamed Tc_uncertainty. Spinfluctuations/anisotropy omitted.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Tetragonal Cr-Tc vs Cr-Re is an exact colored-site substitution with matched cutoff and coarse/fine grids. No exact magnetic contradiction found; source prior excluded magnetic entries. Short Cr-Cr2.3857A is descriptive, not a universal SDW threshold.",
        "decision": "Same-cell NM/FM/one commensurate AF seed: stable appreciable Cr moments and lower energy would reverse the nonmag EPC interpretation; otherwise retain and test finer sampling."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "magnetic_model",
        "sampling_method",
        "technetium"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/CrRe_agm003163891",
            "batch-a/CrTc_agm003163920"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/CrRe_agm003163891",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/CrTc_agm003163920",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.3567,
            0.28979999999999995,
            0.24120000000000008,
            0.21209999999999996,
            0.1936,
            0.18159999999999998,
            0.17369999999999997,
            0.16849999999999998,
            0.1652,
            0.1632
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.1632,
            0.3567
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              11.969
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              17.431
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 5.4620000000000015,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 101
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "coarse": {
          "source_record": 4145,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 12May2023 at 17: 0:24"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 6,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 2,
              "last": {
                "value": "SCF correction compared to forces is large: reduce conv_thr to get better values"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 4,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 8.2e-07,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 8.2e-07,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 8.2e-07,
            "max_component_eV_A": 2.1083047665293612e-05,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 2.1083047665293612e-05,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                -8.2e-07
              ],
              "atom_index": 1,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": -0.01,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "-0.01",
              "GPa": -0.001
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.01"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    -8e-08,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.01,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -8e-08,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.01,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -7e-08,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.01
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  -0.001,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.001,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  -0.001
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": -0.01,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.001,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -703.33056339,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-703.33056339"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": -0.00019674,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-0.00019674"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -703.33036665
        },
        "fine": {
          "source_record": 4146,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 12May2023 at 16:51: 9"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 5,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.002668     Total SCF correction =     0.000004"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 4,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 0.00135131,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.00135131,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.00135131,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.034743577000716966,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.034743577000716966,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                -0.00135131
              ],
              "atom_index": 1,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": -1.34,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "-1.34",
              "GPa": -0.134
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -1.34"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    -3.19e-06,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.47,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -3.19e-06,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.47,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -2.101e-05,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -3.09
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  -0.047,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.047,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  -0.309
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": -1.343333333333333,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.309,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -703.33055861,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-703.33055861"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": -0.0001394,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-0.00013940"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -703.3304192100001
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "Gamma_optical_sign": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "Gamma_optical_minimum": 1.185126877943133e-06,
          "Gamma_printing_bound": 1.3702167384646535e-12,
          "Gamma_native_signed_modes": [
            {
              "number": 1,
              "THz": -0.376297,
              "cm_inverse": -12.551915,
              "line": 85
            },
            {
              "number": 2,
              "THz": -0.376297,
              "cm_inverse": -12.551915,
              "line": 90
            },
            {
              "number": 3,
              "THz": -0.273088,
              "cm_inverse": -9.109249,
              "line": 95
            },
            {
              "number": 4,
              "THz": 3.581438,
              "cm_inverse": 119.463915,
              "line": 100
            },
            {
              "number": 5,
              "THz": 4.489389,
              "cm_inverse": 149.749898,
              "line": 105
            },
            {
              "number": 6,
              "THz": 4.489389,
              "cm_inverse": 149.749898,
              "line": 110
            },
            {
              "number": 7,
              "THz": 5.309756,
              "cm_inverse": 177.114408,
              "line": 115
            },
            {
              "number": 8,
              "THz": 5.309756,
              "cm_inverse": 177.114408,
              "line": 120
            },
            {
              "number": 9,
              "THz": 5.483525,
              "cm_inverse": 182.910721,
              "line": 125
            },
            {
              "number": 10,
              "THz": 5.483525,
              "cm_inverse": 182.910721,
              "line": 130
            },
            {
              "number": 11,
              "THz": 7.786635,
              "cm_inverse": 259.734184,
              "line": 135
            },
            {
              "number": 12,
              "THz": 8.824394,
              "cm_inverse": 294.350094,
              "line": 140
            }
          ],
          "Gamma_ASR_relative": 0.002212007529889663,
          "Gamma_source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/CrTc_agm003163920",
            "bytes": 8948,
            "sha256": "8cbbc7ca668157da7c57e21172d67f1faef58e068b0ca85aeffa5d23e349a56d"
          }
        },
        "finite_path": {
          "raw_header_lines": [],
          "negative_printed_values": 0,
          "minimum_printed_mode": {
            "value": 0.0,
            "column_index_zero_based": 1
          },
          "frequency_unit_header": null,
          "fullBZ_coverage": null,
          "dynamical_stability": null,
          "state_link_verified": null
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm003163920",
          "dyn0_source_record": 4125,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                5.0,
                5.0,
                2.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                12.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 10,
              "source_record": 4132,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 11,
              "source_record": 4133,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 12,
              "source_record": 4134,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 4135,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 4136,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 4137,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 4138,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 5,
              "source_record": 4139,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 6,
              "source_record": 4140,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 7,
              "source_record": 4141,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 8,
              "source_record": 4142,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 9,
              "source_record": 4143,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 12,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "composition-assessments.json",
          "bytes": 1863044,
          "sha256": "5fc901f5f4a90b41e807722d92f39d81714b70091a189cdb5eba13367624350b",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "numeric-review.json",
          "bytes": 4542684,
          "sha256": "c4fae01d3d67f774429114902a6b39f5b133de48ea81d3d9773ba40ff4419ce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-two-PH-actual-complete-response-products-readback-v1.json",
          "bytes": 77119,
          "sha256": "434c5fe7a590607adbc104dd75d126497457317bc20f37973b5013491e9fdce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Published source predictions already known; exact matched mechanism new to reviewed catalogue only, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001619538",
      "formula": "HTcRu2Ta",
      "reduced_formula": "HTcRu2Ta",
      "composition": {
        "H": 1,
        "Ru": 2,
        "Ta": 1,
        "Tc": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "H:1|Ru:2|Ta:1|Tc:1",
      "elements": [
        "H",
        "Ru",
        "Ta",
        "Tc"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001619538",
      "control_state": "agm001619536",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/HTcRu2Ta_agm001619538",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/HRu2TaRe_agm001619536",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": "weighted_phonon_log_moment_net_pairing",
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 123. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": [
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.0001,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 123,
          "hall_number": 400,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "d",
            "b",
            "a",
            "f",
            "f"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            3,
            3
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.0001,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 123,
          "hall_number": 400,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "d",
            "b",
            "a",
            "f",
            "f"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            3,
            3
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.001,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 123,
          "hall_number": 400,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "d",
            "b",
            "a",
            "f",
            "f"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            3,
            3
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.001,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 123,
          "hall_number": 400,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "d",
            "b",
            "a",
            "f",
            "f"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            3,
            3
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.01,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 123,
          "hall_number": 400,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "d",
            "b",
            "a",
            "f",
            "f"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            3,
            3
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.01,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 221,
          "hall_number": 517,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "b",
            "d",
            "a",
            "d",
            "d"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            1,
            1
          ]
        }
      ],
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 12.112,
        "control_K": 11.188,
        "delta_K": 0.9239999999999995,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.07689999999999997,
          0.041000000000000036,
          0.02199999999999991,
          0.009099999999999997,
          0.00029999999999996696,
          -0.005599999999999938,
          -0.00979999999999992,
          -0.013000000000000012,
          -0.01539999999999997,
          -0.017000000000000015
        ],
        "range": [
          -0.017000000000000015,
          0.07689999999999997
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": [
        1.0943353172716728,
        1.089893504248414,
        1.0870273390788008,
        1.0851006643036627,
        1.083597786767059,
        1.0823563790640287,
        1.0813218582010788,
        1.0804465333247508,
        1.0796684111593438,
        1.0789362782940248
      ],
      "risk_summary": "All six target and control q records have positive printed convergence, no routine error and DONE. Fine full stress reaches .750 GPa despite only −.075 GPa mean pressure; Tc radioactivity, hydrogen retention/anharmonicity and relativistic/magnetic model sensitivity are concrete counterrisks.",
      "ambient_scope": "The exact source neutral zero-applied-pressure model has positive Γ optical compression intervals and no negative retained sampled path value for target and selected control. Coarse/fine force and full stress, relaxation warnings and every q record are retained. These finite observations do not prove full-BZ or thermodynamic hull stability.",
      "route_response": "Re→Tc on the frozen hydride metal role raises weighted ωlog by 7.89–9.43% with mixed λ −.0170…+.0769. The hydrogen content and matched roles are retained, but metal chemistry, isotope mass and equilibrium metric are coupled.",
      "next_action": "Inspect the saved H-versus-metal-resolved spectral contribution and exact source PP role metadata, then resolve the fine anisotropic strain sensitivity. If the log-moment advantage comes from an anharmonic unstable H branch, the route interpretation is falsified.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact agm001619538 ordered coordinates, species and metric are linked through source CIF→coarse/fine input→Γ header; actual bounded association residuals and original record IDs are retained below. This is not an experimental structure certificate.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Re→Tc on the frozen hydride metal role raises weighted ωlog by 7.89–9.43% with mixed λ −.0170…+.0769. The hydrogen content and matched roles are retained, but metal chemistry, isotope mass and equilibrium metric are coupled.",
        "pairing_relevance": "Separate source Eli gain 0.924 K is retained with source McMillan/AD. Actual source-header descriptor reproduces the first McMillan column to printed precision. Header-to-ten-σ and Eli-to-σ association remains null, and ωlog is α²F weighted rather than an assertion that all bare modes harden.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "The exact source neutral zero-applied-pressure model has positive Γ optical compression intervals and no negative retained sampled path value for target and selected control. Coarse/fine force and full stress, relaxation warnings and every q record are retained. These finite observations do not prove full-BZ or thermodynamic hull stability.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "All six target and control q records have positive printed convergence, no routine error and DONE. Fine full stress reaches .750 GPa despite only −.075 GPa mean pressure; Tc radioactivity, hydrogen retention/anharmonicity and relativistic/magnetic model sensitivity are concrete counterrisks.",
        "novelty": "No exact ordered HTcRu2Ta experimental superconducting phase was returned by the bounded formula search. Tc handling makes experimental follow-up demanding but does not invalidate a finite source-computational hypothesis.",
        "decision": "Supported as a private finite-source hypothesis at the printed μ*=.1 under the neutral scalar NC/PBEsol approximation; no calibrated physical probability or public score."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "hydrogen_anharmonicity",
        "residual_force_stress",
        "technetium"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 125,
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/HNbTcRu2_agm001616455",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/HTcRu2Ta_agm001619538",
          "other_state": "batch-a/HNbTcRu2_agm001616455",
          "three_symprec_supported": false,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.01
          ],
          "source_Eli_gain_target_minus_other_K": -1.5050000000000008,
          "other_printed_path_negative_values": 0,
          "other_q_sampling_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001616455",
            "dyn0_source_record": 10499,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 10506,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 10507,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 10508,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 10509,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 10510,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 10511,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.06610000000000005,
            -0.03080000000000005
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 126,
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/HRu2TaRe_agm001619536",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/HTcRu2Ta_agm001619538",
          "other_state": "batch-a/HRu2TaRe_agm001619536",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "source_Eli_gain_target_minus_other_K": 0.9239999999999995,
          "other_printed_path_negative_values": 0,
          "other_q_sampling_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001619536",
            "dyn0_source_record": 17821,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 17828,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 17829,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 17830,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 17831,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 17832,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 17833,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.017000000000000015,
            0.07689999999999997
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "directory_key": "batch-a/HTcRu2Ta_agm001619538",
        "source_ID": "agm001619538",
        "composition": {
          "H": 1,
          "Ru": 2,
          "Ta": 1,
          "Tc": 1
        },
        "listed_sites": 5,
        "CIF_source_record": 15403,
        "source_McMillan_and_AD_mu0p1": {
          "value": [
            0.1,
            10.536,
            11.149
          ],
          "missing_tokens": [
            false,
            false,
            false
          ],
          "printed_zero": [
            false,
            false,
            false
          ]
        },
        "source_Eli_mu0p1": {
          "value": [
            0.1,
            12.112
          ],
          "missing_tokens": [
            false,
            false
          ],
          "printed_zero": [
            false,
            false
          ]
        },
        "SCF_coarse": {
          "source_record": 15429,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 14May2023 at 22:50:49"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 5,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000000     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 5,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 0.0,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.0,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.0,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              "atom_index": 1,
              "type_index": 3
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": -0.04,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "-0.04",
              "GPa": -0.004
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.04"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    -2.7e-07,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.04,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -2.7e-07,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.04,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -2.3e-07,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.03
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  -0.004,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.004,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  -0.003
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": -0.03666666666666667,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.004,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
          "native_exit_status": null
        },
        "SCF_fine": {
          "source_record": 15430,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 14May2023 at 22:41: 8"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 5,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000000     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 5,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 0.0,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.0,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.0,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              "atom_index": 1,
              "type_index": 3
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": -0.75,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "-0.75",
              "GPa": -0.075
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.75"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    -3.312e-05,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -4.87,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -3.312e-05,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -4.87,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    5.101e-05,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    7.5
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  -0.487,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.487,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.75
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": -0.7466666666666667,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.75,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
          "native_exit_status": null
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/HTcRu2Ta_agm001619538",
            "bytes": 13395,
            "sha256": "fa92ac4de24ccb2867eecb04afa1d9a6da3e66b682649257ca3247d879b2440d"
          },
          "raw_optical_minimum": 1.0603602382614344e-06,
          "raw_optical_printing_intervals": [
            [
              1.0603363197382995e-06,
              1.0603841567845693e-06
            ],
            [
              1.4000854228221982e-06,
              1.400133259868468e-06
            ],
            [
              1.5618506568318776e-06,
              1.5618984938781474e-06
            ],
            [
              1.5618506568318793e-06,
              1.561898493878149e-06
            ],
            [
              2.2024597386216734e-06,
              2.2025075756679432e-06
            ],
            [
              2.202459738621689e-06,
              2.202507575667959e-06
            ],
            [
              3.1351077724312517e-06,
              3.1351556094775215e-06
            ],
            [
              3.173796989302025e-06,
              3.1738448263482946e-06
            ],
            [
              3.1737969893020354e-06,
              3.1738448263483052e-06
            ],
            [
              4.4614835604327265e-05,
              4.461488344137353e-05
            ],
            [
              4.461483560432729e-05,
              4.461488344137356e-05
            ],
            [
              0.00010010004737906507,
              0.00010010009521611136
            ]
          ],
          "unit": "squared source-Ry frequency convention",
          "native_negative_mode_numbers": [
            1,
            2,
            3
          ],
          "physical_error_bar": null,
          "full_BZ": null
        },
        "retained_path": {
          "kind": "qe_freq_gp_source_path_table",
          "raw_header_lines": [],
          "path_rows": 168,
          "column_width_counts": {
            "16": 168
          },
          "mode_column_values": 2520,
          "negative_printed_values": 0,
          "minimum_printed_mode": {
            "value": -0.0,
            "column_index_zero_based": 1
          },
          "frequency_unit_header": null,
          "column_roles_conditional_on_file_schema": true,
          "fullBZ_coverage": null,
          "dynamical_stability": null,
          "state_link_verified": null
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm001619538",
          "dyn0_source_record": 15415,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                3.0,
                3.0,
                3.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                6.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 15422,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 15423,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 15424,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 15425,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 5,
              "source_record": 15426,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 6,
              "source_record": 15427,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 6,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        },
        "unknowns": {
          "physical_mobile_carrier_density": null,
          "active_orbital_bandwidth": null,
          "public_RPS": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-01-eight-actual-omega-net-pairing-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1213076,
          "sha256": "ae6bc2be8e022ea5308483e2f63d28dfc4565f2cfa13948c036a16368c5f6201",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all62-net-pairing-owned-source-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 4086409,
          "sha256": "bced95fc8c75035eb57c3afbae73d98e099c3e732ef1e07a1836df54a1d60e15",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-owned-62-source-observations-for-Tc-header-readback-v1.json",
          "bytes": 10632536,
          "sha256": "35c5bfdd77eb7194ebebc41802600580a842c5526c8727c40a427c8869890d90",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Published source predictions already known; specific matched mechanism new to reviewed catalogue, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001117007",
      "formula": "Hf2TiZr",
      "reduced_formula": "Hf2TiZr",
      "composition": {
        "Hf": 2,
        "Ti": 1,
        "Zr": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Hf:2|Ti:1|Zr:1",
      "elements": [
        "Hf",
        "Ti",
        "Zr"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001117007",
      "control_state": "agm001229369",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/TiZrHf2_agm001117007",
      "control_directory": null,
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "ordered layered tetragonal four-site source model versus near-cubic ordered same-composition control",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "motif": "ordered layered tetragonal four-site source model versus near-cubic ordered same-composition control",
        "space_group_not_assigned_from_P1": true,
        "largest_colored_nearest_distance_contrast_A": 1.2556977100000002
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 17.029,
        "control_K": 13.384,
        "delta_K": 3.6449999999999996,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": null,
        "range": [
          0.581,
          1.0944
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "reviewed: softeromega, residualforce/stress, differingk/q, ordered/disordered competition, SOC/magnetic/synthesis/hull unknown retained",
      "ambient_scope": "supported as local/finite-grid evidence: Gamma optical positivity beyond printing bound, retained path no negative, converged fineSCF and bounded signed pressure/fullstress/forces; not global stability",
      "route_response": "supported within explicit finite sampling: colored-network geometry difference and same-composition all-ten-width source EPC contrast",
      "next_action": "concrete matched reciprocal-resolution/broadening and competing-phase falsification; not mandatory prerequisite newDFPT for allsource candidates",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "supported: exact pinned ordered source states; CIF/finalgeo/SCFinput/Gamma association passes",
        "quantitative_route_response": "supported within explicit finite sampling: colored-network geometry difference and same-composition all-ten-width source EPC contrast",
        "pairing_relevance": "supported: source conventional direct EPC plus separate reported McMillan/AllenDynes/Eliashberg mu0.1 models; no inheritance or new prediction",
        "ambient_feasibility": "supported as local/finite-grid evidence: Gamma optical positivity beyond printing bound, retained path no negative, converged fineSCF and bounded signed pressure/fullstress/forces; not global stability",
        "competition_and_coherence": "reviewed: softeromega, residualforce/stress, differingk/q, ordered/disordered competition, SOC/magnetic/synthesis/hull unknown retained",
        "novelty": "bounded exact-composition/ordered-hypothesis new-to-reviewed-private-catalogue supported by dated ROOT primary query note, retaining MaterialsCloud2023 source prior and known equiatomic HfTiZr; no firstdiscovery/global absence",
        "decision": "concrete matched reciprocal-resolution/broadening and competing-phase falsification; not mandatory prerequisite newDFPT for allsource candidates"
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase",
        "residual_force_stress",
        "sampling_method"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "receipt.json",
          "bytes": 12520,
          "sha256": "bca59ab1e7336161904224857272545b0e9bcfb7f3d4cc10e1f8599650af7436",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "result.json",
          "bytes": 81549,
          "sha256": "37f815ac8e41e2fcb1e36fd9bd6e9f3cbe4d8c5211e8ceee5975c6df996e8667",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "root-bounded-three-priority-ordered-phase-prior-notes-v1.json",
          "bytes": 2872,
          "sha256": "03671a17aea54ebe3121d374f3d8b5acc6ac8888c154717a8cc73fb0712bae3d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "criteria.json",
          "bytes": 16426,
          "sha256": "e1df615f98f5ed472465daf157d70f7935e7279c33ef767396d144d3b53d2a93",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "new-to-reviewed-catalogue exact ordered geometry hypothesis; published2023 EPC source retained, not first discovery",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001271506",
      "formula": "HfNbTa",
      "reduced_formula": "HfNbTa",
      "composition": {
        "Hf": 1,
        "Nb": 1,
        "Ta": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Hf:1|Nb:1|Ta:1",
      "elements": [
        "Hf",
        "Nb",
        "Ta"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001271506",
      "control_state": "agm001839729",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/NbHfTa_agm001271506",
      "control_directory": null,
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "ordered three-site hexagonal model; no formalSG inferred from P1 export",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "motif": "ordered three-site hexagonal model; no formalSG inferred from P1 export",
        "known_prior": "Known experimental disordered bcc HfNbTa is a control prior, not the same ordered state"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 14.176,
        "control_K": 13.408,
        "delta_K": 0.7680000000000007,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": null,
        "range": [
          0.10989999999999989,
          0.1338999999999999
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Explicit softening, q/k sampling, residual force/stress, harmonic scalar/noSOC approximation and ordered/disordered competitors assessed. No retained dominant contradiction reverses the bounded preliminary inference; magnetic/SOC/thermodynamic/coherence tests remain falsifiable follow-ups.",
      "ambient_scope": "Near-zero signed source pressure−0.067GPa, converged fine SCF, positive Gamma optical compression beyond source-printing bound and no signed negative retained interpolation-path modes support bounded local/finite-grid feasibility. Residual maxstress0.502GPa/force0.02436eV-A and no global hull/synthesis proof remain stated.",
      "route_response": "Against same-composition AGM001839729, species-colored nearest-distance network differs by0.384473576A and source lambda A−B=0.1099–0.1339 across all ten common widths. Different geometry-adapted reciprocal grids remain explicit confounding; response supported at source sampling approximation, not a geometry-only causal theorem.",
      "next_action": "Matched reciprocal-resolution and competing-order tests will distinguish stable geometry/EPC benefit from sampling/softening. Maintain only if paired benefit and feasible modes survive; reduce support if gain vanishes or an instability/competing state dominates; ambiguous results retain hypothesis rather than forced acceptance.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact three-site ordered hexagonal AGM001271506, named-species CIF/SCF/PH/Gamma association after proper60degree frame rotation and one global origin shift. QE6.8 scalar neutral/noSOC configured source model and paired PP MD5/PBEsol/cutoffs/smear linked; experimental state not inferred.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Against same-composition AGM001839729, species-colored nearest-distance network differs by0.384473576A and source lambda A−B=0.1099–0.1339 across all ten common widths. Different geometry-adapted reciprocal grids remain explicit confounding; response supported at source sampling approximation, not a geometry-only causal theorem.",
        "pairing_relevance": "Direct published conventional EPC is higher by9.13–11.78%; two separately reported Tc models at mu*=0.1 favor A. Lower omega_log and independent estimator definitions retained; no numerical source-Tc unit silently assigned to a new child.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Near-zero signed source pressure−0.067GPa, converged fine SCF, positive Gamma optical compression beyond source-printing bound and no signed negative retained interpolation-path modes support bounded local/finite-grid feasibility. Residual maxstress0.502GPa/force0.02436eV-A and no global hull/synthesis proof remain stated.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Explicit softening, q/k sampling, residual force/stress, harmonic scalar/noSOC approximation and ordered/disordered competitors assessed. No retained dominant contradiction reverses the bounded preliminary inference; magnetic/SOC/thermodynamic/coherence tests remain falsifiable follow-ups.",
        "novelty": "Dated catalogue/primary review distinguishes exact ordered hexagonal source phase from experimental disordered bcc HfNbTa prior. New-to-reviewed-catalogue material-design hypothesis only; published2023 source calculation and known chemistry intentionally retained, not first discovery.",
        "decision": "Matched reciprocal-resolution and competing-order tests will distinguish stable geometry/EPC benefit from sampling/softening. Maintain only if paired benefit and feasible modes survive; reduce support if gain vanishes or an instability/competing state dominates; ambiguous results retain hypothesis rather than forced acceptance."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase",
        "residual_force_stress",
        "sampling_method"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "receipt.json",
          "bytes": 85501,
          "sha256": "9937b036159cccae22c272c5ed84104d6ec232d87b0d46b5ed3cadf523e0d89a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "receipt.json",
          "bytes": 6442,
          "sha256": "98a1aaf5b9c2626cc72a7fe8a048b89dcc87bd07ff2ef9c82ea8c73e31216882",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "root-bounded-three-priority-ordered-phase-prior-notes-v1.json",
          "bytes": 2872,
          "sha256": "03671a17aea54ebe3121d374f3d8b5acc6ac8888c154717a8cc73fb0712bae3d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "criteria.json",
          "bytes": 16426,
          "sha256": "e1df615f98f5ed472465daf157d70f7935e7279c33ef767396d144d3b53d2a93",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "new-to-reviewed-catalogue ordered geometry hypothesis; literature-derived, not first discovery",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001106125",
      "formula": "HfRu3H",
      "reduced_formula": "HfRu3H",
      "composition": {
        "H": 1,
        "Hf": 1,
        "Ru": 3
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "H:1|Hf:1|Ru:3",
      "elements": [
        "H",
        "Hf",
        "Ru"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001106125",
      "control_state": "agm001106365",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/HRu3Hf_agm001106125",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/HVRu3_agm001106365",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Pm-3m five-site ordered hydrogen intermetallic cage: H 1a, Hf 1b, Ru three edge-center sites",
      "prototype_evidence": "Pm-3m five-site ordered hydrogen intermetallic cage: H 1a, Hf 1b, Ru three edge-center sites",
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 14.498,
        "control_K": 13.564,
        "delta_K": 0.9339999999999993,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.2986,
          0.277,
          0.29070000000000007,
          0.28770000000000007,
          0.27270000000000005,
          0.24959999999999993,
          0.22050000000000014,
          0.18689999999999984,
          0.1509999999999999,
          0.11499999999999999
        ],
        "range": [
          0.11499999999999999,
          0.2986
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Hydrogen zero-point/anharmonic and vacancy/decomposition energetics, ordering entropy and Hf/Ru SOC may alter the prediction. The actual target has no signed negative finite-path value and positive Gamma optical compression. Ti3HfH is better at all ten lambda values and remains a retained negative control for the claim of globally optimal chemistry; it does not contradict the narrower Hf-for-V hypothesis.",
      "ambient_scope": "Both source SCFs converge, near-zero coarse forces/stress and bounded fine response are measured. Fine Fmax=0 eV/A, P=-0.056 GPa, full max stress=0.056 GPa. Gamma optical compression is positive beyond printing bound and sampled path has no signed negative values. All listed q outputs have JOBDONE/last response convergence and no routine errors. This supports a finite-grid local/metastable source model, not global hull or experimental synthesis.",
      "route_response": "Hf replaces V on the unique cage-corner cation site with the three Ru and one H roles retained. Cell volume rises 10.763%, H-Ru distance rises 0.0660796 A and Hf-Ru versus V-Ru rises 0.0934507 A. This coupled cation/network construction increases source lambda across all ten sigma values; it is not an expansion-only causal attribution.",
      "next_action": "Compare HfRu3H and VRu3H at a common cage volume, identical PP/cutoff and q/k sampling, and include H vacancy/decomposition or anharmonic stability evidence. Persistence of the lambda gain supports the coupled construction; collapse of the gain or a nontranslation soft branch opposes it.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Complete ordered CIF/literal coarse-fine input/Gamma periodic species-site association is numerically supported; source input geometry and full tensor/forces are retained. Export occupancy is a discrete computational convention; source experimental P/T/occupancy and actual compiled unit constant are unknown. Exact-version input defaults scope the configured neutral scalar spin1/noSOC model, not magnetic ground state.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Hf replaces V on the unique cage-corner cation site with the three Ru and one H roles retained. Cell volume rises 10.763%, H-Ru distance rises 0.0660796 A and Hf-Ru versus V-Ru rises 0.0934507 A. This coupled cation/network construction increases source lambda across all ten sigma values; it is not an expansion-only causal attribution.",
        "pairing_relevance": "Exact target and mapped control direct source lambda arrays have the same favorable sign at all ten common broadening tokens; omega_ln has explicit K units and separate Eli/McM mu=.1 tables remain independent. Same underlying q mesh is observed. The sensitivity range is not a physical error bound; sigma units, full-BZ convergence, experimental Tc and pure-geometry causality remain unknown. Literal method differences are declared confounds.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Both source SCFs converge, near-zero coarse forces/stress and bounded fine response are measured. Fine Fmax=0 eV/A, P=-0.056 GPa, full max stress=0.056 GPa. Gamma optical compression is positive beyond printing bound and sampled path has no signed negative values. All listed q outputs have JOBDONE/last response convergence and no routine errors. This supports a finite-grid local/metastable source model, not global hull or experimental synthesis.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Hydrogen zero-point/anharmonic and vacancy/decomposition energetics, ordering entropy and Hf/Ru SOC may alter the prediction. The actual target has no signed negative finite-path value and positive Gamma optical compression. Ti3HfH is better at all ten lambda values and remains a retained negative control for the claim of globally optimal chemistry; it does not contradict the narrower Hf-for-V hypothesis.",
        "novelty": "Exact HfRu3H/HRu3Hf superconductivity queries on 2026-10-07 identified no experimental superconducting exact ordered phase. The MC2023 published prediction is acknowledged prior, and only the matched Hf-for-V source hypothesis is proposed as new to this reviewed catalogue.",
        "decision": "Compare HfRu3H and VRu3H at a common cage volume, identical PP/cutoff and q/k sampling, and include H vacancy/decomposition or anharmonic stability evidence. Persistence of the lambda gain supports the coupled construction; collapse of the gain or a nontranslation soft branch opposes it."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "hydrogen_anharmonicity",
        "metastable_phase"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index_zero_based": 127,
          "control_directory": "batch-a/HTi3Hf_agm002488868",
          "mapping_scope": "bounded ordered isostructural analogue",
          "all_three_symprec_support": true,
          "composition_edit": {
            "from": "Ru",
            "to": "Ti",
            "count": 3,
            "kind": "whole_element_substitution"
          },
          "volume_target_over_control": 0.845176649562835,
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_all10": [
            -12.961484120646224,
            -27.37190837950533,
            -31.70731707317073,
            -33.27355265370173,
            -34.133073751717816,
            -34.84492481203007,
            -35.48640009649598,
            -36.084132384781945,
            -36.66582246422692,
            -37.23335488041371
          ],
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_range": [
            -37.23335488041371,
            -12.961484120646224
          ],
          "separate_source_Eli_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              14.498
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              22.108
            ]
          ],
          "separate_source_McM_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              12.645,
              13.809
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              17.125,
              20.133
            ]
          ],
          "literal_method_same_fields": {
            "ecutwfc": true,
            "smear": true,
            "degauss": true,
            "pseudo_dir": false
          },
          "qmesh_target_control": [
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ]
          ],
          "irreducible_qcount_target_control": [
            [
              4.0
            ],
            [
              4.0
            ]
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index_zero_based": 128,
          "control_directory": "batch-a/HVRu3_agm001106365",
          "mapping_scope": "bounded ordered isostructural analogue",
          "all_three_symprec_support": true,
          "composition_edit": {
            "from": "Hf",
            "to": "V",
            "count": 1,
            "kind": "single_site_substitution"
          },
          "volume_target_over_control": 1.107627860937794,
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_all10": [
            26.70124295806134,
            27.853192559074913,
            30.974960042621213,
            31.863993797762767,
            31.07338195077485,
            29.03676128431828,
            25.965614696184662,
            22.08436724565755,
            17.77934769810431,
            13.434579439252337
          ],
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_range": [
            13.434579439252337,
            31.863993797762767
          ],
          "separate_source_Eli_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              14.498
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              13.564
            ]
          ],
          "separate_source_McM_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              12.645,
              13.809
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              11.74,
              12.425
            ]
          ],
          "literal_method_same_fields": {
            "ecutwfc": false,
            "smear": true,
            "degauss": true,
            "pseudo_dir": false
          },
          "qmesh_target_control": [
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ]
          ],
          "irreducible_qcount_target_control": [
            [
              4.0
            ],
            [
              4.0
            ]
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "nat": 5,
        "lambda10": [
          1.4169,
          1.2715,
          1.2292,
          1.1906,
          1.1503,
          1.1092,
          1.0697,
          1.0332,
          1.0003,
          0.971
        ],
        "omega10_K": [
          156.3525,
          157.2329,
          157.0518,
          156.6105,
          156.1813,
          155.8404,
          155.5951,
          155.4384,
          155.3602,
          155.3489
        ],
        "Eli_mu01": [
          0.1,
          14.498
        ],
        "McM_mu01": [
          0.1,
          12.645,
          13.809
        ],
        "coarse_fine": [
          {
            "record": 7463,
            "version": [
              "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 14May2023 at 22: 5:22"
            ],
            "converged": true,
            "JOBDONE": true,
            "errors": 0,
            "Fmax_eVA": 0.0,
            "P_GPa": -0.002,
            "maxstress_GPa": 0.002,
            "fulltensor": [
              [
                -0.002,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                -0.002,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                -0.002
              ]
            ],
            "F_Ry": -1175.51563514,
            "E_Ry": -1175.51471027,
            "pattern_selected_warning_counts": {
              "BFGS": 1,
              "negative_charge": 0,
              "eigen_text": 0,
              "failure_text": 0,
              "SCF_correction_text": 1
            },
            "warning_scope": "pattern-selected contexts; informational SCF correction and ignored cell card are not optimization failure; no whole-file warning-free claim"
          },
          {
            "record": 7464,
            "version": [
              "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 14May2023 at 22: 0:14"
            ],
            "converged": true,
            "JOBDONE": true,
            "errors": 0,
            "Fmax_eVA": 0.0,
            "P_GPa": -0.05600000000000001,
            "maxstress_GPa": 0.05600000000000001,
            "fulltensor": [
              [
                -0.05600000000000001,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                -0.05600000000000001,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                -0.05600000000000001
              ]
            ],
            "F_Ry": -1175.51698699,
            "E_Ry": -1175.5167780900001,
            "pattern_selected_warning_counts": {
              "BFGS": 1,
              "negative_charge": 0,
              "eigen_text": 0,
              "failure_text": 0,
              "SCF_correction_text": 1
            },
            "warning_scope": "pattern-selected contexts; informational SCF correction and ignored cell card are not optimization failure; no whole-file warning-free claim"
          }
        ],
        "inputs": [
          {
            "record": 7453,
            "ecutwfc": [
              144.0
            ],
            "ecutrho": null,
            "pseudo_dir": [
              "/dss/dsshome1/07/di29xud3/software/progs/qe/pp/nc-sr-04_pbesol_stringent_upf/"
            ],
            "spin": null,
            "noncol": null,
            "SOC": null,
            "charge": null,
            "smear": [
              "mp"
            ],
            "degauss": [
              0.014699728870262
            ],
            "ibrav": [
              1.0
            ],
            "nat": [
              5.0
            ],
            "grid": [
              "6 6 6 0 0 0"
            ]
          },
          {
            "record": 7454,
            "ecutwfc": [
              144.0
            ],
            "ecutrho": null,
            "pseudo_dir": [
              "/dss/dsshome1/07/di29xud3/software/progs/qe/pp/nc-sr-04_pbesol_stringent_upf/"
            ],
            "spin": null,
            "noncol": null,
            "SOC": null,
            "charge": null,
            "smear": [
              "mp"
            ],
            "degauss": [
              0.014699728870262
            ],
            "ibrav": [
              1.0
            ],
            "nat": [
              5.0
            ],
            "grid": [
              "24 24 24 0 0 0"
            ]
          }
        ],
        "Gamma": {
          "nat": 5,
          "ibrav": 1,
          "q": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species": [
            "H",
            "Hf",
            "Ru"
          ],
          "optical": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "minopt": 8.118120016713509e-07,
          "printingbound": 2.3913080512637623e-11,
          "negative_native_modes": [
            1,
            2,
            3
          ],
          "negativeoutside3": [],
          "min_low3_translation": 0.9999070909012002,
          "sourcepin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/HRu3Hf_agm001106125",
            "bytes": 13349,
            "sha256": "7e5632224485fd7b22abb8f037cdbc508831fda9b13dc18b2855de8f6c6b00a3"
          }
        },
        "path": {
          "rows": 124,
          "negatives": 0,
          "minimum": -0.0,
          "unit": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-2-compact-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 84096,
          "sha256": "d8ca53bafc5ee0879de647e050127d8e0d20c0e3da10de9602ab2de44bf77532",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-3-five-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 110335,
          "sha256": "861dd76c8368cca687ca20c8468e464badefb533a318ed41c4f8d62dccb6ed50",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-4-three-phase-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 64369,
          "sha256": "56076a077e591b9bdef8ada45d78f224f417a4af8d2e722e332f639eedfafaf7",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all64-light-Nb-rich-owned-review-cache-v2.json",
          "bytes": 4566542,
          "sha256": "f27e8c84c10c4d8de44022f6bd160e7e8aee8b2d562db5fd6003af68d5e35756",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to this reviewed candidate catalogue and mechanism contrast; MC2023 prediction is prior, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001631318",
      "formula": "HfTc2",
      "reduced_formula": "HfTc2",
      "composition": {
        "Hf": 1,
        "Tc": 2
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Hf:1|Tc:2",
      "elements": [
        "Hf",
        "Tc"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001631318",
      "control_state": "agm001631258",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Tc2Hf_agm001631318",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/HfRe2_agm001631258",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "CIF_source_record": 4775,
        "CIF_payload_pin": {
          "bytes": 591661,
          "sha256": "93c3ce21c362fc36392db6d13f4555d76cce96122769d1212414bbc770f81541"
        },
        "SCF_coarse_source_record": 4787,
        "Gamma_source_pin": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/Tc2Hf_agm001631318",
          "bytes": 18568,
          "sha256": "3556faf86093169f277b7728c3fc991409ad679504b033a6983143924813316f"
        },
        "source_input_volume_difference_relative": 7.964295889451023e-12,
        "occupancy_model_all1": true,
        "bounded_signed_axis_and_translation_mapping": {
          "signed_axis_U_CIF_fractional_to_SCF": [
            [
              1,
              0,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              1,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              0,
              1
            ]
          ],
          "determinant": 1,
          "origin_shift_fractional": [
            -7.20888904126582e-09,
            1.1626670071152034e-08,
            -7.20888904126582e-09
          ],
          "species_bijection_CIF_to_SCF": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            3,
            4,
            5
          ],
          "maximum_site_distance_A": 5.999568801562986e-08,
          "relative_Gram_residual": 1.6129126056868282e-09,
          "proper_signed_axis_solution": true
        },
        "attempts": 1,
        "general_GL3_or_chiral_equivalence_asserted": false,
        "CIF_site_precision_A_tolerance": 1e-05,
        "physical_model": "source finite neutral scalar EPC; no SOC transfer certificate"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 16.968,
        "control_K": 14.183,
        "delta_K": 2.785,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.11820000000000008,
          0.07679999999999998,
          0.0807,
          0.08339999999999992,
          0.08509999999999995,
          0.08979999999999988,
          0.09699999999999998,
          0.10519999999999996,
          0.11350000000000005,
          0.12130000000000007
        ],
        "range": [
          0.07679999999999998,
          0.12130000000000007
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Target is not universally superior: ZrTc2 and several ternary children have larger source responses; Lu increases lambda but lowers Tc. Tc radioactivity limits practical follow-up, not this computation. Scalar NC treatment and C14 competitor are explicit. Zero SCF forces and positive sampled phonon evidence support a near-zero-pressure local source minimum, not bulk ground-state synthesis. Saved q2 all12 representations converge, all18 nonzero-q frequencies positive, and ten Ry Gaussian widths contain all18 lambda/gamma modes. No native exit inferred. C14 competition, SOC, radioactivity and metaphase retention remain bounded risks.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.002 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.22999999999999998 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
      "route_response": "Re-to-Tc replacement in the C15 HfX2 network. coupled chemical/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
      "next_action": "Compare the existing C15 branch with published C14 phase and source-controlled Re→Tc EPC. Favorable: C15 retains local stability and pairing advantage as a viable metastable branch; adverse: exact-known C15 alias or phase competition removes distinct useful state; ambiguous: phase-level literature cannot settle exact association.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact source CIF/SCF/Γ state association; CIF source record 4775. Experimental occupancy/P/T and physical magnetic ground state remain unknown; source scalar model only.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Re-to-Tc replacement in the C15 HfX2 network. coupled chemical/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
        "pairing_relevance": "direct published source EPC and independent source isotropic Eliashberg result. 2 favorable comparator(s); bounded source model, not experiment.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.002 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.22999999999999998 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Target is not universally superior: ZrTc2 and several ternary children have larger source responses; Lu increases lambda but lowers Tc. Tc radioactivity limits practical follow-up, not this computation. Scalar NC treatment and C14 competitor are explicit. Zero SCF forces and positive sampled phonon evidence support a near-zero-pressure local source minimum, not bulk ground-state synthesis. Saved q2 all12 representations converge, all18 nonzero-q frequencies positive, and ten Ry Gaussian widths contain all18 lambda/gamma modes. No native exit inferred. C14 competition, SOC, radioactivity and metaphase retention remain bounded risks.",
        "novelty": "Primary binary Tc study Table1 lists experimental HfTc2 as C14, while present source target is C15 SG227. Older calculated HfX2 paper confirms composition already investigated but exact source geometry is not transferred. Count only a reviewed distinct C15 hypothesis, never HfTc2 chemistry as new.",
        "decision": "Compare the existing C15 branch with published C14 phase and source-controlled Re→Tc EPC. Favorable: C15 retains local stability and pairing advantage as a viable metastable branch; adverse: exact-known C15 alias or phase competition removes distinct useful state; ambiguous: phase-level literature cannot settle exact association."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase",
        "residual_force_stress",
        "technetium"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 131,
          "control": "batch-a/HfRe2_agm001631258",
          "target": "batch-a/Tc2Hf_agm001631318",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.07679999999999998,
            0.12130000000000007
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            5.894542942666359,
            13.236577913574866
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 16.968,
          "Tc_control_K": 14.183,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 2.785,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9762514336721332,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.1326546678821608e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.07679999999999998,
            0.12130000000000007
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 243,
          "control": "batch-a/ScTc2_agm003198926",
          "target": "batch-a/Tc2Hf_agm001631318",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.0039000000000000146,
            0.16660000000000008
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            0.377248984329659,
            13.069741900054922
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 16.968,
          "Tc_control_K": 14.29,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 2.678000000000001,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9968620110195329,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.0179346913436019e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.0039000000000000146,
            0.16660000000000008
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 249,
          "control": "batch-a/ScTc4Hf_agm001184600",
          "target": "batch-a/Tc2Hf_agm001631318",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.10410000000000008,
            -0.040000000000000036
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -7.015770319450065,
            -3.7116080541894805
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 16.968,
          "Tc_control_K": 16.724,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 0.24399999999999977,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": false,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.999324946545412,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.2218852735181743e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.10410000000000008,
            -0.040000000000000036
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 271,
          "control": "batch-a/Tc2Lu_agm001631328",
          "target": "batch-a/Tc2Hf_agm001631318",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.8879000000000001,
            -0.7399
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -41.62353735373537,
            -37.93710452447785
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 16.968,
          "Tc_control_K": 15.43,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 1.5380000000000003,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9491836885295002,
          "control_path_negatives": 6,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.0260953212887805e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.8879000000000001,
            -0.7399
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 272,
          "control": "batch-a/YTc4Hf_agm001187527",
          "target": "batch-a/Tc2Hf_agm001631318",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -1.9167,
            -1.0817
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -57.07861822513401,
            -51.038029631027655
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 16.968,
          "Tc_control_K": 18.849,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": -1.8810000000000002,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": true,
          "three_tol_graph": false,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9565764354579344,
          "control_path_negatives": 33,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 9.813657805892442e-07,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -1.9167,
            -1.0817
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 273,
          "control": "batch-a/ZrTc2_agm003203155",
          "target": "batch-a/Tc2Hf_agm001631318",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.4991000000000001,
            -0.2761
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -26.56482861400895,
            -21.015375247374028
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 16.968,
          "Tc_control_K": 20.576,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": -3.6080000000000005,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": true,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9856800510287274,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.4596680273831718e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.4991000000000001,
            -0.2761
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 274,
          "control": "batch-a/ZrTc4Hf_agm001177851",
          "target": "batch-a/Tc2Hf_agm001631318",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.21960000000000002,
            -0.12209999999999988
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -13.73100731570062,
            -10.527677185721664
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 16.968,
          "Tc_control_K": 18.96,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": -1.9920000000000009,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": true,
          "three_tol_graph": false,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9927570038391133,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.1274324923852392e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.21960000000000002,
            -0.12209999999999988
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-01-ten-specific-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 381754,
          "sha256": "5d05478212c4d22080ab1b7bf22d92b784de6c0f8a99590d0758f9cdbfdafb32",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-remaining-transition-owned-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 5381838,
          "sha256": "62f4910578c7b65392d26619cf81b31afd6142f38aa49834a70bb147e7ab222d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "composition-assessments.json",
          "bytes": 1863044,
          "sha256": "5fc901f5f4a90b41e807722d92f39d81714b70091a189cdb5eba13367624350b",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "numeric-review.json",
          "bytes": 4542684,
          "sha256": "c4fae01d3d67f774429114902a6b39f5b133de48ea81d3d9773ba40ff4419ce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-two-PH-actual-complete-response-products-readback-v1.json",
          "bytes": 77119,
          "sha256": "434c5fe7a590607adbc104dd75d126497457317bc20f37973b5013491e9fdce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "receipt.json",
          "bytes": 14112,
          "sha256": "1f156c1df5e254b2b234b38948e599c99f87983de7f6fbc24663e88726dfe2fb",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Previously published source model; new to reviewed exact-state mechanism catalogue, not first composition or SC discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm002488868",
      "formula": "HfTi3H",
      "reduced_formula": "HfTi3H",
      "composition": {
        "H": 1,
        "Hf": 1,
        "Ti": 3
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "H:1|Hf:1|Ti:3",
      "elements": [
        "H",
        "Hf",
        "Ti"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm002488868",
      "control_state": "agm001106125",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/HTi3Hf_agm002488868",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/HRu3Hf_agm001106125",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "cubic Pm-3m five-site antiperovskite-like metal hydride: H 1a, Hf 1b, three Ti edge centers forming the H octahedral cage",
      "prototype_evidence": "cubic Pm-3m five-site antiperovskite-like metal hydride: H 1a, Hf 1b, three Ti edge centers forming the H octahedral cage",
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 22.108,
        "control_K": 14.498,
        "delta_K": 7.610000000000001,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.21099999999999985,
          0.47919999999999985,
          0.5707,
          0.5936999999999999,
          0.5960999999999999,
          0.5932,
          0.5883999999999998,
          0.5833000000000002,
          0.5791,
          0.576
        ],
        "range": [
          0.21099999999999985,
          0.5960999999999999
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Hydrogen desorption, competing binary metal hydrides/alloys and anharmonicity are the primary metastability risks; source no-SOC scalar metal model does not resolve all magnetic states. No actual instability has been found in the source path or Gamma optical subspace. Fine stress .090 GPa and exactly symmetry-zero printed forces support the specified near-ambient approximation, not an experimental sample.",
      "ambient_scope": "Coarse/fine SCF both converge; complete source forces/stress, positive Gamma optical compression and no signed negative finite-path value support this model near ambient. All listed q outputs end JOBDONE/response convergence with zero routine errors. This is finite-grid local/metastable evidence, not exhaustive thermodynamic or all-irrep certification.",
      "route_response": "Replace all three symmetry-equivalent Ru sites in HfRu3H by Ti. Ordered cage roles/bijection are retained at three symprec scales. Cell volume rises 18.31846%; H-cage-metal distance rises .1137601 A and cage-metal nearest separation .1608810 A. All-ten lambda rises 14.892–59.320%, with separate Eli mu=.1 14.498→22.108 K. This directly tests a coupled cage reconstruction with cation chemistry, not high mobile n or active bandwidth.",
      "next_action": "Use a fixed-composition volume/cage control and one matched H-metal cage response, preserving the ordered H site. Favorable: Ti cage pairing response remains stronger at common sampling and anharmonic displacement is bounded; adverse: H loss/decomposition or an unstable cage branch removes the response.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Raw CIF, literal coarse/fine crystal input and Gamma header agree by complete ordered species/site periodic association; exact natural-isotope discrete computational occupancy is export convention, experimental occupancy/P/T unknown. Source model configured neutral scalar spin1/noSOC by exact-version defaults plus literal omission; magnetic ground state and binary build not certified.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Replace all three symmetry-equivalent Ru sites in HfRu3H by Ti. Ordered cage roles/bijection are retained at three symprec scales. Cell volume rises 18.31846%; H-cage-metal distance rises .1137601 A and cage-metal nearest separation .1608810 A. All-ten lambda rises 14.892–59.320%, with separate Eli mu=.1 14.498→22.108 K. This directly tests a coupled cage reconstruction with cation chemistry, not high mobile n or active bandwidth.",
        "pairing_relevance": "Direct exact-source lambda has the favorable sign at all ten matched sigma tokens, independently accompanied by the separate mu=.1 Eli table. Finite-grid broadening sensitivity is preserved; differing PP/cutoff/version are model confounds where shown. Sigma units, physical error bar, fullBZ convergence and experimental Tc remain unknown.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Coarse/fine SCF both converge; complete source forces/stress, positive Gamma optical compression and no signed negative finite-path value support this model near ambient. All listed q outputs end JOBDONE/response convergence with zero routine errors. This is finite-grid local/metastable evidence, not exhaustive thermodynamic or all-irrep certification.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Hydrogen desorption, competing binary metal hydrides/alloys and anharmonicity are the primary metastability risks; source no-SOC scalar metal model does not resolve all magnetic states. No actual instability has been found in the source path or Gamma optical subspace. Fine stress .090 GPa and exactly symmetry-zero printed forces support the specified near-ambient approximation, not an experimental sample.",
        "novelty": "2026-10-07 exact Ti3HfH/HfTi3H/HfRu3H search did not locate an experimental superconducting exact ordered phase. MC2023 prediction is already known and is retained as the primary prior; this is a new-to-reviewed-catalogue Hf-centered cage construction hypothesis.",
        "decision": "Use a fixed-composition volume/cage control and one matched H-metal cage response, preserving the ordered H site. Favorable: Ti cage pairing response remains stronger at common sampling and anharmonic displacement is bounded; adverse: H loss/decomposition or an unstable cage branch removes the response."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "hydrogen_anharmonicity",
        "metastable_phase",
        "residual_force_stress"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [],
      "physical_summary": {
        "nat": 5,
        "lambda10": [
          1.6279,
          1.7507,
          1.7999,
          1.7843,
          1.7464,
          1.7024,
          1.6581,
          1.6165,
          1.5794,
          1.547
        ],
        "omega10_K": [
          140.0328,
          136.1951,
          134.9773,
          134.3801,
          134.0242,
          133.7706,
          133.542,
          133.2942,
          133.0074,
          132.6801
        ],
        "Eli_mu01": [
          0.1,
          22.108
        ],
        "McM_mu01": [
          0.1,
          17.125,
          20.133
        ],
        "coarse_fine": [
          {
            "record": 1503,
            "version": [
              "Program PWSCF v.6.8 starts on 10May2023 at 10:42:31"
            ],
            "converged": true,
            "JOBDONE": true,
            "errors": 0,
            "Fmax_eVA": 0.0,
            "P_GPa": -0.001,
            "maxstress_GPa": 0.001,
            "fulltensor": [
              [
                -0.001,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                -0.001,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                -0.001
              ]
            ],
            "pattern_selected_warning_counts": {
              "BFGS": 1,
              "negative_charge": 0,
              "eigen_text": 0,
              "failure_text": 0,
              "SCF_correction_text": 1
            }
          },
          {
            "record": 1504,
            "version": [
              "Program PWSCF v.6.8 starts on 10May2023 at 10:37:14"
            ],
            "converged": true,
            "JOBDONE": true,
            "errors": 0,
            "Fmax_eVA": 0.0,
            "P_GPa": 0.09,
            "maxstress_GPa": 0.09,
            "fulltensor": [
              [
                0.09,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                0.09,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                0.09
              ]
            ],
            "pattern_selected_warning_counts": {
              "BFGS": 1,
              "negative_charge": 0,
              "eigen_text": 0,
              "failure_text": 0,
              "SCF_correction_text": 1
            }
          }
        ],
        "Gamma": {
          "nat": 5,
          "ibrav": 1,
          "q": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species": [
            "H",
            "Hf",
            "Ti"
          ],
          "optical": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "minopt": 5.907594139705179e-07,
          "printingbound": 2.4680928139459147e-11,
          "negative_native_modes": [
            1,
            2,
            3
          ],
          "negativeoutside3": [],
          "min_low3_translation": 0.9995604484291484,
          "sourcepin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/HTi3Hf_agm002488868",
            "bytes": 13355,
            "sha256": "0b618479eea665299d2542fb98d99bbd3c60d4c002e15a32f2da77590a91a701"
          }
        },
        "path": {
          "rows": 121,
          "negatives": 0,
          "minimum": -0.0,
          "unit": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-1-compact-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 34933,
          "sha256": "c27b3f0105c6f12aa51f2d0801a476adfacdc6cac93b8dd5b60cd485d18cd4f2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-four-tranche-eight-source-states-independent-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 267678,
          "sha256": "857ce54f337154bb41cfa9e21370ab305f2bd35f31ab86c37fcd0ba8de21a391",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to this reviewed candidate catalogue and mechanism contrast; MC2023 prediction is prior, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001117008",
      "formula": "HfTiZr2",
      "reduced_formula": "HfTiZr2",
      "composition": {
        "Hf": 1,
        "Ti": 1,
        "Zr": 2
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Hf:1|Ti:1|Zr:2",
      "elements": [
        "Hf",
        "Ti",
        "Zr"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001117008",
      "control_state": "agm001229341",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/TiZr2Hf_agm001117008",
      "control_directory": null,
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "ordered layered tetragonal four-site source model versus near-cubic ordered same-composition control",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "motif": "ordered layered tetragonal four-site source model versus near-cubic ordered same-composition control",
        "space_group_not_assigned_from_P1": true,
        "largest_colored_nearest_distance_contrast_A": 1.24918306
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 17.936,
        "control_K": 14.171,
        "delta_K": 3.7650000000000006,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": null,
        "range": [
          0.5230000000000001,
          0.7524
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "reviewed: softeromega, residualforce/stress, differingk/q, ordered/disordered competition, SOC/magnetic/synthesis/hull unknown retained",
      "ambient_scope": "supported as local/finite-grid evidence: Gamma optical positivity beyond printing bound, retained path no negative, converged fineSCF and bounded signed pressure/fullstress/forces; not global stability",
      "route_response": "supported within explicit finite sampling: colored-network geometry difference and same-composition all-ten-width source EPC contrast",
      "next_action": "concrete matched reciprocal-resolution/broadening and competing-phase falsification; not mandatory prerequisite newDFPT for allsource candidates",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "supported: exact pinned ordered source states; CIF/finalgeo/SCFinput/Gamma association passes",
        "quantitative_route_response": "supported within explicit finite sampling: colored-network geometry difference and same-composition all-ten-width source EPC contrast",
        "pairing_relevance": "supported: source conventional direct EPC plus separate reported McMillan/AllenDynes/Eliashberg mu0.1 models; no inheritance or new prediction",
        "ambient_feasibility": "supported as local/finite-grid evidence: Gamma optical positivity beyond printing bound, retained path no negative, converged fineSCF and bounded signed pressure/fullstress/forces; not global stability",
        "competition_and_coherence": "reviewed: softeromega, residualforce/stress, differingk/q, ordered/disordered competition, SOC/magnetic/synthesis/hull unknown retained",
        "novelty": "bounded exact-composition/ordered-hypothesis new-to-reviewed-private-catalogue supported by dated ROOT primary query note, retaining MaterialsCloud2023 source prior and known equiatomic HfTiZr; no firstdiscovery/global absence",
        "decision": "concrete matched reciprocal-resolution/broadening and competing-phase falsification; not mandatory prerequisite newDFPT for allsource candidates"
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase",
        "residual_force_stress",
        "sampling_method"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "receipt.json",
          "bytes": 12520,
          "sha256": "bca59ab1e7336161904224857272545b0e9bcfb7f3d4cc10e1f8599650af7436",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "result.json",
          "bytes": 81549,
          "sha256": "37f815ac8e41e2fcb1e36fd9bd6e9f3cbe4d8c5211e8ceee5975c6df996e8667",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "root-bounded-three-priority-ordered-phase-prior-notes-v1.json",
          "bytes": 2872,
          "sha256": "03671a17aea54ebe3121d374f3d8b5acc6ac8888c154717a8cc73fb0712bae3d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "criteria.json",
          "bytes": 16426,
          "sha256": "e1df615f98f5ed472465daf157d70f7935e7279c33ef767396d144d3b53d2a93",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "new-to-reviewed-catalogue exact ordered geometry hypothesis; published2023 EPC source retained, not first discovery",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm002493455",
      "formula": "LiPtH3",
      "reduced_formula": "LiPtH3",
      "composition": {
        "H": 3,
        "Li": 1,
        "Pt": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "H:3|Li:1|Pt:1",
      "elements": [
        "H",
        "Li",
        "Pt"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm002493455",
      "control_state": "agm002486518",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/H3LiPt_agm002493455",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/H3NaPt_agm002486518",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Pm-3m five-site ordered perovskite hydride: Pt 1a, Li 1b, H three edge-center sites",
      "prototype_evidence": "Pm-3m five-site ordered perovskite hydride: Pt 1a, Li 1b, H three edge-center sites",
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 17.461,
        "control_K": 13.298,
        "delta_K": 4.1629999999999985,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          1.0056,
          0.5058,
          0.3201,
          0.22759999999999997,
          0.16850000000000004,
          0.13639999999999997,
          0.1235,
          0.12139999999999995,
          0.12429999999999997,
          0.12899999999999995
        ],
        "range": [
          0.12139999999999995,
          1.0056
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Hydrogen desorption, zero-point/anharmonic response and decomposition compete with superconductivity. The exact source path is nonnegative and Gamma optical compression positive; force is zero by symmetry but fine pressure remains 0.288 GPa. The retained LaPtH3 control has larger lambda but lower separate Eli Tc, showing an omega/coupling tradeoff; AgPtH3 and LiPdH3 have still larger lambda with actual negative source paths, so they are not silently discarded or treated as stable superior cases.",
      "ambient_scope": "Both source SCFs converge, near-zero coarse forces/stress and bounded fine response are measured. Fine Fmax=0 eV/A, P=0.288 GPa, full max stress=0.288 GPa. Gamma optical compression is positive beyond printing bound and sampled path has no signed negative values. All listed q outputs have JOBDONE/last response convergence and no routine errors. This supports a finite-grid local/metastable source model, not global hull or experimental synthesis.",
      "route_response": "Li replaces Na on the alkali site with the Pt-H network and ordered sites retained. Source cell volume decreases 7.661%, changing the actual Pt-H/H-H distances. All ten lambda values and the independent Eli mu=.1 result improve versus NaPtH3. This is a coupled cation/bond-network construction, not an inferred mobile-carrier density or volume-only mechanism.",
      "next_action": "Use the frozen Li/Na roles to compare at common volume and common sampling, retaining lambda and omega separately, then address H loss or anharmonicity. Stable positive paired response supports the stated source domain; desorption/decomposition or disappearance under common method reverses it.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Complete ordered CIF/literal coarse-fine input/Gamma periodic species-site association is numerically supported; source input geometry and full tensor/forces are retained. Export occupancy is a discrete computational convention; source experimental P/T/occupancy and actual compiled unit constant are unknown. Exact-version input defaults scope the configured neutral scalar spin1/noSOC model, not magnetic ground state.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Li replaces Na on the alkali site with the Pt-H network and ordered sites retained. Source cell volume decreases 7.661%, changing the actual Pt-H/H-H distances. All ten lambda values and the independent Eli mu=.1 result improve versus NaPtH3. This is a coupled cation/bond-network construction, not an inferred mobile-carrier density or volume-only mechanism.",
        "pairing_relevance": "Exact target and mapped control direct source lambda arrays have the same favorable sign at all ten common broadening tokens; omega_ln has explicit K units and separate Eli/McM mu=.1 tables remain independent. Same underlying q mesh is observed. The sensitivity range is not a physical error bound; sigma units, full-BZ convergence, experimental Tc and pure-geometry causality remain unknown. Literal method differences are declared confounds.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Both source SCFs converge, near-zero coarse forces/stress and bounded fine response are measured. Fine Fmax=0 eV/A, P=0.288 GPa, full max stress=0.288 GPa. Gamma optical compression is positive beyond printing bound and sampled path has no signed negative values. All listed q outputs have JOBDONE/last response convergence and no routine errors. This supports a finite-grid local/metastable source model, not global hull or experimental synthesis.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Hydrogen desorption, zero-point/anharmonic response and decomposition compete with superconductivity. The exact source path is nonnegative and Gamma optical compression positive; force is zero by symmetry but fine pressure remains 0.288 GPa. The retained LaPtH3 control has larger lambda but lower separate Eli Tc, showing an omega/coupling tradeoff; AgPtH3 and LiPdH3 have still larger lambda with actual negative source paths, so they are not silently discarded or treated as stable superior cases.",
        "novelty": "Published DFT studies of LiPtH3/NaPtH3 hydrogen storage and metallic/mechanical/phonon properties are acknowledged. A 2026-10-07 exact-phase search found no experimental superconducting LiPtH3 benchmark. Novelty is the bounded matched Li-for-Na pairing-construction hypothesis in the reviewed catalogue, not first synthesis/composition.",
        "decision": "Use the frozen Li/Na roles to compare at common volume and common sampling, retaining lambda and omega separately, then address H loss or anharmonicity. Stable positive paired response supports the stated source domain; desorption/decomposition or disappearance under common method reverses it."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "hydrogen_anharmonicity",
        "metastable_phase",
        "residual_force_stress"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index_zero_based": 107,
          "control_directory": "batch-a/H3AgPt_agm002491760",
          "mapping_scope": "bounded ordered isostructural analogue",
          "all_three_symprec_support": true,
          "composition_edit": {
            "from": "Ag",
            "to": "Li",
            "count": 1,
            "kind": "single_site_substitution"
          },
          "volume_target_over_control": 0.9574690712351873,
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_all10": [
            -53.824737245075525,
            -51.59238909238909,
            -55.39597161821928,
            -58.671252715423606,
            -60.65186290974683,
            -61.55310239817282,
            -62.02669747144141,
            -62.52253412310069,
            -63.22096898231223,
            -64.13133041769665
          ],
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_range": [
            -64.13133041769665,
            -51.59238909238909
          ],
          "separate_source_Eli_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              17.461
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              18.386
            ]
          ],
          "separate_source_McM_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              17.069,
              17.677
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              14.983,
              16.397
            ]
          ],
          "literal_method_same_fields": {
            "ecutwfc": false,
            "smear": true,
            "degauss": true,
            "pseudo_dir": true
          },
          "qmesh_target_control": [
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ]
          ],
          "irreducible_qcount_target_control": [
            [
              4.0
            ],
            [
              4.0
            ]
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index_zero_based": 109,
          "control_directory": "batch-a/H3LaPt_agm002486449",
          "mapping_scope": "bounded ordered isostructural analogue",
          "all_three_symprec_support": true,
          "composition_edit": {
            "from": "La",
            "to": "Li",
            "count": 1,
            "kind": "single_site_substitution"
          },
          "volume_target_over_control": 0.7776178719797753,
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_all10": [
            -12.876748309147018,
            -27.615062761506277,
            -35.578512396694215,
            -40.46936114732726,
            -42.94218454045278,
            -43.62266257326263,
            -43.49694423223834,
            -43.13208284486128,
            -42.71883421499152,
            -42.26688430932463
          ],
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_range": [
            -43.62266257326263,
            -12.876748309147018
          ],
          "separate_source_Eli_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              17.461
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              11.642
            ]
          ],
          "separate_source_McM_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              17.069,
              17.677
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              11.258,
              12.179
            ]
          ],
          "literal_method_same_fields": {
            "ecutwfc": false,
            "smear": true,
            "degauss": true,
            "pseudo_dir": false
          },
          "qmesh_target_control": [
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ]
          ],
          "irreducible_qcount_target_control": [
            [
              4.0
            ],
            [
              4.0
            ]
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index_zero_based": 111,
          "control_directory": "batch-a/H3LiPd_agm001105243",
          "mapping_scope": "bounded ordered isostructural analogue",
          "all_three_symprec_support": true,
          "composition_edit": {
            "from": "Pd",
            "to": "Pt",
            "count": 1,
            "kind": "single_site_substitution"
          },
          "volume_target_over_control": 1.0328092894324439,
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_all10": [
            -67.71226242912418,
            -68.79714042106644,
            -67.3494177766608,
            -66.05877397294218,
            -64.67895030709101,
            -63.412425285274395,
            -62.60034131850073,
            -62.340687067348135,
            -62.548942834768994,
            -63.102301623524816
          ],
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_range": [
            -68.79714042106644,
            -62.340687067348135
          ],
          "separate_source_Eli_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              17.461
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              25.83
            ]
          ],
          "separate_source_McM_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              17.069,
              17.677
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              22.112,
              23.693
            ]
          ],
          "literal_method_same_fields": {
            "ecutwfc": true,
            "smear": true,
            "degauss": true,
            "pseudo_dir": false
          },
          "qmesh_target_control": [
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ]
          ],
          "irreducible_qcount_target_control": [
            [
              4.0
            ],
            [
              4.0
            ]
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index_zero_based": 113,
          "control_directory": "batch-a/H3NaPt_agm002486518",
          "mapping_scope": "bounded ordered isostructural analogue",
          "all_three_symprec_support": true,
          "composition_edit": {
            "from": "Li",
            "to": "Na",
            "count": 1,
            "kind": "single_site_substitution"
          },
          "volume_target_over_control": 0.9233864852333025,
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_all10": [
            313.07596513075964,
            113.48440655149203,
            69.67784066173269,
            49.770391427946635,
            36.306830424477496,
            29.045996592844965,
            26.377616403246474,
            26.351204688517466,
            27.646797153024906,
            29.526207370107567
          ],
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_range": [
            26.351204688517466,
            313.07596513075964
          ],
          "separate_source_Eli_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              17.461
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              13.298
            ]
          ],
          "separate_source_McM_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              17.069,
              17.677
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              11.519,
              11.748
            ]
          ],
          "literal_method_same_fields": {
            "ecutwfc": false,
            "smear": true,
            "degauss": true,
            "pseudo_dir": true
          },
          "qmesh_target_control": [
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ]
          ],
          "irreducible_qcount_target_control": [
            [
              4.0
            ],
            [
              4.0
            ]
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "nat": 5,
        "lambda10": [
          1.3268,
          0.9515,
          0.7795,
          0.6849,
          0.6326,
          0.606,
          0.5917,
          0.5821,
          0.5739,
          0.5659
        ],
        "omega10_K": [
          629.526,
          638.3858,
          652.1379,
          666.4524,
          679.1847,
          687.6085,
          691.8244,
          693.6825,
          694.8525,
          696.326
        ],
        "Eli_mu01": [
          0.1,
          17.461
        ],
        "McM_mu01": [
          0.1,
          17.069,
          17.677
        ],
        "coarse_fine": [
          {
            "record": 2645,
            "version": [
              "Program PWSCF v.6.8 starts on 20Apr2023 at 12:46:28"
            ],
            "converged": true,
            "JOBDONE": true,
            "errors": 0,
            "Fmax_eVA": 0.0,
            "P_GPa": -0.003,
            "maxstress_GPa": 0.003,
            "fulltensor": [
              [
                -0.003,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                -0.003,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                -0.003
              ]
            ],
            "F_Ry": -279.19945297,
            "E_Ry": -279.19946837,
            "pattern_selected_warning_counts": {
              "BFGS": 1,
              "negative_charge": 0,
              "eigen_text": 0,
              "failure_text": 0,
              "SCF_correction_text": 1
            },
            "warning_scope": "pattern-selected contexts; informational SCF correction and ignored cell card are not optimization failure; no whole-file warning-free claim"
          },
          {
            "record": 2646,
            "version": [
              "Program PWSCF v.6.8 starts on 20Apr2023 at 12:43:22"
            ],
            "converged": true,
            "JOBDONE": true,
            "errors": 0,
            "Fmax_eVA": 0.0,
            "P_GPa": 0.288,
            "maxstress_GPa": 0.288,
            "fulltensor": [
              [
                0.288,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                0.288,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                0.288
              ]
            ],
            "F_Ry": -279.2054762,
            "E_Ry": -279.20543129000004,
            "pattern_selected_warning_counts": {
              "BFGS": 1,
              "negative_charge": 0,
              "eigen_text": 0,
              "failure_text": 0,
              "SCF_correction_text": 1
            },
            "warning_scope": "pattern-selected contexts; informational SCF correction and ignored cell card are not optimization failure; no whole-file warning-free claim"
          }
        ],
        "inputs": [
          {
            "record": 2635,
            "ecutwfc": [
              104.0
            ],
            "ecutrho": null,
            "pseudo_dir": [
              "[private custody location omitted]"
            ],
            "spin": null,
            "noncol": null,
            "SOC": null,
            "charge": null,
            "smear": [
              "mp"
            ],
            "degauss": [
              0.014699728870262
            ],
            "ibrav": [
              1.0
            ],
            "nat": [
              5.0
            ],
            "grid": [
              "6 6 6 0 0 0"
            ]
          },
          {
            "record": 2636,
            "ecutwfc": [
              104.0
            ],
            "ecutrho": null,
            "pseudo_dir": [
              "[private custody location omitted]"
            ],
            "spin": null,
            "noncol": null,
            "SOC": null,
            "charge": null,
            "smear": [
              "mp"
            ],
            "degauss": [
              0.014699728870262
            ],
            "ibrav": [
              1.0
            ],
            "nat": [
              5.0
            ],
            "grid": [
              "24 24 24 0 0 0"
            ]
          }
        ],
        "Gamma": {
          "nat": 5,
          "ibrav": 1,
          "q": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species": [
            "H",
            "Li",
            "Pt"
          ],
          "optical": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "minopt": 1.7806831738979924e-06,
          "printingbound": 7.274800903313775e-11,
          "negative_native_modes": [],
          "negativeoutside3": [],
          "min_low3_translation": 0.9999725961710253,
          "sourcepin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/H3LiPt_agm002493455",
            "bytes": 13349,
            "sha256": "b2ca638c7026895b2881a7e7290f0a2396b84336fefb5f3f076e7f8309d3dc38"
          }
        },
        "path": {
          "rows": 140,
          "negatives": 0,
          "minimum": -0.0,
          "unit": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-2-compact-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 84096,
          "sha256": "d8ca53bafc5ee0879de647e050127d8e0d20c0e3da10de9602ab2de44bf77532",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-3-five-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 110335,
          "sha256": "861dd76c8368cca687ca20c8468e464badefb533a318ed41c4f8d62dccb6ed50",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-4-three-phase-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 64369,
          "sha256": "56076a077e591b9bdef8ada45d78f224f417a4af8d2e722e332f639eedfafaf7",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all64-light-Nb-rich-owned-review-cache-v2.json",
          "bytes": 4566542,
          "sha256": "f27e8c84c10c4d8de44022f6bd160e7e8aee8b2d562db5fd6003af68d5e35756",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to this reviewed candidate catalogue and mechanism contrast; MC2023 prediction is prior, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm002290660",
      "formula": "LuTaN2",
      "reduced_formula": "LuTaN2",
      "composition": {
        "Lu": 1,
        "N": 2,
        "Ta": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Lu:1|N:2|Ta:1",
      "elements": [
        "Lu",
        "N",
        "Ta"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm002290660",
      "control_state": "agm002291033",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/N2LuTa_agm002290660",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/N2YTa_agm002291033",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "R-3m four-site layered Lu-Ta-N2 ordered phase; two N sites form a common orbit, Lu and Ta occupy distinct cation sheets",
      "prototype_evidence": "R-3m four-site layered Lu-Ta-N2 ordered phase; two N sites form a common orbit, Lu and Ta occupy distinct cation sheets",
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 15.539,
        "control_K": 12.416,
        "delta_K": 3.1229999999999993,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.37950000000000006,
          0.3985000000000001,
          0.3992999999999999,
          0.3973000000000001,
          0.397,
          0.3985000000000001,
          0.39980000000000004,
          0.4005000000000001,
          0.40060000000000007,
          0.4001999999999999
        ],
        "range": [
          0.37950000000000006,
          0.40060000000000007
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Ta SOC and Lu electronic-shell treatment, cation order versus competing nitrides, and layered shear are case-specific risks. Full fine stress reaches .242 GPa and fine force .01729 eV/A; coarse force 2.19e-5 eV/A/P=.001 GPa and the nonnegative finite path/positive Gamma optical subspace support a bounded near-ambient local phase. No claim of global hull or experimentally realized phase.",
      "ambient_scope": "Coarse/fine SCF both converge; complete source forces/stress, positive Gamma optical compression and no signed negative finite-path value support this model near ambient. All listed q outputs end JOBDONE/response convergence with zero routine errors. This is finite-grid local/metastable evidence, not exhaustive thermodynamic or all-irrep certification.",
      "route_response": "Replace Y by Lu in the frozen YTaN2 analogue. Volume decreases 4.316116%; Lu-N versus Y-N nearest distance decreases .0744086 A while Ta-N increases .00273149 A. Same ecut/smearing/degauss/pseudo-family directory and 4x4x4/13-q grid give all-ten lambda gains 45.878–51.321%, separate Eli mu=.1 12.416→15.539 K. The opposite changes in cation-N and Ta-N distances distinguish local reconstruction from a uniform-volume description.",
      "next_action": "Compare YTaN2/LuTaN2 at a common volume and with a consistent SOC treatment or one matched layer-shear/metal-N mode. Favorable: the 45–51% source advantage survives and the layer branch stays positive; adverse: SOC/order changes remove the advantage or a competing nitride path destabilizes the phase.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Raw CIF, literal coarse/fine crystal input and Gamma header agree by complete ordered species/site periodic association; exact natural-isotope discrete computational occupancy is export convention, experimental occupancy/P/T unknown. Source model configured neutral scalar spin1/noSOC by exact-version defaults plus literal omission; magnetic ground state and binary build not certified.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Replace Y by Lu in the frozen YTaN2 analogue. Volume decreases 4.316116%; Lu-N versus Y-N nearest distance decreases .0744086 A while Ta-N increases .00273149 A. Same ecut/smearing/degauss/pseudo-family directory and 4x4x4/13-q grid give all-ten lambda gains 45.878–51.321%, separate Eli mu=.1 12.416→15.539 K. The opposite changes in cation-N and Ta-N distances distinguish local reconstruction from a uniform-volume description.",
        "pairing_relevance": "Direct exact-source lambda has the favorable sign at all ten matched sigma tokens, independently accompanied by the separate mu=.1 Eli table. Finite-grid broadening sensitivity is preserved; differing PP/cutoff/version are model confounds where shown. Sigma units, physical error bar, fullBZ convergence and experimental Tc remain unknown.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Coarse/fine SCF both converge; complete source forces/stress, positive Gamma optical compression and no signed negative finite-path value support this model near ambient. All listed q outputs end JOBDONE/response convergence with zero routine errors. This is finite-grid local/metastable evidence, not exhaustive thermodynamic or all-irrep certification.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Ta SOC and Lu electronic-shell treatment, cation order versus competing nitrides, and layered shear are case-specific risks. Full fine stress reaches .242 GPa and fine force .01729 eV/A; coarse force 2.19e-5 eV/A/P=.001 GPa and the nonnegative finite path/positive Gamma optical subspace support a bounded near-ambient local phase. No claim of global hull or experimentally realized phase.",
        "novelty": "2026-10-07 LuTaN2/TaLuN2 exact search found no experimental SC benchmark. Related CaM N2 layered nitrides have known superconducting phases, but they are different cations/chemistry and do not make this exact Lu/Ta ordered phase a benchmark. MC2023 source prediction remains prior.",
        "decision": "Compare YTaN2/LuTaN2 at a common volume and with a consistent SOC treatment or one matched layer-shear/metal-N mode. Favorable: the 45–51% source advantage survives and the layer branch stays positive; adverse: SOC/order changes remove the advantage or a competing nitride path destabilizes the phase."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase",
        "residual_force_stress"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [],
      "physical_summary": {
        "nat": 4,
        "lambda10": [
          1.2067,
          1.1988,
          1.2003,
          1.2009,
          1.1997,
          1.1973,
          1.1936,
          1.1891,
          1.1845,
          1.18
        ],
        "omega10_K": [
          162.1414,
          157.1441,
          156.1658,
          156.3511,
          156.9199,
          157.6384,
          158.4122,
          159.1731,
          159.8683,
          160.4685
        ],
        "Eli_mu01": [
          0.1,
          15.539
        ],
        "McM_mu01": [
          0.1,
          14.147,
          15.648
        ],
        "coarse_fine": [
          {
            "record": 4509,
            "version": [
              "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 13May2023 at 13:46:36"
            ],
            "converged": true,
            "JOBDONE": true,
            "errors": 0,
            "Fmax_eVA": 2.18543786774385e-05,
            "P_GPa": 0.001,
            "maxstress_GPa": 0.001,
            "fulltensor": [
              [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                -0.0,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                -0.0,
                0.0,
                0.001
              ]
            ],
            "pattern_selected_warning_counts": {
              "BFGS": 1,
              "negative_charge": 0,
              "eigen_text": 0,
              "failure_text": 0,
              "SCF_correction_text": 1
            }
          },
          {
            "record": 4510,
            "version": [
              "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 13May2023 at 13: 3:20"
            ],
            "converged": true,
            "JOBDONE": true,
            "errors": 0,
            "Fmax_eVA": 0.01729067018891458,
            "P_GPa": -0.061,
            "maxstress_GPa": 0.242,
            "fulltensor": [
              [
                -0.21200000000000002,
                -0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                -0.0,
                -0.21200000000000002,
                -0.0
              ],
              [
                -0.0,
                -0.0,
                0.242
              ]
            ],
            "pattern_selected_warning_counts": {
              "BFGS": 1,
              "negative_charge": 0,
              "eigen_text": 0,
              "failure_text": 0,
              "SCF_correction_text": 1
            }
          }
        ],
        "Gamma": {
          "nat": 4,
          "ibrav": 5,
          "q": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species": [
            "Lu",
            "N",
            "Ta"
          ],
          "optical": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "minopt": 1.0584606787687853e-06,
          "printingbound": 3.5849510897001415e-12,
          "negative_native_modes": [
            1
          ],
          "negativeoutside3": [],
          "min_low3_translation": 0.9996066081219963,
          "sourcepin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/N2LuTa_agm002290660",
            "bytes": 8994,
            "sha256": "e16d0789558755bb9569faddf074897453dbfeea77326a84f7a2dd820a9948e9"
          }
        },
        "path": {
          "rows": 158,
          "negatives": 0,
          "minimum": -0.0,
          "unit": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-1-compact-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 34933,
          "sha256": "c27b3f0105c6f12aa51f2d0801a476adfacdc6cac93b8dd5b60cd485d18cd4f2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-four-tranche-eight-source-states-independent-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 267678,
          "sha256": "857ce54f337154bb41cfa9e21370ab305f2bd35f31ab86c37fcd0ba8de21a391",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to this reviewed candidate catalogue and mechanism contrast; MC2023 prediction is prior, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm002339932",
      "formula": "MgIrH3",
      "reduced_formula": "MgIrH3",
      "composition": {
        "H": 3,
        "Ir": 1,
        "Mg": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "H:3|Ir:1|Mg:1",
      "elements": [
        "H",
        "Ir",
        "Mg"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm002339932",
      "control_state": "agm002153282",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/H3MgIr_agm002339932",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/H3MgRh_agm002153282",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Pm-3m five-site perovskite hydride: Mg 1a, Ir 1b, H on the three face-center sites (origin/basis equivalent to ABH3)",
      "prototype_evidence": "Pm-3m five-site perovskite hydride: Mg 1a, Ir 1b, H on the three face-center sites (origin/basis equivalent to ABH3)",
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 11.862,
        "control_K": 11.198,
        "delta_K": 0.6639999999999997,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.7844,
          0.4872000000000001,
          0.3256,
          0.2952,
          0.30359999999999987,
          0.3173,
          0.3286,
          0.33519999999999994,
          0.3360000000000001,
          0.3318
        ],
        "range": [
          0.2952,
          0.7844
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Hydrogen stoichiometry, anharmonicity and competing complex hydrides are the important physical risks. Hansen et al. observed a minor Pm-3m MgIrHx phase but could not establish x, potentially even zero; their Mg2IrH5 synthesis and proposed Mg2IrH6 superconductivity are different stoichiometries/prototypes. These priors neither establish MgIrH3 superconductivity nor invalidate the exact locally stable model. Neglected Ir SOC and different PP/cutoff between Rh and Ir remain matched-method falsifiers.",
      "ambient_scope": "Both source SCFs converge, near-zero coarse forces/stress and bounded fine response are measured. Fine Fmax=0 eV/A, P=0.108 GPa, full max stress=0.108 GPa. Gamma optical compression is positive beyond printing bound and sampled path has no signed negative values. All listed q outputs have JOBDONE/last response convergence and no routine errors. This supports a finite-grid local/metastable source model, not global hull or experimental synthesis.",
      "route_response": "Ir replaces Rh on the single transition-metal site while the Mg and three H roles remain mapped. The volume rises 3.573%, with the actual H-metal and H-H distances retained below. Lambda improves at all ten sigma values, whereas the separate Eli mu=.1 change is modest, 11.198 to 11.862 K; this distinction avoids ranking solely by coupling.",
      "next_action": "At the same ordered MgIrH3/MgRhH3 geometry roles, separate common-volume chemical substitution from expansion and test H stoichiometry/anharmonic modes. A persistent direct coupling advantage without an unstable H/order branch supports screening; a stable hydrogen-deficient insulating phase or erased coupling advantage opposes it.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Complete ordered CIF/literal coarse-fine input/Gamma periodic species-site association is numerically supported; source input geometry and full tensor/forces are retained. Export occupancy is a discrete computational convention; source experimental P/T/occupancy and actual compiled unit constant are unknown. Exact-version input defaults scope the configured neutral scalar spin1/noSOC model, not magnetic ground state.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Ir replaces Rh on the single transition-metal site while the Mg and three H roles remain mapped. The volume rises 3.573%, with the actual H-metal and H-H distances retained below. Lambda improves at all ten sigma values, whereas the separate Eli mu=.1 change is modest, 11.198 to 11.862 K; this distinction avoids ranking solely by coupling.",
        "pairing_relevance": "Exact target and mapped control direct source lambda arrays have the same favorable sign at all ten common broadening tokens; omega_ln has explicit K units and separate Eli/McM mu=.1 tables remain independent. Same underlying q mesh is observed. The sensitivity range is not a physical error bound; sigma units, full-BZ convergence, experimental Tc and pure-geometry causality remain unknown. Literal method differences are declared confounds.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Both source SCFs converge, near-zero coarse forces/stress and bounded fine response are measured. Fine Fmax=0 eV/A, P=0.108 GPa, full max stress=0.108 GPa. Gamma optical compression is positive beyond printing bound and sampled path has no signed negative values. All listed q outputs have JOBDONE/last response convergence and no routine errors. This supports a finite-grid local/metastable source model, not global hull or experimental synthesis.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Hydrogen stoichiometry, anharmonicity and competing complex hydrides are the important physical risks. Hansen et al. observed a minor Pm-3m MgIrHx phase but could not establish x, potentially even zero; their Mg2IrH5 synthesis and proposed Mg2IrH6 superconductivity are different stoichiometries/prototypes. These priors neither establish MgIrH3 superconductivity nor invalidate the exact locally stable model. Neglected Ir SOC and different PP/cutoff between Rh and Ir remain matched-method falsifiers.",
        "novelty": "The 2026-10-07 bounded MgIrH3/IrMgH3 search found a related experimentally observed Pm-3m MgIrHx phase with unknown hydrogen content, not an exact experimental superconducting MgIrH3 benchmark. The new-to-reviewed-catalogue object is the fully ordered H3 occupancy and matched Ir-for-Rh hypothesis; no first-composition claim.",
        "decision": "At the same ordered MgIrH3/MgRhH3 geometry roles, separate common-volume chemical substitution from expansion and test H stoichiometry/anharmonic modes. A persistent direct coupling advantage without an unstable H/order branch supports screening; a stable hydrogen-deficient insulating phase or erased coupling advantage opposes it."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "hydrogen_anharmonicity",
        "metastable_phase",
        "sampling_method"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index_zero_based": 114,
          "control_directory": "batch-a/H3MgRh_agm002153282",
          "mapping_scope": "bounded ordered isostructural analogue",
          "all_three_symprec_support": true,
          "composition_edit": {
            "from": "Ir",
            "to": "Rh",
            "count": 1,
            "kind": "single_site_substitution"
          },
          "volume_target_over_control": 1.0357258440065038,
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_all10": [
            104.55878432418022,
            60.86196127420364,
            42.012903225806454,
            40.28384279475983,
            43.54561101549051,
            47.021339656194435,
            49.32452716901831,
            50.07469375560203,
            49.31024361608454,
            47.4813966800229
          ],
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_range": [
            40.28384279475983,
            104.55878432418022
          ],
          "separate_source_Eli_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              11.862
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              11.198
            ]
          ],
          "separate_source_McM_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              10.217,
              10.918
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              10.56,
              11.02
            ]
          ],
          "literal_method_same_fields": {
            "ecutwfc": false,
            "smear": true,
            "degauss": true,
            "pseudo_dir": false
          },
          "qmesh_target_control": [
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ]
          ],
          "irreducible_qcount_target_control": [
            [
              4.0
            ],
            [
              4.0
            ]
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "nat": 5,
        "lambda10": [
          1.5346,
          1.2877,
          1.1006,
          1.028,
          1.0008,
          0.9921,
          0.9948,
          1.0046,
          1.0174,
          1.0306
        ],
        "omega10_K": [
          140.424,
          136.265,
          135.747,
          137.8171,
          140.6125,
          143.2232,
          145.7284,
          148.0545,
          150.0245,
          151.5446
        ],
        "Eli_mu01": [
          0.1,
          11.862
        ],
        "McM_mu01": [
          0.1,
          10.217,
          10.918
        ],
        "coarse_fine": [
          {
            "record": 16221,
            "version": [
              "Program PWSCF v.6.8 starts on 12May2023 at 12:24:20"
            ],
            "converged": true,
            "JOBDONE": true,
            "errors": 0,
            "Fmax_eVA": 0.0,
            "P_GPa": -0.001,
            "maxstress_GPa": 0.001,
            "fulltensor": [
              [
                -0.001,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                -0.001,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                -0.001
              ]
            ],
            "F_Ry": -352.40617104,
            "E_Ry": -352.4061112,
            "pattern_selected_warning_counts": {
              "BFGS": 1,
              "negative_charge": 0,
              "eigen_text": 0,
              "failure_text": 0,
              "SCF_correction_text": 1
            },
            "warning_scope": "pattern-selected contexts; informational SCF correction and ignored cell card are not optimization failure; no whole-file warning-free claim"
          },
          {
            "record": 16222,
            "version": [
              "Program PWSCF v.6.8 starts on 12May2023 at 12:23:11"
            ],
            "converged": true,
            "JOBDONE": true,
            "errors": 0,
            "Fmax_eVA": 0.0,
            "P_GPa": 0.10800000000000001,
            "maxstress_GPa": 0.10800000000000001,
            "fulltensor": [
              [
                0.10800000000000001,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                0.10800000000000001,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                0.10800000000000001
              ]
            ],
            "F_Ry": -352.41005291,
            "E_Ry": -352.40996828,
            "pattern_selected_warning_counts": {
              "BFGS": 1,
              "negative_charge": 0,
              "eigen_text": 0,
              "failure_text": 0,
              "SCF_correction_text": 1
            },
            "warning_scope": "pattern-selected contexts; informational SCF correction and ignored cell card are not optimization failure; no whole-file warning-free claim"
          }
        ],
        "inputs": [
          {
            "record": 16211,
            "ecutwfc": [
              96.0
            ],
            "ecutrho": null,
            "pseudo_dir": [
              "/pc2/users/e/e2dm2/software/progs/qe/pp/nc-sr-04_pbesol_stringent_upf/"
            ],
            "spin": null,
            "noncol": null,
            "SOC": null,
            "charge": null,
            "smear": [
              "mp"
            ],
            "degauss": [
              0.014699728870262
            ],
            "ibrav": [
              1.0
            ],
            "nat": [
              5.0
            ],
            "grid": [
              "6 6 6 0 0 0"
            ]
          },
          {
            "record": 16212,
            "ecutwfc": [
              96.0
            ],
            "ecutrho": null,
            "pseudo_dir": [
              "/pc2/users/e/e2dm2/software/progs/qe/pp/nc-sr-04_pbesol_stringent_upf/"
            ],
            "spin": null,
            "noncol": null,
            "SOC": null,
            "charge": null,
            "smear": [
              "mp"
            ],
            "degauss": [
              0.014699728870262
            ],
            "ibrav": [
              1.0
            ],
            "nat": [
              5.0
            ],
            "grid": [
              "24 24 24 0 0 0"
            ]
          }
        ],
        "Gamma": {
          "nat": 5,
          "ibrav": 1,
          "q": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species": [
            "H",
            "Ir",
            "Mg"
          ],
          "optical": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "minopt": 8.68108668585955e-07,
          "printingbound": 7.035422181988358e-11,
          "negative_native_modes": [],
          "negativeoutside3": [],
          "min_low3_translation": 0.999707078778001,
          "sourcepin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/H3MgIr_agm002339932",
            "bytes": 13355,
            "sha256": "28bb8cdea897f34cd764cd4689b68662195f6396b042997592413cd8012dc5a9"
          }
        },
        "path": {
          "rows": 139,
          "negatives": 0,
          "minimum": -0.0,
          "unit": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-2-compact-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 84096,
          "sha256": "d8ca53bafc5ee0879de647e050127d8e0d20c0e3da10de9602ab2de44bf77532",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-3-five-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 110335,
          "sha256": "861dd76c8368cca687ca20c8468e464badefb533a318ed41c4f8d62dccb6ed50",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-4-three-phase-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 64369,
          "sha256": "56076a077e591b9bdef8ada45d78f224f417a4af8d2e722e332f639eedfafaf7",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all64-light-Nb-rich-owned-review-cache-v2.json",
          "bytes": 4566542,
          "sha256": "f27e8c84c10c4d8de44022f6bd160e7e8aee8b2d562db5fd6003af68d5e35756",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to this reviewed candidate catalogue and mechanism contrast; MC2023 prediction is prior, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003203150",
      "formula": "Mn2Mo",
      "reduced_formula": "Mn2Mo",
      "composition": {
        "Mn": 2,
        "Mo": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Mn:2|Mo:1",
      "elements": [
        "Mn",
        "Mo"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003203150",
      "control_state": "agm003203261",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Mn2Mo_agm003203150",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Mn2W_agm003203261",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 227. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "symprec_A": 0.0001,
        "mode": "color_aware",
        "status": "completed",
        "SG_number": 227,
        "hall_number": 525,
        "input_wyckoff_letters": [
          "d",
          "d",
          "d",
          "d",
          "a",
          "a"
        ],
        "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          4,
          4
        ]
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 14.713,
        "control_K": 12.139,
        "delta_K": 2.574,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.09330000000000005,
          0.08689999999999998,
          0.07780000000000009,
          0.06720000000000004,
          0.0625,
          0.0615,
          0.062000000000000055,
          0.06299999999999994,
          0.06359999999999999,
          0.06420000000000003
        ],
        "range": [
          0.0615,
          0.09330000000000005
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "C15 Mn2Mo versus Mn2W has matched138Ry/grids and consistent EPC gain, no sampled negative path. Mn-C15 network2.3337A is evaluated using actual nonmag database preselection and experimentally paramagnetic Mn-Laves counterexamples; competing polymorph/moments remain prospective.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
      "route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
      "next_action": "Spin-polarized fixed-cell comparison plus C14 structural competitor diagnostic; do not infer pureMn moments or demand exhaustive phase proof.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "CIF lattice/sites to both SCFinputs andGamma atomicheader via speciesbijection/wholetranslation; 1e-6A observationaltolerance, not physicaluncertainty",
        "novelty": "Bounded exact formula/prototype primary search; published source calculations not claimed as first discovery. New-to-reviewed exact ordered hypothesis only. Literature-wide novelty unproved.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
        "pairing_relevance": "All ten raw printed lambda values andseparate mu*=.1 sourceEliashberg/McMillan products retained; representative common-sigma response isnotrenamed Tc_uncertainty. Spinfluctuations/anisotropy omitted.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "C15 Mn2Mo versus Mn2W has matched138Ry/grids and consistent EPC gain, no sampled negative path. Mn-C15 network2.3337A is evaluated using actual nonmag database preselection and experimentally paramagnetic Mn-Laves counterexamples; competing polymorph/moments remain prospective.",
        "decision": "Spin-polarized fixed-cell comparison plus C14 structural competitor diagnostic; do not infer pureMn moments or demand exhaustive phase proof."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "magnetic_model",
        "metastable_phase",
        "sampling_method"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr2Mo_agm003197051",
            "batch-a/Mn2Mo_agm003203150"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr2Mo_agm003197051",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Mn2Mo_agm003203150",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -2.2529,
            -2.1659,
            -2.0081999999999995,
            -1.8427999999999998,
            -1.6747999999999998,
            -1.515,
            -1.3721999999999999,
            -1.2510000000000003,
            -1.1526999999999998,
            -1.0757
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -2.2529,
            -1.0757
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              28.839
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              14.713
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -14.126,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 24
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn2Mo_agm003203150",
            "batch-a/Mn2W_agm003203261"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn2Mo_agm003203150",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Mn2W_agm003203261",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.09330000000000005,
            -0.08689999999999998,
            -0.07780000000000009,
            -0.06720000000000004,
            -0.0625,
            -0.0615,
            -0.062000000000000055,
            -0.06299999999999994,
            -0.06359999999999999,
            -0.06420000000000003
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.09330000000000005,
            -0.0615
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              14.713
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              12.139
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -2.574,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 138
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "coarse": {
          "source_record": 8881,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.6.8 starts on  2Aug2022 at  7:49:21"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 5,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000000     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 0.0,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.0,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.0,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                0.0,
                -0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              "atom_index": 1,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": -0.05,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "-0.05",
              "GPa": -0.005
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.05"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    -3.5e-07,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.05,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -3.5e-07,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.05,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -3.5e-07,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.05
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  -0.005,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.005,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.0,
                  -0.005
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": -0.05000000000000001,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.005,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1157.07620161,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1157.07620161"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": 0.00035708,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "0.00035708"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1157.07655869
        },
        "fine": {
          "source_record": 8882,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.6.8 starts on  2Aug2022 at  6:36:16"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 7,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 2,
              "last": {
                "value": "c_bands:  1 eigenvalues not converged"
              }
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000000     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 0.0,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.0,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.0,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                0.0,
                -0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              "atom_index": 1,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": -0.62,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "-0.62",
              "GPa": -0.062
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.62"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    -4.18e-06,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.62,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -4.18e-06,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.62,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -4.18e-06,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.62
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  -0.062,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.062,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.0,
                  -0.062
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": -0.62,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.062,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1157.07585483,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1157.07585483"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": 0.00039948,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "0.00039948"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1157.07625431
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "Gamma_optical_sign": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "Gamma_optical_minimum": 1.1993062083205249e-06,
          "Gamma_printing_bound": 2.1797687273022058e-12,
          "Gamma_native_signed_modes": [
            {
              "number": 1,
              "THz": 0.265704,
              "cm_inverse": 8.862925,
              "line": 167
            },
            {
              "number": 2,
              "THz": 0.265704,
              "cm_inverse": 8.862925,
              "line": 174
            },
            {
              "number": 3,
              "THz": 0.265704,
              "cm_inverse": 8.862925,
              "line": 181
            },
            {
              "number": 4,
              "THz": 3.602818,
              "cm_inverse": 120.17706,
              "line": 188
            },
            {
              "number": 5,
              "THz": 3.602818,
              "cm_inverse": 120.17706,
              "line": 195
            },
            {
              "number": 6,
              "THz": 3.602818,
              "cm_inverse": 120.17706,
              "line": 202
            },
            {
              "number": 7,
              "THz": 3.995035,
              "cm_inverse": 133.260027,
              "line": 209
            },
            {
              "number": 8,
              "THz": 3.995035,
              "cm_inverse": 133.260027,
              "line": 216
            },
            {
              "number": 9,
              "THz": 3.995035,
              "cm_inverse": 133.260027,
              "line": 223
            },
            {
              "number": 10,
              "THz": 5.207345,
              "cm_inverse": 173.698322,
              "line": 230
            },
            {
              "number": 11,
              "THz": 5.207345,
              "cm_inverse": 173.698322,
              "line": 237
            },
            {
              "number": 12,
              "THz": 5.207345,
              "cm_inverse": 173.698322,
              "line": 244
            },
            {
              "number": 13,
              "THz": 6.560237,
              "cm_inverse": 218.825964,
              "line": 251
            },
            {
              "number": 14,
              "THz": 6.560237,
              "cm_inverse": 218.825964,
              "line": 258
            },
            {
              "number": 15,
              "THz": 8.309383,
              "cm_inverse": 277.171195,
              "line": 265
            },
            {
              "number": 16,
              "THz": 8.309383,
              "cm_inverse": 277.171195,
              "line": 272
            },
            {
              "number": 17,
              "THz": 8.309383,
              "cm_inverse": 277.171195,
              "line": 279
            },
            {
              "number": 18,
              "THz": 9.645282,
              "cm_inverse": 321.731966,
              "line": 286
            }
          ],
          "Gamma_ASR_relative": 0.001650651745821416,
          "Gamma_source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/Mn2Mo_agm003203150",
            "bytes": 18568,
            "sha256": "31bfbea873e9d00c4ca3f654e889f384acfe2078998e27f59230de72805c010e"
          }
        },
        "finite_path": {
          "raw_header_lines": [],
          "negative_printed_values": 0,
          "minimum_printed_mode": {
            "value": -0.0,
            "column_index_zero_based": 1
          },
          "frequency_unit_header": null,
          "fullBZ_coverage": null,
          "dynamical_stability": null,
          "state_link_verified": null
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm003203150",
          "dyn0_source_record": 8869,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                3.0,
                3.0,
                3.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                4.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 8876,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 8877,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 8878,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 8879,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 4,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "composition-assessments.json",
          "bytes": 1863044,
          "sha256": "5fc901f5f4a90b41e807722d92f39d81714b70091a189cdb5eba13367624350b",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "numeric-review.json",
          "bytes": 4542684,
          "sha256": "c4fae01d3d67f774429114902a6b39f5b133de48ea81d3d9773ba40ff4419ce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-two-PH-actual-complete-response-products-readback-v1.json",
          "bytes": 77119,
          "sha256": "434c5fe7a590607adbc104dd75d126497457317bc20f37973b5013491e9fdce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Published source predictions already known; exact matched mechanism new to reviewed catalogue only, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003195946",
      "formula": "Mn4MoTa",
      "reduced_formula": "Mn4MoTa",
      "composition": {
        "Mn": 4,
        "Mo": 1,
        "Ta": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Mn:4|Mo:1|Ta:1",
      "elements": [
        "Mn",
        "Mo",
        "Ta"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003195946",
      "control_state": "agm003195948",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Mn4MoTa_agm003195946",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Mn4MoW_agm003195948",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 216. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "symprec_A": 0.0001,
        "mode": "color_aware",
        "status": "completed",
        "SG_number": 216,
        "hall_number": 512,
        "input_wyckoff_letters": [
          "a",
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "c"
        ],
        "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
          0,
          1,
          1,
          1,
          1,
          5
        ]
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 17.3,
        "control_K": 13.698,
        "delta_K": 3.6020000000000003,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.4952,
          0.32319999999999993,
          0.243,
          0.19509999999999994,
          0.16490000000000005,
          0.14250000000000007,
          0.12380000000000002,
          0.10770000000000002,
          0.09419999999999995,
          0.08350000000000002
        ],
        "range": [
          0.08350000000000002,
          0.4952
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Mo/Ta ordered C15-derived network gains relative Mo/W but loses to Nb/Mo and V/Mo. TaMn2 paramagnetic prior supports a plausible nonmag domain, not exact child proof; cutoff contrast144/138Ry is explicit.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
      "route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
      "next_action": "Exact ordered-cell moment seed and common cutoff/mesh Mo/W comparator.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "CIF lattice/sites to both SCFinputs andGamma atomicheader via speciesbijection/wholetranslation; 1e-6A observationaltolerance, not physicaluncertainty",
        "novelty": "Bounded exact formula/prototype primary search; published source calculations not claimed as first discovery. New-to-reviewed exact ordered hypothesis only. Literature-wide novelty unproved.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
        "pairing_relevance": "All ten raw printed lambda values andseparate mu*=.1 sourceEliashberg/McMillan products retained; representative common-sigma response isnotrenamed Tc_uncertainty. Spinfluctuations/anisotropy omitted.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Mo/Ta ordered C15-derived network gains relative Mo/W but loses to Nb/Mo and V/Mo. TaMn2 paramagnetic prior supports a plausible nonmag domain, not exact child proof; cutoff contrast144/138Ry is explicit.",
        "decision": "Exact ordered-cell moment seed and common cutoff/mesh Mo/W comparator."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "magnetic_model",
        "sampling_method"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4MoTa_agm003195946",
            "batch-a/Mn4MoW_agm003195948"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4MoTa_agm003195946",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Mn4MoW_agm003195948",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.4952,
            -0.32319999999999993,
            -0.243,
            -0.19509999999999994,
            -0.16490000000000005,
            -0.14250000000000007,
            -0.12380000000000002,
            -0.10770000000000002,
            -0.09419999999999995,
            -0.08350000000000002
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.4952,
            -0.08350000000000002
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              17.3
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              13.698
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -3.6020000000000003,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 139
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4MoTa_agm003195946",
            "batch-a/Mn4NbMo_agm001179868"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4MoTa_agm003195946",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Mn4NbMo_agm001179868",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.12980000000000014,
            0.13030000000000008,
            0.10460000000000003,
            0.0824999999999999,
            0.06929999999999992,
            0.061899999999999844,
            0.057699999999999974,
            0.05510000000000004,
            0.05369999999999997,
            0.05290000000000006
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.05290000000000006,
            0.13030000000000008
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              17.3
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              19.063
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 1.7629999999999981,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 140
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4MoTa_agm003195946",
            "batch-a/Mn4RuTa_agm003199927"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4MoTa_agm003195946",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Mn4RuTa_agm003199927",
          "three_symprec_supported": false,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.5540999999999999,
            -0.3827999999999999,
            -0.3239000000000001,
            -0.27769999999999995,
            -0.2411000000000001,
            -0.21110000000000007,
            -0.18480000000000008,
            -0.16189999999999993,
            -0.14249999999999996,
            -0.1269
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.5540999999999999,
            -0.1269
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              17.3
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              11.901
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -5.399000000000001,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 141
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4MoTa_agm003195946",
            "batch-a/Mn4TaRe_agm003204489"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4MoTa_agm003195946",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Mn4TaRe_agm003204489",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.5551999999999999,
            -0.3838999999999999,
            -0.3015,
            -0.2512,
            -0.2197,
            -0.19610000000000005,
            -0.17610000000000003,
            -0.15889999999999993,
            -0.14459999999999995,
            -0.13329999999999997
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.5551999999999999,
            -0.13329999999999997
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              17.3
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              11.832
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -5.468,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 142
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4MoTa_agm003195946",
            "batch-a/Mn4TaW_agm003195951"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4MoTa_agm003195946",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Mn4TaW_agm003195951",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.1520999999999999,
            -0.12039999999999995,
            -0.09079999999999999,
            -0.07399999999999995,
            -0.0676,
            -0.06540000000000001,
            -0.06440000000000001,
            -0.06379999999999997,
            -0.06309999999999993,
            -0.06240000000000001
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.1520999999999999,
            -0.06240000000000001
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              17.3
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              14.96
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -2.34,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 143
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4MoTa_agm003195946",
            "batch-a/Mn4TcTa_agm003199931"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4MoTa_agm003195946",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Mn4TcTa_agm003199931",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.4777,
            -0.29679999999999995,
            -0.23320000000000007,
            -0.1975,
            -0.17380000000000007,
            -0.15390000000000004,
            -0.13570000000000004,
            -0.11949999999999994,
            -0.10609999999999997,
            -0.09550000000000003
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.4777,
            -0.09550000000000003
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              17.3
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              13.109
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -4.191000000000001,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 144
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4MoTa_agm003195946",
            "batch-a/VMn4Mo_agm001186980"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4MoTa_agm003195946",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/VMn4Mo_agm001186980",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.14670000000000005,
            0.12760000000000016,
            0.10640000000000005,
            0.08009999999999995,
            0.06159999999999988,
            0.0512999999999999,
            0.0464,
            0.04420000000000002,
            0.04349999999999998,
            0.043300000000000005
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.043300000000000005,
            0.14670000000000005
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              17.3
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              19.425
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 2.125,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 145
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "coarse": {
          "source_record": 4391,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.6.8 starts on  4Aug2022 at 23:38:55"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 5,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000002     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 4.4e-07,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 4.4e-07,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 7.62102355330306e-07,
            "max_component_eV_A": 1.1312854844791695e-05,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 1.9594439369830943e-05,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                -4.4e-07,
                4.4e-07,
                -4.4e-07
              ],
              "atom_index": 2,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": 0.01,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "0.01",
              "GPa": 0.001
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=        0.01"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    9e-08,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.01,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    9e-08,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.01,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    9e-08,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.01
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  0.001,
                  -0.0,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  0.001,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.001
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": 0.01,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.001,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1664.82916588,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1664.82916588"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": -0.00047476,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-0.00047476"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1664.8286911199998
        },
        "fine": {
          "source_record": 4392,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.6.8 starts on  4Aug2022 at 22:21:30"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 6,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "c_bands:  2 eigenvalues not converged"
              }
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000566     Total SCF correction =     0.000002"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 0.00016325,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.00016325,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.0002827572943356192,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.004197326257755101,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.007269982334374775,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                -0.00016325,
                0.00016325,
                -0.00016325
              ],
              "atom_index": 2,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": 0.12,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "0.12",
              "GPa": 0.012
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=        0.12"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    8e-07,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.12,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    8e-07,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.12,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    8e-07,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.12
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  0.012,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.012,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.012
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": 0.12,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.012,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1664.8283057,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1664.82830570"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": -0.00047106,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-0.00047106"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1664.82783464
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "Gamma_optical_sign": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "Gamma_optical_minimum": 1.3645296614411823e-06,
          "Gamma_printing_bound": 2.0658009252338018e-12,
          "Gamma_native_signed_modes": [
            {
              "number": 1,
              "THz": 0.506609,
              "cm_inverse": 16.898654,
              "line": 168
            },
            {
              "number": 2,
              "THz": 0.506609,
              "cm_inverse": 16.898654,
              "line": 175
            },
            {
              "number": 3,
              "THz": 0.506609,
              "cm_inverse": 16.898654,
              "line": 182
            },
            {
              "number": 4,
              "THz": 3.843351,
              "cm_inverse": 128.20038,
              "line": 189
            },
            {
              "number": 5,
              "THz": 3.843351,
              "cm_inverse": 128.20038,
              "line": 196
            },
            {
              "number": 6,
              "THz": 3.843351,
              "cm_inverse": 128.20038,
              "line": 203
            },
            {
              "number": 7,
              "THz": 4.569446,
              "cm_inverse": 152.420322,
              "line": 210
            },
            {
              "number": 8,
              "THz": 4.569446,
              "cm_inverse": 152.420322,
              "line": 217
            },
            {
              "number": 9,
              "THz": 4.569446,
              "cm_inverse": 152.420322,
              "line": 224
            },
            {
              "number": 10,
              "THz": 5.553429,
              "cm_inverse": 185.24245,
              "line": 231
            },
            {
              "number": 11,
              "THz": 5.553429,
              "cm_inverse": 185.24245,
              "line": 238
            },
            {
              "number": 12,
              "THz": 5.553429,
              "cm_inverse": 185.24245,
              "line": 245
            },
            {
              "number": 13,
              "THz": 7.047461,
              "cm_inverse": 235.07798,
              "line": 252
            },
            {
              "number": 14,
              "THz": 7.047461,
              "cm_inverse": 235.07798,
              "line": 259
            },
            {
              "number": 15,
              "THz": 8.206865,
              "cm_inverse": 273.751554,
              "line": 266
            },
            {
              "number": 16,
              "THz": 8.206865,
              "cm_inverse": 273.751554,
              "line": 273
            },
            {
              "number": 17,
              "THz": 8.206865,
              "cm_inverse": 273.751554,
              "line": 280
            },
            {
              "number": 18,
              "THz": 10.058947,
              "cm_inverse": 335.530341,
              "line": 287
            }
          ],
          "Gamma_ASR_relative": 0.004526933157285642,
          "Gamma_source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/Mn4MoTa_agm003195946",
            "bytes": 18614,
            "sha256": "50ac2718cd7b0adc559734209a2c7182875d7ddd909048ed7cc76588afc8adb8"
          }
        },
        "finite_path": {
          "raw_header_lines": [],
          "negative_printed_values": 0,
          "minimum_printed_mode": {
            "value": -0.0,
            "column_index_zero_based": 1
          },
          "frequency_unit_header": null,
          "fullBZ_coverage": null,
          "dynamical_stability": null,
          "state_link_verified": null
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm003195946",
          "dyn0_source_record": 4379,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                3.0,
                3.0,
                3.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                4.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 4386,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 4387,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 4388,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 4389,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 4,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "composition-assessments.json",
          "bytes": 1863044,
          "sha256": "5fc901f5f4a90b41e807722d92f39d81714b70091a189cdb5eba13367624350b",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "numeric-review.json",
          "bytes": 4542684,
          "sha256": "c4fae01d3d67f774429114902a6b39f5b133de48ea81d3d9773ba40ff4419ce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-two-PH-actual-complete-response-products-readback-v1.json",
          "bytes": 77119,
          "sha256": "434c5fe7a590607adbc104dd75d126497457317bc20f37973b5013491e9fdce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Published source predictions already known; exact matched mechanism new to reviewed catalogue only, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001179868",
      "formula": "Mn4NbMo",
      "reduced_formula": "Mn4NbMo",
      "composition": {
        "Mn": 4,
        "Mo": 1,
        "Nb": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Mn:4|Mo:1|Nb:1",
      "elements": [
        "Mn",
        "Mo",
        "Nb"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001179868",
      "control_state": "agm003195946",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Mn4NbMo_agm001179868",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Mn4MoTa_agm003195946",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 216. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "symprec_A": 0.0001,
        "mode": "color_aware",
        "status": "completed",
        "SG_number": 216,
        "hall_number": 512,
        "input_wyckoff_letters": [
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "c",
          "b"
        ],
        "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          4,
          5
        ]
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 19.063,
        "control_K": 17.3,
        "delta_K": 1.7629999999999981,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.12980000000000014,
          0.13030000000000008,
          0.10460000000000003,
          0.0824999999999999,
          0.06929999999999992,
          0.061899999999999844,
          0.057699999999999974,
          0.05510000000000004,
          0.05369999999999997,
          0.05290000000000006
        ],
        "range": [
          0.05290000000000006,
          0.13030000000000008
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Nb/Mo ordered large-site sublattice has positive Ta->Nb gain. Actual NbMn2 C14 FM/AF structural competition is retained alongside experimental paramagnetic Laves prior; 50%Mo substitution means no direct parent property transfer.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
      "route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
      "next_action": "One C15-cell FM/AF pair and mapped C14 competitor response; sign reversal of the small Ta->Nb gain is adverse.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "CIF lattice/sites to both SCFinputs andGamma atomicheader via speciesbijection/wholetranslation; 1e-6A observationaltolerance, not physicaluncertainty",
        "novelty": "Bounded exact formula/prototype primary search; published source calculations not claimed as first discovery. New-to-reviewed exact ordered hypothesis only. Literature-wide novelty unproved.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
        "pairing_relevance": "All ten raw printed lambda values andseparate mu*=.1 sourceEliashberg/McMillan products retained; representative common-sigma response isnotrenamed Tc_uncertainty. Spinfluctuations/anisotropy omitted.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Nb/Mo ordered large-site sublattice has positive Ta->Nb gain. Actual NbMn2 C14 FM/AF structural competition is retained alongside experimental paramagnetic Laves prior; 50%Mo substitution means no direct parent property transfer.",
        "decision": "One C15-cell FM/AF pair and mapped C14 competitor response; sign reversal of the small Ta->Nb gain is adverse."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "magnetic_model",
        "metastable_phase"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4MoTa_agm003195946",
            "batch-a/Mn4NbMo_agm001179868"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4MoTa_agm003195946",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Mn4NbMo_agm001179868",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.12980000000000014,
            0.13030000000000008,
            0.10460000000000003,
            0.0824999999999999,
            0.06929999999999992,
            0.061899999999999844,
            0.057699999999999974,
            0.05510000000000004,
            0.05369999999999997,
            0.05290000000000006
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.05290000000000006,
            0.13030000000000008
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              17.3
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              19.063
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 1.7629999999999981,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 140
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4MoW_agm003195948",
            "batch-a/Mn4NbMo_agm001179868"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4MoW_agm003195948",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Mn4NbMo_agm001179868",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.6250000000000001,
            0.4535,
            0.3476,
            0.27759999999999985,
            0.23419999999999996,
            0.20439999999999992,
            0.1815,
            0.16280000000000006,
            0.14789999999999992,
            0.13640000000000008
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.13640000000000008,
            0.6250000000000001
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              13.698
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              19.063
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 5.364999999999998,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 146
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4NbMo_agm001179868",
            "batch-a/Mn4NbRe_agm001179875"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4NbMo_agm001179868",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Mn4NbRe_agm001179875",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.6381000000000001,
            -0.48450000000000004,
            -0.3843000000000001,
            -0.3135999999999999,
            -0.2682,
            -0.23649999999999993,
            -0.21189999999999998,
            -0.19210000000000005,
            -0.1765,
            -0.16460000000000008
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.6381000000000001,
            -0.16460000000000008
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              19.063
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              12.782
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -6.280999999999999,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 150
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4NbMo_agm001179868",
            "batch-a/Mn4NbTc_agm001179882"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4NbMo_agm001179868",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Mn4NbTc_agm001179882",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.5357000000000001,
            -0.382,
            -0.3078000000000001,
            -0.2550999999999999,
            -0.21849999999999992,
            -0.19089999999999985,
            -0.1684,
            -0.14980000000000004,
            -0.1352,
            -0.12409999999999999
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.5357000000000001,
            -0.12409999999999999
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              19.063
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              14.574
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -4.488999999999999,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 151
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4NbMo_agm001179868",
            "batch-a/VMn4Mo_agm001186980"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4NbMo_agm001179868",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/VMn4Mo_agm001186980",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.016899999999999915,
            -0.0026999999999999247,
            0.0018000000000000238,
            -0.0023999999999999577,
            -0.00770000000000004,
            -0.010599999999999943,
            -0.011299999999999977,
            -0.01090000000000002,
            -0.010199999999999987,
            -0.009600000000000053
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.011299999999999977,
            0.016899999999999915
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "mixed_or_unknown",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              19.063
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              19.425
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 0.3620000000000019,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": null,
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 152
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "coarse": {
          "source_record": 2901,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on  1Oct2022 at  0: 3:36"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 5,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000007     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 1.98e-06,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 1.98e-06,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 3.429460598986377e-06,
            "max_component_eV_A": 5.0907846801562626e-05,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 8.817497716423924e-05,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                1.98e-06,
                1.98e-06,
                -1.98e-06
              ],
              "atom_index": 1,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "-0.00",
              "GPa": -0.0
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.00"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    -3e-08,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -3e-08,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -3e-08,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  -0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  -0.0
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": 0.0,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.0,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1141.04354196,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1141.04354196"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": -0.00087575,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-0.00087575"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1141.04266621
        },
        "fine": {
          "source_record": 2902,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 30Sep2022 at 23:35:39"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 9,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 4,
              "last": {
                "value": "c_bands:  1 eigenvalues not converged"
              }
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000522     Total SCF correction =     0.000001"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 0.00015079,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.00015079,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.000261175941273311,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.0038769667773775906,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.006715103437674563,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                -0.00015079,
                -0.00015079,
                0.00015079
              ],
              "atom_index": 1,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": 0.04,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "0.04",
              "GPa": 0.004
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=        0.04"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    2.9e-07,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.04,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    2.9e-07,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.04,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    2.9e-07,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.04
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  0.004,
                  -0.0,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  0.004,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  -0.0,
                  0.004
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": 0.04,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.004,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1141.04261417,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1141.04261417"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": -0.00096746,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-0.00096746"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1141.04164671
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "Gamma_optical_sign": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "Gamma_optical_minimum": 1.2631442069471407e-06,
          "Gamma_printing_bound": 2.1876898937272243e-12,
          "Gamma_native_signed_modes": [
            {
              "number": 1,
              "THz": -0.330859,
              "cm_inverse": -11.036282,
              "line": 168
            },
            {
              "number": 2,
              "THz": -0.330859,
              "cm_inverse": -11.036282,
              "line": 175
            },
            {
              "number": 3,
              "THz": -0.330859,
              "cm_inverse": -11.036282,
              "line": 182
            },
            {
              "number": 4,
              "THz": 3.698107,
              "cm_inverse": 123.355571,
              "line": 189
            },
            {
              "number": 5,
              "THz": 3.698107,
              "cm_inverse": 123.355571,
              "line": 196
            },
            {
              "number": 6,
              "THz": 3.698107,
              "cm_inverse": 123.355571,
              "line": 203
            },
            {
              "number": 7,
              "THz": 5.209808,
              "cm_inverse": 173.780482,
              "line": 210
            },
            {
              "number": 8,
              "THz": 5.209808,
              "cm_inverse": 173.780482,
              "line": 217
            },
            {
              "number": 9,
              "THz": 5.209808,
              "cm_inverse": 173.780482,
              "line": 224
            },
            {
              "number": 10,
              "THz": 5.246932,
              "cm_inverse": 175.018815,
              "line": 231
            },
            {
              "number": 11,
              "THz": 5.246932,
              "cm_inverse": 175.018815,
              "line": 238
            },
            {
              "number": 12,
              "THz": 5.246932,
              "cm_inverse": 175.018815,
              "line": 245
            },
            {
              "number": 13,
              "THz": 6.803267,
              "cm_inverse": 226.932574,
              "line": 252
            },
            {
              "number": 14,
              "THz": 6.803267,
              "cm_inverse": 226.932574,
              "line": 259
            },
            {
              "number": 15,
              "THz": 8.297082,
              "cm_inverse": 276.760867,
              "line": 266
            },
            {
              "number": 16,
              "THz": 8.297082,
              "cm_inverse": 276.760867,
              "line": 273
            },
            {
              "number": 17,
              "THz": 8.297082,
              "cm_inverse": 276.760867,
              "line": 280
            },
            {
              "number": 18,
              "THz": 9.80874,
              "cm_inverse": 327.184353,
              "line": 287
            }
          ],
          "Gamma_ASR_relative": 0.002837639253817585,
          "Gamma_source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/Mn4NbMo_agm001179868",
            "bytes": 18614,
            "sha256": "c0997b18b50dde94cafff842cdc0b0e3308ce63d5c45cbcf251272efb7c11b2b"
          }
        },
        "finite_path": {
          "raw_header_lines": [],
          "negative_printed_values": 0,
          "minimum_printed_mode": {
            "value": 0.0,
            "column_index_zero_based": 1
          },
          "frequency_unit_header": null,
          "fullBZ_coverage": null,
          "dynamical_stability": null,
          "state_link_verified": null
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm001179868",
          "dyn0_source_record": 2889,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                3.0,
                3.0,
                3.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                4.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 2896,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 2897,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 2898,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 2899,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 4,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "composition-assessments.json",
          "bytes": 1863044,
          "sha256": "5fc901f5f4a90b41e807722d92f39d81714b70091a189cdb5eba13367624350b",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "numeric-review.json",
          "bytes": 4542684,
          "sha256": "c4fae01d3d67f774429114902a6b39f5b133de48ea81d3d9773ba40ff4419ce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-two-PH-actual-complete-response-products-readback-v1.json",
          "bytes": 77119,
          "sha256": "434c5fe7a590607adbc104dd75d126497457317bc20f37973b5013491e9fdce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Published source predictions already known; exact matched mechanism new to reviewed catalogue only, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001179875",
      "formula": "Mn4NbRe",
      "reduced_formula": "Mn4NbRe",
      "composition": {
        "Mn": 4,
        "Nb": 1,
        "Re": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Mn:4|Nb:1|Re:1",
      "elements": [
        "Mn",
        "Nb",
        "Re"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001179875",
      "control_state": "agm003204489",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Mn4NbRe_agm001179875",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Mn4TaRe_agm003204489",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 216. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "symprec_A": 0.0001,
        "mode": "color_aware",
        "status": "completed",
        "SG_number": 216,
        "hall_number": 512,
        "input_wyckoff_letters": [
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "c",
          "b"
        ],
        "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          4,
          5
        ]
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 12.782,
        "control_K": 11.832,
        "delta_K": 0.9499999999999993,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.04689999999999994,
          0.02969999999999995,
          0.02179999999999993,
          0.020100000000000007,
          0.02079999999999993,
          0.021499999999999964,
          0.02190000000000003,
          0.02189999999999992,
          0.02179999999999993,
          0.021599999999999953
        ],
        "range": [
          0.020100000000000007,
          0.04689999999999994
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Actual saved q2 all12 representations converge with18 positive nonzero-q frequencies and ten×18 mode EPC. This resolves the specific text-gap concern; C15-derived Mn magnetic competition, scalar/SOC and small .950K paired response remain research risks. Native exit and fullBZ unknown.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
      "route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
      "next_action": "Now resolve exact ordered NM/FM/commensurateAF branch and matched Ta/Re control sensitivity. A lower magnetic or unstable branch or reversal of the small gain would demote this bounded source-model hypothesis.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "CIF lattice/sites to both SCFinputs andGamma atomicheader via speciesbijection/wholetranslation; 1e-6A observationaltolerance, not physicaluncertainty",
        "novelty": "Bounded exact formula/prototype primary search; published source calculations not claimed as first discovery. New-to-reviewed exact ordered hypothesis only. Literature-wide novelty unproved.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
        "pairing_relevance": "All ten raw printed lambda values andseparate mu*=.1 sourceEliashberg/McMillan products retained; representative common-sigma response isnotrenamed Tc_uncertainty. Spinfluctuations/anisotropy omitted.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Actual saved q2 all12 representations converge with18 positive nonzero-q frequencies and ten×18 mode EPC. This resolves the specific text-gap concern; C15-derived Mn magnetic competition, scalar/SOC and small .950K paired response remain research risks. Native exit and fullBZ unknown.",
        "decision": "Now resolve exact ordered NM/FM/commensurateAF branch and matched Ta/Re control sensitivity. A lower magnetic or unstable branch or reversal of the small gain would demote this bounded source-model hypothesis."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "magnetic_model",
        "metastable_phase"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4NbRe_agm001173527",
            "batch-a/Mn4NbRe_agm001179875"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4NbRe_agm001173527",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Mn4NbRe_agm001179875",
          "three_symprec_supported": false,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -2.4518000000000004,
            -2.2086,
            -1.9200000000000002,
            -1.6761,
            -1.4761,
            -1.3099999999999998,
            -1.1723,
            -1.0598,
            -0.9699000000000001,
            -0.9001000000000001
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -2.4518000000000004,
            -0.9001000000000001
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              27.745
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              12.782
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -14.963000000000001,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 72
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4NbMo_agm001179868",
            "batch-a/Mn4NbRe_agm001179875"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4NbMo_agm001179868",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Mn4NbRe_agm001179875",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.6381000000000001,
            -0.48450000000000004,
            -0.3843000000000001,
            -0.3135999999999999,
            -0.2682,
            -0.23649999999999993,
            -0.21189999999999998,
            -0.19210000000000005,
            -0.1765,
            -0.16460000000000008
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.6381000000000001,
            -0.16460000000000008
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              19.063
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              12.782
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -6.280999999999999,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 150
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4NbRe_agm001179875",
            "batch-a/Mn4NbTc_agm001179882"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4NbRe_agm001179875",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Mn4NbTc_agm001179882",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.10240000000000005,
            0.10250000000000004,
            0.07650000000000001,
            0.058499999999999996,
            0.04970000000000008,
            0.045600000000000085,
            0.04349999999999998,
            0.042300000000000004,
            0.0413,
            0.04050000000000009
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.04050000000000009,
            0.10250000000000004
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              12.782
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              14.574
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 1.7919999999999998,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 153
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4NbRe_agm001179875",
            "batch-a/Mn4TaRe_agm003204489"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4NbRe_agm001179875",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Mn4TaRe_agm003204489",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.04689999999999994,
            -0.02969999999999995,
            -0.02179999999999993,
            -0.020100000000000007,
            -0.02079999999999993,
            -0.021499999999999964,
            -0.02190000000000003,
            -0.02189999999999992,
            -0.02179999999999993,
            -0.021599999999999953
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.04689999999999994,
            -0.020100000000000007
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              12.782
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              11.832
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -0.9499999999999993,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 154
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4NbRe_agm001179875",
            "batch-a/TiMn4Re_agm001186283"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4NbRe_agm001179875",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/TiMn4Re_agm001186283",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.3857999999999999,
            0.2096,
            0.1382,
            0.10980000000000001,
            0.09600000000000009,
            0.08520000000000005,
            0.07499999999999996,
            0.0655,
            0.05730000000000002,
            0.05070000000000008
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.05070000000000008,
            0.3857999999999999
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              12.782
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              15.197
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 2.414999999999999,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 155
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-01-ten-specific-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 381754,
          "sha256": "5d05478212c4d22080ab1b7bf22d92b784de6c0f8a99590d0758f9cdbfdafb32",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-remaining-transition-owned-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 5381838,
          "sha256": "62f4910578c7b65392d26619cf81b31afd6142f38aa49834a70bb147e7ab222d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "composition-assessments.json",
          "bytes": 1863044,
          "sha256": "5fc901f5f4a90b41e807722d92f39d81714b70091a189cdb5eba13367624350b",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "numeric-review.json",
          "bytes": 4542684,
          "sha256": "c4fae01d3d67f774429114902a6b39f5b133de48ea81d3d9773ba40ff4419ce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-two-PH-actual-complete-response-products-readback-v1.json",
          "bytes": 77119,
          "sha256": "434c5fe7a590607adbc104dd75d126497457317bc20f37973b5013491e9fdce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "receipt.json",
          "bytes": 14112,
          "sha256": "1f156c1df5e254b2b234b38948e599c99f87983de7f6fbc24663e88726dfe2fb",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Previously published source model; new to reviewed exact-state mechanism catalogue, not first composition or SC discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001179882",
      "formula": "Mn4NbTc",
      "reduced_formula": "Mn4NbTc",
      "composition": {
        "Mn": 4,
        "Nb": 1,
        "Tc": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Mn:4|Nb:1|Tc:1",
      "elements": [
        "Mn",
        "Nb",
        "Tc"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001179882",
      "control_state": "agm001179875",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Mn4NbTc_agm001179882",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Mn4NbRe_agm001179875",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 216. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "symprec_A": 0.0001,
        "mode": "color_aware",
        "status": "completed",
        "SG_number": 216,
        "hall_number": 512,
        "input_wyckoff_letters": [
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "c",
          "b"
        ],
        "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          4,
          5
        ]
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 14.574,
        "control_K": 12.782,
        "delta_K": 1.7919999999999998,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.10240000000000005,
          0.10250000000000004,
          0.07650000000000001,
          0.058499999999999996,
          0.04970000000000008,
          0.045600000000000085,
          0.04349999999999998,
          0.042300000000000004,
          0.0413,
          0.04050000000000009
        ],
        "range": [
          0.04050000000000009,
          0.10250000000000004
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Tc-for-Re onNb-bearing network yields all-sigma gain with same138Ry/grids. The representative lower-response Re control has a q2 tail gap; candidate itself4q reports complete, and other frozen controls are retained rather than declaring full control convergence.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
      "route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
      "next_action": "Resolve comparator q2 tail and exact-cell magnetic seed; if comparator corrected EPC flips direction, demote the response hypothesis.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "CIF lattice/sites to both SCFinputs andGamma atomicheader via speciesbijection/wholetranslation; 1e-6A observationaltolerance, not physicaluncertainty",
        "novelty": "Bounded exact formula/prototype primary search; published source calculations not claimed as first discovery. New-to-reviewed exact ordered hypothesis only. Literature-wide novelty unproved.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
        "pairing_relevance": "All ten raw printed lambda values andseparate mu*=.1 sourceEliashberg/McMillan products retained; representative common-sigma response isnotrenamed Tc_uncertainty. Spinfluctuations/anisotropy omitted.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Tc-for-Re onNb-bearing network yields all-sigma gain with same138Ry/grids. The representative lower-response Re control has a q2 tail gap; candidate itself4q reports complete, and other frozen controls are retained rather than declaring full control convergence.",
        "decision": "Resolve comparator q2 tail and exact-cell magnetic seed; if comparator corrected EPC flips direction, demote the response hypothesis."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "magnetic_model",
        "sampling_method",
        "technetium"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4NbMo_agm001179868",
            "batch-a/Mn4NbTc_agm001179882"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4NbMo_agm001179868",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Mn4NbTc_agm001179882",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.5357000000000001,
            -0.382,
            -0.3078000000000001,
            -0.2550999999999999,
            -0.21849999999999992,
            -0.19089999999999985,
            -0.1684,
            -0.14980000000000004,
            -0.1352,
            -0.12409999999999999
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.5357000000000001,
            -0.12409999999999999
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              19.063
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              14.574
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -4.488999999999999,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 151
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4NbRe_agm001179875",
            "batch-a/Mn4NbTc_agm001179882"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4NbRe_agm001179875",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Mn4NbTc_agm001179882",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.10240000000000005,
            0.10250000000000004,
            0.07650000000000001,
            0.058499999999999996,
            0.04970000000000008,
            0.045600000000000085,
            0.04349999999999998,
            0.042300000000000004,
            0.0413,
            0.04050000000000009
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.04050000000000009,
            0.10250000000000004
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              12.782
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              14.574
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 1.7919999999999998,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 153
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4NbTc_agm001179882",
            "batch-a/Mn4TcTa_agm003199931"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4NbTc_agm001179882",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Mn4TcTa_agm003199931",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.07180000000000009,
            -0.04510000000000003,
            -0.030000000000000027,
            -0.024900000000000033,
            -0.024600000000000066,
            -0.024900000000000033,
            -0.025000000000000022,
            -0.024799999999999933,
            -0.024599999999999955,
            -0.0243000000000001
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.07180000000000009,
            -0.0243000000000001
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              14.574
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              13.109
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -1.4649999999999999,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 156
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4NbTc_agm001179882",
            "batch-a/TiMn4Tc_agm001186290"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4NbTc_agm001179882",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/TiMn4Tc_agm001186290",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.4537,
            0.24549999999999994,
            0.17510000000000003,
            0.14669999999999994,
            0.13069999999999993,
            0.11769999999999992,
            0.1058,
            0.09520000000000006,
            0.08630000000000004,
            0.07909999999999995
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.07909999999999995,
            0.4537
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              14.574
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              17.71
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 3.136000000000001,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 157
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "coarse": {
          "source_record": 9399,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on  1Oct2022 at  0:30:48"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 6,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 2,
              "last": {
                "value": "SCF correction compared to forces is large: reduce conv_thr to get better values"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 8e-08,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 8e-08,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 1.385640646055102e-07,
            "max_component_eV_A": 2.0568826990530355e-06,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 3.5626253399692625e-06,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                -8e-08,
                -8e-08,
                8e-08
              ],
              "atom_index": 1,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": -0.04,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "-0.04",
              "GPa": -0.004
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.04"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    -2.5e-07,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.04,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -2.5e-07,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.04,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -2.5e-07,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.04
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  -0.004,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.004,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.0,
                  -0.004
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": -0.04,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.004,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1170.13694497,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1170.13694497"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": 0.00069795,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "0.00069795"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1170.13764292
        },
        "fine": {
          "source_record": 9400,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on  1Oct2022 at  0: 4:14"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 8,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 3,
              "last": {
                "value": "c_bands:  1 eigenvalues not converged"
              }
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000668     Total SCF correction =     0.000001"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 0.00019292,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.00019292,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.0003341472417961878,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.0049601726287663945,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.008591271007335876,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                0.00019292,
                0.00019292,
                -0.00019292
              ],
              "atom_index": 1,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": -0.28,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "-0.28",
              "GPa": -0.028000000000000004
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.28"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    -1.88e-06,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.28,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    -1.88e-06,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.28,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -1.88e-06,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.28
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  -0.028000000000000004,
                  -0.0,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  -0.028000000000000004,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  -0.0,
                  -0.028000000000000004
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": -0.28,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.028000000000000004,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1170.136321,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1170.13632100"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": 0.0001942,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "0.00019420"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1170.1365151999998
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "Gamma_optical_sign": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "Gamma_optical_minimum": 9.307767524088083e-07,
          "Gamma_printing_bound": 2.182590511116476e-12,
          "Gamma_native_signed_modes": [
            {
              "number": 1,
              "THz": 0.01325,
              "cm_inverse": 0.441966,
              "line": 168
            },
            {
              "number": 2,
              "THz": 0.01325,
              "cm_inverse": 0.441966,
              "line": 175
            },
            {
              "number": 3,
              "THz": 0.01325,
              "cm_inverse": 0.441966,
              "line": 182
            },
            {
              "number": 4,
              "THz": 3.174121,
              "cm_inverse": 105.877264,
              "line": 189
            },
            {
              "number": 5,
              "THz": 3.174121,
              "cm_inverse": 105.877264,
              "line": 196
            },
            {
              "number": 6,
              "THz": 3.174121,
              "cm_inverse": 105.877264,
              "line": 203
            },
            {
              "number": 7,
              "THz": 4.709925,
              "cm_inverse": 157.106186,
              "line": 210
            },
            {
              "number": 8,
              "THz": 4.709925,
              "cm_inverse": 157.106186,
              "line": 217
            },
            {
              "number": 9,
              "THz": 4.709925,
              "cm_inverse": 157.106186,
              "line": 224
            },
            {
              "number": 10,
              "THz": 5.50019,
              "cm_inverse": 183.466604,
              "line": 231
            },
            {
              "number": 11,
              "THz": 5.50019,
              "cm_inverse": 183.466604,
              "line": 238
            },
            {
              "number": 12,
              "THz": 5.50019,
              "cm_inverse": 183.466604,
              "line": 245
            },
            {
              "number": 13,
              "THz": 6.339109,
              "cm_inverse": 211.449909,
              "line": 252
            },
            {
              "number": 14,
              "THz": 6.339109,
              "cm_inverse": 211.449909,
              "line": 259
            },
            {
              "number": 15,
              "THz": 8.270933,
              "cm_inverse": 275.888645,
              "line": 266
            },
            {
              "number": 16,
              "THz": 8.270933,
              "cm_inverse": 275.888645,
              "line": 273
            },
            {
              "number": 17,
              "THz": 8.270933,
              "cm_inverse": 275.888645,
              "line": 280
            },
            {
              "number": 18,
              "THz": 10.010511,
              "cm_inverse": 333.91472,
              "line": 287
            }
          ],
          "Gamma_ASR_relative": 0.00146793662674511,
          "Gamma_source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/Mn4NbTc_agm001179882",
            "bytes": 18614,
            "sha256": "23c17447ba42038e9a82391100bc3eb64494c6f08130c8ebd7d26b69095a04d4"
          }
        },
        "finite_path": {
          "raw_header_lines": [],
          "negative_printed_values": 0,
          "minimum_printed_mode": {
            "value": -0.0,
            "column_index_zero_based": 1
          },
          "frequency_unit_header": null,
          "fullBZ_coverage": null,
          "dynamical_stability": null,
          "state_link_verified": null
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm001179882",
          "dyn0_source_record": 9387,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                3.0,
                3.0,
                3.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                4.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 9394,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 9395,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 9396,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 9397,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 4,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "composition-assessments.json",
          "bytes": 1863044,
          "sha256": "5fc901f5f4a90b41e807722d92f39d81714b70091a189cdb5eba13367624350b",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "numeric-review.json",
          "bytes": 4542684,
          "sha256": "c4fae01d3d67f774429114902a6b39f5b133de48ea81d3d9773ba40ff4419ce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-two-PH-actual-complete-response-products-readback-v1.json",
          "bytes": 77119,
          "sha256": "434c5fe7a590607adbc104dd75d126497457317bc20f37973b5013491e9fdce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Published source predictions already known; exact matched mechanism new to reviewed catalogue only, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003195951",
      "formula": "Mn4TaW",
      "reduced_formula": "Mn4TaW",
      "composition": {
        "Mn": 4,
        "Ta": 1,
        "W": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Mn:4|Ta:1|W:1",
      "elements": [
        "Mn",
        "Ta",
        "W"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003195951",
      "control_state": "agm003195948",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Mn4TaW_agm003195951",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Mn4MoW_agm003195948",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 216. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "symprec_A": 0.0001,
        "mode": "color_aware",
        "status": "completed",
        "SG_number": 216,
        "hall_number": 512,
        "input_wyckoff_letters": [
          "c",
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "b"
        ],
        "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
          0,
          1,
          1,
          1,
          1,
          5
        ]
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 14.96,
        "control_K": 13.698,
        "delta_K": 1.2620000000000005,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.34310000000000007,
          0.20279999999999998,
          0.1522,
          0.12109999999999999,
          0.09730000000000005,
          0.07710000000000006,
          0.05940000000000001,
          0.04390000000000005,
          0.031100000000000017,
          0.021100000000000008
        ],
        "range": [
          0.021100000000000008,
          0.34310000000000007
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Ta-for-Mo withW expands volume and Mn distance and gains allsigmas, cutoff138->144Ry preserved; Ti/W is higher sourceTc, so no highest-potential claim.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
      "route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
      "next_action": "Common cutoff/mesh and moment seeds; separate soft-phonon benefit from a magnetic branch.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "CIF lattice/sites to both SCFinputs andGamma atomicheader via speciesbijection/wholetranslation; 1e-6A observationaltolerance, not physicaluncertainty",
        "novelty": "Bounded exact formula/prototype primary search; published source calculations not claimed as first discovery. New-to-reviewed exact ordered hypothesis only. Literature-wide novelty unproved.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
        "pairing_relevance": "All ten raw printed lambda values andseparate mu*=.1 sourceEliashberg/McMillan products retained; representative common-sigma response isnotrenamed Tc_uncertainty. Spinfluctuations/anisotropy omitted.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Ta-for-Mo withW expands volume and Mn distance and gains allsigmas, cutoff138->144Ry preserved; Ti/W is higher sourceTc, so no highest-potential claim.",
        "decision": "Common cutoff/mesh and moment seeds; separate soft-phonon benefit from a magnetic branch."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "magnetic_model",
        "sampling_method"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Cr4TaW_agm003199689",
            "batch-a/Mn4TaW_agm003195951"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Cr4TaW_agm003199689",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Mn4TaW_agm003195951",
          "three_symprec_supported": false,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.18859999999999988,
            -0.40790000000000004,
            -0.41270000000000007,
            -0.35050000000000003,
            -0.27890000000000004,
            -0.21489999999999998,
            -0.16260000000000008,
            -0.12270000000000003,
            -0.0938,
            -0.07490000000000008
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.41270000000000007,
            -0.07490000000000008
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              19.143
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              14.96
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -4.183,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 84
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4MoTa_agm003195946",
            "batch-a/Mn4TaW_agm003195951"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4MoTa_agm003195946",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Mn4TaW_agm003195951",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.1520999999999999,
            -0.12039999999999995,
            -0.09079999999999999,
            -0.07399999999999995,
            -0.0676,
            -0.06540000000000001,
            -0.06440000000000001,
            -0.06379999999999997,
            -0.06309999999999993,
            -0.06240000000000001
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.1520999999999999,
            -0.06240000000000001
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              17.3
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              14.96
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -2.34,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 143
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4MoW_agm003195948",
            "batch-a/Mn4TaW_agm003195951"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4MoW_agm003195948",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Mn4TaW_agm003195951",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.34310000000000007,
            0.20279999999999998,
            0.1522,
            0.12109999999999999,
            0.09730000000000005,
            0.07710000000000006,
            0.05940000000000001,
            0.04390000000000005,
            0.031100000000000017,
            0.021100000000000008
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.021100000000000008,
            0.34310000000000007
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              13.698
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              14.96
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 1.2620000000000005,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 147
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4RuTa_agm003199927",
            "batch-a/Mn4TaW_agm003195951"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4RuTa_agm003199927",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Mn4TaW_agm003195951",
          "three_symprec_supported": false,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.402,
            0.26239999999999997,
            0.23310000000000008,
            0.2037,
            0.1735000000000001,
            0.14570000000000005,
            0.12040000000000006,
            0.09809999999999997,
            0.07940000000000003,
            0.0645
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.0645,
            0.402
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              11.901
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              14.96
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 3.059000000000001,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 159
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4TaRe_agm003204489",
            "batch-a/Mn4TaW_agm003195951"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4TaRe_agm003204489",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Mn4TaW_agm003195951",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.4031,
            0.26349999999999996,
            0.2107,
            0.17720000000000002,
            0.1521,
            0.13070000000000004,
            0.11170000000000002,
            0.09509999999999996,
            0.08150000000000002,
            0.07089999999999996
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.07089999999999996,
            0.4031
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              11.832
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              14.96
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 3.128,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 161
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4TaW_agm003195951",
            "batch-a/Mn4TcTa_agm003199931"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4TaW_agm003195951",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Mn4TcTa_agm003199931",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.3256000000000001,
            -0.1764,
            -0.14240000000000008,
            -0.12350000000000005,
            -0.10620000000000007,
            -0.08850000000000002,
            -0.07130000000000003,
            -0.05569999999999997,
            -0.04300000000000004,
            -0.03310000000000002
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.3256000000000001,
            -0.03310000000000002
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              14.96
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              13.109
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -1.8510000000000009,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 164
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4TaW_agm003195951",
            "batch-a/TiMn4W_agm001186294"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4TaW_agm003195951",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/TiMn4W_agm001186294",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.09260000000000002,
            0.2860999999999999,
            0.2647999999999999,
            0.20689999999999986,
            0.15739999999999987,
            0.12209999999999999,
            0.09760000000000002,
            0.0807,
            0.06879999999999997,
            0.0605
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.0605,
            0.2860999999999999
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              14.96
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              19.035
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 4.074999999999999,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 165
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "coarse": {
          "source_record": 7951,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.6.8 starts on  5Aug2022 at  6:37: 0"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 5,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000004     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 1.23e-06,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 1.23e-06,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 2.130422493309719e-06,
            "max_component_eV_A": 3.162457149794042e-05,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 5.47753646020274e-05,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                -1.23e-06,
                1.23e-06,
                1.23e-06
              ],
              "atom_index": 2,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "-0.00",
              "GPa": -0.0
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.00"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    -3e-08,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -3e-08,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -3e-08,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  -0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.0,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  -0.0
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": 0.0,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.0,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1675.94561835,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1675.94561835"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": -8.692e-05,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-0.00008692"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1675.9455314299998
        },
        "fine": {
          "source_record": 7952,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.6.8 starts on  5Aug2022 at  5:17: 3"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 5,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000709     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 0.00020453,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.00020453,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.00035425635167206246,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.005258677730466467,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.009108297009798915,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                0.00020453,
                -0.00020453,
                -0.00020453
              ],
              "atom_index": 2,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": 0.36,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "0.36",
              "GPa": 0.036
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=        0.36"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    2.46e-06,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.36,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    2.46e-06,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.36,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    2.46e-06,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.36
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  0.036,
                  -0.0,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  0.036,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  -0.0,
                  0.036
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": 0.36000000000000004,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.036,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1675.9446918,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1675.94469180"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": -0.00023622,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-0.00023622"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1675.94445558
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "Gamma_optical_sign": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "Gamma_optical_minimum": 1.1827324370087536e-06,
          "Gamma_printing_bound": 1.9498096577210258e-12,
          "Gamma_native_signed_modes": [
            {
              "number": 1,
              "THz": 0.515389,
              "cm_inverse": 17.191537,
              "line": 168
            },
            {
              "number": 2,
              "THz": 0.515389,
              "cm_inverse": 17.191537,
              "line": 175
            },
            {
              "number": 3,
              "THz": 0.515389,
              "cm_inverse": 17.191537,
              "line": 182
            },
            {
              "number": 4,
              "THz": 3.577828,
              "cm_inverse": 119.343496,
              "line": 189
            },
            {
              "number": 5,
              "THz": 3.577828,
              "cm_inverse": 119.343496,
              "line": 196
            },
            {
              "number": 6,
              "THz": 3.577828,
              "cm_inverse": 119.343496,
              "line": 203
            },
            {
              "number": 7,
              "THz": 4.332551,
              "cm_inverse": 144.518344,
              "line": 210
            },
            {
              "number": 8,
              "THz": 4.332551,
              "cm_inverse": 144.518344,
              "line": 217
            },
            {
              "number": 9,
              "THz": 4.332551,
              "cm_inverse": 144.518344,
              "line": 224
            },
            {
              "number": 10,
              "THz": 5.74992,
              "cm_inverse": 191.796679,
              "line": 231
            },
            {
              "number": 11,
              "THz": 5.74992,
              "cm_inverse": 191.796679,
              "line": 238
            },
            {
              "number": 12,
              "THz": 5.74992,
              "cm_inverse": 191.796679,
              "line": 245
            },
            {
              "number": 13,
              "THz": 7.41981,
              "cm_inverse": 247.49821,
              "line": 252
            },
            {
              "number": 14,
              "THz": 7.41981,
              "cm_inverse": 247.49821,
              "line": 259
            },
            {
              "number": 15,
              "THz": 8.153591,
              "cm_inverse": 271.974522,
              "line": 266
            },
            {
              "number": 16,
              "THz": 8.153591,
              "cm_inverse": 271.974522,
              "line": 273
            },
            {
              "number": 17,
              "THz": 8.153591,
              "cm_inverse": 271.974522,
              "line": 280
            },
            {
              "number": 18,
              "THz": 10.008135,
              "cm_inverse": 333.835441,
              "line": 287
            }
          ],
          "Gamma_ASR_relative": 0.004380348850773119,
          "Gamma_source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/Mn4TaW_agm003195951",
            "bytes": 18614,
            "sha256": "e20126d357b3fd412167861c601a6f4d970ff7e85890f231728e66649d3f1927"
          }
        },
        "finite_path": {
          "raw_header_lines": [],
          "negative_printed_values": 0,
          "minimum_printed_mode": {
            "value": -0.0,
            "column_index_zero_based": 1
          },
          "frequency_unit_header": null,
          "fullBZ_coverage": null,
          "dynamical_stability": null,
          "state_link_verified": null
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm003195951",
          "dyn0_source_record": 7939,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                3.0,
                3.0,
                3.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                4.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 7946,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 7947,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 7948,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 7949,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 4,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "composition-assessments.json",
          "bytes": 1863044,
          "sha256": "5fc901f5f4a90b41e807722d92f39d81714b70091a189cdb5eba13367624350b",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "numeric-review.json",
          "bytes": 4542684,
          "sha256": "c4fae01d3d67f774429114902a6b39f5b133de48ea81d3d9773ba40ff4419ce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-two-PH-actual-complete-response-products-readback-v1.json",
          "bytes": 77119,
          "sha256": "434c5fe7a590607adbc104dd75d126497457317bc20f37973b5013491e9fdce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Published source predictions already known; exact matched mechanism new to reviewed catalogue only, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003199931",
      "formula": "Mn4TcTa",
      "reduced_formula": "Mn4TcTa",
      "composition": {
        "Mn": 4,
        "Ta": 1,
        "Tc": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Mn:4|Ta:1|Tc:1",
      "elements": [
        "Mn",
        "Ta",
        "Tc"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003199931",
      "control_state": "agm003204489",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Mn4TcTa_agm003199931",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Mn4TaRe_agm003204489",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 216. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "symprec_A": 0.0001,
        "mode": "color_aware",
        "status": "completed",
        "SG_number": 216,
        "hall_number": 512,
        "input_wyckoff_letters": [
          "c",
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "b"
        ],
        "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
          0,
          1,
          1,
          1,
          1,
          5
        ]
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 13.109,
        "control_K": 11.832,
        "delta_K": 1.2769999999999992,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.0774999999999999,
          0.08709999999999996,
          0.06829999999999992,
          0.05369999999999997,
          0.04589999999999994,
          0.042200000000000015,
          0.04039999999999999,
          0.03939999999999999,
          0.03849999999999998,
          0.037799999999999945
        ],
        "range": [
          0.037799999999999945,
          0.08709999999999996
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Tc-for-Re onTa-bearing network gives modest all-sigma gain and matched144Ry/grids. Experimental TaMn2 Pauli behavior is a bounded prior, not a certificate for orderedTc child.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
      "route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
      "next_action": "Ta/Tc-Re common-cell moment/mode check, with oxygen/antisite perturbation kept a distinct hypothesis.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "CIF lattice/sites to both SCFinputs andGamma atomicheader via speciesbijection/wholetranslation; 1e-6A observationaltolerance, not physicaluncertainty",
        "novelty": "Bounded exact formula/prototype primary search; published source calculations not claimed as first discovery. New-to-reviewed exact ordered hypothesis only. Literature-wide novelty unproved.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
        "pairing_relevance": "All ten raw printed lambda values andseparate mu*=.1 sourceEliashberg/McMillan products retained; representative common-sigma response isnotrenamed Tc_uncertainty. Spinfluctuations/anisotropy omitted.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Tc-for-Re onTa-bearing network gives modest all-sigma gain and matched144Ry/grids. Experimental TaMn2 Pauli behavior is a bounded prior, not a certificate for orderedTc child.",
        "decision": "Ta/Tc-Re common-cell moment/mode check, with oxygen/antisite perturbation kept a distinct hypothesis."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "magnetic_model",
        "sampling_method",
        "technetium"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4MoTa_agm003195946",
            "batch-a/Mn4TcTa_agm003199931"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4MoTa_agm003195946",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Mn4TcTa_agm003199931",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.4777,
            -0.29679999999999995,
            -0.23320000000000007,
            -0.1975,
            -0.17380000000000007,
            -0.15390000000000004,
            -0.13570000000000004,
            -0.11949999999999994,
            -0.10609999999999997,
            -0.09550000000000003
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.4777,
            -0.09550000000000003
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              17.3
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              13.109
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -4.191000000000001,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 144
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4NbTc_agm001179882",
            "batch-a/Mn4TcTa_agm003199931"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4NbTc_agm001179882",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Mn4TcTa_agm003199931",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.07180000000000009,
            -0.04510000000000003,
            -0.030000000000000027,
            -0.024900000000000033,
            -0.024600000000000066,
            -0.024900000000000033,
            -0.025000000000000022,
            -0.024799999999999933,
            -0.024599999999999955,
            -0.0243000000000001
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.07180000000000009,
            -0.0243000000000001
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              14.574
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              13.109
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -1.4649999999999999,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 156
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4RuTa_agm003199927",
            "batch-a/Mn4TcTa_agm003199931"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4RuTa_agm003199927",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Mn4TcTa_agm003199931",
          "three_symprec_supported": false,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.07639999999999991,
            0.08599999999999997,
            0.0907,
            0.08019999999999994,
            0.06730000000000003,
            0.05720000000000003,
            0.04910000000000003,
            0.04239999999999999,
            0.03639999999999999,
            0.031399999999999983
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.031399999999999983,
            0.0907
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              11.901
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              13.109
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 1.2080000000000002,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 160
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4TaRe_agm003204489",
            "batch-a/Mn4TcTa_agm003199931"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4TaRe_agm003204489",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Mn4TcTa_agm003199931",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.0774999999999999,
            0.08709999999999996,
            0.06829999999999992,
            0.05369999999999997,
            0.04589999999999994,
            0.042200000000000015,
            0.04039999999999999,
            0.03939999999999999,
            0.03849999999999998,
            0.037799999999999945
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.037799999999999945,
            0.08709999999999996
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              11.832
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              13.109
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 1.2769999999999992,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 162
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4TaW_agm003195951",
            "batch-a/Mn4TcTa_agm003199931"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4TaW_agm003195951",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Mn4TcTa_agm003199931",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.3256000000000001,
            -0.1764,
            -0.14240000000000008,
            -0.12350000000000005,
            -0.10620000000000007,
            -0.08850000000000002,
            -0.07130000000000003,
            -0.05569999999999997,
            -0.04300000000000004,
            -0.03310000000000002
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.3256000000000001,
            -0.03310000000000002
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "A",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              14.96
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              13.109
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": -1.8510000000000009,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "A",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 164
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4TcTa_agm003199931",
            "batch-a/TiMn4Tc_agm001186290"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4TcTa_agm003199931",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/TiMn4Tc_agm001186290",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.5255000000000001,
            0.29059999999999997,
            0.20510000000000006,
            0.17159999999999997,
            0.1553,
            0.14259999999999995,
            0.13080000000000003,
            0.12,
            0.1109,
            0.10340000000000005
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.10340000000000005,
            0.5255000000000001
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              13.109
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              17.71
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 4.601000000000001,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 166
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "coarse": {
          "source_record": 13619,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.6.8 starts on  5Aug2022 at  6:34: 6"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 6,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 2,
              "last": {
                "value": "SCF correction compared to forces is large: reduce conv_thr to get better values"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 3.9e-07,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 3.9e-07,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 6.754998149518622e-07,
            "max_component_eV_A": 1.0027303157883548e-05,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 1.7367798532350153e-05,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                -3.9e-07,
                3.9e-07,
                3.9e-07
              ],
              "atom_index": 2,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": -0.01,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "-0.01",
              "GPa": -0.001
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.01"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    -5e-08,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.01,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    -5e-08,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.01,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -5e-08,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.01
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  -0.001,
                  -0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  -0.001,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  -0.001
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": -0.01,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.001,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1693.92139181,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1693.92139181"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": 0.00109494,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "0.00109494"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1693.92248675
        },
        "fine": {
          "source_record": 13620,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.6.8 starts on  5Aug2022 at  5:18:22"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 5,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000491     Total SCF correction =     0.000001"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 0.00014181,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.00014181,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.0002456221250213425,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.003646081694408887,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.006315198743263013,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                -0.00014181,
                0.00014181,
                0.00014181
              ],
              "atom_index": 2,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": 0.03,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "0.03",
              "GPa": 0.003
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=        0.03"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    2.1e-07,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.03,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    2.1e-07,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.03,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    2.1e-07,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.03
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  0.003,
                  0.0,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.003,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.003
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": 0.03,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.003,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1693.92065279,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1693.92065279"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": 0.00030061,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "0.00030061"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1693.9209534000001
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "Gamma_optical_sign": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "Gamma_optical_minimum": 1.056071194156294e-06,
          "Gamma_printing_bound": 2.0607015428710133e-12,
          "Gamma_native_signed_modes": [
            {
              "number": 1,
              "THz": 0.708351,
              "cm_inverse": 23.628037,
              "line": 168
            },
            {
              "number": 2,
              "THz": 0.708351,
              "cm_inverse": 23.628037,
              "line": 175
            },
            {
              "number": 3,
              "THz": 0.708351,
              "cm_inverse": 23.628037,
              "line": 182
            },
            {
              "number": 4,
              "THz": 3.380817,
              "cm_inverse": 112.771906,
              "line": 189
            },
            {
              "number": 5,
              "THz": 3.380817,
              "cm_inverse": 112.771906,
              "line": 196
            },
            {
              "number": 6,
              "THz": 3.380817,
              "cm_inverse": 112.771906,
              "line": 203
            },
            {
              "number": 7,
              "THz": 4.779607,
              "cm_inverse": 159.430531,
              "line": 210
            },
            {
              "number": 8,
              "THz": 4.779607,
              "cm_inverse": 159.430531,
              "line": 217
            },
            {
              "number": 9,
              "THz": 4.779607,
              "cm_inverse": 159.430531,
              "line": 224
            },
            {
              "number": 10,
              "THz": 5.192415,
              "cm_inverse": 173.200328,
              "line": 231
            },
            {
              "number": 11,
              "THz": 5.192415,
              "cm_inverse": 173.200328,
              "line": 238
            },
            {
              "number": 12,
              "THz": 5.192415,
              "cm_inverse": 173.200328,
              "line": 245
            },
            {
              "number": 13,
              "THz": 6.526984,
              "cm_inverse": 217.716752,
              "line": 252
            },
            {
              "number": 14,
              "THz": 6.526984,
              "cm_inverse": 217.716752,
              "line": 259
            },
            {
              "number": 15,
              "THz": 8.05526,
              "cm_inverse": 268.694564,
              "line": 266
            },
            {
              "number": 16,
              "THz": 8.05526,
              "cm_inverse": 268.694564,
              "line": 273
            },
            {
              "number": 17,
              "THz": 8.05526,
              "cm_inverse": 268.694564,
              "line": 280
            },
            {
              "number": 18,
              "THz": 10.109864,
              "cm_inverse": 337.228772,
              "line": 287
            }
          ],
          "Gamma_ASR_relative": 0.007628049089872758,
          "Gamma_source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/Mn4TcTa_agm003199931",
            "bytes": 18614,
            "sha256": "c22ffdc1a862bdb5f2131cd8713ee6cb422a67d14e82b43fc46dba1550184802"
          }
        },
        "finite_path": {
          "raw_header_lines": [],
          "negative_printed_values": 0,
          "minimum_printed_mode": {
            "value": -0.0,
            "column_index_zero_based": 1
          },
          "frequency_unit_header": null,
          "fullBZ_coverage": null,
          "dynamical_stability": null,
          "state_link_verified": null
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm003199931",
          "dyn0_source_record": 13607,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                3.0,
                3.0,
                3.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                4.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 13614,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 13615,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 13616,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 13617,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 4,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "composition-assessments.json",
          "bytes": 1863044,
          "sha256": "5fc901f5f4a90b41e807722d92f39d81714b70091a189cdb5eba13367624350b",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "numeric-review.json",
          "bytes": 4542684,
          "sha256": "c4fae01d3d67f774429114902a6b39f5b133de48ea81d3d9773ba40ff4419ce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-two-PH-actual-complete-response-products-readback-v1.json",
          "bytes": 77119,
          "sha256": "434c5fe7a590607adbc104dd75d126497457317bc20f37973b5013491e9fdce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Published source predictions already known; exact matched mechanism new to reviewed catalogue only, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003273573",
      "formula": "Mo2Tc",
      "reduced_formula": "Mo2Tc",
      "composition": {
        "Mo": 2,
        "Tc": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Mo:2|Tc:1",
      "elements": [
        "Mo",
        "Tc"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003273573",
      "control_state": "agm003273564",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Mo2Tc_agm003273573",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Mo2Re_agm003273564",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "CIF_source_record": 4281,
        "CIF_payload_pin": {
          "bytes": 591661,
          "sha256": "93c3ce21c362fc36392db6d13f4555d76cce96122769d1212414bbc770f81541"
        },
        "SCF_coarse_source_record": 4302,
        "Gamma_source_pin": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/Mo2Tc_agm003273573",
          "bytes": 5507,
          "sha256": "6d525fac7d5a6e666a755f7864c1957d2bc9673f053f0392326e640c33180bdf"
        },
        "source_input_volume_difference_relative": -7.162659354520429e-11,
        "occupancy_model_all1": true,
        "bounded_signed_axis_and_translation_mapping": {
          "signed_axis_U_CIF_fractional_to_SCF": [
            [
              1,
              0,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              1,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              0,
              1
            ]
          ],
          "determinant": 1,
          "origin_shift_fractional": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species_bijection_CIF_to_SCF": [
            0,
            1,
            2
          ],
          "maximum_site_distance_A": 5.705544481335504e-16,
          "relative_Gram_residual": 1.558545264645852e-09,
          "proper_signed_axis_solution": true
        },
        "attempts": 1,
        "general_GL3_or_chiral_equivalence_asserted": false,
        "CIF_site_precision_A_tolerance": 1e-05,
        "physical_model": "source finite neutral scalar EPC; no SOC transfer certificate"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 17.515,
        "control_K": 14.115,
        "delta_K": 3.4000000000000004,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.10309999999999997,
          0.1191000000000001,
          0.11180000000000001,
          0.1018,
          0.09540000000000004,
          0.09199999999999997,
          0.09009999999999996,
          0.08879999999999999,
          0.08760000000000001,
          0.08640000000000003
        ],
        "range": [
          0.08640000000000003,
          0.1191000000000001
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "All ten lambda gains +.0864…+.1191 and source Tc+3.400 K accompany positive optical Gamma, no printed path negatives, fine force .01216 eV/A and stress .041 GPa. Separate primary Tc-binary calculations find no ordered Mo-Tc ground states, a concrete decomposition/order competition. This source-positive local metastable basin is admissible only as a metastable phase research object, not equilibrium proof.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse force 4.473719870440352e-05 eV/Å, pressure -0.0 GPa; fine force 0.012160290516801547 eV/Å, pressure 0.022 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
      "route_response": "Re-to-Tc role construction in tetragonal Mo2X. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
      "next_action": "Compare the exact ordered SG139 source phase with the nearest saved Mo-Tc competitor or explicitly known disordered branch. Favorable: local basin and useful paired response persist under a feasible metastable preparation hypothesis; adverse: direct phase competition rules out accessible retained phase; ambiguous: no comparable formation information.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact source CIF/SCF/Γ state association; CIF source record 4281. Experimental occupancy/P/T and physical magnetic ground state remain unknown; source scalar model only.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Re-to-Tc role construction in tetragonal Mo2X. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
        "pairing_relevance": "direct published source EPC plus independent source isotropic Eliashberg result.  favorable comparator(s); bounded source model, not experiment.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse force 4.473719870440352e-05 eV/Å, pressure -0.0 GPa; fine force 0.012160290516801547 eV/Å, pressure 0.022 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "All ten lambda gains +.0864…+.1191 and source Tc+3.400 K accompany positive optical Gamma, no printed path negatives, fine force .01216 eV/A and stress .041 GPa. Separate primary Tc-binary calculations find no ordered Mo-Tc ground states, a concrete decomposition/order competition. This source-positive local metastable basin is admissible only as a metastable phase research object, not equilibrium proof.",
        "novelty": "Published binary work has A15/sigma Mo-Tc alloy chemistry and a different PBE phase survey; no exact SG139 Mo2Tc experimental phase was retrieved. Its energy/hull cannot transfer to NC/PBEsol state.",
        "decision": "Compare the exact ordered SG139 source phase with the nearest saved Mo-Tc competitor or explicitly known disordered branch. Favorable: local basin and useful paired response persist under a feasible metastable preparation hypothesis; adverse: direct phase competition rules out accessible retained phase; ambiguous: no comparable formation information."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase",
        "residual_force_stress",
        "technetium"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 170,
          "control": "batch-a/Mo2Re_agm003273564",
          "target": "batch-a/Mo2Tc_agm003273573",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.08640000000000003,
            0.1191000000000001
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            10.180275715800642,
            12.714850005337897
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 17.515,
          "Tc_control_K": 14.115,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 3.4000000000000004,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9914197556498444,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.8481677291856843e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003273564",
            "dyn0_source_record": 10374,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 10381,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 11,
                "source_record": 10382,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 12,
                "source_record": 10383,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 13,
                "source_record": 10384,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 10385,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 10386,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 10387,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 10388,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 10389,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 10390,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 10391,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 10392,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 10393,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.08640000000000003,
            0.1191000000000001
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-02-eleven-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1219201,
          "sha256": "ee658cb8e6309178e268b736f8aeb6429c030a92019c068963e2d64ca51cbb17",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-03-fifteen-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1347056,
          "sha256": "1be9342cb74006b2542e9351fc2de310967f1a31a5ee9f1909ae730b9a11476a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-remaining-transition-owned-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 5381838,
          "sha256": "62f4910578c7b65392d26619cf81b31afd6142f38aa49834a70bb147e7ab222d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to the reviewed candidate mechanism catalogue, source prediction already published; not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm002702984",
      "formula": "Mo2TcW",
      "reduced_formula": "Mo2TcW",
      "composition": {
        "Mo": 2,
        "Tc": 1,
        "W": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Mo:2|Tc:1|W:1",
      "elements": [
        "Mo",
        "Tc",
        "W"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm002702984",
      "control_state": "agm002665225",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Mo2TcW_agm002702984",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Cr2TcW_agm002665225",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "CIF_source_record": 5911,
        "CIF_payload_pin": {
          "bytes": 591661,
          "sha256": "93c3ce21c362fc36392db6d13f4555d76cce96122769d1212414bbc770f81541"
        },
        "SCF_coarse_source_record": 5927,
        "Gamma_source_pin": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/Mo2TcW_agm002702984",
          "bytes": 8994,
          "sha256": "8a5504ad4d005d0e2fc18ac003e8a4826b54f36a32bd43b1953e933b2149018b"
        },
        "source_input_volume_difference_relative": -4.2330028371395656e-11,
        "occupancy_model_all1": true,
        "bounded_signed_axis_and_translation_mapping": {
          "signed_axis_U_CIF_fractional_to_SCF": [
            [
              1,
              0,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              1,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              0,
              1
            ]
          ],
          "determinant": 1,
          "origin_shift_fractional": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species_bijection_CIF_to_SCF": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            3
          ],
          "maximum_site_distance_A": 0,
          "relative_Gram_residual": 1.3099295106966998e-09,
          "proper_signed_axis_solution": true
        },
        "attempts": 1,
        "general_GL3_or_chiral_equivalence_asserted": false,
        "CIF_site_precision_A_tolerance": 1e-05,
        "physical_model": "source finite neutral scalar EPC; no SOC transfer certificate"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 16.389,
        "control_K": 15.24,
        "delta_K": 1.1489999999999991,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.23940000000000006,
          0.19889999999999997,
          0.16649999999999998,
          0.14790000000000014,
          0.1372,
          0.13080000000000003,
          0.12670000000000003,
          0.1238999999999999,
          0.12120000000000009,
          0.11770000000000003
        ],
        "range": [
          0.11770000000000003,
          0.23940000000000006
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Re-to-Tc produces +.1137…+.3243 lambda and +3.761 K source Tc; another W/Mo exchange also favorable. Mo3Tc is better and several Cr-containing controls are not physical matching certificates. Target no path negatives, force0 and .110 GPa fine stress support local finite-source basin. Binary Tc phase competition remains bounded, not a mandatory full hull gate.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.003 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure 0.11000000000000001 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
      "route_response": "Re-to-Tc mapped role substitution in cubic Mo2WX. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
      "next_action": "Resolve saved Mo/W/Tc role contributions and compare candidate local phase to source accessible competitors. Favorable: matching role response remains on stable branch; adverse: decomposition or channel competition dominates; ambiguous: missing mode/formation association.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact source CIF/SCF/Γ state association; CIF source record 5911. Experimental occupancy/P/T and physical magnetic ground state remain unknown; source scalar model only.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Re-to-Tc mapped role substitution in cubic Mo2WX. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
        "pairing_relevance": "direct published source EPC plus independent source isotropic Eliashberg result.  favorable comparator(s); bounded source model, not experiment.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.003 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure 0.11000000000000001 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Re-to-Tc produces +.1137…+.3243 lambda and +3.761 K source Tc; another W/Mo exchange also favorable. Mo3Tc is better and several Cr-containing controls are not physical matching certificates. Target no path negatives, force0 and .110 GPa fine stress support local finite-source basin. Binary Tc phase competition remains bounded, not a mandatory full hull gate.",
        "novelty": "Exact Mo2TcW experimental ordered SG225 phase was not retrieved; source computational proposal is known. Broader sigma/A15 Mo-Tc and W-Tc phase context is not exact identity.",
        "decision": "Resolve saved Mo/W/Tc role contributions and compare candidate local phase to source accessible competitors. Favorable: matching role response remains on stable branch; adverse: decomposition or channel competition dominates; ambiguous: missing mode/formation association."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase",
        "residual_force_stress",
        "technetium"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 34,
          "control": "batch-a/Cr2TcW_agm002665225",
          "target": "batch-a/Mo2TcW_agm002702984",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.11770000000000003,
            0.23940000000000006
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            15.165571446978486,
            22.72856735972658
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 16.389,
          "Tc_control_K": 15.24,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 1.1489999999999991,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.15875118742557,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 9.801122549040458e-07,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": 0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm002665225",
            "dyn0_source_record": 7909,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 7916,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 7917,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 7918,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 7919,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 7920,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 7921,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 7922,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 7923,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.11770000000000003,
            0.23940000000000006
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 95,
          "control": "batch-a/CrMo2Tc_agm002666214",
          "target": "batch-a/Mo2TcW_agm002702984",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.07150000000000001,
            0.38549999999999995
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            8.695123434269732,
            42.49338624338624
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 16.389,
          "Tc_control_K": 15.343,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 1.0459999999999994,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.0761051839504456,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.4544580115048503e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm002666214",
            "dyn0_source_record": 7845,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 7852,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 7853,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 7854,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 7855,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 7856,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 7857,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 7858,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 7859,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.07150000000000001,
            0.38549999999999995
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 174,
          "control": "batch-a/Mo2WRe_agm002703009",
          "target": "batch-a/Mo2TcW_agm002702984",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.11370000000000002,
            0.3242999999999999
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            14.57505448019485,
            33.48822800495662
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 16.389,
          "Tc_control_K": 12.628,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 3.7609999999999992,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9938564354484516,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.1250539694149318e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm002703009",
            "dyn0_source_record": 15555,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 15562,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 15563,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 15564,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 15565,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 15566,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 15567,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 15568,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 15569,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.11370000000000002,
            0.3242999999999999
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 175,
          "control": "batch-a/Mo3Tc_agm003165329",
          "target": "batch-a/Mo2TcW_agm002702984",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.04830000000000001,
            -0.015800000000000036
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -3.614859237048133,
            -1.5526729559748462
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 16.389,
          "Tc_control_K": 17.722,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": -1.333000000000002,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": true,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.006407439685082,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.069894241246668e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": 0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003165329",
            "dyn0_source_record": 4013,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 4020,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 4021,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 4022,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 4023,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 4024,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 4025,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 4026,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 4027,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.04830000000000001,
            -0.015800000000000036
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 176,
          "control": "batch-a/MoTcW2_agm003183396",
          "target": "batch-a/Mo2TcW_agm002702984",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.0746,
            0.20889999999999986
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            9.1064453125,
            19.274773943532004
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 16.389,
          "Tc_control_K": 14.179,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 2.209999999999999,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9944828486905507,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.074236213943098e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003183396",
            "dyn0_source_record": 10335,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 10342,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 10343,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 10344,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 10345,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 10346,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 10347,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 10348,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 10349,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.0746,
            0.20889999999999986
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-02-eleven-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1219201,
          "sha256": "ee658cb8e6309178e268b736f8aeb6429c030a92019c068963e2d64ca51cbb17",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-03-fifteen-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1347056,
          "sha256": "1be9342cb74006b2542e9351fc2de310967f1a31a5ee9f1909ae730b9a11476a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-remaining-transition-owned-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 5381838,
          "sha256": "62f4910578c7b65392d26619cf81b31afd6142f38aa49834a70bb147e7ab222d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to the reviewed candidate mechanism catalogue, source prediction already published; not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003165292",
      "formula": "Mo3Re",
      "reduced_formula": "Mo3Re",
      "composition": {
        "Mo": 3,
        "Re": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Mo:3|Re:1",
      "elements": [
        "Mo",
        "Re"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003165292",
      "control_state": "agm002666208",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Mo3Re_agm003165292",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/CrMo2Re_agm002666208",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "CIF_source_record": 11023,
        "CIF_payload_pin": {
          "bytes": 591661,
          "sha256": "93c3ce21c362fc36392db6d13f4555d76cce96122769d1212414bbc770f81541"
        },
        "SCF_coarse_source_record": 11039,
        "Gamma_source_pin": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/Mo3Re_agm003165292",
          "bytes": 8948,
          "sha256": "775b810f5a63c3983e91e35d8700946a9d317636200ab686236f6b9fa401540c"
        },
        "source_input_volume_difference_relative": -3.745348475803212e-11,
        "occupancy_model_all1": true,
        "bounded_signed_axis_and_translation_mapping": {
          "signed_axis_U_CIF_fractional_to_SCF": [
            [
              1,
              0,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              1,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              0,
              1
            ]
          ],
          "determinant": 1,
          "origin_shift_fractional": [
            -7.20888904126582e-09,
            1.1626670071152034e-08,
            -7.20888904126582e-09
          ],
          "species_bijection_CIF_to_SCF": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            3
          ],
          "maximum_site_distance_A": 5.099278809529921e-08,
          "relative_Gram_residual": 5.504372497812968e-10,
          "proper_signed_axis_solution": true
        },
        "attempts": 1,
        "general_GL3_or_chiral_equivalence_asserted": false,
        "CIF_site_precision_A_tolerance": 1e-05,
        "physical_model": "source finite neutral scalar EPC; no SOC transfer certificate"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 13.994,
        "control_K": 13.314,
        "delta_K": 0.6799999999999997,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.07689999999999997,
          0.08329999999999993,
          0.08010000000000006,
          0.07600000000000007,
          0.06919999999999993,
          0.062000000000000055,
          0.05600000000000005,
          0.05170000000000008,
          0.0494,
          0.04809999999999992
        ],
        "range": [
          0.04809999999999992,
          0.08329999999999993
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Small but coherent W-to-Mo gain +.0089…+.0743 lambda and Tc+1.366 K is supported by path0, force0 and .08 GPa fine stress. Better Mo3Tc and adverse Cr2MoRe Tc direction remain visible. Experimental Mo-Re alloys and A15 Mo3Re are concrete competing phases; no equilibrium retention claim.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.003 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure 0.08 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
      "route_response": "W-to-Mo or Cr-to-Mo role construction in cubic Mo3Re. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
      "next_action": "Compare source SG225 geometry/EPC with actual known A15/disordered competitor without transferring properties. Favorable: distinct local phase and role gain remain accessible; adverse: only A15/disordered phase persists; ambiguous: formation/retention mechanism unknown.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact source CIF/SCF/Γ state association; CIF source record 11023. Experimental occupancy/P/T and physical magnetic ground state remain unknown; source scalar model only.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "W-to-Mo or Cr-to-Mo role construction in cubic Mo3Re. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
        "pairing_relevance": "direct published source EPC plus independent source isotropic Eliashberg result.  favorable comparator(s); bounded source model, not experiment.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.003 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure 0.08 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Small but coherent W-to-Mo gain +.0089…+.0743 lambda and Tc+1.366 K is supported by path0, force0 and .08 GPa fine stress. Better Mo3Tc and adverse Cr2MoRe Tc direction remain visible. Experimental Mo-Re alloys and A15 Mo3Re are concrete competing phases; no equilibrium retention claim.",
        "novelty": "Known Mo3Re superconducting prior is A15 SG223, while this exact mapped source object is SG225. Same chemistry is not exact phase identity and cannot be called a new-worldwide material.",
        "decision": "Compare source SG225 geometry/EPC with actual known A15/disordered competitor without transferring properties. Favorable: distinct local phase and role gain remain accessible; adverse: only A15/disordered phase persists; ambiguous: formation/retention mechanism unknown."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase",
        "residual_force_stress"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 17,
          "control": "batch-a/Cr2MoRe_agm002145097",
          "target": "batch-a/Mo3Re_agm003165292",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.03720000000000001,
            0.0695
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            4.573262461137295,
            7.615603769449924
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 13.994,
          "Tc_control_K": 14.195,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": -0.2010000000000005,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.1585170889325949,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.4747929256234286e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm002145097",
            "dyn0_source_record": 10531,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 10538,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 10539,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 10540,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 10541,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 10542,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 10543,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 10544,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 10545,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.03720000000000001,
            0.0695
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 92,
          "control": "batch-a/CrMo2Re_agm002666208",
          "target": "batch-a/Mo3Re_agm003165292",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.04809999999999992,
            0.08329999999999993
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            6.425327277584813,
            9.368421052631586
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 13.994,
          "Tc_control_K": 13.314,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 0.6799999999999997,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.064902364148138,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.4938909463600663e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm002666208",
            "dyn0_source_record": 13535,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 13542,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 13543,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 13544,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 13545,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 13546,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 13547,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 13548,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 13549,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.04809999999999992,
            0.08329999999999993
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 179,
          "control": "batch-a/Mo2WRe_agm002703009",
          "target": "batch-a/Mo3Re_agm003165292",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.008900000000000019,
            0.07429999999999992
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            0.9936278215790147,
            7.672449401073928
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 13.994,
          "Tc_control_K": 12.628,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 1.3659999999999997,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9943603145723672,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.1250539694149318e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm002703009",
            "dyn0_source_record": 15555,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 15562,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 15563,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 15564,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 15565,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 15566,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 15567,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 15568,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 15569,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.008900000000000019,
            0.07429999999999992
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 187,
          "control": "batch-a/Mo3Tc_agm003165329",
          "target": "batch-a/Mo3Re_agm003165292",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.2983,
            -0.12140000000000006
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -22.244593586875467,
            -13.222960461823337
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 13.994,
          "Tc_control_K": 17.722,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": -3.7280000000000015,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": true,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.0069176820912518,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.069894241246668e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": 0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003165329",
            "dyn0_source_record": 4013,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 4020,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 4021,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 4022,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 4023,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 4024,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 4025,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 4026,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 4027,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.2983,
            -0.12140000000000006
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-02-eleven-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1219201,
          "sha256": "ee658cb8e6309178e268b736f8aeb6429c030a92019c068963e2d64ca51cbb17",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-03-fifteen-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1347056,
          "sha256": "1be9342cb74006b2542e9351fc2de310967f1a31a5ee9f1909ae730b9a11476a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-remaining-transition-owned-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 5381838,
          "sha256": "62f4910578c7b65392d26619cf81b31afd6142f38aa49834a70bb147e7ab222d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to the reviewed candidate mechanism catalogue, source prediction already published; not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003165329",
      "formula": "Mo3Tc",
      "reduced_formula": "Mo3Tc",
      "composition": {
        "Mo": 3,
        "Tc": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Mo:3|Tc:1",
      "elements": [
        "Mo",
        "Tc"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003165329",
      "control_state": "agm002145239",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Mo3Tc_agm003165329",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Cr3Tc_agm002145239",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "CIF_source_record": 3999,
        "CIF_payload_pin": {
          "bytes": 591661,
          "sha256": "93c3ce21c362fc36392db6d13f4555d76cce96122769d1212414bbc770f81541"
        },
        "SCF_coarse_source_record": 4015,
        "Gamma_source_pin": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/Mo3Tc_agm003165329",
          "bytes": 8948,
          "sha256": "a8f0f806e5cab9ce75b184fd69fa52ab8268317793e778c31e77a427f6545bea"
        },
        "source_input_volume_difference_relative": 4.765032812770187e-11,
        "occupancy_model_all1": true,
        "bounded_signed_axis_and_translation_mapping": {
          "signed_axis_U_CIF_fractional_to_SCF": [
            [
              1,
              0,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              1,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              0,
              1
            ]
          ],
          "determinant": 1,
          "origin_shift_fractional": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species_bijection_CIF_to_SCF": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            3
          ],
          "maximum_site_distance_A": 0,
          "relative_Gram_residual": 1.0136435789607268e-09,
          "proper_signed_axis_solution": true
        },
        "attempts": 1,
        "general_GL3_or_chiral_equivalence_asserted": false,
        "CIF_site_precision_A_tolerance": 1e-05,
        "physical_model": "source finite neutral scalar EPC; no SOC transfer certificate"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 17.722,
        "control_K": 15.804,
        "delta_K": 1.918000000000001,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.38139999999999996,
          0.28569999999999984,
          0.23749999999999993,
          0.2097,
          0.19310000000000005,
          0.18259999999999998,
          0.17590000000000006,
          0.17120000000000002,
          0.16709999999999992,
          0.16249999999999998
        ],
        "range": [
          0.16249999999999998,
          0.38139999999999996
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Use AGM003165329 SG225 as group candidate: no printed path negatives, force0 and .052 GPa fine stress. SG166 sibling has only tiny first-row x0 acoustic negatives but BFGS failure; SG123 sibling has fine force .0506 and .793 GPa stress. Both remain separate source variants, not extra candidate counts. Binary primary Mo-Tc ground-state opposition limits claim to local metastable research phase.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure 0.002 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.052000000000000005 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
      "route_response": "Re-to-Tc and W-to-Mo ordered role construction in Mo3Tc. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
      "next_action": "Compare retained exact SG225 Mo3Tc and Mo3Re orbital/mode evidence, then bounded phase competition. Favorable: local source pairing advantage and plausible metastable phase remain; adverse: decomposition/ordering competition eliminates object; ambiguous: no formation relation. Do not select a sibling merely by its Tc.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact source CIF/SCF/Γ state association; CIF source record 3999. Experimental occupancy/P/T and physical magnetic ground state remain unknown; source scalar model only.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Re-to-Tc and W-to-Mo ordered role construction in Mo3Tc. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
        "pairing_relevance": "direct published source EPC plus independent source isotropic Eliashberg result.  favorable comparator(s); bounded source model, not experiment.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure 0.002 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.052000000000000005 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Use AGM003165329 SG225 as group candidate: no printed path negatives, force0 and .052 GPa fine stress. SG166 sibling has only tiny first-row x0 acoustic negatives but BFGS failure; SG123 sibling has fine force .0506 and .793 GPa stress. Both remain separate source variants, not extra candidate counts. Binary primary Mo-Tc ground-state opposition limits claim to local metastable research phase.",
        "novelty": "Known Mo-Tc A15/sigma compositions differ from exact source SG225 ordered3:1 phase. Already published calculated proposal, new to reviewed catalogue only.",
        "decision": "Compare retained exact SG225 Mo3Tc and Mo3Re orbital/mode evidence, then bounded phase competition. Favorable: local source pairing advantage and plausible metastable phase remain; adverse: decomposition/ordering competition eliminates object; ambiguous: no formation relation. Do not select a sibling merely by its Tc."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase",
        "residual_force_stress",
        "technetium"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 20,
          "control": "batch-a/Cr2MoTc_agm002664904",
          "target": "batch-a/Mo3Tc_agm003165329",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.03539999999999999,
            0.12630000000000008
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            3.7122483221476497,
            10.397629044208454
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 17.722,
          "Tc_control_K": 18.783,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": -1.061,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.1585783274687078,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 7.743678394179404e-07,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm002664904",
            "dyn0_source_record": 3215,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 3222,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 3223,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 3224,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 3225,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 3226,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 3227,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 3228,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 3229,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.03539999999999999,
            0.12630000000000008
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 44,
          "control": "batch-a/Cr3Tc_agm002145239",
          "target": "batch-a/Mo3Tc_agm003165329",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.16249999999999998,
            0.38139999999999996
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            21.50608787718369,
            39.745727386411
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 17.722,
          "Tc_control_K": 15.804,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 1.918000000000001,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.2584527640344387,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.1607638967890708e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm002145239",
            "dyn0_source_record": 7251,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 7258,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 7259,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 7260,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 7261,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 7262,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 7263,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 7264,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 7265,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.16249999999999998,
            0.38139999999999996
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 96,
          "control": "batch-a/CrMo2Tc_agm002666214",
          "target": "batch-a/Mo3Tc_agm003165329",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.0958,
            0.43379999999999996
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            11.650249300741821,
            47.81746031746031
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 17.722,
          "Tc_control_K": 15.343,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 2.3790000000000013,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.069254003415528,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.4544580115048503e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm002666214",
            "dyn0_source_record": 7845,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 7852,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 7853,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 7854,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 7855,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 7856,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 7857,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 7858,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 7859,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.0958,
            0.43379999999999996
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 175,
          "control": "batch-a/Mo2TcW_agm002702984",
          "target": "batch-a/Mo3Tc_agm003165329",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.015800000000000036,
            0.04830000000000001
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            1.577161110002,
            3.750432077428265
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 17.722,
          "Tc_control_K": 16.389,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 1.333000000000002,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9936333542137894,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 9.626147809268024e-07,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": 0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm002702984",
            "dyn0_source_record": 5925,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 5932,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 5933,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 5934,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 5935,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 5936,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 5937,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 5938,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 5939,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.015800000000000036,
            0.04830000000000001
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 177,
          "control": "batch-a/Mo2TcW_agm003183408",
          "target": "batch-a/Mo3Tc_agm003165329",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.10450000000000004,
            0.2944
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            12.84414945919371,
            28.129180202560672
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 17.722,
          "Tc_control_K": 14.072,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 3.650000000000002,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9949776107503648,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.2616967733689425e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003183408",
            "dyn0_source_record": 10737,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 10744,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 10745,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 10746,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 10747,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 10748,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 10749,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 10750,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 10751,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.10450000000000004,
            0.2944
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 187,
          "control": "batch-a/Mo3Re_agm003165292",
          "target": "batch-a/Mo3Tc_agm003165329",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.12140000000000006,
            0.2983
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            15.237856156646174,
            28.60842044691666
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 17.722,
          "Tc_control_K": 13.994,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 3.7280000000000015,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9931298434675567,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.321691541741064e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003165292",
            "dyn0_source_record": 11037,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 11044,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 11045,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 11046,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 11047,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 11048,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 11049,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 11050,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 11051,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.12140000000000006,
            0.2983
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 188,
          "control": "batch-a/MoTcW2_agm003183396",
          "target": "batch-a/Mo3Tc_agm003165329",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.09889999999999999,
            0.2571999999999999
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            11.72254335260116,
            23.731315740911594
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 17.722,
          "Tc_control_K": 14.179,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 3.543000000000001,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9881513286524762,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.074236213943098e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003183396",
            "dyn0_source_record": 10335,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 10342,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 10343,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 10344,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 10345,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 10346,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 10347,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 10348,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 10349,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.09889999999999999,
            0.2571999999999999
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-02-eleven-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1219201,
          "sha256": "ee658cb8e6309178e268b736f8aeb6429c030a92019c068963e2d64ca51cbb17",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-03-fifteen-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1347056,
          "sha256": "1be9342cb74006b2542e9351fc2de310967f1a31a5ee9f1909ae730b9a11476a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-remaining-transition-owned-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 5381838,
          "sha256": "62f4910578c7b65392d26619cf81b31afd6142f38aa49834a70bb147e7ab222d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to the reviewed candidate mechanism catalogue, source prediction already published; not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001192155",
      "formula": "MoH",
      "reduced_formula": "MoH",
      "composition": {
        "H": 1,
        "Mo": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "H:1|Mo:1",
      "elements": [
        "H",
        "Mo"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001192155",
      "control_state": "agm001192164",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/HMo_agm001192155",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/HCr_agm001192164",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Fm-3m B1/rock-salt MoH primitive two-site source with octahedral H, not the known P63/mmc NiAs MoH phase",
      "prototype_evidence": "Fm-3m B1/rock-salt MoH primitive two-site source with octahedral H, not the known P63/mmc NiAs MoH phase",
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 17.312,
        "control_K": 15.56,
        "delta_K": 1.7520000000000007,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.29889999999999994,
          0.22710000000000008,
          0.18730000000000002,
          0.17110000000000003,
          0.1664,
          0.16649999999999998,
          0.16809999999999992,
          0.16979999999999995,
          0.17059999999999997,
          0.1703
        ],
        "range": [
          0.1664,
          0.29889999999999994
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "The known competing MoH phase is hexagonal NiAs/P63mmc, with high-pressure synthesis and ambient recovered measurements; known superconductivity in that phase is not this B1 source phase. FCC gamma MoH exists as a pressure/temperature phase prior, while source B1 is locally stable at Gamma and sampled path. H loss, competing hcp/metal+H2, anharmonicity and the omitted magnetic competition of Cr/Mn controls are substantive falsifiers. The source paper reports a near-hull B1 phase in a separate calculation, not an exact-state thermodynamic certificate. PdH is a retained higher-lambda control and experimental benchmark, not omitted.",
      "ambient_scope": "Both source SCFs converge, near-zero coarse forces/stress and bounded fine response are measured. Fine Fmax=0 eV/A, P=-0.319 GPa, full max stress=0.319 GPa. Gamma optical compression is positive beyond printing bound and sampled path has no signed negative values. All listed q outputs have JOBDONE/last response convergence and no routine errors. This supports a finite-grid local/metastable source model, not global hull or experimental synthesis.",
      "route_response": "Mo replaces Cr in the same rock-salt metal/H site motif; source cell volume rises 31.870%, Mo-H versus Cr-H rises 0.180451 A and the metal self-neighbor distance rises 0.255196 A. Direct lambda is 21.448–41.624% larger at all ten sigma values and separate Eli mu=.1 rises 15.560 to 17.312 K. This bounded configured-scalar coupled metal/network contrast does not prove real magnetic CrH is a weaker superconductor.",
      "next_action": "Compare B1 MoH with the same-composition NiAs competitor and an H-loss reaction at a common functional, while separately testing magnetic CrH/MnH and common sampling for the source paired response. Retained B1 local stability and coupling gain support the bounded source hypothesis; easy phase conversion, H loss or magnetic/method reversal opposes it.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Complete ordered CIF/literal coarse-fine input/Gamma periodic species-site association is numerically supported; source input geometry and full tensor/forces are retained. Export occupancy is a discrete computational convention; source experimental P/T/occupancy and actual compiled unit constant are unknown. Exact-version input defaults scope the configured neutral scalar spin1/noSOC model, not magnetic ground state.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Mo replaces Cr in the same rock-salt metal/H site motif; source cell volume rises 31.870%, Mo-H versus Cr-H rises 0.180451 A and the metal self-neighbor distance rises 0.255196 A. Direct lambda is 21.448–41.624% larger at all ten sigma values and separate Eli mu=.1 rises 15.560 to 17.312 K. This bounded configured-scalar coupled metal/network contrast does not prove real magnetic CrH is a weaker superconductor.",
        "pairing_relevance": "Exact target and mapped control direct source lambda arrays have the same favorable sign at all ten common broadening tokens; omega_ln has explicit K units and separate Eli/McM mu=.1 tables remain independent. Same underlying q mesh is observed. The sensitivity range is not a physical error bound; sigma units, full-BZ convergence, experimental Tc and pure-geometry causality remain unknown. Literal method differences are declared confounds.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Both source SCFs converge, near-zero coarse forces/stress and bounded fine response are measured. Fine Fmax=0 eV/A, P=-0.319 GPa, full max stress=0.319 GPa. Gamma optical compression is positive beyond printing bound and sampled path has no signed negative values. All listed q outputs have JOBDONE/last response convergence and no routine errors. This supports a finite-grid local/metastable source model, not global hull or experimental synthesis.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "The known competing MoH phase is hexagonal NiAs/P63mmc, with high-pressure synthesis and ambient recovered measurements; known superconductivity in that phase is not this B1 source phase. FCC gamma MoH exists as a pressure/temperature phase prior, while source B1 is locally stable at Gamma and sampled path. H loss, competing hcp/metal+H2, anharmonicity and the omitted magnetic competition of Cr/Mn controls are substantive falsifiers. The source paper reports a near-hull B1 phase in a separate calculation, not an exact-state thermodynamic certificate. PdH is a retained higher-lambda control and experimental benchmark, not omitted.",
        "novelty": "MoH chemistry and P63/mmc superconductivity are known. Dated 2026-10-07 B1/FCC MoH searches found phase/structure predictions and FCC gamma phase prior, but no experimental superconducting exact B1 source state. The object is an ordered B1 source-phase and matched metal substitution hypothesis new to the reviewed catalogue, not first discovery of MoH or inherited NiAs Tc.",
        "decision": "Compare B1 MoH with the same-composition NiAs competitor and an H-loss reaction at a common functional, while separately testing magnetic CrH/MnH and common sampling for the source paired response. Retained B1 local stability and coupling gain support the bounded source hypothesis; easy phase conversion, H loss or magnetic/method reversal opposes it."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "hydrogen_anharmonicity",
        "metastable_phase"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index_zero_based": 118,
          "control_directory": "batch-a/HCr_agm001192164",
          "mapping_scope": "bounded ordered isostructural analogue",
          "all_three_symprec_support": true,
          "composition_edit": {
            "from": "Cr",
            "to": "Mo",
            "count": 1,
            "kind": "single_site_substitution"
          },
          "volume_target_over_control": 1.3187034214434448,
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_all10": [
            41.623729285614814,
            31.709019826864015,
            25.23578550255996,
            22.424639580602886,
            21.51538660460305,
            21.447893855468244,
            21.69872208596875,
            22.026203139187956,
            22.25120646928394,
            22.325642370215
          ],
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_range": [
            21.447893855468244,
            41.623729285614814
          ],
          "separate_source_Eli_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              17.312
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              15.56
            ]
          ],
          "separate_source_McM_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              15.415,
              16.53
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              13.517,
              14.179
            ]
          ],
          "literal_method_same_fields": {
            "ecutwfc": false,
            "smear": true,
            "degauss": true,
            "pseudo_dir": false
          },
          "qmesh_target_control": [
            [
              5.0,
              5.0,
              5.0
            ],
            [
              5.0,
              5.0,
              5.0
            ]
          ],
          "irreducible_qcount_target_control": [
            [
              10.0
            ],
            [
              10.0
            ]
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index_zero_based": 120,
          "control_directory": "batch-a/HMn_agm001192157",
          "mapping_scope": "bounded ordered isostructural analogue",
          "all_three_symprec_support": true,
          "composition_edit": {
            "from": "Mn",
            "to": "Mo",
            "count": 1,
            "kind": "single_site_substitution"
          },
          "volume_target_over_control": 1.4174986029010364,
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_all10": [
            44.9750534568781,
            33.68764172335601,
            31.769208959455618,
            31.212248911363965,
            31.147083449623214,
            31.419013102871467,
            31.823266219239375,
            32.306610407876235,
            32.818478106844275,
            33.35715306559955
          ],
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_range": [
            31.147083449623214,
            44.9750534568781
          ],
          "separate_source_Eli_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              17.312
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              11.63
            ]
          ],
          "separate_source_McM_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              15.415,
              16.53
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              10.26,
              10.718
            ]
          ],
          "literal_method_same_fields": {
            "ecutwfc": false,
            "smear": true,
            "degauss": true,
            "pseudo_dir": false
          },
          "qmesh_target_control": [
            [
              5.0,
              5.0,
              5.0
            ],
            [
              5.0,
              5.0,
              5.0
            ]
          ],
          "irreducible_qcount_target_control": [
            [
              10.0
            ],
            [
              10.0
            ]
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index_zero_based": 123,
          "control_directory": "batch-a/HPd_agm003157455",
          "mapping_scope": "bounded ordered isostructural analogue",
          "all_three_symprec_support": true,
          "composition_edit": {
            "from": "Mo",
            "to": "Pd",
            "count": 1,
            "kind": "single_site_substitution"
          },
          "volume_target_over_control": 1.0216258883422131,
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_all10": [
            -36.603914723849904,
            -40.98104235750485,
            -40.11339475549256,
            -38.71539168088177,
            -37.296503869762475,
            -35.80280539289119,
            -34.54141498298966,
            -33.72084830550271,
            -33.37361387546204,
            -33.416583416583414
          ],
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_range": [
            -40.98104235750485,
            -33.37361387546204
          ],
          "separate_source_Eli_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              17.312
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              41.75
            ]
          ],
          "separate_source_McM_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              15.415,
              16.53
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              34.676,
              39.07
            ]
          ],
          "literal_method_same_fields": {
            "ecutwfc": false,
            "smear": true,
            "degauss": true,
            "pseudo_dir": false
          },
          "qmesh_target_control": [
            [
              5.0,
              5.0,
              5.0
            ],
            [
              5.0,
              5.0,
              5.0
            ]
          ],
          "irreducible_qcount_target_control": [
            [
              10.0
            ],
            [
              10.0
            ]
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "nat": 2,
        "lambda10": [
          1.017,
          0.9433,
          0.9295,
          0.9341,
          0.9398,
          0.9428,
          0.9428,
          0.9407,
          0.9373,
          0.9331
        ],
        "omega10_K": [
          240.2067,
          239.0803,
          238.3686,
          237.8886,
          237.3932,
          236.9082,
          236.4611,
          236.0772,
          235.7848,
          235.6085
        ],
        "Eli_mu01": [
          0.1,
          17.312
        ],
        "McM_mu01": [
          0.1,
          15.415,
          16.53
        ],
        "coarse_fine": [
          {
            "record": 3483,
            "version": [
              "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 28Sep2022 at 14: 0:22"
            ],
            "converged": true,
            "JOBDONE": true,
            "errors": 0,
            "Fmax_eVA": 0.0,
            "P_GPa": 0.002,
            "maxstress_GPa": 0.002,
            "fulltensor": [
              [
                0.002,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                -0.0,
                0.002,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                -0.0,
                0.0,
                0.002
              ]
            ],
            "F_Ry": -141.70763762,
            "E_Ry": -141.7073009,
            "pattern_selected_warning_counts": {
              "BFGS": 1,
              "negative_charge": 0,
              "eigen_text": 0,
              "failure_text": 0,
              "SCF_correction_text": 1
            },
            "warning_scope": "pattern-selected contexts; informational SCF correction and ignored cell card are not optimization failure; no whole-file warning-free claim"
          },
          {
            "record": 3484,
            "version": [
              "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 28Sep2022 at 13:58:50"
            ],
            "converged": true,
            "JOBDONE": true,
            "errors": 0,
            "Fmax_eVA": 0.0,
            "P_GPa": -0.319,
            "maxstress_GPa": 0.319,
            "fulltensor": [
              [
                -0.319,
                -0.0,
                -0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                -0.319,
                -0.0
              ],
              [
                -0.0,
                0.0,
                -0.319
              ]
            ],
            "F_Ry": -141.70762591,
            "E_Ry": -141.70767709,
            "pattern_selected_warning_counts": {
              "BFGS": 1,
              "negative_charge": 0,
              "eigen_text": 0,
              "failure_text": 0,
              "SCF_correction_text": 1
            },
            "warning_scope": "pattern-selected contexts; informational SCF correction and ignored cell card are not optimization failure; no whole-file warning-free claim"
          }
        ],
        "inputs": [
          {
            "record": 3467,
            "ecutwfc": [
              92.0
            ],
            "ecutrho": null,
            "pseudo_dir": [
              "[private custody location omitted]"
            ],
            "spin": null,
            "noncol": null,
            "SOC": null,
            "charge": null,
            "smear": [
              "mp"
            ],
            "degauss": [
              0.014699728870262
            ],
            "ibrav": [
              2.0
            ],
            "nat": [
              2.0
            ],
            "grid": [
              "10 10 10 0 0 0"
            ]
          },
          {
            "record": 3468,
            "ecutwfc": [
              92.0
            ],
            "ecutrho": null,
            "pseudo_dir": [
              "[private custody location omitted]"
            ],
            "spin": null,
            "noncol": null,
            "SOC": null,
            "charge": null,
            "smear": [
              "mp"
            ],
            "degauss": [
              0.014699728870262
            ],
            "ibrav": [
              2.0
            ],
            "nat": [
              2.0
            ],
            "grid": [
              "40 40 40 0 0 0"
            ]
          }
        ],
        "Gamma": {
          "nat": 2,
          "ibrav": 2,
          "q": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species": [
            "H",
            "Mo"
          ],
          "optical": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "minopt": 7.194352928936132e-05,
          "printingbound": 2.333444081916256e-11,
          "negative_native_modes": [
            1,
            2,
            3
          ],
          "negativeoutside3": [],
          "min_low3_translation": 0.9999999929054028,
          "sourcepin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/HMo_agm001192155",
            "bytes": 2968,
            "sha256": "4c2647430b428cbe17b367e956f2628d093ef92a9c00229be08eb354aa6afff4"
          }
        },
        "path": {
          "rows": 202,
          "negatives": 0,
          "minimum": -0.0,
          "unit": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-2-compact-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 84096,
          "sha256": "d8ca53bafc5ee0879de647e050127d8e0d20c0e3da10de9602ab2de44bf77532",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-3-five-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 110335,
          "sha256": "861dd76c8368cca687ca20c8468e464badefb533a318ed41c4f8d62dccb6ed50",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-4-three-phase-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 64369,
          "sha256": "56076a077e591b9bdef8ada45d78f224f417a4af8d2e722e332f639eedfafaf7",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all64-light-Nb-rich-owned-review-cache-v2.json",
          "bytes": 4566542,
          "sha256": "f27e8c84c10c4d8de44022f6bd160e7e8aee8b2d562db5fd6003af68d5e35756",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to this reviewed candidate catalogue and mechanism contrast; MC2023 prediction is prior, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001637483",
      "formula": "MoTc2RuH",
      "reduced_formula": "MoTc2RuH",
      "composition": {
        "H": 1,
        "Mo": 1,
        "Ru": 1,
        "Tc": 2
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "H:1|Mo:1|Ru:1|Tc:2",
      "elements": [
        "H",
        "Mo",
        "Ru",
        "Tc"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001637483",
      "control_state": "agm001620158",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/HMoTc2Ru_agm001637483",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/HTc2RuW_agm001620158",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "P4/mmm ordered five-site tetragonal hydride: H corner, Ru c-axis midpoint, Mo body center, two Tc basal edge centers",
      "prototype_evidence": "P4/mmm ordered five-site tetragonal hydride: H corner, Ru c-axis midpoint, Mo body center, two Tc basal edge centers",
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 15.603,
        "control_K": 11.976,
        "delta_K": 3.626999999999999,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.18279999999999996,
          0.1361,
          0.12609999999999988,
          0.12179999999999991,
          0.12219999999999998,
          0.12660000000000005,
          0.13360000000000005,
          0.14129999999999998,
          0.14839999999999998,
          0.15370000000000006
        ],
        "range": [
          0.12179999999999991,
          0.18279999999999996
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "The actual source target has no negative sampled-path value and positive Gamma optical compression. Fine stress reaches 0.459 GPa although forces vanish by symmetry, so cell response remains a concrete next test. Hydrogen desorption/decomposition, cation disorder, Tc/Ru phase competition and SOC can change the result; radioactivity is a practical limitation, not fabricated evidence of phonon instability. No exact thermodynamic equilibrium or experimental realization is claimed.",
      "ambient_scope": "Both source SCFs converge, near-zero coarse forces/stress and bounded fine response are measured. Fine Fmax=0 eV/A, P=0.009 GPa, full max stress=0.459 GPa. Gamma optical compression is positive beyond printing bound and sampled path has no signed negative values. All listed q outputs have JOBDONE/last response convergence and no routine errors. This supports a finite-grid local/metastable source model, not global hull or experimental synthesis.",
      "route_response": "Mo replaces W on the unique body-centered metal site with H, Ru and two Tc roles retained. Volume contracts 0.5125%, Mo-Ru versus W-Ru falls 0.0046193 A and H-Mo versus H-W falls 0.0057705 A. All ten lambda values rise 14.206–21.248%, with separate Eli mu=.1 11.976 to 15.603 K. The effect is a measured coupled site/network construction, not a nominal-valence or DOS carrier inference.",
      "next_action": "At the frozen Mo/W site roles compare common volume and electronic/q sampling, then test the dominant H-loss or cation-disorder competitor and residual-cell strain. Stable persistent coupling gain supports the screen; a nontranslation unstable branch, low-energy decomposition or lost paired gain opposes it.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Complete ordered CIF/literal coarse-fine input/Gamma periodic species-site association is numerically supported; source input geometry and full tensor/forces are retained. Export occupancy is a discrete computational convention; source experimental P/T/occupancy and actual compiled unit constant are unknown. Exact-version input defaults scope the configured neutral scalar spin1/noSOC model, not magnetic ground state.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Mo replaces W on the unique body-centered metal site with H, Ru and two Tc roles retained. Volume contracts 0.5125%, Mo-Ru versus W-Ru falls 0.0046193 A and H-Mo versus H-W falls 0.0057705 A. All ten lambda values rise 14.206–21.248%, with separate Eli mu=.1 11.976 to 15.603 K. The effect is a measured coupled site/network construction, not a nominal-valence or DOS carrier inference.",
        "pairing_relevance": "Exact target and mapped control direct source lambda arrays have the same favorable sign at all ten common broadening tokens; omega_ln has explicit K units and separate Eli/McM mu=.1 tables remain independent. Same underlying q mesh is observed. The sensitivity range is not a physical error bound; sigma units, full-BZ convergence, experimental Tc and pure-geometry causality remain unknown. Literal method differences are declared confounds.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Both source SCFs converge, near-zero coarse forces/stress and bounded fine response are measured. Fine Fmax=0 eV/A, P=0.009 GPa, full max stress=0.459 GPa. Gamma optical compression is positive beyond printing bound and sampled path has no signed negative values. All listed q outputs have JOBDONE/last response convergence and no routine errors. This supports a finite-grid local/metastable source model, not global hull or experimental synthesis.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "The actual source target has no negative sampled-path value and positive Gamma optical compression. Fine stress reaches 0.459 GPa although forces vanish by symmetry, so cell response remains a concrete next test. Hydrogen desorption/decomposition, cation disorder, Tc/Ru phase competition and SOC can change the result; radioactivity is a practical limitation, not fabricated evidence of phonon instability. No exact thermodynamic equilibrium or experimental realization is claimed.",
        "novelty": "Dated 2026-10-07 exact MoTc2RuH/HMoTc2Ru superconductivity queries identified no experimental exact-phase benchmark. The MC2023 predicted phase is acknowledged prior. Novelty is this bounded Mo-for-W ordered hydride construction in the reviewed catalogue, not a first composition claim.",
        "decision": "At the frozen Mo/W site roles compare common volume and electronic/q sampling, then test the dominant H-loss or cation-disorder competitor and residual-cell strain. Stable persistent coupling gain supports the screen; a nontranslation unstable branch, low-energy decomposition or lost paired gain opposes it."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "hydrogen_anharmonicity",
        "metastable_phase",
        "residual_force_stress",
        "technetium"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index_zero_based": 122,
          "control_directory": "batch-a/HTc2RuW_agm001620158",
          "mapping_scope": "bounded ordered isostructural analogue",
          "all_three_symprec_support": true,
          "composition_edit": {
            "from": "Mo",
            "to": "W",
            "count": 1,
            "kind": "single_site_substitution"
          },
          "volume_target_over_control": 0.994875343552301,
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_all10": [
            21.248401720330115,
            15.527666856816886,
            14.414723365340635,
            14.205738278516433,
            14.620722660923663,
            15.52041191614565,
            16.725087631447177,
            17.986252545824847,
            19.11878381860345,
            19.945497015312753
          ],
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_range": [
            14.205738278516433,
            21.248401720330115
          ],
          "separate_source_Eli_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              15.603
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              11.976
            ]
          ],
          "separate_source_McM_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              13.467,
              14.348
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              10.292,
              10.838
            ]
          ],
          "literal_method_same_fields": {
            "ecutwfc": true,
            "smear": true,
            "degauss": true,
            "pseudo_dir": true
          },
          "qmesh_target_control": [
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ]
          ],
          "irreducible_qcount_target_control": [
            [
              6.0
            ],
            [
              6.0
            ]
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "nat": 5,
        "lambda10": [
          1.0431,
          1.0126,
          1.0009,
          0.9792,
          0.958,
          0.9423,
          0.9324,
          0.9269,
          0.9246,
          0.9243
        ],
        "omega10_K": [
          214.228,
          213.7399,
          213.5061,
          213.3576,
          213.2484,
          213.1665,
          213.107,
          213.0561,
          212.9935,
          212.902
        ],
        "Eli_mu01": [
          0.1,
          15.603
        ],
        "McM_mu01": [
          0.1,
          13.467,
          14.348
        ],
        "coarse_fine": [
          {
            "record": 6457,
            "version": [
              "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 14May2023 at 21: 7:41"
            ],
            "converged": true,
            "JOBDONE": true,
            "errors": 0,
            "Fmax_eVA": 0.0,
            "P_GPa": -0.002,
            "maxstress_GPa": 0.005,
            "fulltensor": [
              [
                -0.0,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                -0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                -0.005
              ]
            ],
            "F_Ry": -683.02414806,
            "E_Ry": -683.02406547,
            "pattern_selected_warning_counts": {
              "BFGS": 1,
              "negative_charge": 0,
              "eigen_text": 0,
              "failure_text": 0,
              "SCF_correction_text": 1
            },
            "warning_scope": "pattern-selected contexts; informational SCF correction and ignored cell card are not optimization failure; no whole-file warning-free claim"
          },
          {
            "record": 6458,
            "version": [
              "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 14May2023 at 21: 3: 2"
            ],
            "converged": true,
            "JOBDONE": true,
            "errors": 0,
            "Fmax_eVA": 0.0,
            "P_GPa": 0.009,
            "maxstress_GPa": 0.45899999999999996,
            "fulltensor": [
              [
                0.24300000000000002,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                0.24300000000000002,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                -0.45899999999999996
              ]
            ],
            "F_Ry": -683.02535276,
            "E_Ry": -683.02518119,
            "pattern_selected_warning_counts": {
              "BFGS": 1,
              "negative_charge": 0,
              "eigen_text": 0,
              "failure_text": 0,
              "SCF_correction_text": 1
            },
            "warning_scope": "pattern-selected contexts; informational SCF correction and ignored cell card are not optimization failure; no whole-file warning-free claim"
          }
        ],
        "inputs": [
          {
            "record": 6445,
            "ecutwfc": [
              100.0
            ],
            "ecutrho": null,
            "pseudo_dir": [
              "/dss/dsshome1/07/di29xud3/software/progs/qe/pp/nc-sr-04_pbesol_stringent_upf/"
            ],
            "spin": null,
            "noncol": null,
            "SOC": null,
            "charge": null,
            "smear": [
              "mp"
            ],
            "degauss": [
              0.014699728870262
            ],
            "ibrav": [
              6.0
            ],
            "nat": [
              5.0
            ],
            "grid": [
              "6 6 6 0 0 0"
            ]
          },
          {
            "record": 6446,
            "ecutwfc": [
              100.0
            ],
            "ecutrho": null,
            "pseudo_dir": [
              "/dss/dsshome1/07/di29xud3/software/progs/qe/pp/nc-sr-04_pbesol_stringent_upf/"
            ],
            "spin": null,
            "noncol": null,
            "SOC": null,
            "charge": null,
            "smear": [
              "mp"
            ],
            "degauss": [
              0.014699728870262
            ],
            "ibrav": [
              6.0
            ],
            "nat": [
              5.0
            ],
            "grid": [
              "24 24 24 0 0 0"
            ]
          }
        ],
        "Gamma": {
          "nat": 5,
          "ibrav": 6,
          "q": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species": [
            "H",
            "Mo",
            "Ru",
            "Tc"
          ],
          "optical": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "minopt": 9.973136666181456e-07,
          "printingbound": 2.403970477751264e-11,
          "negative_native_modes": [
            1,
            2,
            3
          ],
          "negativeoutside3": [],
          "min_low3_translation": 0.9999587001245754,
          "sourcepin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/HMoTc2Ru_agm001637483",
            "bytes": 13395,
            "sha256": "e4aa1f0a28643f4c2158a60af548c42b8596125ce47470fa1202a99342554d78"
          }
        },
        "path": {
          "rows": 168,
          "negatives": 0,
          "minimum": -0.0,
          "unit": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-2-compact-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 84096,
          "sha256": "d8ca53bafc5ee0879de647e050127d8e0d20c0e3da10de9602ab2de44bf77532",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-3-five-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 110335,
          "sha256": "861dd76c8368cca687ca20c8468e464badefb533a318ed41c4f8d62dccb6ed50",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-4-three-phase-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 64369,
          "sha256": "56076a077e591b9bdef8ada45d78f224f417a4af8d2e722e332f639eedfafaf7",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all64-light-Nb-rich-owned-review-cache-v2.json",
          "bytes": 4566542,
          "sha256": "f27e8c84c10c4d8de44022f6bd160e7e8aee8b2d562db5fd6003af68d5e35756",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to this reviewed candidate catalogue and mechanism contrast; MC2023 prediction is prior, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm004326783",
      "formula": "MoTcRu2",
      "reduced_formula": "MoTcRu2",
      "composition": {
        "Mo": 1,
        "Ru": 2,
        "Tc": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Mo:1|Ru:2|Tc:1",
      "elements": [
        "Mo",
        "Ru",
        "Tc"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm004326783",
      "control_state": "agm003183338",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/MoTcRu2_agm004326783",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/MoTcRu2_agm003183338",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": null,
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 13.125,
        "control_K": 12.502,
        "delta_K": 0.6229999999999993,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.08009999999999995,
          0.0625,
          0.05169999999999997,
          0.04400000000000004,
          0.037899999999999934,
          0.033499999999999974,
          0.030500000000000083,
          0.028400000000000092,
          0.027000000000000024,
          0.0262
        ],
        "range": [
          0.0262,
          0.08009999999999995
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": [
        0.9747875580848436,
        0.9761792671499285,
        0.976913146475351,
        0.9776345301331544,
        0.9781167569224942,
        0.9781340812098285,
        0.9778435061007761,
        0.9774662730447824,
        0.9771251066648904,
        0.9768579993018895
      ],
      "risk_summary": "The λ increment is small and the fine-grid geometries and sampling differ. Published Ru–Tc competing structures are a chemical-system prior, not evidence the exact ternary phase exists or lacks EPC.",
      "ambient_scope": "Exact model force/full stress, converged electronic outputs, reported finite-q workflow and raw Γ optical evidence provide a bounded near-ambient source-model screen. Source residual stress/metastable alternatives remain explicit; this is not proof of synthesizeability, full BZ or global equilibrium.",
      "route_response": "Two distinct tetragonal species networks have all-ten λ preference for A and separate Eliashberg +0.623 K. Fine F also favors A by 8.618 meV/atom. Complete species-channel geometry differences and computed all-σ pairing response are saved against the frozen controls. Cell/grid/method sensitivity prevents a pure geometry-only causal claim; no bandwidth/carrier quantity is substituted.",
      "next_action": "Use a matched-grid pair and the closest Ru–Tc-derived structural competitor to test the small response. A control-equivalent gain is adverse; a retained λ/ω response with finite-q coherence supports the construction.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Source-specific full-species CIF→both SCF inputs→Γ coordinate/cell association, actual atom order and origin, within 1e-6 Å observational matching policy. Original experimental occupancy and measured P/T unknown; configured QE neutral/nonmagnetic/no-SOC model is distinct from a magnetic ground-state claim.",
        "novelty": "One exact reduced composition/ordered phase-design group, new to the frozen reviewed cohort. Published computed source is acknowledged, known experimental chemistry remains a comparator. Bounded primary phase search has not tied the exact target order to an established SC sample; no global absence claim.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Two distinct tetragonal species networks have all-ten λ preference for A and separate Eliashberg +0.623 K. Fine F also favors A by 8.618 meV/atom. Complete species-channel geometry differences and computed all-σ pairing response are saved against the frozen controls. Cell/grid/method sensitivity prevents a pure geometry-only causal claim; no bandwidth/carrier quantity is substituted.",
        "pairing_relevance": "All ten source λ/ω rows retained with original units/nulls, and μ*=0.1 source McMillan, Allen–Dynes and Eliashberg products kept separate. Source Gaussian EPC broadening is distinct from explicit MP electronic SCF smearing. No product maximum or selected σ defines the recommendation.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Exact model force/full stress, converged electronic outputs, reported finite-q workflow and raw Γ optical evidence provide a bounded near-ambient source-model screen. Source residual stress/metastable alternatives remain explicit; this is not proof of synthesizeability, full BZ or global equilibrium.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "The λ increment is small and the fine-grid geometries and sampling differ. Published Ru–Tc competing structures are a chemical-system prior, not evidence the exact ternary phase exists or lacks EPC.",
        "decision": "Use a matched-grid pair and the closest Ru–Tc-derived structural competitor to test the small response. A control-equivalent gain is adverse; a retained λ/ω response with finite-q coherence supports the construction."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase",
        "sampling_method",
        "technetium"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "control_directory": "batch-a/MoTcRu2_agm003183338",
          "lambda_target_minus_control_all10": [
            0.08009999999999995,
            0.0625,
            0.05169999999999997,
            0.04400000000000004,
            0.037899999999999934,
            0.033499999999999974,
            0.030500000000000083,
            0.028400000000000092,
            0.027000000000000024,
            0.0262
          ],
          "omega_log_target_over_control_all10": [
            0.9747875580848436,
            0.9761792671499285,
            0.976913146475351,
            0.9776345301331544,
            0.9781167569224942,
            0.9781340812098285,
            0.9778435061007761,
            0.9774662730447824,
            0.9771251066648904,
            0.9768579993018895
          ],
          "source_Eli_mu01_target_control_K": [
            13.125,
            12.502
          ],
          "separate_Eli_target_minus_control_K": 0.6229999999999993,
          "target_control_q_mesh_match": true,
          "target_control_q_meshes": [
            [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ]
          ],
          "q_comparison_scope": "Different cells can have different configured physical sampling. Actual meshes retained as confounds; source-paired products do not establish convergence or isolated geometry causality.",
          "original_frozen_pair": {
            "original_contrast_index": 19,
            "composition": {
              "Mo": 1,
              "Ru": 2,
              "Tc": 1
            },
            "fixed_A": "batch-a/MoTcRu2_agm004326783",
            "fixed_B": "batch-a/MoTcRu2_agm003183338",
            "lambda_B_minus_A_all10": [
              -0.08009999999999995,
              -0.0625,
              -0.05169999999999997,
              -0.04400000000000004,
              -0.037899999999999934,
              -0.033499999999999974,
              -0.030500000000000083,
              -0.028400000000000092,
              -0.027000000000000024,
              -0.0262
            ],
            "lambda_direction": "A",
            "separate_Eli_A_B_K": [
              13.125,
              12.502
            ],
            "separate_Eli_B_minus_A_K": -0.6229999999999993
          },
          "control_source_q_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003183338",
            "dyn0_source_record": 16600,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 16607,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 11,
                "source_record": 16608,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 12,
                "source_record": 16609,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 13,
                "source_record": 16610,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 16611,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 16612,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 16613,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 16614,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 16615,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 16616,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 16617,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 16618,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 16619,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.0262,
            0.08009999999999995
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "SCF_stages": {
          "scf_coarse.out.bz2": {
            "source_record": 14227,
            "explicit_program_start_headers": [
              {
                "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 13May2023 at 13: 1:35"
              }
            ],
            "last_printed_convergence_event": {
              "value": true,
              "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
            },
            "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
            "routine_error_count": 0,
            "warning_patterns": {
              "pattern_selected_count": 5,
              "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
              "BFGS": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
                }
              },
              "negative_charge": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "eigen_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "failure_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "SCF_correction_text": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Total force =     0.000000     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
                }
              }
            },
            "last_force": {
              "header": {
                "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
              },
              "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "printed_site_rows": 4,
              "ordered_atom_indices": [
                1,
                2,
                3,
                4
              ],
              "reported_max_abs_component": {
                "value": 0.0,
                "unit": "Ry/bohr",
                "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
              },
              "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
              "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
              "max_component_eV_A": 0.0,
              "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.0,
              "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
              "conversion_constants": {
                "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
                "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
              },
              "unit_conversion_valid": true,
              "max_norm_site": {
                "value": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                "atom_index": 1,
                "type_index": 3
              },
              "reported_component_agrees": true
            },
            "last_stress": {
              "last_pressure_print": {
                "value": -0.03,
                "unit": "kbar",
                "raw_value": "-0.03",
                "GPa": -0.003
              },
              "last_stress_block": {
                "header": {
                  "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.03"
                },
                "complete_3x6": true,
                "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
                "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
                "rows": [
                  {
                    "value": [
                      -1.8e-07,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -0.03,
                      0.0,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      -1.8e-07,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -0.03,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -1.6e-07,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -0.02
                    ]
                  }
                ],
                "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                  [
                    -0.003,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    -0.003,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.002
                  ]
                ],
                "trace_mean_kbar": -0.02666666666666667,
                "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.003,
                "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
              }
            },
            "last_total_energy_print": {
              "value": -714.27821505,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-714.27821505"
            },
            "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
              "value": -0.00010279,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-0.00010279"
            },
            "native_exit_status": null,
            "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
            "PH_all_irreps_complete": null,
            "fullBZ_dynamical_stability": null,
            "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -714.27811226
          },
          "scf_fine.out.bz2": {
            "source_record": 14228,
            "explicit_program_start_headers": [
              {
                "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 13May2023 at 12:53:46"
              }
            ],
            "last_printed_convergence_event": {
              "value": true,
              "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
            },
            "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
            "routine_error_count": 0,
            "warning_patterns": {
              "pattern_selected_count": 5,
              "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
              "BFGS": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
                }
              },
              "negative_charge": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "eigen_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "failure_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "SCF_correction_text": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Total force =     0.000000     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
                }
              }
            },
            "last_force": {
              "header": {
                "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
              },
              "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "printed_site_rows": 4,
              "ordered_atom_indices": [
                1,
                2,
                3,
                4
              ],
              "reported_max_abs_component": {
                "value": 0.0,
                "unit": "Ry/bohr",
                "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
              },
              "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
              "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
              "max_component_eV_A": 0.0,
              "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.0,
              "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
              "conversion_constants": {
                "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
                "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
              },
              "unit_conversion_valid": true,
              "max_norm_site": {
                "value": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                "atom_index": 1,
                "type_index": 3
              },
              "reported_component_agrees": true
            },
            "last_stress": {
              "last_pressure_print": {
                "value": -0.44,
                "unit": "kbar",
                "raw_value": "-0.44",
                "GPa": -0.044
              },
              "last_stress_block": {
                "header": {
                  "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.44"
                },
                "complete_3x6": true,
                "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
                "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
                "rows": [
                  {
                    "value": [
                      4.72e-06,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      0.69,
                      0.0,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      4.72e-06,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      0.69,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -1.832e-05,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -2.7
                    ]
                  }
                ],
                "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                  [
                    0.06899999999999999,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    0.06899999999999999,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.27
                  ]
                ],
                "trace_mean_kbar": -0.4400000000000001,
                "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.27,
                "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
              }
            },
            "last_total_energy_print": {
              "value": -714.27868253,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-714.27868253"
            },
            "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
              "value": -0.00013452,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-0.00013452"
            },
            "native_exit_status": null,
            "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
            "PH_all_irreps_complete": null,
            "fullBZ_dynamical_stability": null,
            "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -714.27854801
          }
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/MoTcRu2_agm004326783",
            "bytes": 8994,
            "sha256": "2d454372507263096e2def959f6d4f1dbd2ac5317048f8da1850a447ff859cd1"
          },
          "raw_header": {
            "ntyp": 3,
            "nat": 4,
            "ibrav": 6,
            "celldm": [
              7.2398525,
              0.0,
              0.9976305,
              0.0,
              0.0,
              0.0
            ],
            "basis_alat": null,
            "species": [
              {
                "index": 1,
                "element": "Mo",
                "header_mass": 87443.9606838445,
                "header_mass_halfwidth": 5e-11,
                "raw_mass_token": "87443.9606838445",
                "line": 4
              },
              {
                "index": 2,
                "element": "Ru",
                "header_mass": 92119.6696509919,
                "header_mass_halfwidth": 5e-11,
                "raw_mass_token": "92119.6696509919",
                "line": 5
              },
              {
                "index": 3,
                "element": "Tc",
                "header_mass": 89321.5358246484,
                "header_mass_halfwidth": 5e-11,
                "raw_mass_token": "89321.5358246484",
                "line": 6
              }
            ],
            "atoms": [
              {
                "index": 1,
                "type": 3,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.5,
                  0.5,
                  0.498815265
                ],
                "line": 7
              },
              {
                "index": 2,
                "type": 1,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.498815265
                ],
                "line": 8
              },
              {
                "index": 3,
                "type": 2,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.5,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                "line": 9
              },
              {
                "index": 4,
                "type": 2,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.0,
                  0.5,
                  0.0
                ],
                "line": 10
              }
            ],
            "q": [
              0.0,
              0.0,
              0.0
            ],
            "matrix_header_line": 12
          },
          "optical_sign": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "minimum": 1.1644664584809691e-06,
          "printing_bound": 9.406420987257256e-13,
          "ASR_relative": 0.006337885999279135,
          "native_signed_modes": [
            {
              "number": 1,
              "THz": -0.452931,
              "cm_inverse": -15.108161,
              "line": 86
            },
            {
              "number": 2,
              "THz": -0.44349,
              "cm_inverse": -14.793247,
              "line": 91
            },
            {
              "number": 3,
              "THz": -0.44349,
              "cm_inverse": -14.793247,
              "line": 96
            },
            {
              "number": 4,
              "THz": 3.550092,
              "cm_inverse": 118.418334,
              "line": 101
            },
            {
              "number": 5,
              "THz": 3.758233,
              "cm_inverse": 125.361147,
              "line": 106
            },
            {
              "number": 6,
              "THz": 4.024196,
              "cm_inverse": 134.232725,
              "line": 111
            },
            {
              "number": 7,
              "THz": 4.024196,
              "cm_inverse": 134.232725,
              "line": 116
            },
            {
              "number": 8,
              "THz": 4.648804,
              "cm_inverse": 155.067419,
              "line": 121
            },
            {
              "number": 9,
              "THz": 4.648804,
              "cm_inverse": 155.067419,
              "line": 126
            },
            {
              "number": 10,
              "THz": 4.882158,
              "cm_inverse": 162.851271,
              "line": 131
            },
            {
              "number": 11,
              "THz": 5.442336,
              "cm_inverse": 181.536802,
              "line": 136
            },
            {
              "number": 12,
              "THz": 5.442336,
              "cm_inverse": 181.536802,
              "line": 141
            }
          ],
          "native_negative_outside_lowest3": []
        },
        "finite_path": {
          "source_record": 14202,
          "observations": {
            "kind": "qe_freq_gp_source_path_table",
            "raw_header_lines": [],
            "path_rows": 170,
            "column_width_counts": {
              "13": 170
            },
            "mode_column_values": 2040,
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "column_roles_conditional_on_file_schema": true,
            "fullBZ_coverage": null,
            "dynamical_stability": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          }
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm004326783",
          "dyn0_source_record": 14201,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                4.0,
                4.0,
                4.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                18.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 10,
              "source_record": 14208,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 11,
              "source_record": 14209,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 12,
              "source_record": 14210,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 13,
              "source_record": 14211,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 14,
              "source_record": 14212,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 15,
              "source_record": 14213,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 16,
              "source_record": 14214,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 17,
              "source_record": 14215,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 18,
              "source_record": 14216,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 14217,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 14218,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 14219,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 14220,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 5,
              "source_record": 14221,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 6,
              "source_record": 14222,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 7,
              "source_record": 14223,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 8,
              "source_record": 14224,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 9,
              "source_record": 14225,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 18,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "composition-assessments.json",
          "bytes": 2036037,
          "sha256": "87a3759b8bb3bd9985bd6537220b4ea8fa427be6672204f9010e300e647c284a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "numeric-review.json",
          "bytes": 2556012,
          "sha256": "a0e7a487691b01ab8f0a4ea02eab40af649a455b97dc9ebdfdcabc4cd2453000",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Exact ordered-state mechanism new to reviewed catalogue only; source predictions/known chemistry acknowledged, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003159857",
      "formula": "MoTcW",
      "reduced_formula": "MoTcW",
      "composition": {
        "Mo": 1,
        "Tc": 1,
        "W": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Mo:1|Tc:1|W:1",
      "elements": [
        "Mo",
        "Tc",
        "W"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003159857",
      "control_state": "agm003160457",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/MoTcW_agm003159857",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/MoWRe_agm003160457",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "CIF_source_record": 3161,
        "CIF_payload_pin": {
          "bytes": 591661,
          "sha256": "93c3ce21c362fc36392db6d13f4555d76cce96122769d1212414bbc770f81541"
        },
        "SCF_coarse_source_record": 3180,
        "Gamma_source_pin": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/MoTcW_agm003159857",
          "bytes": 5555,
          "sha256": "8f1805562e727da0db230c28ad2a15eb8609f9419db84793908c04b1e842b280"
        },
        "source_input_volume_difference_relative": 2.0595258831690444e-10,
        "occupancy_model_all1": true,
        "bounded_signed_axis_and_translation_mapping": {
          "signed_axis_U_CIF_fractional_to_SCF": [
            [
              -1,
              0,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              -1,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              0,
              1
            ]
          ],
          "determinant": 1,
          "origin_shift_fractional": [
            0.66666667,
            0.33333333,
            9.999999994736442e-09
          ],
          "species_bijection_CIF_to_SCF": [
            0,
            1,
            2
          ],
          "maximum_site_distance_A": 8.061906464565582e-08,
          "relative_Gram_residual": 2.3588889609874264e-09,
          "proper_signed_axis_solution": true
        },
        "attempts": 2,
        "general_GL3_or_chiral_equivalence_asserted": false,
        "CIF_site_precision_A_tolerance": 1e-05,
        "physical_model": "source finite neutral scalar EPC; no SOC transfer certificate"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 18.404,
        "control_K": 13.541,
        "delta_K": 4.8629999999999995,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.36980000000000013,
          0.34120000000000006,
          0.34230000000000005,
          0.33919999999999995,
          0.33340000000000003,
          0.3266,
          0.31889999999999996,
          0.3101999999999999,
          0.30110000000000003,
          0.29200000000000004
        ],
        "range": [
          0.29200000000000004,
          0.36980000000000013
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Large all-token paired gain is supported, but fine-grid stress reaches 0.364 GPa and residual force 0.02598 eV/A on coarse-relaxed coordinates. Source pressure-zero relaxation and local phonon minimum justify only a finite coarse-grid metastable hypothesis. Tc/W/Re chemistry and SOC/mass are coupled; no pure high-W or carrier causal statement.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse force 0.00016352217457471632 eV/Å, pressure -0.0 GPa; fine force 0.025977914268365074 eV/Å, pressure -0.34700000000000003 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
      "route_response": "Re-to-Tc construction on the Mo-W trigonal role network. coupled chemical/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
      "next_action": "Inspect existing exact target/control mode/orbital evidence and stress/phase competition. Favorable: local near-zero-pressure role construction retains pairing advantage under matched refinement; adverse: cell strain or competing phase removes favorable branch; ambiguous: conditional internal-force scale cannot answer strain stability.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact source CIF/SCF/Γ state association; CIF source record 3161. Experimental occupancy/P/T and physical magnetic ground state remain unknown; source scalar model only.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Re-to-Tc construction on the Mo-W trigonal role network. coupled chemical/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
        "pairing_relevance": "direct published source EPC and independent source isotropic Eliashberg result. 1 favorable comparator(s); bounded source model, not experiment.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse force 0.00016352217457471632 eV/Å, pressure -0.0 GPa; fine force 0.025977914268365074 eV/Å, pressure -0.34700000000000003 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Large all-token paired gain is supported, but fine-grid stress reaches 0.364 GPa and residual force 0.02598 eV/A on coarse-relaxed coordinates. Source pressure-zero relaxation and local phonon minimum justify only a finite coarse-grid metastable hypothesis. Tc/W/Re chemistry and SOC/mass are coupled; no pure high-W or carrier causal statement.",
        "novelty": "Exact MoTcW query found no primary exact experimental superconducting phase. Closest Tc binary primary literature finds sigma/phase-separated Mo-Tc and W-Tc competitors; neither establishes decomposition of this exact ternary phase nor removes its local source minimum. Source proposed geometry is already published.",
        "decision": "Inspect existing exact target/control mode/orbital evidence and stress/phase competition. Favorable: local near-zero-pressure role construction retains pairing advantage under matched refinement; adverse: cell strain or competing phase removes favorable branch; ambiguous: conditional internal-force scale cannot answer strain stability."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase",
        "residual_force_stress",
        "sampling_method",
        "technetium"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 190,
          "control": "batch-a/MoWRe_agm003160457",
          "target": "batch-a/MoTcW_agm003159857",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.29200000000000004,
            0.36980000000000013
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            33.382874128272555,
            35.208636080548054
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 18.404,
          "Tc_control_K": 13.541,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 4.8629999999999995,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9906812329273262,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.5695090932680408e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.29200000000000004,
            0.36980000000000013
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-01-ten-specific-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 381754,
          "sha256": "5d05478212c4d22080ab1b7bf22d92b784de6c0f8a99590d0758f9cdbfdafb32",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-remaining-transition-owned-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 5381838,
          "sha256": "62f4910578c7b65392d26619cf81b31afd6142f38aa49834a70bb147e7ab222d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to the reviewed candidate mechanism catalogue, source prediction already published; not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003183396",
      "formula": "MoTcW2",
      "reduced_formula": "MoTcW2",
      "composition": {
        "Mo": 1,
        "Tc": 1,
        "W": 2
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Mo:1|Tc:1|W:2",
      "elements": [
        "Mo",
        "Tc",
        "W"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003183396",
      "control_state": "agm003183408",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/MoTcW2_agm003183396",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Mo2TcW_agm003183408",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "CIF_source_record": 10321,
        "CIF_payload_pin": {
          "bytes": 591661,
          "sha256": "93c3ce21c362fc36392db6d13f4555d76cce96122769d1212414bbc770f81541"
        },
        "SCF_coarse_source_record": 10337,
        "Gamma_source_pin": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/MoTcW2_agm003183396",
          "bytes": 8994,
          "sha256": "0b8ecc92a4771f20c2e1765e4536d28cdb60bb35690d8ae3cb964a989fcd43b5"
        },
        "source_input_volume_difference_relative": -3.471234411023261e-11,
        "occupancy_model_all1": true,
        "bounded_signed_axis_and_translation_mapping": {
          "signed_axis_U_CIF_fractional_to_SCF": [
            [
              1,
              0,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              1,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              0,
              1
            ]
          ],
          "determinant": 1,
          "origin_shift_fractional": [
            -0.5,
            -0.5,
            -0.5
          ],
          "species_bijection_CIF_to_SCF": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            3
          ],
          "maximum_site_distance_A": 2.4514905277352206e-16,
          "relative_Gram_residual": 4.004591863472954e-10,
          "proper_signed_axis_solution": true
        },
        "attempts": 1,
        "general_GL3_or_chiral_equivalence_asserted": false,
        "CIF_site_precision_A_tolerance": 1e-05,
        "physical_model": "source finite neutral scalar EPC; no SOC transfer certificate"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 14.179,
        "control_K": 14.072,
        "delta_K": 0.1070000000000011,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.03720000000000012,
          0.02069999999999994,
          0.01739999999999997,
          0.021100000000000008,
          0.021299999999999986,
          0.019100000000000006,
          0.015900000000000025,
          0.012499999999999956,
          0.009099999999999997,
          0.005600000000000049
        ],
        "range": [
          0.005600000000000049,
          0.03720000000000012
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "The SG216 comparator has all ten lambda gains +.0056…+.0372 and separate source Tc+.107 K, which is a modest coherent source response, not a calibrated significant physical gain. Different SG225 Mo2TcW and Mo3Tc neighbors outperform it; all preserved. No high-W claim or source-wide Ta/W ranking.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure 0.003 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure 0.191 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
      "route_response": "Mo-to-W mapped role change within the SG216 Mo2TcW branch. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
      "next_action": "Compare retained mode/orbital weights and source Coulomb sensitivity within the exact SG216 pair, without substituting the better SG225 control. Favorable: small response retains sign under physically justified uncertainty; adverse: sign reverses; ambiguous: numerical/physical uncertainty exceeds gain.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact source CIF/SCF/Γ state association; CIF source record 10321. Experimental occupancy/P/T and physical magnetic ground state remain unknown; source scalar model only.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Mo-to-W mapped role change within the SG216 Mo2TcW branch. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
        "pairing_relevance": "direct published source EPC plus independent source isotropic Eliashberg result.  favorable comparator(s); bounded source model, not experiment.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure 0.003 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure 0.191 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "The SG216 comparator has all ten lambda gains +.0056…+.0372 and separate source Tc+.107 K, which is a modest coherent source response, not a calibrated significant physical gain. Different SG225 Mo2TcW and Mo3Tc neighbors outperform it; all preserved. No high-W claim or source-wide Ta/W ranking.",
        "novelty": "Exact MoTcW2 queries yielded no experimental exact phase. Tc-binary competitors are broader phase-level context, not this ternary ordered identity.",
        "decision": "Compare retained mode/orbital weights and source Coulomb sensitivity within the exact SG216 pair, without substituting the better SG225 control. Favorable: small response retains sign under physically justified uncertainty; adverse: sign reverses; ambiguous: numerical/physical uncertainty exceeds gain."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "technetium"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 176,
          "control": "batch-a/Mo2TcW_agm002702984",
          "target": "batch-a/MoTcW2_agm003183396",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.20889999999999986,
            -0.0746
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -16.159975245609953,
            -8.34638621615574
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 14.179,
          "Tc_control_K": 16.389,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": -2.209999999999999,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": true,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.0055477591360311,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 9.626147809268024e-07,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": 0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm002702984",
            "dyn0_source_record": 5925,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 5932,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 5933,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 5934,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 5935,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 5936,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 5937,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 5938,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 5939,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.20889999999999986,
            -0.0746
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 178,
          "control": "batch-a/Mo2TcW_agm003183408",
          "target": "batch-a/MoTcW2_agm003183396",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.005600000000000049,
            0.03720000000000012
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            0.6882989183874201,
            3.5543665201605315
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 14.179,
          "Tc_control_K": 14.072,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 0.1070000000000011,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.0069081343109638,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.2616967733689425e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003183408",
            "dyn0_source_record": 10737,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 10744,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 10745,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 10746,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 10747,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 10748,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 10749,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 10750,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 10751,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.005600000000000049,
            0.03720000000000012
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 188,
          "control": "batch-a/Mo3Tc_agm003165329",
          "target": "batch-a/MoTcW2_agm003183396",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.2571999999999999,
            -0.09889999999999999
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -19.17971662938105,
            -10.492549668874176
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 14.179,
          "Tc_control_K": 17.722,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": -3.543000000000001,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": true,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.0119907457531647,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.069894241246668e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": 0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003165329",
            "dyn0_source_record": 4013,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 4020,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 4021,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 4022,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 4023,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 4024,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 4025,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 4026,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 4027,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.2571999999999999,
            -0.09889999999999999
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-02-eleven-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1219201,
          "sha256": "ee658cb8e6309178e268b736f8aeb6429c030a92019c068963e2d64ca51cbb17",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-03-fifteen-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1347056,
          "sha256": "1be9342cb74006b2542e9351fc2de310967f1a31a5ee9f1909ae730b9a11476a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-remaining-transition-owned-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 5381838,
          "sha256": "62f4910578c7b65392d26619cf81b31afd6142f38aa49834a70bb147e7ab222d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to the reviewed candidate mechanism catalogue, source prediction already published; not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm002346313",
      "formula": "N2TiZr",
      "reduced_formula": "N2TiZr",
      "composition": {
        "N": 2,
        "Ti": 1,
        "Zr": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "N:2|Ti:1|Zr:1",
      "elements": [
        "N",
        "Ti",
        "Zr"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm002346313",
      "control_state": "agm002291077",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/N2TiZr_agm002346313",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/N2ZrHf_agm002291077",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": "weighted_phonon_log_moment_net_pairing",
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 166. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": [
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.0001,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 166,
          "hall_number": 458,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "b",
            "a",
            "c",
            "c"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            2
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.0001,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 166,
          "hall_number": 458,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "b",
            "a",
            "c",
            "c"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            2
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.001,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 166,
          "hall_number": 458,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "b",
            "a",
            "c",
            "c"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            2
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.001,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 166,
          "hall_number": 458,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "b",
            "a",
            "c",
            "c"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            2
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.01,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 166,
          "hall_number": 458,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "b",
            "a",
            "c",
            "c"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            2
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.01,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 166,
          "hall_number": 458,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "b",
            "a",
            "c",
            "c"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            2
          ]
        }
      ],
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 12.845,
        "control_K": 11.965,
        "delta_K": 0.8800000000000008,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          -0.02290000000000003,
          -0.01749999999999996,
          -0.017800000000000038,
          -0.01970000000000005,
          -0.01990000000000003,
          -0.019299999999999984,
          -0.018900000000000028,
          -0.018400000000000083,
          -0.017800000000000038,
          -0.017100000000000004
        ],
        "range": [
          -0.02290000000000003,
          -0.017100000000000004
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": [
        1.1319498056867696,
        1.1271227504519745,
        1.1260403444324811,
        1.1272032010964002,
        1.1290156103360394,
        1.1305887673366108,
        1.1318007036416873,
        1.1327287524635257,
        1.1334319628903233,
        1.133923455888782
      ],
      "risk_summary": "Geoopt0 prints BFGS failure, but geoopt1 prints later positive convergence/no failure and low force. Coarse source stress is near zero; fine stress is anisotropic (−.567,−.567,+.861 GPa). This is finite basin support, not proof of a thermodynamic ambient ground state.",
      "ambient_scope": "The exact source neutral zero-applied-pressure model has positive Γ optical compression intervals and no negative retained sampled path value for target and selected control. Coarse/fine force and full stress, relaxation warnings and every q record are retained. These finite observations do not prove full-BZ or thermodynamic hull stability.",
      "route_response": "Hf→Ti on the matched ordered cation role raises weighted ωlog by 12.60–13.39% while λ drops .0171–.0229 at every token. Source fixed μ*=.1 McMillan/AD/Eli outputs all improve; separate-header proxy crosses below one at μ*=.2, so the positive claim is explicitly source-μ-limited.",
      "next_action": "Discriminate the ordered SG166 phase from the known rocksalt nanophase, and read saved α²F weights plus fine-strain response. A realistic μ or strain correction can reverse the net benefit; do not extrapolate the source μ=.1 result to high physical probability.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact agm002346313 ordered coordinates, species and metric are linked through source CIF→coarse/fine input→Γ header; actual bounded association residuals and original record IDs are retained below. This is not an experimental structure certificate.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Hf→Ti on the matched ordered cation role raises weighted ωlog by 12.60–13.39% while λ drops .0171–.0229 at every token. Source fixed μ*=.1 McMillan/AD/Eli outputs all improve; separate-header proxy crosses below one at μ*=.2, so the positive claim is explicitly source-μ-limited.",
        "pairing_relevance": "Separate source Eli gain 0.88 K is retained with source McMillan/AD. Actual source-header descriptor reproduces the first McMillan column to printed precision. Header-to-ten-σ and Eli-to-σ association remains null, and ωlog is α²F weighted rather than an assertion that all bare modes harden.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "The exact source neutral zero-applied-pressure model has positive Γ optical compression intervals and no negative retained sampled path value for target and selected control. Coarse/fine force and full stress, relaxation warnings and every q record are retained. These finite observations do not prove full-BZ or thermodynamic hull stability.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Geoopt0 prints BFGS failure, but geoopt1 prints later positive convergence/no failure and low force. Coarse source stress is near zero; fine stress is anisotropic (−.567,−.567,+.861 GPa). This is finite basin support, not proof of a thermodynamic ambient ground state.",
        "novelty": "TiZrN2 composition is experimentally known in a rocksalt nanophase. Current new-to-reviewed-catalogue support concerns the ordered SG166 phase and route comparison, not a new formula or an established new experimental superconductor.",
        "decision": "Supported as a private finite-source hypothesis at the printed μ*=.1 under the neutral scalar NC/PBEsol approximation; no calibrated physical probability or public score."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "residual_force_stress"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 194,
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/N2TiZr_agm002346313",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/N2ZrHf_agm002291077",
          "other_state": "batch-a/N2ZrHf_agm002291077",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "source_Eli_gain_target_minus_other_K": 0.8800000000000008,
          "other_printed_path_negative_values": 0,
          "other_q_sampling_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm002291077",
            "dyn0_source_record": 15486,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 15493,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 11,
                "source_record": 15494,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 12,
                "source_record": 15495,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 13,
                "source_record": 15496,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 15497,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 15498,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 15499,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 15500,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 15501,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 15502,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 15503,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 15504,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 15505,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.02290000000000003,
            -0.017100000000000004
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "directory_key": "batch-a/N2TiZr_agm002346313",
        "source_ID": "agm002346313",
        "composition": {
          "N": 2,
          "Ti": 1,
          "Zr": 1
        },
        "listed_sites": 4,
        "CIF_source_record": 13695,
        "source_McMillan_and_AD_mu0p1": {
          "value": [
            0.1,
            11.181,
            11.585
          ],
          "missing_tokens": [
            false,
            false,
            false
          ],
          "printed_zero": [
            false,
            false,
            false
          ]
        },
        "source_Eli_mu0p1": {
          "value": [
            0.1,
            12.845
          ],
          "missing_tokens": [
            false,
            false
          ],
          "printed_zero": [
            false,
            false
          ]
        },
        "SCF_coarse": {
          "source_record": 13735,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 13May2023 at 13: 4:33"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 7,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "c_bands:  1 eigenvalues not converged"
              }
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 2,
              "last": {
                "value": "SCF correction compared to forces is large: reduce conv_thr to get better values"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 4,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 1.25e-06,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 1.25e-06,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 1.25e-06,
            "max_component_eV_A": 3.213879217270368e-05,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 3.213879217270368e-05,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                1.25e-06
              ],
              "atom_index": 3,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "-0.00",
              "GPa": -0.0
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.00"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    -1e-08,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -1e-08,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -2e-08,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  -0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.0,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.0,
                  -0.0
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": 0.0,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.0,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
          "native_exit_status": null
        },
        "SCF_fine": {
          "source_record": 13736,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 13May2023 at 12:55:55"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 23,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 18,
              "last": {
                "value": "c_bands:  1 eigenvalues not converged"
              }
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000160     Total SCF correction =     0.000002"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 4,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 0.00011322,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.00011322,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.00011322,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.0029110032398348084,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.0029110032398348084,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                0.00011322
              ],
              "atom_index": 3,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": -0.91,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "-0.91",
              "GPa": -0.091
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.91"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    -3.854e-05,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -5.67,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -3.854e-05,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -5.67,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    5.85e-05,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    8.61
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  -0.567,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.567,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.0,
                  0.861
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": -0.9100000000000001,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.861,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
          "native_exit_status": null
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/N2TiZr_agm002346313",
            "bytes": 8994,
            "sha256": "45ac6fed46dd1dc724b17284a3f89cba23da8bdcb17d86813e1dc11c10845553"
          },
          "raw_optical_minimum": 2.6244312957262977e-06,
          "raw_optical_printing_intervals": [
            [
              2.624427231059115e-06,
              2.6244353603934804e-06
            ],
            [
              2.624427231059118e-06,
              2.6244353603934834e-06
            ],
            [
              4.461617147113459e-06,
              4.461625276447824e-06
            ],
            [
              2.0863396443421832e-05,
              2.0863404572756196e-05
            ],
            [
              2.1023618303968038e-05,
              2.1023626433302402e-05
            ],
            [
              2.1023618303968045e-05,
              2.102362643330241e-05
            ],
            [
              2.2676967225818123e-05,
              2.2676975355152487e-05
            ],
            [
              2.267696722581813e-05,
              2.2676975355152493e-05
            ],
            [
              2.5234236231446398e-05,
              2.523424436078076e-05
            ]
          ],
          "unit": "squared source-Ry frequency convention",
          "native_negative_mode_numbers": [],
          "physical_error_bar": null,
          "full_BZ": null
        },
        "retained_path": {
          "kind": "qe_freq_gp_source_path_table",
          "raw_header_lines": [],
          "path_rows": 160,
          "column_width_counts": {
            "13": 160
          },
          "mode_column_values": 1920,
          "negative_printed_values": 0,
          "minimum_printed_mode": {
            "value": -0.0,
            "column_index_zero_based": 1
          },
          "frequency_unit_header": null,
          "column_roles_conditional_on_file_schema": true,
          "fullBZ_coverage": null,
          "dynamical_stability": null,
          "state_link_verified": null
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm002346313",
          "dyn0_source_record": 13714,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                4.0,
                4.0,
                4.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                13.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 10,
              "source_record": 13721,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 11,
              "source_record": 13722,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 12,
              "source_record": 13723,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 13,
              "source_record": 13724,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 13725,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 13726,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 13727,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 13728,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 5,
              "source_record": 13729,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 6,
              "source_record": 13730,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 7,
              "source_record": 13731,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 8,
              "source_record": 13732,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 9,
              "source_record": 13733,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 13,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        },
        "unknowns": {
          "physical_mobile_carrier_density": null,
          "active_orbital_bandwidth": null,
          "public_RPS": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-01-eight-actual-omega-net-pairing-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1213076,
          "sha256": "ae6bc2be8e022ea5308483e2f63d28dfc4565f2cfa13948c036a16368c5f6201",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all62-net-pairing-owned-source-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 4086409,
          "sha256": "bced95fc8c75035eb57c3afbae73d98e099c3e732ef1e07a1836df54a1d60e15",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-owned-62-source-observations-for-Tc-header-readback-v1.json",
          "bytes": 10632536,
          "sha256": "35c5bfdd77eb7194ebebc41802600580a842c5526c8727c40a427c8869890d90",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Published source predictions already known; specific matched mechanism new to reviewed catalogue, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm002489249",
      "formula": "NaAuH3",
      "reduced_formula": "NaAuH3",
      "composition": {
        "Au": 1,
        "H": 3,
        "Na": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Au:1|H:3|Na:1",
      "elements": [
        "Au",
        "H",
        "Na"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm002489249",
      "control_state": "agm002486518",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/H3NaAu_agm002489249",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/H3NaPt_agm002486518",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "cubic Pm-3m 5-site perovskite hydride: Au 1a, Na 1b, H on three edge centers",
      "prototype_evidence": "cubic Pm-3m 5-site perovskite hydride: Au 1a, Na 1b, H on three edge centers",
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 23.838,
        "control_K": 13.298,
        "delta_K": 10.540000000000001,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.9058000000000002,
          0.5152,
          0.3148,
          0.22890000000000005,
          0.18080000000000002,
          0.15610000000000002,
          0.1476,
          0.14939999999999998,
          0.15700000000000003,
          0.16739999999999994
        ],
        "range": [
          0.1476,
          0.9058000000000002
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Hydrogen anharmonicity and zero-point/decomposition pathways, Au charge redistribution and neglected SOC can change the magnitude. They are unmeasured here, but there is no actual negative path or optical mode in this exact source model. The PdH anharmonic counterexample prohibits treating harmonic Tc as experimental.",
      "ambient_scope": "Coarse/fine SCF both converge; complete source forces/stress, positive Gamma optical compression and no signed negative finite-path value support this model near ambient. All listed q outputs end JOBDONE/response convergence with zero routine errors. This is finite-grid local/metastable evidence, not exhaustive thermodynamic or all-irrep certification.",
      "route_response": "Replace the Pt site of NaPtH3 by Au with all ordered roles retained; the source cell expands 10.911%, Au-H minus Pt-H = +0.0631033 A and H-H = +0.0892416 A. The coupled chemistry/bond-network intervention gives all-ten lambda gains 31.525–282.005% and separate Eli mu=.1 13.298→23.838 K. This is not proof that expansion alone causes the gain.",
      "next_action": "Hold the composition/ordered sites fixed and compare Au/Pt source structures at a common cell volume and common converged sampling. Favorable: the lambda advantage persists without a nontranslation soft branch; adverse: it vanishes under common sampling or an anharmonic/decomposition instability appears.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Raw CIF, literal coarse/fine crystal input and Gamma header agree by complete ordered species/site periodic association; exact natural-isotope discrete computational occupancy is export convention, experimental occupancy/P/T unknown. Source model configured neutral scalar spin1/noSOC by exact-version defaults plus literal omission; magnetic ground state and binary build not certified.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Replace the Pt site of NaPtH3 by Au with all ordered roles retained; the source cell expands 10.911%, Au-H minus Pt-H = +0.0631033 A and H-H = +0.0892416 A. The coupled chemistry/bond-network intervention gives all-ten lambda gains 31.525–282.005% and separate Eli mu=.1 13.298→23.838 K. This is not proof that expansion alone causes the gain.",
        "pairing_relevance": "Direct exact-source lambda has the favorable sign at all ten matched sigma tokens, independently accompanied by the separate mu=.1 Eli table. Finite-grid broadening sensitivity is preserved; differing PP/cutoff/version are model confounds where shown. Sigma units, physical error bar, fullBZ convergence and experimental Tc remain unknown.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Coarse/fine SCF both converge; complete source forces/stress, positive Gamma optical compression and no signed negative finite-path value support this model near ambient. All listed q outputs end JOBDONE/response convergence with zero routine errors. This is finite-grid local/metastable evidence, not exhaustive thermodynamic or all-irrep certification.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Hydrogen anharmonicity and zero-point/decomposition pathways, Au charge redistribution and neglected SOC can change the magnitude. They are unmeasured here, but there is no actual negative path or optical mode in this exact source model. The PdH anharmonic counterexample prohibits treating harmonic Tc as experimental.",
        "novelty": "2026-10-07 exact NaAuH3/AuNaH3 search identified no experimental superconducting exact phase. The published MC2023 ordered source itself is prior prediction; proposed novelty is new-to-reviewed-catalogue matched Au-for-Pt construction hypothesis, not first composition discovery.",
        "decision": "Hold the composition/ordered sites fixed and compare Au/Pt source structures at a common cell volume and common converged sampling. Favorable: the lambda advantage persists without a nontranslation soft branch; adverse: it vanishes under common sampling or an anharmonic/decomposition instability appears."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "hydrogen_anharmonicity",
        "metastable_phase"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [],
      "physical_summary": {
        "nat": 5,
        "lambda10": [
          1.227,
          0.9609,
          0.7742,
          0.6862,
          0.6449,
          0.6257,
          0.6158,
          0.6101,
          0.6066,
          0.6043
        ],
        "omega10_K": [
          990.6985,
          941.2136,
          902.2223,
          865.8444,
          838.2735,
          821.0684,
          811.65,
          806.7062,
          803.8696,
          801.8099
        ],
        "Eli_mu01": [
          0.1,
          23.838
        ],
        "McM_mu01": [
          0.1,
          21.273,
          21.972
        ],
        "coarse_fine": [
          {
            "record": 1085,
            "version": [
              "Program PWSCF v.6.8 starts on 20Apr2023 at 14:32:45"
            ],
            "converged": true,
            "JOBDONE": true,
            "errors": 0,
            "Fmax_eVA": 0.0,
            "P_GPa": 0.001,
            "maxstress_GPa": 0.001,
            "fulltensor": [
              [
                0.001,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                0.001,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                0.001
              ]
            ],
            "pattern_selected_warning_counts": {
              "BFGS": 1,
              "negative_charge": 0,
              "eigen_text": 0,
              "failure_text": 0,
              "SCF_correction_text": 1
            }
          },
          {
            "record": 1086,
            "version": [
              "Program PWSCF v.6.8 starts on 20Apr2023 at 14:17: 8"
            ],
            "converged": true,
            "JOBDONE": true,
            "errors": 0,
            "Fmax_eVA": 0.0,
            "P_GPa": 0.019,
            "maxstress_GPa": 0.019,
            "fulltensor": [
              [
                0.019,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                0.019,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                0.019
              ]
            ],
            "pattern_selected_warning_counts": {
              "BFGS": 1,
              "negative_charge": 0,
              "eigen_text": 0,
              "failure_text": 0,
              "SCF_correction_text": 1
            }
          }
        ],
        "Gamma": {
          "nat": 5,
          "ibrav": 1,
          "q": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species": [
            "Au",
            "H",
            "Na"
          ],
          "optical": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "minopt": 1.2560752393128044e-06,
          "printingbound": 7.040608399040303e-11,
          "negative_native_modes": [
            1,
            2,
            3
          ],
          "negativeoutside3": [],
          "min_low3_translation": 0.997789892670841,
          "sourcepin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/H3NaAu_agm002489249",
            "bytes": 13349,
            "sha256": "15f9c7747dca345c8df2e515bfe0e8b8508ee18adbee3c1b142de47943b4106b"
          }
        },
        "path": {
          "rows": 131,
          "negatives": 0,
          "minimum": -0.0,
          "unit": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-1-compact-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 34933,
          "sha256": "c27b3f0105c6f12aa51f2d0801a476adfacdc6cac93b8dd5b60cd485d18cd4f2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-four-tranche-eight-source-states-independent-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 267678,
          "sha256": "857ce54f337154bb41cfa9e21370ab305f2bd35f31ab86c37fcd0ba8de21a391",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to this reviewed candidate catalogue and mechanism contrast; MC2023 prediction is prior, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001216814",
      "formula": "Nb2HfTa",
      "reduced_formula": "Nb2HfTa",
      "composition": {
        "Hf": 1,
        "Nb": 2,
        "Ta": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Hf:1|Nb:2|Ta:1",
      "elements": [
        "Hf",
        "Nb",
        "Ta"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001216814",
      "control_state": "agm001146453",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Nb2HfTa_agm001216814",
      "control_directory": null,
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "ordered tetragonal P4/mmm-compatible four-site motif",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "motif": "ordered tetragonal P4/mmm-compatible four-site motif",
        "raw_geometry_basis": "a=b=4.70608636419 A,c=3.31345093391 A; Hf(1/2,1/2,1/2),Ta(0,0,1/2),Nb(1/2,0,0),(0,1/2,0)",
        "role": "A, stronger EPC member versus B",
        "known_prior_scope": "Nb2HfTa ordered source state; known experimental HfNbTa is different stoichiometry, not a benchmark identity match"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 20.749,
        "control_K": 17.554,
        "delta_K": 3.1950000000000003,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.5058,
          0.5609,
          0.5656000000000001,
          0.5421999999999998,
          0.5119999999999998,
          0.48330000000000006,
          0.4575,
          0.43490000000000006,
          0.41559999999999997,
          0.3993
        ],
        "range": [
          0.3993,
          0.5656000000000001
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "NegativeGamma modes are predominantly translational, and the independently checked optical form is positive beyond raw printing bounds. Magnetism/SOC/disorder and full-BZ/finite-temperature stability remain beyond this nonmagnetic source approximation.",
      "ambient_scope": "Zero-pressure-target optimized models and completed sampled non-Gamma/ASR-path phonons plus positive Gamma optical compression support local near-ambient harmonic feasibility within the declared source model.",
      "route_response": "Non-isometric species-resolved network differences accompany the same-composition source EPC contrast at ten common widths; different reciprocal grids remain an explicit numerical confound.",
      "next_action": "Matched reciprocal-resolution refinement must preserve A>B and optical positivity; reversal or adverse structural/magnetic evidence revises this screen. Source association or inconclusive refinement leaves the research hypothesis unresolved.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact ordered source sites, canonical SCF input, neutral spin1/noSOC model and SCF/PH/dyn association are linked. Experimental conditions remain unknown.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Non-isometric species-resolved network differences accompany the same-composition source EPC contrast at ten common widths; different reciprocal grids remain an explicit numerical confound.",
        "pairing_relevance": "Direct conventional source EPC gives A>B at every retained width in both the directory and raw-q aggregation; this is a bounded source-protocol benefit.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Zero-pressure-target optimized models and completed sampled non-Gamma/ASR-path phonons plus positive Gamma optical compression support local near-ambient harmonic feasibility within the declared source model.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "NegativeGamma modes are predominantly translational, and the independently checked optical form is positive beyond raw printing bounds. Magnetism/SOC/disorder and full-BZ/finite-temperature stability remain beyond this nonmagnetic source approximation.",
        "novelty": "New to the reviewed catalogue as an exact ordered Nb2HfTa geometry-route hypothesis. Known experimental HfNbTa has a different composition and is not an identity match. Published source predictions are acknowledged; worldwide first discovery is not claimed.",
        "decision": "Matched reciprocal-resolution refinement must preserve A>B and optical positivity; reversal or adverse structural/magnetic evidence revises this screen. Source association or inconclusive refinement leaves the research hypothesis unresolved."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "minimum-cases.json",
          "bytes": 44905,
          "sha256": "0ae09a6f4264f3bc4105f653d324dc9416fa98bf72aec5438435554c5d2cfd2e",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "four-Gamma-mode-diagnostic-owned-workingview-root-v1.json",
          "bytes": 145994,
          "sha256": "204728005269006f08ed40019b950e63f5e73ffe068d92d0a5ae1e716b90d723",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "receipt.json",
          "bytes": 12340,
          "sha256": "e205f3f041eaa43b16263049bc11b3c42169e37dd4efa136e962dd65c3539515",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "new-to-reviewed-catalogue ordered geometry hypothesis; literature-derived, not first discovery",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm002166694",
      "formula": "Nb2TcRu",
      "reduced_formula": "Nb2TcRu",
      "composition": {
        "Nb": 2,
        "Ru": 1,
        "Tc": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Nb:2|Ru:1|Tc:1",
      "elements": [
        "Nb",
        "Ru",
        "Tc"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm002166694",
      "control_state": "agm001312766",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Nb2TcRu_agm002166694",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/NbTcRuTa_agm001312766",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "CIF_source_record": 7135,
        "CIF_payload_pin": {
          "bytes": 591661,
          "sha256": "93c3ce21c362fc36392db6d13f4555d76cce96122769d1212414bbc770f81541"
        },
        "SCF_coarse_source_record": 7151,
        "Gamma_source_pin": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/Nb2TcRu_agm002166694",
          "bytes": 8994,
          "sha256": "54a3ea76a07e09632a75804e3162516b5c4bc9c790092751e13f8ed426385163"
        },
        "source_input_volume_difference_relative": -2.3785529101871816e-11,
        "occupancy_model_all1": true,
        "bounded_signed_axis_and_translation_mapping": {
          "signed_axis_U_CIF_fractional_to_SCF": [
            [
              1,
              0,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              1,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              0,
              1
            ]
          ],
          "determinant": 1,
          "origin_shift_fractional": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species_bijection_CIF_to_SCF": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            3
          ],
          "maximum_site_distance_A": 0,
          "relative_Gram_residual": 1.5920990470958367e-09,
          "proper_signed_axis_solution": true
        },
        "attempts": 1,
        "general_GL3_or_chiral_equivalence_asserted": false,
        "CIF_site_precision_A_tolerance": 1e-05,
        "physical_model": "source finite neutral scalar EPC; no SOC transfer certificate"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 15.312,
        "control_K": 12.29,
        "delta_K": 3.0220000000000002,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.2538,
          0.22870000000000013,
          0.21649999999999991,
          0.2096,
          0.20319999999999994,
          0.19530000000000014,
          0.18599999999999994,
          0.17680000000000007,
          0.1684,
          0.16149999999999998
        ],
        "range": [
          0.16149999999999998,
          0.2538
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "All-token gain +.1615…+.2538 lambda and source Tc+3.022 K versus NbTcRuTa accompanies path0, force0 and fine stress .051 GPa. MnNb2Ru is better but its scalar magnetic matching is not certified; retained as contrary source observation, not erased. Tc radioactivity and Ru/Tc channel competition remain risks.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.001 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure 0.051000000000000004 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
      "route_response": "Ta-to-Nb role replacement in cubic Nb2TcRu. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
      "next_action": "Bind Nb/Ta site EPC/orbital evidence on same frozen geometry roles. Favorable: Ta-to-Nb paired gain remains with valid channel matching; adverse: relevant competition cancels it; ambiguous: only electron counts or unmatched Mn control available.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact source CIF/SCF/Γ state association; CIF source record 7135. Experimental occupancy/P/T and physical magnetic ground state remain unknown; source scalar model only.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Ta-to-Nb role replacement in cubic Nb2TcRu. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
        "pairing_relevance": "direct published source EPC plus independent source isotropic Eliashberg result.  favorable comparator(s); bounded source model, not experiment.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.001 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure 0.051000000000000004 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "All-token gain +.1615…+.2538 lambda and source Tc+3.022 K versus NbTcRuTa accompanies path0, force0 and fine stress .051 GPa. MnNb2Ru is better but its scalar magnetic matching is not certified; retained as contrary source observation, not erased. Tc radioactivity and Ru/Tc channel competition remain risks.",
        "novelty": "Exact Nb2TcRu ordered phase was not found in bounded retrieval. Tc-Ru binary competing phases and Mo-Re-Ru HCP alloy superconductivity are not exact SG225 identity.",
        "decision": "Bind Nb/Ta site EPC/orbital evidence on same frozen geometry roles. Favorable: Ta-to-Nb paired gain remains with valid channel matching; adverse: relevant competition cancels it; ambiguous: only electron counts or unmatched Mn control available."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase",
        "residual_force_stress",
        "technetium"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 167,
          "control": "batch-a/MnNb2Ru_agm002701848",
          "target": "batch-a/Nb2TcRu_agm002166694",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.2583,
            -0.08129999999999993
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -16.19740390042014,
            -7.368516339277624
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 15.312,
          "Tc_control_K": 17.179,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": -1.866999999999999,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": true,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.0562532153688038,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 2.4257286089021345e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm002701848",
            "dyn0_source_record": 4047,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 4054,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 4055,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 4056,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 4057,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 4058,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 4059,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 4060,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 4061,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.2583,
            -0.08129999999999993
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 210,
          "control": "batch-a/NbTcRuTa_agm001312766",
          "target": "batch-a/Nb2TcRu_agm002166694",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.16149999999999998,
            0.2538
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            20.17993252530301,
            23.443561795677077
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 15.312,
          "Tc_control_K": 12.29,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 3.0220000000000002,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.000367714631971,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 2.0500784895374795e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001312766",
            "dyn0_source_record": 16023,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 16030,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 16031,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 16032,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 16033,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 16034,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 16035,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 16036,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 16037,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.16149999999999998,
            0.2538
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-02-eleven-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1219201,
          "sha256": "ee658cb8e6309178e268b736f8aeb6429c030a92019c068963e2d64ca51cbb17",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-03-fifteen-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1347056,
          "sha256": "1be9342cb74006b2542e9351fc2de310967f1a31a5ee9f1909ae730b9a11476a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-remaining-transition-owned-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 5381838,
          "sha256": "62f4910578c7b65392d26619cf81b31afd6142f38aa49834a70bb147e7ab222d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to the reviewed candidate mechanism catalogue, source prediction already published; not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003766932",
      "formula": "Nb6GaRh",
      "reduced_formula": "Nb6GaRh",
      "composition": {
        "Ga": 1,
        "Nb": 6,
        "Rh": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Ga:1|Nb:6|Rh:1",
      "elements": [
        "Ga",
        "Nb",
        "Rh"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003766932",
      "control_state": "agm003768532",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/GaNb6Rh_agm003766932",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/AlNb6Rh_agm003768532",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Pm-3 ordered A15-derived eight-site network: six Nb in one chain-site orbit, unique Ga and Rh corner/body-center roles",
      "prototype_evidence": "Pm-3 ordered A15-derived eight-site network: six Nb in one chain-site orbit, unique Ga and Rh corner/body-center roles",
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 14.014,
        "control_K": 13.213,
        "delta_K": 0.8010000000000002,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.1967000000000001,
          0.13729999999999998,
          0.0996999999999999,
          0.07550000000000012,
          0.05989999999999995,
          0.04910000000000003,
          0.04159999999999997,
          0.036599999999999966,
          0.033299999999999996,
          0.031100000000000017
        ],
        "range": [
          0.031100000000000017,
          0.1967000000000001
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "The exact target has no signed negative sampled-path values or negative optical compression. Order/disorder, competing A15 compositions and a martensitic/CDW branch remain the relevant risks; the fine force 0.033558 eV/A and early eigen warnings are preserved. GaNb6Sb is better at all sigma values and remains a retained opposite control. The small minimum effect and changed ecutwfc require a common-cutoff falsifier, rather than an asserted numerical significance bound.",
      "ambient_scope": "Both source SCFs converge, near-zero coarse forces/stress and bounded fine response are measured. Fine Fmax=0.033558041 eV/A, P=0.062 GPa, full max stress=0.062 GPa. Gamma optical compression is positive beyond printing bound and sampled path has no signed negative values. All listed q outputs have JOBDONE/last response convergence and no routine errors. This supports a finite-grid local/metastable source model, not global hull or experimental synthesis.",
      "route_response": "Ga replaces Al at the unique Al/Ga site while all six Nb-chain and Rh roles remain mapped. Cell volume contracts 0.5193% and nearest Nb-Nb falls 0.0158926 A. The coupled ordered-site/chain construction gives a modest but same-sign 3.796–18.373% lambda improvement and separate Eli mu=.1 13.213 to 14.014 K. It is not proof of pure compression or higher mobile carrier density.",
      "next_action": "Compare the retained Ga/Al site roles at common cutoff/PP family and volume, quantify Nb-chain response and test order/CDW stability. A stable persistent gain supports this narrow hypothesis; disappearance within common sampling or a chain instability opposes it.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Complete ordered CIF/literal coarse-fine input/Gamma periodic species-site association is numerically supported; source input geometry and full tensor/forces are retained. Export occupancy is a discrete computational convention; source experimental P/T/occupancy and actual compiled unit constant are unknown. Exact-version input defaults scope the configured neutral scalar spin1/noSOC model, not magnetic ground state.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Ga replaces Al at the unique Al/Ga site while all six Nb-chain and Rh roles remain mapped. Cell volume contracts 0.5193% and nearest Nb-Nb falls 0.0158926 A. The coupled ordered-site/chain construction gives a modest but same-sign 3.796–18.373% lambda improvement and separate Eli mu=.1 13.213 to 14.014 K. It is not proof of pure compression or higher mobile carrier density.",
        "pairing_relevance": "Exact target and mapped control direct source lambda arrays have the same favorable sign at all ten common broadening tokens; omega_ln has explicit K units and separate Eli/McM mu=.1 tables remain independent. Same underlying q mesh is observed. The sensitivity range is not a physical error bound; sigma units, full-BZ convergence, experimental Tc and pure-geometry causality remain unknown. Literal method differences are declared confounds.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Both source SCFs converge, near-zero coarse forces/stress and bounded fine response are measured. Fine Fmax=0.033558041 eV/A, P=0.062 GPa, full max stress=0.062 GPa. Gamma optical compression is positive beyond printing bound and sampled path has no signed negative values. All listed q outputs have JOBDONE/last response convergence and no routine errors. This supports a finite-grid local/metastable source model, not global hull or experimental synthesis.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "The exact target has no signed negative sampled-path values or negative optical compression. Order/disorder, competing A15 compositions and a martensitic/CDW branch remain the relevant risks; the fine force 0.033558 eV/A and early eigen warnings are preserved. GaNb6Sb is better at all sigma values and remains a retained opposite control. The small minimum effect and changed ecutwfc require a common-cutoff falsifier, rather than an asserted numerical significance bound.",
        "novelty": "Known Nb3Ga and mixed A15 B-site superconductors establish the family prior, not this fully ordered Pm-3 Nb6GaRh state. Dated 2026-10-07 exact Nb6GaRh/Nb6GaSb/Nb6PdPt queries found no exact experimental superconducting match. Novelty is the single Ga-for-Al ordered-source construction hypothesis, not discovery of superconductivity in Nb-rich alloys.",
        "decision": "Compare the retained Ga/Al site roles at common cutoff/PP family and volume, quantify Nb-chain response and test order/CDW stability. A stable persistent gain supports this narrow hypothesis; disappearance within common sampling or a chain instability opposes it."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase",
        "residual_force_stress",
        "sampling_method"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index_zero_based": 4,
          "control_directory": "batch-a/AlNb6Rh_agm003768532",
          "mapping_scope": "bounded ordered isostructural analogue",
          "all_three_symprec_support": true,
          "composition_edit": {
            "from": "Al",
            "to": "Ga",
            "count": 1,
            "kind": "single_site_substitution"
          },
          "volume_target_over_control": 0.9948066520470835,
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_all10": [
            18.3728750233514,
            12.803058560238714,
            9.715455076983034,
            7.71746907901463,
            6.396155899626263,
            5.44708231639672,
            4.765177548682701,
            4.3028450505525475,
            3.997119193374145,
            3.795923349200539
          ],
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_range": [
            3.795923349200539,
            18.3728750233514
          ],
          "separate_source_Eli_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              14.014
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              13.213
            ]
          ],
          "separate_source_McM_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              11.93,
              12.606
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              11.219,
              11.807
            ]
          ],
          "literal_method_same_fields": {
            "ecutwfc": false,
            "smear": true,
            "degauss": true,
            "pseudo_dir": true
          },
          "qmesh_target_control": [
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ]
          ],
          "irreducible_qcount_target_control": [
            [
              4.0
            ],
            [
              4.0
            ]
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index_zero_based": 103,
          "control_directory": "batch-a/GaNb6Sb_agm003262771",
          "mapping_scope": "bounded ordered isostructural analogue",
          "all_three_symprec_support": true,
          "composition_edit": {
            "from": "Rh",
            "to": "Sb",
            "count": 1,
            "kind": "single_site_substitution"
          },
          "volume_target_over_control": 0.9580125938261984,
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_all10": [
            -34.54028925619834,
            -28.58913813459268,
            -25.18936877076412,
            -22.268938555727658,
            -20.000000000000007,
            -18.44002059378754,
            -17.29812822135818,
            -16.32556823540508,
            -15.415405642878067,
            -14.541252135463766
          ],
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_range": [
            -34.54028925619834,
            -14.541252135463766
          ],
          "separate_source_Eli_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              14.014
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              17.221
            ]
          ],
          "separate_source_McM_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              11.93,
              12.606
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              14.457,
              15.605
            ]
          ],
          "literal_method_same_fields": {
            "ecutwfc": true,
            "smear": true,
            "degauss": true,
            "pseudo_dir": false
          },
          "qmesh_target_control": [
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ]
          ],
          "irreducible_qcount_target_control": [
            [
              4.0
            ],
            [
              4.0
            ]
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "nat": 8,
        "lambda10": [
          1.2673,
          1.2097,
          1.1259,
          1.0538,
          0.9964,
          0.9505,
          0.9146,
          0.8872,
          0.8664,
          0.8504
        ],
        "omega10_K": [
          190.8899,
          186.7369,
          185.774,
          185.5391,
          185.5191,
          185.5889,
          185.6966,
          185.8097,
          185.9065,
          185.9736
        ],
        "Eli_mu01": [
          0.1,
          14.014
        ],
        "McM_mu01": [
          0.1,
          11.93,
          12.606
        ],
        "coarse_fine": [
          {
            "record": 10317,
            "version": [
              "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 24Sep2022 at 22:18:47"
            ],
            "converged": true,
            "JOBDONE": true,
            "errors": 0,
            "Fmax_eVA": 1.0284413495265177e-05,
            "P_GPa": -0.0,
            "maxstress_GPa": 0.0,
            "fulltensor": [
              [
                -0.0,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                -0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                -0.0
              ]
            ],
            "F_Ry": -1477.54084599,
            "E_Ry": -1477.54083403,
            "pattern_selected_warning_counts": {
              "BFGS": 1,
              "negative_charge": 0,
              "eigen_text": 0,
              "failure_text": 0,
              "SCF_correction_text": 1
            },
            "warning_scope": "pattern-selected contexts; informational SCF correction and ignored cell card are not optimization failure; no whole-file warning-free claim"
          },
          {
            "record": 10318,
            "version": [
              "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 24Sep2022 at 21:25:38"
            ],
            "converged": true,
            "JOBDONE": true,
            "errors": 0,
            "Fmax_eVA": 0.033558041235050275,
            "P_GPa": 0.062,
            "maxstress_GPa": 0.062,
            "fulltensor": [
              [
                0.062,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                0.062,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                0.062
              ]
            ],
            "F_Ry": -1477.53913321,
            "E_Ry": -1477.5384199300001,
            "pattern_selected_warning_counts": {
              "BFGS": 1,
              "negative_charge": 0,
              "eigen_text": 10,
              "failure_text": 0,
              "SCF_correction_text": 1
            },
            "warning_scope": "pattern-selected contexts; informational SCF correction and ignored cell card are not optimization failure; no whole-file warning-free claim"
          }
        ],
        "inputs": [
          {
            "record": 10307,
            "ecutwfc": [
              122.0
            ],
            "ecutrho": null,
            "pseudo_dir": [
              "[private custody location omitted]"
            ],
            "spin": null,
            "noncol": null,
            "SOC": null,
            "charge": null,
            "smear": [
              "mp"
            ],
            "degauss": [
              0.014699728870262
            ],
            "ibrav": [
              1.0
            ],
            "nat": [
              8.0
            ],
            "grid": [
              "6 6 6 0 0 0"
            ]
          },
          {
            "record": 10308,
            "ecutwfc": [
              122.0
            ],
            "ecutrho": null,
            "pseudo_dir": [
              "[private custody location omitted]"
            ],
            "spin": null,
            "noncol": null,
            "SOC": null,
            "charge": null,
            "smear": [
              "mp"
            ],
            "degauss": [
              0.014699728870262
            ],
            "ibrav": [
              1.0
            ],
            "nat": [
              8.0
            ],
            "grid": [
              "24 24 24 0 0 0"
            ]
          }
        ],
        "Gamma": {
          "nat": 8,
          "ibrav": 1,
          "q": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species": [
            "Ga",
            "Nb",
            "Rh"
          ],
          "optical": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "minopt": 1.2982831630852998e-06,
          "printingbound": 2.0630607768179983e-12,
          "negative_native_modes": [],
          "negativeoutside3": [],
          "min_low3_translation": 0.9998716536021373,
          "sourcepin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/GaNb6Rh_agm003766932",
            "bytes": 31874,
            "sha256": "d084087b8d7581b78b5bd010a292ac357cb85645192c317ea2ad2dcb7a4cf225"
          }
        },
        "path": {
          "rows": 99,
          "negatives": 0,
          "minimum": -0.0,
          "unit": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-2-compact-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 84096,
          "sha256": "d8ca53bafc5ee0879de647e050127d8e0d20c0e3da10de9602ab2de44bf77532",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-3-five-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 110335,
          "sha256": "861dd76c8368cca687ca20c8468e464badefb533a318ed41c4f8d62dccb6ed50",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-4-three-phase-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 64369,
          "sha256": "56076a077e591b9bdef8ada45d78f224f417a4af8d2e722e332f639eedfafaf7",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all64-light-Nb-rich-owned-review-cache-v2.json",
          "bytes": 4566542,
          "sha256": "f27e8c84c10c4d8de44022f6bd160e7e8aee8b2d562db5fd6003af68d5e35756",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to this reviewed candidate catalogue and mechanism contrast; MC2023 prediction is prior, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003262771",
      "formula": "Nb6GaSb",
      "reduced_formula": "Nb6GaSb",
      "composition": {
        "Ga": 1,
        "Nb": 6,
        "Sb": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Ga:1|Nb:6|Sb:1",
      "elements": [
        "Ga",
        "Nb",
        "Sb"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003262771",
      "control_state": "agm003766932",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/GaNb6Sb_agm003262771",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/GaNb6Rh_agm003766932",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Pm-3 ordered A15-derived eight-site network: six Nb chain sites, distinct Ga 1b and Sb 1a roles",
      "prototype_evidence": "Pm-3 ordered A15-derived eight-site network: six Nb chain sites, distinct Ga 1b and Sb 1a roles",
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 17.221,
        "control_K": 14.014,
        "delta_K": 3.2070000000000007,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.6686999999999999,
          0.48429999999999995,
          0.3791,
          0.30189999999999984,
          0.2491000000000001,
          0.21489999999999998,
          0.19130000000000014,
          0.17310000000000003,
          0.15790000000000004,
          0.14469999999999994
        ],
        "range": [
          0.14469999999999994,
          0.6686999999999999
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "The source target path has no signed negative values and Gamma optical compression is positive. Ordered-site entropy, antisite disorder, chain/CDW distortion and Sb SOC are physical competing effects. The target loses to AlNb6Sb at all ten lambda values; that opposite control and its small negative-path risk remain explicit. Different PP paths/code versions across the Rh/Sb comparison are not concealed and the response is not geometry-only causal.",
      "ambient_scope": "Both source SCFs converge, near-zero coarse forces/stress and bounded fine response are measured. Fine Fmax=0.022252643 eV/A, P=0.051 GPa, full max stress=0.051 GPa. Gamma optical compression is positive beyond printing bound and sampled path has no signed negative values. All listed q outputs have JOBDONE/last response convergence and no routine errors. This supports a finite-grid local/metastable source model, not global hull or experimental synthesis.",
      "route_response": "Sb replaces Rh on its unique ordered site. Volume expands 4.3828%, nearest Nb-Nb grows 0.0758951 A and the Nb-to-replaced-site bond grows 0.0531240 A. Direct source lambda rises at all ten sigma values by 17.016–52.766% and separate Eli mu=.1 rises 14.014 to 17.221 K. This coupled chain/site construction is measured, not inferred from an A15 name.",
      "next_action": "At the frozen ordered Ga/(Rh or Sb) roles compare a common source method and common volume, then test an antisite/disordered or symmetry-breaking chain competitor. Persistent favorable lambda with stable order supports the bounded candidate; loss under the matched method or a lower unstable ordered branch opposes it.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Complete ordered CIF/literal coarse-fine input/Gamma periodic species-site association is numerically supported; source input geometry and full tensor/forces are retained. Export occupancy is a discrete computational convention; source experimental P/T/occupancy and actual compiled unit constant are unknown. Exact-version input defaults scope the configured neutral scalar spin1/noSOC model, not magnetic ground state.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Sb replaces Rh on its unique ordered site. Volume expands 4.3828%, nearest Nb-Nb grows 0.0758951 A and the Nb-to-replaced-site bond grows 0.0531240 A. Direct source lambda rises at all ten sigma values by 17.016–52.766% and separate Eli mu=.1 rises 14.014 to 17.221 K. This coupled chain/site construction is measured, not inferred from an A15 name.",
        "pairing_relevance": "Exact target and mapped control direct source lambda arrays have the same favorable sign at all ten common broadening tokens; omega_ln has explicit K units and separate Eli/McM mu=.1 tables remain independent. Same underlying q mesh is observed. The sensitivity range is not a physical error bound; sigma units, full-BZ convergence, experimental Tc and pure-geometry causality remain unknown. Literal method differences are declared confounds.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Both source SCFs converge, near-zero coarse forces/stress and bounded fine response are measured. Fine Fmax=0.022252643 eV/A, P=0.051 GPa, full max stress=0.051 GPa. Gamma optical compression is positive beyond printing bound and sampled path has no signed negative values. All listed q outputs have JOBDONE/last response convergence and no routine errors. This supports a finite-grid local/metastable source model, not global hull or experimental synthesis.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "The source target path has no signed negative values and Gamma optical compression is positive. Ordered-site entropy, antisite disorder, chain/CDW distortion and Sb SOC are physical competing effects. The target loses to AlNb6Sb at all ten lambda values; that opposite control and its small negative-path risk remain explicit. Different PP paths/code versions across the Rh/Sb comparison are not concealed and the response is not geometry-only causal.",
        "novelty": "1973 primary Nb3Ga experiments included partial Ga replacement by Sb, so Nb-Ga-Sb superconducting chemistry is prior art. They do not establish this exact 1a/1b ordering and relaxed Pm-3 chain structure. Dated exact-formula/ordered-phase searches found no matching experimental superconducting source state; the candidate hypothesis is phase/ordering scoped and new to the reviewed catalogue.",
        "decision": "At the frozen ordered Ga/(Rh or Sb) roles compare a common source method and common volume, then test an antisite/disordered or symmetry-breaking chain competitor. Persistent favorable lambda with stable order supports the bounded candidate; loss under the matched method or a lower unstable ordered branch opposes it."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase",
        "sampling_method"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index_zero_based": 5,
          "control_directory": "batch-a/AlNb6Sb_agm003262532",
          "mapping_scope": "bounded ordered isostructural analogue",
          "all_three_symprec_support": true,
          "composition_edit": {
            "from": "Al",
            "to": "Ga",
            "count": 1,
            "kind": "single_site_substitution"
          },
          "volume_target_over_control": 0.9947206231629179,
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_all10": [
            -24.501813360371248,
            -20.36105495745381,
            -17.02960471911352,
            -15.284634131100427,
            -14.103448275862062,
            -13.15299202623147,
            -12.376198399492901,
            -11.759320905459386,
            -11.262236853504296,
            -10.857296425692025
          ],
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_range": [
            -24.501813360371248,
            -10.857296425692025
          ],
          "separate_source_Eli_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              17.221
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              18.238
            ]
          ],
          "separate_source_McM_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              14.457,
              15.605
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              14.849,
              16.362
            ]
          ],
          "literal_method_same_fields": {
            "ecutwfc": false,
            "smear": true,
            "degauss": true,
            "pseudo_dir": true
          },
          "qmesh_target_control": [
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ]
          ],
          "irreducible_qcount_target_control": [
            [
              4.0
            ],
            [
              4.0
            ]
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index_zero_based": 103,
          "control_directory": "batch-a/GaNb6Rh_agm003766932",
          "mapping_scope": "bounded ordered isostructural analogue",
          "all_three_symprec_support": true,
          "composition_edit": {
            "from": "Rh",
            "to": "Sb",
            "count": 1,
            "kind": "single_site_substitution"
          },
          "volume_target_over_control": 1.0438276140046432,
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_all10": [
            52.76572240195691,
            40.03471935190543,
            33.67084110489387,
            28.648699943063182,
            25.00000000000001,
            22.609153077327722,
            20.916247539908174,
            19.51082055906222,
            18.22483841181903,
            17.01552210724364
          ],
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_range": [
            17.01552210724364,
            52.76572240195691
          ],
          "separate_source_Eli_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              17.221
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              14.014
            ]
          ],
          "separate_source_McM_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              14.457,
              15.605
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              11.93,
              12.606
            ]
          ],
          "literal_method_same_fields": {
            "ecutwfc": true,
            "smear": true,
            "degauss": true,
            "pseudo_dir": false
          },
          "qmesh_target_control": [
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ]
          ],
          "irreducible_qcount_target_control": [
            [
              4.0
            ],
            [
              4.0
            ]
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "nat": 8,
        "lambda10": [
          1.936,
          1.694,
          1.505,
          1.3557,
          1.2455,
          1.1654,
          1.1059,
          1.0603,
          1.0243,
          0.9951
        ],
        "omega10_K": [
          165.8752,
          167.4332,
          167.7953,
          167.7468,
          167.524,
          167.2772,
          167.0835,
          166.9634,
          166.9081,
          166.8994
        ],
        "Eli_mu01": [
          0.1,
          17.221
        ],
        "McM_mu01": [
          0.1,
          14.457,
          15.605
        ],
        "coarse_fine": [
          {
            "record": 4535,
            "version": [
              "Program PWSCF v.6.8 starts on 28Jul2022 at 20:18: 8"
            ],
            "converged": true,
            "JOBDONE": true,
            "errors": 0,
            "Fmax_eVA": 5.605005354919521e-05,
            "P_GPa": -0.0,
            "maxstress_GPa": 0.0,
            "fulltensor": [
              [
                -0.0,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                -0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                -0.0
              ]
            ],
            "F_Ry": -1748.61179654,
            "E_Ry": -1748.6099154899998,
            "pattern_selected_warning_counts": {
              "BFGS": 1,
              "negative_charge": 0,
              "eigen_text": 0,
              "failure_text": 0,
              "SCF_correction_text": 2
            },
            "warning_scope": "pattern-selected contexts; informational SCF correction and ignored cell card are not optimization failure; no whole-file warning-free claim"
          },
          {
            "record": 4536,
            "version": [
              "Program PWSCF v.6.8 starts on 28Jul2022 at 18:15: 5"
            ],
            "converged": true,
            "JOBDONE": true,
            "errors": 0,
            "Fmax_eVA": 0.022252642590042646,
            "P_GPa": 0.051000000000000004,
            "maxstress_GPa": 0.051000000000000004,
            "fulltensor": [
              [
                0.051000000000000004,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                0.051000000000000004,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                0.051000000000000004
              ]
            ],
            "F_Ry": -1748.61010759,
            "E_Ry": -1748.60778927,
            "pattern_selected_warning_counts": {
              "BFGS": 1,
              "negative_charge": 0,
              "eigen_text": 1,
              "failure_text": 0,
              "SCF_correction_text": 1
            },
            "warning_scope": "pattern-selected contexts; informational SCF correction and ignored cell card are not optimization failure; no whole-file warning-free claim"
          }
        ],
        "inputs": [
          {
            "record": 4525,
            "ecutwfc": [
              122.0
            ],
            "ecutrho": null,
            "pseudo_dir": [
              "[private custody location omitted]"
            ],
            "spin": null,
            "noncol": null,
            "SOC": null,
            "charge": null,
            "smear": [
              "mp"
            ],
            "degauss": [
              0.014699728870262
            ],
            "ibrav": [
              1.0
            ],
            "nat": [
              8.0
            ],
            "grid": [
              "6 6 6 0 0 0"
            ]
          },
          {
            "record": 4526,
            "ecutwfc": [
              122.0
            ],
            "ecutrho": null,
            "pseudo_dir": [
              "[private custody location omitted]"
            ],
            "spin": null,
            "noncol": null,
            "SOC": null,
            "charge": null,
            "smear": [
              "mp"
            ],
            "degauss": [
              0.014699728870262
            ],
            "ibrav": [
              1.0
            ],
            "nat": [
              8.0
            ],
            "grid": [
              "24 24 24 0 0 0"
            ]
          }
        ],
        "Gamma": {
          "nat": 8,
          "ibrav": 1,
          "q": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species": [
            "Ga",
            "Nb",
            "Sb"
          ],
          "optical": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "minopt": 1.0282342388778858e-06,
          "printingbound": 2.0280382133887887e-12,
          "negative_native_modes": [],
          "negativeoutside3": [],
          "min_low3_translation": 0.9985912478985064,
          "sourcepin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/GaNb6Sb_agm003262771",
            "bytes": 31874,
            "sha256": "24d63f185b8255b4973221fd09302628b4cbae44a4ace622b9df003e7306c535"
          }
        },
        "path": {
          "rows": 84,
          "negatives": 0,
          "minimum": -0.0,
          "unit": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-2-compact-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 84096,
          "sha256": "d8ca53bafc5ee0879de647e050127d8e0d20c0e3da10de9602ab2de44bf77532",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-3-five-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 110335,
          "sha256": "861dd76c8368cca687ca20c8468e464badefb533a318ed41c4f8d62dccb6ed50",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-4-three-phase-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 64369,
          "sha256": "56076a077e591b9bdef8ada45d78f224f417a4af8d2e722e332f639eedfafaf7",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all64-light-Nb-rich-owned-review-cache-v2.json",
          "bytes": 4566542,
          "sha256": "f27e8c84c10c4d8de44022f6bd160e7e8aee8b2d562db5fd6003af68d5e35756",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to this reviewed candidate catalogue and mechanism contrast; MC2023 prediction is prior, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003260934",
      "formula": "Nb6PdPt",
      "reduced_formula": "Nb6PdPt",
      "composition": {
        "Nb": 6,
        "Pd": 1,
        "Pt": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Nb:6|Pd:1|Pt:1",
      "elements": [
        "Nb",
        "Pd",
        "Pt"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003260934",
      "control_state": "agm003763536",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Nb6PdPt_agm003260934",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Nb6TaPt_agm003763536",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Pm-3 ordered A15-derived eight-site network with six Nb chain sites and distinct Pd and Pt single-site roles",
      "prototype_evidence": "Pm-3 ordered A15-derived eight-site network with six Nb chain sites and distinct Pd and Pt single-site roles",
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 15.273,
        "control_K": 12.195,
        "delta_K": 3.0779999999999994,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.3366,
          0.4382999999999999,
          0.4364000000000001,
          0.40370000000000006,
          0.3678999999999999,
          0.33919999999999995,
          0.31779999999999997,
          0.3015000000000001,
          0.2881999999999999,
          0.27680000000000005
        ],
        "range": [
          0.27680000000000005,
          0.4382999999999999
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Target Gamma optical compression is positive and sampled path nonnegative. Antisite disorder, A15-chain softening/CDW and Pt SOC are the leading physical competitors; fine Fmax is 0.018999 eV/A. The PtAu control has much higher lambda but an actual negative source path and is retained, rather than silently treated as a stable superior candidate. Changed ecutwfc/PP/code between Ta and Pd remain explicit numerical-model confounds.",
      "ambient_scope": "Both source SCFs converge, near-zero coarse forces/stress and bounded fine response are measured. Fine Fmax=0.018998654 eV/A, P=0.032 GPa, full max stress=0.032 GPa. Gamma optical compression is positive beyond printing bound and sampled path has no signed negative values. All listed q outputs have JOBDONE/last response convergence and no routine errors. This supports a finite-grid local/metastable source model, not global hull or experimental synthesis.",
      "route_response": "Pd replaces Ta on the unique non-Pt cation site while all six Nb and the Pt site retain mapped roles. Volume contracts 2.8275%, Nb-chain nearest distance falls 0.0253916 A and Nb-Pd versus Nb-Ta falls 0.0273996 A. All ten lambda values rise 31.713–43.016%, with separate Eli mu=.1 12.195 to 15.273 K; measured coupled chemistry/chain construction is not pure strain causality.",
      "next_action": "Hold ordered Pd/Ta and Pt roles fixed while matching cutoff/PP, volume and sampling, and compare an antisite or chain distortion competitor. A persistent stable direct coupling gain supports the screen; loss under common numerical controls or a nontranslation soft branch opposes it.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Complete ordered CIF/literal coarse-fine input/Gamma periodic species-site association is numerically supported; source input geometry and full tensor/forces are retained. Export occupancy is a discrete computational convention; source experimental P/T/occupancy and actual compiled unit constant are unknown. Exact-version input defaults scope the configured neutral scalar spin1/noSOC model, not magnetic ground state.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Pd replaces Ta on the unique non-Pt cation site while all six Nb and the Pt site retain mapped roles. Volume contracts 2.8275%, Nb-chain nearest distance falls 0.0253916 A and Nb-Pd versus Nb-Ta falls 0.0273996 A. All ten lambda values rise 31.713–43.016%, with separate Eli mu=.1 12.195 to 15.273 K; measured coupled chemistry/chain construction is not pure strain causality.",
        "pairing_relevance": "Exact target and mapped control direct source lambda arrays have the same favorable sign at all ten common broadening tokens; omega_ln has explicit K units and separate Eli/McM mu=.1 tables remain independent. Same underlying q mesh is observed. The sensitivity range is not a physical error bound; sigma units, full-BZ convergence, experimental Tc and pure-geometry causality remain unknown. Literal method differences are declared confounds.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Both source SCFs converge, near-zero coarse forces/stress and bounded fine response are measured. Fine Fmax=0.018998654 eV/A, P=0.032 GPa, full max stress=0.032 GPa. Gamma optical compression is positive beyond printing bound and sampled path has no signed negative values. All listed q outputs have JOBDONE/last response convergence and no routine errors. This supports a finite-grid local/metastable source model, not global hull or experimental synthesis.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Target Gamma optical compression is positive and sampled path nonnegative. Antisite disorder, A15-chain softening/CDW and Pt SOC are the leading physical competitors; fine Fmax is 0.018999 eV/A. The PtAu control has much higher lambda but an actual negative source path and is retained, rather than silently treated as a stable superior candidate. Changed ecutwfc/PP/code between Ta and Pd remain explicit numerical-model confounds.",
        "novelty": "Experimental Nb3Pt and A15 alloys are known. The exact two-species ordered Nb6PdPt Pm-3 source is not established by binary Nb3Pt or random B-site alloy evidence. The 2026-10-07 exact Nb6PdPt query found no matching experimental superconducting ordered phase; novelty is bounded to this matched ordered-site hypothesis.",
        "decision": "Hold ordered Pd/Ta and Pt roles fixed while matching cutoff/PP, volume and sampling, and compare an antisite or chain distortion competitor. A persistent stable direct coupling gain supports the screen; loss under common numerical controls or a nontranslation soft branch opposes it."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase",
        "sampling_method"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index_zero_based": 218,
          "control_directory": "batch-a/Nb6PtAu_agm003273866",
          "mapping_scope": "bounded ordered isostructural analogue",
          "all_three_symprec_support": true,
          "composition_edit": {
            "from": "Pd",
            "to": "Au",
            "count": 1,
            "kind": "single_site_substitution"
          },
          "volume_target_over_control": 0.9874470636507975,
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_all10": [
            -63.13777191825972,
            -51.817949862856416,
            -47.473028745203095,
            -45.652520740268024,
            -44.64147035982398,
            -43.859406670351945,
            -43.14431735215381,
            -42.465334420880914,
            -41.85171445227623,
            -41.30530004380201
          ],
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_range": [
            -63.13777191825972,
            -41.30530004380201
          ],
          "separate_source_Eli_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              15.273
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              16.212
            ]
          ],
          "separate_source_McM_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              12.968,
              14.154
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              12.003,
              14.04
            ]
          ],
          "literal_method_same_fields": {
            "ecutwfc": true,
            "smear": true,
            "degauss": true,
            "pseudo_dir": true
          },
          "qmesh_target_control": [
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ]
          ],
          "irreducible_qcount_target_control": [
            [
              4.0
            ],
            [
              4.0
            ]
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index_zero_based": 219,
          "control_directory": "batch-a/Nb6TaPt_agm003763536",
          "mapping_scope": "bounded ordered isostructural analogue",
          "all_three_symprec_support": true,
          "composition_edit": {
            "from": "Pd",
            "to": "Ta",
            "count": 1,
            "kind": "single_site_substitution"
          },
          "volume_target_over_control": 0.9717250492792951,
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_all10": [
            31.7128321085359,
            40.87094367773218,
            43.016264169541664,
            42.10032328709981,
            40.198863636363626,
            38.56736782262649,
            37.37504410208162,
            36.45266594124049,
            35.62422744128552,
            34.80885311871228
          ],
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_range": [
            31.7128321085359,
            43.016264169541664
          ],
          "separate_source_Eli_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              15.273
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              12.195
            ]
          ],
          "separate_source_McM_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              12.968,
              14.154
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              10.319,
              10.841
            ]
          ],
          "literal_method_same_fields": {
            "ecutwfc": false,
            "smear": true,
            "degauss": true,
            "pseudo_dir": false
          },
          "qmesh_target_control": [
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ]
          ],
          "irreducible_qcount_target_control": [
            [
              4.0
            ],
            [
              4.0
            ]
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "nat": 8,
        "lambda10": [
          1.398,
          1.5107,
          1.4509,
          1.3626,
          1.2831,
          1.2187,
          1.1681,
          1.1286,
          1.0972,
          1.072
        ],
        "omega10_K": [
          143.1487,
          140.3441,
          140.6091,
          141.2134,
          141.7904,
          142.3332,
          142.8485,
          143.334,
          143.7904,
          144.2218
        ],
        "Eli_mu01": [
          0.1,
          15.273
        ],
        "McM_mu01": [
          0.1,
          12.968,
          14.154
        ],
        "coarse_fine": [
          {
            "record": 6859,
            "version": [
              "Program PWSCF v.6.8 starts on 18Aug2022 at 13:10: 4"
            ],
            "converged": true,
            "JOBDONE": true,
            "errors": 0,
            "Fmax_eVA": 4.885096410250959e-06,
            "P_GPa": -0.002,
            "maxstress_GPa": 0.002,
            "fulltensor": [
              [
                -0.002,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                -0.002,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                -0.002
              ]
            ],
            "F_Ry": -1278.03473344,
            "E_Ry": -1278.03414775,
            "pattern_selected_warning_counts": {
              "BFGS": 1,
              "negative_charge": 0,
              "eigen_text": 0,
              "failure_text": 0,
              "SCF_correction_text": 2
            },
            "warning_scope": "pattern-selected contexts; informational SCF correction and ignored cell card are not optimization failure; no whole-file warning-free claim"
          },
          {
            "record": 6860,
            "version": [
              "Program PWSCF v.6.8 starts on 18Aug2022 at 11:35:26"
            ],
            "converged": true,
            "JOBDONE": true,
            "errors": 0,
            "Fmax_eVA": 0.01899865416014074,
            "P_GPa": 0.032,
            "maxstress_GPa": 0.032,
            "fulltensor": [
              [
                0.032,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                0.032,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                0.032
              ]
            ],
            "F_Ry": -1278.03308913,
            "E_Ry": -1278.03284768,
            "pattern_selected_warning_counts": {
              "BFGS": 1,
              "negative_charge": 0,
              "eigen_text": 13,
              "failure_text": 0,
              "SCF_correction_text": 1
            },
            "warning_scope": "pattern-selected contexts; informational SCF correction and ignored cell card are not optimization failure; no whole-file warning-free claim"
          }
        ],
        "inputs": [
          {
            "record": 6849,
            "ecutwfc": [
              100.0
            ],
            "ecutrho": null,
            "pseudo_dir": [
              "[private custody location omitted]"
            ],
            "spin": null,
            "noncol": null,
            "SOC": null,
            "charge": null,
            "smear": [
              "mp"
            ],
            "degauss": [
              0.014699728870262
            ],
            "ibrav": [
              1.0
            ],
            "nat": [
              8.0
            ],
            "grid": [
              "6 6 6 0 0 0"
            ]
          },
          {
            "record": 6850,
            "ecutwfc": [
              100.0
            ],
            "ecutrho": null,
            "pseudo_dir": [
              "[private custody location omitted]"
            ],
            "spin": null,
            "noncol": null,
            "SOC": null,
            "charge": null,
            "smear": [
              "mp"
            ],
            "degauss": [
              0.014699728870262
            ],
            "ibrav": [
              1.0
            ],
            "nat": [
              8.0
            ],
            "grid": [
              "24 24 24 0 0 0"
            ]
          }
        ],
        "Gamma": {
          "nat": 8,
          "ibrav": 1,
          "q": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species": [
            "Nb",
            "Pd",
            "Pt"
          ],
          "optical": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "minopt": 4.2279712190582507e-07,
          "printingbound": 1.841084802497857e-12,
          "negative_native_modes": [],
          "negativeoutside3": [],
          "min_low3_translation": 0.9999485745755563,
          "sourcepin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/Nb6PdPt_agm003260934",
            "bytes": 31874,
            "sha256": "ce8dd9a8ffd649ec9dc183a30608ac3744dc0a62bb68fd2766009e7aaeeccebe"
          }
        },
        "path": {
          "rows": 85,
          "negatives": 0,
          "minimum": -0.0,
          "unit": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-2-compact-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 84096,
          "sha256": "d8ca53bafc5ee0879de647e050127d8e0d20c0e3da10de9602ab2de44bf77532",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-3-five-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 110335,
          "sha256": "861dd76c8368cca687ca20c8468e464badefb533a318ed41c4f8d62dccb6ed50",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-4-three-phase-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 64369,
          "sha256": "56076a077e591b9bdef8ada45d78f224f417a4af8d2e722e332f639eedfafaf7",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all64-light-Nb-rich-owned-review-cache-v2.json",
          "bytes": 4566542,
          "sha256": "f27e8c84c10c4d8de44022f6bd160e7e8aee8b2d562db5fd6003af68d5e35756",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to this reviewed candidate catalogue and mechanism contrast; MC2023 prediction is prior, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm002713597",
      "formula": "NbMoTc2",
      "reduced_formula": "NbMoTc2",
      "composition": {
        "Mo": 1,
        "Nb": 1,
        "Tc": 2
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Mo:1|Nb:1|Tc:2",
      "elements": [
        "Mo",
        "Nb",
        "Tc"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm002713597",
      "control_state": "agm001397716",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/NbMoTc2_agm002713597",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/NbMoTcRe_agm001397716",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "CIF_source_record": 12641,
        "CIF_payload_pin": {
          "bytes": 591661,
          "sha256": "93c3ce21c362fc36392db6d13f4555d76cce96122769d1212414bbc770f81541"
        },
        "SCF_coarse_source_record": 12657,
        "Gamma_source_pin": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/NbMoTc2_agm002713597",
          "bytes": 8994,
          "sha256": "8bafa63e66e359717db2fd161b82b32169fb58c48551cf46f9d64a6d25267b54"
        },
        "source_input_volume_difference_relative": 7.756595366004149e-11,
        "occupancy_model_all1": true,
        "bounded_signed_axis_and_translation_mapping": {
          "signed_axis_U_CIF_fractional_to_SCF": [
            [
              1,
              0,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              1,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              0,
              1
            ]
          ],
          "determinant": 1,
          "origin_shift_fractional": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species_bijection_CIF_to_SCF": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            3
          ],
          "maximum_site_distance_A": 0,
          "relative_Gram_residual": 1.6393642563380358e-09,
          "proper_signed_axis_solution": true
        },
        "attempts": 1,
        "general_GL3_or_chiral_equivalence_asserted": false,
        "CIF_site_precision_A_tolerance": 1e-05,
        "physical_model": "source finite neutral scalar EPC; no SOC transfer certificate"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 13.542,
        "control_K": 12.171,
        "delta_K": 1.3710000000000004,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.0017999999999999128,
          0.022499999999999964,
          0.030299999999999994,
          0.037699999999999956,
          0.041200000000000014,
          0.04090000000000005,
          0.03959999999999997,
          0.039000000000000035,
          0.03939999999999999,
          0.04080000000000006
        ],
        "range": [
          0.0017999999999999128,
          0.041200000000000014
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Target source lambda gain is small at one token but positive at all ten, and separate isotropic Tc increases by 1.371 K. The effect mixes mass, orbital chemistry and charge redistribution; actual mobile n and orbital bandwidth are unknown. Tc availability/radioactivity is a follow-up cost risk only. All target forces zero, finite source q and Gamma evidence positive.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure 0.002 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure 0.036 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
      "route_response": "Re-to-Tc minority role replacement in Nb-Mo-Tc ordered SG225. coupled chemical/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
      "next_action": "Compare saved orbital/mode and Coulomb-sensitive source evidence for Re/Tc neighbors. Favorable: the fixed-phase response survives physically matched model checks; adverse: the small EPC change reverses and Tc benefit is solely assumed mu; ambiguous: only nominal electrons available.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact source CIF/SCF/Γ state association; CIF source record 12641. Experimental occupancy/P/T and physical magnetic ground state remain unknown; source scalar model only.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Re-to-Tc minority role replacement in Nb-Mo-Tc ordered SG225. coupled chemical/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
        "pairing_relevance": "direct published source EPC and independent source isotropic Eliashberg result. 1 favorable comparator(s); bounded source model, not experiment.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure 0.002 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure 0.036 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Target source lambda gain is small at one token but positive at all ten, and separate isotropic Tc increases by 1.371 K. The effect mixes mass, orbital chemistry and charge redistribution; actual mobile n and orbital bandwidth are unknown. Tc availability/radioactivity is a follow-up cost risk only. All target forces zero, finite source q and Gamma evidence positive.",
        "novelty": "Exact NbMoTc2 query found no primary experimental exact ordered phase. Closest retrieved primary Tc alloy study examines binary phases and unknown experimental Tc chemistry, not this ternary source SG225 object. No independent experimental validation or global novelty is implied.",
        "decision": "Compare saved orbital/mode and Coulomb-sensitive source evidence for Re/Tc neighbors. Favorable: the fixed-phase response survives physically matched model checks; adverse: the small EPC change reverses and Tc benefit is solely assumed mu; ambiguous: only nominal electrons available."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "residual_force_stress",
        "technetium"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 227,
          "control": "batch-a/NbMoTcRe_agm001397716",
          "target": "batch-a/NbMoTc2_agm002713597",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.0017999999999999128,
            0.041200000000000014
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            0.20118475466635885,
            5.4025423728813635
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 13.542,
          "Tc_control_K": 12.171,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 1.3710000000000004,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9918315518209998,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.5429028962323255e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.0017999999999999128,
            0.041200000000000014
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-01-ten-specific-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 381754,
          "sha256": "5d05478212c4d22080ab1b7bf22d92b784de6c0f8a99590d0758f9cdbfdafb32",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-remaining-transition-owned-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 5381838,
          "sha256": "62f4910578c7b65392d26619cf81b31afd6142f38aa49834a70bb147e7ab222d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to the reviewed candidate mechanism catalogue, source prediction already published; not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001828806",
      "formula": "NbTa3",
      "reduced_formula": "NbTa3",
      "composition": {
        "Nb": 1,
        "Ta": 3
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Nb:1|Ta:3",
      "elements": [
        "Nb",
        "Ta"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001828806",
      "control_state": "agm001416090",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/NbTa3_agm001828806",
      "control_directory": null,
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "ordered tetragonal four-site network versus equal60-degree primitive cation order",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "motif": "ordered tetragonal four-site network versus equal60-degree primitive cation order",
        "verified_space_group": null,
        "role": "A versus samecomposition B",
        "known_prior_scope": "Primary Nb-rich Nb-Ta superconducting alloys and published theoretical source states are known; no exact ordered25Nb75Ta experimental benchmark identified by the bounded primary query."
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 12.871,
        "control_K": 12.235,
        "delta_K": 0.636000000000001,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.08379999999999999,
          0.07820000000000005,
          0.06709999999999994,
          0.056599999999999984,
          0.049100000000000144,
          0.04369999999999996,
          0.03969999999999996,
          0.03660000000000008,
          0.03420000000000001,
          0.032299999999999995
        ],
        "range": [
          0.032299999999999995,
          0.08379999999999999
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Small source Eli Tc gain12.871 versus12.235K; all ten lambda contrasts positive but q3x3x5 versus4^3. Coarse/fine phase-energy preference flips at sub-meV fine scale; assess as near-degenerate phase response, not global ground state. Evaluated risks define a falsifiable bounded hypothesis, not an established bulk ground state or experimental coherence proof.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source nearambient fullstress/pressure and coarse-relaxed geometry, positive raw-Gamma optical compression beyond printing bounds, and no negative printed finite-path values support preliminary local feasibility only within the declared source approximation. WholeBZ/global hull/synthesis remain unknown.",
      "route_response": "Unique Nb periodic distance3.28156452 versus4.63614381A, while volumes differ only0.02134%; this is a colored ordering contrast, not a basis alias. Computed source EPC response is associated with construction; pure geometry-only causality and converged numerical uplift are unproved.",
      "next_action": "Match reciprocal-grid density/code and test whether the phase/EPC ordering survives; retain all ten source sigma points and competing phase.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact reduced composition and non-alias decorated ordered network linked to canonical SCF input and source PH/Gamma/model evidence; source positions bind Gamma within printing/operational tolerances. Nb same-species permutation and Zr scalar parity reflection are explicit. Experimental phase/state remains unknown.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Unique Nb periodic distance3.28156452 versus4.63614381A, while volumes differ only0.02134%; this is a colored ordering contrast, not a basis alias. Computed source EPC response is associated with construction; pure geometry-only causality and converged numerical uplift are unproved.",
        "pairing_relevance": "Direct source lambda at ten common printed width tokens and independently retained mu*=0.1 Eliashberg Tc rows provide state-specific pairing relevance. Width units and Tc-to-width link remain unknown; no parent-property transfer or300K claim.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source nearambient fullstress/pressure and coarse-relaxed geometry, positive raw-Gamma optical compression beyond printing bounds, and no negative printed finite-path values support preliminary local feasibility only within the declared source approximation. WholeBZ/global hull/synthesis remain unknown.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Small source Eli Tc gain12.871 versus12.235K; all ten lambda contrasts positive but q3x3x5 versus4^3. Coarse/fine phase-energy preference flips at sub-meV fine scale; assess as near-degenerate phase response, not global ground state. Evaluated risks define a falsifiable bounded hypothesis, not an established bulk ground state or experimental coherence proof.",
        "novelty": "Primary Nb-rich Nb-Ta superconducting alloys and published theoretical source states are known; no exact ordered25Nb75Ta experimental benchmark identified by the bounded primary query. Default one exact-composition group, with all source/control variants underneath.",
        "decision": "Match reciprocal-grid density/code and test whether the phase/EPC ordering survives; retain all ten source sigma points and competing phase. All seven minima support grade3 preliminary source-model screening; retained model-dependent uncertainty prevents grade4/formal publication."
      },
      "risk_tags": [],
      "countercontrols": [],
      "physical_summary": {
        "target": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/NbTa3_agm001828806",
          "site_composition_matches_name": true,
          "site_count": 4,
          "volume_per_site_A3": 17.611771159680746,
          "source_fine_pressure_GPa": -0.146,
          "source_fine_maxstress_GPa": 0.331,
          "source_fine_maxforce_eV_A": 0.0,
          "fine_JOB_DONE": true,
          "fine_convergence": true,
          "path_min_signed_printed_value": -0.0,
          "path_units_not_inferred": null,
          "path_signed_negative_printed_count": 0,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        },
        "control": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/NbTa3_agm001416090",
          "site_composition_matches_name": true,
          "site_count": 4,
          "volume_per_site_A3": 17.615529737243975,
          "source_fine_pressure_GPa": -0.177,
          "source_fine_maxstress_GPa": 0.177,
          "source_fine_maxforce_eV_A": 0.0,
          "fine_JOB_DONE": true,
          "fine_convergence": true,
          "path_min_signed_printed_value": -0.0,
          "path_units_not_inferred": null,
          "path_signed_negative_printed_count": 0,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-owned-five-pairs-scientific-workingview.json",
          "bytes": 933925,
          "sha256": "0a5d3b507b305b8991218157264276e898799837932a8050942ecf74ee389034",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-captured-five-pairs-method-slices.json",
          "bytes": 1387111,
          "sha256": "d84758cc1e54d79e08e01fe3b08b96dfa071953b16a488b0aef3a867ff30c147",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "CASE.md",
          "bytes": 12162,
          "sha256": "b8b3a4d931a852d21b4343c2fa718235137d41d3218d5ab2e5251c38f428cd1c",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "receipt.json",
          "bytes": 4813,
          "sha256": "f00c9787a8f7af8c076d8dcdac1f23f36fc8e4339b697329a37143ca618bc11a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "SMEARING-CORRECTION.json",
          "bytes": 8933,
          "sha256": "137158d36dfd25524acf4bcd7df583f59bfdcbb477172a790e49788eeb232b13",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-NbTa3-TiMoTa2-existing-source-coordinate-association-v1.json",
          "bytes": 28460,
          "sha256": "6d6e76e4b325dc2579db1d707675a68ba3cea1e9b3eb4bb0800d081d31d0883b",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-NbTa3-canonical-input-translation-association-addendum-v1.json",
          "bytes": 1493,
          "sha256": "04af0ae1799ff1c446c26909c80705394f2f21d1a9288e476eec7d41ca9f7725",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "new-to-reviewed-catalogue ordered source-model route hypothesis; literature-derived, not first discovery",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003636382",
      "formula": "ScMoC2",
      "reduced_formula": "ScMoC2",
      "composition": {
        "C": 2,
        "Mo": 1,
        "Sc": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "C:2|Mo:1|Sc:1",
      "elements": [
        "C",
        "Mo",
        "Sc"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003636382",
      "control_state": "agm003636380",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/C2ScMo_agm003636382",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/C2ScW_agm003636380",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "R-3m four-site alternating Sc-C-Mo-C layered carbide; Sc and Mo have distinct single-site roles and C has a two-site orbit",
      "prototype_evidence": "R-3m four-site alternating Sc-C-Mo-C layered carbide; Sc and Mo have distinct single-site roles and C has a two-site orbit",
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 15.678,
        "control_K": 11.083,
        "delta_K": 4.595000000000001,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.08650000000000002,
          0.10529999999999995,
          0.10329999999999995,
          0.09670000000000001,
          0.08950000000000002,
          0.0826,
          0.07669999999999999,
          0.07230000000000003,
          0.06979999999999997,
          0.0695
        ],
        "range": [
          0.0695,
          0.10529999999999995
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "The original 2023 primary study associates appreciable coupling with an acoustic softening along Gamma-X and places predicted ScMoC2 49 meV/atom above its hull. This is a metastable research route, not equilibrium synthesis certification. Its later exact-source path has no signed negative printed modes and Gamma optical compression is positive; fine force .00823 eV/A and anisotropic stress .363 GPa remain finite-grid stationarity limits.",
      "ambient_scope": "Coarse/fine SCF both converge; complete source forces/stress, positive Gamma optical compression and no signed negative finite-path value support this model near ambient. All listed q outputs end JOBDONE/response convergence with zero routine errors. This is finite-grid local/metastable evidence, not exhaustive thermodynamic or all-irrep certification.",
      "route_response": "Replace W by Mo in the frozen ScWC2 analogue. Volume changes −0.342810%, Sc-C nearest distance −0.00476510 A and C-C +0.00726968 A. The same 4x4x4 PH grid with 13 q representatives yields all-ten lambda gains 10.495–13.659%; separate Eli mu=.1 increases 11.083→15.678 K. Tiny geometry changes accompany a chemically different metal response, so this is a coupled cation-construction hypothesis, not a geometry-only strain mechanism.",
      "next_action": "Test one common-grid acoustic Gamma-X/q-mode response in ScWC2 and ScMoC2, or an equal-volume composition cross-control. Favorable: the bounded Mo advantage persists with finite positive curvature; adverse: stronger softening turns the branch unstable or a competing decomposition route reverses near-ambient feasibility.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Raw CIF, literal coarse/fine crystal input and Gamma header agree by complete ordered species/site periodic association; exact natural-isotope discrete computational occupancy is export convention, experimental occupancy/P/T unknown. Source model configured neutral scalar spin1/noSOC by exact-version defaults plus literal omission; magnetic ground state and binary build not certified.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Replace W by Mo in the frozen ScWC2 analogue. Volume changes −0.342810%, Sc-C nearest distance −0.00476510 A and C-C +0.00726968 A. The same 4x4x4 PH grid with 13 q representatives yields all-ten lambda gains 10.495–13.659%; separate Eli mu=.1 increases 11.083→15.678 K. Tiny geometry changes accompany a chemically different metal response, so this is a coupled cation-construction hypothesis, not a geometry-only strain mechanism.",
        "pairing_relevance": "Direct exact-source lambda has the favorable sign at all ten matched sigma tokens, independently accompanied by the separate mu=.1 Eli table. Finite-grid broadening sensitivity is preserved; differing PP/cutoff/version are model confounds where shown. Sigma units, physical error bar, fullBZ convergence and experimental Tc remain unknown.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Coarse/fine SCF both converge; complete source forces/stress, positive Gamma optical compression and no signed negative finite-path value support this model near ambient. All listed q outputs end JOBDONE/response convergence with zero routine errors. This is finite-grid local/metastable evidence, not exhaustive thermodynamic or all-irrep certification.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "The original 2023 primary study associates appreciable coupling with an acoustic softening along Gamma-X and places predicted ScMoC2 49 meV/atom above its hull. This is a metastable research route, not equilibrium synthesis certification. Its later exact-source path has no signed negative printed modes and Gamma optical compression is positive; fine force .00823 eV/A and anisotropic stress .363 GPa remain finite-grid stationarity limits.",
        "novelty": "ScMoC2 was already predicted in the 2023 institutional primary paper (SG166); no first-discovery claim. A dated exact ScMoC2 superconductivity search found that prediction, not an experimental SC benchmark. The exact source phase and new matched W→Mo mechanism define the reviewed-catalogue candidate. The old paper hull/elastic calculation is separate-method supporting prior and is not silently assigned as a new exact-state measurement.",
        "decision": "Test one common-grid acoustic Gamma-X/q-mode response in ScWC2 and ScMoC2, or an equal-volume composition cross-control. Favorable: the bounded Mo advantage persists with finite positive curvature; adverse: stronger softening turns the branch unstable or a competing decomposition route reverses near-ambient feasibility."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase",
        "residual_force_stress",
        "sampling_method"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [],
      "physical_summary": {
        "nat": 4,
        "lambda10": [
          0.858,
          0.8762,
          0.8681,
          0.8473,
          0.8217,
          0.7958,
          0.7721,
          0.7516,
          0.7349,
          0.7226
        ],
        "omega10_K": [
          318.8573,
          314.1111,
          312.9065,
          312.2653,
          311.8595,
          311.5572,
          311.2387,
          310.8055,
          310.1601,
          309.22
        ],
        "Eli_mu01": [
          0.1,
          15.678
        ],
        "McM_mu01": [
          0.1,
          14.513,
          15.287
        ],
        "coarse_fine": [
          {
            "record": 5093,
            "version": [
              "Program PWSCF v.7.0 starts on 14Jun2022 at  0:59:30"
            ],
            "converged": true,
            "JOBDONE": true,
            "errors": 0,
            "Fmax_eVA": 1.4398178893371249e-05,
            "P_GPa": -0.0,
            "maxstress_GPa": 0.0,
            "fulltensor": [
              [
                -0.0,
                0.0,
                -0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                -0.0,
                -0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                -0.0,
                -0.0
              ]
            ],
            "pattern_selected_warning_counts": {
              "BFGS": 1,
              "negative_charge": 0,
              "eigen_text": 4,
              "failure_text": 0,
              "SCF_correction_text": 2
            }
          },
          {
            "record": 5094,
            "version": [
              "Program PWSCF v.7.0 starts on 13Jun2022 at 23:22:37"
            ],
            "converged": true,
            "JOBDONE": true,
            "errors": 0,
            "Fmax_eVA": 0.00822727368587476,
            "P_GPa": 0.003,
            "maxstress_GPa": 0.363,
            "fulltensor": [
              [
                0.186,
                0.0,
                -0.0
              ],
              [
                -0.0,
                0.186,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                -0.363
              ]
            ],
            "pattern_selected_warning_counts": {
              "BFGS": 1,
              "negative_charge": 0,
              "eigen_text": 90,
              "failure_text": 0,
              "SCF_correction_text": 1
            }
          }
        ],
        "Gamma": {
          "nat": 4,
          "ibrav": 5,
          "q": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species": [
            "C",
            "Mo",
            "Sc"
          ],
          "optical": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "minopt": 2.40102934142016e-06,
          "printingbound": 4.635895439396663e-12,
          "negative_native_modes": [
            1,
            2
          ],
          "negativeoutside3": [],
          "min_low3_translation": 0.9999908729169358,
          "sourcepin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/C2ScMo_agm003636382",
            "bytes": 9000,
            "sha256": "77787ba207dd14490849ce717c7ee766b8dd3725d31b24993bebeb0d1502ef93"
          }
        },
        "path": {
          "rows": 41,
          "negatives": 0,
          "minimum": -0.0,
          "unit": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-1-compact-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 34933,
          "sha256": "c27b3f0105c6f12aa51f2d0801a476adfacdc6cac93b8dd5b60cd485d18cd4f2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-four-tranche-eight-source-states-independent-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 267678,
          "sha256": "857ce54f337154bb41cfa9e21370ab305f2bd35f31ab86c37fcd0ba8de21a391",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to this reviewed candidate catalogue and mechanism contrast; MC2023 prediction is prior, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003198926",
      "formula": "ScTc2",
      "reduced_formula": "ScTc2",
      "composition": {
        "Sc": 1,
        "Tc": 2
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Sc:1|Tc:2",
      "elements": [
        "Sc",
        "Tc"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003198926",
      "control_state": "agm002184779",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/ScTc2_agm003198926",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/ScRu2_agm002184779",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "CIF_source_record": 9443,
        "CIF_payload_pin": {
          "bytes": 591661,
          "sha256": "93c3ce21c362fc36392db6d13f4555d76cce96122769d1212414bbc770f81541"
        },
        "SCF_coarse_source_record": 9455,
        "Gamma_source_pin": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/ScTc2_agm003198926",
          "bytes": 18568,
          "sha256": "ff90c3b83197c44e61a02a461caa1f053e059ea820c5a42054e09c8b9838ef6a"
        },
        "source_input_volume_difference_relative": -2.264133325269313e-11,
        "occupancy_model_all1": true,
        "bounded_signed_axis_and_translation_mapping": {
          "signed_axis_U_CIF_fractional_to_SCF": [
            [
              1,
              0,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              1,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              0,
              1
            ]
          ],
          "determinant": 1,
          "origin_shift_fractional": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species_bijection_CIF_to_SCF": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            3,
            4,
            5
          ],
          "maximum_site_distance_A": 5.6617485970997366e-08,
          "relative_Gram_residual": 8.673160546801638e-10,
          "proper_signed_axis_solution": true
        },
        "attempts": 1,
        "general_GL3_or_chiral_equivalence_asserted": false,
        "CIF_site_precision_A_tolerance": 1e-05,
        "physical_model": "source finite neutral scalar EPC; no SOC transfer certificate"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 14.29,
        "control_K": 13.115,
        "delta_K": 1.174999999999999,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.368,
          0.43200000000000005,
          0.3878999999999999,
          0.3023000000000001,
          0.22909999999999986,
          0.17920000000000014,
          0.14939999999999987,
          0.13349999999999995,
          0.126,
          0.12280000000000002
        ],
        "range": [
          0.12280000000000002,
          0.43200000000000005
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "ScRu2→ScTc2 has +.1228…+.4320 lambda and sourceTc+1.175 K, path0, force0 and stress .290 GPa. Hf/Zr/Lu/ternary neighbors usually beat target and stay visible. Tc radioactivity and C14/C15 competition bound the sourceC15 local candidate.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure 0.001 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.29 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
      "route_response": "Ru-to-Tc role substitution in C15 ScX2. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
      "next_action": "Resolve exact priorphase and saved ScRu2/Tc2 mode differences. Favorable: distinct C15 local phase with preserved controlled response; adverse: exact alias benchmark or phase conversion; ambiguous: prior structure incomplete.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact source CIF/SCF/Γ state association; CIF source record 9443. Experimental occupancy/P/T and physical magnetic ground state remain unknown; source scalar model only.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Ru-to-Tc role substitution in C15 ScX2. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
        "pairing_relevance": "direct published source EPC plus independent source isotropic Eliashberg result.  favorable comparator(s); bounded source model, not experiment.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure 0.001 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.29 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "ScRu2→ScTc2 has +.1228…+.4320 lambda and sourceTc+1.175 K, path0, force0 and stress .290 GPa. Hf/Zr/Lu/ternary neighbors usually beat target and stay visible. Tc radioactivity and C14/C15 competition bound the sourceC15 local candidate.",
        "novelty": "ScTc2 superconducting Laves composition is known in1981; primarybinaryphase table identifies experimentalScTc2C14, while this source phase isSG227C15. Sourcecomputedproposal alreadyknown, only new to reviewed catalogue.",
        "decision": "Resolve exact priorphase and saved ScRu2/Tc2 mode differences. Favorable: distinct C15 local phase with preserved controlled response; adverse: exact alias benchmark or phase conversion; ambiguous: prior structure incomplete."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase",
        "residual_force_stress",
        "technetium"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 237,
          "control": "batch-a/ScRu2_agm002184779",
          "target": "batch-a/ScTc2_agm003198926",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.12280000000000002,
            0.43200000000000005
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            13.479692645444567,
            52.83111165464107
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 14.29,
          "Tc_control_K": 13.115,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 1.174999999999999,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.0390009972103011,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 4.4573319101011896e-07,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm002184779",
            "dyn0_source_record": 13047,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 13054,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 13055,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 13056,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 13057,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.12280000000000002,
            0.43200000000000005
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 239,
          "control": "batch-a/ScTc4Hf_agm001184600",
          "target": "batch-a/ScTc2_agm003198926",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.26890000000000014,
            -0.04390000000000005
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -17.420316144078786,
            -4.0734898394729555
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 14.29,
          "Tc_control_K": 16.724,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": -2.434000000000001,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": true,
          "three_tol_graph": false,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.0024706885192267,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.2218852735181743e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001184600",
            "dyn0_source_record": 5565,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 5572,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 5573,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 5574,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": false,
                "routine_error_count": 3,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 5575,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.26890000000000014,
            -0.04390000000000005
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 240,
          "control": "batch-a/ScTc4Lu_agm001184602",
          "target": "batch-a/ScTc2_agm003198926",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.18359999999999999,
            -0.12339999999999995
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -12.59000205718988,
            -10.663670929830623
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 14.29,
          "Tc_control_K": 14.407,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": -0.11700000000000088,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": true,
          "three_tol_graph": false,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9753171837274083,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.033298623315104e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001184602",
            "dyn0_source_record": 9033,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 9040,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 9041,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 9042,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 9043,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.18359999999999999,
            -0.12339999999999995
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 241,
          "control": "batch-a/ScYTc4_agm003199982",
          "target": "batch-a/ScTc2_agm003198926",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -1.5043,
            -1.0241
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -54.13098236775819,
            -49.76432285339423
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 14.29,
          "Tc_control_K": 16.894,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": -2.603999999999999,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": true,
          "three_tol_graph": false,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.956250550422108,
          "control_path_negatives": 3,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 8.896586838363715e-07,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 3,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.8474,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003199982",
            "dyn0_source_record": 6315,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 6322,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 6323,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 6324,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 6325,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -1.5043,
            -1.0241
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 242,
          "control": "batch-a/ScZrTc4_agm003195954",
          "target": "batch-a/ScTc2_agm003198926",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.8726,
            -0.3575999999999999
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -40.637079122619106,
            -25.700733074601114
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 14.29,
          "Tc_control_K": 18.415,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": -4.125,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": true,
          "three_tol_graph": false,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9949589798475522,
          "control_path_negatives": 14,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.3988466370001736e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 14,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -5.2679,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003195954",
            "dyn0_source_record": 3701,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 3708,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 3709,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 3710,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 3711,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.8726,
            -0.3575999999999999
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 243,
          "control": "batch-a/Tc2Hf_agm001631318",
          "target": "batch-a/ScTc2_agm003198926",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.16660000000000008,
            -0.0039000000000000146
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -11.55900922778048,
            -0.3758311650766131
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 14.29,
          "Tc_control_K": 16.968,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": -2.678000000000001,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": true,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.0031478669522753,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.2231348741446305e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": 0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001631318",
            "dyn0_source_record": 4785,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 4792,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 4793,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": false,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 4794,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 4795,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.16660000000000008,
            -0.0039000000000000146
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 244,
          "control": "batch-a/Tc2Lu_agm001631328",
          "target": "batch-a/ScTc2_agm003198926",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -1.0545000000000002,
            -0.7438
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -45.2730551262236,
            -41.84293429342934
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 14.29,
          "Tc_control_K": 15.43,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": -1.1400000000000006,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": true,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9521715924942611,
          "control_path_negatives": 6,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.0260953212887805e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 6,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -2.6365,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001631328",
            "dyn0_source_record": 8253,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 8260,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 8261,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 8262,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 8263,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -1.0545000000000002,
            -0.7438
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 245,
          "control": "batch-a/ZrTc2_agm003203155",
          "target": "batch-a/ScTc2_agm003198926",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.6544000000000001,
            -0.28
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -33.92255455912084,
            -21.312224082813216
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 14.29,
          "Tc_control_K": 20.576,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": -6.286000000000001,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": true,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9887828406868778,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.4596680273831718e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003203155",
            "dyn0_source_record": 2197,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 2204,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 2205,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 2206,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 2207,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.6544000000000001,
            -0.28
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-02-eleven-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1219201,
          "sha256": "ee658cb8e6309178e268b736f8aeb6429c030a92019c068963e2d64ca51cbb17",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-03-fifteen-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1347056,
          "sha256": "1be9342cb74006b2542e9351fc2de310967f1a31a5ee9f1909ae730b9a11476a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-remaining-transition-owned-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 5381838,
          "sha256": "62f4910578c7b65392d26619cf81b31afd6142f38aa49834a70bb147e7ab222d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to the reviewed candidate mechanism catalogue, source prediction already published; not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003158378",
      "formula": "ScZr2",
      "reduced_formula": "ScZr2",
      "composition": {
        "Sc": 1,
        "Zr": 2
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Sc:1|Zr:2",
      "elements": [
        "Sc",
        "Zr"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003158378",
      "control_state": "agm003158379",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/ScZr2_agm003158378",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/ScZr2_agm003158379",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": null,
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 13.91,
        "control_K": 13.444,
        "delta_K": 0.4659999999999993,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          -0.15250000000000008,
          -0.10880000000000001,
          -0.09000000000000008,
          -0.08050000000000002,
          -0.07499999999999996,
          -0.07319999999999993,
          -0.0737000000000001,
          -0.07519999999999993,
          -0.07630000000000003,
          -0.07679999999999998
        ],
        "range": [
          -0.15250000000000008,
          -0.07319999999999993
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": [
        1.320183372174656,
        1.2814722300104502,
        1.2555035287488723,
        1.2340857241981098,
        1.2190005859356405,
        1.2096963791316722,
        1.2040505722332075,
        1.2001940944706995,
        1.1969850438308682,
        1.1939222731745418
      ],
      "risk_summary": "The fine target force norm is 0.04820 eV/Å, full stress 0.307 GPa, and fine F is 2.316 meV/atom above B. Hexagonal Zr–Sc alloys were experimentally nonsuperconducting in 1.1–4.2 K; that is a genuine contrary benchmark, not proof about these distinct ordered states.",
      "ambient_scope": "Exact model force/full stress, converged electronic outputs, reported finite-q workflow and raw Γ optical evidence provide a bounded near-ambient source-model screen. Source residual stress/metastable alternatives remain explicit; this is not proof of synthesizeability, full BZ or global equilibrium.",
      "route_response": "Layered hexagonal A has LOWER λ in every row than tetragonal B, but its ω_log is larger in all rows and every separate fixed-μ Tc product favors A: Eliashberg +0.466 K, McMillan +0.598 K, Allen–Dynes +0.537 K. This supports a phonon-frequency/coherence tradeoff hypothesis. Complete species-channel geometry differences and computed all-σ pairing response are saved against the frozen controls. Cell/grid/method sensitivity prevents a pure geometry-only causal claim; no bandwidth/carrier quantity is substituted.",
      "next_action": "Compare the ordered layered versus tetragonal geometry at converged exact cells, then test order/disorder and the known hexagonal alloy reference. If the ω advantage is a residual-force artifact or the exact ordered phase behaves like the reference, the benefit is adverse.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Source-specific full-species CIF→both SCF inputs→Γ coordinate/cell association, actual atom order and origin, within 1e-6 Å observational matching policy. Original experimental occupancy and measured P/T unknown; configured QE neutral/nonmagnetic/no-SOC model is distinct from a magnetic ground-state claim.",
        "novelty": "One exact reduced composition/ordered phase-design group, new to the frozen reviewed cohort. Published computed source is acknowledged, known experimental chemistry remains a comparator. Bounded primary phase search has not tied the exact target order to an established SC sample; no global absence claim.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Layered hexagonal A has LOWER λ in every row than tetragonal B, but its ω_log is larger in all rows and every separate fixed-μ Tc product favors A: Eliashberg +0.466 K, McMillan +0.598 K, Allen–Dynes +0.537 K. This supports a phonon-frequency/coherence tradeoff hypothesis. Complete species-channel geometry differences and computed all-σ pairing response are saved against the frozen controls. Cell/grid/method sensitivity prevents a pure geometry-only causal claim; no bandwidth/carrier quantity is substituted.",
        "pairing_relevance": "All ten source λ/ω rows retained with original units/nulls, and μ*=0.1 source McMillan, Allen–Dynes and Eliashberg products kept separate. Source Gaussian EPC broadening is distinct from explicit MP electronic SCF smearing. No product maximum or selected σ defines the recommendation.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Exact model force/full stress, converged electronic outputs, reported finite-q workflow and raw Γ optical evidence provide a bounded near-ambient source-model screen. Source residual stress/metastable alternatives remain explicit; this is not proof of synthesizeability, full BZ or global equilibrium.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "The fine target force norm is 0.04820 eV/Å, full stress 0.307 GPa, and fine F is 2.316 meV/atom above B. Hexagonal Zr–Sc alloys were experimentally nonsuperconducting in 1.1–4.2 K; that is a genuine contrary benchmark, not proof about these distinct ordered states.",
        "decision": "Compare the ordered layered versus tetragonal geometry at converged exact cells, then test order/disorder and the known hexagonal alloy reference. If the ω advantage is a residual-force artifact or the exact ordered phase behaves like the reference, the benefit is adverse."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "residual_force_stress"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "control_directory": "batch-a/ScZr2_agm003158379",
          "lambda_target_minus_control_all10": [
            -0.15250000000000008,
            -0.10880000000000001,
            -0.09000000000000008,
            -0.08050000000000002,
            -0.07499999999999996,
            -0.07319999999999993,
            -0.0737000000000001,
            -0.07519999999999993,
            -0.07630000000000003,
            -0.07679999999999998
          ],
          "omega_log_target_over_control_all10": [
            1.320183372174656,
            1.2814722300104502,
            1.2555035287488723,
            1.2340857241981098,
            1.2190005859356405,
            1.2096963791316722,
            1.2040505722332075,
            1.2001940944706995,
            1.1969850438308682,
            1.1939222731745418
          ],
          "source_Eli_mu01_target_control_K": [
            13.91,
            13.444
          ],
          "separate_Eli_target_minus_control_K": 0.4659999999999993,
          "target_control_q_mesh_match": false,
          "target_control_q_meshes": [
            [
              5.0,
              5.0,
              2.0
            ],
            [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ]
          ],
          "q_comparison_scope": "Different cells can have different configured physical sampling. Actual meshes retained as confounds; source-paired products do not establish convergence or isolated geometry causality.",
          "original_frozen_pair": {
            "original_contrast_index": 64,
            "composition": {
              "Sc": 1,
              "Zr": 2
            },
            "fixed_A": "batch-a/ScZr2_agm003158378",
            "fixed_B": "batch-a/ScZr2_agm003158379",
            "lambda_B_minus_A_all10": [
              0.15250000000000008,
              0.10880000000000001,
              0.09000000000000008,
              0.08050000000000002,
              0.07499999999999996,
              0.07319999999999993,
              0.0737000000000001,
              0.07519999999999993,
              0.07630000000000003,
              0.07679999999999998
            ],
            "lambda_direction": "B",
            "separate_Eli_A_B_K": [
              13.91,
              13.444
            ],
            "separate_Eli_B_minus_A_K": -0.4659999999999993
          },
          "control_source_q_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003158379",
            "dyn0_source_record": 11666,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 11673,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 11,
                "source_record": 11674,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 12,
                "source_record": 11675,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 13,
                "source_record": 11676,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 11677,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 11678,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 11679,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 11680,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 11681,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 11682,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 11683,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 11684,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 11685,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.15250000000000008,
            -0.07319999999999993
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "SCF_stages": {
          "scf_coarse.out.bz2": {
            "source_record": 10105,
            "explicit_program_start_headers": [
              {
                "value": "Program PWSCF v.6.8 starts on 13May2023 at 10:12:55"
              }
            ],
            "last_printed_convergence_event": {
              "value": true,
              "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
            },
            "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
            "routine_error_count": 0,
            "warning_patterns": {
              "pattern_selected_count": 6,
              "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
              "BFGS": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
                }
              },
              "negative_charge": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "eigen_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "failure_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "SCF_correction_text": {
                "count": 2,
                "last": {
                  "value": "SCF correction compared to forces is large: reduce conv_thr to get better values"
                }
              }
            },
            "last_force": {
              "header": {
                "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
              },
              "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "printed_site_rows": 3,
              "ordered_atom_indices": [
                1,
                2,
                3
              ],
              "reported_max_abs_component": {
                "value": 1.42e-06,
                "unit": "Ry/bohr",
                "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
              },
              "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 1.42e-06,
              "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 1.42e-06,
              "max_component_eV_A": 3.650966790819138e-05,
              "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 3.650966790819138e-05,
              "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
              "conversion_constants": {
                "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
                "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
              },
              "unit_conversion_valid": true,
              "max_norm_site": {
                "value": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  1.42e-06
                ],
                "atom_index": 1,
                "type_index": 2
              },
              "reported_component_agrees": true
            },
            "last_stress": {
              "last_pressure_print": {
                "value": -0.0,
                "unit": "kbar",
                "raw_value": "-0.00",
                "GPa": -0.0
              },
              "last_stress_block": {
                "header": {
                  "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.00"
                },
                "complete_3x6": true,
                "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
                "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
                "rows": [
                  {
                    "value": [
                      -1e-08,
                      0.0,
                      -0.0,
                      -0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      -1e-08,
                      -0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -0.0,
                      -0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      2e-08,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  }
                ],
                "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                  [
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                ],
                "trace_mean_kbar": 0.0,
                "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.0,
                "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
              }
            },
            "last_total_energy_print": {
              "value": -299.03157165,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-299.03157165"
            },
            "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
              "value": -2.635e-05,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-0.00002635"
            },
            "native_exit_status": null,
            "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
            "PH_all_irreps_complete": null,
            "fullBZ_dynamical_stability": null,
            "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -299.0315453
          },
          "scf_fine.out.bz2": {
            "source_record": 10106,
            "explicit_program_start_headers": [
              {
                "value": "Program PWSCF v.6.8 starts on 13May2023 at 10: 9:24"
              }
            ],
            "last_printed_convergence_event": {
              "value": true,
              "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
            },
            "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
            "routine_error_count": 0,
            "warning_patterns": {
              "pattern_selected_count": 31,
              "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
              "BFGS": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
                }
              },
              "negative_charge": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "eigen_text": {
                "count": 26,
                "last": {
                  "value": "c_bands:  2 eigenvalues not converged"
                }
              },
              "failure_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "SCF_correction_text": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Total force =     0.002651     Total SCF correction =     0.000001"
                }
              }
            },
            "last_force": {
              "header": {
                "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
              },
              "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "printed_site_rows": 3,
              "ordered_atom_indices": [
                1,
                2,
                3
              ],
              "reported_max_abs_component": {
                "value": 0.00187469,
                "unit": "Ry/bohr",
                "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
              },
              "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.00187469,
              "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.00187469,
              "max_component_eV_A": 0.04820021783859669,
              "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.04820021783859669,
              "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
              "conversion_constants": {
                "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
                "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
              },
              "unit_conversion_valid": true,
              "max_norm_site": {
                "value": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00187469
                ],
                "atom_index": 1,
                "type_index": 2
              },
              "reported_component_agrees": true
            },
            "last_stress": {
              "last_pressure_print": {
                "value": 0.2,
                "unit": "kbar",
                "raw_value": "0.20",
                "GPa": 0.02
              },
              "last_stress_block": {
                "header": {
                  "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=        0.20"
                },
                "complete_3x6": true,
                "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
                "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
                "rows": [
                  {
                    "value": [
                      1.25e-05,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      1.84,
                      0.0,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      1.25e-05,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      1.84,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      -0.0,
                      -0.0,
                      -2.088e-05,
                      -0.0,
                      -0.0,
                      -3.07
                    ]
                  }
                ],
                "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                  [
                    0.184,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    0.184,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.307
                  ]
                ],
                "trace_mean_kbar": 0.20333333333333345,
                "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.307,
                "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
              }
            },
            "last_total_energy_print": {
              "value": -299.03174523,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-299.03174523"
            },
            "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
              "value": -0.00016095,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-0.00016095"
            },
            "native_exit_status": null,
            "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
            "PH_all_irreps_complete": null,
            "fullBZ_dynamical_stability": null,
            "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -299.03158428
          }
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/ScZr2_agm003158378",
            "bytes": 5507,
            "sha256": "ef041ddb9b222070c1eebf421401ce923b1a1bbbf055b4c8230eb405427f86de"
          },
          "raw_header": {
            "ntyp": 2,
            "nat": 3,
            "ibrav": 4,
            "celldm": [
              5.971685,
              0.0,
              2.4693828,
              0.0,
              0.0,
              0.0
            ],
            "basis_alat": null,
            "species": [
              {
                "index": 1,
                "element": "Sc",
                "header_mass": 40974.79624876845,
                "header_mass_halfwidth": 5e-13,
                "raw_mass_token": "40974.796248768449",
                "line": 4
              },
              {
                "index": 2,
                "element": "Zr",
                "header_mass": 83145.58963334408,
                "header_mass_halfwidth": 5e-13,
                "raw_mass_token": "83145.589633344076",
                "line": 5
              }
            ],
            "atoms": [
              {
                "index": 1,
                "type": 2,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.500000005,
                  0.2886751317,
                  0.8304991918
                ],
                "line": 6
              },
              {
                "index": 2,
                "type": 2,
                "tau_alat": [
                  -5e-09,
                  0.5773502721,
                  1.6388836038
                ],
                "line": 7
              },
              {
                "index": 3,
                "type": 1,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                "line": 8
              }
            ],
            "q": [
              0.0,
              0.0,
              0.0
            ],
            "matrix_header_line": 10
          },
          "optical_sign": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "minimum": 2.8462772474595977e-07,
          "printing_bound": 1.0279799317428569e-12,
          "ASR_relative": 0.010153641982199813,
          "native_signed_modes": [
            {
              "number": 1,
              "THz": -0.337555,
              "cm_inverse": -11.259609,
              "line": 56
            },
            {
              "number": 2,
              "THz": -0.337555,
              "cm_inverse": -11.259609,
              "line": 60
            },
            {
              "number": 3,
              "THz": -0.314571,
              "cm_inverse": -10.492966,
              "line": 64
            },
            {
              "number": 4,
              "THz": 1.755148,
              "cm_inverse": 58.545426,
              "line": 68
            },
            {
              "number": 5,
              "THz": 1.755148,
              "cm_inverse": 58.545426,
              "line": 72
            },
            {
              "number": 6,
              "THz": 2.544227,
              "cm_inverse": 84.866271,
              "line": 76
            },
            {
              "number": 7,
              "THz": 2.544227,
              "cm_inverse": 84.866271,
              "line": 80
            },
            {
              "number": 8,
              "THz": 4.481591,
              "cm_inverse": 149.489772,
              "line": 84
            },
            {
              "number": 9,
              "THz": 4.648942,
              "cm_inverse": 155.072023,
              "line": 88
            }
          ],
          "native_negative_outside_lowest3": []
        },
        "finite_path": {
          "source_record": 10088,
          "observations": {
            "kind": "qe_freq_gp_source_path_table",
            "raw_header_lines": [],
            "path_rows": 158,
            "column_width_counts": {
              "10": 158
            },
            "mode_column_values": 1422,
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "column_roles_conditional_on_file_schema": true,
            "fullBZ_coverage": null,
            "dynamical_stability": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          }
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm003158378",
          "dyn0_source_record": 10087,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                5.0,
                5.0,
                2.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                10.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 10,
              "source_record": 10094,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 10095,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 10096,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 10097,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 10098,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 5,
              "source_record": 10099,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 6,
              "source_record": 10100,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 7,
              "source_record": 10101,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 8,
              "source_record": 10102,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 9,
              "source_record": 10103,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 10,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "composition-assessments.json",
          "bytes": 2036037,
          "sha256": "87a3759b8bb3bd9985bd6537220b4ea8fa427be6672204f9010e300e647c284a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "numeric-review.json",
          "bytes": 2556012,
          "sha256": "a0e7a487691b01ab8f0a4ea02eab40af649a455b97dc9ebdfdcabc4cd2453000",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Exact ordered-state mechanism new to reviewed catalogue only; source predictions/known chemistry acknowledged, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003187563",
      "formula": "ScZr3",
      "reduced_formula": "ScZr3",
      "composition": {
        "Sc": 1,
        "Zr": 3
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Sc:1|Zr:3",
      "elements": [
        "Sc",
        "Zr"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003187563",
      "control_state": "agm003187562",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/ScZr3_agm003187563",
      "control_directory": null,
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "four-site tetragonal internal-height ordering versus cubic Cu3Au/L12-like ordering",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "motif": "four-site tetragonal internal-height ordering versus cubic Cu3Au/L12-like ordering",
        "verified_space_group": null,
        "role": "A versus samecomposition B",
        "known_prior_scope": "Existing Zr3Sc computational and2025 alloy composition mentions are acknowledged. This exact tetragonal superconducting phase is not an identified experimental benchmark in bounded primary search; not first composition discovery."
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 13.57,
        "control_K": 13.368,
        "delta_K": 0.20199999999999996,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.2549000000000001,
          0.1943999999999999,
          0.13539999999999996,
          0.10329999999999995,
          0.09220000000000006,
          0.09169999999999989,
          0.09450000000000003,
          0.09760000000000013,
          0.09980000000000011,
          0.10079999999999989
        ],
        "range": [
          0.09169999999999989,
          0.2549000000000001
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "All ten lambda gains8.64-21.67%, but source Eli Tc only13.570 versus13.368K (+1.51%). Target finite-grid F is10.370meV/atom higher; BFGSfailed is preserved although fine force0.0037703eV/A and maxstress0.026GPa are small. Competing lower-energy cubic ordering and q-grid sensitivity make this a lower-priority metastable screen. Evaluated risks define a falsifiable bounded hypothesis, not an established bulk ground state or experimental coherence proof.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source nearambient fullstress/pressure and coarse-relaxed geometry, positive raw-Gamma optical compression beyond printing bounds, and no negative printed finite-path values support preliminary local feasibility only within the declared source approximation. WholeBZ/global hull/synthesis remain unknown.",
      "route_response": "Sc-Sc shortest3.14376 versus4.46792A; within4A Sc-Sc/Sc-Zr counts4/8 versus0/12, volume+0.8667%; real colored network construction. Computed source EPC response is associated with construction; pure geometry-only causality and converged numerical uplift are unproved.",
      "next_action": "Use matched code/reciprocal sampling to determine whether the modest Tc uplift survives, while assessing the lower-energy cubic ordering; downgrade if the contrast vanishes.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact reduced composition and non-alias decorated ordered network linked to canonical SCF input and source PH/Gamma/model evidence; source positions bind Gamma within printing/operational tolerances. Nb same-species permutation and Zr scalar parity reflection are explicit. Experimental phase/state remains unknown.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Sc-Sc shortest3.14376 versus4.46792A; within4A Sc-Sc/Sc-Zr counts4/8 versus0/12, volume+0.8667%; real colored network construction. Computed source EPC response is associated with construction; pure geometry-only causality and converged numerical uplift are unproved.",
        "pairing_relevance": "Direct source lambda at ten common printed width tokens and independently retained mu*=0.1 Eliashberg Tc rows provide state-specific pairing relevance. Width units and Tc-to-width link remain unknown; no parent-property transfer or300K claim.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source nearambient fullstress/pressure and coarse-relaxed geometry, positive raw-Gamma optical compression beyond printing bounds, and no negative printed finite-path values support preliminary local feasibility only within the declared source approximation. WholeBZ/global hull/synthesis remain unknown.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "All ten lambda gains8.64-21.67%, but source Eli Tc only13.570 versus13.368K (+1.51%). Target finite-grid F is10.370meV/atom higher; BFGSfailed is preserved although fine force0.0037703eV/A and maxstress0.026GPa are small. Competing lower-energy cubic ordering and q-grid sensitivity make this a lower-priority metastable screen. Evaluated risks define a falsifiable bounded hypothesis, not an established bulk ground state or experimental coherence proof.",
        "novelty": "Existing Zr3Sc computational and2025 alloy composition mentions are acknowledged. This exact tetragonal superconducting phase is not an identified experimental benchmark in bounded primary search; not first composition discovery. Default one exact-composition group, with all source/control variants underneath.",
        "decision": "Use matched code/reciprocal sampling to determine whether the modest Tc uplift survives, while assessing the lower-energy cubic ordering; downgrade if the contrast vanishes. All seven minima support grade3 preliminary source-model screening; retained model-dependent uncertainty prevents grade4/formal publication."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase",
        "residual_force_stress",
        "sampling_method"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [],
      "physical_summary": {
        "target": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/ScZr3_agm003187563",
          "site_composition_matches_name": true,
          "site_count": 4,
          "volume_per_site_A3": 22.490697609234815,
          "source_fine_pressure_GPa": -0.002,
          "source_fine_maxstress_GPa": 0.026000000000000002,
          "source_fine_maxforce_eV_A": 0.003770265987364214,
          "fine_JOB_DONE": true,
          "fine_convergence": true,
          "path_min_signed_printed_value": -0.0,
          "path_units_not_inferred": null,
          "path_signed_negative_printed_count": 0,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        },
        "control": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/ScZr3_agm003187562",
          "site_composition_matches_name": true,
          "site_count": 4,
          "volume_per_site_A3": 22.297447946420036,
          "source_fine_pressure_GPa": 0.01,
          "source_fine_maxstress_GPa": 0.01,
          "source_fine_maxforce_eV_A": 0.0,
          "fine_JOB_DONE": true,
          "fine_convergence": true,
          "path_min_signed_printed_value": -0.0,
          "path_units_not_inferred": null,
          "path_signed_negative_printed_count": 0,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-owned-five-pairs-scientific-workingview.json",
          "bytes": 933925,
          "sha256": "0a5d3b507b305b8991218157264276e898799837932a8050942ecf74ee389034",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-captured-five-pairs-method-slices.json",
          "bytes": 1387111,
          "sha256": "d84758cc1e54d79e08e01fe3b08b96dfa071953b16a488b0aef3a867ff30c147",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "CASE.md",
          "bytes": 6744,
          "sha256": "992e8549b51e96ffe5ffe85525d6915b4cf02665edd9fb34fa23c5933d3d4704",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "receipt.json",
          "bytes": 22444,
          "sha256": "4772aaec35c5cf28426f09895c0f414427609c340c776511b9e2a953040b5430",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "compact-receipt.json",
          "bytes": 10485,
          "sha256": "4f870f243383fa1c615b11558fe463d6723c134454495e422659cfa4d3777f44",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "new-to-reviewed-catalogue ordered source-model route hypothesis; literature-derived, not first discovery",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003557884",
      "formula": "ScZr3N4",
      "reduced_formula": "ScZr3N4",
      "composition": {
        "N": 4,
        "Sc": 1,
        "Zr": 3
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "N:4|Sc:1|Zr:3",
      "elements": [
        "N",
        "Sc",
        "Zr"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003557884",
      "control_state": "agm003558452",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/N4ScZr3_agm003557884",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/N4Zr3Hf_agm003558452",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Pm-3m ordered rock-salt-derived eight-site ScZr3N4: Sc corner, three Zr face centers, N three edge centers plus body center",
      "prototype_evidence": "Pm-3m ordered rock-salt-derived eight-site ScZr3N4: Sc corner, three Zr face centers, N three edge centers plus body center",
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 16.568,
        "control_K": 14.993,
        "delta_K": 1.575000000000001,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.24420000000000008,
          0.13659999999999994,
          0.11219999999999997,
          0.10649999999999993,
          0.09660000000000002,
          0.0847,
          0.07329999999999992,
          0.06299999999999994,
          0.054200000000000026,
          0.046700000000000075
        ],
        "range": [
          0.046700000000000075,
          0.24420000000000008
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Source Gamma optical compression and sampled path are stable at the stated scalar approximation. Fine pressure is -0.205 GPa despite zero symmetry-constrained forces. ScHf3N4 has larger lambda but lower separate Eli Tc, and already accepted YZr3N4 has substantially larger lambda; both controls are retained. Nitrogen vacancies, ordered-cation disorder, charge redistribution and alternate nitrides are appropriate falsifiers. No pure volume-only causal claim or inherited YZr3N4 qualification is used.",
      "ambient_scope": "Both source SCFs converge, near-zero coarse forces/stress and bounded fine response are measured. Fine Fmax=0 eV/A, P=-0.205 GPa, full max stress=0.205 GPa. Gamma optical compression is positive beyond printing bound and sampled path has no signed negative values. All listed q outputs have JOBDONE/last response convergence and no routine errors. This supports a finite-grid local/metastable source model, not global hull or experimental synthesis.",
      "route_response": "Sc replaces Hf on the single cation corner site while three Zr and all four N sites remain mapped. The volume contracts 0.5685%, Sc-N versus Hf-N falls 0.0043104 A and Zr-N also falls 0.0043104 A. All ten lambda values improve 6.741–28.257% and separate Eli mu=.1 rises 14.993 to 16.568 K. This is a coupled cation/network intervention; the valence change is not converted to mobile n.",
      "next_action": "Cross the Sc/Hf unique-site substitution with a fixed-volume comparison and test the lowest N-vacancy/order competitor. A stable coupling gain at common source method supports screening; a missing metallic channel, unfavorable ordering basin or reversed paired response opposes it.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Complete ordered CIF/literal coarse-fine input/Gamma periodic species-site association is numerically supported; source input geometry and full tensor/forces are retained. Export occupancy is a discrete computational convention; source experimental P/T/occupancy and actual compiled unit constant are unknown. Exact-version input defaults scope the configured neutral scalar spin1/noSOC model, not magnetic ground state.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Sc replaces Hf on the single cation corner site while three Zr and all four N sites remain mapped. The volume contracts 0.5685%, Sc-N versus Hf-N falls 0.0043104 A and Zr-N also falls 0.0043104 A. All ten lambda values improve 6.741–28.257% and separate Eli mu=.1 rises 14.993 to 16.568 K. This is a coupled cation/network intervention; the valence change is not converted to mobile n.",
        "pairing_relevance": "Exact target and mapped control direct source lambda arrays have the same favorable sign at all ten common broadening tokens; omega_ln has explicit K units and separate Eli/McM mu=.1 tables remain independent. Same underlying q mesh is observed. The sensitivity range is not a physical error bound; sigma units, full-BZ convergence, experimental Tc and pure-geometry causality remain unknown. Literal method differences are declared confounds.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Both source SCFs converge, near-zero coarse forces/stress and bounded fine response are measured. Fine Fmax=0 eV/A, P=-0.205 GPa, full max stress=0.205 GPa. Gamma optical compression is positive beyond printing bound and sampled path has no signed negative values. All listed q outputs have JOBDONE/last response convergence and no routine errors. This supports a finite-grid local/metastable source model, not global hull or experimental synthesis.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Source Gamma optical compression and sampled path are stable at the stated scalar approximation. Fine pressure is -0.205 GPa despite zero symmetry-constrained forces. ScHf3N4 has larger lambda but lower separate Eli Tc, and already accepted YZr3N4 has substantially larger lambda; both controls are retained. Nitrogen vacancies, ordered-cation disorder, charge redistribution and alternate nitrides are appropriate falsifiers. No pure volume-only causal claim or inherited YZr3N4 qualification is used.",
        "novelty": "ScZr3N4 is a published computational prediction in the 2023 primary screening study, with SG221 and separate hull/coupling model data. It is not first predicted here. The 2026-10-07 bounded exact-phase review found no experimental superconducting ScZr3N4 benchmark. Novelty is the matched Sc-for-Hf corner-site source construction in this reviewed catalogue.",
        "decision": "Cross the Sc/Hf unique-site substitution with a fixed-volume comparison and test the lowest N-vacancy/order competitor. A stable coupling gain at common source method supports screening; a missing metallic channel, unfavorable ordering basin or reversed paired response opposes it."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase",
        "residual_force_stress"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index_zero_based": 196,
          "control_directory": "batch-a/N4ScHf3_agm003557883",
          "mapping_scope": "bounded ordered isostructural analogue",
          "all_three_symprec_support": true,
          "composition_edit": {
            "from": "Hf",
            "to": "Zr",
            "count": 3,
            "kind": "whole_element_substitution"
          },
          "volume_target_over_control": 1.0296135777144353,
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_all10": [
            -6.747433955914525,
            -1.8441273326015406,
            -0.11644154634373556,
            -0.37767024666589066,
            -0.9713394891473794,
            -1.4544121241750207,
            -1.8197681665212586,
            -2.1219822109275794,
            -2.3433454168824452,
            -2.50494396835859
          ],
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_range": [
            -6.747433955914525,
            -0.11644154634373556
          ],
          "separate_source_Eli_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              16.568
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              13.482
            ]
          ],
          "separate_source_McM_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              14.826,
              15.585
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              12.466,
              13.167
            ]
          ],
          "literal_method_same_fields": {
            "ecutwfc": false,
            "smear": true,
            "degauss": true,
            "pseudo_dir": false
          },
          "qmesh_target_control": [
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ]
          ],
          "irreducible_qcount_target_control": [
            [
              4.0
            ],
            [
              4.0
            ]
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index_zero_based": 198,
          "control_directory": "batch-a/N4YZr3_agm003559755",
          "mapping_scope": "bounded ordered isostructural analogue",
          "all_three_symprec_support": true,
          "composition_edit": {
            "from": "Sc",
            "to": "Y",
            "count": 1,
            "kind": "single_site_substitution"
          },
          "volume_target_over_control": 0.9443896797863038,
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_all10": [
            -44.765037125629135,
            -43.63693665300977,
            -41.78091489072892,
            -40.109266354477086,
            -39.095803525333736,
            -38.41277115795905,
            -37.83933080808082,
            -37.31282552083333,
            -36.80462466487936,
            -36.32684690890304
          ],
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_range": [
            -44.765037125629135,
            -36.32684690890304
          ],
          "separate_source_Eli_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              16.568
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              21.437
            ]
          ],
          "separate_source_McM_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              14.826,
              15.585
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              17.905,
              19.975
            ]
          ],
          "literal_method_same_fields": {
            "ecutwfc": true,
            "smear": true,
            "degauss": true,
            "pseudo_dir": true
          },
          "qmesh_target_control": [
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ]
          ],
          "irreducible_qcount_target_control": [
            [
              4.0
            ],
            [
              4.0
            ]
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index_zero_based": 199,
          "control_directory": "batch-a/N4Zr3Hf_agm003558452",
          "mapping_scope": "bounded ordered isostructural analogue",
          "all_three_symprec_support": true,
          "composition_edit": {
            "from": "Sc",
            "to": "Hf",
            "count": 1,
            "kind": "single_site_substitution"
          },
          "volume_target_over_control": 0.9943153589645417,
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_all10": [
            28.257347836149048,
            18.03062302006335,
            15.04828326180257,
            14.438720173535783,
            13.247394404827212,
            11.73780487804878,
            10.260358342665162,
            8.907111550968464,
            7.741751178403089,
            6.740762124711328
          ],
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_range": [
            6.740762124711328,
            28.257347836149048
          ],
          "separate_source_Eli_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              16.568
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              14.993
            ]
          ],
          "separate_source_McM_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              14.826,
              15.585
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              13.316,
              13.879
            ]
          ],
          "literal_method_same_fields": {
            "ecutwfc": false,
            "smear": true,
            "degauss": true,
            "pseudo_dir": false
          },
          "qmesh_target_control": [
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ]
          ],
          "irreducible_qcount_target_control": [
            [
              4.0
            ],
            [
              4.0
            ]
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "nat": 8,
        "lambda10": [
          1.1084,
          0.8942,
          0.8578,
          0.8441,
          0.8258,
          0.8063,
          0.7877,
          0.7703,
          0.7543,
          0.7395
        ],
        "omega10_K": [
          284.2425,
          295.68,
          302.7148,
          306.3358,
          308.8772,
          311.069,
          313.1276,
          315.112,
          317.0266,
          318.8586
        ],
        "Eli_mu01": [
          0.1,
          16.568
        ],
        "McM_mu01": [
          0.1,
          14.826,
          15.585
        ],
        "coarse_fine": [
          {
            "record": 4561,
            "version": [
              "Program PWSCF v.7.0 starts on  3Jul2022 at  8:37: 2"
            ],
            "converged": true,
            "JOBDONE": true,
            "errors": 0,
            "Fmax_eVA": 0.0,
            "P_GPa": 0.001,
            "maxstress_GPa": 0.001,
            "fulltensor": [
              [
                0.001,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                0.001,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                0.001
              ]
            ],
            "F_Ry": -484.09164343,
            "E_Ry": -484.09128181999995,
            "pattern_selected_warning_counts": {
              "BFGS": 1,
              "negative_charge": 0,
              "eigen_text": 1,
              "failure_text": 0,
              "SCF_correction_text": 1
            },
            "warning_scope": "pattern-selected contexts; informational SCF correction and ignored cell card are not optimization failure; no whole-file warning-free claim"
          },
          {
            "record": 4562,
            "version": [
              "Program PWSCF v.7.0 starts on  3Jul2022 at  7:45: 2"
            ],
            "converged": true,
            "JOBDONE": true,
            "errors": 0,
            "Fmax_eVA": 0.0,
            "P_GPa": -0.205,
            "maxstress_GPa": 0.205,
            "fulltensor": [
              [
                -0.205,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                -0.205,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                -0.205
              ]
            ],
            "F_Ry": -484.09965421,
            "E_Ry": -484.09973385999996,
            "pattern_selected_warning_counts": {
              "BFGS": 1,
              "negative_charge": 0,
              "eigen_text": 5,
              "failure_text": 0,
              "SCF_correction_text": 1
            },
            "warning_scope": "pattern-selected contexts; informational SCF correction and ignored cell card are not optimization failure; no whole-file warning-free claim"
          }
        ],
        "inputs": [
          {
            "record": 4551,
            "ecutwfc": [
              98.0
            ],
            "ecutrho": null,
            "pseudo_dir": [
              "/espresso/runs/nc-sr-04_pbesol_stringent_upf/"
            ],
            "spin": null,
            "noncol": null,
            "SOC": null,
            "charge": null,
            "smear": [
              "mp"
            ],
            "degauss": [
              0.014699728870262
            ],
            "ibrav": [
              1.0
            ],
            "nat": [
              8.0
            ],
            "grid": [
              "6 6 6 0 0 0"
            ]
          },
          {
            "record": 4552,
            "ecutwfc": [
              98.0
            ],
            "ecutrho": null,
            "pseudo_dir": [
              "/espresso/runs/nc-sr-04_pbesol_stringent_upf/"
            ],
            "spin": null,
            "noncol": null,
            "SOC": null,
            "charge": null,
            "smear": [
              "mp"
            ],
            "degauss": [
              0.014699728870262
            ],
            "ibrav": [
              1.0
            ],
            "nat": [
              8.0
            ],
            "grid": [
              "24 24 24 0 0 0"
            ]
          }
        ],
        "Gamma": {
          "nat": 8,
          "ibrav": 1,
          "q": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species": [
            "N",
            "Sc",
            "Zr"
          ],
          "optical": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "minopt": 3.4675523338838122e-06,
          "printingbound": 7.929724982890149e-12,
          "negative_native_modes": [
            1,
            2,
            3
          ],
          "negativeoutside3": [],
          "min_low3_translation": 0.9999787020299221,
          "sourcepin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/N4ScZr3_agm003557884",
            "bytes": 31880,
            "sha256": "685f7e2a4f79569a6a0598ec611a3a1b640b0af195c3d568c034f94522ed1338"
          }
        },
        "path": {
          "rows": 94,
          "negatives": 0,
          "minimum": -0.0,
          "unit": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-2-compact-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 84096,
          "sha256": "d8ca53bafc5ee0879de647e050127d8e0d20c0e3da10de9602ab2de44bf77532",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-3-five-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 110335,
          "sha256": "861dd76c8368cca687ca20c8468e464badefb533a318ed41c4f8d62dccb6ed50",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-4-three-phase-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 64369,
          "sha256": "56076a077e591b9bdef8ada45d78f224f417a4af8d2e722e332f639eedfafaf7",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all64-light-Nb-rich-owned-review-cache-v2.json",
          "bytes": 4566542,
          "sha256": "f27e8c84c10c4d8de44022f6bd160e7e8aee8b2d562db5fd6003af68d5e35756",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to this reviewed candidate catalogue and mechanism contrast; MC2023 prediction is prior, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003184276",
      "formula": "Tc2RuRe",
      "reduced_formula": "Tc2RuRe",
      "composition": {
        "Re": 1,
        "Ru": 1,
        "Tc": 2
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Re:1|Ru:1|Tc:2",
      "elements": [
        "Re",
        "Ru",
        "Tc"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003184276",
      "control_state": "agm003184282",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Tc2RuRe_agm003184276",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/TcRuRe2_agm003184282",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "CIF_source_record": 6601,
        "CIF_payload_pin": {
          "bytes": 591661,
          "sha256": "93c3ce21c362fc36392db6d13f4555d76cce96122769d1212414bbc770f81541"
        },
        "SCF_coarse_source_record": 6627,
        "Gamma_source_pin": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/Tc2RuRe_agm003184276",
          "bytes": 8994,
          "sha256": "836f5a98aae7c8ee44adb3387826cb90fe61f5575fd1b237f3a610f1ac2def9e"
        },
        "source_input_volume_difference_relative": 3.232170087130726e-11,
        "occupancy_model_all1": true,
        "bounded_signed_axis_and_translation_mapping": {
          "signed_axis_U_CIF_fractional_to_SCF": [
            [
              1,
              0,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              1,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              0,
              1
            ]
          ],
          "determinant": 1,
          "origin_shift_fractional": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species_bijection_CIF_to_SCF": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            3
          ],
          "maximum_site_distance_A": 3.2911517886692002e-16,
          "relative_Gram_residual": 1.2670623395362117e-09,
          "proper_signed_axis_solution": true
        },
        "attempts": 1,
        "general_GL3_or_chiral_equivalence_asserted": false,
        "CIF_site_precision_A_tolerance": 1e-05,
        "physical_model": "source finite neutral scalar EPC; no SOC transfer certificate"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 15.921,
        "control_K": 13.281,
        "delta_K": 2.639999999999999,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.07429999999999992,
          0.0917,
          0.09389999999999998,
          0.0938,
          0.09219999999999995,
          0.08960000000000001,
          0.0867,
          0.08390000000000009,
          0.08140000000000003,
          0.07930000000000004
        ],
        "range": [
          0.07429999999999992,
          0.09389999999999998
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Ten-token gain +.0743…+.0939 and source Tc+2.640 K occurs on a three-tolerance frozen role map; Tc3Re is better and W comparison has opposing lambda/Tc trend. Path0, force0 and stress .247 GPa support only local finite source scope. Tc/Re radioactivity/SOC/phase competition is retained, not assumed absent.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure 0.004 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.08399999999999999 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
      "route_response": "Re-to-Tc site construction in Tc2RuRe relative to TcRuRe2. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
      "next_action": "Bind Re/Tc role EPC and source phase competitors. Favorable: specific paired gain with retained local phase; adverse: decomposition/ordering/channel response dominates; ambiguous: missing role/phase association.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact source CIF/SCF/Γ state association; CIF source record 6601. Experimental occupancy/P/T and physical magnetic ground state remain unknown; source scalar model only.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Re-to-Tc site construction in Tc2RuRe relative to TcRuRe2. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
        "pairing_relevance": "direct published source EPC plus independent source isotropic Eliashberg result.  favorable comparator(s); bounded source model, not experiment.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure 0.004 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.08399999999999999 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Ten-token gain +.0743…+.0939 and source Tc+2.640 K occurs on a three-tolerance frozen role map; Tc3Re is better and W comparison has opposing lambda/Tc trend. Path0, force0 and stress .247 GPa support only local finite source scope. Tc/Re radioactivity/SOC/phase competition is retained, not assumed absent.",
        "novelty": "No exact Tc2RuRe experimental SG123 phase retrieved. Primary Tc-Ru/Re binary ordered/phase-separated alternatives are closer phase-level competitors, not this ternary identity.",
        "decision": "Bind Re/Tc role EPC and source phase competitors. Favorable: specific paired gain with retained local phase; adverse: decomposition/ordering/channel response dominates; ambiguous: missing role/phase association."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase",
        "residual_force_stress",
        "technetium"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 280,
          "control": "batch-a/Tc2RuW_agm003184452",
          "target": "batch-a/Tc2RuRe_agm003184276",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.1835,
            -0.0030000000000000027
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -16.39563974267334,
            -0.3119151590767314
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 15.921,
          "Tc_control_K": 14.708,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 1.2129999999999992,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": false,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9787748279077709,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.111965086986822e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003184452",
            "dyn0_source_record": 8487,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 8494,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 11,
                "source_record": 8495,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 12,
                "source_record": 8496,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 13,
                "source_record": 8497,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 14,
                "source_record": 8498,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 15,
                "source_record": 8499,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 16,
                "source_record": 8500,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 17,
                "source_record": 8501,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 18,
                "source_record": 8502,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 8503,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 8504,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 8505,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 8506,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 8507,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 8508,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 8509,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 8510,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 8511,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.1835,
            -0.0030000000000000027
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 281,
          "control": "batch-a/Tc3Re_agm003187512",
          "target": "batch-a/Tc2RuRe_agm003184276",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.1612,
            -0.042300000000000115
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -14.695961345610357,
            -4.199344783083501
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 15.921,
          "Tc_control_K": 16.682,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": -0.7609999999999992,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": true,
          "three_tol_graph": false,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.985735256522428,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.2823466398936683e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003187512",
            "dyn0_source_record": 5597,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 5604,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 5605,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 5606,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 5607,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 5608,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 5609,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 5610,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 5611,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 5612,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 5613,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.1612,
            -0.042300000000000115
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 282,
          "control": "batch-a/TcRuRe2_agm003184282",
          "target": "batch-a/Tc2RuRe_agm003184276",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.07429999999999992,
            0.09389999999999998
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            8.625493382865095,
            10.91733519358214
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 15.921,
          "Tc_control_K": 13.281,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 2.639999999999999,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9909506211997398,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 7.269502951412095e-07,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003184282",
            "dyn0_source_record": 13265,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 13272,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 11,
                "source_record": 13273,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 12,
                "source_record": 13274,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 13,
                "source_record": 13275,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 14,
                "source_record": 13276,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 15,
                "source_record": 13277,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 16,
                "source_record": 13278,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 17,
                "source_record": 13279,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 18,
                "source_record": 13280,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 13281,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 13282,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 13283,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 13284,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 13285,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 13286,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 13287,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 13288,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 13289,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.07429999999999992,
            0.09389999999999998
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-02-eleven-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1219201,
          "sha256": "ee658cb8e6309178e268b736f8aeb6429c030a92019c068963e2d64ca51cbb17",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-03-fifteen-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1347056,
          "sha256": "1be9342cb74006b2542e9351fc2de310967f1a31a5ee9f1909ae730b9a11476a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-remaining-transition-owned-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 5381838,
          "sha256": "62f4910578c7b65392d26619cf81b31afd6142f38aa49834a70bb147e7ab222d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to the reviewed candidate mechanism catalogue, source prediction already published; not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm004377652",
      "formula": "Tc2RuRh",
      "reduced_formula": "Tc2RuRh",
      "composition": {
        "Rh": 1,
        "Ru": 1,
        "Tc": 2
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Rh:1|Ru:1|Tc:2",
      "elements": [
        "Rh",
        "Ru",
        "Tc"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm004377652",
      "control_state": "agm004274320",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Tc2RuRh_agm004377652",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Tc2RhOs_agm004274320",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "CIF_source_record": 9291,
        "CIF_payload_pin": {
          "bytes": 591661,
          "sha256": "93c3ce21c362fc36392db6d13f4555d76cce96122769d1212414bbc770f81541"
        },
        "SCF_coarse_source_record": 9311,
        "Gamma_source_pin": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/Tc2RuRh_agm004377652",
          "bytes": 8994,
          "sha256": "d8d51a7616797c6b54a0cbadeeeaeaa362572d4e9cb260c654193135ddf22344"
        },
        "source_input_volume_difference_relative": 2.9299451753672656e-11,
        "occupancy_model_all1": true,
        "bounded_signed_axis_and_translation_mapping": {
          "signed_axis_U_CIF_fractional_to_SCF": [
            [
              1,
              0,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              1,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              0,
              1
            ]
          ],
          "determinant": 1,
          "origin_shift_fractional": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species_bijection_CIF_to_SCF": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            3
          ],
          "maximum_site_distance_A": 1.6418650019030685e-16,
          "relative_Gram_residual": 4.4666027926518795e-10,
          "proper_signed_axis_solution": true
        },
        "attempts": 1,
        "general_GL3_or_chiral_equivalence_asserted": false,
        "CIF_site_precision_A_tolerance": 1e-05,
        "physical_model": "source finite neutral scalar EPC; no SOC transfer certificate"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 14.632,
        "control_K": 13.041,
        "delta_K": 1.5909999999999993,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.11460000000000004,
          0.08449999999999991,
          0.07279999999999998,
          0.062000000000000055,
          0.054300000000000015,
          0.04949999999999999,
          0.04689999999999994,
          0.045399999999999996,
          0.04469999999999996,
          0.044399999999999995
        ],
        "range": [
          0.044399999999999995,
          0.11460000000000004
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Three-tolerance all-token +.0444…+.1146 lambda and sourceTc+1.591 K versusTc2RhOs occur on path0/Gammaopt+ target. Fine force .01652/stress .649 GPa remain numerical/strain limitations. Ru4d vsOs5d changes mass, potential and SOC jointly; not highW or nominal-n proof.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse force 2.0054606315767095e-05 eV/Å, pressure 0.001 GPa; fine force 0.016516510963058492 eV/Å, pressure -0.1 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
      "route_response": "Os-to-Ru role substitution in ordered Tc2RhX. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
      "next_action": "Resolve Ru/Os role EPC and fine stress direction. Favorable: paired source response survives bounded correction; adverse: SOC/strain reverses gain; ambiguous: only formal valence or source Tc remains.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact source CIF/SCF/Γ state association; CIF source record 9291. Experimental occupancy/P/T and physical magnetic ground state remain unknown; source scalar model only.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Os-to-Ru role substitution in ordered Tc2RhX. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
        "pairing_relevance": "direct published source EPC plus independent source isotropic Eliashberg result.  favorable comparator(s); bounded source model, not experiment.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse force 2.0054606315767095e-05 eV/Å, pressure 0.001 GPa; fine force 0.016516510963058492 eV/Å, pressure -0.1 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Three-tolerance all-token +.0444…+.1146 lambda and sourceTc+1.591 K versusTc2RhOs occur on path0/Gammaopt+ target. Fine force .01652/stress .649 GPa remain numerical/strain limitations. Ru4d vsOs5d changes mass, potential and SOC jointly; not highW or nominal-n proof.",
        "novelty": "No exact Tc2RuRh experimental orderedSG123 phase retrieved. PrimarybinaryTc phase competitors are different objects.",
        "decision": "Resolve Ru/Os role EPC and fine stress direction. Favorable: paired source response survives bounded correction; adverse: SOC/strain reverses gain; ambiguous: only formal valence or source Tc remains."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "residual_force_stress",
        "sampling_method",
        "technetium"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 279,
          "control": "batch-a/Tc2RhOs_agm004274320",
          "target": "batch-a/Tc2RuRh_agm004377652",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.044399999999999995,
            0.11460000000000004
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            5.390312006798591,
            12.27243521096595
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 14.632,
          "Tc_control_K": 13.041,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 1.5909999999999993,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9895259039000887,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.1706517914414516e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm004274320",
            "dyn0_source_record": 14385,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              5.0,
              5.0,
              2.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 14392,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 11,
                "source_record": 14393,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 12,
                "source_record": 14394,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 14395,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 14396,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 14397,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 14398,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 14399,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 14400,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 14401,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 14402,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 14403,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.044399999999999995,
            0.11460000000000004
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-02-eleven-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1219201,
          "sha256": "ee658cb8e6309178e268b736f8aeb6429c030a92019c068963e2d64ca51cbb17",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-03-fifteen-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1347056,
          "sha256": "1be9342cb74006b2542e9351fc2de310967f1a31a5ee9f1909ae730b9a11476a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-remaining-transition-owned-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 5381838,
          "sha256": "62f4910578c7b65392d26619cf81b31afd6142f38aa49834a70bb147e7ab222d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to the reviewed candidate mechanism catalogue, source prediction already published; not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003187522",
      "formula": "Tc3Re",
      "reduced_formula": "Tc3Re",
      "composition": {
        "Re": 1,
        "Tc": 3
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Re:1|Tc:3",
      "elements": [
        "Re",
        "Tc"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003187522",
      "control_state": "agm003184277",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Tc3Re_agm003187522",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Tc2RuRe_agm003184277",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "CIF_source_record": 5315,
        "CIF_payload_pin": {
          "bytes": 591661,
          "sha256": "93c3ce21c362fc36392db6d13f4555d76cce96122769d1212414bbc770f81541"
        },
        "SCF_coarse_source_record": 5336,
        "Gamma_source_pin": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/Tc3Re_agm003187522",
          "bytes": 8948,
          "sha256": "13428c905b8f39793ff5d7f8879a0b7a08c3c0b26a52782d6f1791ec8a7c402d"
        },
        "source_input_volume_difference_relative": -4.3183123743517626e-11,
        "occupancy_model_all1": true,
        "bounded_signed_axis_and_translation_mapping": {
          "signed_axis_U_CIF_fractional_to_SCF": [
            [
              1,
              0,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              1,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              0,
              1
            ]
          ],
          "determinant": 1,
          "origin_shift_fractional": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species_bijection_CIF_to_SCF": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            3
          ],
          "maximum_site_distance_A": 0,
          "relative_Gram_residual": 1.1130083917017131e-09,
          "proper_signed_axis_solution": true
        },
        "attempts": 1,
        "general_GL3_or_chiral_equivalence_asserted": false,
        "CIF_site_precision_A_tolerance": 1e-05,
        "physical_model": "source finite neutral scalar EPC; no SOC transfer certificate"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 16.887,
        "control_K": 15.798,
        "delta_K": 1.0890000000000004,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.11939999999999995,
          0.10560000000000003,
          0.07689999999999997,
          0.06330000000000013,
          0.05929999999999991,
          0.05869999999999986,
          0.05920000000000003,
          0.06040000000000001,
          0.06249999999999989,
          0.0655
        ],
        "range": [
          0.05869999999999986,
          0.11939999999999995
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Tc2RuRe→Tc3Re three-tolerance map gives +.0587…+.1194 lambda and Tc+1.089 K, plus an additional two-tolerance TcRe response. Path0, force0 and .282 GPa stress support local source phase. Binary Tc-Re phase competition and radioactive/SOC approximations remain explicit.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure 0.002 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure 0.10600000000000001 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
      "route_response": "Ru-to-Tc mapped role substitution in Tc3Re. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
      "next_action": "Compare exact Tc3Re SG139 mode/orbital response with retained Ru-containing parent and closest Tc-Re competing order. Favorable: distinct local role gain remains; adverse: phase/channel competition eliminates it; ambiguous: geometry/energy comparison not available.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact source CIF/SCF/Γ state association; CIF source record 5315. Experimental occupancy/P/T and physical magnetic ground state remain unknown; source scalar model only.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Ru-to-Tc mapped role substitution in Tc3Re. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
        "pairing_relevance": "direct published source EPC plus independent source isotropic Eliashberg result.  favorable comparator(s); bounded source model, not experiment.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure 0.002 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure 0.10600000000000001 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Tc2RuRe→Tc3Re three-tolerance map gives +.0587…+.1194 lambda and Tc+1.089 K, plus an additional two-tolerance TcRe response. Path0, force0 and .282 GPa stress support local source phase. Binary Tc-Re phase competition and radioactive/SOC approximations remain explicit.",
        "novelty": "Primary ReTc3 D011 prediction is known composition with a different named ordered prototype; current source SG1394-site phase is not asserted identical. No exact experimental phase retrieved; already computed source object.",
        "decision": "Compare exact Tc3Re SG139 mode/orbital response with retained Ru-containing parent and closest Tc-Re competing order. Favorable: distinct local role gain remains; adverse: phase/channel competition eliminates it; ambiguous: geometry/energy comparison not available."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase",
        "residual_force_stress",
        "technetium"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 283,
          "control": "batch-a/Tc2RuRe_agm003184277",
          "target": "batch-a/Tc3Re_agm003187522",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.05869999999999986,
            0.11939999999999995
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            6.087317224929987,
            12.79194343261195
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 16.887,
          "Tc_control_K": 15.798,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 1.0890000000000004,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.013462520004191,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 9.313651535794205e-07,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003184277",
            "dyn0_source_record": 7004,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 7011,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 11,
                "source_record": 7012,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 12,
                "source_record": 7013,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 13,
                "source_record": 7014,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 7015,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 7016,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 7017,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 7018,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 7019,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 7020,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 7021,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 7022,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 7023,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.05869999999999986,
            0.11939999999999995
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 286,
          "control": "batch-a/TcRe_agm003165652",
          "target": "batch-a/Tc3Re_agm003187522",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.06769999999999998,
            0.08689999999999998
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            6.872398741244542,
            9.288157332193242
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 16.887,
          "Tc_control_K": 14.527,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 2.360000000000001,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": false,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9904847173813868,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.263020661996788e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003165652",
            "dyn0_source_record": 9224,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 9231,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 11,
                "source_record": 9232,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 12,
                "source_record": 9233,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 13,
                "source_record": 9234,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 9235,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 9236,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 9237,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 9238,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 9239,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 9240,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 9241,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 9242,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 9243,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.06769999999999998,
            0.08689999999999998
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-02-eleven-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1219201,
          "sha256": "ee658cb8e6309178e268b736f8aeb6429c030a92019c068963e2d64ca51cbb17",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-03-fifteen-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1347056,
          "sha256": "1be9342cb74006b2542e9351fc2de310967f1a31a5ee9f1909ae730b9a11476a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-remaining-transition-owned-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 5381838,
          "sha256": "62f4910578c7b65392d26619cf81b31afd6142f38aa49834a70bb147e7ab222d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to the reviewed candidate mechanism catalogue, source prediction already published; not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003267205",
      "formula": "Tc8Os",
      "reduced_formula": "Tc8Os",
      "composition": {
        "Os": 1,
        "Tc": 8
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Os:1|Tc:8",
      "elements": [
        "Os",
        "Tc"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003267205",
      "control_state": "agm003267229",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Tc8Os_agm003267205",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Tc8Re_agm003267229",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "CIF_source_record": 2395,
        "CIF_payload_pin": {
          "bytes": 591661,
          "sha256": "93c3ce21c362fc36392db6d13f4555d76cce96122769d1212414bbc770f81541"
        },
        "SCF_coarse_source_record": 2409,
        "Gamma_source_pin": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/Tc8Os_agm003267205",
          "bytes": 39823,
          "sha256": "bb90571a10f525a472636d27051b716e402ffe4fda7e38213364951d885000b9"
        },
        "source_input_volume_difference_relative": -7.080114272639548e-12,
        "occupancy_model_all1": true,
        "bounded_signed_axis_and_translation_mapping": {
          "signed_axis_U_CIF_fractional_to_SCF": [
            [
              1,
              0,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              1,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              0,
              1
            ]
          ],
          "determinant": 1,
          "origin_shift_fractional": [
            -2.925980013834817e-10,
            7.405188018339004e-09,
            7.405188018339004e-09
          ],
          "species_bijection_CIF_to_SCF": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            3,
            4,
            5,
            6,
            7,
            8
          ],
          "maximum_site_distance_A": 6.285806134576137e-08,
          "relative_Gram_residual": 1.4327395244502268e-09,
          "proper_signed_axis_solution": true
        },
        "attempts": 1,
        "general_GL3_or_chiral_equivalence_asserted": false,
        "CIF_site_precision_A_tolerance": 1e-05,
        "physical_model": "source finite neutral scalar EPC; no SOC transfer certificate"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 20.247,
        "control_K": 18.083,
        "delta_K": 2.1640000000000015,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.16569999999999996,
          0.1362000000000001,
          0.13030000000000008,
          0.12230000000000008,
          0.11060000000000003,
          0.09839999999999982,
          0.08749999999999991,
          0.07779999999999987,
          0.06920000000000015,
          0.06149999999999989
        ],
        "range": [
          0.06149999999999989,
          0.16569999999999996
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "All-token lambda gain +.0615…+.1657 and source Tc+2.164 K versus Tc8Re supports a local finite route; Tc8Ru is better and remains visible. Sourcepath0 and small coarse force coexist with geoopt BFGS failure and fine force .01353/stress .435 GPa. Radioactive Tc, heavy-Os scalar/SOC and ordered-vs-disordered phase competition remain risks.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse force 7.147667379209298e-05 eV/Å, pressure -0.0 GPa; fine force 0.01353068861504563 eV/Å, pressure 0.11200000000000002 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
      "route_response": "Re-to-Os role substitution in ordered Tc8X. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
      "next_action": "Resolve Tc/Os/Re mode and SOC-sensitive orbital changes on the fixed roles. Favorable: gain remains with bounded channel/strain correction; adverse: ordered phase or channel benefit disappears; ambiguous: no exact mode/phase evidence.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact source CIF/SCF/Γ state association; CIF source record 2395. Experimental occupancy/P/T and physical magnetic ground state remain unknown; source scalar model only.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Re-to-Os role substitution in ordered Tc8X. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
        "pairing_relevance": "direct published source EPC plus independent source isotropic Eliashberg result.  favorable comparator(s); bounded source model, not experiment.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse force 7.147667379209298e-05 eV/Å, pressure -0.0 GPa; fine force 0.01353068861504563 eV/Å, pressure 0.11200000000000002 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "All-token lambda gain +.0615…+.1657 and source Tc+2.164 K versus Tc8Re supports a local finite route; Tc8Ru is better and remains visible. Sourcepath0 and small coarse force coexist with geoopt BFGS failure and fine force .01353/stress .435 GPa. Radioactive Tc, heavy-Os scalar/SOC and ordered-vs-disordered phase competition remain risks.",
        "novelty": "Binary primary Tc-Os competitor predictions and elemental Os superconductivity do not establish exact ordered8:1 SG139 phase. Source computational phase is known, no global novelty claim.",
        "decision": "Resolve Tc/Os/Re mode and SOC-sensitive orbital changes on the fixed roles. Favorable: gain remains with bounded channel/strain correction; adverse: ordered phase or channel benefit disappears; ambiguous: no exact mode/phase evidence."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase",
        "residual_force_stress",
        "technetium"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 287,
          "control": "batch-a/Tc8Re_agm003267229",
          "target": "batch-a/Tc8Os_agm003267205",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.06149999999999989,
            0.16569999999999996
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            6.008206330597878,
            15.679409538228612
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 20.247,
          "Tc_control_K": 18.083,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 2.1640000000000015,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9949224789216228,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.055010021245863e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003267229",
            "dyn0_source_record": 3729,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 3736,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 3737,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 3738,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 3739,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 3740,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 3741,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.06149999999999989,
            0.16569999999999996
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 288,
          "control": "batch-a/Tc8Ru_agm003267242",
          "target": "batch-a/Tc8Os_agm003267205",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.04180000000000006,
            -0.007300000000000084
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -3.3061773313295943,
            -0.6312694569353238
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 20.247,
          "Tc_control_K": 20.601,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": -0.3539999999999992,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": true,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.0045851730326807,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.1644448258595444e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003267242",
            "dyn0_source_record": 2225,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 2232,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 2233,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 2234,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 2235,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 2236,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 2237,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.04180000000000006,
            -0.007300000000000084
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-02-eleven-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1219201,
          "sha256": "ee658cb8e6309178e268b736f8aeb6429c030a92019c068963e2d64ca51cbb17",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-03-fifteen-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1347056,
          "sha256": "1be9342cb74006b2542e9351fc2de310967f1a31a5ee9f1909ae730b9a11476a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-remaining-transition-owned-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 5381838,
          "sha256": "62f4910578c7b65392d26619cf81b31afd6142f38aa49834a70bb147e7ab222d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to the reviewed candidate mechanism catalogue, source prediction already published; not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003267242",
      "formula": "Tc8Ru",
      "reduced_formula": "Tc8Ru",
      "composition": {
        "Ru": 1,
        "Tc": 8
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Ru:1|Tc:8",
      "elements": [
        "Ru",
        "Tc"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003267242",
      "control_state": "agm003267205",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Tc8Ru_agm003267242",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Tc8Os_agm003267205",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "CIF_source_record": 2213,
        "CIF_payload_pin": {
          "bytes": 591661,
          "sha256": "93c3ce21c362fc36392db6d13f4555d76cce96122769d1212414bbc770f81541"
        },
        "SCF_coarse_source_record": 2227,
        "Gamma_source_pin": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/Tc8Ru_agm003267242",
          "bytes": 39823,
          "sha256": "08ade0c7744cb44edc377a6ac2d07f17f83357e11e0c2f93f57620f4e9ea48dc"
        },
        "source_input_volume_difference_relative": 2.8030022747316252e-11,
        "occupancy_model_all1": true,
        "bounded_signed_axis_and_translation_mapping": {
          "signed_axis_U_CIF_fractional_to_SCF": [
            [
              1,
              0,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              1,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              0,
              1
            ]
          ],
          "determinant": 1,
          "origin_shift_fractional": [
            -7.2198409473145375e-09,
            7.2198409473145375e-09,
            0.0
          ],
          "species_bijection_CIF_to_SCF": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            3,
            4,
            5,
            6,
            7,
            8
          ],
          "maximum_site_distance_A": 8.296336793955593e-08,
          "relative_Gram_residual": 8.448981778607021e-10,
          "proper_signed_axis_solution": true
        },
        "attempts": 1,
        "general_GL3_or_chiral_equivalence_asserted": false,
        "CIF_site_precision_A_tolerance": 1e-05,
        "physical_model": "source finite neutral scalar EPC; no SOC transfer certificate"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 20.601,
        "control_K": 20.247,
        "delta_K": 0.3539999999999992,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.04180000000000006,
          0.02499999999999991,
          0.012199999999999989,
          0.00770000000000004,
          0.007300000000000084,
          0.008700000000000152,
          0.010499999999999954,
          0.012299999999999978,
          0.013900000000000023,
          0.015300000000000091
        ],
        "range": [
          0.007300000000000084,
          0.04180000000000006
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "SourceTc8Ru benefits overRe(+.0768…+.2075 lambda,+2.518 K) andOs(+.0073…+.0418,+.354 K). Path0/Gammaopt+ and lowcoarse force support local basin; BFGSfailed and fine force .01824/stress .457 GPa remain visible. No universal Ru ranking or equilibrium Tc8 phase claim.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse force 3.7538109257717896e-05 eV/Å, pressure 0.0 GPa; fine force 0.01824377820958828 eV/Å, pressure 0.094 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
      "route_response": "Re/Os-to-Ru minority-site construction in Tc8X. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
      "next_action": "Compare saved minority-role modes with Re/Os parents and the specific nearby binary phase alternative. Favorable: stable local response survives role/channel uncertainty; adverse: ordering/phase competition eliminates it; ambiguous: no exact mode/retention relation.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact source CIF/SCF/Γ state association; CIF source record 2213. Experimental occupancy/P/T and physical magnetic ground state remain unknown; source scalar model only.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Re/Os-to-Ru minority-site construction in Tc8X. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
        "pairing_relevance": "direct published source EPC plus independent source isotropic Eliashberg result.  favorable comparator(s); bounded source model, not experiment.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse force 3.7538109257717896e-05 eV/Å, pressure 0.0 GPa; fine force 0.01824377820958828 eV/Å, pressure 0.094 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "SourceTc8Ru benefits overRe(+.0768…+.2075 lambda,+2.518 K) andOs(+.0073…+.0418,+.354 K). Path0/Gammaopt+ and lowcoarse force support local basin; BFGSfailed and fine force .01824/stress .457 GPa remain visible. No universal Ru ranking or equilibrium Tc8 phase claim.",
        "novelty": "PrimarybinaryTc-Ru predicts D019/B19 andRuTc5 competitors, not this exact ordered8:1SG139 source phase. No exact experimental phase retrieved.",
        "decision": "Compare saved minority-role modes with Re/Os parents and the specific nearby binary phase alternative. Favorable: stable local response survives role/channel uncertainty; adverse: ordering/phase competition eliminates it; ambiguous: no exact mode/retention relation."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "residual_force_stress",
        "technetium"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 288,
          "control": "batch-a/Tc8Os_agm003267205",
          "target": "batch-a/Tc8Ru_agm003267242",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.007300000000000084,
            0.04180000000000006
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            0.6352797841789299,
            3.4192229038854856
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 20.601,
          "Tc_control_K": 20.247,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 0.3539999999999992,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9954357548212276,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.1710366229673048e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003267205",
            "dyn0_source_record": 2407,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 2414,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 2415,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 2416,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 2417,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 2418,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 2419,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.007300000000000084,
            0.04180000000000006
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 289,
          "control": "batch-a/Tc8Re_agm003267229",
          "target": "batch-a/Tc8Ru_agm003267242",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.07679999999999998,
            0.20750000000000002
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            7.502930832356387,
            19.634746404239213
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 20.601,
          "Tc_control_K": 18.083,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 2.5180000000000007,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9903814087939525,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.055010021245863e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003267229",
            "dyn0_source_record": 3729,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 3736,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 3737,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 3738,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 3739,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 3740,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 3741,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.07679999999999998,
            0.20750000000000002
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-02-eleven-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1219201,
          "sha256": "ee658cb8e6309178e268b736f8aeb6429c030a92019c068963e2d64ca51cbb17",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-03-fifteen-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1347056,
          "sha256": "1be9342cb74006b2542e9351fc2de310967f1a31a5ee9f1909ae730b9a11476a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-remaining-transition-owned-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 5381838,
          "sha256": "62f4910578c7b65392d26619cf81b31afd6142f38aa49834a70bb147e7ab222d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to the reviewed candidate mechanism catalogue, source prediction already published; not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003165652",
      "formula": "TcRe",
      "reduced_formula": "TcRe",
      "composition": {
        "Re": 1,
        "Tc": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Re:1|Tc:1",
      "elements": [
        "Re",
        "Tc"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003165652",
      "control_state": "agm001281037",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/TcRe_agm003165652",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/TcRe3_agm001281037",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "CIF_source_record": 9205,
        "CIF_payload_pin": {
          "bytes": 591661,
          "sha256": "93c3ce21c362fc36392db6d13f4555d76cce96122769d1212414bbc770f81541"
        },
        "SCF_coarse_source_record": 9226,
        "Gamma_source_pin": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/TcRe_agm003165652",
          "bytes": 8948,
          "sha256": "497811ad3da7b22655dc1f5d69f89978461b86ec0240c839e4cde1d4befc16d3"
        },
        "source_input_volume_difference_relative": -7.061018436615996e-12,
        "occupancy_model_all1": true,
        "bounded_signed_axis_and_translation_mapping": {
          "signed_axis_U_CIF_fractional_to_SCF": [
            [
              1,
              0,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              1,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              0,
              1
            ]
          ],
          "determinant": 1,
          "origin_shift_fractional": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species_bijection_CIF_to_SCF": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            3
          ],
          "maximum_site_distance_A": 5.241413118631527e-16,
          "relative_Gram_residual": 1.5220169639113339e-09,
          "proper_signed_axis_solution": true
        },
        "attempts": 1,
        "general_GL3_or_chiral_equivalence_asserted": false,
        "CIF_site_precision_A_tolerance": 1e-05,
        "physical_model": "source finite neutral scalar EPC; no SOC transfer certificate"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 14.527,
        "control_K": 12.351,
        "delta_K": 2.1759999999999984,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.09949999999999992,
          0.08409999999999995,
          0.0746,
          0.07190000000000007,
          0.07220000000000004,
          0.07289999999999996,
          0.07350000000000001,
          0.07389999999999997,
          0.0746,
          0.07520000000000004
        ],
        "range": [
          0.07190000000000007,
          0.09949999999999992
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "All-token gain +.0719…+.0995 and source Tc+2.176 K accompanies path0, force0 and stress .173 GPa. Tc3Re and other ternary neighbors outperform or cross. Primary Tc-Re equilibrium phase-separation/opposing ordered predictions limit present object to a metastable local research phase.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.0 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.09 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
      "route_response": "Re-to-Tc ordered role construction in TcRe relative to TcRe3. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
      "next_action": "Compare exact SG141 retained geometry and EPC to closest already saved Tc-Re ordered competitors. Favorable: distinct local phase and source response remain plausible; adverse: direct competing phase or channel suppression wins; ambiguous: no compatible formation/retention evidence.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact source CIF/SCF/Γ state association; CIF source record 9205. Experimental occupancy/P/T and physical magnetic ground state remain unknown; source scalar model only.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Re-to-Tc ordered role construction in TcRe relative to TcRe3. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
        "pairing_relevance": "direct published source EPC plus independent source isotropic Eliashberg result.  favorable comparator(s); bounded source model, not experiment.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.0 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.09 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "All-token gain +.0719…+.0995 and source Tc+2.176 K accompanies path0, force0 and stress .173 GPa. Tc3Re and other ternary neighbors outperform or cross. Primary Tc-Re equilibrium phase-separation/opposing ordered predictions limit present object to a metastable local research phase.",
        "novelty": "Known computed ReTc source high-precision table is SG187 two-site; current SG141 four-site object is distinct. Binary ReTc3 D011 prediction is also a different phase. No formation/Tc transfer or first chemistry claim.",
        "decision": "Compare exact SG141 retained geometry and EPC to closest already saved Tc-Re ordered competitors. Favorable: distinct local phase and source response remain plausible; adverse: direct competing phase or channel suppression wins; ambiguous: no compatible formation/retention evidence."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase",
        "residual_force_stress",
        "technetium"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 284,
          "control": "batch-a/Tc2RuRe_agm003184277",
          "target": "batch-a/TcRe_agm003165652",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.021399999999999975,
            0.05169999999999997
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -2.2210690192008276,
            5.538890079280048
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 14.527,
          "Tc_control_K": 15.798,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": -1.2710000000000008,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": false,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.0231985433188229,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 9.313651535794205e-07,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003184277",
            "dyn0_source_record": 7004,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 7011,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 11,
                "source_record": 7012,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 12,
                "source_record": 7013,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 13,
                "source_record": 7014,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 7015,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 7016,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 7017,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 7018,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 7019,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 7020,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 7021,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 7022,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 7023,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.021399999999999975,
            0.05169999999999997
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 286,
          "control": "batch-a/Tc3Re_agm003187522",
          "target": "batch-a/TcRe_agm003165652",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.08689999999999998,
            -0.06769999999999998
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -8.498777506112468,
            -6.430471124620059
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 14.527,
          "Tc_control_K": 16.887,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": -2.360000000000001,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": true,
          "three_tol_graph": false,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.009606693017707,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.4416949535813618e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003187522",
            "dyn0_source_record": 5334,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 5341,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 11,
                "source_record": 5342,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 12,
                "source_record": 5343,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 13,
                "source_record": 5344,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 5345,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 5346,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 5347,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 5348,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 5349,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 5350,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 5351,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 5352,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 5353,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.08689999999999998,
            -0.06769999999999998
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 290,
          "control": "batch-a/TcRe3_agm001281037",
          "target": "batch-a/TcRe_agm003165652",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.07190000000000007,
            0.09949999999999992
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            8.299804575238538,
            11.23532068654019
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 14.527,
          "Tc_control_K": 12.351,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 2.1759999999999984,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9909279930481182,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.2760868891104772e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001281037",
            "dyn0_source_record": 16316,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 16323,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 11,
                "source_record": 16324,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 12,
                "source_record": 16325,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 13,
                "source_record": 16326,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 16327,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 16328,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 16329,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 16330,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 16331,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 16332,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 16333,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 16334,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 16335,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.07190000000000007,
            0.09949999999999992
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 295,
          "control": "batch-a/TcRuRe2_agm003184283",
          "target": "batch-a/TcRe_agm003165652",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.08440000000000003,
            0.135
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            9.840270490847619,
            15.88048464886484
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 14.527,
          "Tc_control_K": 13.031,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 1.4959999999999987,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": false,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.0135727405891566,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.0123249986974428e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003184283",
            "dyn0_source_record": 14250,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 14257,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 11,
                "source_record": 14258,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 12,
                "source_record": 14259,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 13,
                "source_record": 14260,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 14261,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 14262,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 14263,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 14264,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 14265,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 14266,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 14267,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 14268,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 14269,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.08440000000000003,
            0.135
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-02-eleven-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1219201,
          "sha256": "ee658cb8e6309178e268b736f8aeb6429c030a92019c068963e2d64ca51cbb17",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-03-fifteen-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1347056,
          "sha256": "1be9342cb74006b2542e9351fc2de310967f1a31a5ee9f1909ae730b9a11476a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-remaining-transition-owned-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 5381838,
          "sha256": "62f4910578c7b65392d26619cf81b31afd6142f38aa49834a70bb147e7ab222d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to the reviewed candidate mechanism catalogue, source prediction already published; not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003158344",
      "formula": "TcRe2",
      "reduced_formula": "TcRe2",
      "composition": {
        "Re": 2,
        "Tc": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Re:2|Tc:1",
      "elements": [
        "Re",
        "Tc"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003158344",
      "control_state": "agm003158343",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/TcRe2_agm003158344",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/TcRe2_agm003158343",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 139. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": [
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.0001,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 139,
          "hall_number": 424,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "e",
            "e",
            "a"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            2
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.0001,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 139,
          "hall_number": 424,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "e",
            "e",
            "a"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            2
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.001,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 139,
          "hall_number": 424,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "e",
            "e",
            "a"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            2
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.001,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 139,
          "hall_number": 424,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "e",
            "e",
            "a"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            2
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.01,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 139,
          "hall_number": 424,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "e",
            "e",
            "a"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            2
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.01,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 139,
          "hall_number": 424,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "e",
            "e",
            "a"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            2
          ]
        }
      ],
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 13.709,
        "control_K": 13.273,
        "delta_K": 0.43599999999999994,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.04970000000000008,
          0.03179999999999994,
          0.03579999999999994,
          0.03649999999999998,
          0.0363,
          0.03550000000000009,
          0.03410000000000002,
          0.03279999999999994,
          0.03189999999999993,
          0.03149999999999997
        ],
        "range": [
          0.03149999999999997,
          0.04970000000000008
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": [
        0.9647885909410465,
        0.9646217307707778,
        0.9651247724334983,
        0.965655895943899,
        0.9660548488561576,
        0.9663181241437369,
        0.9664536474206471,
        0.9664977507458212,
        0.9665011884070775,
        0.9665104372981557
      ],
      "risk_summary": "The source benefit is small; the tiny fine F difference does not establish the stable phase. Published Re–Tc phase-separation and a predicted Tc-rich ReTc3 state do not bind this Re-rich TcRe2 ordering.",
      "ambient_scope": "Exact model force/full stress, converged electronic outputs, reported finite-q workflow and raw Γ optical evidence provide a bounded near-ambient source-model screen. Source residual stress/metastable alternatives remain explicit; this is not proof of synthesizeability, full BZ or global equilibrium.",
      "route_response": "Tetragonal A versus hexagonal B has all-ten λ preference for A and separate Eliashberg +0.436 K. Its actual full-stress maximum is lower (0.635 versus 1.479 GPa), with small mean pressure. Complete species-channel geometry differences and computed all-σ pairing response are saved against the frozen controls. Cell/grid/method sensitivity prevents a pure geometry-only causal claim; no bandwidth/carrier quantity is substituted.",
      "next_action": "Converge the two actual anisotropic cells and pairing grids without reselecting phases, then test the closest phase-separated/ordered competitor. A discarded order or vanished pairing difference reverses this bounded hypothesis.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Source-specific full-species CIF→both SCF inputs→Γ coordinate/cell association, actual atom order and origin, within 1e-6 Å observational matching policy. Original experimental occupancy and measured P/T unknown; configured QE neutral/nonmagnetic/no-SOC model is distinct from a magnetic ground-state claim.",
        "novelty": "One exact reduced composition/ordered phase-design group, new to the frozen reviewed cohort. Published computed source is acknowledged, known experimental chemistry remains a comparator. Bounded primary phase search has not tied the exact target order to an established SC sample; no global absence claim.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Tetragonal A versus hexagonal B has all-ten λ preference for A and separate Eliashberg +0.436 K. Its actual full-stress maximum is lower (0.635 versus 1.479 GPa), with small mean pressure. Complete species-channel geometry differences and computed all-σ pairing response are saved against the frozen controls. Cell/grid/method sensitivity prevents a pure geometry-only causal claim; no bandwidth/carrier quantity is substituted.",
        "pairing_relevance": "All ten source λ/ω rows retained with original units/nulls, and μ*=0.1 source McMillan, Allen–Dynes and Eliashberg products kept separate. Source Gaussian EPC broadening is distinct from explicit MP electronic SCF smearing. No product maximum or selected σ defines the recommendation.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Exact model force/full stress, converged electronic outputs, reported finite-q workflow and raw Γ optical evidence provide a bounded near-ambient source-model screen. Source residual stress/metastable alternatives remain explicit; this is not proof of synthesizeability, full BZ or global equilibrium.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "The source benefit is small; the tiny fine F difference does not establish the stable phase. Published Re–Tc phase-separation and a predicted Tc-rich ReTc3 state do not bind this Re-rich TcRe2 ordering.",
        "decision": "Converge the two actual anisotropic cells and pairing grids without reselecting phases, then test the closest phase-separated/ordered competitor. A discarded order or vanished pairing difference reverses this bounded hypothesis."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase",
        "technetium"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "control_directory": "batch-a/TcRe2_agm003158343",
          "lambda_target_minus_control_all10": [
            0.04970000000000008,
            0.03179999999999994,
            0.03579999999999994,
            0.03649999999999998,
            0.0363,
            0.03550000000000009,
            0.03410000000000002,
            0.03279999999999994,
            0.03189999999999993,
            0.03149999999999997
          ],
          "omega_log_target_over_control_all10": [
            0.9647885909410465,
            0.9646217307707778,
            0.9651247724334983,
            0.965655895943899,
            0.9660548488561576,
            0.9663181241437369,
            0.9664536474206471,
            0.9664977507458212,
            0.9665011884070775,
            0.9665104372981557
          ],
          "source_Eli_mu01_target_control_K": [
            13.709,
            13.273
          ],
          "separate_Eli_target_minus_control_K": 0.43599999999999994,
          "target_control_q_mesh_match": false,
          "target_control_q_meshes": [
            [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            [
              5.0,
              5.0,
              2.0
            ]
          ],
          "q_comparison_scope": "Different cells can have different configured physical sampling. Actual meshes retained as confounds; source-paired products do not establish convergence or isolated geometry causality.",
          "original_frozen_pair": {
            "original_contrast_index": 61,
            "composition": {
              "Re": 2,
              "Tc": 1
            },
            "fixed_A": "batch-a/TcRe2_agm003158344",
            "fixed_B": "batch-a/TcRe2_agm003158343",
            "lambda_B_minus_A_all10": [
              -0.04970000000000008,
              -0.03179999999999994,
              -0.03579999999999994,
              -0.03649999999999998,
              -0.0363,
              -0.03550000000000009,
              -0.03410000000000002,
              -0.03279999999999994,
              -0.03189999999999993,
              -0.03149999999999997
            ],
            "lambda_direction": "A",
            "separate_Eli_A_B_K": [
              13.709,
              13.273
            ],
            "separate_Eli_B_minus_A_K": -0.43599999999999994
          },
          "control_source_q_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003158343",
            "dyn0_source_record": 13311,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              5.0,
              5.0,
              2.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 13318,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 13319,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 13320,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 13321,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 13322,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 13323,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 13324,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 13325,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 13326,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 13327,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.03149999999999997,
            0.04970000000000008
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "SCF_stages": {
          "scf_coarse.out.bz2": {
            "source_record": 11479,
            "explicit_program_start_headers": [
              {
                "value": "Program PWSCF v.6.8 starts on 13May2023 at 14:13:36"
              }
            ],
            "last_printed_convergence_event": {
              "value": true,
              "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
            },
            "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
            "routine_error_count": 0,
            "warning_patterns": {
              "pattern_selected_count": 6,
              "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
              "BFGS": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
                }
              },
              "negative_charge": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "eigen_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "failure_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "SCF_correction_text": {
                "count": 2,
                "last": {
                  "value": "SCF correction compared to forces is large: reduce conv_thr to get better values"
                }
              }
            },
            "last_force": {
              "header": {
                "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
              },
              "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "printed_site_rows": 3,
              "ordered_atom_indices": [
                1,
                2,
                3
              ],
              "reported_max_abs_component": {
                "value": 3.8e-07,
                "unit": "Ry/bohr",
                "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
              },
              "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 3.8e-07,
              "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 3.8e-07,
              "max_component_eV_A": 9.770192820501919e-06,
              "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 9.770192820501919e-06,
              "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
              "conversion_constants": {
                "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
                "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
              },
              "unit_conversion_valid": true,
              "max_norm_site": {
                "value": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  -3.8e-07
                ],
                "atom_index": 1,
                "type_index": 1
              },
              "reported_component_agrees": true
            },
            "last_stress": {
              "last_pressure_print": {
                "value": -0.09,
                "unit": "kbar",
                "raw_value": "-0.09",
                "GPa": -0.009
              },
              "last_stress_block": {
                "header": {
                  "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.09"
                },
                "complete_3x6": true,
                "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
                "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
                "rows": [
                  {
                    "value": [
                      -6.5e-07,
                      -0.0,
                      -0.0,
                      -0.1,
                      -0.0,
                      -0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      -0.0,
                      -6.5e-07,
                      0.0,
                      -0.0,
                      -0.1,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      -0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -6.3e-07,
                      -0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -0.09
                    ]
                  }
                ],
                "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                  [
                    -0.01,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    -0.0,
                    -0.01,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.009
                  ]
                ],
                "trace_mean_kbar": -0.09666666666666668,
                "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.01,
                "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
              }
            },
            "last_total_energy_print": {
              "value": -516.75828755,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-516.75828755"
            },
            "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
              "value": 0.00072488,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "0.00072488"
            },
            "native_exit_status": null,
            "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
            "PH_all_irreps_complete": null,
            "fullBZ_dynamical_stability": null,
            "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -516.75901243
          },
          "scf_fine.out.bz2": {
            "source_record": 11480,
            "explicit_program_start_headers": [
              {
                "value": "Program PWSCF v.6.8 starts on 13May2023 at 14: 4:44"
              }
            ],
            "last_printed_convergence_event": {
              "value": true,
              "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
            },
            "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
            "routine_error_count": 0,
            "warning_patterns": {
              "pattern_selected_count": 5,
              "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
              "BFGS": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
                }
              },
              "negative_charge": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "eigen_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "failure_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "SCF_correction_text": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Total force =     0.001584     Total SCF correction =     0.000002"
                }
              }
            },
            "last_force": {
              "header": {
                "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
              },
              "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "printed_site_rows": 3,
              "ordered_atom_indices": [
                1,
                2,
                3
              ],
              "reported_max_abs_component": {
                "value": 0.00112039,
                "unit": "Ry/bohr",
                "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
              },
              "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.00112039,
              "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.00112039,
              "max_component_eV_A": 0.02880638508990038,
              "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.02880638508990038,
              "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
              "conversion_constants": {
                "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
                "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
              },
              "unit_conversion_valid": true,
              "max_norm_site": {
                "value": [
                  0.0,
                  -0.0,
                  0.00112039
                ],
                "atom_index": 1,
                "type_index": 1
              },
              "reported_component_agrees": true
            },
            "last_stress": {
              "last_pressure_print": {
                "value": 0.18,
                "unit": "kbar",
                "raw_value": "0.18",
                "GPa": 0.018
              },
              "last_stress_block": {
                "header": {
                  "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=        0.18"
                },
                "complete_3x6": true,
                "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
                "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
                "rows": [
                  {
                    "value": [
                      -1.971e-05,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -2.9,
                      0.0,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      -1.971e-05,
                      -0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -2.9,
                      -0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      4.316e-05,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      6.35
                    ]
                  }
                ],
                "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                  [
                    -0.29,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    -0.29,
                    -0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.635
                  ]
                ],
                "trace_mean_kbar": 0.18333333333333326,
                "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.635,
                "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
              }
            },
            "last_total_energy_print": {
              "value": -516.75847845,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-516.75847845"
            },
            "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
              "value": 6.672e-05,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "0.00006672"
            },
            "native_exit_status": null,
            "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
            "PH_all_irreps_complete": null,
            "fullBZ_dynamical_stability": null,
            "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -516.7585451699999
          }
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/TcRe2_agm003158344",
            "bytes": 5507,
            "sha256": "3825e74c748c575b4ea461e5a9225f041fb124aebbf2766d7e5fef12baeb572f"
          },
          "raw_header": {
            "ntyp": 2,
            "nat": 3,
            "ibrav": 7,
            "celldm": [
              5.1710268,
              0.0,
              4.2260741,
              0.0,
              0.0,
              0.0
            ],
            "basis_alat": null,
            "species": [
              {
                "index": 1,
                "element": "Re",
                "header_mass": 169717.29817653357,
                "header_mass_halfwidth": 5e-12,
                "raw_mass_token": "169717.29817653357",
                "line": 4
              },
              {
                "index": 2,
                "element": "Tc",
                "header_mass": 89321.53582464835,
                "header_mass_halfwidth": 5e-13,
                "raw_mass_token": "89321.535824648352",
                "line": 5
              }
            ],
            "atoms": [
              {
                "index": 1,
                "type": 1,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  1.4111224837
                ],
                "line": 6
              },
              {
                "index": 2,
                "type": 1,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.0,
                  -0.0,
                  2.8149516088
                ],
                "line": 7
              },
              {
                "index": 3,
                "type": 2,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                "line": 8
              }
            ],
            "q": [
              0.0,
              0.0,
              0.0
            ],
            "matrix_header_line": 10
          },
          "optical_sign": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "minimum": 1.2423831999769264e-06,
          "printing_bound": 4.874754048911471e-13,
          "ASR_relative": 0.00129516021305849,
          "native_signed_modes": [
            {
              "number": 1,
              "THz": -0.121488,
              "cm_inverse": -4.052403,
              "line": 56
            },
            {
              "number": 2,
              "THz": -0.121488,
              "cm_inverse": -4.052403,
              "line": 60
            },
            {
              "number": 3,
              "THz": -0.046243,
              "cm_inverse": -1.542488,
              "line": 64
            },
            {
              "number": 4,
              "THz": 3.666932,
              "cm_inverse": 122.315675,
              "line": 68
            },
            {
              "number": 5,
              "THz": 3.666932,
              "cm_inverse": 122.315675,
              "line": 72
            },
            {
              "number": 6,
              "THz": 4.544267,
              "cm_inverse": 151.580434,
              "line": 76
            },
            {
              "number": 7,
              "THz": 4.544267,
              "cm_inverse": 151.580434,
              "line": 80
            },
            {
              "number": 8,
              "THz": 5.27593,
              "cm_inverse": 175.986094,
              "line": 84
            },
            {
              "number": 9,
              "THz": 6.214656,
              "cm_inverse": 207.298609,
              "line": 88
            }
          ],
          "native_negative_outside_lowest3": []
        },
        "finite_path": {
          "source_record": 11459,
          "observations": {
            "kind": "qe_freq_gp_source_path_table",
            "raw_header_lines": [],
            "path_rows": 189,
            "column_width_counts": {
              "10": 189
            },
            "mode_column_values": 1701,
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "column_roles_conditional_on_file_schema": true,
            "fullBZ_coverage": null,
            "dynamical_stability": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          }
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm003158344",
          "dyn0_source_record": 11458,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                4.0,
                4.0,
                4.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                13.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 10,
              "source_record": 11465,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 11,
              "source_record": 11466,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 12,
              "source_record": 11467,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 13,
              "source_record": 11468,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 11469,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 11470,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 11471,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 11472,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 5,
              "source_record": 11473,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 6,
              "source_record": 11474,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 7,
              "source_record": 11475,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 8,
              "source_record": 11476,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 9,
              "source_record": 11477,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 13,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "composition-assessments.json",
          "bytes": 2036037,
          "sha256": "87a3759b8bb3bd9985bd6537220b4ea8fa427be6672204f9010e300e647c284a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "numeric-review.json",
          "bytes": 2556012,
          "sha256": "a0e7a487691b01ab8f0a4ea02eab40af649a455b97dc9ebdfdcabc4cd2453000",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Exact ordered-state mechanism new to reviewed catalogue only; source predictions/known chemistry acknowledged, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003165657",
      "formula": "TcRe3",
      "reduced_formula": "TcRe3",
      "composition": {
        "Re": 3,
        "Tc": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Re:3|Tc:1",
      "elements": [
        "Re",
        "Tc"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003165657",
      "control_state": "agm003165653",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/TcRe3_agm003165657",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/TcRe3_agm003165653",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 123. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": [
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.0001,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 123,
          "hall_number": 400,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "g",
            "g",
            "c",
            "d"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            2,
            3
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.0001,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 123,
          "hall_number": 400,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "g",
            "g",
            "c",
            "d"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            2,
            3
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.001,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 123,
          "hall_number": 400,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "g",
            "g",
            "c",
            "d"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            2,
            3
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.001,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 123,
          "hall_number": 400,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "g",
            "g",
            "c",
            "d"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            2,
            3
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.01,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 123,
          "hall_number": 400,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "g",
            "g",
            "c",
            "d"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            2,
            3
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.01,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 123,
          "hall_number": 400,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "g",
            "g",
            "c",
            "d"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            2,
            3
          ]
        }
      ],
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 12.62,
        "control_K": 11.91,
        "delta_K": 0.7099999999999991,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.08350000000000002,
          0.05259999999999998,
          0.03920000000000001,
          0.030400000000000094,
          0.02629999999999999,
          0.024499999999999966,
          0.02310000000000001,
          0.02190000000000003,
          0.020299999999999985,
          0.01880000000000004
        ],
        "range": [
          0.01880000000000004,
          0.08350000000000002
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": [
        1.0102555814771852,
        1.0085218448099684,
        1.007284859742237,
        1.0063591547525268,
        1.0055618541469762,
        1.005021156469823,
        1.0047761814046776,
        1.0047908266486318,
        1.004987506257388,
        1.005278374886292
      ],
      "risk_summary": "A fine F is 3.820 meV/atom higher than B, its residual full-stress maximum is 0.488 GPa, and Re–Tc decomposition remains a competing prior. ReTc3 in the literature is Tc-rich and must not be aliased with this Re3Tc state.",
      "ambient_scope": "Exact model force/full stress, converged electronic outputs, reported finite-q workflow and raw Γ optical evidence provide a bounded near-ambient source-model screen. Source residual stress/metastable alternatives remain explicit; this is not proof of synthesizeability, full BZ or global equilibrium.",
      "route_response": "Ordered tetragonal Re-rich A versus L12 B has all-ten λ gain and all separate fixed-μ Tc products favor A (Eliashberg +0.710 K). The like-Tc network differs by about 1.135 Å. Complete species-channel geometry differences and computed all-σ pairing response are saved against the frozen controls. Cell/grid/method sensitivity prevents a pure geometry-only causal claim; no bandwidth/carrier quantity is substituted.",
      "next_action": "Test tetragonal versus L12 persistence and the explicitly distinct phase-separated reference at converged sampling. Loss of order or a reversed λ/ω benefit is adverse; no global hull conclusion is claimed.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Source-specific full-species CIF→both SCF inputs→Γ coordinate/cell association, actual atom order and origin, within 1e-6 Å observational matching policy. Original experimental occupancy and measured P/T unknown; configured QE neutral/nonmagnetic/no-SOC model is distinct from a magnetic ground-state claim.",
        "novelty": "One exact reduced composition/ordered phase-design group, new to the frozen reviewed cohort. Published computed source is acknowledged, known experimental chemistry remains a comparator. Bounded primary phase search has not tied the exact target order to an established SC sample; no global absence claim.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Ordered tetragonal Re-rich A versus L12 B has all-ten λ gain and all separate fixed-μ Tc products favor A (Eliashberg +0.710 K). The like-Tc network differs by about 1.135 Å. Complete species-channel geometry differences and computed all-σ pairing response are saved against the frozen controls. Cell/grid/method sensitivity prevents a pure geometry-only causal claim; no bandwidth/carrier quantity is substituted.",
        "pairing_relevance": "All ten source λ/ω rows retained with original units/nulls, and μ*=0.1 source McMillan, Allen–Dynes and Eliashberg products kept separate. Source Gaussian EPC broadening is distinct from explicit MP electronic SCF smearing. No product maximum or selected σ defines the recommendation.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Exact model force/full stress, converged electronic outputs, reported finite-q workflow and raw Γ optical evidence provide a bounded near-ambient source-model screen. Source residual stress/metastable alternatives remain explicit; this is not proof of synthesizeability, full BZ or global equilibrium.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "A fine F is 3.820 meV/atom higher than B, its residual full-stress maximum is 0.488 GPa, and Re–Tc decomposition remains a competing prior. ReTc3 in the literature is Tc-rich and must not be aliased with this Re3Tc state.",
        "decision": "Test tetragonal versus L12 persistence and the explicitly distinct phase-separated reference at converged sampling. Loss of order or a reversed λ/ω benefit is adverse; no global hull conclusion is claimed."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase",
        "residual_force_stress",
        "technetium"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "control_directory": "batch-a/TcRe3_agm003165653",
          "lambda_target_minus_control_all10": [
            0.08350000000000002,
            0.05259999999999998,
            0.03920000000000001,
            0.030400000000000094,
            0.02629999999999999,
            0.024499999999999966,
            0.02310000000000001,
            0.02190000000000003,
            0.020299999999999985,
            0.01880000000000004
          ],
          "omega_log_target_over_control_all10": [
            1.0102555814771852,
            1.0085218448099684,
            1.007284859742237,
            1.0063591547525268,
            1.0055618541469762,
            1.005021156469823,
            1.0047761814046776,
            1.0047908266486318,
            1.004987506257388,
            1.005278374886292
          ],
          "source_Eli_mu01_target_control_K": [
            12.62,
            11.91
          ],
          "separate_Eli_target_minus_control_K": 0.7099999999999991,
          "target_control_q_mesh_match": false,
          "target_control_q_meshes": [
            [
              5.0,
              5.0,
              2.0
            ],
            [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ]
          ],
          "q_comparison_scope": "Different cells can have different configured physical sampling. Actual meshes retained as confounds; source-paired products do not establish convergence or isolated geometry causality.",
          "original_frozen_pair": {
            "original_contrast_index": 63,
            "composition": {
              "Re": 3,
              "Tc": 1
            },
            "fixed_A": "batch-a/TcRe3_agm003165657",
            "fixed_B": "batch-a/TcRe3_agm003165653",
            "lambda_B_minus_A_all10": [
              -0.08350000000000002,
              -0.05259999999999998,
              -0.03920000000000001,
              -0.030400000000000094,
              -0.02629999999999999,
              -0.024499999999999966,
              -0.02310000000000001,
              -0.02190000000000003,
              -0.020299999999999985,
              -0.01880000000000004
            ],
            "lambda_direction": "A",
            "separate_Eli_A_B_K": [
              12.62,
              11.91
            ],
            "separate_Eli_B_minus_A_K": -0.7099999999999991
          },
          "control_source_q_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003165653",
            "dyn0_source_record": 17673,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 17680,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 17681,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 17682,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 17683,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 17684,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 17685,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 17686,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 17687,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 17688,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 17689,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.01880000000000004,
            0.08350000000000002
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "SCF_stages": {
          "scf_coarse.out.bz2": {
            "source_record": 15613,
            "explicit_program_start_headers": [
              {
                "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 13May2023 at 11: 1:28"
              }
            ],
            "last_printed_convergence_event": {
              "value": true,
              "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
            },
            "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
            "routine_error_count": 0,
            "warning_patterns": {
              "pattern_selected_count": 6,
              "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
              "BFGS": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
                }
              },
              "negative_charge": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "eigen_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "failure_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "SCF_correction_text": {
                "count": 2,
                "last": {
                  "value": "SCF correction compared to forces is large: reduce conv_thr to get better values"
                }
              }
            },
            "last_force": {
              "header": {
                "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
              },
              "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "printed_site_rows": 4,
              "ordered_atom_indices": [
                1,
                2,
                3,
                4
              ],
              "reported_max_abs_component": {
                "value": 7.9e-07,
                "unit": "Ry/bohr",
                "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
              },
              "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 7.9e-07,
              "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 7.9e-07,
              "max_component_eV_A": 2.0311716653148723e-05,
              "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 2.0311716653148723e-05,
              "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
              "conversion_constants": {
                "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
                "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
              },
              "unit_conversion_valid": true,
              "max_norm_site": {
                "value": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  7.9e-07
                ],
                "atom_index": 1,
                "type_index": 1
              },
              "reported_component_agrees": true
            },
            "last_stress": {
              "last_pressure_print": {
                "value": -0.0,
                "unit": "kbar",
                "raw_value": "-0.00",
                "GPa": -0.0
              },
              "last_stress_block": {
                "header": {
                  "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.00"
                },
                "complete_3x6": true,
                "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
                "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
                "rows": [
                  {
                    "value": [
                      1e-08,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      1e-08,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -6e-08,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -0.01
                    ]
                  }
                ],
                "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                  [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.001
                  ]
                ],
                "trace_mean_kbar": -0.0033333333333333335,
                "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.001,
                "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
              }
            },
            "last_total_energy_print": {
              "value": -690.32174299,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-690.32174299"
            },
            "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
              "value": 2.355e-05,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "0.00002355"
            },
            "native_exit_status": null,
            "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
            "PH_all_irreps_complete": null,
            "fullBZ_dynamical_stability": null,
            "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -690.32176654
          },
          "scf_fine.out.bz2": {
            "source_record": 15614,
            "explicit_program_start_headers": [
              {
                "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 13May2023 at 10:53:36"
              }
            ],
            "last_printed_convergence_event": {
              "value": true,
              "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
            },
            "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
            "routine_error_count": 0,
            "warning_patterns": {
              "pattern_selected_count": 6,
              "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
              "BFGS": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
                }
              },
              "negative_charge": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "eigen_text": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "c_bands:  1 eigenvalues not converged"
                }
              },
              "failure_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "SCF_correction_text": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Total force =     0.001039     Total SCF correction =     0.000001"
                }
              }
            },
            "last_force": {
              "header": {
                "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
              },
              "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "printed_site_rows": 4,
              "ordered_atom_indices": [
                1,
                2,
                3,
                4
              ],
              "reported_max_abs_component": {
                "value": 0.00073501,
                "unit": "Ry/bohr",
                "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
              },
              "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.00073501,
              "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.00073501,
              "max_component_eV_A": 0.018897866907887147,
              "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.018897866907887147,
              "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
              "conversion_constants": {
                "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
                "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
              },
              "unit_conversion_valid": true,
              "max_norm_site": {
                "value": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00073501
                ],
                "atom_index": 1,
                "type_index": 1
              },
              "reported_component_agrees": true
            },
            "last_stress": {
              "last_pressure_print": {
                "value": -0.47,
                "unit": "kbar",
                "raw_value": "-0.47",
                "GPa": -0.047
              },
              "last_stress_block": {
                "header": {
                  "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.47"
                },
                "complete_3x6": true,
                "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
                "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
                "rows": [
                  {
                    "value": [
                      1.182e-05,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      1.74,
                      0.0,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      1.182e-05,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      1.74,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -3.32e-05,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -4.88
                    ]
                  }
                ],
                "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                  [
                    0.174,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    0.174,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.488
                  ]
                ],
                "trace_mean_kbar": -0.4666666666666666,
                "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.488,
                "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
              }
            },
            "last_total_energy_print": {
              "value": -690.32017198,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-690.32017198"
            },
            "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
              "value": -7.61e-06,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-0.00000761"
            },
            "native_exit_status": null,
            "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
            "PH_all_irreps_complete": null,
            "fullBZ_dynamical_stability": null,
            "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -690.32016437
          }
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/TcRe3_agm003165657",
            "bytes": 8948,
            "sha256": "c620fda95900dd6b7538a9c1cf0af30927f1da126692f776c5e5d86e47cc1e6c"
          },
          "raw_header": {
            "ntyp": 2,
            "nat": 4,
            "ibrav": 6,
            "celldm": [
              5.1666298,
              0.0,
              2.8335877,
              0.0,
              0.0,
              0.0
            ],
            "basis_alat": null,
            "species": [
              {
                "index": 1,
                "element": "Re",
                "header_mass": 169717.298176534,
                "header_mass_halfwidth": 5e-10,
                "raw_mass_token": "169717.298176534",
                "line": 4
              },
              {
                "index": 2,
                "element": "Tc",
                "header_mass": 89321.5358246484,
                "header_mass_halfwidth": 5e-11,
                "raw_mass_token": "89321.5358246484",
                "line": 5
              }
            ],
            "atoms": [
              {
                "index": 1,
                "type": 1,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  2.1221495477
                ],
                "line": 6
              },
              {
                "index": 2,
                "type": 1,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.7114381504
                ],
                "line": 7
              },
              {
                "index": 3,
                "type": 1,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.5,
                  0.5,
                  0.0
                ],
                "line": 8
              },
              {
                "index": 4,
                "type": 2,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.5,
                  0.5,
                  1.4167938349
                ],
                "line": 9
              }
            ],
            "q": [
              0.0,
              0.0,
              0.0
            ],
            "matrix_header_line": 11
          },
          "optical_sign": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "minimum": 9.553476383494432e-07,
          "printing_bound": 6.124668126677999e-13,
          "ASR_relative": 0.002122633897125852,
          "native_signed_modes": [
            {
              "number": 1,
              "THz": -0.146645,
              "cm_inverse": -4.89154,
              "line": 85
            },
            {
              "number": 2,
              "THz": -0.136617,
              "cm_inverse": -4.557054,
              "line": 90
            },
            {
              "number": 3,
              "THz": -0.136617,
              "cm_inverse": -4.557054,
              "line": 95
            },
            {
              "number": 4,
              "THz": 3.215554,
              "cm_inverse": 107.259324,
              "line": 100
            },
            {
              "number": 5,
              "THz": 3.215554,
              "cm_inverse": 107.259324,
              "line": 105
            },
            {
              "number": 6,
              "THz": 3.400607,
              "cm_inverse": 113.432025,
              "line": 110
            },
            {
              "number": 7,
              "THz": 3.400607,
              "cm_inverse": 113.432025,
              "line": 115
            },
            {
              "number": 8,
              "THz": 4.17361,
              "cm_inverse": 139.216634,
              "line": 120
            },
            {
              "number": 9,
              "THz": 4.17361,
              "cm_inverse": 139.216634,
              "line": 125
            },
            {
              "number": 10,
              "THz": 4.738071,
              "cm_inverse": 158.045049,
              "line": 130
            },
            {
              "number": 11,
              "THz": 5.133619,
              "cm_inverse": 171.239108,
              "line": 135
            },
            {
              "number": 12,
              "THz": 6.192172,
              "cm_inverse": 206.548636,
              "line": 140
            }
          ],
          "native_negative_outside_lowest3": []
        },
        "finite_path": {
          "source_record": 15594,
          "observations": {
            "kind": "qe_freq_gp_source_path_table",
            "raw_header_lines": [],
            "path_rows": 188,
            "column_width_counts": {
              "13": 188
            },
            "mode_column_values": 2256,
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "column_roles_conditional_on_file_schema": true,
            "fullBZ_coverage": null,
            "dynamical_stability": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          }
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm003165657",
          "dyn0_source_record": 15593,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                5.0,
                5.0,
                2.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                12.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 10,
              "source_record": 15600,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 11,
              "source_record": 15601,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 12,
              "source_record": 15602,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 15603,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 15604,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 15605,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 15606,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 5,
              "source_record": 15607,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 6,
              "source_record": 15608,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 7,
              "source_record": 15609,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 8,
              "source_record": 15610,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 9,
              "source_record": 15611,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 12,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "composition-assessments.json",
          "bytes": 2036037,
          "sha256": "87a3759b8bb3bd9985bd6537220b4ea8fa427be6672204f9010e300e647c284a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "numeric-review.json",
          "bytes": 2556012,
          "sha256": "a0e7a487691b01ab8f0a4ea02eab40af649a455b97dc9ebdfdcabc4cd2453000",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Exact ordered-state mechanism new to reviewed catalogue only; source predictions/known chemistry acknowledged, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003780812",
      "formula": "TcRuRe2",
      "reduced_formula": "TcRuRe2",
      "composition": {
        "Re": 2,
        "Ru": 1,
        "Tc": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Re:2|Ru:1|Tc:1",
      "elements": [
        "Re",
        "Ru",
        "Tc"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003780812",
      "control_state": "agm003184282",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/TcRuRe2_agm003780812",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/TcRuRe2_agm003184282",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 123. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": [
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.0001,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 123,
          "hall_number": 400,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "g",
            "g",
            "d",
            "c"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            2,
            3
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.0001,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 123,
          "hall_number": 400,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "g",
            "g",
            "d",
            "c"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            2,
            3
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.001,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 123,
          "hall_number": 400,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "g",
            "g",
            "d",
            "c"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            2,
            3
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.001,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 123,
          "hall_number": 400,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "g",
            "g",
            "d",
            "c"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            2,
            3
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.01,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 123,
          "hall_number": 400,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "g",
            "g",
            "d",
            "c"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            2,
            3
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.01,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 123,
          "hall_number": 400,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "g",
            "g",
            "d",
            "c"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            2,
            3
          ]
        }
      ],
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 13.339,
        "control_K": 13.281,
        "delta_K": 0.05799999999999983,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          -0.051000000000000045,
          -0.04139999999999999,
          -0.018399999999999972,
          -0.005900000000000016,
          -0.0029000000000000137,
          -0.0040000000000000036,
          -0.006000000000000005,
          -0.007799999999999918,
          -0.009299999999999975,
          -0.010299999999999976
        ],
        "range": [
          -0.051000000000000045,
          -0.0029000000000000137
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": [
        1.0281883586321745,
        1.0249339168739495,
        1.021617497329521,
        1.0187182466361269,
        1.0165005576475337,
        1.0148721178226439,
        1.0136706807825622,
        1.0127690338520527,
        1.0120783934528015,
        1.0115390327261198
      ],
      "risk_summary": "The A Eliashberg benefit is only 0.058 K (McMillan and Allen–Dynes +0.051 K), not a demonstrated robust improvement; the A fine F is 16.80 meV/atom higher. The support grade is for the bounded phase/network hypothesis with explicit opposite λ, not a significant global potential ranking.",
      "ambient_scope": "Exact model force/full stress, converged electronic outputs, reported finite-q workflow and raw Γ optical evidence provide a bounded near-ambient source-model screen. Source residual stress/metastable alternatives remain explicit; this is not proof of synthesizeability, full BZ or global equilibrium.",
      "route_response": "Both ordered tetragonal phases have strongly different Ru/Tc like-species separations (about 2.71258 versus 3.83478 Å). λ favors B in all ten rows, whereas ω and all three separate Tc products favor A. This is a geometry/pairing tradeoff vector, not monotonic λ optimization. Complete species-channel geometry differences and computed all-σ pairing response are saved against the frozen controls. Cell/grid/method sensitivity prevents a pure geometry-only causal claim; no bandwidth/carrier quantity is substituted.",
      "next_action": "Freeze A/B identity and test the tradeoff at matched grids and common product definitions. If all Tc benefits vanish or change sign while B keeps greater λ, downgrade the claim of A benefit; no maximum-σ or outcome-based comparator substitution.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Source-specific full-species CIF→both SCF inputs→Γ coordinate/cell association, actual atom order and origin, within 1e-6 Å observational matching policy. Original experimental occupancy and measured P/T unknown; configured QE neutral/nonmagnetic/no-SOC model is distinct from a magnetic ground-state claim.",
        "novelty": "One exact reduced composition/ordered phase-design group, new to the frozen reviewed cohort. Published computed source is acknowledged, known experimental chemistry remains a comparator. Bounded primary phase search has not tied the exact target order to an established SC sample; no global absence claim.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Both ordered tetragonal phases have strongly different Ru/Tc like-species separations (about 2.71258 versus 3.83478 Å). λ favors B in all ten rows, whereas ω and all three separate Tc products favor A. This is a geometry/pairing tradeoff vector, not monotonic λ optimization. Complete species-channel geometry differences and computed all-σ pairing response are saved against the frozen controls. Cell/grid/method sensitivity prevents a pure geometry-only causal claim; no bandwidth/carrier quantity is substituted.",
        "pairing_relevance": "All ten source λ/ω rows retained with original units/nulls, and μ*=0.1 source McMillan, Allen–Dynes and Eliashberg products kept separate. Source Gaussian EPC broadening is distinct from explicit MP electronic SCF smearing. No product maximum or selected σ defines the recommendation.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Exact model force/full stress, converged electronic outputs, reported finite-q workflow and raw Γ optical evidence provide a bounded near-ambient source-model screen. Source residual stress/metastable alternatives remain explicit; this is not proof of synthesizeability, full BZ or global equilibrium.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "The A Eliashberg benefit is only 0.058 K (McMillan and Allen–Dynes +0.051 K), not a demonstrated robust improvement; the A fine F is 16.80 meV/atom higher. The support grade is for the bounded phase/network hypothesis with explicit opposite λ, not a significant global potential ranking.",
        "decision": "Freeze A/B identity and test the tradeoff at matched grids and common product definitions. If all Tc benefits vanish or change sign while B keeps greater λ, downgrade the claim of A benefit; no maximum-σ or outcome-based comparator substitution."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "technetium"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "control_directory": "batch-a/TcRuRe2_agm003184282",
          "lambda_target_minus_control_all10": [
            -0.051000000000000045,
            -0.04139999999999999,
            -0.018399999999999972,
            -0.005900000000000016,
            -0.0029000000000000137,
            -0.0040000000000000036,
            -0.006000000000000005,
            -0.007799999999999918,
            -0.009299999999999975,
            -0.010299999999999976
          ],
          "omega_log_target_over_control_all10": [
            1.0281883586321745,
            1.0249339168739495,
            1.021617497329521,
            1.0187182466361269,
            1.0165005576475337,
            1.0148721178226439,
            1.0136706807825622,
            1.0127690338520527,
            1.0120783934528015,
            1.0115390327261198
          ],
          "source_Eli_mu01_target_control_K": [
            13.339,
            13.281
          ],
          "separate_Eli_target_minus_control_K": 0.05799999999999983,
          "target_control_q_mesh_match": false,
          "target_control_q_meshes": [
            [
              5.0,
              5.0,
              2.0
            ],
            [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ]
          ],
          "q_comparison_scope": "Different cells can have different configured physical sampling. Actual meshes retained as confounds; source-paired products do not establish convergence or isolated geometry causality.",
          "original_frozen_pair": {
            "original_contrast_index": 58,
            "composition": {
              "Re": 2,
              "Ru": 1,
              "Tc": 1
            },
            "fixed_A": "batch-a/TcRuRe2_agm003780812",
            "fixed_B": "batch-a/TcRuRe2_agm003184282",
            "lambda_B_minus_A_all10": [
              0.051000000000000045,
              0.04139999999999999,
              0.018399999999999972,
              0.005900000000000016,
              0.0029000000000000137,
              0.0040000000000000036,
              0.006000000000000005,
              0.007799999999999918,
              0.009299999999999975,
              0.010299999999999976
            ],
            "lambda_direction": "B",
            "separate_Eli_A_B_K": [
              13.339,
              13.281
            ],
            "separate_Eli_B_minus_A_K": -0.05799999999999983
          },
          "control_source_q_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003184282",
            "dyn0_source_record": 13265,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 13272,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 11,
                "source_record": 13273,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 12,
                "source_record": 13274,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 13,
                "source_record": 13275,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 14,
                "source_record": 13276,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 15,
                "source_record": 13277,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 16,
                "source_record": 13278,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 17,
                "source_record": 13279,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 18,
                "source_record": 13280,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 13281,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 13282,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 13283,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 13284,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 13285,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 13286,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 13287,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 13288,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 13289,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.051000000000000045,
            -0.0029000000000000137
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "SCF_stages": {
          "scf_coarse.out.bz2": {
            "source_record": 13033,
            "explicit_program_start_headers": [
              {
                "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 13May2023 at 10:17:31"
              }
            ],
            "last_printed_convergence_event": {
              "value": true,
              "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
            },
            "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
            "routine_error_count": 0,
            "warning_patterns": {
              "pattern_selected_count": 6,
              "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
              "BFGS": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
                }
              },
              "negative_charge": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "eigen_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "failure_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "SCF_correction_text": {
                "count": 2,
                "last": {
                  "value": "SCF correction compared to forces is large: reduce conv_thr to get better values"
                }
              }
            },
            "last_force": {
              "header": {
                "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
              },
              "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "printed_site_rows": 4,
              "ordered_atom_indices": [
                1,
                2,
                3,
                4
              ],
              "reported_max_abs_component": {
                "value": 2.97e-06,
                "unit": "Ry/bohr",
                "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
              },
              "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 2.97e-06,
              "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 2.97e-06,
              "max_component_eV_A": 7.636177020234394e-05,
              "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 7.636177020234394e-05,
              "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
              "conversion_constants": {
                "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
                "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
              },
              "unit_conversion_valid": true,
              "max_norm_site": {
                "value": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  -2.97e-06
                ],
                "atom_index": 1,
                "type_index": 1
              },
              "reported_component_agrees": true
            },
            "last_stress": {
              "last_pressure_print": {
                "value": -0.02,
                "unit": "kbar",
                "raw_value": "-0.02",
                "GPa": -0.002
              },
              "last_stress_block": {
                "header": {
                  "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.02"
                },
                "complete_3x6": true,
                "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
                "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
                "rows": [
                  {
                    "value": [
                      -1.7e-07,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -0.03,
                      0.0,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      -1.7e-07,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -0.03,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -1.6e-07,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -0.02
                    ]
                  }
                ],
                "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                  [
                    -0.003,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    -0.003,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.002
                  ]
                ],
                "trace_mean_kbar": -0.02666666666666667,
                "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.003,
                "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
              }
            },
            "last_total_energy_print": {
              "value": -718.80863641,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-718.80863641"
            },
            "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
              "value": 0.00019732,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "0.00019732"
            },
            "native_exit_status": null,
            "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
            "PH_all_irreps_complete": null,
            "fullBZ_dynamical_stability": null,
            "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -718.80883373
          },
          "scf_fine.out.bz2": {
            "source_record": 13034,
            "explicit_program_start_headers": [
              {
                "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 13May2023 at 10: 9:18"
              }
            ],
            "last_printed_convergence_event": {
              "value": true,
              "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
            },
            "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
            "routine_error_count": 0,
            "warning_patterns": {
              "pattern_selected_count": 5,
              "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
              "BFGS": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
                }
              },
              "negative_charge": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "eigen_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "failure_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "SCF_correction_text": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Total force =     0.001795     Total SCF correction =     0.000005"
                }
              }
            },
            "last_force": {
              "header": {
                "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
              },
              "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "printed_site_rows": 4,
              "ordered_atom_indices": [
                1,
                2,
                3,
                4
              ],
              "reported_max_abs_component": {
                "value": 0.0012696,
                "unit": "Ry/bohr",
                "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
              },
              "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.0012696,
              "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.0012696,
              "max_component_eV_A": 0.032642728433971674,
              "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.032642728433971674,
              "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
              "conversion_constants": {
                "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
                "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
              },
              "unit_conversion_valid": true,
              "max_norm_site": {
                "value": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0012696
                ],
                "atom_index": 1,
                "type_index": 1
              },
              "reported_component_agrees": true
            },
            "last_stress": {
              "last_pressure_print": {
                "value": -0.25,
                "unit": "kbar",
                "raw_value": "-0.25",
                "GPa": -0.025
              },
              "last_stress_block": {
                "header": {
                  "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.25"
                },
                "complete_3x6": true,
                "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
                "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
                "rows": [
                  {
                    "value": [
                      1.38e-05,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      2.03,
                      0.0,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      1.38e-05,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      2.03,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -3.269e-05,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -4.81
                    ]
                  }
                ],
                "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                  [
                    0.20299999999999999,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    0.20299999999999999,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.481
                  ]
                ],
                "trace_mean_kbar": -0.25,
                "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.481,
                "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
              }
            },
            "last_total_energy_print": {
              "value": -718.80693234,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-718.80693234"
            },
            "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
              "value": 0.00021426,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "0.00021426"
            },
            "native_exit_status": null,
            "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
            "PH_all_irreps_complete": null,
            "fullBZ_dynamical_stability": null,
            "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -718.8071466
          }
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/TcRuRe2_agm003780812",
            "bytes": 8994,
            "sha256": "ce96f8f1d6c88414b30d88d22240b854e81a6467d78ee3d69de0916770feedcb"
          },
          "raw_header": {
            "ntyp": 3,
            "nat": 4,
            "ibrav": 6,
            "celldm": [
              5.1260345,
              0.0,
              2.8369894,
              0.0,
              0.0,
              0.0
            ],
            "basis_alat": null,
            "species": [
              {
                "index": 1,
                "element": "Re",
                "header_mass": 169717.298176534,
                "header_mass_halfwidth": 5e-10,
                "raw_mass_token": "169717.298176534",
                "line": 4
              },
              {
                "index": 2,
                "element": "Ru",
                "header_mass": 92119.6696509919,
                "header_mass_halfwidth": 5e-11,
                "raw_mass_token": "92119.6696509919",
                "line": 5
              },
              {
                "index": 3,
                "element": "Tc",
                "header_mass": 89321.5358246484,
                "header_mass_halfwidth": 5e-11,
                "raw_mass_token": "89321.5358246484",
                "line": 6
              }
            ],
            "atoms": [
              {
                "index": 1,
                "type": 1,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  2.131633689
                ],
                "line": 7
              },
              {
                "index": 2,
                "type": 1,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.7053557378
                ],
                "line": 8
              },
              {
                "index": 3,
                "type": 3,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.5,
                  0.5,
                  1.4184946992
                ],
                "line": 9
              },
              {
                "index": 4,
                "type": 2,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.5,
                  0.5,
                  0.0
                ],
                "line": 10
              }
            ],
            "q": [
              0.0,
              0.0,
              0.0
            ],
            "matrix_header_line": 12
          },
          "optical_sign": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "minimum": 1.0541571891741138e-06,
          "printing_bound": 7.177541685974774e-13,
          "ASR_relative": 0.0034494773085085935,
          "native_signed_modes": [
            {
              "number": 1,
              "THz": -0.289137,
              "cm_inverse": -9.644581,
              "line": 86
            },
            {
              "number": 2,
              "THz": -0.289137,
              "cm_inverse": -9.644581,
              "line": 91
            },
            {
              "number": 3,
              "THz": -0.237224,
              "cm_inverse": -7.912931,
              "line": 96
            },
            {
              "number": 4,
              "THz": 3.377752,
              "cm_inverse": 112.669671,
              "line": 101
            },
            {
              "number": 5,
              "THz": 3.377752,
              "cm_inverse": 112.669671,
              "line": 106
            },
            {
              "number": 6,
              "THz": 3.630962,
              "cm_inverse": 121.115842,
              "line": 111
            },
            {
              "number": 7,
              "THz": 3.630962,
              "cm_inverse": 121.115842,
              "line": 116
            },
            {
              "number": 8,
              "THz": 3.906729,
              "cm_inverse": 130.314437,
              "line": 121
            },
            {
              "number": 9,
              "THz": 4.325741,
              "cm_inverse": 144.291192,
              "line": 126
            },
            {
              "number": 10,
              "THz": 4.325741,
              "cm_inverse": 144.291192,
              "line": 131
            },
            {
              "number": 11,
              "THz": 4.87961,
              "cm_inverse": 162.766285,
              "line": 136
            },
            {
              "number": 12,
              "THz": 6.519401,
              "cm_inverse": 217.463802,
              "line": 141
            }
          ],
          "native_negative_outside_lowest3": []
        },
        "finite_path": {
          "source_record": 13014,
          "observations": {
            "kind": "qe_freq_gp_source_path_table",
            "raw_header_lines": [],
            "path_rows": 192,
            "column_width_counts": {
              "13": 192
            },
            "mode_column_values": 2304,
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "column_roles_conditional_on_file_schema": true,
            "fullBZ_coverage": null,
            "dynamical_stability": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          }
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm003780812",
          "dyn0_source_record": 13013,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                5.0,
                5.0,
                2.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                12.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 10,
              "source_record": 13020,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 11,
              "source_record": 13021,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 12,
              "source_record": 13022,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 13023,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 13024,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 13025,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 13026,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 5,
              "source_record": 13027,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 6,
              "source_record": 13028,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 7,
              "source_record": 13029,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 8,
              "source_record": 13030,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 9,
              "source_record": 13031,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 12,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "composition-assessments.json",
          "bytes": 2036037,
          "sha256": "87a3759b8bb3bd9985bd6537220b4ea8fa427be6672204f9010e300e647c284a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "numeric-review.json",
          "bytes": 2556012,
          "sha256": "a0e7a487691b01ab8f0a4ea02eab40af649a455b97dc9ebdfdcabc4cd2453000",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Exact ordered-state mechanism new to reviewed catalogue only; source predictions/known chemistry acknowledged, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm002028410",
      "formula": "Ti",
      "reduced_formula": "Ti",
      "composition": {
        "Ti": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Ti:1",
      "elements": [
        "Ti"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm002028410",
      "control_state": "agm003283597",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Ti_agm002028410",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Zr_agm003283597",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Fm-3m one-site FCC Ti primitive source phase; distinct from equilibrium two-site hcp alpha-Ti and bcc beta-Ti",
      "prototype_evidence": "Fm-3m one-site FCC Ti primitive source phase; distinct from equilibrium two-site hcp alpha-Ti and bcc beta-Ti",
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 19.962,
        "control_K": 13.386,
        "delta_K": 6.5760000000000005,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.052100000000000035,
          0.08889999999999998,
          0.0844999999999998,
          0.07499999999999996,
          0.06390000000000007,
          0.05360000000000009,
          0.04500000000000015,
          0.03770000000000007,
          0.03179999999999983,
          0.026799999999999935
        ],
        "range": [
          0.026799999999999935,
          0.08889999999999998
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "FCC Ti is metastable rather than equilibrium ambient hcp Ti. Primary DFT phonon work and experimental rolling/film/interface observations provide credible metastability priors without establishing superconductivity in clean bulk FCC Ti. Potential contamination, interface stabilization, hcp/Bain conversion and small lambda effect under changed cutoff/PP are substantive risks. The exact source has zero force, 0.019 GPa fine stress and no negative sampled path; nat1 has no optical subspace, so no nonexistent optical stability claim is made. Magnetic Mn and La tradeoff controls are retained.",
      "ambient_scope": "The one-site FCC source SCFs converge with zero forces and fine full stress 0.019 GPa, and the sampled finite-q path has no signed negative value. Nat1 has no optical subspace; its Gamma translation result is not an optical certificate. Primary DFT and experimental metastable FCC-Ti observations support a bounded ambient metastability route, not equilibrium bulk retention or full-BZ proof.",
      "route_response": "The frozen one-site FCC control replaces Zr by Ti with the periodic neighbor topology retained. Volume contracts 24.703%, and nearest Ti-Ti versus Zr-Zr falls 0.284535 A. All ten lambda values rise 2.493–7.937% and separate Eli mu=.1 rises 13.386 to 19.962 K; omega and coupling remain separately reported. This is a phase-scoped coupled elemental/metal-network response, not generic Ti chemistry novelty or a measured hopping bandwidth.",
      "next_action": "Compare the source FCC and same-composition hcp/Bain competitors and evaluate phase retention under a stated interface/strain or bulk metastable domain; confirm the small paired lambda advantage with common source method. A retained FCC local basin and response support this phase hypothesis; rapid hcp conversion or loss of the common-method advantage opposes it.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Complete ordered CIF/literal coarse-fine input/Gamma periodic species-site association is numerically supported; source input geometry and full tensor/forces are retained. Export occupancy is a discrete computational convention; source experimental P/T/occupancy and actual compiled unit constant are unknown. Exact-version input defaults scope the configured neutral scalar spin1/noSOC model, not magnetic ground state.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "The frozen one-site FCC control replaces Zr by Ti with the periodic neighbor topology retained. Volume contracts 24.703%, and nearest Ti-Ti versus Zr-Zr falls 0.284535 A. All ten lambda values rise 2.493–7.937% and separate Eli mu=.1 rises 13.386 to 19.962 K; omega and coupling remain separately reported. This is a phase-scoped coupled elemental/metal-network response, not generic Ti chemistry novelty or a measured hopping bandwidth.",
        "pairing_relevance": "Exact target and mapped control direct source lambda arrays have the same favorable sign at all ten common broadening tokens; omega_ln has explicit K units and separate Eli/McM mu=.1 tables remain independent. Same underlying q mesh is observed. The sensitivity range is not a physical error bound; sigma units, full-BZ convergence, experimental Tc and pure-geometry causality remain unknown. Literal method differences are declared confounds.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "The one-site FCC source SCFs converge with zero forces and fine full stress 0.019 GPa, and the sampled finite-q path has no signed negative value. Nat1 has no optical subspace; its Gamma translation result is not an optical certificate. Primary DFT and experimental metastable FCC-Ti observations support a bounded ambient metastability route, not equilibrium bulk retention or full-BZ proof.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "FCC Ti is metastable rather than equilibrium ambient hcp Ti. Primary DFT phonon work and experimental rolling/film/interface observations provide credible metastability priors without establishing superconductivity in clean bulk FCC Ti. Potential contamination, interface stabilization, hcp/Bain conversion and small lambda effect under changed cutoff/PP are substantive risks. The exact source has zero force, 0.019 GPa fine stress and no negative sampled path; nat1 has no optical subspace, so no nonexistent optical stability claim is made. Magnetic Mn and La tradeoff controls are retained.",
        "novelty": "Elemental hcp Ti superconductivity and metastable FCC Ti structures are known. Dated 2026-10-07 FCC-Ti superconductivity searches found no experimental superconducting exact FCC source benchmark. The proposed reviewed-catalogue hypothesis is the FCC source-phase and Zr-to-Ti metal-network construction, not discovery of titanium superconductivity.",
        "decision": "Compare the source FCC and same-composition hcp/Bain competitors and evaluate phase retention under a stated interface/strain or bulk metastable domain; confirm the small paired lambda advantage with common source method. A retained FCC local basin and response support this phase hypothesis; rapid hcp conversion or loss of the common-method advantage opposes it."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase",
        "residual_force_stress",
        "sampling_method"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index_zero_based": 135,
          "control_directory": "batch-a/La_agm002156005",
          "mapping_scope": "bounded ordered isostructural analogue",
          "all_three_symprec_support": true,
          "composition_edit": {
            "from": "La",
            "to": "Ti",
            "count": 1,
            "kind": "single_site_substitution"
          },
          "volume_target_over_control": 0.49571020480748756,
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_all10": [
            -54.38218923933209,
            -52.99377916018663,
            -51.244897959183675,
            -48.87633179484967,
            -46.62724584944281,
            -44.78814165197083,
            -43.33052234733864,
            -42.14362712386428,
            -41.08465608465608,
            -40.05550416281221
          ],
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_range": [
            -54.38218923933209,
            -40.05550416281221
          ],
          "separate_source_Eli_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              19.962
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              13.092
            ]
          ],
          "separate_source_McM_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              16.842,
              18.124
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              10.138,
              11.884
            ]
          ],
          "literal_method_same_fields": {
            "ecutwfc": false,
            "smear": true,
            "degauss": true,
            "pseudo_dir": false
          },
          "qmesh_target_control": [
            [
              6.0,
              6.0,
              6.0
            ],
            [
              6.0,
              6.0,
              6.0
            ]
          ],
          "irreducible_qcount_target_control": [
            [
              16.0
            ],
            [
              16.0
            ]
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index_zero_based": 168,
          "control_directory": "batch-a/Mn_agm003273519",
          "mapping_scope": "bounded ordered isostructural analogue",
          "all_three_symprec_support": true,
          "composition_edit": {
            "from": "Mn",
            "to": "Ti",
            "count": 1,
            "kind": "single_site_substitution"
          },
          "volume_target_over_control": 1.6110778361206688,
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_all10": [
            22.976893067920376,
            26.226769680517865,
            24.530859049207653,
            23.176054874246514,
            21.734619773835462,
            19.92959933740554,
            17.882571458053878,
            15.77812018489984,
            13.79662749105773,
            11.996746644977621
          ],
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_range": [
            11.996746644977621,
            26.226769680517865
          ],
          "separate_source_Eli_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              19.962
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              20.429
            ]
          ],
          "separate_source_McM_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              16.842,
              18.124
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              17.491,
              18.454
            ]
          ],
          "literal_method_same_fields": {
            "ecutwfc": false,
            "smear": true,
            "degauss": true,
            "pseudo_dir": false
          },
          "qmesh_target_control": [
            [
              6.0,
              6.0,
              6.0
            ],
            [
              6.0,
              6.0,
              6.0
            ]
          ],
          "irreducible_qcount_target_control": [
            [
              16.0
            ],
            [
              16.0
            ]
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index_zero_based": 359,
          "control_directory": "batch-a/Zr_agm003283597",
          "mapping_scope": "bounded ordered isostructural analogue",
          "all_three_symprec_support": true,
          "composition_edit": {
            "from": "Ti",
            "to": "Zr",
            "count": 1,
            "kind": "single_site_substitution"
          },
          "volume_target_over_control": 0.752966803638494,
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_all10": [
            4.425380107024551,
            7.936791357914469,
            7.612612612612593,
            6.755539542424784,
            5.759351059035608,
            4.851556842867496,
            4.10060142154184,
            3.4606205250596727,
            2.9398169547933644,
            2.4934871604019295
          ],
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_range": [
            2.4934871604019295,
            7.936791357914469
          ],
          "separate_source_Eli_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              19.962
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              13.386
            ]
          ],
          "separate_source_McM_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              16.842,
              18.124
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              11.339,
              12.171
            ]
          ],
          "literal_method_same_fields": {
            "ecutwfc": false,
            "smear": true,
            "degauss": true,
            "pseudo_dir": false
          },
          "qmesh_target_control": [
            [
              6.0,
              6.0,
              6.0
            ],
            [
              6.0,
              6.0,
              6.0
            ]
          ],
          "irreducible_qcount_target_control": [
            [
              16.0
            ],
            [
              16.0
            ]
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "nat": 1,
        "lambda10": [
          1.2294,
          1.209,
          1.1945,
          1.1852,
          1.1734,
          1.1584,
          1.1424,
          1.1271,
          1.1135,
          1.1016
        ],
        "omega10_K": [
          195.9419,
          195.4413,
          196.0944,
          196.6126,
          196.825,
          196.8118,
          196.5935,
          196.1811,
          195.6066,
          194.9123
        ],
        "Eli_mu01": [
          0.1,
          19.962
        ],
        "McM_mu01": [
          0.1,
          16.842,
          18.124
        ],
        "coarse_fine": [
          {
            "record": 2471,
            "version": [
              "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 15Mar2023 at 14: 7:44"
            ],
            "converged": true,
            "JOBDONE": true,
            "errors": 0,
            "Fmax_eVA": 0.0,
            "P_GPa": -0.001,
            "maxstress_GPa": 0.001,
            "fulltensor": [
              [
                -0.001,
                -0.0,
                -0.0
              ],
              [
                -0.0,
                -0.001,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                -0.0,
                0.0,
                -0.001
              ]
            ],
            "F_Ry": -118.59714519,
            "E_Ry": -118.59700254,
            "pattern_selected_warning_counts": {
              "BFGS": 1,
              "negative_charge": 0,
              "eigen_text": 0,
              "failure_text": 0,
              "SCF_correction_text": 1
            },
            "warning_scope": "pattern-selected contexts; informational SCF correction and ignored cell card are not optimization failure; no whole-file warning-free claim"
          },
          {
            "record": 2472,
            "version": [
              "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 15Mar2023 at 14: 5:27"
            ],
            "converged": true,
            "JOBDONE": true,
            "errors": 0,
            "Fmax_eVA": 0.0,
            "P_GPa": 0.019,
            "maxstress_GPa": 0.019,
            "fulltensor": [
              [
                0.019,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                0.019,
                -0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                -0.0,
                0.019
              ]
            ],
            "F_Ry": -118.59717478,
            "E_Ry": -118.59716610000001,
            "pattern_selected_warning_counts": {
              "BFGS": 1,
              "negative_charge": 0,
              "eigen_text": 0,
              "failure_text": 0,
              "SCF_correction_text": 1
            },
            "warning_scope": "pattern-selected contexts; informational SCF correction and ignored cell card are not optimization failure; no whole-file warning-free claim"
          }
        ],
        "inputs": [
          {
            "record": 2449,
            "ecutwfc": [
              92.0
            ],
            "ecutrho": null,
            "pseudo_dir": [
              "[private custody location omitted]"
            ],
            "spin": null,
            "noncol": null,
            "SOC": null,
            "charge": null,
            "smear": [
              "mp"
            ],
            "degauss": [
              0.014699728870262
            ],
            "ibrav": [
              2.0
            ],
            "nat": [
              1.0
            ],
            "grid": [
              "12 12 12 0 0 0"
            ]
          },
          {
            "record": 2450,
            "ecutwfc": [
              92.0
            ],
            "ecutrho": null,
            "pseudo_dir": [
              "[private custody location omitted]"
            ],
            "spin": null,
            "noncol": null,
            "SOC": null,
            "charge": null,
            "smear": [
              "mp"
            ],
            "degauss": [
              0.014699728870262
            ],
            "ibrav": [
              2.0
            ],
            "nat": [
              1.0
            ],
            "grid": [
              "48 48 48 0 0 0"
            ]
          }
        ],
        "Gamma": {
          "nat": 1,
          "ibrav": 2,
          "q": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species": [
            "Ti"
          ],
          "optical": "not_applicable_nat1",
          "minopt": null,
          "printingbound": 4.862279738391104e-13,
          "negative_native_modes": [
            1,
            2,
            3
          ],
          "negativeoutside3": [],
          "min_low3_translation": 1.0,
          "sourcepin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/Ti_agm002028410",
            "bytes": 1297,
            "sha256": "fb2e91cbafc018ba19ed207376d5a63df49029255360e5ec0d793ada938ea280"
          }
        },
        "path": {
          "rows": 202,
          "negatives": 0,
          "minimum": -0.0,
          "unit": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-2-compact-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 84096,
          "sha256": "d8ca53bafc5ee0879de647e050127d8e0d20c0e3da10de9602ab2de44bf77532",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-3-five-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 110335,
          "sha256": "861dd76c8368cca687ca20c8468e464badefb533a318ed41c4f8d62dccb6ed50",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-4-three-phase-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 64369,
          "sha256": "56076a077e591b9bdef8ada45d78f224f417a4af8d2e722e332f639eedfafaf7",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all64-light-Nb-rich-owned-review-cache-v2.json",
          "bytes": 4566542,
          "sha256": "f27e8c84c10c4d8de44022f6bd160e7e8aee8b2d562db5fd6003af68d5e35756",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to this reviewed candidate catalogue and mechanism contrast; MC2023 prediction is prior, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001116470",
      "formula": "Ti2NbTc",
      "reduced_formula": "Ti2NbTc",
      "composition": {
        "Nb": 1,
        "Tc": 1,
        "Ti": 2
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Nb:1|Tc:1|Ti:2",
      "elements": [
        "Nb",
        "Tc",
        "Ti"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001116470",
      "control_state": "agm001116458",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Ti2NbTc_agm001116470",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Ti2NbRe_agm001116458",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "CIF_source_record": 14061,
        "CIF_payload_pin": {
          "bytes": 591661,
          "sha256": "93c3ce21c362fc36392db6d13f4555d76cce96122769d1212414bbc770f81541"
        },
        "SCF_coarse_source_record": 14081,
        "Gamma_source_pin": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/Ti2NbTc_agm001116470",
          "bytes": 8994,
          "sha256": "83d5d9f3b1841c9a67ff92ba41ac2ab8bcd9bee03277e6377b04b2f8fd7bc283"
        },
        "source_input_volume_difference_relative": -1.9524937222570315e-11,
        "occupancy_model_all1": true,
        "bounded_signed_axis_and_translation_mapping": {
          "signed_axis_U_CIF_fractional_to_SCF": [
            [
              1,
              0,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              1,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              0,
              1
            ]
          ],
          "determinant": 1,
          "origin_shift_fractional": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            5.051260965061033e-09
          ],
          "species_bijection_CIF_to_SCF": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            3
          ],
          "maximum_site_distance_A": 4.6089958099165923e-08,
          "relative_Gram_residual": 7.210985349017258e-10,
          "proper_signed_axis_solution": true
        },
        "attempts": 1,
        "general_GL3_or_chiral_equivalence_asserted": false,
        "CIF_site_precision_A_tolerance": 1e-05,
        "physical_model": "source finite neutral scalar EPC; no SOC transfer certificate"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 12.444,
        "control_K": 12.041,
        "delta_K": 0.40300000000000047,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.04269999999999996,
          0.03379999999999994,
          0.030100000000000016,
          0.03599999999999992,
          0.04380000000000006,
          0.050899999999999945,
          0.05669999999999997,
          0.06169999999999998,
          0.06559999999999999,
          0.06879999999999997
        ],
        "range": [
          0.030100000000000016,
          0.06879999999999997
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Small coherent gain +.0301…+.0688 lambda and Tc+.403 K is not a calibrated physical significance claim. Path0/Gammaopt+, low coarse residual and fine force .0375/stress .364 GPa support only finite-source local basin. Geoopt BFGS failure is retained. Tc radioactivity, heavy-Re scalar/SOC differential and weak benefit are material-specific refinement risks.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse force 6.81342394061318e-05 eV/Å, pressure 0.0 GPa; fine force 0.037504684913858284 eV/Å, pressure -0.191 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
      "route_response": "Re-to-Tc ordered role change in Ti2NbX. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
      "next_action": "Resolve Tc/Re site mode and Coulomb/SOC sensitivity. Favorable: small paired role gain remains under justified corrections; adverse: sign reversal; ambiguous: uncertainty exceeds response. Do not award high n from electron counting.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact source CIF/SCF/Γ state association; CIF source record 14061. Experimental occupancy/P/T and physical magnetic ground state remain unknown; source scalar model only.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Re-to-Tc ordered role change in Ti2NbX. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
        "pairing_relevance": "direct published source EPC plus independent source isotropic Eliashberg result.  favorable comparator(s); bounded source model, not experiment.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse force 6.81342394061318e-05 eV/Å, pressure 0.0 GPa; fine force 0.037504684913858284 eV/Å, pressure -0.191 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Small coherent gain +.0301…+.0688 lambda and Tc+.403 K is not a calibrated physical significance claim. Path0/Gammaopt+, low coarse residual and fine force .0375/stress .364 GPa support only finite-source local basin. Geoopt BFGS failure is retained. Tc radioactivity, heavy-Re scalar/SOC differential and weak benefit are material-specific refinement risks.",
        "novelty": "No exact experimental Ti2NbTc SG123 phase retrieved. Nb-Ti-Ta wire chemistry and Re-alloy superconductivity do not identify this phase.",
        "decision": "Resolve Tc/Re site mode and Coulomb/SOC sensitivity. Favorable: small paired role gain remains under justified corrections; adverse: sign reversal; ambiguous: uncertainty exceeds response. Do not award high n from electron counting."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "residual_force_stress",
        "technetium"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 301,
          "control": "batch-a/Ti2NbRe_agm001116458",
          "target": "batch-a/Ti2NbTc_agm001116470",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.030100000000000016,
            0.06879999999999997
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            3.251242168934977,
            7.667446784798838
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 12.444,
          "Tc_control_K": 12.041,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 0.40300000000000047,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9933669734172772,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.1114592392281823e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001116458",
            "dyn0_source_record": 15825,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              5.0,
              5.0,
              2.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 15832,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 11,
                "source_record": 15833,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 12,
                "source_record": 15834,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 15835,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 15836,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 15837,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 15838,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 15839,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 15840,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 15841,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 15842,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 15843,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.030100000000000016,
            0.06879999999999997
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-02-eleven-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1219201,
          "sha256": "ee658cb8e6309178e268b736f8aeb6429c030a92019c068963e2d64ca51cbb17",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-03-fifteen-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1347056,
          "sha256": "1be9342cb74006b2542e9351fc2de310967f1a31a5ee9f1909ae730b9a11476a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-remaining-transition-owned-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 5381838,
          "sha256": "62f4910578c7b65392d26619cf81b31afd6142f38aa49834a70bb147e7ab222d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to the reviewed candidate mechanism catalogue, source prediction already published; not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm002244680",
      "formula": "Ti2Re",
      "reduced_formula": "Ti2Re",
      "composition": {
        "Re": 1,
        "Ti": 2
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Re:1|Ti:2",
      "elements": [
        "Re",
        "Ti"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm002244680",
      "control_state": "agm001850181",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Ti2Re_agm002244680",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Ti2Tc_agm001850181",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "CIF_source_record": 11733,
        "CIF_payload_pin": {
          "bytes": 591661,
          "sha256": "93c3ce21c362fc36392db6d13f4555d76cce96122769d1212414bbc770f81541"
        },
        "SCF_coarse_source_record": 11754,
        "Gamma_source_pin": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/Ti2Re_agm002244680",
          "bytes": 5503,
          "sha256": "8be846f07c16ec027023553295ba72632c240e3a16fb387c05a0567e19d20953"
        },
        "source_input_volume_difference_relative": 3.2063907084989296e-11,
        "occupancy_model_all1": true,
        "bounded_signed_axis_and_translation_mapping": {
          "signed_axis_U_CIF_fractional_to_SCF": [
            [
              1,
              0,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              1,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              0,
              1
            ]
          ],
          "determinant": 1,
          "origin_shift_fractional": [
            1.47370697153721e-34,
            -1.5542569453685928e-09,
            -1.5542569453685928e-09
          ],
          "species_bijection_CIF_to_SCF": [
            0,
            1,
            2
          ],
          "maximum_site_distance_A": 7.118414219106914e-08,
          "relative_Gram_residual": 2.0994080977357881e-10,
          "proper_signed_axis_solution": true
        },
        "attempts": 1,
        "general_GL3_or_chiral_equivalence_asserted": false,
        "CIF_site_precision_A_tolerance": 1e-05,
        "physical_model": "source finite neutral scalar EPC; no SOC transfer certificate"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 13.454,
        "control_K": 12.646,
        "delta_K": 0.8079999999999998,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.10819999999999985,
          0.11719999999999997,
          0.13240000000000007,
          0.1251000000000001,
          0.11080000000000001,
          0.09670000000000001,
          0.08490000000000009,
          0.07520000000000004,
          0.06720000000000004,
          0.06059999999999999
        ],
        "range": [
          0.06059999999999999,
          0.13240000000000007
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "All-token lambda gain +.0606…+.1324 and Tc+.808 K accompanies path0/Gammaopt+. Geoopt BFGS failure has small final printed force2.75e-5; fine force .02614/stress .126 GPa are explicit. Ti2W is better source response but has negative path and is not hidden. Heavy Re/SOC may change small benefit.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse force 2.5968144075544575e-05 eV/Å, pressure 0.0 GPa; fine force 0.026138094008553832 eV/Å, pressure 0.05600000000000001 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
      "route_response": "Tc-to-Re role modification in Ti2X. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
      "next_action": "Resolve Ti/Re/Tc EPC modes and differential SOC/Coulomb sensitivity. Favorable: small coherent source gain remains; adverse: relevant correction reverses sign or unstable branch is required; ambiguous: no matched mode evidence.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact source CIF/SCF/Γ state association; CIF source record 11733. Experimental occupancy/P/T and physical magnetic ground state remain unknown; source scalar model only.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Tc-to-Re role modification in Ti2X. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
        "pairing_relevance": "direct published source EPC plus independent source isotropic Eliashberg result.  favorable comparator(s); bounded source model, not experiment.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse force 2.5968144075544575e-05 eV/Å, pressure 0.0 GPa; fine force 0.026138094008553832 eV/Å, pressure 0.05600000000000001 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "All-token lambda gain +.0606…+.1324 and Tc+.808 K accompanies path0/Gammaopt+. Geoopt BFGS failure has small final printed force2.75e-5; fine force .02614/stress .126 GPa are explicit. Ti2W is better source response but has negative path and is not hidden. Heavy Re/SOC may change small benefit.",
        "novelty": "Experimental Re7Ti3 and other Re-Ti stoichiometries are known superconductors, not Ti2Re SG139. Exact current experimental phase not retrieved.",
        "decision": "Resolve Ti/Re/Tc EPC modes and differential SOC/Coulomb sensitivity. Favorable: small coherent source gain remains; adverse: relevant correction reverses sign or unstable branch is required; ambiguous: no matched mode evidence."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "residual_force_stress"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 303,
          "control": "batch-a/Ti2Tc_agm001850181",
          "target": "batch-a/Ti2Re_agm002244680",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.06059999999999999,
            0.13240000000000007
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            8.32875206157229,
            13.9736147757256
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 13.454,
          "Tc_control_K": 12.646,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 0.8079999999999998,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.014590345092959,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 2.580533553149428e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001850181",
            "dyn0_source_record": 15130,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 15137,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 11,
                "source_record": 15138,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 12,
                "source_record": 15139,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 13,
                "source_record": 15140,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 15141,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 15142,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 15143,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 15144,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 15145,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 15146,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 15147,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 15148,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 15149,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.06059999999999999,
            0.13240000000000007
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 304,
          "control": "batch-a/Ti2W_agm001850171",
          "target": "batch-a/Ti2Re_agm002244680",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.9544999999999999,
            -0.7479
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -48.68823644293992,
            -44.75649682832003
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 13.454,
          "Tc_control_K": 20.034,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": -6.579999999999998,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": true,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.962613539088452,
          "control_path_negatives": 3,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 2.368730976343465e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 3,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -1.3722,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001850171",
            "dyn0_source_record": 2572,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 2579,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 11,
                "source_record": 2580,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 12,
                "source_record": 2581,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 13,
                "source_record": 2582,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 2583,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 2584,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 2585,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 2586,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 2587,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 2588,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 2589,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 2590,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 2591,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.9544999999999999,
            -0.7479
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-02-eleven-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1219201,
          "sha256": "ee658cb8e6309178e268b736f8aeb6429c030a92019c068963e2d64ca51cbb17",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-03-fifteen-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1347056,
          "sha256": "1be9342cb74006b2542e9351fc2de310967f1a31a5ee9f1909ae730b9a11476a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-remaining-transition-owned-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 5381838,
          "sha256": "62f4910578c7b65392d26619cf81b31afd6142f38aa49834a70bb147e7ab222d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to the reviewed candidate mechanism catalogue, source prediction already published; not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001116173",
      "formula": "Ti2ZrW",
      "reduced_formula": "Ti2ZrW",
      "composition": {
        "Ti": 2,
        "W": 1,
        "Zr": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Ti:2|W:1|Zr:1",
      "elements": [
        "Ti",
        "W",
        "Zr"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001116173",
      "control_state": "agm001116062",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Ti2ZrW_agm001116173",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/ScTi2W_agm001116062",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "CIF_source_record": 3261,
        "CIF_payload_pin": {
          "bytes": 591661,
          "sha256": "93c3ce21c362fc36392db6d13f4555d76cce96122769d1212414bbc770f81541"
        },
        "SCF_coarse_source_record": 3281,
        "Gamma_source_pin": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/Ti2ZrW_agm001116173",
          "bytes": 8994,
          "sha256": "3cb583f326e7f49ed09ca4f0deec467cb42f6598806d5b6575271e63dc16fb53"
        },
        "source_input_volume_difference_relative": 5.075073694627008e-11,
        "occupancy_model_all1": true,
        "bounded_signed_axis_and_translation_mapping": {
          "signed_axis_U_CIF_fractional_to_SCF": [
            [
              1,
              0,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              1,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              0,
              1
            ]
          ],
          "determinant": 1,
          "origin_shift_fractional": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species_bijection_CIF_to_SCF": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            3
          ],
          "maximum_site_distance_A": 1.9642774577907088e-16,
          "relative_Gram_residual": 6.870326765964499e-10,
          "proper_signed_axis_solution": true
        },
        "attempts": 1,
        "general_GL3_or_chiral_equivalence_asserted": false,
        "CIF_site_precision_A_tolerance": 1e-05,
        "physical_model": "source finite neutral scalar EPC; no SOC transfer certificate"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 18.34,
        "control_K": 13.43,
        "delta_K": 4.91,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.24970000000000003,
          0.21079999999999988,
          0.1735,
          0.1632,
          0.16570000000000018,
          0.16809999999999992,
          0.16500000000000004,
          0.15629999999999988,
          0.14380000000000015,
          0.12939999999999996
        ],
        "range": [
          0.12939999999999996,
          0.24970000000000003
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "All-tokenlambda+.1294…+.2497 andsourceTc+4.910K supportsfinitepairedroute;path0/Gammaopt+, fineforce .016585/stress .088GPa. GeooptBFGSfailureisspecificretainedmessagewithsmallfinalprintedforce .00010259 andnearzero coarse stress; notpurportedfine-gridoptimization. Chemistry/mass/volume rolecoupled,nothighcarrier-densityclaim.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse force 0.00010130147292836201 eV/Å, pressure 0.0 GPa; fine force 0.016584645202464627 eV/Å, pressure 0.02 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
      "route_response": "Sc-to-Zr role substitution in ordered Ti2XW. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
      "next_action": "Resolve Sc/Zrrole EPCandfine-force projection. Favorable: controlledlocalgainpersistsunderjustifiedgeometryuncertainty; adverse: relevantrelaxation/channel reverses; ambiguous: no matchedmodeevidence.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact source CIF/SCF/Γ state association; CIF source record 3261. Experimental occupancy/P/T and physical magnetic ground state remain unknown; source scalar model only.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Sc-to-Zr role substitution in ordered Ti2XW. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
        "pairing_relevance": "direct published source EPC plus independent source isotropic Eliashberg result.  favorable comparator(s); bounded source model, not experiment.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse force 0.00010130147292836201 eV/Å, pressure 0.0 GPa; fine force 0.016584645202464627 eV/Å, pressure 0.02 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "All-tokenlambda+.1294…+.2497 andsourceTc+4.910K supportsfinitepairedroute;path0/Gammaopt+, fineforce .016585/stress .088GPa. GeooptBFGSfailureisspecificretainedmessagewithsmallfinalprintedforce .00010259 andnearzero coarse stress; notpurportedfine-gridoptimization. Chemistry/mass/volume rolecoupled,nothighcarrier-densityclaim.",
        "novelty": "NoexactexperimentalTi2ZrWSG123phase retrieved. Nb/Ti/Zrrefractoryalloypriorsare differentstates; sourceproposalalreadyknown.",
        "decision": "Resolve Sc/Zrrole EPCandfine-force projection. Favorable: controlledlocalgainpersistsunderjustifiedgeometryuncertainty; adverse: relevantrelaxation/channel reverses; ambiguous: no matchedmodeevidence."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "residual_force_stress",
        "sampling_method"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 256,
          "control": "batch-a/ScTi2W_agm001116062",
          "target": "batch-a/Ti2ZrW_agm001116173",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.12939999999999996,
            0.24970000000000003
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            12.119509225437852,
            18.08764940239044
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 18.34,
          "Tc_control_K": 13.43,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 4.91,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9806732812028716,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.2758926075883155e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001116062",
            "dyn0_source_record": 11981,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              5.0,
              5.0,
              2.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 11988,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 11,
                "source_record": 11989,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 12,
                "source_record": 11990,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 11991,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 11992,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 11993,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 11994,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 11995,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 11996,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 11997,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 11998,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 11999,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.12939999999999996,
            0.24970000000000003
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-02-eleven-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1219201,
          "sha256": "ee658cb8e6309178e268b736f8aeb6429c030a92019c068963e2d64ca51cbb17",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-03-fifteen-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1347056,
          "sha256": "1be9342cb74006b2542e9351fc2de310967f1a31a5ee9f1909ae730b9a11476a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-remaining-transition-owned-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 5381838,
          "sha256": "62f4910578c7b65392d26619cf81b31afd6142f38aa49834a70bb147e7ab222d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to the reviewed candidate mechanism catalogue, source prediction already published; not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm002190754",
      "formula": "Ti3Ge",
      "reduced_formula": "Ti3Ge",
      "composition": {
        "Ge": 1,
        "Ti": 3
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Ge:1|Ti:3",
      "elements": [
        "Ge",
        "Ti"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm002190754",
      "control_state": "agm002190808",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Ti3Ge_agm002190754",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Ti3Sn_agm002190808",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": "weighted_phonon_log_moment_net_pairing",
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 223. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": [
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.0001,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 223,
          "hall_number": 520,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "a",
            "a"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            6,
            6
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.0001,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 223,
          "hall_number": 520,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "a",
            "a"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            6,
            6
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.001,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 223,
          "hall_number": 520,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "a",
            "a"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            6,
            6
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.001,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 223,
          "hall_number": 520,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "a",
            "a"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            6,
            6
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.01,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 223,
          "hall_number": 520,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "a",
            "a"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            6,
            6
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.01,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 223,
          "hall_number": 520,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "a",
            "a"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            6,
            6
          ]
        }
      ],
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 16.928,
        "control_K": 13.176,
        "delta_K": 3.7520000000000007,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          -0.12939999999999996,
          -0.10740000000000016,
          -0.09689999999999999,
          -0.07789999999999986,
          -0.06040000000000001,
          -0.0484,
          -0.04060000000000008,
          -0.03539999999999999,
          -0.03159999999999996,
          -0.02859999999999996
        ],
        "range": [
          -0.12939999999999996,
          -0.02859999999999996
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": [
        1.4026034301604482,
        1.4060637450146158,
        1.4032763231279342,
        1.3953978464476438,
        1.3878868667678674,
        1.3825681804710312,
        1.3789824405754494,
        1.376258437378764,
        1.3738671218285186,
        1.3716134854671007
      ],
      "risk_summary": "All three frozen Ti3Ni/Ti3Sn/Ti3Te neighbors remain. The Ge target has the highest separate source Eli response among these four, and the Sn-controlled header proxy remains positive for μ*=.1/.15/.2.",
      "ambient_scope": "The exact source neutral zero-applied-pressure model has positive Γ optical compression intervals and no negative retained sampled path value for target and selected control. Coarse/fine force and full stress, relaxation warnings and every q record are retained. These finite observations do not prove full-BZ or thermodynamic hull stability.",
      "route_response": "Ge-for-Sn on the A15 B role increases ωlog by 37.16–40.61% at all ten common integration tokens despite lowering λ by .0286–.1294; this is a coupled role-substitution hypothesis, not an isolated isotope effect.",
      "next_action": "Compare saved α²F cumulative λ and logarithmic moment for Ge/Sn under their exact source geometry; discriminate a shift of coupling to higher frequencies from a change of electronic matrix elements. Code-version and finite integration uncertainty stay explicit.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact agm002190754 ordered coordinates, species and metric are linked through source CIF→coarse/fine input→Γ header; actual bounded association residuals and original record IDs are retained below. This is not an experimental structure certificate.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Ge-for-Sn on the A15 B role increases ωlog by 37.16–40.61% at all ten common integration tokens despite lowering λ by .0286–.1294; this is a coupled role-substitution hypothesis, not an isolated isotope effect.",
        "pairing_relevance": "Separate source Eli gain 3.752 K is retained with source McMillan/AD. Actual source-header descriptor reproduces the first McMillan column to printed precision. Header-to-ten-σ and Eli-to-σ association remains null, and ωlog is α²F weighted rather than an assertion that all bare modes harden.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "The exact source neutral zero-applied-pressure model has positive Γ optical compression intervals and no negative retained sampled path value for target and selected control. Coarse/fine force and full stress, relaxation warnings and every q record are retained. These finite observations do not prove full-BZ or thermodynamic hull stability.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "All three frozen Ti3Ni/Ti3Sn/Ti3Te neighbors remain. The Ge target has the highest separate source Eli response among these four, and the Sn-controlled header proxy remains positive for μ*=.1/.15/.2.",
        "novelty": "Ti3Ge is already a published calculated proposal. The source ordered A15 state can be new to the reviewed catalogue; no exact experimental superconducting phase was identified by the bounded review.",
        "decision": "Supported as a private finite-source hypothesis at the printed μ*=.1 under the neutral scalar NC/PBEsol approximation; no calibrated physical probability or public score."
      },
      "risk_tags": [],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 306,
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Ti3Ge_agm002190754",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Ti3Ni_agm002190774",
          "other_state": "batch-a/Ti3Ni_agm002190774",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "source_Eli_gain_target_minus_other_K": 2.9620000000000015,
          "other_printed_path_negative_values": 0,
          "other_q_sampling_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm002190774",
            "dyn0_source_record": 9763,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 9770,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 9771,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 9772,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 9773,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.13929999999999998,
            -0.021499999999999853
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 307,
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Ti3Ge_agm002190754",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Ti3Sn_agm002190808",
          "other_state": "batch-a/Ti3Sn_agm002190808",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "source_Eli_gain_target_minus_other_K": 3.7520000000000007,
          "other_printed_path_negative_values": 0,
          "other_q_sampling_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm002190808",
            "dyn0_source_record": 12015,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 12022,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 12023,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 12024,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 12025,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.12939999999999996,
            -0.02859999999999996
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 308,
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Ti3Ge_agm002190754",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Ti3Te_agm002190814",
          "other_state": "batch-a/Ti3Te_agm002190814",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "source_Eli_gain_target_minus_other_K": 1.0260000000000016,
          "other_printed_path_negative_values": 0,
          "other_q_sampling_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm002190814",
            "dyn0_source_record": 6341,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 6348,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 6349,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 6350,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 6351,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.09870000000000001,
            0.007199999999999984
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "directory_key": "batch-a/Ti3Ge_agm002190754",
        "source_ID": "agm002190754",
        "composition": {
          "Ge": 1,
          "Ti": 3
        },
        "listed_sites": 8,
        "CIF_source_record": 4985,
        "source_McMillan_and_AD_mu0p1": {
          "value": [
            0.1,
            14.441,
            15.306
          ],
          "missing_tokens": [
            false,
            false,
            false
          ],
          "printed_zero": [
            false,
            false,
            false
          ]
        },
        "source_Eli_mu0p1": {
          "value": [
            0.1,
            16.928
          ],
          "missing_tokens": [
            false,
            false
          ],
          "printed_zero": [
            false,
            false
          ]
        },
        "SCF_coarse": {
          "source_record": 5007,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.6.8 starts on  1Oct2022 at  0:14:40"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 5,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000000     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 8,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6,
              7,
              8
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 0.0,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.0,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.0,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                -0.0
              ],
              "atom_index": 1,
              "type_index": 2
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": -0.02,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "-0.02",
              "GPa": -0.002
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.02"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    -1.6e-07,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.02,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -1.6e-07,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.02,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -1.6e-07,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.02
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  -0.002,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.002,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  -0.002
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": -0.02,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.002,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
          "native_exit_status": null
        },
        "SCF_fine": {
          "source_record": 5008,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.6.8 starts on 30Sep2022 at 22:40:57"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 12,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 7,
              "last": {
                "value": "c_bands:  1 eigenvalues not converged"
              }
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000000     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 8,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6,
              7,
              8
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 0.0,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.0,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.0,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              "atom_index": 1,
              "type_index": 2
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": -0.7,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "-0.70",
              "GPa": -0.06999999999999999
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.70"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    -4.76e-06,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.7,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -4.76e-06,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.7,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -4.76e-06,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.7
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  -0.06999999999999999,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.06999999999999999,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  -0.06999999999999999
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": -0.6999999999999998,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.06999999999999999,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
          "native_exit_status": null
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/Ti3Ge_agm002190754",
            "bytes": 31828,
            "sha256": "9728a57ad704482cee66885d2c562c3b107284f9539957201ded708879f4d207"
          },
          "raw_optical_minimum": 1.5458756689640685e-06,
          "raw_optical_printing_intervals": [
            [
              1.5458721107846993e-06,
              1.5458792271434376e-06
            ],
            [
              1.5458721107847006e-06,
              1.545879227143439e-06
            ],
            [
              1.545872110784701e-06,
              1.5458792271434393e-06
            ],
            [
              1.890438083878681e-06,
              1.8904452002374193e-06
            ],
            [
              1.8904380838786827e-06,
              1.890445200237421e-06
            ],
            [
              1.8904380838786841e-06,
              1.8904452002374225e-06
            ],
            [
              2.0694383088782974e-06,
              2.069445425237036e-06
            ],
            [
              2.0694383088782996e-06,
              2.0694454252370383e-06
            ],
            [
              2.0694383088782996e-06,
              2.0694454252370383e-06
            ],
            [
              2.2907245175661207e-06,
              2.2907316339248594e-06
            ],
            [
              2.2907245175661228e-06,
              2.2907316339248615e-06
            ],
            [
              2.290724517566124e-06,
              2.290731633924863e-06
            ],
            [
              4.046688301578077e-06,
              4.0466954179368146e-06
            ],
            [
              4.0466883015780775e-06,
              4.046695417936815e-06
            ],
            [
              4.046688301578079e-06,
              4.046695417936817e-06
            ],
            [
              4.355437264510864e-06,
              4.355444380869602e-06
            ],
            [
              4.355437264510866e-06,
              4.355444380869604e-06
            ],
            [
              4.355437264510866e-06,
              4.355444380869604e-06
            ],
            [
              7.86710634418994e-06,
              7.867113460548678e-06
            ],
            [
              7.867106344189945e-06,
              7.867113460548683e-06
            ],
            [
              9.355062446833995e-06,
              9.355069563192733e-06
            ]
          ],
          "unit": "squared source-Ry frequency convention",
          "native_negative_mode_numbers": [
            1,
            2,
            3
          ],
          "physical_error_bar": null,
          "full_BZ": null
        },
        "retained_path": {
          "kind": "qe_freq_gp_source_path_table",
          "raw_header_lines": [],
          "path_rows": 99,
          "column_width_counts": {
            "25": 99
          },
          "mode_column_values": 2376,
          "negative_printed_values": 0,
          "minimum_printed_mode": {
            "value": -0.0,
            "column_index_zero_based": 1
          },
          "frequency_unit_header": null,
          "column_roles_conditional_on_file_schema": true,
          "fullBZ_coverage": null,
          "dynamical_stability": null,
          "state_link_verified": null
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm002190754",
          "dyn0_source_record": 4995,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                3.0,
                3.0,
                3.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                4.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 5002,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 5003,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 5004,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 5005,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 4,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        },
        "unknowns": {
          "physical_mobile_carrier_density": null,
          "active_orbital_bandwidth": null,
          "public_RPS": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-01-eight-actual-omega-net-pairing-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1213076,
          "sha256": "ae6bc2be8e022ea5308483e2f63d28dfc4565f2cfa13948c036a16368c5f6201",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all62-net-pairing-owned-source-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 4086409,
          "sha256": "bced95fc8c75035eb57c3afbae73d98e099c3e732ef1e07a1836df54a1d60e15",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-owned-62-source-observations-for-Tc-header-readback-v1.json",
          "bytes": 10632536,
          "sha256": "35c5bfdd77eb7194ebebc41802600580a842c5526c8727c40a427c8869890d90",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Published source predictions already known; specific matched mechanism new to reviewed catalogue, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm002190757",
      "formula": "Ti3Hf",
      "reduced_formula": "Ti3Hf",
      "composition": {
        "Hf": 1,
        "Ti": 3
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Hf:1|Ti:3",
      "elements": [
        "Hf",
        "Ti"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm002190757",
      "control_state": "agm001229341",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Ti3Hf_agm002190757",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/TiZr2Hf_agm001229341",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "CIF_source_record": 2945,
        "CIF_payload_pin": {
          "bytes": 591661,
          "sha256": "93c3ce21c362fc36392db6d13f4555d76cce96122769d1212414bbc770f81541"
        },
        "SCF_coarse_source_record": 2963,
        "Gamma_source_pin": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/Ti3Hf_agm002190757",
          "bytes": 8948,
          "sha256": "903599df9e62cef388489ba919cee07dead1edd676fe6b55e58b657c95e8f5d8"
        },
        "source_input_volume_difference_relative": 5.263567359747867e-12,
        "occupancy_model_all1": true,
        "bounded_signed_axis_and_translation_mapping": {
          "signed_axis_U_CIF_fractional_to_SCF": [
            [
              1,
              0,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              1,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              0,
              1
            ]
          ],
          "determinant": 1,
          "origin_shift_fractional": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species_bijection_CIF_to_SCF": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            3
          ],
          "maximum_site_distance_A": 3.3396409723832607e-16,
          "relative_Gram_residual": 1.4767967251134099e-09,
          "proper_signed_axis_solution": true
        },
        "attempts": 1,
        "general_GL3_or_chiral_equivalence_asserted": false,
        "CIF_site_precision_A_tolerance": 1e-05,
        "physical_model": "source finite neutral scalar EPC; no SOC transfer certificate"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 18.802,
        "control_K": 14.171,
        "delta_K": 4.631,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.21389999999999998,
          0.20140000000000002,
          0.19489999999999985,
          0.17409999999999992,
          0.15369999999999995,
          0.13790000000000013,
          0.1258999999999999,
          0.11609999999999987,
          0.10759999999999992,
          0.0999000000000001
        ],
        "range": [
          0.0999000000000001,
          0.21389999999999998
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "The matched all-Ti role substitution improves source pairing strongly, while Ti3Zr is a mixed-sign lambda control with only 0.05 K Tc change. Thus role/chemistry and 23% original graph volume change must be retained together; not an isolated geometry or mass cause. Target SCF forces are zero. Finite cubic local minimum does not prove thermodynamic ordering.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.002 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure 0.118 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
      "route_response": "Zr-to-Ti role replacement in cubic Ti3Hf/Zr3Hf framework. coupled chemical/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
      "next_action": "Use existing same-prototype electronic/mode data to separate Ti/Hf role response from volume, then phase-ordering evidence. Favorable: direct paired gain persists on the exact ordered branch; adverse: disorder or another phase destroys the relevant active network; ambiguous: nominal count/shorter bonds alone.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact source CIF/SCF/Γ state association; CIF source record 2945. Experimental occupancy/P/T and physical magnetic ground state remain unknown; source scalar model only.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Zr-to-Ti role replacement in cubic Ti3Hf/Zr3Hf framework. coupled chemical/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
        "pairing_relevance": "direct published source EPC and independent source isotropic Eliashberg result. 2 favorable comparator(s); bounded source model, not experiment.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.002 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure 0.118 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "The matched all-Ti role substitution improves source pairing strongly, while Ti3Zr is a mixed-sign lambda control with only 0.05 K Tc change. Thus role/chemistry and 23% original graph volume change must be retained together; not an isolated geometry or mass cause. Target SCF forces are zero. Finite cubic local minimum does not prove thermodynamic ordering.",
        "novelty": "Exact Ti3Hf/HfTi3 ordered-phase query found no primary exact superconducting phase. Closest identified literature concerns ordinary refractory solid-solution chemistry; current SG221 ordered source object is distinct from hcp/bcc disordered alloys. Worldwide novelty remains unproved.",
        "decision": "Use existing same-prototype electronic/mode data to separate Ti/Hf role response from volume, then phase-ordering evidence. Favorable: direct paired gain persists on the exact ordered branch; adverse: disorder or another phase destroys the relevant active network; ambiguous: nominal count/shorter bonds alone."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase",
        "residual_force_stress"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 309,
          "control": "batch-a/Ti3Zr_agm002190827",
          "target": "batch-a/Ti3Hf_agm002190757",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.013800000000000034,
            0.02839999999999998
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -1.1709800593975421,
            2.1459876076771938
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 18.802,
          "Tc_control_K": 18.752,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 0.05000000000000071,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9918918036079947,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.3575505487995628e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.013800000000000034,
            0.02839999999999998
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 310,
          "control": "batch-a/TiZr2Hf_agm001229341",
          "target": "batch-a/Ti3Hf_agm002190757",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.0999000000000001,
            0.21389999999999998
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            9.38204357625846,
            17.805710480312992
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 18.802,
          "Tc_control_K": 14.171,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 4.631,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": false,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.8651881606932853,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 8.399491635131153e-07,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.0999000000000001,
            0.21389999999999998
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 311,
          "control": "batch-a/Zr3Hf_agm001190885",
          "target": "batch-a/Ti3Hf_agm002190757",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.15400000000000014,
            0.3356000000000001
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            15.236964480063335,
            31.08558725453873
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 18.802,
          "Tc_control_K": 12.514,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 6.288,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.8112083629284785,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 8.296086237767607e-07,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.15400000000000014,
            0.3356000000000001
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-01-ten-specific-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 381754,
          "sha256": "5d05478212c4d22080ab1b7bf22d92b784de6c0f8a99590d0758f9cdbfdafb32",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-remaining-transition-owned-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 5381838,
          "sha256": "62f4910578c7b65392d26619cf81b31afd6142f38aa49834a70bb147e7ab222d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to the reviewed candidate mechanism catalogue, source prediction already published; not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm002190814",
      "formula": "Ti3Te",
      "reduced_formula": "Ti3Te",
      "composition": {
        "Te": 1,
        "Ti": 3
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Te:1|Ti:3",
      "elements": [
        "Te",
        "Ti"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm002190814",
      "control_state": "agm002190808",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Ti3Te_agm002190814",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Ti3Sn_agm002190808",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": "weighted_phonon_log_moment_net_pairing",
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 223. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": [
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.0001,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 223,
          "hall_number": 520,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "a",
            "a"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            6,
            6
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.0001,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 223,
          "hall_number": 520,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "a",
            "a"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            6,
            6
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.001,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 223,
          "hall_number": 520,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "a",
            "a"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            6,
            6
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.001,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 223,
          "hall_number": 520,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "a",
            "a"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            6,
            6
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.01,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 223,
          "hall_number": 520,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "a",
            "a"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            6,
            6
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.01,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 223,
          "hall_number": 520,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c",
            "a",
            "a"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0,
            6,
            6
          ]
        }
      ],
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 15.902,
        "control_K": 13.176,
        "delta_K": 2.725999999999999,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          -0.03069999999999995,
          -0.03869999999999996,
          -0.007200000000000095,
          0.00770000000000004,
          0.0043999999999999595,
          -0.006699999999999928,
          -0.018200000000000105,
          -0.026999999999999913,
          -0.03269999999999995,
          -0.03579999999999994
        ],
        "range": [
          -0.03869999999999996,
          0.00770000000000004
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": [
        1.2329407055713115,
        1.2424313030534417,
        1.2421402986147438,
        1.235912773459094,
        1.2279432313321899,
        1.2211770637176131,
        1.2162266826837458,
        1.2125613671485818,
        1.2095731574286777,
        1.2069138968213997
      ],
      "risk_summary": "Ti3Ge has a still higher source response and is retained as the reverse comparison. Ti3Ni is also retained. Source McMillan, Allen–Dynes and Eli outputs all favor Te versus Sn, and the separate-header proxy is positive at the three declared μ sensitivities.",
      "ambient_scope": "The exact source neutral zero-applied-pressure model has positive Γ optical compression intervals and no negative retained sampled path value for target and selected control. Coarse/fine force and full stress, relaxation warnings and every q record are retained. These finite observations do not prove full-BZ or thermodynamic hull stability.",
      "route_response": "Te-for-Sn on the A15 B role raises weighted ωlog by 20.69–24.24% with a mixed λ change −.0387…+.0077. A heavier element raises the coupled weighted moment here, showing that bare mass alone does not explain the response.",
      "next_action": "Use exact-state saved mode weights or α²F to determine whether the log-moment gain comes from altered coupling weights rather than bare phonon stiffening; preserve the omission of explicit SOC in the bounded scalar model.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact agm002190814 ordered coordinates, species and metric are linked through source CIF→coarse/fine input→Γ header; actual bounded association residuals and original record IDs are retained below. This is not an experimental structure certificate.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Te-for-Sn on the A15 B role raises weighted ωlog by 20.69–24.24% with a mixed λ change −.0387…+.0077. A heavier element raises the coupled weighted moment here, showing that bare mass alone does not explain the response.",
        "pairing_relevance": "Separate source Eli gain 2.726 K is retained with source McMillan/AD. Actual source-header descriptor reproduces the first McMillan column to printed precision. Header-to-ten-σ and Eli-to-σ association remains null, and ωlog is α²F weighted rather than an assertion that all bare modes harden.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "The exact source neutral zero-applied-pressure model has positive Γ optical compression intervals and no negative retained sampled path value for target and selected control. Coarse/fine force and full stress, relaxation warnings and every q record are retained. These finite observations do not prove full-BZ or thermodynamic hull stability.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Ti3Ge has a still higher source response and is retained as the reverse comparison. Ti3Ni is also retained. Source McMillan, Allen–Dynes and Eli outputs all favor Te versus Sn, and the separate-header proxy is positive at the three declared μ sensitivities.",
        "novelty": "The A15 Ti3Te hypothesis is a known published computational proposal. No world-first or experimental-validation claim is made; the catalogue object is the exact retained source state.",
        "decision": "Supported as a private finite-source hypothesis at the printed μ*=.1 under the neutral scalar NC/PBEsol approximation; no calibrated physical probability or public score."
      },
      "risk_tags": [],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 308,
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Ti3Ge_agm002190754",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Ti3Te_agm002190814",
          "other_state": "batch-a/Ti3Ge_agm002190754",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "source_Eli_gain_target_minus_other_K": -1.0260000000000016,
          "other_printed_path_negative_values": 0,
          "other_q_sampling_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm002190754",
            "dyn0_source_record": 4995,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 5002,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 5003,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 5004,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 5005,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.007199999999999984,
            0.09870000000000001
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 313,
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Ti3Ni_agm002190774",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Ti3Te_agm002190814",
          "other_state": "batch-a/Ti3Ni_agm002190774",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "source_Eli_gain_target_minus_other_K": 1.936,
          "other_printed_path_negative_values": 0,
          "other_q_sampling_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm002190774",
            "dyn0_source_record": 9763,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 9770,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 9771,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 9772,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 9773,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.14,
            0.06820000000000004
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 314,
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Ti3Sn_agm002190808",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/Ti3Te_agm002190814",
          "other_state": "batch-a/Ti3Sn_agm002190808",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "source_Eli_gain_target_minus_other_K": 2.725999999999999,
          "other_printed_path_negative_values": 0,
          "other_q_sampling_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm002190808",
            "dyn0_source_record": 12015,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 12022,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 12023,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 12024,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 12025,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.03869999999999996,
            0.00770000000000004
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "directory_key": "batch-a/Ti3Te_agm002190814",
        "source_ID": "agm002190814",
        "composition": {
          "Te": 1,
          "Ti": 3
        },
        "listed_sites": 8,
        "CIF_source_record": 6331,
        "source_McMillan_and_AD_mu0p1": {
          "value": [
            0.1,
            13.527,
            14.459
          ],
          "missing_tokens": [
            false,
            false,
            false
          ],
          "printed_zero": [
            false,
            false,
            false
          ]
        },
        "source_Eli_mu0p1": {
          "value": [
            0.1,
            15.902
          ],
          "missing_tokens": [
            false,
            false
          ],
          "printed_zero": [
            false,
            false
          ]
        },
        "SCF_coarse": {
          "source_record": 6353,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 12Mar2023 at 10:47:28"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 5,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000000     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 8,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6,
              7,
              8
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 0.0,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.0,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.0,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                0.0,
                -0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              "atom_index": 1,
              "type_index": 2
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "-0.00",
              "GPa": -0.0
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.00"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    -1e-08,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -1e-08,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -1e-08,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  -0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  -0.0
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": 0.0,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.0,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
          "native_exit_status": null
        },
        "SCF_fine": {
          "source_record": 6354,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 12Mar2023 at 10: 9: 9"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 63,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 58,
              "last": {
                "value": "c_bands:  1 eigenvalues not converged"
              }
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000000     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 8,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6,
              7,
              8
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 0.0,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.0,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.0,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                0.0,
                -0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              "atom_index": 1,
              "type_index": 2
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": 0.2,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "0.20",
              "GPa": 0.02
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=        0.20"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    1.39e-06,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.2,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    1.39e-06,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.2,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    1.39e-06,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.2
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  0.02,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.02,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.02
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": 0.20000000000000004,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.02,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
          "native_exit_status": null
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/Ti3Te_agm002190814",
            "bytes": 31828,
            "sha256": "0d6b7b4eee63a6707dbe2343942fdcfa95f27c5a5e0eb5be7445b574311d69b4"
          },
          "raw_optical_minimum": 8.283230273374323e-07,
          "raw_optical_printing_intervals": [
            [
              8.283197451690436e-07,
              8.28326309505821e-07
            ],
            [
              8.283197451690438e-07,
              8.283263095058212e-07
            ],
            [
              8.283197451690448e-07,
              8.283263095058223e-07
            ],
            [
              2.38022405359962e-06,
              2.3802306179363976e-06
            ],
            [
              2.38022405359962e-06,
              2.3802306179363976e-06
            ],
            [
              2.3802240535996214e-06,
              2.380230617936399e-06
            ],
            [
              2.4287637408986313e-06,
              2.4287703052354088e-06
            ],
            [
              2.4287637408986313e-06,
              2.4287703052354088e-06
            ],
            [
              2.4287637408986318e-06,
              2.428770305235409e-06
            ],
            [
              2.456956248638793e-06,
              2.4569628129755703e-06
            ],
            [
              2.456956248638794e-06,
              2.4569628129755716e-06
            ],
            [
              2.456956248638794e-06,
              2.4569628129755716e-06
            ],
            [
              3.4544072517227076e-06,
              3.454413816059485e-06
            ],
            [
              3.4544072517227085e-06,
              3.454413816059486e-06
            ],
            [
              3.454407251722709e-06,
              3.4544138160594863e-06
            ],
            [
              3.84829381497095e-06,
              3.848300379307727e-06
            ],
            [
              3.848293814970951e-06,
              3.848300379307728e-06
            ],
            [
              3.848293814970951e-06,
              3.848300379307728e-06
            ],
            [
              5.751913507329434e-06,
              5.7519200716662105e-06
            ],
            [
              5.7519135073294364e-06,
              5.751920071666213e-06
            ],
            [
              6.351240983202477e-06,
              6.3512475475392534e-06
            ]
          ],
          "unit": "squared source-Ry frequency convention",
          "native_negative_mode_numbers": [
            1,
            2,
            3
          ],
          "physical_error_bar": null,
          "full_BZ": null
        },
        "retained_path": {
          "kind": "qe_freq_gp_source_path_table",
          "raw_header_lines": [],
          "path_rows": 99,
          "column_width_counts": {
            "25": 99
          },
          "mode_column_values": 2376,
          "negative_printed_values": 0,
          "minimum_printed_mode": {
            "value": -0.0,
            "column_index_zero_based": 1
          },
          "frequency_unit_header": null,
          "column_roles_conditional_on_file_schema": true,
          "fullBZ_coverage": null,
          "dynamical_stability": null,
          "state_link_verified": null
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm002190814",
          "dyn0_source_record": 6341,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                3.0,
                3.0,
                3.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                4.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 6348,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 6349,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 6350,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 6351,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 4,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        },
        "unknowns": {
          "physical_mobile_carrier_density": null,
          "active_orbital_bandwidth": null,
          "public_RPS": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-01-eight-actual-omega-net-pairing-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1213076,
          "sha256": "ae6bc2be8e022ea5308483e2f63d28dfc4565f2cfa13948c036a16368c5f6201",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all62-net-pairing-owned-source-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 4086409,
          "sha256": "bced95fc8c75035eb57c3afbae73d98e099c3e732ef1e07a1836df54a1d60e15",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-owned-62-source-observations-for-Tc-header-readback-v1.json",
          "bytes": 10632536,
          "sha256": "35c5bfdd77eb7194ebebc41802600580a842c5526c8727c40a427c8869890d90",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Published source predictions already known; specific matched mechanism new to reviewed catalogue, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm002190827",
      "formula": "Ti3Zr",
      "reduced_formula": "Ti3Zr",
      "composition": {
        "Ti": 3,
        "Zr": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Ti:3|Zr:1",
      "elements": [
        "Ti",
        "Zr"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm002190827",
      "control_state": "agm002190826",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Ti3Zr_agm002190827",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Ti3Zr_agm002190826",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 221. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": [
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.0001,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 221,
          "hall_number": 517,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "a",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            1,
            1
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.0001,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 225,
          "hall_number": 523,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "a",
            "a",
            "a",
            "a"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.001,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 221,
          "hall_number": 517,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "a",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            1,
            1
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.001,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 225,
          "hall_number": 523,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "a",
            "a",
            "a",
            "a"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.01,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 221,
          "hall_number": 517,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "a",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            1,
            1
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.01,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 225,
          "hall_number": 523,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "a",
            "a",
            "a",
            "a"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0
          ]
        }
      ],
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 18.752,
        "control_K": 16.61,
        "delta_K": 2.1419999999999995,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.32230000000000003,
          0.26990000000000003,
          0.2428999999999999,
          0.21760000000000002,
          0.19669999999999987,
          0.18049999999999988,
          0.16749999999999998,
          0.15670000000000006,
          0.14739999999999998,
          0.13950000000000018
        ],
        "range": [
          0.13950000000000018,
          0.32230000000000003
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": [
        0.8937704033368421,
        0.8992789818643239,
        0.9049125883386973,
        0.9101329297304801,
        0.9143743303997299,
        0.9178057863575844,
        0.920692809493773,
        0.9232181800457195,
        0.9254614228773449,
        0.9274412215575069
      ],
      "risk_summary": "The nearest-distance contrast is only about 0.00481 Å; numerical sampling and strain can account for part of the response. A fine F is 3.898 meV/atom higher. The variants count as one ordered Ti3Zr design group, not multiple phases or strain-derived materials.",
      "ambient_scope": "Exact model force/full stress, converged electronic outputs, reported finite-q workflow and raw Γ optical evidence provide a bounded near-ambient source-model screen. Source residual stress/metastable alternatives remain explicit; this is not proof of synthesizeability, full BZ or global equilibrium.",
      "route_response": "L12 A versus a near-cubic tetragonal B has all-ten λ preference and separate Eliashberg +2.142 K, with a nonzero but small species-network contrast. Complete species-channel geometry differences and computed all-σ pairing response are saved against the frozen controls. Cell/grid/method sensitivity prevents a pure geometry-only causal claim; no bandwidth/carrier quantity is substituted.",
      "next_action": "Use the same physical mesh and a small explicitly controlled near-cubic deformation to isolate the response, retaining the known alloy reference. A benefit that vanishes under control-equivalent sampling lowers this geometry mechanism support.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Source-specific full-species CIF→both SCF inputs→Γ coordinate/cell association, actual atom order and origin, within 1e-6 Å observational matching policy. Original experimental occupancy and measured P/T unknown; configured QE neutral/nonmagnetic/no-SOC model is distinct from a magnetic ground-state claim.",
        "novelty": "One exact reduced composition/ordered phase-design group, new to the frozen reviewed cohort. Published computed source is acknowledged, known experimental chemistry remains a comparator. Bounded primary phase search has not tied the exact target order to an established SC sample; no global absence claim.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "L12 A versus a near-cubic tetragonal B has all-ten λ preference and separate Eliashberg +2.142 K, with a nonzero but small species-network contrast. Complete species-channel geometry differences and computed all-σ pairing response are saved against the frozen controls. Cell/grid/method sensitivity prevents a pure geometry-only causal claim; no bandwidth/carrier quantity is substituted.",
        "pairing_relevance": "All ten source λ/ω rows retained with original units/nulls, and μ*=0.1 source McMillan, Allen–Dynes and Eliashberg products kept separate. Source Gaussian EPC broadening is distinct from explicit MP electronic SCF smearing. No product maximum or selected σ defines the recommendation.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Exact model force/full stress, converged electronic outputs, reported finite-q workflow and raw Γ optical evidence provide a bounded near-ambient source-model screen. Source residual stress/metastable alternatives remain explicit; this is not proof of synthesizeability, full BZ or global equilibrium.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "The nearest-distance contrast is only about 0.00481 Å; numerical sampling and strain can account for part of the response. A fine F is 3.898 meV/atom higher. The variants count as one ordered Ti3Zr design group, not multiple phases or strain-derived materials.",
        "decision": "Use the same physical mesh and a small explicitly controlled near-cubic deformation to isolate the response, retaining the known alloy reference. A benefit that vanishes under control-equivalent sampling lowers this geometry mechanism support."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "residual_force_stress",
        "sampling_method"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "control_directory": "batch-a/Ti3Zr_agm002190826",
          "lambda_target_minus_control_all10": [
            0.32230000000000003,
            0.26990000000000003,
            0.2428999999999999,
            0.21760000000000002,
            0.19669999999999987,
            0.18049999999999988,
            0.16749999999999998,
            0.15670000000000006,
            0.14739999999999998,
            0.13950000000000018
          ],
          "omega_log_target_over_control_all10": [
            0.8937704033368421,
            0.8992789818643239,
            0.9049125883386973,
            0.9101329297304801,
            0.9143743303997299,
            0.9178057863575844,
            0.920692809493773,
            0.9232181800457195,
            0.9254614228773449,
            0.9274412215575069
          ],
          "source_Eli_mu01_target_control_K": [
            18.752,
            16.61
          ],
          "separate_Eli_target_minus_control_K": 2.1419999999999995,
          "target_control_q_mesh_match": true,
          "target_control_q_meshes": [
            [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ]
          ],
          "q_comparison_scope": "Different cells can have different configured physical sampling. Actual meshes retained as confounds; source-paired products do not establish convergence or isolated geometry causality.",
          "original_frozen_pair": {
            "original_contrast_index": 71,
            "composition": {
              "Ti": 3,
              "Zr": 1
            },
            "fixed_A": "batch-a/Ti3Zr_agm002190827",
            "fixed_B": "batch-a/Ti3Zr_agm002190826",
            "lambda_B_minus_A_all10": [
              -0.32230000000000003,
              -0.26990000000000003,
              -0.2428999999999999,
              -0.21760000000000002,
              -0.19669999999999987,
              -0.18049999999999988,
              -0.16749999999999998,
              -0.15670000000000006,
              -0.14739999999999998,
              -0.13950000000000018
            ],
            "lambda_direction": "A",
            "separate_Eli_A_B_K": [
              18.752,
              16.61
            ],
            "separate_Eli_B_minus_A_K": -2.1419999999999995
          },
          "control_source_q_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm002190826",
            "dyn0_source_record": 5488,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 5495,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 11,
                "source_record": 5496,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 12,
                "source_record": 5497,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 13,
                "source_record": 5498,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 5499,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 5500,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 5501,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 5502,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 5503,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 5504,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 5505,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 5506,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 5507,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.13950000000000018,
            0.32230000000000003
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "SCF_stages": {
          "scf_coarse.out.bz2": {
            "source_record": 3017,
            "explicit_program_start_headers": [
              {
                "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 14May2023 at  9:29:49"
              }
            ],
            "last_printed_convergence_event": {
              "value": true,
              "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
            },
            "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
            "routine_error_count": 0,
            "warning_patterns": {
              "pattern_selected_count": 6,
              "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
              "BFGS": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
                }
              },
              "negative_charge": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "eigen_text": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "c_bands:  1 eigenvalues not converged"
                }
              },
              "failure_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "SCF_correction_text": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Total force =     0.000000     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
                }
              }
            },
            "last_force": {
              "header": {
                "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
              },
              "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "printed_site_rows": 4,
              "ordered_atom_indices": [
                1,
                2,
                3,
                4
              ],
              "reported_max_abs_component": {
                "value": 0.0,
                "unit": "Ry/bohr",
                "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
              },
              "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
              "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
              "max_component_eV_A": 0.0,
              "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.0,
              "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
              "conversion_constants": {
                "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
                "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
              },
              "unit_conversion_valid": true,
              "max_norm_site": {
                "value": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                "atom_index": 1,
                "type_index": 2
              },
              "reported_component_agrees": true
            },
            "last_stress": {
              "last_pressure_print": {
                "value": -0.01,
                "unit": "kbar",
                "raw_value": "-0.01",
                "GPa": -0.001
              },
              "last_stress_block": {
                "header": {
                  "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.01"
                },
                "complete_3x6": true,
                "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
                "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
                "rows": [
                  {
                    "value": [
                      -8e-08,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -0.01,
                      0.0,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      -8e-08,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -0.01,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -8e-08,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -0.01
                    ]
                  }
                ],
                "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                  [
                    -0.001,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    -0.001,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.001
                  ]
                ],
                "trace_mean_kbar": -0.01,
                "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.001,
                "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
              }
            },
            "last_total_energy_print": {
              "value": -456.97461682,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-456.97461682"
            },
            "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
              "value": 0.00017371,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "0.00017371"
            },
            "native_exit_status": null,
            "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
            "PH_all_irreps_complete": null,
            "fullBZ_dynamical_stability": null,
            "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -456.97479053
          },
          "scf_fine.out.bz2": {
            "source_record": 3018,
            "explicit_program_start_headers": [
              {
                "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 14May2023 at  9:24:48"
              }
            ],
            "last_printed_convergence_event": {
              "value": true,
              "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
            },
            "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
            "routine_error_count": 0,
            "warning_patterns": {
              "pattern_selected_count": 18,
              "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
              "BFGS": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
                }
              },
              "negative_charge": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "eigen_text": {
                "count": 13,
                "last": {
                  "value": "c_bands:  1 eigenvalues not converged"
                }
              },
              "failure_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "SCF_correction_text": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Total force =     0.000000     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
                }
              }
            },
            "last_force": {
              "header": {
                "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
              },
              "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "printed_site_rows": 4,
              "ordered_atom_indices": [
                1,
                2,
                3,
                4
              ],
              "reported_max_abs_component": {
                "value": 0.0,
                "unit": "Ry/bohr",
                "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
              },
              "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
              "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
              "max_component_eV_A": 0.0,
              "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.0,
              "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
              "conversion_constants": {
                "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
                "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
              },
              "unit_conversion_valid": true,
              "max_norm_site": {
                "value": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                "atom_index": 1,
                "type_index": 2
              },
              "reported_component_agrees": true
            },
            "last_stress": {
              "last_pressure_print": {
                "value": 1.3,
                "unit": "kbar",
                "raw_value": "1.30",
                "GPa": 0.13
              },
              "last_stress_block": {
                "header": {
                  "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=        1.30"
                },
                "complete_3x6": true,
                "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
                "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
                "rows": [
                  {
                    "value": [
                      8.81e-06,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      1.3,
                      0.0,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      8.81e-06,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      1.3,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      8.81e-06,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      1.3
                    ]
                  }
                ],
                "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                  [
                    0.13,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    0.13,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.13
                  ]
                ],
                "trace_mean_kbar": 1.3,
                "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.13,
                "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
              }
            },
            "last_total_energy_print": {
              "value": -456.97425309,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-456.97425309"
            },
            "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
              "value": -0.00019901,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-0.00019901"
            },
            "native_exit_status": null,
            "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
            "PH_all_irreps_complete": null,
            "fullBZ_dynamical_stability": null,
            "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -456.97405408
          }
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/Ti3Zr_agm002190827",
            "bytes": 8948,
            "sha256": "4a5289156fd240ec1278b5aa4ed6b1838113569469df8e7a2c4298a47c9594f7"
          },
          "raw_header": {
            "ntyp": 2,
            "nat": 4,
            "ibrav": 1,
            "celldm": [
              7.8702411,
              0.0,
              0.0,
              0.0,
              0.0,
              0.0
            ],
            "basis_alat": null,
            "species": [
              {
                "index": 1,
                "element": "Ti",
                "header_mass": 43628.1015848821,
                "header_mass_halfwidth": 5e-11,
                "raw_mass_token": "43628.1015848821",
                "line": 4
              },
              {
                "index": 2,
                "element": "Zr",
                "header_mass": 83145.5896333441,
                "header_mass_halfwidth": 5e-11,
                "raw_mass_token": "83145.5896333441",
                "line": 5
              }
            ],
            "atoms": [
              {
                "index": 1,
                "type": 2,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                "line": 6
              },
              {
                "index": 2,
                "type": 1,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.0,
                  0.5,
                  0.5
                ],
                "line": 7
              },
              {
                "index": 3,
                "type": 1,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.5,
                  0.0,
                  0.5
                ],
                "line": 8
              },
              {
                "index": 4,
                "type": 1,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.5,
                  0.5,
                  0.0
                ],
                "line": 9
              }
            ],
            "q": [
              0.0,
              0.0,
              0.0
            ],
            "matrix_header_line": 11
          },
          "optical_sign": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "minimum": 1.3575505487995628e-06,
          "printing_bound": 1.7138171618347517e-12,
          "ASR_relative": 0.0029700035806767924,
          "native_signed_modes": [
            {
              "number": 1,
              "THz": -0.347576,
              "cm_inverse": -11.593874,
              "line": 85
            },
            {
              "number": 2,
              "THz": -0.347576,
              "cm_inverse": -11.593874,
              "line": 90
            },
            {
              "number": 3,
              "THz": -0.347576,
              "cm_inverse": -11.593874,
              "line": 95
            },
            {
              "number": 4,
              "THz": 3.833132,
              "cm_inverse": 127.859513,
              "line": 100
            },
            {
              "number": 5,
              "THz": 3.833132,
              "cm_inverse": 127.859513,
              "line": 105
            },
            {
              "number": 6,
              "THz": 3.833132,
              "cm_inverse": 127.859513,
              "line": 110
            },
            {
              "number": 7,
              "THz": 5.053874,
              "cm_inverse": 168.579082,
              "line": 115
            },
            {
              "number": 8,
              "THz": 5.053874,
              "cm_inverse": 168.579082,
              "line": 120
            },
            {
              "number": 9,
              "THz": 5.053874,
              "cm_inverse": 168.579082,
              "line": 125
            },
            {
              "number": 10,
              "THz": 6.893487,
              "cm_inverse": 229.941982,
              "line": 130
            },
            {
              "number": 11,
              "THz": 6.893487,
              "cm_inverse": 229.941982,
              "line": 135
            },
            {
              "number": 12,
              "THz": 6.893487,
              "cm_inverse": 229.941982,
              "line": 140
            }
          ],
          "native_negative_outside_lowest3": []
        },
        "finite_path": {
          "source_record": 3000,
          "observations": {
            "kind": "qe_freq_gp_source_path_table",
            "raw_header_lines": [],
            "path_rows": 121,
            "column_width_counts": {
              "13": 121
            },
            "mode_column_values": 1452,
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "column_roles_conditional_on_file_schema": true,
            "fullBZ_coverage": null,
            "dynamical_stability": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          }
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm002190827",
          "dyn0_source_record": 2999,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                4.0,
                4.0,
                4.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                10.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 10,
              "source_record": 3006,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 3007,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 3008,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 3009,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 3010,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 5,
              "source_record": 3011,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 6,
              "source_record": 3012,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 7,
              "source_record": 3013,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 8,
              "source_record": 3014,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 9,
              "source_record": 3015,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 10,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "composition-assessments.json",
          "bytes": 2036037,
          "sha256": "87a3759b8bb3bd9985bd6537220b4ea8fa427be6672204f9010e300e647c284a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "numeric-review.json",
          "bytes": 2556012,
          "sha256": "a0e7a487691b01ab8f0a4ea02eab40af649a455b97dc9ebdfdcabc4cd2453000",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Exact ordered-state mechanism new to reviewed catalogue only; source predictions/known chemistry acknowledged, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001186283",
      "formula": "TiMn4Re",
      "reduced_formula": "TiMn4Re",
      "composition": {
        "Mn": 4,
        "Re": 1,
        "Ti": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Mn:4|Re:1|Ti:1",
      "elements": [
        "Mn",
        "Re",
        "Ti"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001186283",
      "control_state": "agm001179875",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/TiMn4Re_agm001186283",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Mn4NbRe_agm001179875",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 216. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "symprec_A": 0.0001,
        "mode": "color_aware",
        "status": "completed",
        "SG_number": 216,
        "hall_number": 512,
        "input_wyckoff_letters": [
          "c",
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "b"
        ],
        "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
          0,
          1,
          1,
          1,
          1,
          5
        ]
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 15.197,
        "control_K": 12.782,
        "delta_K": 2.414999999999999,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.3857999999999999,
          0.2096,
          0.1382,
          0.10980000000000001,
          0.09600000000000009,
          0.08520000000000005,
          0.07499999999999996,
          0.0655,
          0.05730000000000002,
          0.05070000000000008
        ],
        "range": [
          0.05070000000000008,
          0.3857999999999999
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Ti-for-Nb onRe-bearing network contracts Mn bonds by.03269A and increases all common-sigma EPC/Tc; exact spin reconstruction unknown, with C14/NbMn2 magnetic competitor treated as adjacent analogue not child observation.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
      "route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
      "next_action": "Same-cell spin/order and common-grid Nb/Ti comparator; test robustness under mapped structural competitor.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "CIF lattice/sites to both SCFinputs andGamma atomicheader via speciesbijection/wholetranslation; 1e-6A observationaltolerance, not physicaluncertainty",
        "novelty": "Bounded exact formula/prototype primary search; published source calculations not claimed as first discovery. New-to-reviewed exact ordered hypothesis only. Literature-wide novelty unproved.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
        "pairing_relevance": "All ten raw printed lambda values andseparate mu*=.1 sourceEliashberg/McMillan products retained; representative common-sigma response isnotrenamed Tc_uncertainty. Spinfluctuations/anisotropy omitted.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Ti-for-Nb onRe-bearing network contracts Mn bonds by.03269A and increases all common-sigma EPC/Tc; exact spin reconstruction unknown, with C14/NbMn2 magnetic competitor treated as adjacent analogue not child observation.",
        "decision": "Same-cell spin/order and common-grid Nb/Ti comparator; test robustness under mapped structural competitor."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "magnetic_model",
        "metastable_phase"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4NbRe_agm001179875",
            "batch-a/TiMn4Re_agm001186283"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4NbRe_agm001179875",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/TiMn4Re_agm001186283",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.3857999999999999,
            0.2096,
            0.1382,
            0.10980000000000001,
            0.09600000000000009,
            0.08520000000000005,
            0.07499999999999996,
            0.0655,
            0.05730000000000002,
            0.05070000000000008
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.05070000000000008,
            0.3857999999999999
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              12.782
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              15.197
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 2.414999999999999,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 155
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4TaRe_agm003204489",
            "batch-a/TiMn4Re_agm001186283"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4TaRe_agm003204489",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/TiMn4Re_agm001186283",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.43269999999999986,
            0.23929999999999996,
            0.15999999999999992,
            0.12990000000000002,
            0.11680000000000001,
            0.10670000000000002,
            0.09689999999999999,
            0.08739999999999992,
            0.07909999999999995,
            0.07230000000000003
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.07230000000000003,
            0.43269999999999986
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              11.832
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              15.197
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 3.3649999999999984,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 163
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/TiMn4Re_agm001186283",
            "batch-a/TiMn4Tc_agm001186290"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/TiMn4Re_agm001186283",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/TiMn4Tc_agm001186290",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.17030000000000012,
            0.13839999999999997,
            0.11340000000000006,
            0.09539999999999993,
            0.08439999999999992,
            0.07809999999999995,
            0.07430000000000003,
            0.07200000000000006,
            0.07030000000000003,
            0.06889999999999996
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.06889999999999996,
            0.17030000000000012
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              15.197
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              17.71
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 2.5130000000000017,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 319
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/TiMn4Re_agm001186283",
            "batch-a/TiMn4W_agm001186294"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/TiMn4Re_agm001186283",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/TiMn4W_agm001186294",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.06300000000000017,
            0.3102999999999999,
            0.3155,
            0.25419999999999987,
            0.19269999999999987,
            0.1461,
            0.11240000000000006,
            0.08840000000000003,
            0.07120000000000004,
            0.05909999999999993
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.05909999999999993,
            0.3155
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              15.197
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              19.035
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 3.838000000000001,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 320
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "coarse": {
          "source_record": 7725,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 12Sep2022 at 16:15:53"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 7,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "c_bands:  1 eigenvalues not converged"
              }
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 2,
              "last": {
                "value": "SCF correction compared to forces is large: reduce conv_thr to get better values"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 8e-07,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 8e-07,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 1.3856406460551018e-06,
            "max_component_eV_A": 2.0568826990530354e-05,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 3.562625339969262e-05,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                -8e-07,
                -8e-07,
                8e-07
              ],
              "atom_index": 2,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": -0.01,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "-0.01",
              "GPa": -0.001
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.01"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    -4e-08,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.01,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -4e-08,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.01,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -4e-08,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.01
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  -0.001,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.001,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.0,
                  -0.001
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": -0.01,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.001,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1168.19286206,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1168.19286206"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": -0.00040197,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-0.00040197"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1168.19246009
        },
        "fine": {
          "source_record": 7726,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 12Sep2022 at 15:56:16"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 27,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 22,
              "last": {
                "value": "c_bands:  1 eigenvalues not converged"
              }
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000784     Total SCF correction =     0.000001"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 0.00022642,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.00022642,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.00039217094384974517,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.0058214922589948535,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.010083120368448002,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                -0.00022642,
                -0.00022642,
                0.00022642
              ],
              "atom_index": 2,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": -0.42,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "-0.42",
              "GPa": -0.041999999999999996
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.42"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    -2.87e-06,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.42,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    -2.87e-06,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.42,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -2.87e-06,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.42
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  -0.041999999999999996,
                  -0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  -0.041999999999999996,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.0,
                  -0.041999999999999996
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": -0.42,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.041999999999999996,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1168.19248067,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1168.19248067"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": 6.209e-05,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "0.00006209"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1168.19254276
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "Gamma_optical_sign": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "Gamma_optical_minimum": 8.751661317797681e-07,
          "Gamma_printing_bound": 2.3058041524606673e-12,
          "Gamma_native_signed_modes": [
            {
              "number": 1,
              "THz": 0.071688,
              "cm_inverse": 2.391262,
              "line": 168
            },
            {
              "number": 2,
              "THz": 0.071688,
              "cm_inverse": 2.391262,
              "line": 175
            },
            {
              "number": 3,
              "THz": 0.071688,
              "cm_inverse": 2.391262,
              "line": 182
            },
            {
              "number": 4,
              "THz": 3.077694,
              "cm_inverse": 102.660833,
              "line": 189
            },
            {
              "number": 5,
              "THz": 3.077694,
              "cm_inverse": 102.660833,
              "line": 196
            },
            {
              "number": 6,
              "THz": 3.077694,
              "cm_inverse": 102.660833,
              "line": 203
            },
            {
              "number": 7,
              "THz": 5.239419,
              "cm_inverse": 174.768204,
              "line": 210
            },
            {
              "number": 8,
              "THz": 5.239419,
              "cm_inverse": 174.768204,
              "line": 217
            },
            {
              "number": 9,
              "THz": 5.239419,
              "cm_inverse": 174.768204,
              "line": 224
            },
            {
              "number": 10,
              "THz": 6.247398,
              "cm_inverse": 208.390756,
              "line": 231
            },
            {
              "number": 11,
              "THz": 6.247398,
              "cm_inverse": 208.390756,
              "line": 238
            },
            {
              "number": 12,
              "THz": 6.247398,
              "cm_inverse": 208.390756,
              "line": 245
            },
            {
              "number": 13,
              "THz": 6.721865,
              "cm_inverse": 224.217277,
              "line": 252
            },
            {
              "number": 14,
              "THz": 6.721865,
              "cm_inverse": 224.217277,
              "line": 259
            },
            {
              "number": 15,
              "THz": 8.908157,
              "cm_inverse": 297.144119,
              "line": 266
            },
            {
              "number": 16,
              "THz": 8.908157,
              "cm_inverse": 297.144119,
              "line": 273
            },
            {
              "number": 17,
              "THz": 8.908157,
              "cm_inverse": 297.144119,
              "line": 280
            },
            {
              "number": 18,
              "THz": 11.101307,
              "cm_inverse": 370.299735,
              "line": 287
            }
          ],
          "Gamma_ASR_relative": 0.0006960094445586817,
          "Gamma_source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/TiMn4Re_agm001186283",
            "bytes": 18614,
            "sha256": "a6d5dc0793cd7ed29f82f76c254378d5988db7557047c1ac4a1fc14a81abe4b3"
          }
        },
        "finite_path": {
          "raw_header_lines": [],
          "negative_printed_values": 0,
          "minimum_printed_mode": {
            "value": -0.0,
            "column_index_zero_based": 1
          },
          "frequency_unit_header": null,
          "fullBZ_coverage": null,
          "dynamical_stability": null,
          "state_link_verified": null
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm001186283",
          "dyn0_source_record": 7713,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                3.0,
                3.0,
                3.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                4.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 7720,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 7721,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 7722,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 7723,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 4,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "composition-assessments.json",
          "bytes": 1863044,
          "sha256": "5fc901f5f4a90b41e807722d92f39d81714b70091a189cdb5eba13367624350b",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "numeric-review.json",
          "bytes": 4542684,
          "sha256": "c4fae01d3d67f774429114902a6b39f5b133de48ea81d3d9773ba40ff4419ce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-two-PH-actual-complete-response-products-readback-v1.json",
          "bytes": 77119,
          "sha256": "434c5fe7a590607adbc104dd75d126497457317bc20f37973b5013491e9fdce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Published source predictions already known; exact matched mechanism new to reviewed catalogue only, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001186290",
      "formula": "TiMn4Tc",
      "reduced_formula": "TiMn4Tc",
      "composition": {
        "Mn": 4,
        "Tc": 1,
        "Ti": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Mn:4|Tc:1|Ti:1",
      "elements": [
        "Mn",
        "Tc",
        "Ti"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001186290",
      "control_state": "agm001179882",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/TiMn4Tc_agm001186290",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Mn4NbTc_agm001179882",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 216. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "symprec_A": 0.0001,
        "mode": "color_aware",
        "status": "completed",
        "SG_number": 216,
        "hall_number": 512,
        "input_wyckoff_letters": [
          "c",
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "b"
        ],
        "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
          0,
          1,
          1,
          1,
          1,
          5
        ]
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 17.71,
        "control_K": 14.574,
        "delta_K": 3.136000000000001,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.4537,
          0.24549999999999994,
          0.17510000000000003,
          0.14669999999999994,
          0.13069999999999993,
          0.11769999999999992,
          0.1058,
          0.09520000000000006,
          0.08630000000000004,
          0.07909999999999995
        ],
        "range": [
          0.07909999999999995,
          0.4537
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Ti-for-Nb onTc-bearing network contracts Mn bonds by.03174A and increases all common-sigma response. Ti/W sibling is mixed lambda vsTc; cannot impose a monotonic lambda ranking.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
      "route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
      "next_action": "Exact-cell spin and controlled source-mode check; loss of pairing benefit under magnetic/structural branch is adverse.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "CIF lattice/sites to both SCFinputs andGamma atomicheader via speciesbijection/wholetranslation; 1e-6A observationaltolerance, not physicaluncertainty",
        "novelty": "Bounded exact formula/prototype primary search; published source calculations not claimed as first discovery. New-to-reviewed exact ordered hypothesis only. Literature-wide novelty unproved.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
        "pairing_relevance": "All ten raw printed lambda values andseparate mu*=.1 sourceEliashberg/McMillan products retained; representative common-sigma response isnotrenamed Tc_uncertainty. Spinfluctuations/anisotropy omitted.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Ti-for-Nb onTc-bearing network contracts Mn bonds by.03174A and increases all common-sigma response. Ti/W sibling is mixed lambda vsTc; cannot impose a monotonic lambda ranking.",
        "decision": "Exact-cell spin and controlled source-mode check; loss of pairing benefit under magnetic/structural branch is adverse."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "magnetic_model",
        "technetium"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4NbTc_agm001179882",
            "batch-a/TiMn4Tc_agm001186290"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4NbTc_agm001179882",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/TiMn4Tc_agm001186290",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.4537,
            0.24549999999999994,
            0.17510000000000003,
            0.14669999999999994,
            0.13069999999999993,
            0.11769999999999992,
            0.1058,
            0.09520000000000006,
            0.08630000000000004,
            0.07909999999999995
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.07909999999999995,
            0.4537
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              14.574
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              17.71
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 3.136000000000001,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 157
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4TcTa_agm003199931",
            "batch-a/TiMn4Tc_agm001186290"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4TcTa_agm003199931",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/TiMn4Tc_agm001186290",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.5255000000000001,
            0.29059999999999997,
            0.20510000000000006,
            0.17159999999999997,
            0.1553,
            0.14259999999999995,
            0.13080000000000003,
            0.12,
            0.1109,
            0.10340000000000005
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.10340000000000005,
            0.5255000000000001
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              13.109
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              17.71
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 4.601000000000001,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 166
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/TiMn4Re_agm001186283",
            "batch-a/TiMn4Tc_agm001186290"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/TiMn4Re_agm001186283",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/TiMn4Tc_agm001186290",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.17030000000000012,
            0.13839999999999997,
            0.11340000000000006,
            0.09539999999999993,
            0.08439999999999992,
            0.07809999999999995,
            0.07430000000000003,
            0.07200000000000006,
            0.07030000000000003,
            0.06889999999999996
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.06889999999999996,
            0.17030000000000012
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              15.197
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              17.71
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 2.5130000000000017,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 319
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/TiMn4Tc_agm001186290",
            "batch-a/TiMn4W_agm001186294"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/TiMn4Tc_agm001186290",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/TiMn4W_agm001186294",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.10729999999999995,
            0.17189999999999994,
            0.20209999999999995,
            0.15879999999999994,
            0.10829999999999995,
            0.06800000000000006,
            0.03810000000000002,
            0.01639999999999997,
            0.0009000000000000119,
            -0.009800000000000031
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.10729999999999995,
            0.20209999999999995
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "mixed_or_unknown",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              17.71
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              19.035
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 1.3249999999999993,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": null,
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 321
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "coarse": {
          "source_record": 3847,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on  7Oct2022 at 13: 3:33"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 6,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 2,
              "last": {
                "value": "SCF correction compared to forces is large: reduce conv_thr to get better values"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 4.6e-07,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 4.6e-07,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 7.967433714816835e-07,
            "max_component_eV_A": 1.1827075519554954e-05,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 2.0485095704823255e-05,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                -4.6e-07,
                -4.6e-07,
                4.6e-07
              ],
              "atom_index": 2,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": 0.01,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "0.01",
              "GPa": 0.001
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=        0.01"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    5e-08,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.01,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    5e-08,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.01,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    5e-08,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.01
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  0.001,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.001,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.001
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": 0.01,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.001,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1164.25488062,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1164.25488062"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": -0.00046233,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-0.00046233"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1164.25441829
        },
        "fine": {
          "source_record": 3848,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on  7Oct2022 at 12:30:34"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 11,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 6,
              "last": {
                "value": "c_bands:  1 eigenvalues not converged"
              }
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000854     Total SCF correction =     0.000001"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 0.00024651,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.00024651,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.000426967844573804,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.006338026926794547,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.010977784656947787,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                -0.00024651,
                -0.00024651,
                0.00024651
              ],
              "atom_index": 2,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": -0.52,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "-0.52",
              "GPa": -0.052000000000000005
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.52"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    -3.52e-06,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.52,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -3.52e-06,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.52,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -3.52e-06,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.52
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  -0.052000000000000005,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.052000000000000005,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  -0.052000000000000005
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": -0.52,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.052000000000000005,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1164.2545441,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1164.25454410"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": -0.0001421,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-0.00014210"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1164.254402
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "Gamma_optical_sign": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "Gamma_optical_minimum": 9.388908735157936e-07,
          "Gamma_printing_bound": 2.4183053425578574e-12,
          "Gamma_native_signed_modes": [
            {
              "number": 1,
              "THz": 0.072096,
              "cm_inverse": 2.404858,
              "line": 168
            },
            {
              "number": 2,
              "THz": 0.072096,
              "cm_inverse": 2.404858,
              "line": 175
            },
            {
              "number": 3,
              "THz": 0.072096,
              "cm_inverse": 2.404858,
              "line": 182
            },
            {
              "number": 4,
              "THz": 3.187741,
              "cm_inverse": 106.331594,
              "line": 189
            },
            {
              "number": 5,
              "THz": 3.187741,
              "cm_inverse": 106.331594,
              "line": 196
            },
            {
              "number": 6,
              "THz": 3.187741,
              "cm_inverse": 106.331594,
              "line": 203
            },
            {
              "number": 7,
              "THz": 5.075888,
              "cm_inverse": 169.313394,
              "line": 210
            },
            {
              "number": 8,
              "THz": 5.075888,
              "cm_inverse": 169.313394,
              "line": 217
            },
            {
              "number": 9,
              "THz": 5.075888,
              "cm_inverse": 169.313394,
              "line": 224
            },
            {
              "number": 10,
              "THz": 6.176984,
              "cm_inverse": 206.042001,
              "line": 231
            },
            {
              "number": 11,
              "THz": 6.176984,
              "cm_inverse": 206.042001,
              "line": 238
            },
            {
              "number": 12,
              "THz": 6.189045,
              "cm_inverse": 206.444316,
              "line": 245
            },
            {
              "number": 13,
              "THz": 6.189045,
              "cm_inverse": 206.444316,
              "line": 252
            },
            {
              "number": 14,
              "THz": 6.189045,
              "cm_inverse": 206.444316,
              "line": 259
            },
            {
              "number": 15,
              "THz": 8.745225,
              "cm_inverse": 291.709322,
              "line": 266
            },
            {
              "number": 16,
              "THz": 8.745225,
              "cm_inverse": 291.709322,
              "line": 273
            },
            {
              "number": 17,
              "THz": 8.745225,
              "cm_inverse": 291.709322,
              "line": 280
            },
            {
              "number": 18,
              "THz": 11.031435,
              "cm_inverse": 367.96907,
              "line": 287
            }
          ],
          "Gamma_ASR_relative": 0.00022036515158210362,
          "Gamma_source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/TiMn4Tc_agm001186290",
            "bytes": 18614,
            "sha256": "6277c966b5ebcbef78a9adfe4518f817b0adc38b533681d38fd12c8586f9c0b5"
          }
        },
        "finite_path": {
          "raw_header_lines": [],
          "negative_printed_values": 0,
          "minimum_printed_mode": {
            "value": -0.0,
            "column_index_zero_based": 1
          },
          "frequency_unit_header": null,
          "fullBZ_coverage": null,
          "dynamical_stability": null,
          "state_link_verified": null
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm001186290",
          "dyn0_source_record": 3835,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                3.0,
                3.0,
                3.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                4.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 3842,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 3843,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 3844,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 3845,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 4,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "composition-assessments.json",
          "bytes": 1863044,
          "sha256": "5fc901f5f4a90b41e807722d92f39d81714b70091a189cdb5eba13367624350b",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "numeric-review.json",
          "bytes": 4542684,
          "sha256": "c4fae01d3d67f774429114902a6b39f5b133de48ea81d3d9773ba40ff4419ce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-two-PH-actual-complete-response-products-readback-v1.json",
          "bytes": 77119,
          "sha256": "434c5fe7a590607adbc104dd75d126497457317bc20f37973b5013491e9fdce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Published source predictions already known; exact matched mechanism new to reviewed catalogue only, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001186294",
      "formula": "TiMn4W",
      "reduced_formula": "TiMn4W",
      "composition": {
        "Mn": 4,
        "Ti": 1,
        "W": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Mn:4|Ti:1|W:1",
      "elements": [
        "Mn",
        "Ti",
        "W"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001186294",
      "control_state": "agm003195948",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/TiMn4W_agm001186294",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Mn4MoW_agm003195948",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 216. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "symprec_A": 0.0001,
        "mode": "color_aware",
        "status": "completed",
        "SG_number": 216,
        "hall_number": 512,
        "input_wyckoff_letters": [
          "c",
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "b"
        ],
        "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
          0,
          1,
          1,
          1,
          1,
          5
        ]
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 19.035,
        "control_K": 13.698,
        "delta_K": 5.337,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.4357000000000001,
          0.4888999999999999,
          0.4169999999999999,
          0.32799999999999985,
          0.2546999999999999,
          0.19920000000000004,
          0.15700000000000003,
          0.12460000000000004,
          0.09989999999999999,
          0.0816
        ],
        "range": [
          0.0816,
          0.4888999999999999
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Ti-for-Mo onW-bearing ordered network yields all-sigma gain and5.337K separateEli gain, with same138Ry/grids. Mn nearest distance decrease.00711A does not measurebandwidth/carriers or moments.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
      "route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
      "next_action": "Shared-grid spin/mode sensitivity of Mo/Ti comparator; competing C14 ordering and SOC sensitivity remain follow-up, not falsely passed.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "CIF lattice/sites to both SCFinputs andGamma atomicheader via speciesbijection/wholetranslation; 1e-6A observationaltolerance, not physicaluncertainty",
        "novelty": "Bounded exact formula/prototype primary search; published source calculations not claimed as first discovery. New-to-reviewed exact ordered hypothesis only. Literature-wide novelty unproved.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
        "pairing_relevance": "All ten raw printed lambda values andseparate mu*=.1 sourceEliashberg/McMillan products retained; representative common-sigma response isnotrenamed Tc_uncertainty. Spinfluctuations/anisotropy omitted.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Ti-for-Mo onW-bearing ordered network yields all-sigma gain and5.337K separateEli gain, with same138Ry/grids. Mn nearest distance decrease.00711A does not measurebandwidth/carriers or moments.",
        "decision": "Shared-grid spin/mode sensitivity of Mo/Ti comparator; competing C14 ordering and SOC sensitivity remain follow-up, not falsely passed."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "magnetic_model",
        "sampling_method"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4MoW_agm003195948",
            "batch-a/TiMn4W_agm001186294"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4MoW_agm003195948",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/TiMn4W_agm001186294",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.4357000000000001,
            0.4888999999999999,
            0.4169999999999999,
            0.32799999999999985,
            0.2546999999999999,
            0.19920000000000004,
            0.15700000000000003,
            0.12460000000000004,
            0.09989999999999999,
            0.0816
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.0816,
            0.4888999999999999
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              13.698
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              19.035
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 5.337,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 148
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4TaW_agm003195951",
            "batch-a/TiMn4W_agm001186294"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4TaW_agm003195951",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/TiMn4W_agm001186294",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.09260000000000002,
            0.2860999999999999,
            0.2647999999999999,
            0.20689999999999986,
            0.15739999999999987,
            0.12209999999999999,
            0.09760000000000002,
            0.0807,
            0.06879999999999997,
            0.0605
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.0605,
            0.2860999999999999
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              14.96
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              19.035
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 4.074999999999999,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 165
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/TiMn4Re_agm001186283",
            "batch-a/TiMn4W_agm001186294"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/TiMn4Re_agm001186283",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/TiMn4W_agm001186294",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.06300000000000017,
            0.3102999999999999,
            0.3155,
            0.25419999999999987,
            0.19269999999999987,
            0.1461,
            0.11240000000000006,
            0.08840000000000003,
            0.07120000000000004,
            0.05909999999999993
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.05909999999999993,
            0.3155
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              15.197
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              19.035
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 3.838000000000001,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 320
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/TiMn4Tc_agm001186290",
            "batch-a/TiMn4W_agm001186294"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/TiMn4Tc_agm001186290",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/TiMn4W_agm001186294",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            -0.10729999999999995,
            0.17189999999999994,
            0.20209999999999995,
            0.15879999999999994,
            0.10829999999999995,
            0.06800000000000006,
            0.03810000000000002,
            0.01639999999999997,
            0.0009000000000000119,
            -0.009800000000000031
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.10729999999999995,
            0.20209999999999995
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "mixed_or_unknown",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              17.71
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              19.035
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 1.3249999999999993,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": null,
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 321
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "coarse": {
          "source_record": 2849,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 13Jan2023 at  9:52:26"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 7,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "c_bands:  1 eigenvalues not converged"
              }
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 2,
              "last": {
                "value": "SCF correction compared to forces is large: reduce conv_thr to get better values"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 5.6e-07,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 5.6e-07,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 9.699484522385713e-07,
            "max_component_eV_A": 1.4398178893371249e-05,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 2.4938377379784835e-05,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                -5.6e-07,
                -5.6e-07,
                5.6e-07
              ],
              "atom_index": 2,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "-0.00",
              "GPa": -0.0
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.00"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    -2e-08,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -2e-08,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -2e-08,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  -0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.0,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.0,
                  -0.0
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": 0.0,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.0,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1146.28254171,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1146.28254171"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": -0.00047055,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-0.00047055"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1146.28207116
        },
        "fine": {
          "source_record": 2850,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 13Jan2023 at  9:20:46"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 82,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 77,
              "last": {
                "value": "c_bands:  1 eigenvalues not converged"
              }
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000299     Total SCF correction =     0.000001"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 8.62e-05,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 8.62e-05,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.00014930277961243722,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.0022162911082296457,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.00383872880381688,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                -8.62e-05,
                -8.62e-05,
                8.62e-05
              ],
              "atom_index": 2,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": 0.07,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "0.07",
              "GPa": 0.007000000000000001
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=        0.07"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    4.6e-07,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.07,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    4.6e-07,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.07,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    4.6e-07,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.07
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  0.007000000000000001,
                  -0.0,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  0.007000000000000001,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.007000000000000001
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": 0.07,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.007000000000000001,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1146.28177995,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1146.28177995"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": -0.00058628,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-0.00058628"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1146.28119367
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "Gamma_optical_sign": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "Gamma_optical_minimum": 1.3755850091817694e-06,
          "Gamma_printing_bound": 2.307413456740592e-12,
          "Gamma_native_signed_modes": [
            {
              "number": 1,
              "THz": -0.494228,
              "cm_inverse": -16.485684,
              "line": 168
            },
            {
              "number": 2,
              "THz": -0.494228,
              "cm_inverse": -16.485684,
              "line": 175
            },
            {
              "number": 3,
              "THz": -0.494228,
              "cm_inverse": -16.485684,
              "line": 182
            },
            {
              "number": 4,
              "THz": 3.859698,
              "cm_inverse": 128.745662,
              "line": 189
            },
            {
              "number": 5,
              "THz": 3.859698,
              "cm_inverse": 128.745662,
              "line": 196
            },
            {
              "number": 6,
              "THz": 3.859698,
              "cm_inverse": 128.745662,
              "line": 203
            },
            {
              "number": 7,
              "THz": 5.817981,
              "cm_inverse": 194.066961,
              "line": 210
            },
            {
              "number": 8,
              "THz": 5.817981,
              "cm_inverse": 194.066961,
              "line": 217
            },
            {
              "number": 9,
              "THz": 5.817981,
              "cm_inverse": 194.066961,
              "line": 224
            },
            {
              "number": 10,
              "THz": 6.226127,
              "cm_inverse": 207.681256,
              "line": 231
            },
            {
              "number": 11,
              "THz": 6.226127,
              "cm_inverse": 207.681256,
              "line": 238
            },
            {
              "number": 12,
              "THz": 6.226127,
              "cm_inverse": 207.681256,
              "line": 245
            },
            {
              "number": 13,
              "THz": 7.451619,
              "cm_inverse": 248.559265,
              "line": 252
            },
            {
              "number": 14,
              "THz": 7.451619,
              "cm_inverse": 248.559265,
              "line": 259
            },
            {
              "number": 15,
              "THz": 8.693401,
              "cm_inverse": 289.980635,
              "line": 266
            },
            {
              "number": 16,
              "THz": 8.693401,
              "cm_inverse": 289.980635,
              "line": 273
            },
            {
              "number": 17,
              "THz": 8.693401,
              "cm_inverse": 289.980635,
              "line": 280
            },
            {
              "number": 18,
              "THz": 11.262095,
              "cm_inverse": 375.663062,
              "line": 287
            }
          ],
          "Gamma_ASR_relative": 0.0043659704710568605,
          "Gamma_source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/TiMn4W_agm001186294",
            "bytes": 18614,
            "sha256": "06ffc537d1ac2e87ffee45e1e0f3bda5c1abf155ca11c7b8a67f838a11d7a632"
          }
        },
        "finite_path": {
          "raw_header_lines": [],
          "negative_printed_values": 0,
          "minimum_printed_mode": {
            "value": -0.0,
            "column_index_zero_based": 1
          },
          "frequency_unit_header": null,
          "fullBZ_coverage": null,
          "dynamical_stability": null,
          "state_link_verified": null
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm001186294",
          "dyn0_source_record": 2837,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                3.0,
                3.0,
                3.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                4.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 2844,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 2845,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 2846,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 2847,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 4,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "composition-assessments.json",
          "bytes": 1863044,
          "sha256": "5fc901f5f4a90b41e807722d92f39d81714b70091a189cdb5eba13367624350b",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "numeric-review.json",
          "bytes": 4542684,
          "sha256": "c4fae01d3d67f774429114902a6b39f5b133de48ea81d3d9773ba40ff4419ce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-two-PH-actual-complete-response-products-readback-v1.json",
          "bytes": 77119,
          "sha256": "434c5fe7a590607adbc104dd75d126497457317bc20f37973b5013491e9fdce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Published source predictions already known; exact matched mechanism new to reviewed catalogue only, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001116204",
      "formula": "TiMoTa2",
      "reduced_formula": "TiMoTa2",
      "composition": {
        "Mo": 1,
        "Ta": 2,
        "Ti": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Mo:1|Ta:2|Ti:1",
      "elements": [
        "Mo",
        "Ta",
        "Ti"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001116204",
      "control_state": "agm002191224",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/TiMoTa2_agm001116204",
      "control_directory": null,
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "ordered tetragonal four-site network versus equal60-degree primitive cation order",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "motif": "ordered tetragonal four-site network versus equal60-degree primitive cation order",
        "verified_space_group": null,
        "role": "A versus samecomposition B",
        "known_prior_scope": "Known Ti-Mo-Ta bcc diffusion and theoretical source studies are acknowledged; exact orderedTi25Mo25Ta50 experimental SC benchmark not identified in bounded primary search."
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 12.132,
        "control_K": 11.632,
        "delta_K": 0.5,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.04180000000000006,
          0.04620000000000002,
          0.04920000000000002,
          0.0494,
          0.04479999999999995,
          0.0381999999999999,
          0.03169999999999995,
          0.0263000000000001,
          0.02189999999999992,
          0.018300000000000094
        ],
        "range": [
          0.018300000000000094,
          0.0494
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Small source Eli Tc gain12.132 versus11.632K, q5x5x2 versus4^3. Target fine force0.0248561eV/A and maxstress0.371GPa are geometry/grid sensitivity, whereas source finite-grid target energy is8.488meV/atom lower. No uniform force threshold or global-ground-state requirement is used. Evaluated risks define a falsifiable bounded hypothesis, not an established bulk ground state or experimental coherence proof.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source nearambient fullstress/pressure and coarse-relaxed geometry, positive raw-Gamma optical compression beyond printing bounds, and no negative printed finite-path values support preliminary local feasibility only within the declared source approximation. WholeBZ/global hull/synthesis remain unknown.",
      "route_response": "Unique Ti/Mo periodic distance3.20425449 versus4.54011919A and Ti-Mo nearest3.24879784 versus3.21034907A; non-alias ordering with0.80722% lower control volume. Computed source EPC response is associated with construction; pure geometry-only causality and converged numerical uplift are unproved.",
      "next_action": "Check target stationarity on matched fine sampling and preserve ordering; only add response calculation that resolves the existing EPC ordering if necessary.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact reduced composition and non-alias decorated ordered network linked to canonical SCF input and source PH/Gamma/model evidence; source positions bind Gamma within printing/operational tolerances. Nb same-species permutation and Zr scalar parity reflection are explicit. Experimental phase/state remains unknown.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Unique Ti/Mo periodic distance3.20425449 versus4.54011919A and Ti-Mo nearest3.24879784 versus3.21034907A; non-alias ordering with0.80722% lower control volume. Computed source EPC response is associated with construction; pure geometry-only causality and converged numerical uplift are unproved.",
        "pairing_relevance": "Direct source lambda at ten common printed width tokens and independently retained mu*=0.1 Eliashberg Tc rows provide state-specific pairing relevance. Width units and Tc-to-width link remain unknown; no parent-property transfer or300K claim.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source nearambient fullstress/pressure and coarse-relaxed geometry, positive raw-Gamma optical compression beyond printing bounds, and no negative printed finite-path values support preliminary local feasibility only within the declared source approximation. WholeBZ/global hull/synthesis remain unknown.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Small source Eli Tc gain12.132 versus11.632K, q5x5x2 versus4^3. Target fine force0.0248561eV/A and maxstress0.371GPa are geometry/grid sensitivity, whereas source finite-grid target energy is8.488meV/atom lower. No uniform force threshold or global-ground-state requirement is used. Evaluated risks define a falsifiable bounded hypothesis, not an established bulk ground state or experimental coherence proof.",
        "novelty": "Known Ti-Mo-Ta bcc diffusion and theoretical source studies are acknowledged; exact orderedTi25Mo25Ta50 experimental SC benchmark not identified in bounded primary search. Default one exact-composition group, with all source/control variants underneath.",
        "decision": "Check target stationarity on matched fine sampling and preserve ordering; only add response calculation that resolves the existing EPC ordering if necessary. All seven minima support grade3 preliminary source-model screening; retained model-dependent uncertainty prevents grade4/formal publication."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "residual_force_stress",
        "sampling_method"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [],
      "physical_summary": {
        "target": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/TiMoTa2_agm001116204",
          "site_composition_matches_name": true,
          "site_count": 4,
          "volume_per_site_A3": 16.67810467288479,
          "source_fine_pressure_GPa": -0.096,
          "source_fine_maxstress_GPa": 0.371,
          "source_fine_maxforce_eV_A": 0.024856141866369027,
          "fine_JOB_DONE": true,
          "fine_convergence": true,
          "path_min_signed_printed_value": -0.0,
          "path_units_not_inferred": null,
          "path_signed_negative_printed_count": 0,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        },
        "control": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/TiMoTa2_agm002191224",
          "site_composition_matches_name": true,
          "site_count": 4,
          "volume_per_site_A3": 16.54347631312946,
          "source_fine_pressure_GPa": 0.03,
          "source_fine_maxstress_GPa": 0.03,
          "source_fine_maxforce_eV_A": 0.0,
          "fine_JOB_DONE": true,
          "fine_convergence": true,
          "path_min_signed_printed_value": -0.0,
          "path_units_not_inferred": null,
          "path_signed_negative_printed_count": 0,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-owned-five-pairs-scientific-workingview.json",
          "bytes": 933925,
          "sha256": "0a5d3b507b305b8991218157264276e898799837932a8050942ecf74ee389034",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-captured-five-pairs-method-slices.json",
          "bytes": 1387111,
          "sha256": "d84758cc1e54d79e08e01fe3b08b96dfa071953b16a488b0aef3a867ff30c147",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "CASE.md",
          "bytes": 12162,
          "sha256": "b8b3a4d931a852d21b4343c2fa718235137d41d3218d5ab2e5251c38f428cd1c",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "receipt.json",
          "bytes": 4813,
          "sha256": "f00c9787a8f7af8c076d8dcdac1f23f36fc8e4339b697329a37143ca618bc11a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "SMEARING-CORRECTION.json",
          "bytes": 8933,
          "sha256": "137158d36dfd25524acf4bcd7df583f59bfdcbb477172a790e49788eeb232b13",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-NbTa3-TiMoTa2-existing-source-coordinate-association-v1.json",
          "bytes": 28460,
          "sha256": "6d6e76e4b325dc2579db1d707675a68ba3cea1e9b3eb4bb0800d081d31d0883b",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "new-to-reviewed-catalogue ordered source-model route hypothesis; literature-derived, not first discovery",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001228974",
      "formula": "TiNb2Mo",
      "reduced_formula": "TiNb2Mo",
      "composition": {
        "Mo": 1,
        "Nb": 2,
        "Ti": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Mo:1|Nb:2|Ti:1",
      "elements": [
        "Mo",
        "Nb",
        "Ti"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001228974",
      "control_state": "agm002322068",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/TiNb2Mo_agm001228974",
      "control_directory": null,
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "ordered tetragonal P4/mmm-compatible four-site motif",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "motif": "ordered tetragonal P4/mmm-compatible four-site motif",
        "raw_geometry_basis": "a=b=4.54338183547 A,c=3.20085899551 A; Ti(0,0,1/2),Mo(1/2,1/2,1/2),Nb(0,1/2,0),(1/2,0,0),with source literal coordinate deviations retained",
        "role": "A, stronger EPC member versus ordered cubic B",
        "known_prior_scope": "different from known disordered BCC Im-3m Nb2TiMo experiment; not yet claimed an unreported phase globally"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 15.378,
        "control_K": 14.888,
        "delta_K": 0.4900000000000002,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.1875,
          0.16770000000000018,
          0.1502000000000001,
          0.13159999999999994,
          0.11399999999999988,
          0.0988,
          0.08630000000000004,
          0.07679999999999987,
          0.06999999999999995,
          0.06500000000000006
        ],
        "range": [
          0.06500000000000006,
          0.1875
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "NegativeGamma modes are predominantly translational, and the independently checked optical form is positive beyond raw printing bounds. Magnetism/SOC/disorder and full-BZ/finite-temperature stability remain beyond this nonmagnetic source approximation.",
      "ambient_scope": "Zero-pressure-target optimized models and completed sampled non-Gamma/ASR-path phonons plus positive Gamma optical compression support local near-ambient harmonic feasibility within the declared source model.",
      "route_response": "Non-isometric species-resolved network differences accompany the same-composition source EPC contrast at ten common widths; different reciprocal grids remain an explicit numerical confound.",
      "next_action": "Matched reciprocal-resolution refinement must preserve A>B and optical positivity; reversal or adverse structural/magnetic evidence revises this screen. Source association or inconclusive refinement leaves the research hypothesis unresolved.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact ordered source sites, canonical SCF input, neutral spin1/noSOC model and SCF/PH/dyn association are linked. Experimental conditions remain unknown.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Non-isometric species-resolved network differences accompany the same-composition source EPC contrast at ten common widths; different reciprocal grids remain an explicit numerical confound.",
        "pairing_relevance": "Direct conventional source EPC gives A>B at every retained width in both the directory and raw-q aggregation; this is a bounded source-protocol benefit.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Zero-pressure-target optimized models and completed sampled non-Gamma/ASR-path phonons plus positive Gamma optical compression support local near-ambient harmonic feasibility within the declared source model.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "NegativeGamma modes are predominantly translational, and the independently checked optical form is positive beyond raw printing bounds. Magnetism/SOC/disorder and full-BZ/finite-temperature stability remain beyond this nonmagnetic source approximation.",
        "novelty": "New to the reviewed catalogue as an exact ordered geometry-route hypothesis; known experimental disorderedBCC Nb2TiMo is a distinct object. Published source predictions are acknowledged and worldwide first discovery is not claimed.",
        "decision": "Matched reciprocal-resolution refinement must preserve A>B and optical positivity; reversal or adverse structural/magnetic evidence revises this screen. Source association or inconclusive refinement leaves the research hypothesis unresolved."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "minimum-cases.json",
          "bytes": 44905,
          "sha256": "0ae09a6f4264f3bc4105f653d324dc9416fa98bf72aec5438435554c5d2cfd2e",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "four-Gamma-mode-diagnostic-owned-workingview-root-v1.json",
          "bytes": 145994,
          "sha256": "204728005269006f08ed40019b950e63f5e73ffe068d92d0a5ae1e716b90d723",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "receipt.json",
          "bytes": 12340,
          "sha256": "e205f3f041eaa43b16263049bc11b3c42169e37dd4efa136e962dd65c3539515",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "new-to-reviewed-catalogue ordered geometry hypothesis; literature-derived, not first discovery",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001228986",
      "formula": "TiNb2Ta",
      "reduced_formula": "TiNb2Ta",
      "composition": {
        "Nb": 2,
        "Ta": 1,
        "Ti": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Nb:2|Ta:1|Ti:1",
      "elements": [
        "Nb",
        "Ta",
        "Ti"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001228986",
      "control_state": "agm001228974",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/TiNb2Ta_agm001228986",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/TiNb2Mo_agm001228974",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "CIF_source_record": 1507,
        "CIF_payload_pin": {
          "bytes": 591661,
          "sha256": "93c3ce21c362fc36392db6d13f4555d76cce96122769d1212414bbc770f81541"
        },
        "SCF_coarse_source_record": 1524,
        "Gamma_source_pin": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/TiNb2Ta_agm001228986",
          "bytes": 8994,
          "sha256": "5de6053cbb88d19da45af8a4c1987c6ffd5649157a1746198c662c3171cf5af9"
        },
        "source_input_volume_difference_relative": -2.5476176723771005e-11,
        "occupancy_model_all1": true,
        "bounded_signed_axis_and_translation_mapping": {
          "signed_axis_U_CIF_fractional_to_SCF": [
            [
              1,
              0,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              1,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              0,
              1
            ]
          ],
          "determinant": 1,
          "origin_shift_fractional": [
            7.20888904126582e-09,
            7.20888904126582e-09,
            7.20888904126582e-09
          ],
          "species_bijection_CIF_to_SCF": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            3
          ],
          "maximum_site_distance_A": 4.69582274986816e-08,
          "relative_Gram_residual": 1.4430596482775559e-09,
          "proper_signed_axis_solution": true
        },
        "attempts": 1,
        "general_GL3_or_chiral_equivalence_asserted": false,
        "CIF_site_precision_A_tolerance": 1e-05,
        "physical_model": "source finite neutral scalar EPC; no SOC transfer certificate"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 22.196,
        "control_K": 15.378,
        "delta_K": 6.818000000000001,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.6476000000000002,
          0.6951999999999998,
          0.7262,
          0.7308999999999999,
          0.7187000000000001,
          0.6983000000000001,
          0.6745999999999999,
          0.6503000000000001,
          0.6265000000000001,
          0.6040000000000001
        ],
        "range": [
          0.6040000000000001,
          0.7308999999999999
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Three-tolerance frozen TiTa3 contrast yields +.1953…+.2764 lambda and Tc+4.258 K. Mo/W comparisons are only two-tolerance and do not become equivalent controls; TiNb3 lambda crosses and Tc is .537 K higher. Target path0/force0 and stress .212 GPa support finite local source scope only.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.002 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.077 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
      "route_response": "Ta-to-Nb site construction in TiNb2Ta against TiTa3. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
      "next_action": "Resolve orbital/mode redistribution for the exact TiTa3→TiNb2Ta frozen roles and retained counterexamples. Favorable: specific advantage persists; adverse: channel/strain removes it; ambiguous: physical route cannot be separated from chemical coupling.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact source CIF/SCF/Γ state association; CIF source record 1507. Experimental occupancy/P/T and physical magnetic ground state remain unknown; source scalar model only.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Ta-to-Nb site construction in TiNb2Ta against TiTa3. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
        "pairing_relevance": "direct published source EPC plus independent source isotropic Eliashberg result.  favorable comparator(s); bounded source model, not experiment.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.002 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.077 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Three-tolerance frozen TiTa3 contrast yields +.1953…+.2764 lambda and Tc+4.258 K. Mo/W comparisons are only two-tolerance and do not become equivalent controls; TiNb3 lambda crosses and Tc is .537 K higher. Target path0/force0 and stress .212 GPa support finite local source scope only.",
        "novelty": "Known Ta-Ti/Nb-Ti-Ta superconducting wires are solid solutions, not source ordered SG123 TiNb2Ta. Exact experimental state not retrieved.",
        "decision": "Resolve orbital/mode redistribution for the exact TiTa3→TiNb2Ta frozen roles and retained counterexamples. Favorable: specific advantage persists; adverse: channel/strain removes it; ambiguous: physical route cannot be separated from chemical coupling."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "residual_force_stress"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 204,
          "control": "batch-a/Nb2HfTa_agm001216814",
          "target": "batch-a/TiNb2Ta_agm001228986",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.25029999999999997,
            -0.15549999999999997
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -11.467973975991935,
            -9.07131105690134
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 22.196,
          "Tc_control_K": 20.749,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 1.4470000000000027,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": false,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9402394314428593,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 2.373908598490119e-07,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001216814",
            "dyn0_source_record": 2088,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              5.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 2095,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 2096,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 2097,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 2098,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 2099,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 2100,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 2101,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 2102,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 2103,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.25029999999999997,
            -0.15549999999999997
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 328,
          "control": "batch-a/TiNb2Mo_agm001228974",
          "target": "batch-a/TiNb2Ta_agm001228986",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.6040000000000001,
            0.7308999999999999
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            50.70466645787663,
            64.99036608863196
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 22.196,
          "Tc_control_K": 15.378,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 6.818000000000001,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": false,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.0442723276448393,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.9755063662237992e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001228974",
            "dyn0_source_record": 7482,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              5.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 7489,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 7490,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 7491,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 7492,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 7493,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 7494,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 7495,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 7496,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 7497,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.6040000000000001,
            0.7308999999999999
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 333,
          "control": "batch-a/TiNb2W_agm001228989",
          "target": "batch-a/TiNb2Ta_agm001228986",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.7122,
            0.8769
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            70.97175341979039,
            87.10698459590633
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 22.196,
          "Tc_control_K": 13.736,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 8.46,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": false,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.0376785680629366,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.575767843524403e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001228989",
            "dyn0_source_record": 11182,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              5.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 11189,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 11190,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 11191,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 11192,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 11193,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 11194,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 11195,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 11196,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 11197,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.7122,
            0.8769
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 334,
          "control": "batch-a/TiNb3_agm001827673",
          "target": "batch-a/TiNb2Ta_agm001228986",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.02639999999999998,
            0.057800000000000074
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -1.619125924988922,
            3.0958757364756333
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 22.196,
          "Tc_control_K": 22.733,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": -0.536999999999999,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.003506196577347,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 8.637269409717946e-07,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001827673",
            "dyn0_source_record": 1460,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              5.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 1467,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 1468,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 1469,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 1470,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 1471,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 1472,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 1473,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 1474,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 1475,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.02639999999999998,
            0.057800000000000074
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 335,
          "control": "batch-a/TiTa3_agm001827667",
          "target": "batch-a/TiNb2Ta_agm001228986",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.19530000000000003,
            0.2764
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            14.35818262020291,
            17.129400099157163
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 22.196,
          "Tc_control_K": 17.938,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 4.258000000000003,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9981556321133174,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 3.107872481009013e-07,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001827667",
            "dyn0_source_record": 3402,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              5.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 3409,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 3410,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 3411,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 3412,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 3413,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 3414,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 3415,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 3416,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 3417,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.19530000000000003,
            0.2764
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 336,
          "control": "batch-a/ZrNb2Ta_agm001233891",
          "target": "batch-a/TiNb2Ta_agm001228986",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.8124,
            -0.43189999999999995
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -29.679964927663303,
            -21.731911039549157
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 22.196,
          "Tc_control_K": 22.564,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": -0.36799999999999855,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": true,
          "three_tol_graph": false,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9351395846581044,
          "control_path_negatives": 4,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 3.1542094248560656e-07,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 4,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -22.6498,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001233891",
            "dyn0_source_record": 1558,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              5.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 1565,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 1566,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 1567,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 1568,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 1569,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 1570,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 1571,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 1572,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 1573,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.8124,
            -0.43189999999999995
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-02-eleven-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1219201,
          "sha256": "ee658cb8e6309178e268b736f8aeb6429c030a92019c068963e2d64ca51cbb17",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-03-fifteen-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1347056,
          "sha256": "1be9342cb74006b2542e9351fc2de310967f1a31a5ee9f1909ae730b9a11476a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-remaining-transition-owned-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 5381838,
          "sha256": "62f4910578c7b65392d26619cf81b31afd6142f38aa49834a70bb147e7ab222d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to the reviewed candidate mechanism catalogue, source prediction already published; not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm002746041",
      "formula": "TiNb2W",
      "reduced_formula": "TiNb2W",
      "composition": {
        "Nb": 2,
        "Ti": 1,
        "W": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Nb:2|Ti:1|W:1",
      "elements": [
        "Nb",
        "Ti",
        "W"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm002746041",
      "control_state": "agm001293942",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/TiNb2W_agm002746041",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/TiNbTaW_agm001293942",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "CIF_source_record": 11271,
        "CIF_payload_pin": {
          "bytes": 591661,
          "sha256": "93c3ce21c362fc36392db6d13f4555d76cce96122769d1212414bbc770f81541"
        },
        "SCF_coarse_source_record": 11287,
        "Gamma_source_pin": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/TiNb2W_agm002746041",
          "bytes": 8994,
          "sha256": "3b72e6ec198934e0507c1f3ec00acbd1ad75950d51595f12e2437bb5d4de47f2"
        },
        "source_input_volume_difference_relative": 4.908518036472742e-11,
        "occupancy_model_all1": true,
        "bounded_signed_axis_and_translation_mapping": {
          "signed_axis_U_CIF_fractional_to_SCF": [
            [
              1,
              0,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              1,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              0,
              1
            ]
          ],
          "determinant": 1,
          "origin_shift_fractional": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species_bijection_CIF_to_SCF": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            3
          ],
          "maximum_site_distance_A": 5.313984010946286e-08,
          "relative_Gram_residual": 1.4118239969911126e-09,
          "proper_signed_axis_solution": true
        },
        "attempts": 1,
        "general_GL3_or_chiral_equivalence_asserted": false,
        "CIF_site_precision_A_tolerance": 1e-05,
        "physical_model": "source finite neutral scalar EPC; no SOC transfer certificate"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 13.641,
        "control_K": 12.118,
        "delta_K": 1.5229999999999997,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.02429999999999999,
          0.04360000000000008,
          0.05080000000000007,
          0.05249999999999999,
          0.051000000000000045,
          0.0484,
          0.04610000000000003,
          0.04420000000000002,
          0.04269999999999996,
          0.04169999999999996
        ],
        "range": [
          0.02429999999999999,
          0.05249999999999999
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Ta-to-Nb contrast yields +.0243…+.0525 lambda and Tc+1.523 K with path0, force0 and .130 GPa stress. Mo-to-W alternative is an actual contrary case: TiNb2Mo has larger lambda and Tc; TiV2W also better. This candidate uses the former controlled route and never rewrites the failed general W enhancement hypothesis.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure 0.002 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.13 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
      "route_response": "Ta-to-Nb role construction in TiNb2W against TiNbTaW. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
      "next_action": "Use existing Nb/Ta minority-role mode/orbital evidence. Favorable: specific Ta-to-Nb paired gain survives; adverse: its channel competition reverses; ambiguous: only wider finite band envelope or nominal electrons are available. Retain failed Mo-to-W edge.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact source CIF/SCF/Γ state association; CIF source record 11271. Experimental occupancy/P/T and physical magnetic ground state remain unknown; source scalar model only.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Ta-to-Nb role construction in TiNb2W against TiNbTaW. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
        "pairing_relevance": "direct published source EPC plus independent source isotropic Eliashberg result.  favorable comparator(s); bounded source model, not experiment.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure 0.002 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.13 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Ta-to-Nb contrast yields +.0243…+.0525 lambda and Tc+1.523 K with path0, force0 and .130 GPa stress. Mo-to-W alternative is an actual contrary case: TiNb2Mo has larger lambda and Tc; TiV2W also better. This candidate uses the former controlled route and never rewrites the failed general W enhancement hypothesis.",
        "novelty": "No exact experimental ordered TiNb2W SG225 phase retrieved. Refractory alloy studies are different disordered states, not exact phase identity.",
        "decision": "Use existing Nb/Ta minority-role mode/orbital evidence. Favorable: specific Ta-to-Nb paired gain survives; adverse: its channel competition reverses; ambiguous: only wider finite band envelope or nominal electrons are available. Retain failed Mo-to-W edge."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "residual_force_stress"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 331,
          "control": "batch-a/TiNb2Mo_agm002322068",
          "target": "batch-a/TiNb2W_agm002746041",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.04859999999999998,
            -0.03939999999999988
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -4.895657078398195,
            -3.712362072189999
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 13.641,
          "Tc_control_K": 14.888,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": -1.2469999999999999,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": true,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.0067737679779265,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 2.050791258399247e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm002322068",
            "dyn0_source_record": 8157,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 8164,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 8165,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 8166,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 8167,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 8168,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 8169,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 8170,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 8171,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.04859999999999998,
            -0.03939999999999988
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 339,
          "control": "batch-a/TiNbTaW_agm001293942",
          "target": "batch-a/TiNb2W_agm002746041",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.02429999999999999,
            0.05249999999999999
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            2.389850511408339,
            5.612572161642078
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 13.641,
          "Tc_control_K": 12.118,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 1.5229999999999997,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9991346615769874,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.552549127284534e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001293942",
            "dyn0_source_record": 16639,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 16646,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 16647,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 16648,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 16649,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 16650,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 16651,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 16652,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 16653,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.02429999999999999,
            0.05249999999999999
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 340,
          "control": "batch-a/TiV2W_agm001099873",
          "target": "batch-a/TiNb2W_agm002746041",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.13070000000000004,
            -0.015300000000000091
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -11.153780508619223,
            -1.7823858341099825
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 13.641,
          "Tc_control_K": 17.103,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": -3.4620000000000015,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": true,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.1610911697688042,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 2.6653405017030005e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001099873",
            "dyn0_source_record": 4681,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 4688,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 4689,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 4690,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 4691,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 4692,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 4693,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 4694,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 4695,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.13070000000000004,
            -0.015300000000000091
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-02-eleven-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1219201,
          "sha256": "ee658cb8e6309178e268b736f8aeb6429c030a92019c068963e2d64ca51cbb17",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-03-fifteen-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1347056,
          "sha256": "1be9342cb74006b2542e9351fc2de310967f1a31a5ee9f1909ae730b9a11476a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-remaining-transition-owned-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 5381838,
          "sha256": "62f4910578c7b65392d26619cf81b31afd6142f38aa49834a70bb147e7ab222d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to the reviewed candidate mechanism catalogue, source prediction already published; not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001827673",
      "formula": "TiNb3",
      "reduced_formula": "TiNb3",
      "composition": {
        "Nb": 3,
        "Ti": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Nb:3|Ti:1",
      "elements": [
        "Nb",
        "Ti"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001827673",
      "control_state": "agm001827667",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/TiNb3_agm001827673",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/TiTa3_agm001827667",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "P4/mmm four-site ordered tetragonal fcc-derived Nb3Ti source phase, one Ti and three Nb sites; not A15 Nb3X or disordered bcc Nb-Ti",
      "prototype_evidence": "P4/mmm four-site ordered tetragonal fcc-derived Nb3Ti source phase, one Ti and three Nb sites; not A15 Nb3X or disordered bcc Nb-Ti",
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 22.733,
        "control_K": 17.938,
        "delta_K": 4.795000000000002,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.1875,
          0.23829999999999996,
          0.27790000000000004,
          0.29520000000000013,
          0.2929999999999999,
          0.27970000000000006,
          0.2628999999999999,
          0.24639999999999995,
          0.23230000000000017,
          0.22089999999999987
        ],
        "range": [
          0.1875,
          0.29520000000000013
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "The exact ordered source has positive Gamma optical compression and no signed negative sampled-path value; fine full max stress is 0.142 GPa. The central competition is known disordered bcc Nb-Ti versus this ordered tetragonal/fcc-derived phase, not an assumption that the experimental alloy validates this ordering. Antisite/phase conversion, SOC and fine residual stress can change the result. Current source local stability is positive finite-grid evidence, not a bulk equilibrium certificate.",
      "ambient_scope": "Both source SCFs converge, near-zero coarse forces/stress and bounded fine response are measured. Fine Fmax=0 eV/A, P=0.096 GPa, full max stress=0.142 GPa. Gamma optical compression is positive beyond printing bound and sampled path has no signed negative values. All listed q outputs have JOBDONE/last response convergence and no routine errors. This supports a finite-grid local/metastable source model, not global hull or experimental synthesis.",
      "route_response": "Nb replaces the three Ta sites as a whole-element construction with complete ordered role mapping across all three symmetry tolerances. Volume contracts 0.5332%, Nb-Nb versus Ta-Ta falls 0.0050234 A; all ten lambda values rise 11.164–18.705% and separate Eli mu=.1 rises 17.938 to 22.733 K. Retained single-site Mo/W controls have larger gains, while the Ta single edit has mixed signs; no global ranking or all-three-route conjunction is claimed.",
      "next_action": "Compare the source ordered tetragonal basin with a same-composition disordered/bcc competitor at matched method and a controlled ordering or distortion path. Retained positive pairing response and local stability support the source-phase screen; barrierless conversion or erased response oppose it.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Complete ordered CIF/literal coarse-fine input/Gamma periodic species-site association is numerically supported; source input geometry and full tensor/forces are retained. Export occupancy is a discrete computational convention; source experimental P/T/occupancy and actual compiled unit constant are unknown. Exact-version input defaults scope the configured neutral scalar spin1/noSOC model, not magnetic ground state.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Nb replaces the three Ta sites as a whole-element construction with complete ordered role mapping across all three symmetry tolerances. Volume contracts 0.5332%, Nb-Nb versus Ta-Ta falls 0.0050234 A; all ten lambda values rise 11.164–18.705% and separate Eli mu=.1 rises 17.938 to 22.733 K. Retained single-site Mo/W controls have larger gains, while the Ta single edit has mixed signs; no global ranking or all-three-route conjunction is claimed.",
        "pairing_relevance": "Exact target and mapped control direct source lambda arrays have the same favorable sign at all ten common broadening tokens; omega_ln has explicit K units and separate Eli/McM mu=.1 tables remain independent. Same underlying q mesh is observed. The sensitivity range is not a physical error bound; sigma units, full-BZ convergence, experimental Tc and pure-geometry causality remain unknown. Literal method differences are declared confounds.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Both source SCFs converge, near-zero coarse forces/stress and bounded fine response are measured. Fine Fmax=0 eV/A, P=0.096 GPa, full max stress=0.142 GPa. Gamma optical compression is positive beyond printing bound and sampled path has no signed negative values. All listed q outputs have JOBDONE/last response convergence and no routine errors. This supports a finite-grid local/metastable source model, not global hull or experimental synthesis.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "The exact ordered source has positive Gamma optical compression and no signed negative sampled-path value; fine full max stress is 0.142 GPa. The central competition is known disordered bcc Nb-Ti versus this ordered tetragonal/fcc-derived phase, not an assumption that the experimental alloy validates this ordering. Antisite/phase conversion, SOC and fine residual stress can change the result. Current source local stability is positive finite-grid evidence, not a bulk equilibrium certificate.",
        "novelty": "Commercial superconducting Nb-Ti is well known, and ordered NbTi/Nb3Ti calculations are also prior. Dated exact P4/mmm Nb3Ti queries did not find an experimental superconducting exact ordered phase. The hypothesis is this source ordering and matched Nb-for-Ta construction at finite-grid scalar approximation, not new Nb-Ti chemistry or inherited bcc alloy Tc.",
        "decision": "Compare the source ordered tetragonal basin with a same-composition disordered/bcc competitor at matched method and a controlled ordering or distortion path. Retained positive pairing response and local stability support the source-phase screen; barrierless conversion or erased response oppose it."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase",
        "residual_force_stress",
        "sampling_method"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index_zero_based": 330,
          "control_directory": "batch-a/TiNb2Mo_agm001228974",
          "mapping_scope": "bounded geometric site-edit control; changed chemical symmetry retained",
          "all_three_symprec_support": false,
          "composition_edit": {
            "from": "Mo",
            "to": "Nb",
            "count": 1,
            "kind": "single_site_substitution"
          },
          "volume_target_over_control": 1.0406236966000662,
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_all10": [
            46.17914187284686,
            55.47651766227466,
            61.015397419891805,
            64.6794927098611,
            66.64276752106113,
            67.40768300623199,
            67.52408477842002,
            67.26368159203983,
            66.78275120352353,
            66.16920651602732
          ],
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_range": [
            46.17914187284686,
            67.52408477842002
          ],
          "separate_source_Eli_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              22.733
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              15.378
            ]
          ],
          "separate_source_McM_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              17.23,
              20.216
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              12.814,
              13.787
            ]
          ],
          "literal_method_same_fields": {
            "ecutwfc": true,
            "smear": true,
            "degauss": true,
            "pseudo_dir": false
          },
          "qmesh_target_control": [
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              5.0
            ],
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              5.0
            ]
          ],
          "irreducible_qcount_target_control": [
            [
              9.0
            ],
            [
              9.0
            ]
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index_zero_based": 334,
          "control_directory": "batch-a/TiNb2Ta_agm001228986",
          "mapping_scope": "bounded geometric site-edit control; changed chemical symmetry retained",
          "all_three_symprec_support": true,
          "composition_edit": {
            "from": "Ta",
            "to": "Nb",
            "count": 1,
            "kind": "single_site_substitution"
          },
          "volume_target_over_control": 0.9965060490217874,
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_all10": [
            -3.002909393183711,
            -0.46059100553743765,
            0.3579395134097696,
            0.9947089947090028,
            1.3573180703188839,
            1.4886658396300878,
            1.5356767488029892,
            1.5525886546245429,
            1.5909658098327975,
            1.64577306332368
          ],
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_range": [
            -3.002909393183711,
            1.64577306332368
          ],
          "separate_source_Eli_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              22.733
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              22.196
            ]
          ],
          "separate_source_McM_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              17.23,
              20.216
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              17.294,
              20.106
            ]
          ],
          "literal_method_same_fields": {
            "ecutwfc": false,
            "smear": true,
            "degauss": true,
            "pseudo_dir": false
          },
          "qmesh_target_control": [
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              5.0
            ],
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              5.0
            ]
          ],
          "irreducible_qcount_target_control": [
            [
              9.0
            ],
            [
              9.0
            ]
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index_zero_based": 337,
          "control_directory": "batch-a/TiNb2W_agm001228989",
          "mapping_scope": "bounded geometric site-edit control; changed chemical symmetry retained",
          "all_three_symprec_support": false,
          "composition_edit": {
            "from": "W",
            "to": "Nb",
            "count": 1,
            "kind": "single_site_substitution"
          },
          "volume_target_over_control": 1.0340529725727876,
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_all10": [
            65.83762657665662,
            77.36997417926965,
            84.10734678340313,
            87.83703995276521,
            89.50264981655116,
            89.89238235914752,
            89.62922573609595,
            89.00382280188892,
            88.28630897317299,
            87.48962409581405
          ],
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_range": [
            65.83762657665662,
            89.89238235914752
          ],
          "separate_source_Eli_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              22.733
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              13.736
            ]
          ],
          "separate_source_McM_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              17.23,
              20.216
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              11.615,
              12.307
            ]
          ],
          "literal_method_same_fields": {
            "ecutwfc": true,
            "smear": true,
            "degauss": true,
            "pseudo_dir": false
          },
          "qmesh_target_control": [
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              5.0
            ],
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              5.0
            ]
          ],
          "irreducible_qcount_target_control": [
            [
              9.0
            ],
            [
              9.0
            ]
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index_zero_based": 341,
          "control_directory": "batch-a/TiTa3_agm001827667",
          "mapping_scope": "bounded ordered isostructural analogue",
          "all_three_symprec_support": true,
          "composition_edit": {
            "from": "Nb",
            "to": "Ta",
            "count": 3,
            "kind": "whole_element_substitution"
          },
          "volume_target_over_control": 0.9946681273650183,
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_all10": [
            11.164036915748735,
            14.14159397068423,
            16.774310376048774,
            18.294496777392176,
            18.70531154239019,
            18.400105256233147,
            17.811653116531158,
            17.17551930851805,
            16.64040114613182,
            16.240258785472715
          ],
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_range": [
            11.164036915748735,
            18.70531154239019
          ],
          "separate_source_Eli_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              22.733
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              17.938
            ]
          ],
          "separate_source_McM_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              17.23,
              20.216
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              14.731,
              16.625
            ]
          ],
          "literal_method_same_fields": {
            "ecutwfc": false,
            "smear": true,
            "degauss": true,
            "pseudo_dir": false
          },
          "qmesh_target_control": [
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              5.0
            ],
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              5.0
            ]
          ],
          "irreducible_qcount_target_control": [
            [
              9.0
            ],
            [
              9.0
            ]
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "nat": 4,
        "lambda10": [
          1.867,
          1.9234,
          1.9346,
          1.9088,
          1.8594,
          1.7998,
          1.7389,
          1.681,
          1.6283,
          1.5811
        ],
        "omega10_K": [
          131.4612,
          130.2453,
          129.4357,
          129.0066,
          128.8345,
          128.8368,
          128.9424,
          129.0973,
          129.2673,
          129.4336
        ],
        "Eli_mu01": [
          0.1,
          22.733
        ],
        "McM_mu01": [
          0.1,
          17.23,
          20.216
        ],
        "coarse_fine": [
          {
            "record": 1477,
            "version": [
              "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on  8Oct2022 at  7:21: 5"
            ],
            "converged": true,
            "JOBDONE": true,
            "errors": 0,
            "Fmax_eVA": 0.0,
            "P_GPa": 0.0,
            "maxstress_GPa": 0.005,
            "fulltensor": [
              [
                -0.002,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                -0.002,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                0.005
              ]
            ],
            "F_Ry": -492.10347413,
            "E_Ry": -492.10269979,
            "pattern_selected_warning_counts": {
              "BFGS": 1,
              "negative_charge": 0,
              "eigen_text": 0,
              "failure_text": 0,
              "SCF_correction_text": 1
            },
            "warning_scope": "pattern-selected contexts; informational SCF correction and ignored cell card are not optimization failure; no whole-file warning-free claim"
          },
          {
            "record": 1478,
            "version": [
              "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on  8Oct2022 at  7:12:35"
            ],
            "converged": true,
            "JOBDONE": true,
            "errors": 0,
            "Fmax_eVA": 0.0,
            "P_GPa": 0.096,
            "maxstress_GPa": 0.142,
            "fulltensor": [
              [
                0.142,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                0.142,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                0.005
              ]
            ],
            "F_Ry": -492.1041288,
            "E_Ry": -492.10406474,
            "pattern_selected_warning_counts": {
              "BFGS": 1,
              "negative_charge": 0,
              "eigen_text": 9,
              "failure_text": 0,
              "SCF_correction_text": 1
            },
            "warning_scope": "pattern-selected contexts; informational SCF correction and ignored cell card are not optimization failure; no whole-file warning-free claim"
          }
        ],
        "inputs": [
          {
            "record": 1462,
            "ecutwfc": [
              98.0
            ],
            "ecutrho": null,
            "pseudo_dir": [
              "/hppfs/work/pn49qo/di29xud3/software/progs/qe/pp/nc-sr-04_pbesol_stringent_upf/"
            ],
            "spin": null,
            "noncol": null,
            "SOC": null,
            "charge": null,
            "smear": [
              "mp"
            ],
            "degauss": [
              0.014699728870262
            ],
            "ibrav": [
              6.0
            ],
            "nat": [
              4.0
            ],
            "grid": [
              "6 6 10 0 0 0"
            ]
          },
          {
            "record": 1463,
            "ecutwfc": [
              98.0
            ],
            "ecutrho": null,
            "pseudo_dir": [
              "/hppfs/work/pn49qo/di29xud3/software/progs/qe/pp/nc-sr-04_pbesol_stringent_upf/"
            ],
            "spin": null,
            "noncol": null,
            "SOC": null,
            "charge": null,
            "smear": [
              "mp"
            ],
            "degauss": [
              0.014699728870262
            ],
            "ibrav": [
              6.0
            ],
            "nat": [
              4.0
            ],
            "grid": [
              "24 24 40 0 0 0"
            ]
          }
        ],
        "Gamma": {
          "nat": 4,
          "ibrav": 6,
          "q": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species": [
            "Nb",
            "Ti"
          ],
          "optical": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "minopt": 8.637269409717946e-07,
          "printingbound": 1.2377674101522938e-12,
          "negative_native_modes": [
            1,
            2,
            3
          ],
          "negativeoutside3": [],
          "min_low3_translation": 0.9999725355900968,
          "sourcepin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/TiNb3_agm001827673",
            "bytes": 8948,
            "sha256": "21a773baf742a8c8a74731df69235883ce1339c8d0107c12ae663d3656e3203a"
          }
        },
        "path": {
          "rows": 159,
          "negatives": 0,
          "minimum": -0.0,
          "unit": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-2-compact-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 84096,
          "sha256": "d8ca53bafc5ee0879de647e050127d8e0d20c0e3da10de9602ab2de44bf77532",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-3-five-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 110335,
          "sha256": "861dd76c8368cca687ca20c8468e464badefb533a318ed41c4f8d62dccb6ed50",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-4-three-phase-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 64369,
          "sha256": "56076a077e591b9bdef8ada45d78f224f417a4af8d2e722e332f639eedfafaf7",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all64-light-Nb-rich-owned-review-cache-v2.json",
          "bytes": 4566542,
          "sha256": "f27e8c84c10c4d8de44022f6bd160e7e8aee8b2d562db5fd6003af68d5e35756",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to this reviewed candidate catalogue and mechanism contrast; MC2023 prediction is prior, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001294071",
      "formula": "TiNbMoTa",
      "reduced_formula": "TiNbMoTa",
      "composition": {
        "Mo": 1,
        "Nb": 1,
        "Ta": 1,
        "Ti": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Mo:1|Nb:1|Ta:1|Ti:1",
      "elements": [
        "Mo",
        "Nb",
        "Ta",
        "Ti"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001294071",
      "control_state": "agm002191224",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/TiNbMoTa_agm001294071",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/TiMoTa2_agm002191224",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "CIF_source_record": 13375,
        "CIF_payload_pin": {
          "bytes": 591661,
          "sha256": "93c3ce21c362fc36392db6d13f4555d76cce96122769d1212414bbc770f81541"
        },
        "SCF_coarse_source_record": 13391,
        "Gamma_source_pin": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/TiNbMoTa_agm001294071",
          "bytes": 9040,
          "sha256": "885b4ec87f4f9817fbdf00b8f957023af34dfc442facf5c31f5280db177828c9"
        },
        "source_input_volume_difference_relative": -7.089140385829751e-11,
        "occupancy_model_all1": true,
        "bounded_signed_axis_and_translation_mapping": {
          "signed_axis_U_CIF_fractional_to_SCF": [
            [
              1,
              0,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              1,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              0,
              1
            ]
          ],
          "determinant": 1,
          "origin_shift_fractional": [
            -0.25,
            -0.25,
            -0.24999998999999995
          ],
          "species_bijection_CIF_to_SCF": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            3
          ],
          "maximum_site_distance_A": 7.863152842656546e-08,
          "relative_Gram_residual": 1.068084318568453e-09,
          "proper_signed_axis_solution": true
        },
        "attempts": 1,
        "general_GL3_or_chiral_equivalence_asserted": false,
        "CIF_site_precision_A_tolerance": 1e-05,
        "physical_model": "source finite neutral scalar EPC; no SOC transfer certificate"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 13.031,
        "control_K": 11.632,
        "delta_K": 1.399000000000001,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.011300000000000088,
          0.03370000000000006,
          0.03710000000000002,
          0.036599999999999966,
          0.0343,
          0.03179999999999994,
          0.029900000000000038,
          0.02860000000000007,
          0.027999999999999914,
          0.027700000000000058
        ],
        "range": [
          0.011300000000000088,
          0.03710000000000002
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Both Ta→Nb and W→Mo frozen routes are favorable, whereas replacement of Nb by Ta in TiNb2Mo is adverse. All are geometry-selected controls, not selected by Tc. No high-W/high-n claim; exact SG216 role/composition construction has direct scalar EPC support. Real HEA disorder/carbon or nitrogen contamination are distinct possible physical states, not parent properties.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.001 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.079 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
      "route_response": "Ta-to-Nb ordered role substitution in Ti-Mo-Ta quaternary framework. coupled chemical/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
      "next_action": "Resolve source site-orbital and mode response for Ta/Nb on this ordered metal structure. Favorable: matched ordering retains direct EPC/Tc advantage; adverse: observed real state is disordered/carbidic or response reverses; ambiguous: same formula without phase coordinates.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact source CIF/SCF/Γ state association; CIF source record 13375. Experimental occupancy/P/T and physical magnetic ground state remain unknown; source scalar model only.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Ta-to-Nb ordered role substitution in Ti-Mo-Ta quaternary framework. coupled chemical/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
        "pairing_relevance": "direct published source EPC and independent source isotropic Eliashberg result. 2 favorable comparator(s); bounded source model, not experiment.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.001 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.079 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Both Ta→Nb and W→Mo frozen routes are favorable, whereas replacement of Nb by Ta in TiNb2Mo is adverse. All are geometry-selected controls, not selected by Tc. No high-W/high-n claim; exact SG216 role/composition construction has direct scalar EPC support. Real HEA disorder/carbon or nitrogen contamination are distinct possible physical states, not parent properties.",
        "novelty": "The exact formula query did not identify an experimental exact ordered metal phase. ROOT primary lookup found HEA/carbide studies of TiNbMoTa; those are composition references with different disorder/interstitial chemistry, not this source four-site ordered metal geometry. Source 2023 prediction is already known.",
        "decision": "Resolve source site-orbital and mode response for Ta/Nb on this ordered metal structure. Favorable: matched ordering retains direct EPC/Tc advantage; adverse: observed real state is disordered/carbidic or response reverses; ambiguous: same formula without phase coordinates."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 327,
          "control": "batch-a/TiMoTa2_agm002191224",
          "target": "batch-a/TiNbMoTa_agm001294071",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.011300000000000088,
            0.03710000000000002
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            1.093901258470483,
            3.9186295503211954
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 13.031,
          "Tc_control_K": 11.632,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 1.399000000000001,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9997847347564393,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.0703795308691416e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.011300000000000088,
            0.03710000000000002
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 332,
          "control": "batch-a/TiNb2Mo_agm002322068",
          "target": "batch-a/TiNbMoTa_agm001294071",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.05740000000000001,
            -0.045399999999999885
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -6.192893401015223,
            -4.16628429843075
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 13.031,
          "Tc_control_K": 14.888,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": -1.8569999999999993,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": true,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.0011284700199319,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 2.050791258399247e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.05740000000000001,
            -0.045399999999999885
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 342,
          "control": "batch-a/TiNbTaW_agm001293942",
          "target": "batch-a/TiNbMoTa_agm001294071",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.02750000000000008,
            0.03710000000000013
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            2.7045633359559482,
            3.8185412548122013
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 13.031,
          "Tc_control_K": 12.118,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 0.9130000000000003,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9935321984972323,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.552549127284534e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.02750000000000008,
            0.03710000000000013
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-01-ten-specific-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 381754,
          "sha256": "5d05478212c4d22080ab1b7bf22d92b784de6c0f8a99590d0758f9cdbfdafb32",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-remaining-transition-owned-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 5381838,
          "sha256": "62f4910578c7b65392d26619cf81b31afd6142f38aa49834a70bb147e7ab222d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to the reviewed candidate mechanism catalogue, source prediction already published; not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003603739",
      "formula": "TiNbTa",
      "reduced_formula": "TiNbTa",
      "composition": {
        "Nb": 1,
        "Ta": 1,
        "Ti": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Nb:1|Ta:1|Ti:1",
      "elements": [
        "Nb",
        "Ta",
        "Ti"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003603739",
      "control_state": "agm001004440",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/TiNbTa_agm003603739",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/TiNbTa_agm001004440",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": null,
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 22.169,
        "control_K": 21.327,
        "delta_K": 0.8419999999999987,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.21629999999999994,
          0.1851999999999996,
          0.12350000000000017,
          0.0826,
          0.05729999999999991,
          0.04269999999999996,
          0.03400000000000003,
          0.027599999999999847,
          0.021600000000000064,
          0.01529999999999987
        ],
        "range": [
          0.01529999999999987,
          0.21629999999999994
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": [
        1.0239184357588953,
        1.0224760271497049,
        1.0185693067425774,
        1.0153478884918836,
        1.01281087507158,
        1.011036635167005,
        1.009975462523651,
        1.009467565940967,
        1.0093314706338896,
        1.0094089829496884
      ],
      "risk_summary": "The fine target F is higher by 14.33 and 30.51 meV/atom than its two controls. Source-force norms are about 0.025–0.037 eV/Å and anisotropic stresses remain. Known Ti–Nb–Ta alloy superconducting wire is a chemistry reference, not this exact ordered ternary.",
      "ambient_scope": "Exact model force/full stress, converged electronic outputs, reported finite-q workflow and raw Γ optical evidence provide a bounded near-ambient source-model screen. Source residual stress/metastable alternatives remain explicit; this is not proof of synthesizeability, full BZ or global equilibrium.",
      "route_response": "One three-site target A is contrasted with both the six-site B and the different three-site hexagonal C. All ten λ rows favor A in each contrast; separate Eliashberg gains are 0.842 and 4.841 K. Complete species-channel geometry differences and computed all-σ pairing response are saved against the frozen controls. Cell/grid/method sensitivity prevents a pure geometry-only causal claim; no bandwidth/carrier quantity is substituted.",
      "next_action": "Hold one composition group, retain both controls, and test exact ordering/metastable persistence plus a common physical k/q comparison. A stable competing order that removes the target pairing advantage is the adverse outcome.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Source-specific full-species CIF→both SCF inputs→Γ coordinate/cell association, actual atom order and origin, within 1e-6 Å observational matching policy. Original experimental occupancy and measured P/T unknown; configured QE neutral/nonmagnetic/no-SOC model is distinct from a magnetic ground-state claim.",
        "novelty": "One exact reduced composition/ordered phase-design group, new to the frozen reviewed cohort. Published computed source is acknowledged, known experimental chemistry remains a comparator. Bounded primary phase search has not tied the exact target order to an established SC sample; no global absence claim.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "One three-site target A is contrasted with both the six-site B and the different three-site hexagonal C. All ten λ rows favor A in each contrast; separate Eliashberg gains are 0.842 and 4.841 K. Complete species-channel geometry differences and computed all-σ pairing response are saved against the frozen controls. Cell/grid/method sensitivity prevents a pure geometry-only causal claim; no bandwidth/carrier quantity is substituted.",
        "pairing_relevance": "All ten source λ/ω rows retained with original units/nulls, and μ*=0.1 source McMillan, Allen–Dynes and Eliashberg products kept separate. Source Gaussian EPC broadening is distinct from explicit MP electronic SCF smearing. No product maximum or selected σ defines the recommendation.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Exact model force/full stress, converged electronic outputs, reported finite-q workflow and raw Γ optical evidence provide a bounded near-ambient source-model screen. Source residual stress/metastable alternatives remain explicit; this is not proof of synthesizeability, full BZ or global equilibrium.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "The fine target F is higher by 14.33 and 30.51 meV/atom than its two controls. Source-force norms are about 0.025–0.037 eV/Å and anisotropic stresses remain. Known Ti–Nb–Ta alloy superconducting wire is a chemistry reference, not this exact ordered ternary.",
        "decision": "Hold one composition group, retain both controls, and test exact ordering/metastable persistence plus a common physical k/q comparison. A stable competing order that removes the target pairing advantage is the adverse outcome."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "residual_force_stress"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "control_directory": "batch-a/TiNbTa_agm001004440",
          "lambda_target_minus_control_all10": [
            0.21629999999999994,
            0.1851999999999996,
            0.12350000000000017,
            0.0826,
            0.05729999999999991,
            0.04269999999999996,
            0.03400000000000003,
            0.027599999999999847,
            0.021600000000000064,
            0.01529999999999987
          ],
          "omega_log_target_over_control_all10": [
            1.0239184357588953,
            1.0224760271497049,
            1.0185693067425774,
            1.0153478884918836,
            1.01281087507158,
            1.011036635167005,
            1.009975462523651,
            1.009467565940967,
            1.0093314706338896,
            1.0094089829496884
          ],
          "source_Eli_mu01_target_control_K": [
            22.169,
            21.327
          ],
          "separate_Eli_target_minus_control_K": 0.8419999999999987,
          "target_control_q_mesh_match": false,
          "target_control_q_meshes": [
            [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ]
          ],
          "q_comparison_scope": "Different cells can have different configured physical sampling. Actual meshes retained as confounds; source-paired products do not establish convergence or isolated geometry causality.",
          "original_frozen_pair": {
            "original_contrast_index": 36,
            "composition": {
              "Nb": 1,
              "Ta": 1,
              "Ti": 1
            },
            "fixed_A": "batch-a/TiNbTa_agm003603739",
            "fixed_B": "batch-a/TiNbTa_agm001004440",
            "lambda_B_minus_A_all10": [
              -0.21629999999999994,
              -0.1851999999999996,
              -0.12350000000000017,
              -0.0826,
              -0.05729999999999991,
              -0.04269999999999996,
              -0.03400000000000003,
              -0.027599999999999847,
              -0.021600000000000064,
              -0.01529999999999987
            ],
            "lambda_direction": "A",
            "separate_Eli_A_B_K": [
              22.169,
              21.327
            ],
            "separate_Eli_B_minus_A_K": -0.8419999999999987
          },
          "control_source_q_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001004440",
            "dyn0_source_record": 1875,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 1882,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 1883,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 1884,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 1885,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 1886,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 1887,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 1888,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 1889,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.01529999999999987,
            0.21629999999999994
          ]
        },
        {
          "control_directory": "batch-a/TiNbTa_agm001259673",
          "lambda_target_minus_control_all10": [
            0.9823999999999999,
            0.8964999999999999,
            0.7688000000000001,
            0.6820000000000002,
            0.6221999999999999,
            0.5777000000000001,
            0.5422,
            0.512,
            0.48530000000000006,
            0.46089999999999987
          ],
          "omega_log_target_over_control_all10": [
            0.8365932965622601,
            0.8394504894065933,
            0.8332477351393651,
            0.8272899463707137,
            0.8228891455119519,
            0.8200125568149321,
            0.8182784843041474,
            0.8173324885178586,
            0.8169206680032374,
            0.8168491561348704
          ],
          "source_Eli_mu01_target_control_K": [
            22.169,
            17.328
          ],
          "separate_Eli_target_minus_control_K": 4.841000000000001,
          "target_control_q_mesh_match": false,
          "target_control_q_meshes": [
            [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              5.0
            ]
          ],
          "q_comparison_scope": "Different cells can have different configured physical sampling. Actual meshes retained as confounds; source-paired products do not establish convergence or isolated geometry causality.",
          "original_frozen_pair": {
            "original_contrast_index": 37,
            "composition": {
              "Nb": 1,
              "Ta": 1,
              "Ti": 1
            },
            "fixed_A": "batch-a/TiNbTa_agm003603739",
            "fixed_B": "batch-a/TiNbTa_agm001259673",
            "lambda_B_minus_A_all10": [
              -0.9823999999999999,
              -0.8964999999999999,
              -0.7688000000000001,
              -0.6820000000000002,
              -0.6221999999999999,
              -0.5777000000000001,
              -0.5422,
              -0.512,
              -0.48530000000000006,
              -0.46089999999999987
            ],
            "lambda_direction": "A",
            "separate_Eli_A_B_K": [
              22.169,
              17.328
            ],
            "separate_Eli_B_minus_A_K": -4.841000000000001
          },
          "control_source_q_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001259673",
            "dyn0_source_record": 4232,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              5.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 4239,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 11,
                "source_record": 4240,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 4241,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 4242,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 4243,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 4244,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 4245,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 4246,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 4247,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 4248,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 4249,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.46089999999999987,
            0.9823999999999999
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "SCF_stages": {
          "scf_coarse.out.bz2": {
            "source_record": 1649,
            "explicit_program_start_headers": [
              {
                "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 15Mar2023 at 15:26:38"
              }
            ],
            "last_printed_convergence_event": {
              "value": true,
              "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
            },
            "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
            "routine_error_count": 0,
            "warning_patterns": {
              "pattern_selected_count": 6,
              "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
              "BFGS": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
                }
              },
              "negative_charge": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "eigen_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "failure_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "SCF_correction_text": {
                "count": 2,
                "last": {
                  "value": "SCF correction compared to forces is large: reduce conv_thr to get better values"
                }
              }
            },
            "last_force": {
              "header": {
                "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
              },
              "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "printed_site_rows": 3,
              "ordered_atom_indices": [
                1,
                2,
                3
              ],
              "reported_max_abs_component": {
                "value": 4.01e-06,
                "unit": "Ry/bohr",
                "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
              },
              "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 4.01e-06,
              "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 4.01e-06,
              "max_component_eV_A": 0.00010310124529003339,
              "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.00010310124529003339,
              "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
              "conversion_constants": {
                "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
                "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
              },
              "unit_conversion_valid": true,
              "max_norm_site": {
                "value": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  -4.01e-06
                ],
                "atom_index": 3,
                "type_index": 1
              },
              "reported_component_agrees": true
            },
            "last_stress": {
              "last_pressure_print": {
                "value": -0.0,
                "unit": "kbar",
                "raw_value": "-0.00",
                "GPa": -0.0
              },
              "last_stress_block": {
                "header": {
                  "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.00"
                },
                "complete_3x6": true,
                "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
                "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
                "rows": [
                  {
                    "value": [
                      -1e-08,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -0.0,
                      0.0,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      -1e-08,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -0.0,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      -0.0,
                      1e-08,
                      0.0,
                      -0.0,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  }
                ],
                "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                  [
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                ],
                "trace_mean_kbar": 0.0,
                "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.0,
                "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
              }
            },
            "last_total_energy_print": {
              "value": -891.36580221,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-891.36580221"
            },
            "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
              "value": -0.00064993,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-0.00064993"
            },
            "native_exit_status": null,
            "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
            "PH_all_irreps_complete": null,
            "fullBZ_dynamical_stability": null,
            "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -891.36515228
          },
          "scf_fine.out.bz2": {
            "source_record": 1650,
            "explicit_program_start_headers": [
              {
                "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 15Mar2023 at 14:28: 9"
              }
            ],
            "last_printed_convergence_event": {
              "value": true,
              "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
            },
            "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
            "routine_error_count": 0,
            "warning_patterns": {
              "pattern_selected_count": 7,
              "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
              "BFGS": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
                }
              },
              "negative_charge": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "eigen_text": {
                "count": 2,
                "last": {
                  "value": "c_bands:  1 eigenvalues not converged"
                }
              },
              "failure_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "SCF_correction_text": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Total force =     0.001217     Total SCF correction =     0.000003"
                }
              }
            },
            "last_force": {
              "header": {
                "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
              },
              "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "printed_site_rows": 3,
              "ordered_atom_indices": [
                1,
                2,
                3
              ],
              "reported_max_abs_component": {
                "value": 0.00099036,
                "unit": "Ry/bohr",
                "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
              },
              "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.00099036,
              "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.00099036,
              "max_component_eV_A": 0.025463179372927053,
              "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.025463179372927053,
              "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
              "conversion_constants": {
                "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
                "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
              },
              "unit_conversion_valid": true,
              "max_norm_site": {
                "value": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.00099036
                ],
                "atom_index": 3,
                "type_index": 1
              },
              "reported_component_agrees": true
            },
            "last_stress": {
              "last_pressure_print": {
                "value": -1.03,
                "unit": "kbar",
                "raw_value": "-1.03",
                "GPa": -0.10300000000000001
              },
              "last_stress_block": {
                "header": {
                  "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -1.03"
                },
                "complete_3x6": true,
                "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
                "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
                "rows": [
                  {
                    "value": [
                      6.89e-06,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      1.01,
                      0.0,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      6.89e-06,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      1.01,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -3.476e-05,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -5.11
                    ]
                  }
                ],
                "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                  [
                    0.101,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    0.101,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.511
                  ]
                ],
                "trace_mean_kbar": -1.03,
                "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.511,
                "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
              }
            },
            "last_total_energy_print": {
              "value": -891.36550213,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-891.36550213"
            },
            "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
              "value": -0.00057947,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-0.00057947"
            },
            "native_exit_status": null,
            "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
            "PH_all_irreps_complete": null,
            "fullBZ_dynamical_stability": null,
            "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -891.3649226599999
          }
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/TiNbTa_agm003603739",
            "bytes": 5549,
            "sha256": "d35b841b604d8b4a5aa3b275ae3170cc994818f54e410eff024d90122b55e38b"
          },
          "raw_header": {
            "ntyp": 3,
            "nat": 3,
            "ibrav": 7,
            "celldm": [
              6.170528,
              0.0,
              2.962119,
              0.0,
              0.0,
              0.0
            ],
            "basis_alat": null,
            "species": [
              {
                "index": 1,
                "element": "Nb",
                "header_mass": 84679.0034279501,
                "header_mass_halfwidth": 5e-11,
                "raw_mass_token": "84679.0034279501",
                "line": 4
              },
              {
                "index": 2,
                "element": "Ta",
                "header_mass": 164923.921757601,
                "header_mass_halfwidth": 5e-10,
                "raw_mass_token": "164923.921757601",
                "line": 5
              },
              {
                "index": 3,
                "element": "Ti",
                "header_mass": 43628.1015848821,
                "header_mass_halfwidth": 5e-11,
                "raw_mass_token": "43628.1015848821",
                "line": 6
              }
            ],
            "atoms": [
              {
                "index": 1,
                "type": 2,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  1.9861362418
                ],
                "line": 7
              },
              {
                "index": 2,
                "type": 3,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  1.0177656846
                ],
                "line": 8
              },
              {
                "index": 3,
                "type": 1,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0315147625
                ],
                "line": 9
              }
            ],
            "q": [
              0.0,
              0.0,
              0.0
            ],
            "matrix_header_line": 11
          },
          "optical_sign": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "minimum": 1.772584653345223e-06,
          "printing_bound": 8.653652969992056e-13,
          "ASR_relative": 0.007162504335870862,
          "native_signed_modes": [
            {
              "number": 1,
              "THz": -0.460734,
              "cm_inverse": -15.368426,
              "line": 57
            },
            {
              "number": 2,
              "THz": -0.460734,
              "cm_inverse": -15.368426,
              "line": 61
            },
            {
              "number": 3,
              "THz": -0.32346,
              "cm_inverse": -10.789462,
              "line": 65
            },
            {
              "number": 4,
              "THz": 4.380046,
              "cm_inverse": 146.102597,
              "line": 69
            },
            {
              "number": 5,
              "THz": 4.380046,
              "cm_inverse": 146.102597,
              "line": 73
            },
            {
              "number": 6,
              "THz": 4.67532,
              "cm_inverse": 155.95188,
              "line": 77
            },
            {
              "number": 7,
              "THz": 5.800056,
              "cm_inverse": 193.469055,
              "line": 81
            },
            {
              "number": 8,
              "THz": 5.901253,
              "cm_inverse": 196.8446,
              "line": 85
            },
            {
              "number": 9,
              "THz": 5.901253,
              "cm_inverse": 196.8446,
              "line": 89
            }
          ],
          "native_negative_outside_lowest3": []
        },
        "finite_path": {
          "source_record": 1629,
          "observations": {
            "kind": "qe_freq_gp_source_path_table",
            "raw_header_lines": [],
            "path_rows": 172,
            "column_width_counts": {
              "10": 172
            },
            "mode_column_values": 1548,
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "column_roles_conditional_on_file_schema": true,
            "fullBZ_coverage": null,
            "dynamical_stability": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          }
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm003603739",
          "dyn0_source_record": 1628,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                4.0,
                4.0,
                4.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                13.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 10,
              "source_record": 1635,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 11,
              "source_record": 1636,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 12,
              "source_record": 1637,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 13,
              "source_record": 1638,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 1639,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 1640,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 1641,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 1642,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 5,
              "source_record": 1643,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 6,
              "source_record": 1644,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 7,
              "source_record": 1645,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 8,
              "source_record": 1646,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 9,
              "source_record": 1647,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 13,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "composition-assessments.json",
          "bytes": 2036037,
          "sha256": "87a3759b8bb3bd9985bd6537220b4ea8fa427be6672204f9010e300e647c284a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "numeric-review.json",
          "bytes": 2556012,
          "sha256": "a0e7a487691b01ab8f0a4ea02eab40af649a455b97dc9ebdfdcabc4cd2453000",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Exact ordered-state mechanism new to reviewed catalogue only; source predictions/known chemistry acknowledged, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001116200",
      "formula": "TiNbTa2",
      "reduced_formula": "TiNbTa2",
      "composition": {
        "Nb": 1,
        "Ta": 2,
        "Ti": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Nb:1|Ta:2|Ti:1",
      "elements": [
        "Nb",
        "Ta",
        "Ti"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001116200",
      "control_state": "agm001116139",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/TiNbTa2_agm001116200",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/TiTa2W_agm001116139",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "CIF_source_record": 3345,
        "CIF_payload_pin": {
          "bytes": 591661,
          "sha256": "93c3ce21c362fc36392db6d13f4555d76cce96122769d1212414bbc770f81541"
        },
        "SCF_coarse_source_record": 3365,
        "Gamma_source_pin": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/TiNbTa2_agm001116200",
          "bytes": 8994,
          "sha256": "10174dd16e39e616e6cf0a6fa9b95c45d4ceafe9ab9962852c8efac2b99a70eb"
        },
        "source_input_volume_difference_relative": 5.848987960632712e-11,
        "occupancy_model_all1": true,
        "bounded_signed_axis_and_translation_mapping": {
          "signed_axis_U_CIF_fractional_to_SCF": [
            [
              1,
              0,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              1,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              0,
              1
            ]
          ],
          "determinant": 1,
          "origin_shift_fractional": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species_bijection_CIF_to_SCF": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            3
          ],
          "maximum_site_distance_A": 1.9998299722792695e-16,
          "relative_Gram_residual": 6.218863800439255e-10,
          "proper_signed_axis_solution": true
        },
        "attempts": 1,
        "general_GL3_or_chiral_equivalence_asserted": false,
        "CIF_site_precision_A_tolerance": 1e-05,
        "physical_model": "source finite neutral scalar EPC; no SOC transfer certificate"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 18.117,
        "control_K": 12.899,
        "delta_K": 5.218000000000002,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.5005999999999999,
          0.5296000000000001,
          0.5266,
          0.5142,
          0.5009000000000001,
          0.4881000000000001,
          0.4756,
          0.46340000000000003,
          0.45179999999999987,
          0.4405999999999999
        ],
        "range": [
          0.4405999999999999,
          0.5296000000000001
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "All-token lambda gain +.4406…+.5296 with separate source Tc+5.218 K, positive optical Gamma and no path negatives support finite-source pairing. Geoopt explicitly reports BFGS failure yet final force .000162 eV/A and near-zero coarse stress; fine force .03397 and stress .041 GPa remain uncertainties. This qualifies only source-coarse basin, not converged fine geometry.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse force 0.00014912399568134507 eV/Å, pressure -0.0 GPa; fine force 0.03397455998160851 eV/Å, pressure -0.027000000000000003 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
      "route_response": "W-to-Nb role construction in TiTa2X. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
      "next_action": "Resolve existing fine residual-force direction and paired orbital/mode contributions against TiTa2W. Favorable: internal displacement uncertainty does not reverse role gain; adverse: relevant relaxation/channel response reverses it; ambiguous: no matched mode evidence.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact source CIF/SCF/Γ state association; CIF source record 3345. Experimental occupancy/P/T and physical magnetic ground state remain unknown; source scalar model only.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "W-to-Nb role construction in TiTa2X. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
        "pairing_relevance": "direct published source EPC plus independent source isotropic Eliashberg result.  favorable comparator(s); bounded source model, not experiment.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse force 0.00014912399568134507 eV/Å, pressure -0.0 GPa; fine force 0.03397455998160851 eV/Å, pressure -0.027000000000000003 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "All-token lambda gain +.4406…+.5296 with separate source Tc+5.218 K, positive optical Gamma and no path negatives support finite-source pairing. Geoopt explicitly reports BFGS failure yet final force .000162 eV/A and near-zero coarse stress; fine force .03397 and stress .041 GPa remain uncertainties. This qualifies only source-coarse basin, not converged fine geometry.",
        "novelty": "Closest Ta-Ti and Nb-Ti-Ta superconducting alloy studies concern solid-solution wires rather than this ordered SG123 4-site object. No exact experimental ordered phase retrieved.",
        "decision": "Resolve existing fine residual-force direction and paired orbital/mode contributions against TiTa2W. Favorable: internal displacement uncertainty does not reverse role gain; adverse: relevant relaxation/channel response reverses it; ambiguous: no matched mode evidence."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "residual_force_stress"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 344,
          "control": "batch-a/TiTa2W_agm001116139",
          "target": "batch-a/TiNbTa2_agm001116200",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.4405999999999999,
            0.5296000000000001
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            41.67846141037382,
            50.147962667880705
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 18.117,
          "Tc_control_K": 12.899,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 5.218000000000002,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.029914180418602,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 7.184027564790758e-07,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001116139",
            "dyn0_source_record": 13497,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              5.0,
              5.0,
              2.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 13504,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 11,
                "source_record": 13505,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 12,
                "source_record": 13506,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 13507,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 13508,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 13509,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 13510,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 13511,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 13512,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 13513,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 13514,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 13515,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.4405999999999999,
            0.5296000000000001
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-02-eleven-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1219201,
          "sha256": "ee658cb8e6309178e268b736f8aeb6429c030a92019c068963e2d64ca51cbb17",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-03-fifteen-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1347056,
          "sha256": "1be9342cb74006b2542e9351fc2de310967f1a31a5ee9f1909ae730b9a11476a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-remaining-transition-owned-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 5381838,
          "sha256": "62f4910578c7b65392d26619cf81b31afd6142f38aa49834a70bb147e7ab222d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to the reviewed candidate mechanism catalogue, source prediction already published; not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001116139",
      "formula": "TiTa2W",
      "reduced_formula": "TiTa2W",
      "composition": {
        "Ta": 2,
        "Ti": 1,
        "W": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Ta:2|Ti:1|W:1",
      "elements": [
        "Ta",
        "Ti",
        "W"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001116139",
      "control_state": "agm001116204",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/TiTa2W_agm001116139",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/TiMoTa2_agm001116204",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "CIF_source_record": 13479,
        "CIF_payload_pin": {
          "bytes": 591661,
          "sha256": "93c3ce21c362fc36392db6d13f4555d76cce96122769d1212414bbc770f81541"
        },
        "SCF_coarse_source_record": 13499,
        "Gamma_source_pin": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/TiTa2W_agm001116139",
          "bytes": 8994,
          "sha256": "c9227414554c2191a98717a5607ae6aa83df8d784b3aa71d436ebb881dcffaad"
        },
        "source_input_volume_difference_relative": 7.150946501610633e-12,
        "occupancy_model_all1": true,
        "bounded_signed_axis_and_translation_mapping": {
          "signed_axis_U_CIF_fractional_to_SCF": [
            [
              1,
              0,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              1,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              0,
              1
            ]
          ],
          "determinant": 1,
          "origin_shift_fractional": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species_bijection_CIF_to_SCF": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            3
          ],
          "maximum_site_distance_A": 1.9728292245545834e-16,
          "relative_Gram_residual": 9.23942394021846e-10,
          "proper_signed_axis_solution": true
        },
        "attempts": 1,
        "general_GL3_or_chiral_equivalence_asserted": false,
        "CIF_site_precision_A_tolerance": 1e-05,
        "physical_model": "source finite neutral scalar EPC; no SOC transfer certificate"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 12.899,
        "control_K": 12.132,
        "delta_K": 0.7669999999999995,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.12630000000000008,
          0.09409999999999985,
          0.08000000000000007,
          0.07529999999999992,
          0.07350000000000001,
          0.07140000000000002,
          0.06840000000000002,
          0.06469999999999998,
          0.0606000000000001,
          0.056400000000000006
        ],
        "range": [
          0.056400000000000006,
          0.12630000000000008
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "All-tokenlambda+.0564…+.1263 andsourceTc+.767K versusTiMoTa2 coexistwithpath0/Gammaopt+. TiNbTa2 is betterboth and retained. Fineforce .031835/stress .541GPa are refinementlimits; nophysicalWmeasurement. A failedW effect in TiNb2Mo doesnoterase thisdifferenthost-specific source response.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse force 2.1340158002675243e-05 eV/Å, pressure -0.003 GPa; fine force 0.03183463064358121 eV/Å, pressure -0.065 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
      "route_response": "Mo-to-W role construction in TiTa2X. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
      "next_action": "Resolve Mo/W site EPC and fine-force/strain projections. Favorable: local coupled-rolegain survivesuncertainty; adverse: matchingrelaxation/channel reverses; ambiguous: finitebandspanalone cannotexplain.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact source CIF/SCF/Γ state association; CIF source record 13479. Experimental occupancy/P/T and physical magnetic ground state remain unknown; source scalar model only.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Mo-to-W role construction in TiTa2X. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
        "pairing_relevance": "direct published source EPC plus independent source isotropic Eliashberg result.  favorable comparator(s); bounded source model, not experiment.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse force 2.1340158002675243e-05 eV/Å, pressure -0.003 GPa; fine force 0.03183463064358121 eV/Å, pressure -0.065 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "All-tokenlambda+.0564…+.1263 andsourceTc+.767K versusTiMoTa2 coexistwithpath0/Gammaopt+. TiNbTa2 is betterboth and retained. Fineforce .031835/stress .541GPa are refinementlimits; nophysicalWmeasurement. A failedW effect in TiNb2Mo doesnoterase thisdifferenthost-specific source response.",
        "novelty": "No exactorderedTiTa2W experimentalSG123phase retrieved; knownTa-Tialloywires are not thisphase.",
        "decision": "Resolve Mo/W site EPC and fine-force/strain projections. Favorable: local coupled-rolegain survivesuncertainty; adverse: matchingrelaxation/channel reverses; ambiguous: finitebandspanalone cannotexplain."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "residual_force_stress"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 323,
          "control": "batch-a/TiMoTa2_agm001116204",
          "target": "batch-a/TiTa2W_agm001116139",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.056400000000000006,
            0.12630000000000008
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            6.8596448552663585,
            11.751023446222561
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 12.899,
          "Tc_control_K": 12.132,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 0.7669999999999995,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.0067566194986732,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 6.033349130894898e-07,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001116204",
            "dyn0_source_record": 16175,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              5.0,
              5.0,
              2.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 16182,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 11,
                "source_record": 16183,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 12,
                "source_record": 16184,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 16185,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 16186,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 16187,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 16188,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 16189,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 16190,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 16191,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 16192,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 16193,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.056400000000000006,
            0.12630000000000008
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 344,
          "control": "batch-a/TiNbTa2_agm001116200",
          "target": "batch-a/TiTa2W_agm001116139",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.5296000000000001,
            -0.4405999999999999
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -33.39902971497877,
            -29.41764118234706
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 12.899,
          "Tc_control_K": 18.117,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": -5.218000000000002,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": true,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9709546863346966,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 6.805037668516839e-07,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001116200",
            "dyn0_source_record": 3363,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              5.0,
              5.0,
              2.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 3370,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 11,
                "source_record": 3371,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 12,
                "source_record": 3372,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 3373,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 3374,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 3375,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 3376,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 3377,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 3378,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 3379,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 3380,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 3381,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.5296000000000001,
            -0.4405999999999999
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-02-eleven-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1219201,
          "sha256": "ee658cb8e6309178e268b736f8aeb6429c030a92019c068963e2d64ca51cbb17",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-03-fifteen-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1347056,
          "sha256": "1be9342cb74006b2542e9351fc2de310967f1a31a5ee9f1909ae730b9a11476a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-remaining-transition-owned-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 5381838,
          "sha256": "62f4910578c7b65392d26619cf81b31afd6142f38aa49834a70bb147e7ab222d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to the reviewed candidate mechanism catalogue, source prediction already published; not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001827667",
      "formula": "TiTa3",
      "reduced_formula": "TiTa3",
      "composition": {
        "Ta": 3,
        "Ti": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Ta:3|Ti:1",
      "elements": [
        "Ta",
        "Ti"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001827667",
      "control_state": "agm001828806",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/TiTa3_agm001827667",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/NbTa3_agm001828806",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "CIF_source_record": 3387,
        "CIF_payload_pin": {
          "bytes": 591661,
          "sha256": "93c3ce21c362fc36392db6d13f4555d76cce96122769d1212414bbc770f81541"
        },
        "SCF_coarse_source_record": 3404,
        "Gamma_source_pin": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/TiTa3_agm001827667",
          "bytes": 8948,
          "sha256": "59d43521151c055da5bac83de8fabdd826ed904dacd67ce8bf6f2970f5de7dff"
        },
        "source_input_volume_difference_relative": 5.036837613658918e-11,
        "occupancy_model_all1": true,
        "bounded_signed_axis_and_translation_mapping": {
          "signed_axis_U_CIF_fractional_to_SCF": [
            [
              1,
              0,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              1,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              0,
              1
            ]
          ],
          "determinant": 1,
          "origin_shift_fractional": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species_bijection_CIF_to_SCF": [
            0,
            2,
            1,
            3
          ],
          "maximum_site_distance_A": 3.7060276252784866e-16,
          "relative_Gram_residual": 1.6418341576238458e-09,
          "proper_signed_axis_solution": true
        },
        "attempts": 1,
        "general_GL3_or_chiral_equivalence_asserted": false,
        "CIF_site_precision_A_tolerance": 1e-05,
        "physical_model": "source finite neutral scalar EPC; no SOC transfer certificate"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 17.938,
        "control_K": 12.871,
        "delta_K": 5.066999999999998,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.6045,
          0.5983,
          0.5656000000000001,
          0.5316999999999998,
          0.5045,
          0.48540000000000005,
          0.4717,
          0.46110000000000007,
          0.45189999999999986,
          0.44300000000000006
        ],
        "range": [
          0.44300000000000006,
          0.6045
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "All-tokenlambda+.443…+.6045 andTc+5.067K againstNbTa3;alsofavorableMoTiTa2contrast. TiNb2Ta andTiNb3 arebetter and visible. Path0/force0 andstress .259GPa supportonlysource-localbasin. OrdinaryTa-Ti solid-solutionformation is a physical competingphase, notproofofretainedorderedstate.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.004 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.128 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
      "route_response": "Nb-to-Ti minority-role construction in TiTa3. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
      "next_action": "Compare savedTi/Nb role EPC and feasibleordering versusknownsolid solution. Favorable: distinctlocalorderinggainplausibly retained; adverse: disorder/competitioneliminates object; ambiguous: noordering/retention evidence.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact source CIF/SCF/Γ state association; CIF source record 3387. Experimental occupancy/P/T and physical magnetic ground state remain unknown; source scalar model only.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Nb-to-Ti minority-role construction in TiTa3. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
        "pairing_relevance": "direct published source EPC plus independent source isotropic Eliashberg result.  favorable comparator(s); bounded source model, not experiment.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.004 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.128 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "All-tokenlambda+.443…+.6045 andTc+5.067K againstNbTa3;alsofavorableMoTiTa2contrast. TiNb2Ta andTiNb3 arebetter and visible. Path0/force0 andstress .259GPa supportonlysource-localbasin. OrdinaryTa-Ti solid-solutionformation is a physical competingphase, notproofofretainedorderedstate.",
        "novelty": "Primary1967Ta-Ti superconducting solid-solutionwires areknown; theyare not exactTi25Ta75SG123 ordered4sitephase. Noexactexperimentalorderedphase retrieved.",
        "decision": "Compare savedTi/Nb role EPC and feasibleordering versusknownsolid solution. Favorable: distinctlocalorderinggainplausibly retained; adverse: disorder/competitioneliminates object; ambiguous: noordering/retention evidence."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase",
        "residual_force_stress"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 230,
          "control": "batch-a/NbTa3_agm001828806",
          "target": "batch-a/TiTa3_agm001827667",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.44300000000000006,
            0.6045
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            46.912148448825754,
            56.23255813953489
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 17.938,
          "Tc_control_K": 12.871,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 5.066999999999998,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9812451026352117,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 7.344381569891782e-07,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001828806",
            "dyn0_source_record": 13920,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              5.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 13929,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 13930,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 13931,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 13932,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 13933,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 13934,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 13935,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 13936,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 13937,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.44300000000000006,
            0.6045
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 325,
          "control": "batch-a/TiMoTa2_agm001228967",
          "target": "batch-a/TiTa3_agm001827667",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.5579000000000001,
            0.6565000000000001
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            59.194312796208536,
            69.53757945905522
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 17.938,
          "Tc_control_K": 12.078,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 5.859999999999999,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.0441211024229855,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.1661332544377764e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001228967",
            "dyn0_source_record": 16276,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              5.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 16283,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 16284,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 16285,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 16286,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 16287,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 16288,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 16289,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 16290,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 16291,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.5579000000000001,
            0.6565000000000001
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 335,
          "control": "batch-a/TiNb2Ta_agm001228986",
          "target": "batch-a/TiTa3_agm001827667",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.2764,
            -0.19530000000000003
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -14.624338624338623,
            -12.555448408871746
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 17.938,
          "Tc_control_K": 22.196,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": -4.258000000000003,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": true,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.00184777586515,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 5.972912806548787e-07,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001228986",
            "dyn0_source_record": 1522,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              5.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 1529,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 1530,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 1531,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 1532,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 1533,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 1534,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 1535,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 1536,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 1537,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.2764,
            -0.19530000000000003
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 341,
          "control": "batch-a/TiNb3_agm001827673",
          "target": "batch-a/TiTa3_agm001827667",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.29520000000000013,
            -0.1875
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -15.757771324083034,
            -10.042849491162292
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 17.938,
          "Tc_control_K": 22.733,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": -4.795000000000002,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": true,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.005360451107911,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 8.637269409717946e-07,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001827673",
            "dyn0_source_record": 1460,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              5.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 1467,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 1468,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 1469,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 1470,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 1471,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 1472,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 1473,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 1474,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 1475,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.29520000000000013,
            -0.1875
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-02-eleven-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1219201,
          "sha256": "ee658cb8e6309178e268b736f8aeb6429c030a92019c068963e2d64ca51cbb17",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-03-fifteen-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1347056,
          "sha256": "1be9342cb74006b2542e9351fc2de310967f1a31a5ee9f1909ae730b9a11476a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-remaining-transition-owned-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 5381838,
          "sha256": "62f4910578c7b65392d26619cf81b31afd6142f38aa49834a70bb147e7ab222d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to the reviewed candidate mechanism catalogue, source prediction already published; not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001099873",
      "formula": "TiV2W",
      "reduced_formula": "TiV2W",
      "composition": {
        "Ti": 1,
        "V": 2,
        "W": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Ti:1|V:2|W:1",
      "elements": [
        "Ti",
        "V",
        "W"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001099873",
      "control_state": "agm001229241",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/TiV2W_agm001099873",
      "control_directory": null,
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "ordered full-Heusler-like four-site primitive phase versus tetragonal ordering",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "motif": "ordered full-Heusler-like four-site primitive phase versus tetragonal ordering",
        "verified_space_group": null,
        "role": "A versus samecomposition B",
        "known_prior_scope": "Published source predictions are acknowledged; exact ordered Heusler-like TiV2W experimental SC benchmark not identified in bounded primary search. Conventional16-site representation is an alias, not another material group."
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 17.103,
        "control_K": 15.875,
        "delta_K": 1.2280000000000015,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.08889999999999998,
          0.07909999999999995,
          0.06900000000000017,
          0.06529999999999991,
          0.06400000000000006,
          0.06169999999999998,
          0.05729999999999991,
          0.052100000000000035,
          0.04689999999999994,
          0.04250000000000009
        ],
        "range": [
          0.04250000000000009,
          0.08889999999999998
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "All ten lambda gains5.21-8.21%, separate source Eli Tc17.103 versus15.875K (+7.74%). Source fine F target is8.760meV/atom lower, but QE6.8/7.1 and q4^3/3x3x5 confound precise causal/rank inference. Control fullstress0.663GPa cannot be hidden by small hydrostatic pressure; V magnetism, W SOC and disorder remain overturning physical risks. Evaluated risks define a falsifiable bounded hypothesis, not an established bulk ground state or experimental coherence proof.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source nearambient fullstress/pressure and coarse-relaxed geometry, positive raw-Gamma optical compression beyond printing bounds, and no negative printed finite-path values support preliminary local feasibility only within the declared source approximation. WholeBZ/global hull/synthesis remain unknown.",
      "route_response": "Ti-Ti shortest4.32741 versus3.06244A and Ti-W neighbor count6 versus4 at about3.06A; volumes differ0.102%, so not a pure strain/primitive-cell alias. Computed source EPC response is associated with construction; pure geometry-only causality and converged numerical uplift are unproved.",
      "next_action": "Match code/reciprocal sampling of both ordered states, retain fullstress, and test magnetic/SOC sensitivity if the pairing ordering is robust.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact reduced composition and non-alias decorated ordered network linked to canonical SCF input and source PH/Gamma/model evidence; source positions bind Gamma within printing/operational tolerances. Nb same-species permutation and Zr scalar parity reflection are explicit. Experimental phase/state remains unknown.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Ti-Ti shortest4.32741 versus3.06244A and Ti-W neighbor count6 versus4 at about3.06A; volumes differ0.102%, so not a pure strain/primitive-cell alias. Computed source EPC response is associated with construction; pure geometry-only causality and converged numerical uplift are unproved.",
        "pairing_relevance": "Direct source lambda at ten common printed width tokens and independently retained mu*=0.1 Eliashberg Tc rows provide state-specific pairing relevance. Width units and Tc-to-width link remain unknown; no parent-property transfer or300K claim.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source nearambient fullstress/pressure and coarse-relaxed geometry, positive raw-Gamma optical compression beyond printing bounds, and no negative printed finite-path values support preliminary local feasibility only within the declared source approximation. WholeBZ/global hull/synthesis remain unknown.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "All ten lambda gains5.21-8.21%, separate source Eli Tc17.103 versus15.875K (+7.74%). Source fine F target is8.760meV/atom lower, but QE6.8/7.1 and q4^3/3x3x5 confound precise causal/rank inference. Control fullstress0.663GPa cannot be hidden by small hydrostatic pressure; V magnetism, W SOC and disorder remain overturning physical risks. Evaluated risks define a falsifiable bounded hypothesis, not an established bulk ground state or experimental coherence proof.",
        "novelty": "Published source predictions are acknowledged; exact ordered Heusler-like TiV2W experimental SC benchmark not identified in bounded primary search. Conventional16-site representation is an alias, not another material group. Default one exact-composition group, with all source/control variants underneath.",
        "decision": "Match code/reciprocal sampling of both ordered states, retain fullstress, and test magnetic/SOC sensitivity if the pairing ordering is robust. All seven minima support grade3 preliminary source-model screening; retained model-dependent uncertainty prevents grade4/formal publication."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "magnetic_model",
        "metastable_phase",
        "residual_force_stress"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [],
      "physical_summary": {
        "target": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/TiV2W_agm001099873",
          "site_composition_matches_name": true,
          "site_count": 4,
          "volume_per_site_A3": 14.325475044496482,
          "source_fine_pressure_GPa": 0.129,
          "source_fine_maxstress_GPa": 0.129,
          "source_fine_maxforce_eV_A": 0.0,
          "fine_JOB_DONE": true,
          "fine_convergence": true,
          "path_min_signed_printed_value": -0.0,
          "path_units_not_inferred": null,
          "path_signed_negative_printed_count": 0,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        },
        "control": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/TiV2W_agm001229241",
          "site_composition_matches_name": true,
          "site_count": 4,
          "volume_per_site_A3": 14.340141199942925,
          "source_fine_pressure_GPa": -0.028999999999999998,
          "source_fine_maxstress_GPa": 0.663,
          "source_fine_maxforce_eV_A": 0.0,
          "fine_JOB_DONE": true,
          "fine_convergence": true,
          "path_min_signed_printed_value": -0.0,
          "path_units_not_inferred": null,
          "path_signed_negative_printed_count": 0,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-owned-five-pairs-scientific-workingview.json",
          "bytes": 933925,
          "sha256": "0a5d3b507b305b8991218157264276e898799837932a8050942ecf74ee389034",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-captured-five-pairs-method-slices.json",
          "bytes": 1387111,
          "sha256": "d84758cc1e54d79e08e01fe3b08b96dfa071953b16a488b0aef3a867ff30c147",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "CASE.md",
          "bytes": 6744,
          "sha256": "992e8549b51e96ffe5ffe85525d6915b4cf02665edd9fb34fa23c5933d3d4704",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "receipt.json",
          "bytes": 22444,
          "sha256": "4772aaec35c5cf28426f09895c0f414427609c340c776511b9e2a953040b5430",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "compact-receipt.json",
          "bytes": 10485,
          "sha256": "4f870f243383fa1c615b11558fe463d6723c134454495e422659cfa4d3777f44",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "new-to-reviewed-catalogue ordered source-model route hypothesis; literature-derived, not first discovery",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003157370",
      "formula": "TiZr",
      "reduced_formula": "TiZr",
      "composition": {
        "Ti": 1,
        "Zr": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Ti:1|Zr:1",
      "elements": [
        "Ti",
        "Zr"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003157370",
      "control_state": "agm002028544",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/TiZr_agm003157370",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/TiZr_agm002028544",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": null,
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 18.892,
        "control_K": 13.173,
        "delta_K": 5.718999999999999,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.40490000000000004,
          0.391,
          0.4113,
          0.41559999999999997,
          0.4041000000000001,
          0.38670000000000004,
          0.3678000000000001,
          0.3500000000000001,
          0.33440000000000003,
          0.32199999999999984
        ],
        "range": [
          0.32199999999999984,
          0.41559999999999997
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": [
        1.0048008551886878,
        0.9853311850236229,
        0.9700073995011992,
        0.9579847551631752,
        0.9480859619342809,
        0.9397374573898757,
        0.9326768875075314,
        0.9266373022395725,
        0.9213832152396794,
        0.9167530771159818
      ],
      "risk_summary": "A fine F is 23.25 meV/atom higher. Known hexagonal Ti–Zr alloy superconductivity and pressure-induced bcc behavior cannot be assigned to these ordered near-zero-pressure tetragonal source states.",
      "ambient_scope": "Exact model force/full stress, converged electronic outputs, reported finite-q workflow and raw Γ optical evidence provide a bounded near-ambient source-model screen. Source residual stress/metastable alternatives remain explicit; this is not proof of synthesizeability, full BZ or global equilibrium.",
      "route_response": "Two-site tetragonal A versus four-site tetragonal B has large all-ten λ enhancement and separate Eliashberg +5.719 K with positive tested optical Γ and no saved negative path values. Complete species-channel geometry differences and computed all-σ pairing response are saved against the frozen controls. Cell/grid/method sensitivity prevents a pure geometry-only causal claim; no bandwidth/carrier quantity is substituted.",
      "next_action": "Test exact tetragonal phase persistence against the known hexagonal/order-disorder reference and match physical k/q sampling. Reversion to the established alloy phase or loss of the pairing response is adverse.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Source-specific full-species CIF→both SCF inputs→Γ coordinate/cell association, actual atom order and origin, within 1e-6 Å observational matching policy. Original experimental occupancy and measured P/T unknown; configured QE neutral/nonmagnetic/no-SOC model is distinct from a magnetic ground-state claim.",
        "novelty": "One exact reduced composition/ordered phase-design group, new to the frozen reviewed cohort. Published computed source is acknowledged, known experimental chemistry remains a comparator. Bounded primary phase search has not tied the exact target order to an established SC sample; no global absence claim.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Two-site tetragonal A versus four-site tetragonal B has large all-ten λ enhancement and separate Eliashberg +5.719 K with positive tested optical Γ and no saved negative path values. Complete species-channel geometry differences and computed all-σ pairing response are saved against the frozen controls. Cell/grid/method sensitivity prevents a pure geometry-only causal claim; no bandwidth/carrier quantity is substituted.",
        "pairing_relevance": "All ten source λ/ω rows retained with original units/nulls, and μ*=0.1 source McMillan, Allen–Dynes and Eliashberg products kept separate. Source Gaussian EPC broadening is distinct from explicit MP electronic SCF smearing. No product maximum or selected σ defines the recommendation.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Exact model force/full stress, converged electronic outputs, reported finite-q workflow and raw Γ optical evidence provide a bounded near-ambient source-model screen. Source residual stress/metastable alternatives remain explicit; this is not proof of synthesizeability, full BZ or global equilibrium.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "A fine F is 23.25 meV/atom higher. Known hexagonal Ti–Zr alloy superconductivity and pressure-induced bcc behavior cannot be assigned to these ordered near-zero-pressure tetragonal source states.",
        "decision": "Test exact tetragonal phase persistence against the known hexagonal/order-disorder reference and match physical k/q sampling. Reversion to the established alloy phase or loss of the pairing response is adverse."
      },
      "risk_tags": [],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "control_directory": "batch-a/TiZr_agm002028544",
          "lambda_target_minus_control_all10": [
            0.40490000000000004,
            0.391,
            0.4113,
            0.41559999999999997,
            0.4041000000000001,
            0.38670000000000004,
            0.3678000000000001,
            0.3500000000000001,
            0.33440000000000003,
            0.32199999999999984
          ],
          "omega_log_target_over_control_all10": [
            1.0048008551886878,
            0.9853311850236229,
            0.9700073995011992,
            0.9579847551631752,
            0.9480859619342809,
            0.9397374573898757,
            0.9326768875075314,
            0.9266373022395725,
            0.9213832152396794,
            0.9167530771159818
          ],
          "source_Eli_mu01_target_control_K": [
            18.892,
            13.173
          ],
          "separate_Eli_target_minus_control_K": 5.718999999999999,
          "target_control_q_mesh_match": false,
          "target_control_q_meshes": [
            [
              5.0,
              5.0,
              4.0
            ],
            [
              5.0,
              5.0,
              2.0
            ]
          ],
          "q_comparison_scope": "Different cells can have different configured physical sampling. Actual meshes retained as confounds; source-paired products do not establish convergence or isolated geometry causality.",
          "original_frozen_pair": {
            "original_contrast_index": 68,
            "composition": {
              "Ti": 1,
              "Zr": 1
            },
            "fixed_A": "batch-a/TiZr_agm003157370",
            "fixed_B": "batch-a/TiZr_agm002028544",
            "lambda_B_minus_A_all10": [
              -0.40490000000000004,
              -0.391,
              -0.4113,
              -0.41559999999999997,
              -0.4041000000000001,
              -0.38670000000000004,
              -0.3678000000000001,
              -0.3500000000000001,
              -0.33440000000000003,
              -0.32199999999999984
            ],
            "lambda_direction": "A",
            "separate_Eli_A_B_K": [
              18.892,
              13.173
            ],
            "separate_Eli_B_minus_A_K": -5.718999999999999
          },
          "control_source_q_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm002028544",
            "dyn0_source_record": 12283,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              5.0,
              5.0,
              2.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 12290,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 11,
                "source_record": 12291,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 12,
                "source_record": 12292,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 12293,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 12294,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 12295,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 12296,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 12297,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 12298,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 12299,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 12300,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 12301,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.32199999999999984,
            0.41559999999999997
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "SCF_stages": {
          "scf_coarse.out.bz2": {
            "source_record": 2823,
            "explicit_program_start_headers": [
              {
                "value": "Program PWSCF v.6.8 starts on 10May2023 at 17:22:11"
              }
            ],
            "last_printed_convergence_event": {
              "value": true,
              "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
            },
            "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
            "routine_error_count": 0,
            "warning_patterns": {
              "pattern_selected_count": 5,
              "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
              "BFGS": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
                }
              },
              "negative_charge": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "eigen_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "failure_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "SCF_correction_text": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Total force =     0.000000     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
                }
              }
            },
            "last_force": {
              "header": {
                "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
              },
              "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "printed_site_rows": 2,
              "ordered_atom_indices": [
                1,
                2
              ],
              "reported_max_abs_component": {
                "value": 0.0,
                "unit": "Ry/bohr",
                "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
              },
              "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
              "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
              "max_component_eV_A": 0.0,
              "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.0,
              "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
              "conversion_constants": {
                "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
                "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
              },
              "unit_conversion_valid": true,
              "max_norm_site": {
                "value": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                "atom_index": 1,
                "type_index": 2
              },
              "reported_component_agrees": true
            },
            "last_stress": {
              "last_pressure_print": {
                "value": -0.03,
                "unit": "kbar",
                "raw_value": "-0.03",
                "GPa": -0.003
              },
              "last_stress_block": {
                "header": {
                  "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.03"
                },
                "complete_3x6": true,
                "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
                "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
                "rows": [
                  {
                    "value": [
                      -2.1e-07,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -0.03,
                      0.0,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      -2.1e-07,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -0.03,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -1.8e-07,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -0.03
                    ]
                  }
                ],
                "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                  [
                    -0.003,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    -0.003,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.003
                  ]
                ],
                "trace_mean_kbar": -0.03,
                "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.003,
                "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
              }
            },
            "last_total_energy_print": {
              "value": -219.78279378,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-219.78279378"
            },
            "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
              "value": 8.406e-05,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "0.00008406"
            },
            "native_exit_status": null,
            "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
            "PH_all_irreps_complete": null,
            "fullBZ_dynamical_stability": null,
            "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -219.78287784
          },
          "scf_fine.out.bz2": {
            "source_record": 2824,
            "explicit_program_start_headers": [
              {
                "value": "Program PWSCF v.6.8 starts on 10May2023 at 17:19:24"
              }
            ],
            "last_printed_convergence_event": {
              "value": true,
              "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
            },
            "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
            "routine_error_count": 0,
            "warning_patterns": {
              "pattern_selected_count": 6,
              "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
              "BFGS": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
                }
              },
              "negative_charge": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "eigen_text": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "c_bands:  1 eigenvalues not converged"
                }
              },
              "failure_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "SCF_correction_text": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Total force =     0.000000     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
                }
              }
            },
            "last_force": {
              "header": {
                "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
              },
              "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "printed_site_rows": 2,
              "ordered_atom_indices": [
                1,
                2
              ],
              "reported_max_abs_component": {
                "value": 0.0,
                "unit": "Ry/bohr",
                "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
              },
              "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
              "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
              "max_component_eV_A": 0.0,
              "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.0,
              "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
              "conversion_constants": {
                "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
                "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
              },
              "unit_conversion_valid": true,
              "max_norm_site": {
                "value": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                "atom_index": 1,
                "type_index": 2
              },
              "reported_component_agrees": true
            },
            "last_stress": {
              "last_pressure_print": {
                "value": 0.44,
                "unit": "kbar",
                "raw_value": "0.44",
                "GPa": 0.044
              },
              "last_stress_block": {
                "header": {
                  "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=        0.44"
                },
                "complete_3x6": true,
                "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
                "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
                "rows": [
                  {
                    "value": [
                      6.28e-06,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      0.92,
                      0.0,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      6.28e-06,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      0.92,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -3.66e-06,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -0.54
                    ]
                  }
                ],
                "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                  [
                    0.092,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    0.092,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.054000000000000006
                  ]
                ],
                "trace_mean_kbar": 0.43333333333333335,
                "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.092,
                "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
              }
            },
            "last_total_energy_print": {
              "value": -219.782774,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-219.78277400"
            },
            "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
              "value": -6.322e-05,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-0.00006322"
            },
            "native_exit_status": null,
            "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
            "PH_all_irreps_complete": null,
            "fullBZ_dynamical_stability": null,
            "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -219.78271078
          }
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/TiZr_agm003157370",
            "bytes": 2972,
            "sha256": "af483d9edcbb4ba0d14b1d857fb28e56a5deb025afebc859bd7a9ef833898fae"
          },
          "raw_header": {
            "ntyp": 2,
            "nat": 2,
            "ibrav": 6,
            "celldm": [
              5.7716482,
              0.0,
              1.367662,
              0.0,
              0.0,
              0.0
            ],
            "basis_alat": null,
            "species": [
              {
                "index": 1,
                "element": "Ti",
                "header_mass": 43628.10158488205,
                "header_mass_halfwidth": 5e-13,
                "raw_mass_token": "43628.101584882053",
                "line": 4
              },
              {
                "index": 2,
                "element": "Zr",
                "header_mass": 83145.58963334408,
                "header_mass_halfwidth": 5e-13,
                "raw_mass_token": "83145.589633344076",
                "line": 5
              }
            ],
            "atoms": [
              {
                "index": 1,
                "type": 2,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.5,
                  0.5,
                  0.683831003
                ],
                "line": 6
              },
              {
                "index": 2,
                "type": 1,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                "line": 7
              }
            ],
            "q": [
              0.0,
              0.0,
              0.0
            ],
            "matrix_header_line": 9
          },
          "optical_sign": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "minimum": 1.9354349659208597e-06,
          "printing_bound": 7.413612110057396e-13,
          "ASR_relative": 0.00442973523608993,
          "native_signed_modes": [
            {
              "number": 1,
              "THz": -0.353188,
              "cm_inverse": -11.781092,
              "line": 35
            },
            {
              "number": 2,
              "THz": -0.339562,
              "cm_inverse": -11.326576,
              "line": 38
            },
            {
              "number": 3,
              "THz": -0.339562,
              "cm_inverse": -11.326576,
              "line": 41
            },
            {
              "number": 4,
              "THz": 4.576857,
              "cm_inverse": 152.667504,
              "line": 44
            },
            {
              "number": 5,
              "THz": 4.576857,
              "cm_inverse": 152.667504,
              "line": 47
            },
            {
              "number": 6,
              "THz": 6.692804,
              "cm_inverse": 223.247923,
              "line": 50
            }
          ],
          "native_negative_outside_lowest3": []
        },
        "finite_path": {
          "source_record": 2798,
          "observations": {
            "kind": "qe_freq_gp_source_path_table",
            "raw_header_lines": [],
            "path_rows": 195,
            "column_width_counts": {
              "7": 195
            },
            "mode_column_values": 1170,
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "column_roles_conditional_on_file_schema": true,
            "fullBZ_coverage": null,
            "dynamical_stability": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          }
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm003157370",
          "dyn0_source_record": 2797,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                5.0,
                5.0,
                4.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                18.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 10,
              "source_record": 2804,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 11,
              "source_record": 2805,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 12,
              "source_record": 2806,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 13,
              "source_record": 2807,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 14,
              "source_record": 2808,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 15,
              "source_record": 2809,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 16,
              "source_record": 2810,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 17,
              "source_record": 2811,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 18,
              "source_record": 2812,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 2813,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 2814,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 2815,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 2816,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 5,
              "source_record": 2817,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 6,
              "source_record": 2818,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 7,
              "source_record": 2819,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 8,
              "source_record": 2820,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 9,
              "source_record": 2821,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 18,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "composition-assessments.json",
          "bytes": 2036037,
          "sha256": "87a3759b8bb3bd9985bd6537220b4ea8fa427be6672204f9010e300e647c284a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "numeric-review.json",
          "bytes": 2556012,
          "sha256": "a0e7a487691b01ab8f0a4ea02eab40af649a455b97dc9ebdfdcabc4cd2453000",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Exact ordered-state mechanism new to reviewed catalogue only; source predictions/known chemistry acknowledged, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001190274",
      "formula": "TiZr3",
      "reduced_formula": "TiZr3",
      "composition": {
        "Ti": 1,
        "Zr": 3
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Ti:1|Zr:3",
      "elements": [
        "Ti",
        "Zr"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001190274",
      "control_state": "agm003187562",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/TiZr3_agm001190274",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/ScZr3_agm003187562",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "CIF_source_record": 7403,
        "CIF_payload_pin": {
          "bytes": 591661,
          "sha256": "93c3ce21c362fc36392db6d13f4555d76cce96122769d1212414bbc770f81541"
        },
        "SCF_coarse_source_record": 7421,
        "Gamma_source_pin": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/TiZr3_agm001190274",
          "bytes": 8948,
          "sha256": "5fd87ce4140f210849af3df7c981a0a925e4741b7f86ef92a68ee9315db1e48c"
        },
        "source_input_volume_difference_relative": -2.4022339673024362e-11,
        "occupancy_model_all1": true,
        "bounded_signed_axis_and_translation_mapping": {
          "signed_axis_U_CIF_fractional_to_SCF": [
            [
              1,
              0,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              1,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              0,
              1
            ]
          ],
          "determinant": 1,
          "origin_shift_fractional": [
            8.0406133e-17,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species_bijection_CIF_to_SCF": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            3
          ],
          "maximum_site_distance_A": 5.542130112966221e-16,
          "relative_Gram_residual": 1.0186071243182519e-10,
          "proper_signed_axis_solution": true
        },
        "attempts": 1,
        "general_GL3_or_chiral_equivalence_asserted": false,
        "CIF_site_precision_A_tolerance": 1e-05,
        "physical_model": "source finite neutral scalar EPC; no SOC transfer certificate"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 15.214,
        "control_K": 13.368,
        "delta_K": 1.846,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.04190000000000005,
          0.07010000000000005,
          0.08830000000000005,
          0.10789999999999988,
          0.12360000000000015,
          0.13430000000000009,
          0.14100000000000001,
          0.14550000000000018,
          0.1484000000000001,
          0.15049999999999997
        ],
        "range": [
          0.04190000000000005,
          0.15049999999999997
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Severalhealthyfrozencontrolshaveall-tokenlambda/Tcbenefits;Zr3Lu hasaopposinglambda/Tcdirection and remainsvisible. Force0/path0/Gammaopt+ with .076GPastress supportonlylocalorderedsourcebasin. KnownmisciblehcpTi-Zralloys areactualcompetingstates; neitherhigh-pressureTc norordinaryalloyTc canbe inheritedbyambientSG221phase.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.001 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure 0.076 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
      "route_response": "Sc-to-Ti minorityrole orHf-to-Zr majorityrole construction in TiZr3. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
      "next_action": "Compare savedorderedSG221 role/modebenefit against exactfrozenScZr3/Hfparentandboundhcp/disorderretention. Favorable: locallyretainedorderingbenefit; adverse: onlyhcp/disorderexistsorpairedgainreverses; ambiguous: no comparablephase/formationdata.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact source CIF/SCF/Γ state association; CIF source record 7403. Experimental occupancy/P/T and physical magnetic ground state remain unknown; source scalar model only.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Sc-to-Ti minorityrole orHf-to-Zr majorityrole construction in TiZr3. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
        "pairing_relevance": "direct published source EPC plus independent source isotropic Eliashberg result.  favorable comparator(s); bounded source model, not experiment.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.001 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure 0.076 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Severalhealthyfrozencontrolshaveall-tokenlambda/Tcbenefits;Zr3Lu hasaopposinglambda/Tcdirection and remainsvisible. Force0/path0/Gammaopt+ with .076GPastress supportonlylocalorderedsourcebasin. KnownmisciblehcpTi-Zralloys areactualcompetingstates; neitherhigh-pressureTc norordinaryalloyTc canbe inheritedbyambientSG221phase.",
        "novelty": "2023primaryTi67.6Zr32.4null-scatteringalloySCand2003equimolarhighpressurebccSC aredifferentcomposition/statefromTi25Zr75orderedSG221sourcecell. Exactphase notfound; computationalproposalalreadyknown.",
        "decision": "Compare savedorderedSG221 role/modebenefit against exactfrozenScZr3/Hfparentandboundhcp/disorderretention. Favorable: locallyretainedorderingbenefit; adverse: onlyhcp/disorderexistsorpairedgainreverses; ambiguous: no comparablephase/formationdata."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase",
        "residual_force_stress"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 261,
          "control": "batch-a/ScZr3_agm003187562",
          "target": "batch-a/TiZr3_agm001190274",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.04190000000000005,
            0.15049999999999997
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            3.562319333446697,
            15.379113018597995
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 15.214,
          "Tc_control_K": 13.368,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 1.846,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9364278075170586,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.3903780165585474e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003187562",
            "dyn0_source_record": 12143,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 12150,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 12151,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 12152,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 12153,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 12154,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 12155,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 12156,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 12157,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 12158,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 12159,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.04190000000000005,
            0.15049999999999997
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 317,
          "control": "batch-a/TiHf3_agm001190273",
          "target": "batch-a/TiZr3_agm001190274",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.028699999999999948,
            0.14400000000000002
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            2.4129813351269505,
            14.617805298954423
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 15.214,
          "Tc_control_K": 13.061,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 2.1530000000000005,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.0253809444417084,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 6.300169023708938e-07,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": 0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001190273",
            "dyn0_source_record": 13183,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 13190,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 13191,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 13192,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 13193,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 13194,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 13195,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 13196,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 13197,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 13198,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 13199,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.028699999999999948,
            0.14400000000000002
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 351,
          "control": "batch-a/TiZr2Hf_agm001229341",
          "target": "batch-a/TiZr3_agm001190274",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.016799999999999926,
            0.06430000000000002
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            1.398484974610832,
            6.038692712246434
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 15.214,
          "Tc_control_K": 14.171,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 1.043000000000001,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": false,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.008482129418039,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 8.399491635131153e-07,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001229341",
            "dyn0_source_record": 9723,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 9730,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 11,
                "source_record": 9731,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 12,
                "source_record": 9732,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 13,
                "source_record": 9733,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 14,
                "source_record": 9734,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 15,
                "source_record": 9735,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 16,
                "source_record": 9736,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 17,
                "source_record": 9737,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 18,
                "source_record": 9738,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 9739,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 9740,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 9741,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 9742,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 9743,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 9744,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 9745,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 9746,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 9747,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.016799999999999926,
            0.06430000000000002
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 354,
          "control": "batch-a/TiZrHf2_agm001229369",
          "target": "batch-a/TiZr3_agm001190274",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.05049999999999999,
            0.11250000000000004
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            4.325111339499828,
            11.066299429470789
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 15.214,
          "Tc_control_K": 13.384,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 1.83,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": false,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.0171031226834704,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 6.075629602563222e-07,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001229369",
            "dyn0_source_record": 11933,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 11940,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 11,
                "source_record": 11941,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 12,
                "source_record": 11942,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 13,
                "source_record": 11943,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 14,
                "source_record": 11944,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 15,
                "source_record": 11945,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 16,
                "source_record": 11946,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 17,
                "source_record": 11947,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 18,
                "source_record": 11948,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 11949,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 11950,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 11951,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 11952,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 11953,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 11954,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 11955,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 11956,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 11957,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.05049999999999999,
            0.11250000000000004
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 355,
          "control": "batch-a/Zr3Hf_agm001190885",
          "target": "batch-a/TiZr3_agm001190274",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.11840000000000006,
            0.14070000000000005
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            11.501291742417003,
            13.149532710280377
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 15.214,
          "Tc_control_K": 12.514,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 2.700000000000001,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.945562103614882,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 8.296086237767607e-07,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001190885",
            "dyn0_source_record": 14891,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 14898,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 14899,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 14900,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 14901,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 14902,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 14903,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 14904,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 14905,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 14906,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 14907,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.11840000000000006,
            0.14070000000000005
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 356,
          "control": "batch-a/Zr3Lu_agm001190945",
          "target": "batch-a/TiZr3_agm001190274",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.32530000000000014,
            -0.046499999999999986
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -21.076843332901394,
            -3.955427015991833
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 15.214,
          "Tc_control_K": 14.606,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 0.6080000000000005,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9021734042898499,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 8.092043008218796e-07,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001190945",
            "dyn0_source_record": 8329,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 8336,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 8337,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 8338,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 8339,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 8340,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 8341,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 8342,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 8343,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 8344,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 8345,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.32530000000000014,
            -0.046499999999999986
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-02-eleven-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1219201,
          "sha256": "ee658cb8e6309178e268b736f8aeb6429c030a92019c068963e2d64ca51cbb17",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-03-fifteen-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1347056,
          "sha256": "1be9342cb74006b2542e9351fc2de310967f1a31a5ee9f1909ae730b9a11476a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-remaining-transition-owned-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 5381838,
          "sha256": "62f4910578c7b65392d26619cf81b31afd6142f38aa49834a70bb147e7ab222d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to the reviewed candidate mechanism catalogue, source prediction already published; not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001186980",
      "formula": "VMn4Mo",
      "reduced_formula": "VMn4Mo",
      "composition": {
        "Mn": 4,
        "Mo": 1,
        "V": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Mn:4|Mo:1|V:1",
      "elements": [
        "Mn",
        "Mo",
        "V"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001186980",
      "control_state": "agm003195946",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/VMn4Mo_agm001186980",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Mn4MoTa_agm003195946",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 216. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "symprec_A": 0.0001,
        "mode": "color_aware",
        "status": "completed",
        "SG_number": 216,
        "hall_number": 512,
        "input_wyckoff_letters": [
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "e",
          "a",
          "d"
        ],
        "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          4,
          5
        ]
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 19.425,
        "control_K": 17.3,
        "delta_K": 2.125,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.14670000000000005,
          0.12760000000000016,
          0.10640000000000005,
          0.08009999999999995,
          0.06159999999999988,
          0.0512999999999999,
          0.0464,
          0.04420000000000002,
          0.04349999999999998,
          0.043300000000000005
        ],
        "range": [
          0.043300000000000005,
          0.14670000000000005
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "V substitution contracts the Mn nearest network by.04066A and gives favorable response vsMo/Ta; versusNb/Mo all-sigma sign is mixed despite small Tc gain. Different carrier filling is nominal, not a mobile-n measurement.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
      "route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
      "next_action": "Spin seeds and band/mode discrimination on V/Ta comparison; do not cherry-pick Nb/Mo sigma.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "CIF lattice/sites to both SCFinputs andGamma atomicheader via speciesbijection/wholetranslation; 1e-6A observationaltolerance, not physicaluncertainty",
        "novelty": "Bounded exact formula/prototype primary search; published source calculations not claimed as first discovery. New-to-reviewed exact ordered hypothesis only. Literature-wide novelty unproved.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Colored-site substitution/ordered network plus computed volume/nearest-distance response andEPCagainst frozen geometriccontrols; chemistry/masses co-change. No W/mobile n claim.",
        "pairing_relevance": "All ten raw printed lambda values andseparate mu*=.1 sourceEliashberg/McMillan products retained; representative common-sigma response isnotrenamed Tc_uncertainty. Spinfluctuations/anisotropy omitted.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse/fine pressure/fullstress/force andpositiveopticalGamma plus finite-path/q evidence; exacttested domain only. No laboratory P/T/hull/globalstability inheritance.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "V substitution contracts the Mn nearest network by.04066A and gives favorable response vsMo/Ta; versusNb/Mo all-sigma sign is mixed despite small Tc gain. Different carrier filling is nominal, not a mobile-n measurement.",
        "decision": "Spin seeds and band/mode discrimination on V/Ta comparison; do not cherry-pick Nb/Mo sigma."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "magnetic_model"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4MoTa_agm003195946",
            "batch-a/VMn4Mo_agm001186980"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4MoTa_agm003195946",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/VMn4Mo_agm001186980",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.14670000000000005,
            0.12760000000000016,
            0.10640000000000005,
            0.08009999999999995,
            0.06159999999999988,
            0.0512999999999999,
            0.0464,
            0.04420000000000002,
            0.04349999999999998,
            0.043300000000000005
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.043300000000000005,
            0.14670000000000005
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              17.3
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              19.425
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 2.125,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 145
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4MoW_agm003195948",
            "batch-a/VMn4Mo_agm001186980"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4MoW_agm003195948",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/VMn4Mo_agm001186980",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.6419,
            0.4508000000000001,
            0.34940000000000004,
            0.2751999999999999,
            0.22649999999999992,
            0.19379999999999997,
            0.17020000000000002,
            0.15190000000000003,
            0.13769999999999993,
            0.12680000000000002
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            0.12680000000000002,
            0.6419
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "B",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              13.698
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              19.425
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 5.727,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": "B",
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 149
        },
        {
          "unordered_pair_key": [
            "batch-a/Mn4NbMo_agm001179868",
            "batch-a/VMn4Mo_agm001186980"
          ],
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/Mn4NbMo_agm001179868",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/VMn4Mo_agm001186980",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "same_sigma_tokens": true,
          "sigma_units": null,
          "lambda_B_minus_A_all_common_tokens": [
            0.016899999999999915,
            -0.0026999999999999247,
            0.0018000000000000238,
            -0.0023999999999999577,
            -0.00770000000000004,
            -0.010599999999999943,
            -0.011299999999999977,
            -0.01090000000000002,
            -0.010199999999999987,
            -0.009600000000000053
          ],
          "lambda_B_minus_A_range": [
            -0.011299999999999977,
            0.016899999999999915
          ],
          "all10_higher_lambda_direction": "mixed_or_unknown",
          "source_Eliashberg_mu0p1_A_B": [
            [
              0.1,
              19.063
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              19.425
            ]
          ],
          "source_Eliashberg_delta_B_minus_A_K": 0.3620000000000019,
          "same_direction_lambda_and_separate_Tc": null,
          "independent_Tc_to_sigma_association": null,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "high_W_or_mobile_n_response": null,
          "zero_based_row": 152
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "coarse": {
          "source_record": 2671,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 17Mar2023 at 19:35:51"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 6,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 2,
              "last": {
                "value": "SCF correction compared to forces is large: reduce conv_thr to get better values"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 1.05e-06,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 1.05e-06,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 1.818653347947321e-06,
            "max_component_eV_A": 2.6996585425071088e-05,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 4.6759457587096555e-05,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                -1.05e-06,
                -1.05e-06,
                1.05e-06
              ],
              "atom_index": 1,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": 0.04,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "0.04",
              "GPa": 0.004
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=        0.04"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    2.6e-07,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.04,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    2.6e-07,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.04,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    2.6e-07,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.04
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  0.004,
                  -0.0,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  0.004,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.004
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": 0.04,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.004,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1163.97578318,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1163.97578318"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": -0.00089792,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-0.00089792"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1163.97488526
        },
        "fine": {
          "source_record": 2672,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 17Mar2023 at 19: 4:56"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 31,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 26,
              "last": {
                "value": "c_bands:  1 eigenvalues not converged"
              }
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000236     Total SCF correction =     0.000001"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 6,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4,
              5,
              6
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 6.803e-05,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 6.803e-05,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.00011783141643891072,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.001749121625207225,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.003029567523476361,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                6.803e-05,
                6.803e-05,
                -6.803e-05
              ],
              "atom_index": 1,
              "type_index": 1
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": -0.16,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "-0.16",
              "GPa": -0.016
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.16"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    -1.06e-06,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.16,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -1.06e-06,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.16,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -1.06e-06,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.16
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  -0.016,
                  0.0,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.016,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.0,
                  -0.016
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": -0.16,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.016,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "last_total_energy_print": {
            "value": -1163.97500017,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-1163.97500017"
          },
          "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
            "value": -0.00113604,
            "unit": "Ry",
            "raw_value": "-0.00113604"
          },
          "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -1163.97386413
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "Gamma_optical_sign": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "Gamma_optical_minimum": 1.7409046924662093e-06,
          "Gamma_printing_bound": 2.3940591436528133e-12,
          "Gamma_native_signed_modes": [
            {
              "number": 1,
              "THz": -0.414352,
              "cm_inverse": -13.82131,
              "line": 168
            },
            {
              "number": 2,
              "THz": -0.414352,
              "cm_inverse": -13.82131,
              "line": 175
            },
            {
              "number": 3,
              "THz": -0.414352,
              "cm_inverse": -13.82131,
              "line": 182
            },
            {
              "number": 4,
              "THz": 4.341086,
              "cm_inverse": 144.803037,
              "line": 189
            },
            {
              "number": 5,
              "THz": 4.341086,
              "cm_inverse": 144.803037,
              "line": 196
            },
            {
              "number": 6,
              "THz": 4.341086,
              "cm_inverse": 144.803037,
              "line": 203
            },
            {
              "number": 7,
              "THz": 4.867333,
              "cm_inverse": 162.356754,
              "line": 210
            },
            {
              "number": 8,
              "THz": 4.867333,
              "cm_inverse": 162.356754,
              "line": 217
            },
            {
              "number": 9,
              "THz": 4.867333,
              "cm_inverse": 162.356754,
              "line": 224
            },
            {
              "number": 10,
              "THz": 5.250638,
              "cm_inverse": 175.142416,
              "line": 231
            },
            {
              "number": 11,
              "THz": 5.250638,
              "cm_inverse": 175.142416,
              "line": 238
            },
            {
              "number": 12,
              "THz": 5.250638,
              "cm_inverse": 175.142416,
              "line": 245
            },
            {
              "number": 13,
              "THz": 6.893068,
              "cm_inverse": 229.927988,
              "line": 252
            },
            {
              "number": 14,
              "THz": 6.893068,
              "cm_inverse": 229.927988,
              "line": 259
            },
            {
              "number": 15,
              "THz": 8.699261,
              "cm_inverse": 290.176098,
              "line": 266
            },
            {
              "number": 16,
              "THz": 8.699261,
              "cm_inverse": 290.176098,
              "line": 273
            },
            {
              "number": 17,
              "THz": 8.699261,
              "cm_inverse": 290.176098,
              "line": 280
            },
            {
              "number": 18,
              "THz": 10.899655,
              "cm_inverse": 363.57337,
              "line": 287
            }
          ],
          "Gamma_ASR_relative": 0.0028298623518490324,
          "Gamma_source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/VMn4Mo_agm001186980",
            "bytes": 18614,
            "sha256": "d5b8e0dd320e09199bc640c3bd96ad62336c57f368113ebbcb2350f7a8f22420"
          }
        },
        "finite_path": {
          "raw_header_lines": [],
          "negative_printed_values": 0,
          "minimum_printed_mode": {
            "value": 0.0,
            "column_index_zero_based": 1
          },
          "frequency_unit_header": null,
          "fullBZ_coverage": null,
          "dynamical_stability": null,
          "state_link_verified": null
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm001186980",
          "dyn0_source_record": 2659,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                3.0,
                3.0,
                3.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                4.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 2666,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 2667,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 2668,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 2669,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 4,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "composition-assessments.json",
          "bytes": 1863044,
          "sha256": "5fc901f5f4a90b41e807722d92f39d81714b70091a189cdb5eba13367624350b",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "numeric-review.json",
          "bytes": 4542684,
          "sha256": "c4fae01d3d67f774429114902a6b39f5b133de48ea81d3d9773ba40ff4419ce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-two-PH-actual-complete-response-products-readback-v1.json",
          "bytes": 77119,
          "sha256": "434c5fe7a590607adbc104dd75d126497457317bc20f37973b5013491e9fdce2",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Published source predictions already known; exact matched mechanism new to reviewed catalogue only, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001190846",
      "formula": "VOs3",
      "reduced_formula": "VOs3",
      "composition": {
        "Os": 3,
        "V": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Os:3|V:1",
      "elements": [
        "Os",
        "V"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001190846",
      "control_state": "agm001281070",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/VOs3_agm001190846",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/VOs3_agm001281070",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 221. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": [
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.0001,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 221,
          "hall_number": 517,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "a",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            1,
            1
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.0001,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 225,
          "hall_number": 523,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "a",
            "a",
            "a",
            "a"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.001,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 221,
          "hall_number": 517,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "a",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            1,
            1
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.001,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 225,
          "hall_number": 523,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "a",
            "a",
            "a",
            "a"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.01,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 221,
          "hall_number": 517,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "a",
            "c",
            "c",
            "c"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            1,
            1
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.01,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 225,
          "hall_number": 523,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "a",
            "a",
            "a",
            "a"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0
          ]
        }
      ],
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 14.474,
        "control_K": 12.869,
        "delta_K": 1.6050000000000004,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.09090000000000009,
          0.10870000000000013,
          0.121,
          0.10890000000000011,
          0.08799999999999997,
          0.06830000000000003,
          0.053300000000000014,
          0.043199999999999905,
          0.03709999999999991,
          0.03359999999999996
        ],
        "range": [
          0.03359999999999996,
          0.121
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": [
        1.0112083500941245,
        1.0110376659758797,
        1.0067324943354277,
        1.0018604995652576,
        0.9978357215533982,
        0.9949704128235072,
        0.9933055609827515,
        0.992690582729267,
        0.9928172169660346,
        0.9933699857421245
      ],
      "risk_summary": "Known V–Os superconductivity and B2/A15 order dependence are relevant references, but they do not identify this Os75V25 L12 phase. This source is configured noncollinear=false and SOC=false; a same-phase SOC effect and V spin response remain untested.",
      "ambient_scope": "Exact model force/full stress, converged electronic outputs, reported finite-q workflow and raw Γ optical evidence provide a bounded near-ambient source-model screen. Source residual stress/metastable alternatives remain explicit; this is not proof of synthesizeability, full BZ or global equilibrium.",
      "route_response": "Os-rich L12 A versus tetragonal B has all-ten λ improvement, all three separate fixed-μ Tc products favor A, and fine F lower for A by 19.26 meV/atom. Complete species-channel geometry differences and computed all-σ pairing response are saved against the frozen controls. Cell/grid/method sensitivity prevents a pure geometry-only causal claim; no bandwidth/carrier quantity is substituted.",
      "next_action": "Compare L12 and the explicit tetragonal control with the same spin/SOC and physical grids. An Os-SOC or competing-order response that reverses the source benefit is adverse; the historical V-rich alloy Tc cannot be assigned to A.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Source-specific full-species CIF→both SCF inputs→Γ coordinate/cell association, actual atom order and origin, within 1e-6 Å observational matching policy. Original experimental occupancy and measured P/T unknown; configured QE neutral/nonmagnetic/no-SOC model is distinct from a magnetic ground-state claim.",
        "novelty": "One exact reduced composition/ordered phase-design group, new to the frozen reviewed cohort. Published computed source is acknowledged, known experimental chemistry remains a comparator. Bounded primary phase search has not tied the exact target order to an established SC sample; no global absence claim.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Os-rich L12 A versus tetragonal B has all-ten λ improvement, all three separate fixed-μ Tc products favor A, and fine F lower for A by 19.26 meV/atom. Complete species-channel geometry differences and computed all-σ pairing response are saved against the frozen controls. Cell/grid/method sensitivity prevents a pure geometry-only causal claim; no bandwidth/carrier quantity is substituted.",
        "pairing_relevance": "All ten source λ/ω rows retained with original units/nulls, and μ*=0.1 source McMillan, Allen–Dynes and Eliashberg products kept separate. Source Gaussian EPC broadening is distinct from explicit MP electronic SCF smearing. No product maximum or selected σ defines the recommendation.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Exact model force/full stress, converged electronic outputs, reported finite-q workflow and raw Γ optical evidence provide a bounded near-ambient source-model screen. Source residual stress/metastable alternatives remain explicit; this is not proof of synthesizeability, full BZ or global equilibrium.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Known V–Os superconductivity and B2/A15 order dependence are relevant references, but they do not identify this Os75V25 L12 phase. This source is configured noncollinear=false and SOC=false; a same-phase SOC effect and V spin response remain untested.",
        "decision": "Compare L12 and the explicit tetragonal control with the same spin/SOC and physical grids. An Os-SOC or competing-order response that reverses the source benefit is adverse; the historical V-rich alloy Tc cannot be assigned to A."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "magnetic_model"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "control_directory": "batch-a/VOs3_agm001281070",
          "lambda_target_minus_control_all10": [
            0.09090000000000009,
            0.10870000000000013,
            0.121,
            0.10890000000000011,
            0.08799999999999997,
            0.06830000000000003,
            0.053300000000000014,
            0.043199999999999905,
            0.03709999999999991,
            0.03359999999999996
          ],
          "omega_log_target_over_control_all10": [
            1.0112083500941245,
            1.0110376659758797,
            1.0067324943354277,
            1.0018604995652576,
            0.9978357215533982,
            0.9949704128235072,
            0.9933055609827515,
            0.992690582729267,
            0.9928172169660346,
            0.9933699857421245
          ],
          "source_Eli_mu01_target_control_K": [
            14.474,
            12.869
          ],
          "separate_Eli_target_minus_control_K": 1.6050000000000004,
          "target_control_q_mesh_match": true,
          "target_control_q_meshes": [
            [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ]
          ],
          "q_comparison_scope": "Different cells can have different configured physical sampling. Actual meshes retained as confounds; source-paired products do not establish convergence or isolated geometry causality.",
          "original_frozen_pair": {
            "original_contrast_index": 45,
            "composition": {
              "Os": 3,
              "V": 1
            },
            "fixed_A": "batch-a/VOs3_agm001190846",
            "fixed_B": "batch-a/VOs3_agm001281070",
            "lambda_B_minus_A_all10": [
              -0.09090000000000009,
              -0.10870000000000013,
              -0.121,
              -0.10890000000000011,
              -0.08799999999999997,
              -0.06830000000000003,
              -0.053300000000000014,
              -0.043199999999999905,
              -0.03709999999999991,
              -0.03359999999999996
            ],
            "lambda_direction": "A",
            "separate_Eli_A_B_K": [
              14.474,
              12.869
            ],
            "separate_Eli_B_minus_A_K": -1.6050000000000004
          },
          "control_source_q_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001281070",
            "dyn0_source_record": 14122,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 14129,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 11,
                "source_record": 14130,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 12,
                "source_record": 14131,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 13,
                "source_record": 14132,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 14133,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 14134,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 14135,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 14136,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 14137,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 14138,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 14139,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 14140,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 14141,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.03359999999999996,
            0.121
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "SCF_stages": {
          "scf_coarse.out.bz2": {
            "source_record": 9201,
            "explicit_program_start_headers": [
              {
                "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 13May2023 at  3:27:25"
              }
            ],
            "last_printed_convergence_event": {
              "value": true,
              "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
            },
            "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
            "routine_error_count": 0,
            "warning_patterns": {
              "pattern_selected_count": 5,
              "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
              "BFGS": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
                }
              },
              "negative_charge": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "eigen_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "failure_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "SCF_correction_text": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Total force =     0.000000     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
                }
              }
            },
            "last_force": {
              "header": {
                "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
              },
              "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "printed_site_rows": 4,
              "ordered_atom_indices": [
                1,
                2,
                3,
                4
              ],
              "reported_max_abs_component": {
                "value": 0.0,
                "unit": "Ry/bohr",
                "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
              },
              "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
              "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
              "max_component_eV_A": 0.0,
              "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.0,
              "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
              "conversion_constants": {
                "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
                "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
              },
              "unit_conversion_valid": true,
              "max_norm_site": {
                "value": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                "atom_index": 1,
                "type_index": 2
              },
              "reported_component_agrees": true
            },
            "last_stress": {
              "last_pressure_print": {
                "value": 0.05,
                "unit": "kbar",
                "raw_value": "0.05",
                "GPa": 0.005
              },
              "last_stress_block": {
                "header": {
                  "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=        0.05"
                },
                "complete_3x6": true,
                "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
                "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
                "rows": [
                  {
                    "value": [
                      3.6e-07,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      0.05,
                      0.0,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      3.6e-07,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      0.05,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      3.6e-07,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      0.05
                    ]
                  }
                ],
                "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                  [
                    0.005,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    0.005,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.005
                  ]
                ],
                "trace_mean_kbar": 0.05000000000000001,
                "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.005,
                "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
              }
            },
            "last_total_energy_print": {
              "value": -754.44865405,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-754.44865405"
            },
            "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
              "value": 0.0001453,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "0.00014530"
            },
            "native_exit_status": null,
            "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
            "PH_all_irreps_complete": null,
            "fullBZ_dynamical_stability": null,
            "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -754.44879935
          },
          "scf_fine.out.bz2": {
            "source_record": 9202,
            "explicit_program_start_headers": [
              {
                "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 13May2023 at  3:23:16"
              }
            ],
            "last_printed_convergence_event": {
              "value": true,
              "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
            },
            "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
            "routine_error_count": 0,
            "warning_patterns": {
              "pattern_selected_count": 5,
              "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
              "BFGS": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
                }
              },
              "negative_charge": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "eigen_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "failure_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "SCF_correction_text": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Total force =     0.000000     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
                }
              }
            },
            "last_force": {
              "header": {
                "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
              },
              "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "printed_site_rows": 4,
              "ordered_atom_indices": [
                1,
                2,
                3,
                4
              ],
              "reported_max_abs_component": {
                "value": 0.0,
                "unit": "Ry/bohr",
                "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
              },
              "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
              "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
              "max_component_eV_A": 0.0,
              "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.0,
              "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
              "conversion_constants": {
                "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
                "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
              },
              "unit_conversion_valid": true,
              "max_norm_site": {
                "value": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                "atom_index": 1,
                "type_index": 2
              },
              "reported_component_agrees": true
            },
            "last_stress": {
              "last_pressure_print": {
                "value": 0.26,
                "unit": "kbar",
                "raw_value": "0.26",
                "GPa": 0.026000000000000002
              },
              "last_stress_block": {
                "header": {
                  "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=        0.26"
                },
                "complete_3x6": true,
                "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
                "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
                "rows": [
                  {
                    "value": [
                      1.77e-06,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      0.26,
                      0.0,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      1.77e-06,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      0.26,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      1.77e-06,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      0.26
                    ]
                  }
                ],
                "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                  [
                    0.026000000000000002,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    0.026000000000000002,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.026000000000000002
                  ]
                ],
                "trace_mean_kbar": 0.26,
                "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.026000000000000002,
                "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
              }
            },
            "last_total_energy_print": {
              "value": -754.4483473,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-754.44834730"
            },
            "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
              "value": -6.586e-05,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-0.00006586"
            },
            "native_exit_status": null,
            "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
            "PH_all_irreps_complete": null,
            "fullBZ_dynamical_stability": null,
            "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -754.4482814400001
          }
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/VOs3_agm001190846",
            "bytes": 8948,
            "sha256": "0c2662f44dcc156183033f123f85eda394167b893bd0fc009b2387fac4e347b2"
          },
          "raw_header": {
            "ntyp": 2,
            "nat": 4,
            "ibrav": 1,
            "celldm": [
              7.1766187,
              0.0,
              0.0,
              0.0,
              0.0,
              0.0
            ],
            "basis_alat": null,
            "species": [
              {
                "index": 1,
                "element": "Os",
                "header_mass": 173384.03836656,
                "header_mass_halfwidth": 5e-10,
                "raw_mass_token": "173384.038366560",
                "line": 4
              },
              {
                "index": 2,
                "element": "V",
                "header_mass": 46430.3369103196,
                "header_mass_halfwidth": 5e-11,
                "raw_mass_token": "46430.3369103196",
                "line": 5
              }
            ],
            "atoms": [
              {
                "index": 1,
                "type": 2,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                "line": 6
              },
              {
                "index": 2,
                "type": 1,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.0,
                  0.5,
                  0.5
                ],
                "line": 7
              },
              {
                "index": 3,
                "type": 1,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.5,
                  0.0,
                  0.5
                ],
                "line": 8
              },
              {
                "index": 4,
                "type": 1,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.5,
                  0.5,
                  0.0
                ],
                "line": 9
              }
            ],
            "q": [
              0.0,
              0.0,
              0.0
            ],
            "matrix_header_line": 11
          },
          "optical_sign": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "minimum": 1.090670927852099e-06,
          "printing_bound": 8.239266237122855e-13,
          "ASR_relative": 0.009891372945277222,
          "native_signed_modes": [
            {
              "number": 1,
              "THz": -0.426558,
              "cm_inverse": -14.228437,
              "line": 85
            },
            {
              "number": 2,
              "THz": -0.426558,
              "cm_inverse": -14.228437,
              "line": 90
            },
            {
              "number": 3,
              "THz": -0.426558,
              "cm_inverse": -14.228437,
              "line": 95
            },
            {
              "number": 4,
              "THz": 3.435753,
              "cm_inverse": 114.604378,
              "line": 100
            },
            {
              "number": 5,
              "THz": 3.435753,
              "cm_inverse": 114.604378,
              "line": 105
            },
            {
              "number": 6,
              "THz": 3.435753,
              "cm_inverse": 114.604378,
              "line": 110
            },
            {
              "number": 7,
              "THz": 4.239209,
              "cm_inverse": 141.404789,
              "line": 115
            },
            {
              "number": 8,
              "THz": 4.239209,
              "cm_inverse": 141.404789,
              "line": 120
            },
            {
              "number": 9,
              "THz": 4.239209,
              "cm_inverse": 141.404789,
              "line": 125
            },
            {
              "number": 10,
              "THz": 5.62038,
              "cm_inverse": 187.475713,
              "line": 130
            },
            {
              "number": 11,
              "THz": 5.62038,
              "cm_inverse": 187.475713,
              "line": 135
            },
            {
              "number": 12,
              "THz": 5.62038,
              "cm_inverse": 187.475713,
              "line": 140
            }
          ],
          "native_negative_outside_lowest3": []
        },
        "finite_path": {
          "source_record": 9184,
          "observations": {
            "kind": "qe_freq_gp_source_path_table",
            "raw_header_lines": [],
            "path_rows": 130,
            "column_width_counts": {
              "13": 130
            },
            "mode_column_values": 1560,
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "column_roles_conditional_on_file_schema": true,
            "fullBZ_coverage": null,
            "dynamical_stability": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          }
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm001190846",
          "dyn0_source_record": 9183,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                4.0,
                4.0,
                4.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                10.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 10,
              "source_record": 9190,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 9191,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 9192,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 9193,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 9194,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 5,
              "source_record": 9195,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 6,
              "source_record": 9196,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 7,
              "source_record": 9197,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 8,
              "source_record": 9198,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 9,
              "source_record": 9199,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 10,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "composition-assessments.json",
          "bytes": 2036037,
          "sha256": "87a3759b8bb3bd9985bd6537220b4ea8fa427be6672204f9010e300e647c284a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "numeric-review.json",
          "bytes": 2556012,
          "sha256": "a0e7a487691b01ab8f0a4ea02eab40af649a455b97dc9ebdfdcabc4cd2453000",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Exact ordered-state mechanism new to reviewed catalogue only; source predictions/known chemistry acknowledged, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001230427",
      "formula": "VRu2Os",
      "reduced_formula": "VRu2Os",
      "composition": {
        "Os": 1,
        "Ru": 2,
        "V": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Os:1|Ru:2|V:1",
      "elements": [
        "Os",
        "Ru",
        "V"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001230427",
      "control_state": "agm001230443",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/VRu2Os_agm001230427",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/VRuOs2_agm001230443",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": "weighted_phonon_log_moment_net_pairing",
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 123. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": [
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.0001,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 123,
          "hall_number": 400,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "b",
            "d",
            "f",
            "f"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            2
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.0001,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 139,
          "hall_number": 424,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "b",
            "b",
            "b",
            "b"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.001,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 123,
          "hall_number": 400,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "b",
            "d",
            "f",
            "f"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            2
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.001,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 139,
          "hall_number": 424,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "b",
            "b",
            "b",
            "b"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.01,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 123,
          "hall_number": 400,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "b",
            "d",
            "f",
            "f"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            2
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.01,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 225,
          "hall_number": 523,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "b",
            "b",
            "b",
            "b"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0
          ]
        }
      ],
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 14.63,
        "control_K": 14.224,
        "delta_K": 0.4060000000000006,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          -0.011399999999999855,
          -0.025800000000000045,
          -0.028299999999999992,
          -0.0230999999999999,
          -0.017299999999999982,
          -0.012800000000000034,
          -0.009699999999999931,
          -0.00770000000000004,
          -0.006000000000000005,
          -0.0045999999999999375
        ],
        "range": [
          -0.028299999999999992,
          -0.0045999999999999375
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": [
        1.051476249411087,
        1.052262593857788,
        1.0529235537290826,
        1.0533509631411602,
        1.0534472030471371,
        1.0532695564336434,
        1.0528476703267513,
        1.0522488195354678,
        1.0515660815330434,
        1.0508706544599777
      ],
      "risk_summary": "The VOs3 neighbor is supported at only two of three geometric tolerances and gives weaker model agreement; preserve it without substituting it for the three-tolerance VRuOs2 admission control. Equal V fraction does not eliminate differential V-spin or Os-SOC sensitivity.",
      "ambient_scope": "The exact source neutral zero-applied-pressure model has positive Γ optical compression intervals and no negative retained sampled path value for target and selected control. Coarse/fine force and full stress, relaxation warnings and every q record are retained. These finite observations do not prove full-BZ or thermodynamic hull stability.",
      "route_response": "The stable SG123 role control VRuOs2→VRu2Os raises weighted ωlog by 5.09–5.34% at all ten tokens even though λ is lower at all ten; its source fixed-μ net response and independent header descriptor are positive.",
      "next_action": "Compare exact source Ru/Os-resolved α²F weights and V-projected states to determine whether altered logarithmic weighting survives the scalar-model magnetic/SOC approximation. A future failed differential-spin test would demote the hypothesis.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact agm001230427 ordered coordinates, species and metric are linked through source CIF→coarse/fine input→Γ header; actual bounded association residuals and original record IDs are retained below. This is not an experimental structure certificate.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "The stable SG123 role control VRuOs2→VRu2Os raises weighted ωlog by 5.09–5.34% at all ten tokens even though λ is lower at all ten; its source fixed-μ net response and independent header descriptor are positive.",
        "pairing_relevance": "Separate source Eli gain 0.406 K is retained with source McMillan/AD. Actual source-header descriptor reproduces the first McMillan column to printed precision. Header-to-ten-σ and Eli-to-σ association remains null, and ωlog is α²F weighted rather than an assertion that all bare modes harden.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "The exact source neutral zero-applied-pressure model has positive Γ optical compression intervals and no negative retained sampled path value for target and selected control. Coarse/fine force and full stress, relaxation warnings and every q record are retained. These finite observations do not prove full-BZ or thermodynamic hull stability.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "The VOs3 neighbor is supported at only two of three geometric tolerances and gives weaker model agreement; preserve it without substituting it for the three-tolerance VRuOs2 admission control. Equal V fraction does not eliminate differential V-spin or Os-SOC sensitivity.",
        "novelty": "The bounded exact-formula search did not return an experimental ordered VRu2Os superconducting phase. Catalogue novelty remains bounded; no first-material claim follows.",
        "decision": "Supported as a private finite-source hypothesis at the printed μ*=.1 under the neutral scalar NC/PBEsol approximation; no calibrated physical probability or public score."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "magnetic_model"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 363,
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/VRu2Os_agm001230427",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/VOs3_agm001190846",
          "other_state": "batch-a/VOs3_agm001190846",
          "three_symprec_supported": false,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.01
          ],
          "source_Eli_gain_target_minus_other_K": 0.15600000000000058,
          "other_printed_path_negative_values": 0,
          "other_q_sampling_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001190846",
            "dyn0_source_record": 9183,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 9190,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 9191,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 9192,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 9193,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 9194,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 9195,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 9196,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 9197,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 9198,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 9199,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.09179999999999999,
            -0.03599999999999992
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 367,
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/VRu2Os_agm001230427",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/VRuOs2_agm001230443",
          "other_state": "batch-a/VRuOs2_agm001230443",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "source_Eli_gain_target_minus_other_K": 0.4060000000000006,
          "other_printed_path_negative_values": 0,
          "other_q_sampling_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001230443",
            "dyn0_source_record": 9997,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 10004,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 11,
                "source_record": 10005,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 12,
                "source_record": 10006,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 13,
                "source_record": 10007,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 14,
                "source_record": 10008,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 15,
                "source_record": 10009,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 16,
                "source_record": 10010,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 17,
                "source_record": 10011,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 18,
                "source_record": 10012,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 10013,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 10014,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 10015,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 10016,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 10017,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 10018,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 10019,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 10020,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 10021,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.028299999999999992,
            -0.0045999999999999375
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "directory_key": "batch-a/VRu2Os_agm001230427",
        "source_ID": "agm001230427",
        "composition": {
          "Os": 1,
          "Ru": 2,
          "V": 1
        },
        "listed_sites": 4,
        "CIF_source_record": 9113,
        "source_McMillan_and_AD_mu0p1": {
          "value": [
            0.1,
            12.398,
            13.001
          ],
          "missing_tokens": [
            false,
            false,
            false
          ],
          "printed_zero": [
            false,
            false,
            false
          ]
        },
        "source_Eli_mu0p1": {
          "value": [
            0.1,
            14.63
          ],
          "missing_tokens": [
            false,
            false
          ],
          "printed_zero": [
            false,
            false
          ]
        },
        "SCF_coarse": {
          "source_record": 9163,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 13May2023 at  3:10:38"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 5,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000000     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 4,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 0.0,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.0,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.0,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              "atom_index": 1,
              "type_index": 3
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": -0.03,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "-0.03",
              "GPa": -0.003
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.03"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    -2.5e-07,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.04,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -2.5e-07,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.04,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -1.6e-07,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.02
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  -0.004,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.004,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  -0.002
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": -0.03333333333333333,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.004,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
          "native_exit_status": null
        },
        "SCF_fine": {
          "source_record": 9164,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 13May2023 at  3: 2: 2"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 5,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000000     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 4,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 0.0,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.0,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.0,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              "atom_index": 1,
              "type_index": 3
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": 0.85,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "0.85",
              "GPa": 0.08499999999999999
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=        0.85"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    7.4e-06,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    1.09,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    7.4e-06,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    1.09,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    2.57e-06,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.38
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  0.10900000000000001,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.10900000000000001,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.038
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": 0.8533333333333334,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.10900000000000001,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
          "native_exit_status": null
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/VRu2Os_agm001230427",
            "bytes": 8994,
            "sha256": "362b7221b1f9a9ec4884bcff696280d60878cd78d3f1e886961df7968b21fd59"
          },
          "raw_optical_minimum": 1.3797705279919895e-06,
          "raw_optical_printing_intervals": [
            [
              1.3797694882039954e-06,
              1.3797715677799837e-06
            ],
            [
              1.3797694882039958e-06,
              1.3797715677799841e-06
            ],
            [
              1.656379194510394e-06,
              1.6563812740863823e-06
            ],
            [
              1.6745960926027872e-06,
              1.6745981721787756e-06
            ],
            [
              2.3387670261847586e-06,
              2.3387691057607466e-06
            ],
            [
              2.3387670261847586e-06,
              2.3387691057607466e-06
            ],
            [
              3.2283209951010202e-06,
              3.228323074677008e-06
            ],
            [
              3.576177350289274e-06,
              3.576179429865262e-06
            ],
            [
              3.5761773502892744e-06,
              3.5761794298652623e-06
            ]
          ],
          "unit": "squared source-Ry frequency convention",
          "native_negative_mode_numbers": [
            1,
            2,
            3
          ],
          "physical_error_bar": null,
          "full_BZ": null
        },
        "retained_path": {
          "kind": "qe_freq_gp_source_path_table",
          "raw_header_lines": [],
          "path_rows": 170,
          "column_width_counts": {
            "13": 170
          },
          "mode_column_values": 2040,
          "negative_printed_values": 0,
          "minimum_printed_mode": {
            "value": -0.0,
            "column_index_zero_based": 1
          },
          "frequency_unit_header": null,
          "column_roles_conditional_on_file_schema": true,
          "fullBZ_coverage": null,
          "dynamical_stability": null,
          "state_link_verified": null
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm001230427",
          "dyn0_source_record": 9137,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                4.0,
                4.0,
                4.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                18.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 10,
              "source_record": 9144,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 11,
              "source_record": 9145,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 12,
              "source_record": 9146,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 13,
              "source_record": 9147,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 14,
              "source_record": 9148,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 15,
              "source_record": 9149,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 16,
              "source_record": 9150,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 17,
              "source_record": 9151,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 18,
              "source_record": 9152,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 9153,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 9154,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 9155,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 9156,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 5,
              "source_record": 9157,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 6,
              "source_record": 9158,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 7,
              "source_record": 9159,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 8,
              "source_record": 9160,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 9,
              "source_record": 9161,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 18,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        },
        "unknowns": {
          "physical_mobile_carrier_density": null,
          "active_orbital_bandwidth": null,
          "public_RPS": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-01-eight-actual-omega-net-pairing-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1213076,
          "sha256": "ae6bc2be8e022ea5308483e2f63d28dfc4565f2cfa13948c036a16368c5f6201",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all62-net-pairing-owned-source-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 4086409,
          "sha256": "bced95fc8c75035eb57c3afbae73d98e099c3e732ef1e07a1836df54a1d60e15",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-owned-62-source-observations-for-Tc-header-readback-v1.json",
          "bytes": 10632536,
          "sha256": "35c5bfdd77eb7194ebebc41802600580a842c5526c8727c40a427c8869890d90",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Published source predictions already known; specific matched mechanism new to reviewed catalogue, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001280579",
      "formula": "VRu3",
      "reduced_formula": "VRu3",
      "composition": {
        "Ru": 3,
        "V": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Ru:3|V:1",
      "elements": [
        "Ru",
        "V"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001280579",
      "control_state": "agm003625152",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/VRu3_agm001280579",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/VRuOs2_agm003625152",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": "weighted_phonon_log_moment_net_pairing",
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 139. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": [
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.0001,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 139,
          "hall_number": 424,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "a",
            "d",
            "d",
            "b"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            1,
            3
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.0001,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 139,
          "hall_number": 424,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "a",
            "a",
            "a",
            "a"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.001,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 139,
          "hall_number": 424,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "a",
            "d",
            "d",
            "b"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            1,
            3
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.001,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 139,
          "hall_number": 424,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "a",
            "a",
            "a",
            "a"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.01,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 139,
          "hall_number": 424,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "a",
            "d",
            "d",
            "b"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            1,
            3
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.01,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 139,
          "hall_number": 424,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "a",
            "a",
            "a",
            "a"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0
          ]
        }
      ],
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 14.976,
        "control_K": 12.932,
        "delta_K": 2.0440000000000005,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          -0.012700000000000045,
          0.0005999999999999339,
          0.01440000000000008,
          0.02510000000000001,
          0.030400000000000094,
          0.03249999999999997,
          0.03309999999999991,
          0.03369999999999995,
          0.034499999999999975,
          0.03550000000000009
        ],
        "range": [
          -0.012700000000000045,
          0.03550000000000009
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": [
        1.088214641564192,
        1.0888173559927232,
        1.0886751514843953,
        1.0881681382369353,
        1.0877119401514337,
        1.0874402629541633,
        1.0873059890190881,
        1.0872111158232811,
        1.087085864580351,
        1.0868920427442235
      ],
      "risk_summary": "Both tetragonal VRuOs2 and VOs3 neighbors have positive retained finite paths and remain in the record. The V fraction is equal, but this does not prove spin-fluctuation cancellation: V orbital character can change with the Ru/Os environment.",
      "ambient_scope": "The exact source neutral zero-applied-pressure model has positive Γ optical compression intervals and no negative retained sampled path value for target and selected control. Coarse/fine force and full stress, relaxation warnings and every q record are retained. These finite observations do not prove full-BZ or thermodynamic hull stability.",
      "route_response": "Frozen tetragonal VRuOs2→VRu3 retains the V quarter-site fraction and raises weighted ωlog by 8.69–8.88% while λ crosses. Role occupancy, Ru/Os electronic potential, mass and volume remain coupled.",
      "next_action": "Inspect saved V-projected near-EF spectral weight and α²F coupling weights for the exact tetragonal controls. Reject a high-potential interpretation if a differential magnetic/spin-fluctuation scale offsets the source pairing benefit; no mobile-carrier or physical-W quantity is inferred.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact agm001280579 ordered coordinates, species and metric are linked through source CIF→coarse/fine input→Γ header; actual bounded association residuals and original record IDs are retained below. This is not an experimental structure certificate.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Frozen tetragonal VRuOs2→VRu3 retains the V quarter-site fraction and raises weighted ωlog by 8.69–8.88% while λ crosses. Role occupancy, Ru/Os electronic potential, mass and volume remain coupled.",
        "pairing_relevance": "Separate source Eli gain 2.044 K is retained with source McMillan/AD. Actual source-header descriptor reproduces the first McMillan column to printed precision. Header-to-ten-σ and Eli-to-σ association remains null, and ωlog is α²F weighted rather than an assertion that all bare modes harden.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "The exact source neutral zero-applied-pressure model has positive Γ optical compression intervals and no negative retained sampled path value for target and selected control. Coarse/fine force and full stress, relaxation warnings and every q record are retained. These finite observations do not prove full-BZ or thermodynamic hull stability.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Both tetragonal VRuOs2 and VOs3 neighbors have positive retained finite paths and remain in the record. The V fraction is equal, but this does not prove spin-fluctuation cancellation: V orbital character can change with the Ru/Os environment.",
        "novelty": "VRu3 chemistry has published computational precedents. The retrieved closest 2023 proposal is cubic, so it does not establish an experimental SG139 superconducting benchmark or certify the present phase.",
        "decision": "Supported as a private finite-source hypothesis at the printed μ*=.1 under the neutral scalar NC/PBEsol approximation; no calibrated physical probability or public score."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "magnetic_model"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 365,
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/VOs3_agm001281070",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/VRu3_agm001280579",
          "other_state": "batch-a/VOs3_agm001281070",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "source_Eli_gain_target_minus_other_K": 2.107000000000001,
          "other_printed_path_negative_values": 0,
          "other_q_sampling_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001281070",
            "dyn0_source_record": 14122,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 14129,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 11,
                "source_record": 14130,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 12,
                "source_record": 14131,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 13,
                "source_record": 14132,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 14133,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 14134,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 14135,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 14136,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 14137,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 14138,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 14139,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 14140,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 14141,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.1099,
            0.040000000000000036
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 368,
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/VRuOs2_agm003625152",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/VRu3_agm001280579",
          "other_state": "batch-a/VRuOs2_agm003625152",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "source_Eli_gain_target_minus_other_K": 2.0440000000000005,
          "other_printed_path_negative_values": 0,
          "other_q_sampling_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003625152",
            "dyn0_source_record": 14002,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 14009,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 11,
                "source_record": 14010,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 12,
                "source_record": 14011,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 13,
                "source_record": 14012,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 14013,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 14014,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 14015,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 14016,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 14017,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 14018,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 14019,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 14020,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 14021,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.012700000000000045,
            0.03550000000000009
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "directory_key": "batch-a/VRu3_agm001280579",
        "source_ID": "agm001280579",
        "composition": {
          "Ru": 3,
          "V": 1
        },
        "listed_sites": 4,
        "CIF_source_record": 8269,
        "source_McMillan_and_AD_mu0p1": {
          "value": [
            0.1,
            12.681,
            13.292
          ],
          "missing_tokens": [
            false,
            false,
            false
          ],
          "printed_zero": [
            false,
            false,
            false
          ]
        },
        "source_Eli_mu0p1": {
          "value": [
            0.1,
            14.976
          ],
          "missing_tokens": [
            false,
            false
          ],
          "printed_zero": [
            false,
            false
          ]
        },
        "SCF_coarse": {
          "source_record": 8309,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 13May2023 at  3:10:39"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 5,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000000     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 4,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 0.0,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.0,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.0,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                -0.0,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              "atom_index": 1,
              "type_index": 2
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": -0.04,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "-0.04",
              "GPa": -0.004
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.04"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    -2.8e-07,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.04,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -2.8e-07,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.04,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -2.8e-07,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.04
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  -0.004,
                  0.0,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.004,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  -0.0,
                  -0.004
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": -0.04,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.004,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
          "native_exit_status": null
        },
        "SCF_fine": {
          "source_record": 8310,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 13May2023 at  2:58:23"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 5,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000000     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 4,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 0.0,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.0,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.0,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              "atom_index": 1,
              "type_index": 2
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": 0.69,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "0.69",
              "GPa": 0.06899999999999999
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=        0.69"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    6.73e-06,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.99,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    6.73e-06,
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    0.99,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    6.2e-07,
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.09
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  0.099,
                  -0.0,
                  -0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  0.099,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  -0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.009
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": 0.69,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.099,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
          "native_exit_status": null
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/VRu3_agm001280579",
            "bytes": 8948,
            "sha256": "bac4da1153781feffb5b057822412d106dc9bf225054abc1d931750d067199a0"
          },
          "raw_optical_minimum": 1.7779398162148867e-06,
          "raw_optical_printing_intervals": [
            [
              1.777938668496207e-06,
              1.7779409639335665e-06
            ],
            [
              1.7779386684962072e-06,
              1.7779409639335667e-06
            ],
            [
              2.224035160446629e-06,
              2.224037455883989e-06
            ],
            [
              2.2547635129376072e-06,
              2.254765808374967e-06
            ],
            [
              3.055475723468399e-06,
              3.055478018905759e-06
            ],
            [
              3.0554757234683994e-06,
              3.0554780189057593e-06
            ],
            [
              3.306825151238336e-06,
              3.306827446675696e-06
            ],
            [
              3.3068251512383395e-06,
              3.3068274466756994e-06
            ],
            [
              3.9333395140815465e-06,
              3.9333418095189056e-06
            ]
          ],
          "unit": "squared source-Ry frequency convention",
          "native_negative_mode_numbers": [
            1,
            2,
            3
          ],
          "physical_error_bar": null,
          "full_BZ": null
        },
        "retained_path": {
          "kind": "qe_freq_gp_source_path_table",
          "raw_header_lines": [],
          "path_rows": 161,
          "column_width_counts": {
            "13": 161
          },
          "mode_column_values": 1932,
          "negative_printed_values": 0,
          "minimum_printed_mode": {
            "value": -0.0,
            "column_index_zero_based": 1
          },
          "frequency_unit_header": null,
          "column_roles_conditional_on_file_schema": true,
          "fullBZ_coverage": null,
          "dynamical_stability": null,
          "state_link_verified": null
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm001280579",
          "dyn0_source_record": 8288,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                4.0,
                4.0,
                4.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                13.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 10,
              "source_record": 8295,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 11,
              "source_record": 8296,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 12,
              "source_record": 8297,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 13,
              "source_record": 8298,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 8299,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 8300,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 8301,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 8302,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 5,
              "source_record": 8303,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 6,
              "source_record": 8304,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 7,
              "source_record": 8305,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 8,
              "source_record": 8306,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 9,
              "source_record": 8307,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 13,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        },
        "unknowns": {
          "physical_mobile_carrier_density": null,
          "active_orbital_bandwidth": null,
          "public_RPS": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-01-eight-actual-omega-net-pairing-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1213076,
          "sha256": "ae6bc2be8e022ea5308483e2f63d28dfc4565f2cfa13948c036a16368c5f6201",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all62-net-pairing-owned-source-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 4086409,
          "sha256": "bced95fc8c75035eb57c3afbae73d98e099c3e732ef1e07a1836df54a1d60e15",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-owned-62-source-observations-for-Tc-header-readback-v1.json",
          "bytes": 10632536,
          "sha256": "35c5bfdd77eb7194ebebc41802600580a842c5526c8727c40a427c8869890d90",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Published source predictions already known; specific matched mechanism new to reviewed catalogue, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm002291027",
      "formula": "YNbN2",
      "reduced_formula": "YNbN2",
      "composition": {
        "N": 2,
        "Nb": 1,
        "Y": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "N:2|Nb:1|Y:1",
      "elements": [
        "N",
        "Nb",
        "Y"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm002291027",
      "control_state": "agm002291033",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/N2YNb_agm002291027",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/N2YTa_agm002291033",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "R-3m four-site layered nitride: distinct Y and Nb single-site layers and a two-site N orbit",
      "prototype_evidence": "R-3m four-site layered nitride: distinct Y and Nb single-site layers and a two-site N orbit",
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 15.006,
        "control_K": 12.416,
        "delta_K": 2.59,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.06399999999999995,
          0.07399999999999995,
          0.06809999999999994,
          0.060799999999999965,
          0.05570000000000008,
          0.05360000000000009,
          0.05370000000000008,
          0.055499999999999994,
          0.05819999999999992,
          0.06099999999999994
        ],
        "range": [
          0.05360000000000009,
          0.07399999999999995
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "A concrete competing structure exists: Pilemalm et al. predict a distorted YNbN2 relative to the binaries, while their YTaN2 is unfavorable. Those different relaxed metrics/DFT methods are not the exact R-3m source state and are not imported as its hull energy. The source state is locally stable at Gamma and sampled path, so the prior supplies a falsifiable distortion/decomposition risk rather than automatic rejection. Nitrogen defects/order and suppressed magnetism remain possible; a reported ScMN2 semiconductor result is not assumed to be the exact YNbN2 metallic EPC phase.",
      "ambient_scope": "Both source SCFs converge, near-zero coarse forces/stress and bounded fine response are measured. Fine Fmax=0.023729741 eV/A, P=-0.003 GPa, full max stress=0.103 GPa. Gamma optical compression is positive beyond printing bound and sampled path has no signed negative values. All listed q outputs have JOBDONE/last response convergence and no routine errors. This supports a finite-grid local/metastable source model, not global hull or experimental synthesis.",
      "route_response": "Nb replaces Ta on the unique transition-metal layer, retaining the Y and two N roles. The actual volume rises 0.6563% and nearest Y-N, Nb-N and N-N responses are retained. The favorable lambda sign persists across all ten sigma values, with a favorable separate Eli mu=.1 comparison retained below. This is a coupled layer-chemistry/construction response, not a valence-to-mobile-n inference.",
      "next_action": "Compare the actual R-3m source to the published distorted YNbN2 ordering with identical composition/functional and test the lowest distortion channel; preserve the Nb/Ta matched pairing contrast. A stable local R-3m basin with persistent coupling gain supports screening; a barrierless symmetry-breaking distortion or vanished metallic pairing response opposes it.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Complete ordered CIF/literal coarse-fine input/Gamma periodic species-site association is numerically supported; source input geometry and full tensor/forces are retained. Export occupancy is a discrete computational convention; source experimental P/T/occupancy and actual compiled unit constant are unknown. Exact-version input defaults scope the configured neutral scalar spin1/noSOC model, not magnetic ground state.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Nb replaces Ta on the unique transition-metal layer, retaining the Y and two N roles. The actual volume rises 0.6563% and nearest Y-N, Nb-N and N-N responses are retained. The favorable lambda sign persists across all ten sigma values, with a favorable separate Eli mu=.1 comparison retained below. This is a coupled layer-chemistry/construction response, not a valence-to-mobile-n inference.",
        "pairing_relevance": "Exact target and mapped control direct source lambda arrays have the same favorable sign at all ten common broadening tokens; omega_ln has explicit K units and separate Eli/McM mu=.1 tables remain independent. Same underlying q mesh is observed. The sensitivity range is not a physical error bound; sigma units, full-BZ convergence, experimental Tc and pure-geometry causality remain unknown. Literal method differences are declared confounds.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Both source SCFs converge, near-zero coarse forces/stress and bounded fine response are measured. Fine Fmax=0.023729741 eV/A, P=-0.003 GPa, full max stress=0.103 GPa. Gamma optical compression is positive beyond printing bound and sampled path has no signed negative values. All listed q outputs have JOBDONE/last response convergence and no routine errors. This supports a finite-grid local/metastable source model, not global hull or experimental synthesis.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "A concrete competing structure exists: Pilemalm et al. predict a distorted YNbN2 relative to the binaries, while their YTaN2 is unfavorable. Those different relaxed metrics/DFT methods are not the exact R-3m source state and are not imported as its hull energy. The source state is locally stable at Gamma and sampled path, so the prior supplies a falsifiable distortion/decomposition risk rather than automatic rejection. Nitrogen defects/order and suppressed magnetism remain possible; a reported ScMN2 semiconductor result is not assumed to be the exact YNbN2 metallic EPC phase.",
        "novelty": "2019 primary work explicitly treats hypothetical distorted YNbN2, so the composition is not newly predicted here. The dated YNbN2/YTaN2 search found no exact experimental superconducting R-3m YNbN2 benchmark. The proposed novel object is the matched Nb-for-Ta source-state hypothesis at stated scalar finite-grid approximation.",
        "decision": "Compare the actual R-3m source to the published distorted YNbN2 ordering with identical composition/functional and test the lowest distortion channel; preserve the Nb/Ta matched pairing contrast. A stable local R-3m basin with persistent coupling gain supports screening; a barrierless symmetry-breaking distortion or vanished metallic pairing response opposes it."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index_zero_based": 195,
          "control_directory": "batch-a/N2YTa_agm002291033",
          "mapping_scope": "bounded ordered isostructural analogue",
          "all_three_symprec_support": true,
          "composition_edit": {
            "from": "Nb",
            "to": "Ta",
            "count": 1,
            "kind": "single_site_substitution"
          },
          "volume_target_over_control": 1.006562579338821,
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_all10": [
            7.736943907156666,
            9.246532550293635,
            8.501872659176021,
            7.565953210552509,
            6.939080602965003,
            6.710065097646481,
            6.764928193499633,
            7.0377884859244215,
            7.424416379640249,
            7.822518594511406
          ],
          "target_relative_lambda_gain_percent_range": [
            6.710065097646481,
            9.246532550293635
          ],
          "separate_source_Eli_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              15.006
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              12.416
            ]
          ],
          "separate_source_McM_mu01_target_control": [
            [
              0.1,
              13.687,
              14.494
            ],
            [
              0.1,
              11.546,
              12.172
            ]
          ],
          "literal_method_same_fields": {
            "ecutwfc": false,
            "smear": true,
            "degauss": true,
            "pseudo_dir": true
          },
          "qmesh_target_control": [
            [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ]
          ],
          "irreducible_qcount_target_control": [
            [
              13.0
            ],
            [
              13.0
            ]
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "nat": 4,
        "lambda10": [
          0.8912,
          0.8743,
          0.8691,
          0.8644,
          0.8584,
          0.8524,
          0.8475,
          0.8441,
          0.8421,
          0.8408
        ],
        "omega10_K": [
          256.9674,
          255.1321,
          254.7658,
          255.3502,
          256.5798,
          258.0656,
          259.5506,
          260.8999,
          262.0613,
          263.0301
        ],
        "Eli_mu01": [
          0.1,
          15.006
        ],
        "McM_mu01": [
          0.1,
          13.687,
          14.494
        ],
        "coarse_fine": [
          {
            "record": 6301,
            "version": [
              "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 13May2023 at 13: 9: 2"
            ],
            "converged": true,
            "JOBDONE": true,
            "errors": 0,
            "Fmax_eVA": 1.8769054628858948e-05,
            "P_GPa": 0.0,
            "maxstress_GPa": 0.0,
            "fulltensor": [
              [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                -0.0,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                -0.0,
                0.0,
                -0.0
              ]
            ],
            "F_Ry": -247.86945487,
            "E_Ry": -247.86978448,
            "pattern_selected_warning_counts": {
              "BFGS": 1,
              "negative_charge": 0,
              "eigen_text": 0,
              "failure_text": 0,
              "SCF_correction_text": 2
            },
            "warning_scope": "pattern-selected contexts; informational SCF correction and ignored cell card are not optimization failure; no whole-file warning-free claim"
          },
          {
            "record": 6302,
            "version": [
              "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 13May2023 at 12:55:21"
            ],
            "converged": true,
            "JOBDONE": true,
            "errors": 0,
            "Fmax_eVA": 0.023729741478300106,
            "P_GPa": -0.003,
            "maxstress_GPa": 0.10300000000000001,
            "fulltensor": [
              [
                -0.05500000000000001,
                0.0,
                0.0
              ],
              [
                -0.0,
                -0.05500000000000001,
                -0.0
              ],
              [
                0.0,
                -0.0,
                0.10300000000000001
              ]
            ],
            "F_Ry": -247.8694795,
            "E_Ry": -247.86943276000002,
            "pattern_selected_warning_counts": {
              "BFGS": 1,
              "negative_charge": 0,
              "eigen_text": 8,
              "failure_text": 0,
              "SCF_correction_text": 1
            },
            "warning_scope": "pattern-selected contexts; informational SCF correction and ignored cell card are not optimization failure; no whole-file warning-free claim"
          }
        ],
        "inputs": [
          {
            "record": 6282,
            "ecutwfc": [
              98.0
            ],
            "ecutrho": null,
            "pseudo_dir": [
              "/dss/dsshome1/07/di29xud3/software/progs/qe/pp/nc-sr-04_pbesol_stringent_upf/"
            ],
            "spin": null,
            "noncol": null,
            "SOC": null,
            "charge": null,
            "smear": [
              "mp"
            ],
            "degauss": [
              0.014699728870262
            ],
            "ibrav": [
              5.0
            ],
            "nat": [
              4.0
            ],
            "grid": [
              "8 8 8 0 0 0"
            ]
          },
          {
            "record": 6283,
            "ecutwfc": [
              98.0
            ],
            "ecutrho": null,
            "pseudo_dir": [
              "/dss/dsshome1/07/di29xud3/software/progs/qe/pp/nc-sr-04_pbesol_stringent_upf/"
            ],
            "spin": null,
            "noncol": null,
            "SOC": null,
            "charge": null,
            "smear": [
              "mp"
            ],
            "degauss": [
              0.014699728870262
            ],
            "ibrav": [
              5.0
            ],
            "nat": [
              4.0
            ],
            "grid": [
              "32 32 32 0 0 0"
            ]
          }
        ],
        "Gamma": {
          "nat": 4,
          "ibrav": 5,
          "q": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species": [
            "N",
            "Nb",
            "Y"
          ],
          "optical": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "minopt": 1.839812456649877e-06,
          "printingbound": 3.835604600336974e-12,
          "negative_native_modes": [
            1
          ],
          "negativeoutside3": [],
          "min_low3_translation": 0.9999995588773655,
          "sourcepin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/N2YNb_agm002291027",
            "bytes": 8994,
            "sha256": "8e2726d63be46c77c0434b998acb7a9dd3bcd95fbb2714469089670d5e1395a9"
          }
        },
        "path": {
          "rows": 154,
          "negatives": 0,
          "minimum": -0.0,
          "unit": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-2-compact-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 84096,
          "sha256": "d8ca53bafc5ee0879de647e050127d8e0d20c0e3da10de9602ab2de44bf77532",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-3-five-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 110335,
          "sha256": "861dd76c8368cca687ca20c8468e464badefb533a318ed41c4f8d62dccb6ed50",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-4-three-phase-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 64369,
          "sha256": "56076a077e591b9bdef8ada45d78f224f417a4af8d2e722e332f639eedfafaf7",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all64-light-Nb-rich-owned-review-cache-v2.json",
          "bytes": 4566542,
          "sha256": "f27e8c84c10c4d8de44022f6bd160e7e8aee8b2d562db5fd6003af68d5e35756",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to this reviewed candidate catalogue and mechanism contrast; MC2023 prediction is prior, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003559755",
      "formula": "YZr3N4",
      "reduced_formula": "YZr3N4",
      "composition": {
        "N": 4,
        "Y": 1,
        "Zr": 3
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "N:4|Y:1|Zr:3",
      "elements": [
        "N",
        "Y",
        "Zr"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003559755",
      "control_state": "agm003557884",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/N4YZr3_agm003559755",
      "control_directory": null,
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "SG221 ordered NaCl-derived8-site sixfold minority-cation substitution, source ideal occupancy",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "motif": "SG221 ordered NaCl-derived8-site sixfold minority-cation substitution, source ideal occupancy",
        "new_topology_claim": false,
        "geometry_only_causal_mediation_tested": false
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 21.437,
        "control_K": 16.568,
        "delta_K": 4.869,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.8982999999999999,
          0.6923,
          0.6156,
          0.5653,
          0.5301000000000001,
          0.5028999999999999,
          0.47950000000000015,
          0.4584999999999999,
          0.4393,
          0.42189999999999994
        ],
        "range": [
          0.42189999999999994,
          0.8982999999999999
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Explicitly assessed softening, competing nitrides/disorder, code-model spin/SOC assumptions, mixed mass/potential/volume causes and coarse/fine residual-stress sensitivity. No observed critical sign contradiction reverses this bounded source coupled-intervention inference. Whole-BZ stability, disorder coherence, magnetic ground state and fixed-chemistry causal mediation remain unknown; the smaller/partially capacity-limited electronic envelopes are not claimed as W gains.",
      "ambient_scope": "Bounded near-ambient source feasibility: coarse pressure0 GPa, fine residual isotropic stress-0.178 GPa and printed-zero forces, finite q3^3/4irreducible response;21 Gamma optical-compression eigenvalues positive beyond printing bound and path no signed-negative values. Earlier PBE/PAW phase hull35 meV/atom is a metastability prior, not current NC exact hull or synthesis evidence.",
      "route_response": "Supported for the coupled minority-cation construction Sc->Y on a fixed sixfold network: lattice +1.92551688%, volume +5.888493%, first-shell M-N +0.04363518 A, together with favorable direct EPC. Atomic potential/mass and expansion are a coupled intervention; no isolated geometry-volume cause, topology change, high-W or mobile-n benefit is claimed.",
      "next_action": "Candidate grade3 is justified only for the declared source-model coupled atomic-construction/pairing domain. A fixed-chemistry cross-volume response and named finite-q stationarity check are the next falsifiers; independent numerical/causal strengthening needed for grade4. Formal research-action RPS/publication remains separate.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact ideal ordered8-site source input is pinned; actual cubic-coordinate arithmetic links SCF coarse/fine, species, source Gamma tau and periodic CIF sites. Exact input/run QE7.0 model defaults are resolved from official tag source. Physical sample spin/occupancy/T remains unknown.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Supported for the coupled minority-cation construction Sc->Y on a fixed sixfold network: lattice +1.92551688%, volume +5.888493%, first-shell M-N +0.04363518 A, together with favorable direct EPC. Atomic potential/mass and expansion are a coupled intervention; no isolated geometry-volume cause, topology change, high-W or mobile-n benefit is claimed.",
        "pairing_relevance": "All10 matched printed source-width EPC responses favor Y with lambda +57.052–81.045%; phonon frequency softening is preserved. Independent source Eliashberg mu*=0.1 estimates21.437 versus16.568 K support the source-model pairing contrast; neither a new child calculation nor experiment. Sigma table and Eliashberg estimator are not silently merged.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Bounded near-ambient source feasibility: coarse pressure0 GPa, fine residual isotropic stress-0.178 GPa and printed-zero forces, finite q3^3/4irreducible response;21 Gamma optical-compression eigenvalues positive beyond printing bound and path no signed-negative values. Earlier PBE/PAW phase hull35 meV/atom is a metastability prior, not current NC exact hull or synthesis evidence.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Explicitly assessed softening, competing nitrides/disorder, code-model spin/SOC assumptions, mixed mass/potential/volume causes and coarse/fine residual-stress sensitivity. No observed critical sign contradiction reverses this bounded source coupled-intervention inference. Whole-BZ stability, disorder coherence, magnetic ground state and fixed-chemistry causal mediation remain unknown; the smaller/partially capacity-limited electronic envelopes are not claimed as W gains.",
        "novelty": "Exact composition/phase hypothesis not among current5 reviewed groups. The2023 published prediction of SG221 YZr3N4 is explicitly retained; bounded primary search does not establish an experimental superconducting benchmark for this state. Count only one new-to-reviewed-catalogue Y composition hypothesis, not parentSc/reference, first discovery, a new composition in literature or a trivial cell alias.",
        "decision": "Candidate grade3 is justified only for the declared source-model coupled atomic-construction/pairing domain. A fixed-chemistry cross-volume response and named finite-q stationarity check are the next falsifiers; independent numerical/causal strengthening needed for grade4. Formal research-action RPS/publication remains separate."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase",
        "residual_force_stress"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "receipt.json",
          "bytes": 12148,
          "sha256": "b6cc81917e12c2e2f9f342440407440bb801f7dbb19c65d2d57250aef6539abe",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "observables.json",
          "bytes": 76234,
          "sha256": "38280444b9ba0d3a8d5283cc6560264c71642663321196651b242541b155f72d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "primary-prior.json",
          "bytes": 1715,
          "sha256": "7e61ae596cfdb53bb4f74190819c3afb501f63f3305122caa0230616d3b65c78",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ScY-Zr3N4-root-owned-cubic-coordinate-association-v1.json",
          "bytes": 8468,
          "sha256": "830d43a5412a960da288df72d61021b5b306662d0541ec4927b544a24e645030",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ScY-Zr3N4-root-exact-QE70-model-default-binding-v1.json",
          "bytes": 3973,
          "sha256": "ff0352383b1e5a2018fd594b7573e36cd259d34ab25b04f057b3abb332fa6e51",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-named22-actual-energy-collection-analysis-v1.json",
          "bytes": 1070121,
          "sha256": "0a86b1b7dd6f7253c45cc1e03d9aa95f327f7ca97870c8834d0aa922087772e4",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "criteria.json",
          "bytes": 16426,
          "sha256": "e1df615f98f5ed472465daf157d70f7935e7279c33ef767396d144d3b53d2a93",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "new-to-reviewed-catalogue source-derived coupled cation/geometry hypothesis;2023 prior prediction retained, no first discovery claim",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003199974",
      "formula": "YZrRe4",
      "reduced_formula": "YZrRe4",
      "composition": {
        "Re": 4,
        "Y": 1,
        "Zr": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Re:4|Y:1|Zr:1",
      "elements": [
        "Re",
        "Y",
        "Zr"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003199974",
      "control_state": "agm001177738",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/YZrRe4_agm003199974",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/ZrLuRe4_agm001177738",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "CIF_source_record": 14613,
        "CIF_payload_pin": {
          "bytes": 591661,
          "sha256": "93c3ce21c362fc36392db6d13f4555d76cce96122769d1212414bbc770f81541"
        },
        "SCF_coarse_source_record": 14625,
        "Gamma_source_pin": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/YZrRe4_agm003199974",
          "bytes": 18614,
          "sha256": "6eebebc138716e6bf53e2d342e8f12e4383a12dd36e584320c64b67e564514ee"
        },
        "source_input_volume_difference_relative": 3.793587666223175e-11,
        "occupancy_model_all1": true,
        "bounded_signed_axis_and_translation_mapping": {
          "signed_axis_U_CIF_fractional_to_SCF": [
            [
              1,
              0,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              1,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              0,
              1
            ]
          ],
          "determinant": 1,
          "origin_shift_fractional": [
            -0.25,
            -0.25,
            -0.24999998999999995
          ],
          "species_bijection_CIF_to_SCF": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            3,
            4,
            5
          ],
          "maximum_site_distance_A": 9.197487471757374e-08,
          "relative_Gram_residual": 3.7851695993430635e-10,
          "proper_signed_axis_solution": true
        },
        "attempts": 1,
        "general_GL3_or_chiral_equivalence_asserted": false,
        "CIF_site_precision_A_tolerance": 1e-05,
        "physical_model": "source finite neutral scalar EPC; no SOC transfer certificate"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 12.616,
        "control_K": 11.953,
        "delta_K": 0.6630000000000003,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.19940000000000002,
          0.15139999999999998,
          0.1279999999999999,
          0.11440000000000006,
          0.10549999999999993,
          0.09899999999999998,
          0.09400000000000008,
          0.08999999999999997,
          0.08699999999999997,
          0.08450000000000002
        ],
        "range": [
          0.08450000000000002,
          0.19940000000000002
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "ZrLuRe4→YZrRe4 has coherent +.0845…+.1994 lambda and Tc+.663 K; Hf ternary lambda crosses and binaryZrRe2 is better. Path0/Gammaopt+, fine force .00371 and stress .001 GPa support local source scope. Re-heavy scalar/SOC and C14/C15/disorder phase alternatives remain bounded risks.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse force 1.8258454867342465e-05 eV/Å, pressure 0.003 GPa; fine force 0.0037131462605829637 eV/Å, pressure 0.001 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
      "route_response": "Lu-to-Y mixed-site ordering in YZrRe4. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
      "next_action": "Resolve Y/Lu mixed-site EPC and exact source branch versus binary/phase alternatives. Favorable: local role gain persists; adverse: relevant SOC or phase conversion erases it; ambiguous: no comparable role/phase information.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact source CIF/SCF/Γ state association; CIF source record 14613. Experimental occupancy/P/T and physical magnetic ground state remain unknown; source scalar model only.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Lu-to-Y mixed-site ordering in YZrRe4. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
        "pairing_relevance": "direct published source EPC plus independent source isotropic Eliashberg result.  favorable comparator(s); bounded source model, not experiment.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse force 1.8258454867342465e-05 eV/Å, pressure 0.003 GPa; fine force 0.0037131462605829637 eV/Å, pressure 0.001 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "ZrLuRe4→YZrRe4 has coherent +.0845…+.1994 lambda and Tc+.663 K; Hf ternary lambda crosses and binaryZrRe2 is better. Path0/Gammaopt+, fine force .00371 and stress .001 GPa support local source scope. Re-heavy scalar/SOC and C14/C15/disorder phase alternatives remain bounded risks.",
        "novelty": "Exact YZrRe4 phase not retrieved. ExperimentalC14ZrRe2 and Re7X3 are different composition/phase and do not establish this ordered SG216 ternary.",
        "decision": "Resolve Y/Lu mixed-site EPC and exact source branch versus binary/phase alternatives. Favorable: local role gain persists; adverse: relevant SOC or phase conversion erases it; ambiguous: no comparable role/phase information."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase",
        "residual_force_stress"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 370,
          "control": "batch-a/ZrHfRe4_agm001177717",
          "target": "batch-a/YZrRe4_agm003199974",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.15429999999999988,
            0.035600000000000076
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -11.51285227624652,
            2.3417971319563264
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 12.616,
          "Tc_control_K": 15.587,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": -2.971,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.0402615891709976,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.0906309020278317e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001177717",
            "dyn0_source_record": 6665,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 6672,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 6673,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 6674,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 6675,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.15429999999999988,
            0.035600000000000076
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 371,
          "control": "batch-a/ZrLuRe4_agm001177738",
          "target": "batch-a/YZrRe4_agm003199974",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.08450000000000002,
            0.19940000000000002
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            10.027736291871143,
            14.700678265998231
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 12.616,
          "Tc_control_K": 11.953,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 0.6630000000000003,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.0176399922851613,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.3105080034423595e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001177738",
            "dyn0_source_record": 17173,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 17180,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 17181,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 17182,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 17183,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.08450000000000002,
            0.19940000000000002
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 372,
          "control": "batch-a/ZrRe2_agm003200022",
          "target": "batch-a/YZrRe4_agm003199974",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.23009999999999997,
            -0.11120000000000008
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -15.46449229911492,
            -7.304575786463288
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 12.616,
          "Tc_control_K": 16.476,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": -3.8599999999999994,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": true,
          "three_tol_graph": false,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.0332890217732973,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.0535056350827616e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003200022",
            "dyn0_source_record": 5453,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 5460,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 5461,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 5462,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 5463,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.23009999999999997,
            -0.11120000000000008
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-02-eleven-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1219201,
          "sha256": "ee658cb8e6309178e268b736f8aeb6429c030a92019c068963e2d64ca51cbb17",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-03-fifteen-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1347056,
          "sha256": "1be9342cb74006b2542e9351fc2de310967f1a31a5ee9f1909ae730b9a11476a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-remaining-transition-owned-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 5381838,
          "sha256": "62f4910578c7b65392d26619cf81b31afd6142f38aa49834a70bb147e7ab222d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to the reviewed candidate mechanism catalogue, source prediction already published; not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001281126",
      "formula": "Zr3Hf",
      "reduced_formula": "Zr3Hf",
      "composition": {
        "Hf": 1,
        "Zr": 3
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Hf:1|Zr:3",
      "elements": [
        "Hf",
        "Zr"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001281126",
      "control_state": "agm001190885",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Zr3Hf_agm001281126",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Zr3Hf_agm001190885",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 139. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": [
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.0001,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 139,
          "hall_number": 424,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "a",
            "d",
            "d",
            "b"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            1,
            3
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.0001,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 139,
          "hall_number": 424,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "a",
            "a",
            "a",
            "a"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.001,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 139,
          "hall_number": 424,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "a",
            "d",
            "d",
            "b"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            1,
            3
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.001,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 139,
          "hall_number": 424,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "a",
            "a",
            "a",
            "a"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.01,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 139,
          "hall_number": 424,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "a",
            "d",
            "d",
            "b"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            1,
            3
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.01,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 139,
          "hall_number": 424,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "a",
            "a",
            "a",
            "a"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            0,
            0,
            0
          ]
        }
      ],
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 13.067,
        "control_K": 12.514,
        "delta_K": 0.5530000000000008,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.08100000000000018,
          0.0754999999999999,
          0.07210000000000005,
          0.07000000000000006,
          0.0685,
          0.06689999999999996,
          0.06550000000000011,
          0.0645,
          0.06400000000000006,
          0.06420000000000003
        ],
        "range": [
          0.06400000000000006,
          0.08100000000000018
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": [
        0.9695514505456935,
        0.9684830463628608,
        0.9657821067987477,
        0.9635584515493294,
        0.9623492533163729,
        0.9616998394759434,
        0.9611785227905044,
        0.9605734559744153,
        0.959818631551881,
        0.9589261563724347
      ],
      "risk_summary": "The electronic fine F contrast is only 0.145 meV/atom and changes sign from coarse to fine sampling. This is not a phase-order or formation-energy result. Known hexagonal Zr–Hf alloy thermodynamics is a reference, not proof these ordered states are known superconductors.",
      "ambient_scope": "Exact model force/full stress, converged electronic outputs, reported finite-q workflow and raw Γ optical evidence provide a bounded near-ambient source-model screen. Source residual stress/metastable alternatives remain explicit; this is not proof of synthesizeability, full BZ or global equilibrium.",
      "route_response": "Ordered tetragonal A versus L12-like B has all-ten λ gain and separate Eliashberg +0.553 K, despite a small geometrical difference. Like-species nearest-distance contrasts remain nonzero in the saved network. Complete species-channel geometry differences and computed all-σ pairing response are saved against the frozen controls. Cell/grid/method sensitivity prevents a pure geometry-only causal claim; no bandwidth/carrier quantity is substituted.",
      "next_action": "Keep one Zr3Hf composition group and converge the observed near-cubic strain/order response on matched physical grids. If the gain disappears at that refinement, lower the mechanism support; do not count strain variants as new materials.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Source-specific full-species CIF→both SCF inputs→Γ coordinate/cell association, actual atom order and origin, within 1e-6 Å observational matching policy. Original experimental occupancy and measured P/T unknown; configured QE neutral/nonmagnetic/no-SOC model is distinct from a magnetic ground-state claim.",
        "novelty": "One exact reduced composition/ordered phase-design group, new to the frozen reviewed cohort. Published computed source is acknowledged, known experimental chemistry remains a comparator. Bounded primary phase search has not tied the exact target order to an established SC sample; no global absence claim.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Ordered tetragonal A versus L12-like B has all-ten λ gain and separate Eliashberg +0.553 K, despite a small geometrical difference. Like-species nearest-distance contrasts remain nonzero in the saved network. Complete species-channel geometry differences and computed all-σ pairing response are saved against the frozen controls. Cell/grid/method sensitivity prevents a pure geometry-only causal claim; no bandwidth/carrier quantity is substituted.",
        "pairing_relevance": "All ten source λ/ω rows retained with original units/nulls, and μ*=0.1 source McMillan, Allen–Dynes and Eliashberg products kept separate. Source Gaussian EPC broadening is distinct from explicit MP electronic SCF smearing. No product maximum or selected σ defines the recommendation.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Exact model force/full stress, converged electronic outputs, reported finite-q workflow and raw Γ optical evidence provide a bounded near-ambient source-model screen. Source residual stress/metastable alternatives remain explicit; this is not proof of synthesizeability, full BZ or global equilibrium.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "The electronic fine F contrast is only 0.145 meV/atom and changes sign from coarse to fine sampling. This is not a phase-order or formation-energy result. Known hexagonal Zr–Hf alloy thermodynamics is a reference, not proof these ordered states are known superconductors.",
        "decision": "Keep one Zr3Hf composition group and converge the observed near-cubic strain/order response on matched physical grids. If the gain disappears at that refinement, lower the mechanism support; do not count strain variants as new materials."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "sampling_method"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "control_directory": "batch-a/Zr3Hf_agm001190885",
          "lambda_target_minus_control_all10": [
            0.08100000000000018,
            0.0754999999999999,
            0.07210000000000005,
            0.07000000000000006,
            0.0685,
            0.06689999999999996,
            0.06550000000000011,
            0.0645,
            0.06400000000000006,
            0.06420000000000003
          ],
          "omega_log_target_over_control_all10": [
            0.9695514505456935,
            0.9684830463628608,
            0.9657821067987477,
            0.9635584515493294,
            0.9623492533163729,
            0.9616998394759434,
            0.9611785227905044,
            0.9605734559744153,
            0.959818631551881,
            0.9589261563724347
          ],
          "source_Eli_mu01_target_control_K": [
            13.067,
            12.514
          ],
          "separate_Eli_target_minus_control_K": 0.5530000000000008,
          "target_control_q_mesh_match": true,
          "target_control_q_meshes": [
            [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ]
          ],
          "q_comparison_scope": "Different cells can have different configured physical sampling. Actual meshes retained as confounds; source-paired products do not establish convergence or isolated geometry causality.",
          "original_frozen_pair": {
            "original_contrast_index": 12,
            "composition": {
              "Hf": 1,
              "Zr": 3
            },
            "fixed_A": "batch-a/Zr3Hf_agm001281126",
            "fixed_B": "batch-a/Zr3Hf_agm001190885",
            "lambda_B_minus_A_all10": [
              -0.08100000000000018,
              -0.0754999999999999,
              -0.07210000000000005,
              -0.07000000000000006,
              -0.0685,
              -0.06689999999999996,
              -0.06550000000000011,
              -0.0645,
              -0.06400000000000006,
              -0.06420000000000003
            ],
            "lambda_direction": "A",
            "separate_Eli_A_B_K": [
              13.067,
              12.514
            ],
            "separate_Eli_B_minus_A_K": -0.5530000000000008
          },
          "control_source_q_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001190885",
            "dyn0_source_record": 14891,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              4.0,
              4.0,
              4.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 14898,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 14899,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 14900,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 14901,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 14902,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 14903,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 14904,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 14905,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 14906,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 14907,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.06400000000000006,
            0.08100000000000018
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "SCF_stages": {
          "scf_coarse.out.bz2": {
            "source_record": 12801,
            "explicit_program_start_headers": [
              {
                "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 13May2023 at  0:12:20"
              }
            ],
            "last_printed_convergence_event": {
              "value": true,
              "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
            },
            "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
            "routine_error_count": 0,
            "warning_patterns": {
              "pattern_selected_count": 6,
              "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
              "BFGS": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
                }
              },
              "negative_charge": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "eigen_text": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "c_bands:  1 eigenvalues not converged"
                }
              },
              "failure_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "SCF_correction_text": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Total force =     0.000000     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
                }
              }
            },
            "last_force": {
              "header": {
                "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
              },
              "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "printed_site_rows": 4,
              "ordered_atom_indices": [
                1,
                2,
                3,
                4
              ],
              "reported_max_abs_component": {
                "value": 0.0,
                "unit": "Ry/bohr",
                "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
              },
              "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
              "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
              "max_component_eV_A": 0.0,
              "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.0,
              "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
              "conversion_constants": {
                "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
                "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
              },
              "unit_conversion_valid": true,
              "max_norm_site": {
                "value": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                "atom_index": 1,
                "type_index": 1
              },
              "reported_component_agrees": true
            },
            "last_stress": {
              "last_pressure_print": {
                "value": -0.01,
                "unit": "kbar",
                "raw_value": "-0.01",
                "GPa": -0.001
              },
              "last_stress_block": {
                "header": {
                  "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.01"
                },
                "complete_3x6": true,
                "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
                "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
                "rows": [
                  {
                    "value": [
                      -9e-08,
                      -0.0,
                      -0.0,
                      -0.01,
                      -0.0,
                      -0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      -0.0,
                      -9e-08,
                      0.0,
                      -0.0,
                      -0.01,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      -0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -7e-08,
                      -0.0,
                      0.0,
                      -0.01
                    ]
                  }
                ],
                "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                  [
                    -0.001,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    -0.0,
                    -0.001,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    -0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.001
                  ]
                ],
                "trace_mean_kbar": -0.01,
                "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.001,
                "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
              }
            },
            "last_total_energy_print": {
              "value": -871.70470423,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-871.70470423"
            },
            "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
              "value": 9.835e-05,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "0.00009835"
            },
            "native_exit_status": null,
            "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
            "PH_all_irreps_complete": null,
            "fullBZ_dynamical_stability": null,
            "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -871.70480258
          },
          "scf_fine.out.bz2": {
            "source_record": 12802,
            "explicit_program_start_headers": [
              {
                "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 12May2023 at 23:23:53"
              }
            ],
            "last_printed_convergence_event": {
              "value": true,
              "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
            },
            "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
            "routine_error_count": 0,
            "warning_patterns": {
              "pattern_selected_count": 10,
              "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
              "BFGS": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
                }
              },
              "negative_charge": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "eigen_text": {
                "count": 5,
                "last": {
                  "value": "c_bands:  1 eigenvalues not converged"
                }
              },
              "failure_text": {
                "count": 0,
                "last": null
              },
              "SCF_correction_text": {
                "count": 1,
                "last": {
                  "value": "Total force =     0.000000     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
                }
              }
            },
            "last_force": {
              "header": {
                "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
              },
              "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "printed_site_rows": 4,
              "ordered_atom_indices": [
                1,
                2,
                3,
                4
              ],
              "reported_max_abs_component": {
                "value": 0.0,
                "unit": "Ry/bohr",
                "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
              },
              "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
              "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.0,
              "max_component_eV_A": 0.0,
              "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.0,
              "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
              "conversion_constants": {
                "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
                "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
              },
              "unit_conversion_valid": true,
              "max_norm_site": {
                "value": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                "atom_index": 1,
                "type_index": 1
              },
              "reported_component_agrees": true
            },
            "last_stress": {
              "last_pressure_print": {
                "value": 0.47,
                "unit": "kbar",
                "raw_value": "0.47",
                "GPa": 0.047
              },
              "last_stress_block": {
                "header": {
                  "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=        0.47"
                },
                "complete_3x6": true,
                "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
                "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
                "rows": [
                  {
                    "value": [
                      6.48e-06,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      0.95,
                      0.0,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      6.48e-06,
                      0.0,
                      0.0,
                      0.95,
                      0.0
                    ]
                  },
                  {
                    "value": [
                      0.0,
                      -0.0,
                      -3.45e-06,
                      0.0,
                      -0.0,
                      -0.51
                    ]
                  }
                ],
                "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                  [
                    0.095,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    0.095,
                    0.0
                  ],
                  [
                    0.0,
                    -0.0,
                    -0.051000000000000004
                  ]
                ],
                "trace_mean_kbar": 0.4633333333333333,
                "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.095,
                "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
              }
            },
            "last_total_energy_print": {
              "value": -871.7040221,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-871.70402210"
            },
            "last_signed_minus_TS_print": {
              "value": -2.305e-05,
              "unit": "Ry",
              "raw_value": "-0.00002305"
            },
            "native_exit_status": null,
            "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
            "PH_all_irreps_complete": null,
            "fullBZ_dynamical_stability": null,
            "derived_E_from_F_minus_signed_minus_TS_Ry": -871.70399905
          }
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/Zr3Hf_agm001281126",
            "bytes": 8948,
            "sha256": "8807b11701d8f927dd0cbb68a7a29a23a99f6cc642f310ebfd5c4f528e24b678"
          },
          "raw_header": {
            "ntyp": 2,
            "nat": 4,
            "ibrav": 7,
            "celldm": [
              8.3987109,
              0.0,
              2.0122081,
              0.0,
              0.0,
              0.0
            ],
            "basis_alat": null,
            "species": [
              {
                "index": 1,
                "element": "Hf",
                "header_mass": 162683.682952464,
                "header_mass_halfwidth": 5e-10,
                "raw_mass_token": "162683.682952464",
                "line": 4
              },
              {
                "index": 2,
                "element": "Zr",
                "header_mass": 83145.5896333441,
                "header_mass_halfwidth": 5e-11,
                "raw_mass_token": "83145.5896333441",
                "line": 5
              }
            ],
            "atoms": [
              {
                "index": 1,
                "type": 1,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                "line": 6
              },
              {
                "index": 2,
                "type": 2,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.0,
                  -0.5,
                  1.5091560525
                ],
                "line": 7
              },
              {
                "index": 3,
                "type": 2,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.5,
                  0.0,
                  1.5091560525
                ],
                "line": 8
              },
              {
                "index": 4,
                "type": 2,
                "tau_alat": [
                  0.0,
                  -0.0,
                  1.006104035
                ],
                "line": 9
              }
            ],
            "q": [
              0.0,
              0.0,
              0.0
            ],
            "matrix_header_line": 11
          },
          "optical_sign": "positive_beyond_printing_bound",
          "minimum": 7.504517946216149e-07,
          "printing_bound": 8.957951100286607e-13,
          "ASR_relative": 0.0038751055728924637,
          "native_signed_modes": [
            {
              "number": 1,
              "THz": -0.348232,
              "cm_inverse": -11.615755,
              "line": 85
            },
            {
              "number": 2,
              "THz": -0.049782,
              "cm_inverse": -1.660536,
              "line": 90
            },
            {
              "number": 3,
              "THz": -0.049782,
              "cm_inverse": -1.660536,
              "line": 95
            },
            {
              "number": 4,
              "THz": 2.850084,
              "cm_inverse": 95.068555,
              "line": 100
            },
            {
              "number": 5,
              "THz": 3.225747,
              "cm_inverse": 107.599345,
              "line": 105
            },
            {
              "number": 6,
              "THz": 3.225747,
              "cm_inverse": 107.599345,
              "line": 110
            },
            {
              "number": 7,
              "THz": 3.275799,
              "cm_inverse": 109.26888,
              "line": 115
            },
            {
              "number": 8,
              "THz": 4.440432,
              "cm_inverse": 148.116874,
              "line": 120
            },
            {
              "number": 9,
              "THz": 4.440432,
              "cm_inverse": 148.116874,
              "line": 125
            },
            {
              "number": 10,
              "THz": 5.007916,
              "cm_inverse": 167.04609,
              "line": 130
            },
            {
              "number": 11,
              "THz": 5.007916,
              "cm_inverse": 167.04609,
              "line": 135
            },
            {
              "number": 12,
              "THz": 5.301016,
              "cm_inverse": 176.822862,
              "line": 140
            }
          ],
          "native_negative_outside_lowest3": []
        },
        "finite_path": {
          "source_record": 12781,
          "observations": {
            "kind": "qe_freq_gp_source_path_table",
            "raw_header_lines": [],
            "path_rows": 138,
            "column_width_counts": {
              "13": 138
            },
            "mode_column_values": 1656,
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": 0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "column_roles_conditional_on_file_schema": true,
            "fullBZ_coverage": null,
            "dynamical_stability": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          }
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm001281126",
          "dyn0_source_record": 12780,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                4.0,
                4.0,
                4.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                13.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 10,
              "source_record": 12787,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 11,
              "source_record": 12788,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 12,
              "source_record": 12789,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 13,
              "source_record": 12790,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 12791,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 12792,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 12793,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 12794,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 5,
              "source_record": 12795,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 6,
              "source_record": 12796,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 7,
              "source_record": 12797,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 8,
              "source_record": 12798,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 9,
              "source_record": 12799,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 13,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "composition-assessments.json",
          "bytes": 2036037,
          "sha256": "87a3759b8bb3bd9985bd6537220b4ea8fa427be6672204f9010e300e647c284a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "numeric-review.json",
          "bytes": 2556012,
          "sha256": "a0e7a487691b01ab8f0a4ea02eab40af649a455b97dc9ebdfdcabc4cd2453000",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Exact ordered-state mechanism new to reviewed catalogue only; source predictions/known chemistry acknowledged, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001190945",
      "formula": "Zr3Lu",
      "reduced_formula": "Zr3Lu",
      "composition": {
        "Lu": 1,
        "Zr": 3
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Lu:1|Zr:3",
      "elements": [
        "Lu",
        "Zr"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001190945",
      "control_state": "agm003187562",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/Zr3Lu_agm001190945",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/ScZr3_agm003187562",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "CIF_source_record": 8313,
        "CIF_payload_pin": {
          "bytes": 591661,
          "sha256": "93c3ce21c362fc36392db6d13f4555d76cce96122769d1212414bbc770f81541"
        },
        "SCF_coarse_source_record": 8331,
        "Gamma_source_pin": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/Zr3Lu_agm001190945",
          "bytes": 8948,
          "sha256": "c36c50238d0f24df09e4b452379d2dce0bdd44363ebb3d38b9a330781860c606"
        },
        "source_input_volume_difference_relative": -2.165934098741218e-11,
        "occupancy_model_all1": true,
        "bounded_signed_axis_and_translation_mapping": {
          "signed_axis_U_CIF_fractional_to_SCF": [
            [
              1,
              0,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              1,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              0,
              1
            ]
          ],
          "determinant": 1,
          "origin_shift_fractional": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species_bijection_CIF_to_SCF": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            3
          ],
          "maximum_site_distance_A": 3.6373826119009093e-16,
          "relative_Gram_residual": 5.841645541896771e-10,
          "proper_signed_axis_solution": true
        },
        "attempts": 1,
        "general_GL3_or_chiral_equivalence_asserted": false,
        "CIF_site_precision_A_tolerance": 1e-05,
        "physical_model": "source finite neutral scalar EPC; no SOC transfer certificate"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 14.606,
        "control_K": 13.368,
        "delta_K": 1.2379999999999995,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.3672000000000002,
          0.37249999999999983,
          0.3446,
          0.3134999999999999,
          0.2842,
          0.25839999999999996,
          0.2371000000000001,
          0.22030000000000016,
          0.20720000000000005,
          0.19699999999999995
        ],
        "range": [
          0.19699999999999995,
          0.37249999999999983
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Lu target improves source lambda and Tc against Sc and Hf frozen controls; TiZr3 has lower lambda but higher Tc. This demonstrates that omega_log and electronic/mass changes must accompany lambda, and avoids ranking raw lambda as universally superior. All target forces zero; order/disorder and low-energy competing alloy phase remain untested.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.0 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure 0.001 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
      "route_response": "Sc/Hf-to-Lu minority-role construction in Zr3X cubic order. coupled chemical/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
      "next_action": "Inspect existing Zr-network mode/active-state changes for Lu/Sc/Hf and retain Ti counterexample. Favorable: a matched paired benefit on ordered branch survives refinement; adverse: order or phonon scale benefit disappears; ambiguous: no phase-ordering distinction.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact source CIF/SCF/Γ state association; CIF source record 8313. Experimental occupancy/P/T and physical magnetic ground state remain unknown; source scalar model only.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Sc/Hf-to-Lu minority-role construction in Zr3X cubic order. coupled chemical/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
        "pairing_relevance": "direct published source EPC and independent source isotropic Eliashberg result. 2 favorable comparator(s); bounded source model, not experiment.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.0 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure 0.001 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Lu target improves source lambda and Tc against Sc and Hf frozen controls; TiZr3 has lower lambda but higher Tc. This demonstrates that omega_log and electronic/mass changes must accompany lambda, and avoids ranking raw lambda as universally superior. All target forces zero; order/disorder and low-energy competing alloy phase remain untested.",
        "novelty": "Exact Zr3Lu ordered search found no primary experimental exact SC phase. SG221 Zr3Lu differs from ordinary Zr-rich solid solution and from source ScZr3/Hf variants; known chemistry does not establish same-phase alias.",
        "decision": "Inspect existing Zr-network mode/active-state changes for Lu/Sc/Hf and retain Ti counterexample. Favorable: a matched paired benefit on ordered branch survives refinement; adverse: order or phonon scale benefit disappears; ambiguous: no phase-ordering distinction."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase",
        "residual_force_stress"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 263,
          "control": "batch-a/ScZr3_agm003187562",
          "target": "batch-a/Zr3Lu_agm001190945",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.19699999999999995,
            0.37249999999999983
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            20.130799100756178,
            32.65825004383656
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 14.606,
          "Tc_control_K": 13.368,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 1.2379999999999995,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.0379687575185974,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.3903780165585474e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.19699999999999995,
            0.37249999999999983
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 356,
          "control": "batch-a/TiZr3_agm001190274",
          "target": "batch-a/Zr3Lu_agm001190945",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.046499999999999986,
            0.32530000000000014
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            4.1183243291116804,
            26.705524997947638
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 14.606,
          "Tc_control_K": 15.214,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": -0.6080000000000005,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.1084343600077136,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.1949751085793567e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.046499999999999986,
            0.32530000000000014
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 380,
          "control": "batch-a/Zr3Hf_agm001190885",
          "target": "batch-a/Zr3Lu_agm001190945",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.16490000000000005,
            0.4638000000000002
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            16.315424953002875,
            42.96035568729162
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 14.606,
          "Tc_control_K": 12.514,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 2.0920000000000005,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.048093525167909,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 8.296086237767607e-07,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.16490000000000005,
            0.4638000000000002
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-01-ten-specific-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 381754,
          "sha256": "5d05478212c4d22080ab1b7bf22d92b784de6c0f8a99590d0758f9cdbfdafb32",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-remaining-transition-owned-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 5381838,
          "sha256": "62f4910578c7b65392d26619cf81b31afd6142f38aa49834a70bb147e7ab222d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to the reviewed candidate mechanism catalogue, source prediction already published; not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001177717",
      "formula": "ZrHfRe4",
      "reduced_formula": "ZrHfRe4",
      "composition": {
        "Hf": 1,
        "Re": 4,
        "Zr": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Hf:1|Re:4|Zr:1",
      "elements": [
        "Hf",
        "Re",
        "Zr"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001177717",
      "control_state": "agm001631258",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/ZrHfRe4_agm001177717",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/HfRe2_agm001631258",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "CIF_source_record": 6655,
        "CIF_payload_pin": {
          "bytes": 591661,
          "sha256": "93c3ce21c362fc36392db6d13f4555d76cce96122769d1212414bbc770f81541"
        },
        "SCF_coarse_source_record": 6667,
        "Gamma_source_pin": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/ZrHfRe4_agm001177717",
          "bytes": 18614,
          "sha256": "c71f81333325a09ab21db78a17b41e9bb67fa9c6c999e54f16c6ec6906e04438"
        },
        "source_input_volume_difference_relative": -1.982392028310187e-11,
        "occupancy_model_all1": true,
        "bounded_signed_axis_and_translation_mapping": {
          "signed_axis_U_CIF_fractional_to_SCF": [
            [
              1,
              0,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              1,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              0,
              1
            ]
          ],
          "determinant": 1,
          "origin_shift_fractional": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species_bijection_CIF_to_SCF": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            3,
            4,
            5
          ],
          "maximum_site_distance_A": 9.077265004189281e-08,
          "relative_Gram_residual": 1.361346035818779e-09,
          "proper_signed_axis_solution": true
        },
        "attempts": 1,
        "general_GL3_or_chiral_equivalence_asserted": false,
        "CIF_site_precision_A_tolerance": 1e-05,
        "physical_model": "source finite neutral scalar EPC; no SOC transfer certificate"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 15.587,
        "control_K": 14.183,
        "delta_K": 1.404,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.19710000000000005,
          0.18769999999999998,
          0.16749999999999998,
          0.14619999999999989,
          0.1291,
          0.11599999999999988,
          0.1056999999999999,
          0.09770000000000012,
          0.09150000000000003,
          0.08649999999999991
        ],
        "range": [
          0.08649999999999991,
          0.19710000000000005
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "The Hf-for-Lu frozen contrast is favorable throughout all ten integration tokens and has an independent Tc gain. Other frozen routes are not all favorable: ZrRe2 and ZrTc4Hf outperform target, while Y→Hf lambda crosses sign. Keep this local role hypothesis, not an elemental ranking. Heavy Re/SOC, ordered-vs-disordered phase and C14/C15 competition remain model limitations.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse force 1.2914516857388574e-05 eV/Å, pressure 0.0 GPa; fine force 0.00599099983732581 eV/Å, pressure 0.002 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
      "route_response": "Lu-to-Hf ordered C15-related site construction. coupled chemical/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
      "next_action": "Use saved Re-site modes and occupation/orbital data for Lu/Hf neighbors. Favorable: the role-specific gain survives matched screening and local phase checks; adverse: C14/decomposition or SOC changes the favorable branch; ambiguous: no mode/source-state association.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact source CIF/SCF/Γ state association; CIF source record 6655. Experimental occupancy/P/T and physical magnetic ground state remain unknown; source scalar model only.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Lu-to-Hf ordered C15-related site construction. coupled chemical/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
        "pairing_relevance": "direct published source EPC and independent source isotropic Eliashberg result. 2 favorable comparator(s); bounded source model, not experiment.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse force 1.2914516857388574e-05 eV/Å, pressure 0.0 GPa; fine force 0.00599099983732581 eV/Å, pressure 0.002 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "The Hf-for-Lu frozen contrast is favorable throughout all ten integration tokens and has an independent Tc gain. Other frozen routes are not all favorable: ZrRe2 and ZrTc4Hf outperform target, while Y→Hf lambda crosses sign. Keep this local role hypothesis, not an elemental ranking. Heavy Re/SOC, ordered-vs-disordered phase and C14/C15 competition remain model limitations.",
        "novelty": "Exact ZrHfRe4 query found no primary experimental exact phase. Closest experimental Re systems retrieved are Re7X3 binary alloys (different stoichiometries/structures) and C14 ZrRe2; source SG216 ternary ordering is distinct. This is not a new-worldwide composition claim.",
        "decision": "Use saved Re-site modes and occupation/orbital data for Lu/Hf neighbors. Favorable: the role-specific gain survives matched screening and local phase checks; adverse: C14/decomposition or SOC changes the favorable branch; ambiguous: no mode/source-state association."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 132,
          "control": "batch-a/HfRe2_agm001631258",
          "target": "batch-a/ZrHfRe4_agm001177717",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.08649999999999991,
            0.19710000000000005
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            9.43910955914447,
            14.896833194769863
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 15.587,
          "Tc_control_K": 14.183,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 1.404,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": false,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.0068009700468366,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.1326546678821608e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.08649999999999991,
            0.19710000000000005
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 370,
          "control": "batch-a/YZrRe4_agm003199974",
          "target": "batch-a/ZrHfRe4_agm001177717",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.035600000000000076,
            0.15429999999999988
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -2.2882118524231956,
            13.010762096421388
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 15.587,
          "Tc_control_K": 12.616,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 2.971,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9612966684628981,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.3157873852535568e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.035600000000000076,
            0.15429999999999988
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 382,
          "control": "batch-a/ZrLuRe4_agm001177738",
          "target": "batch-a/ZrHfRe4_agm001177717",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.16379999999999995,
            0.26869999999999994
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            12.076083751105864,
            24.50356660882976
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 15.587,
          "Tc_control_K": 11.953,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 3.6340000000000003,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9782539342783347,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.3105080034423595e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.16379999999999995,
            0.26869999999999994
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 383,
          "control": "batch-a/ZrRe2_agm003200022",
          "target": "batch-a/ZrHfRe4_agm001177717",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.1581999999999999,
            -0.026900000000000146
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -9.425643469971396,
            -2.6121577005243877
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 15.587,
          "Tc_control_K": 16.476,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": -0.8889999999999993,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": true,
          "three_tol_graph": false,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9932972941899576,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.0535056350827616e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.1581999999999999,
            -0.026900000000000146
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 384,
          "control": "batch-a/ZrTc4Hf_agm001177851",
          "target": "batch-a/ZrHfRe4_agm001177717",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.15690000000000004,
            -0.10870000000000002
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -13.528194516295917,
            -6.796723566560371
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 15.587,
          "Tc_control_K": 18.96,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": -3.373000000000001,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": true,
          "three_tol_graph": false,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.0238230439533347,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.1274324923852392e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.15690000000000004,
            -0.10870000000000002
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-01-ten-specific-scientific-recommendations.json",
          "bytes": 381754,
          "sha256": "5d05478212c4d22080ab1b7bf22d92b784de6c0f8a99590d0758f9cdbfdafb32",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-remaining-transition-owned-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 5381838,
          "sha256": "62f4910578c7b65392d26619cf81b31afd6142f38aa49834a70bb147e7ab222d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to the reviewed candidate mechanism catalogue, source prediction already published; not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001146456",
      "formula": "ZrNb2Ta",
      "reduced_formula": "ZrNb2Ta",
      "composition": {
        "Nb": 2,
        "Ta": 1,
        "Zr": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Nb:2|Ta:1|Zr:1",
      "elements": [
        "Nb",
        "Ta",
        "Zr"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001146456",
      "control_state": "agm001146453",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/ZrNb2Ta_agm001146456",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/Nb2HfTa_agm001146453",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "CIF_source_record": 2701,
        "CIF_payload_pin": {
          "bytes": 591661,
          "sha256": "93c3ce21c362fc36392db6d13f4555d76cce96122769d1212414bbc770f81541"
        },
        "SCF_coarse_source_record": 2721,
        "Gamma_source_pin": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/ZrNb2Ta_agm001146456",
          "bytes": 8994,
          "sha256": "4e5f64ac188f9fc5e41ddb00199a392dbff40f7feb27f26532f5cbeb4114221e"
        },
        "source_input_volume_difference_relative": 5.080047493777329e-11,
        "occupancy_model_all1": true,
        "bounded_signed_axis_and_translation_mapping": {
          "signed_axis_U_CIF_fractional_to_SCF": [
            [
              1,
              0,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              1,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              0,
              1
            ]
          ],
          "determinant": 1,
          "origin_shift_fractional": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "species_bijection_CIF_to_SCF": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            3
          ],
          "maximum_site_distance_A": 6.77809437291292e-08,
          "relative_Gram_residual": 1.0384601192102076e-09,
          "proper_signed_axis_solution": true
        },
        "attempts": 1,
        "general_GL3_or_chiral_equivalence_asserted": false,
        "CIF_site_precision_A_tolerance": 1e-05,
        "physical_model": "source finite neutral scalar EPC; no SOC transfer certificate"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 19.391,
        "control_K": 17.554,
        "delta_K": 1.8369999999999997,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.12639999999999985,
          0.12430000000000008,
          0.12939999999999996,
          0.1247999999999998,
          0.11589999999999989,
          0.10650000000000004,
          0.09860000000000002,
          0.09220000000000006,
          0.08750000000000013,
          0.08409999999999984
        ],
        "range": [
          0.08409999999999984,
          0.12939999999999996
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "Use AGM001146456 branch: no path negatives, +.0841…+.1294 lambda and Tc+1.837 K against Nb2HfTa. Fine force .04756/stress .429 GPa are explicit refinements. AGM001233891 has four path negatives (-22.6498 at x5.260949) and is retained grade2; source geometry branch selection is physical and not chosen by larger Tc. One composition group only.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse force 2.3911261376491538e-05 eV/Å, pressure -0.001 GPa; fine force 0.047556156443455705 eV/Å, pressure -0.022 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
      "route_response": "Hf-to-Zr minority-site construction in ZrNb2Ta. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
      "next_action": "Compare saved branch-specific strain/mode evidence, keeping target146456 versus its exact Hf parent. Favorable: stable branch retains gain under fine geometry uncertainty; adverse: phase/strain loses it; ambiguous: branch association incomplete.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact source CIF/SCF/Γ state association; CIF source record 2701. Experimental occupancy/P/T and physical magnetic ground state remain unknown; source scalar model only.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Hf-to-Zr minority-site construction in ZrNb2Ta. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
        "pairing_relevance": "direct published source EPC plus independent source isotropic Eliashberg result.  favorable comparator(s); bounded source model, not experiment.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse force 2.3911261376491538e-05 eV/Å, pressure -0.001 GPa; fine force 0.047556156443455705 eV/Å, pressure -0.022 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "Use AGM001146456 branch: no path negatives, +.0841…+.1294 lambda and Tc+1.837 K against Nb2HfTa. Fine force .04756/stress .429 GPa are explicit refinements. AGM001233891 has four path negatives (-22.6498 at x5.260949) and is retained grade2; source geometry branch selection is physical and not chosen by larger Tc. One composition group only.",
        "novelty": "Related Nb/Ta/Zr and Ti/Nb/Ta alloy superconductivity do not identify the exact ordered SG123 4-site source phase. No exact phase retrieved; known computational proposal.",
        "decision": "Compare saved branch-specific strain/mode evidence, keeping target146456 versus its exact Hf parent. Favorable: stable branch retains gain under fine geometry uncertainty; adverse: phase/strain loses it; ambiguous: branch association incomplete."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "residual_force_stress"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 203,
          "control": "batch-a/Nb2HfTa_agm001146453",
          "target": "batch-a/ZrNb2Ta_agm001146456",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.08409999999999984,
            0.12939999999999996
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            6.411527025996786,
            8.125588697017266
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 19.391,
          "Tc_control_K": 17.554,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 1.8369999999999997,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.0069222133489737,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 6.009788182918559e-07,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001146453",
            "dyn0_source_record": 3939,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              5.0,
              5.0,
              2.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 3946,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 11,
                "source_record": 3947,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 12,
                "source_record": 3948,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 3949,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 3950,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 3951,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 3952,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 3953,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 3954,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 3955,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 3956,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 3957,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.08409999999999984,
            0.12939999999999996
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 387,
          "control": "batch-a/ZrTa3_agm003165876",
          "target": "batch-a/ZrNb2Ta_agm001146456",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.17910000000000004,
            0.32189999999999985
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            14.72014465357114,
            21.998223194150196
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 19.391,
          "Tc_control_K": 14.634,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 4.756999999999998,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9963716509945139,
          "control_path_negatives": 3,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 6.981643340329627e-07,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 3,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -3.6342,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003165876",
            "dyn0_source_record": 7999,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              5.0,
              5.0,
              2.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 8006,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 11,
                "source_record": 8007,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 12,
                "source_record": 8008,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 8009,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 8010,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 8011,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 8012,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 8013,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 8014,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 8015,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 8016,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 8017,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.17910000000000004,
            0.32189999999999985
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-02-eleven-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1219201,
          "sha256": "ee658cb8e6309178e268b736f8aeb6429c030a92019c068963e2d64ca51cbb17",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-03-fifteen-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1347056,
          "sha256": "1be9342cb74006b2542e9351fc2de310967f1a31a5ee9f1909ae730b9a11476a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-remaining-transition-owned-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 5381838,
          "sha256": "62f4910578c7b65392d26619cf81b31afd6142f38aa49834a70bb147e7ab222d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to the reviewed candidate mechanism catalogue, source prediction already published; not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001277510",
      "formula": "ZrNbTa",
      "reduced_formula": "ZrNbTa",
      "composition": {
        "Nb": 1,
        "Ta": 1,
        "Zr": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Nb:1|Ta:1|Zr:1",
      "elements": [
        "Nb",
        "Ta",
        "Zr"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001277510",
      "control_state": "agm001839730",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/ZrNbTa_agm001277510",
      "control_directory": null,
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "three-site hexagonal ordered network versus body-centered tetragonal primitive ordering",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "motif": "three-site hexagonal ordered network versus body-centered tetragonal primitive ordering",
        "verified_space_group": null,
        "role": "A versus samecomposition B",
        "known_prior_scope": "Known equiatomic NbTaZr alloy phase separation and2023 theoretical source are acknowledged; no exact three-site ordered SC experimental benchmark identified in bounded primary search. Not a first material discovery."
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 17.517,
        "control_K": 13.697,
        "delta_K": 3.8200000000000003,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.5243,
          0.4929000000000001,
          0.5065,
          0.5045,
          0.4898,
          0.4707999999999999,
          0.4518,
          0.4347000000000001,
          0.41980000000000006,
          0.40689999999999993
        ],
        "range": [
          0.40689999999999993,
          0.5243
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "All ten lambda gains41.39-46.95%, separate source Eli Tc17.517 versus13.697K (+27.89%). Target coarse force~0.00010eV/A supports the published coarse-relaxed double-grid model; fine force0.04583eV/A is substantial sensitivity. Target fine E is16.23meV/site higher; known equiatomic alloy shows Nb/Ta-rich and Zr-rich BCC plus Zr-rich HCP competition. Conditional Gamma harmonic displacement estimate is not fine relaxation or EPC error certification. Evaluated risks define a falsifiable bounded hypothesis, not an established bulk ground state or experimental coherence proof.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source nearambient fullstress/pressure and coarse-relaxed geometry, positive raw-Gamma optical compression beyond printing bounds, and no negative printed finite-path values support preliminary local feasibility only within the declared source approximation. WholeBZ/global hull/synthesis remain unknown.",
      "route_response": "Cross-species R4 coordination6 versus5 and Zr periodic distance2.96840 versus3.34686A; source SCF is the EPC anchor. CIF/geo basal reflection has det-1 and is retained as scalar parity equivalence, not a proper-rotation proof. Computed source EPC response is associated with construction; pure geometry-only causality and converged numerical uplift are unproved.",
      "next_action": "Test fine-geometry retention/EPC ordering on the two exact states; assess specific Nb/Ta-rich and Zr-rich BCC/HCP competitors or a concrete constrained/metastable preparation route.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact reduced composition and non-alias decorated ordered network linked to canonical SCF input and source PH/Gamma/model evidence; source positions bind Gamma within printing/operational tolerances. Nb same-species permutation and Zr scalar parity reflection are explicit. Experimental phase/state remains unknown.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Cross-species R4 coordination6 versus5 and Zr periodic distance2.96840 versus3.34686A; source SCF is the EPC anchor. CIF/geo basal reflection has det-1 and is retained as scalar parity equivalence, not a proper-rotation proof. Computed source EPC response is associated with construction; pure geometry-only causality and converged numerical uplift are unproved.",
        "pairing_relevance": "Direct source lambda at ten common printed width tokens and independently retained mu*=0.1 Eliashberg Tc rows provide state-specific pairing relevance. Width units and Tc-to-width link remain unknown; no parent-property transfer or300K claim.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source nearambient fullstress/pressure and coarse-relaxed geometry, positive raw-Gamma optical compression beyond printing bounds, and no negative printed finite-path values support preliminary local feasibility only within the declared source approximation. WholeBZ/global hull/synthesis remain unknown.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "All ten lambda gains41.39-46.95%, separate source Eli Tc17.517 versus13.697K (+27.89%). Target coarse force~0.00010eV/A supports the published coarse-relaxed double-grid model; fine force0.04583eV/A is substantial sensitivity. Target fine E is16.23meV/site higher; known equiatomic alloy shows Nb/Ta-rich and Zr-rich BCC plus Zr-rich HCP competition. Conditional Gamma harmonic displacement estimate is not fine relaxation or EPC error certification. Evaluated risks define a falsifiable bounded hypothesis, not an established bulk ground state or experimental coherence proof.",
        "novelty": "Known equiatomic NbTaZr alloy phase separation and2023 theoretical source are acknowledged; no exact three-site ordered SC experimental benchmark identified in bounded primary search. Not a first material discovery. Default one exact-composition group, with all source/control variants underneath.",
        "decision": "Test fine-geometry retention/EPC ordering on the two exact states; assess specific Nb/Ta-rich and Zr-rich BCC/HCP competitors or a concrete constrained/metastable preparation route. All seven minima support grade3 preliminary source-model screening; retained model-dependent uncertainty prevents grade4/formal publication."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase",
        "residual_force_stress",
        "sampling_method"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [],
      "physical_summary": {
        "target": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/ZrNbTa_agm001277510",
          "site_composition_matches_name": true,
          "site_count": 3,
          "volume_per_site_A3": 18.8850009066579,
          "source_fine_pressure_GPa": -0.013000000000000001,
          "source_fine_maxstress_GPa": 0.244,
          "source_fine_maxforce_eV_A": 0.045834545624348313,
          "fine_JOB_DONE": true,
          "fine_convergence": true,
          "path_min_signed_printed_value": -0.0,
          "path_units_not_inferred": null,
          "path_signed_negative_printed_count": 0,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        },
        "control": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/ZrNbTa_agm001839730",
          "site_composition_matches_name": true,
          "site_count": 3,
          "volume_per_site_A3": 19.10503567775417,
          "source_fine_pressure_GPa": -0.05600000000000001,
          "source_fine_maxstress_GPa": 0.23500000000000001,
          "source_fine_maxforce_eV_A": 0.050896276836380455,
          "fine_JOB_DONE": true,
          "fine_convergence": true,
          "path_min_signed_printed_value": -0.0,
          "path_units_not_inferred": null,
          "path_signed_negative_printed_count": 0,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-owned-five-pairs-scientific-workingview.json",
          "bytes": 933925,
          "sha256": "0a5d3b507b305b8991218157264276e898799837932a8050942ecf74ee389034",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-captured-five-pairs-method-slices.json",
          "bytes": 1387111,
          "sha256": "d84758cc1e54d79e08e01fe3b08b96dfa071953b16a488b0aef3a867ff30c147",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "CASE.md",
          "bytes": 9838,
          "sha256": "c8d5a48b83840e33dfd2a7e366a997b1ead78ff4ea99a35befab862017627f53",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "scientific-case-receipt.json",
          "bytes": 1876,
          "sha256": "5a91edc30a7806167992b91733cac09d5507cd1be678c3372874c4d3c13b1d37",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ZrNbTa-scientific-result.json",
          "bytes": 112770,
          "sha256": "7c4c5f777fe34ba094f0aa1062ffe1bf5f8149e080fec1c63a0c879999b70d18",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "new-to-reviewed-catalogue ordered source-model route hypothesis; literature-derived, not first discovery",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm001146455",
      "formula": "ZrNbTa2",
      "reduced_formula": "ZrNbTa2",
      "composition": {
        "Nb": 1,
        "Ta": 2,
        "Zr": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Nb:1|Ta:2|Zr:1",
      "elements": [
        "Nb",
        "Ta",
        "Zr"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm001146455",
      "control_state": "agm001146452",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/ZrNbTa2_agm001146455",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/NbHfTa2_agm001146452",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": "weighted_phonon_log_moment_net_pairing",
      "prototype": "Source symmetry observation: space group 123. Ordered-site evidence is retained; space group alone is not a prototype certificate.",
      "prototype_evidence": [
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.0001,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 123,
          "hall_number": 400,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "d",
            "g",
            "g",
            "c"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            1,
            3
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.0001,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 123,
          "hall_number": 400,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "d",
            "g",
            "g",
            "c"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            1,
            3
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.001,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 123,
          "hall_number": 400,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "d",
            "g",
            "g",
            "c"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            1,
            3
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.001,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 123,
          "hall_number": 400,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "d",
            "g",
            "g",
            "c"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            1,
            3
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.01,
          "mode": "color_aware",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 123,
          "hall_number": 400,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "d",
            "g",
            "g",
            "c"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            1,
            3
          ]
        },
        {
          "symprec_A": 0.01,
          "mode": "color_blind",
          "status": "completed",
          "SG_number": 123,
          "hall_number": 400,
          "input_wyckoff_letters": [
            "d",
            "g",
            "g",
            "c"
          ],
          "input_crystallographic_orbits": [
            0,
            1,
            1,
            3
          ]
        }
      ],
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 14.802,
        "control_K": 14.257,
        "delta_K": 0.5449999999999999,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.040200000000000014,
          -0.010000000000000009,
          -0.018399999999999972,
          -0.018100000000000005,
          -0.018100000000000005,
          -0.019299999999999873,
          -0.02090000000000014,
          -0.022299999999999986,
          -0.023299999999999876,
          -0.023699999999999832
        ],
        "range": [
          -0.023699999999999832,
          0.040200000000000014
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": [
        1.0620191460139803,
        1.0713075041504982,
        1.0738692909813194,
        1.0747917921761525,
        1.0752801479564997,
        1.0755954615436771,
        1.0758224417035003,
        1.0759972134465254,
        1.0761420858555153,
        1.0762722359550005
      ],
      "risk_summary": "The Hf analogue is the admission comparator. ZrTa3 has three negative printed path values and is retained as an adverse auxiliary edge, not used to establish stable controlled benefit.",
      "ambient_scope": "The exact source neutral zero-applied-pressure model has positive Γ optical compression intervals and no negative retained sampled path value for target and selected control. Coarse/fine force and full stress, relaxation warnings and every q record are retained. These finite observations do not prove full-BZ or thermodynamic hull stability.",
      "route_response": "Hf→Zr on the frozen ordered metal role raises the weighted EPC log-frequency while λ crosses; chemistry, mass and the relaxed metric change together.",
      "next_action": "Read the existing α²F or mode-resolved coupling associated with the exact source header, then test whether the Zr-bearing role increases the weighted log moment without a low-frequency divergence; keep fine residual force/strain as convergence sensitivity.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact agm001146455 ordered coordinates, species and metric are linked through source CIF→coarse/fine input→Γ header; actual bounded association residuals and original record IDs are retained below. This is not an experimental structure certificate.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Hf→Zr on the frozen ordered metal role raises the weighted EPC log-frequency while λ crosses; chemistry, mass and the relaxed metric change together.",
        "pairing_relevance": "Separate source Eli gain 0.545 K is retained with source McMillan/AD. Actual source-header descriptor reproduces the first McMillan column to printed precision. Header-to-ten-σ and Eli-to-σ association remains null, and ωlog is α²F weighted rather than an assertion that all bare modes harden.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "The exact source neutral zero-applied-pressure model has positive Γ optical compression intervals and no negative retained sampled path value for target and selected control. Coarse/fine force and full stress, relaxation warnings and every q record are retained. These finite observations do not prove full-BZ or thermodynamic hull stability.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "The Hf analogue is the admission comparator. ZrTa3 has three negative printed path values and is retained as an adverse auxiliary edge, not used to establish stable controlled benefit.",
        "novelty": "Exact ordered SG123 ZrNbTa2 superconductivity was not returned in the bounded exact-formula search. Known refractory Nb/Ta/Zr alloy chemistry would not identify this ordered four-site state. This is new-to-reviewed-catalogue support, not a first-synthesis claim.",
        "decision": "Supported as a private finite-source hypothesis at the printed μ*=.1 under the neutral scalar NC/PBEsol approximation; no calibrated physical probability or public score."
      },
      "risk_tags": [],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 222,
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/NbHfTa2_agm001146452",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/ZrNbTa2_agm001146455",
          "other_state": "batch-a/NbHfTa2_agm001146452",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "source_Eli_gain_target_minus_other_K": 0.5449999999999999,
          "other_printed_path_negative_values": 0,
          "other_q_sampling_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001146452",
            "dyn0_source_record": 8761,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              5.0,
              5.0,
              2.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 8768,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 11,
                "source_record": 8769,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 12,
                "source_record": 8770,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 8771,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 8772,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 8773,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 8774,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 8775,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 8776,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 8777,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 8778,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 8779,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.023699999999999832,
            0.040200000000000014
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 389,
          "fixed_A": "batch-a/ZrNbTa2_agm001146455",
          "fixed_B": "batch-a/ZrTa3_agm003165876",
          "other_state": "batch-a/ZrTa3_agm003165876",
          "three_symprec_supported": true,
          "supported_symprec_A": [
            0.0001,
            0.001,
            0.01
          ],
          "source_Eli_gain_target_minus_other_K": 0.16799999999999926,
          "other_printed_path_negative_values": 3,
          "other_q_sampling_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003165876",
            "dyn0_source_record": 7999,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              5.0,
              5.0,
              2.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 10,
                "source_record": 8006,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 11,
                "source_record": 8007,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 12,
                "source_record": 8008,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 8009,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 8010,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 8011,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 8012,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 5,
                "source_record": 8013,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 6,
                "source_record": 8014,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 7,
                "source_record": 8015,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 8,
                "source_record": 8016,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 9,
                "source_record": 8017,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.0815999999999999,
            -0.0665
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": {
        "directory_key": "batch-a/ZrNbTa2_agm001146455",
        "source_ID": "agm001146455",
        "composition": {
          "Nb": 1,
          "Ta": 2,
          "Zr": 1
        },
        "listed_sites": 4,
        "CIF_source_record": 7729,
        "source_McMillan_and_AD_mu0p1": {
          "value": [
            0.1,
            12.452,
            13.646
          ],
          "missing_tokens": [
            false,
            false,
            false
          ],
          "printed_zero": [
            false,
            false,
            false
          ]
        },
        "source_Eli_mu0p1": {
          "value": [
            0.1,
            14.802
          ],
          "missing_tokens": [
            false,
            false
          ],
          "printed_zero": [
            false,
            false
          ]
        },
        "SCF_coarse": {
          "source_record": 7767,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 14May2023 at  8:28:20"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 5,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000001     Total SCF correction =     0.000000"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 4,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 5.6e-07,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 5.6e-07,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 5.6e-07,
            "max_component_eV_A": 1.4398178893371249e-05,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 1.4398178893371249e-05,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                5.6e-07
              ],
              "atom_index": 2,
              "type_index": 2
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": -0.03,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "-0.03",
              "GPa": -0.003
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.03"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    -2.1e-07,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.03,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -2.1e-07,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.03,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -1.8e-07,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -0.03
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  -0.003,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.003,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  -0.003
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": -0.03,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.003,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
          "native_exit_status": null
        },
        "SCF_fine": {
          "source_record": 7768,
          "explicit_program_start_headers": [
            {
              "value": "Program PWSCF v.7.1 starts on 14May2023 at  8: 8:23"
            }
          ],
          "last_printed_convergence_event": {
            "value": true,
            "role": "printed electronic/linear-response convergence event; context not assumed SCF"
          },
          "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
          "routine_error_count": 0,
          "warning_patterns": {
            "pattern_selected_count": 7,
            "pattern_scope_not_all_warnings": true,
            "BFGS": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Warning: card   CELL_DYNAMICS = 'BFGS', ignored"
              }
            },
            "negative_charge": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "eigen_text": {
              "count": 2,
              "last": {
                "value": "c_bands:  1 eigenvalues not converged"
              }
            },
            "failure_text": {
              "count": 0,
              "last": null
            },
            "SCF_correction_text": {
              "count": 1,
              "last": {
                "value": "Total force =     0.000964     Total SCF correction =     0.000002"
              }
            }
          },
          "last_force": {
            "header": {
              "value": "Forces acting on atoms (cartesian axes, Ry/au):"
            },
            "reported_unit": "Ry/bohr",
            "printed_site_rows": 4,
            "ordered_atom_indices": [
              1,
              2,
              3,
              4
            ],
            "reported_max_abs_component": {
              "value": 0.00068184,
              "unit": "Ry/bohr",
              "derivation": "all components in this printed force block"
            },
            "recomputed_max_component_Ry_bohr": 0.00068184,
            "recomputed_max_atom_norm_Ry_bohr": 0.00068184,
            "max_component_eV_A": 0.01753081124402902,
            "max_atom_norm_eV_A": 0.01753081124402902,
            "Ry_bohr_to_eV_A_factor": 25.711033738162943,
            "conversion_constants": {
              "Ry_eV": 13.605693122994,
              "bohr_A": 0.529177210903
            },
            "unit_conversion_valid": true,
            "max_norm_site": {
              "value": [
                0.0,
                0.0,
                -0.00068184
              ],
              "atom_index": 2,
              "type_index": 2
            },
            "reported_component_agrees": true
          },
          "last_stress": {
            "last_pressure_print": {
              "value": -0.66,
              "unit": "kbar",
              "raw_value": "-0.66",
              "GPa": -0.066
            },
            "last_stress_block": {
              "header": {
                "value": "total   stress  (Ry/bohr**3)                   (kbar)     P=       -0.66"
              },
              "complete_3x6": true,
              "first_tensor_unit": "Ry/bohr^3",
              "last_tensor_unit": "kbar",
              "rows": [
                {
                  "value": [
                    -9.19e-06,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -1.35,
                    0.0,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    -9.19e-06,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    -1.35,
                    0.0
                  ]
                },
                {
                  "value": [
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    5.01e-06,
                    0.0,
                    0.0,
                    0.74
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "full_last_tensor_GPa": [
                [
                  -0.135,
                  0.0,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  -0.135,
                  0.0
                ],
                [
                  0.0,
                  0.0,
                  0.074
                ]
              ],
              "trace_mean_kbar": -0.6533333333333334,
              "max_abs_stress_GPa": 0.135,
              "hydrostatic_pressure_not_full_stress": true
            }
          },
          "ionic_convergence_certificate": null,
          "native_exit_status": null
        },
        "Gamma": {
          "source_pin": {
            "directory_key": "batch-a/ZrNbTa2_agm001146455",
            "bytes": 8994,
            "sha256": "3c2c1113bf650d7ae1009cfff0bd5f1f5c575eea860af9acbf70451d652e9bd4"
          },
          "raw_optical_minimum": 5.022064059435495e-07,
          "raw_optical_printing_intervals": [
            [
              5.022056430488139e-07,
              5.02207168838285e-07
            ],
            [
              5.022056430488144e-07,
              5.022071688382854e-07
            ],
            [
              1.196631929417823e-06,
              1.196633455207294e-06
            ],
            [
              1.196631929417824e-06,
              1.196633455207295e-06
            ],
            [
              1.4220522510076635e-06,
              1.4220537767971346e-06
            ],
            [
              2.4859772333270707e-06,
              2.485978759116542e-06
            ],
            [
              2.96552470984438e-06,
              2.9655262356338515e-06
            ],
            [
              3.0865718103807483e-06,
              3.08657333617022e-06
            ],
            [
              3.0865718103807488e-06,
              3.0865733361702202e-06
            ]
          ],
          "unit": "squared source-Ry frequency convention",
          "native_negative_mode_numbers": [
            1,
            2
          ],
          "physical_error_bar": null,
          "full_BZ": null
        },
        "retained_path": {
          "kind": "qe_freq_gp_source_path_table",
          "raw_header_lines": [],
          "path_rows": 163,
          "column_width_counts": {
            "13": 163
          },
          "mode_column_values": 1956,
          "negative_printed_values": 0,
          "minimum_printed_mode": {
            "value": 0.0,
            "column_index_zero_based": 1
          },
          "frequency_unit_header": null,
          "column_roles_conditional_on_file_schema": true,
          "fullBZ_coverage": null,
          "dynamical_stability": null,
          "state_link_verified": null
        },
        "q_sampling": {
          "source_ID": "agm001146455",
          "dyn0_source_record": 7747,
          "raw_first_two_dyn0_rows": [
            {
              "value": [
                5.0,
                5.0,
                2.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false,
                false,
                false
              ]
            },
            {
              "value": [
                12.0
              ],
              "missing_tokens": [
                false
              ],
              "printed_zero": [
                false
              ]
            }
          ],
          "observed_q_index_records": [
            {
              "q_index": 10,
              "source_record": 7754,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 11,
              "source_record": 7755,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 12,
              "source_record": 7756,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 1,
              "source_record": 7757,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 2,
              "source_record": 7758,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 3,
              "source_record": 7759,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 4,
              "source_record": 7760,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 5,
              "source_record": 7761,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 6,
              "source_record": 7762,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 7,
              "source_record": 7763,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 8,
              "source_record": 7764,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            },
            {
              "q_index": 9,
              "source_record": 7765,
              "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
              "routine_error_count": 0,
              "last_printed_convergence_value": true
            }
          ],
          "source_PH_input_record_count": 12,
          "source_PH_input_bound_mismatch_count": 0,
          "all_irreps_complete": null,
          "native_exit_status": null,
          "full_BZ_stability": null
        },
        "unknowns": {
          "physical_mobile_carrier_density": null,
          "active_orbital_bandwidth": null,
          "public_RPS": null
        }
      },
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-01-eight-actual-omega-net-pairing-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1213076,
          "sha256": "ae6bc2be8e022ea5308483e2f63d28dfc4565f2cfa13948c036a16368c5f6201",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all62-net-pairing-owned-source-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 4086409,
          "sha256": "bced95fc8c75035eb57c3afbae73d98e099c3e732ef1e07a1836df54a1d60e15",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-all500-owned-small-q-sampling-summary-v1.json",
          "bytes": 852876,
          "sha256": "7c41fa11f1d930ec1a1edf424825bf628db3569b27a45512a7ae90000d542175",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-owned-62-source-observations-for-Tc-header-readback-v1.json",
          "bytes": 10632536,
          "sha256": "35c5bfdd77eb7194ebebc41802600580a842c5526c8727c40a427c8869890d90",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "Published source predictions already known; specific matched mechanism new to reviewed catalogue, not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    },
    {
      "id": "source-hypothesis:agm003203155",
      "formula": "ZrTc2",
      "reduced_formula": "ZrTc2",
      "composition": {
        "Tc": 2,
        "Zr": 1
      },
      "canonical_composition_key": "Tc:2|Zr:1",
      "elements": [
        "Tc",
        "Zr"
      ],
      "source_state": "agm003203155",
      "control_state": "agm003198926",
      "source_directory": "batch-a/ZrTc2_agm003203155",
      "control_directory": "batch-a/ScTc2_agm003198926",
      "status": "unscored_research_hypothesis",
      "route": "geometry_construction",
      "route_submechanism": null,
      "prototype": "Exact source geometry association retained; no named prototype is assigned here.",
      "prototype_evidence": {
        "CIF_source_record": 2187,
        "CIF_payload_pin": {
          "bytes": 591661,
          "sha256": "93c3ce21c362fc36392db6d13f4555d76cce96122769d1212414bbc770f81541"
        },
        "SCF_coarse_source_record": 2199,
        "Gamma_source_pin": {
          "directory_key": "batch-a/ZrTc2_agm003203155",
          "bytes": 18568,
          "sha256": "f1fb1fb9f70b06a72300338fecc4021cd4a6f608b457e64e1b7f0e428bf494c8"
        },
        "source_input_volume_difference_relative": 4.0603076456591225e-11,
        "occupancy_model_all1": true,
        "bounded_signed_axis_and_translation_mapping": {
          "signed_axis_U_CIF_fractional_to_SCF": [
            [
              1,
              0,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              1,
              0
            ],
            [
              0,
              0,
              1
            ]
          ],
          "determinant": 1,
          "origin_shift_fractional": [
            -8.133339557403474e-10,
            1.2440000141111796e-08,
            -8.133339557403474e-10
          ],
          "species_bijection_CIF_to_SCF": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            3,
            4,
            5
          ],
          "maximum_site_distance_A": 6.028483198638199e-08,
          "relative_Gram_residual": 1.211790154875418e-09,
          "proper_signed_axis_solution": true
        },
        "attempts": 1,
        "general_GL3_or_chiral_equivalence_asserted": false,
        "CIF_site_precision_A_tolerance": 1e-05,
        "physical_model": "source finite neutral scalar EPC; no SOC transfer certificate"
      },
      "support_grade": 3,
      "support_scale_max": 4,
      "support_meaning": "Preliminary screened support within the stated source model. This ordinal level is not a probability, formal RPS score or human scientific review.",
      "source_tc": {
        "target_K": 20.576,
        "control_K": 14.29,
        "delta_K": 6.286000000000001,
        "unit": "K",
        "method": "Eliashberg",
        "mu_star": 0.1,
        "experimental": false,
        "sigma_binding": null
      },
      "lambda_difference": {
        "all10": [
          0.6544000000000001,
          0.6291,
          0.5911000000000002,
          0.5360999999999998,
          0.4762000000000002,
          0.42169999999999996,
          0.37560000000000016,
          0.33730000000000016,
          0.3057000000000001,
          0.28
        ],
        "range": [
          0.28,
          0.6544000000000001
        ],
        "convention": "target_minus_control",
        "unit": "dimensionless"
      },
      "omega_log_ratio_all10": null,
      "risk_summary": "All-tokenpositivepairingchangesoverHfTc2,ScTc2 andZrRe2 haveindependentTc gains;othermixed/contraryternarycomparisonsretained. Force0/path0/Gammaopt+ withstress .261GPa supportsfinite sourceC15basin. Primaryphase-levelEhull29meV/atom forC15ZrTc2 providesboundedmetastabilitycontext, not currentexactenergytransfer. Tc radioactivity andC14competitorremain risks.",
      "ambient_scope": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure 0.0 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.261 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
      "route_response": "Re-to-Tc andHf/Sc-to-Zr role changes in C15 ZrX2. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
      "next_action": "Compare exactC15sourcegeometry/modes andknownC14 phasecompetitionwithouttransferringhull/Tc. Favorable: distinctaccessiblelocalphaseandcontrolledgain; adverse: exactbenchmarkalias/phaseconversion orsuppression; ambiguous: no comparable retention evidence.",
      "seven_criteria": {
        "identity": "Exact source CIF/SCF/Γ state association; CIF source record 2187. Experimental occupancy/P/T and physical magnetic ground state remain unknown; source scalar model only.",
        "quantitative_route_response": "Re-to-Tc andHf/Sc-to-Zr role changes in C15 ZrX2. coupled chemistry/site-role/volume/mass construction, not isolated geometry or inferred W/n",
        "pairing_relevance": "direct published source EPC plus independent source isotropic Eliashberg result.  favorable comparator(s); bounded source model, not experiment.",
        "ambient_feasibility": "Source coarse force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure 0.0 GPa; fine force 0.0 eV/Å, pressure -0.261 GPa. Actual full stress, Γ interval, finite path and q observations are retained in the complete review; no whole-BZ/global-stability claim.",
        "competition_and_coherence": "All-tokenpositivepairingchangesoverHfTc2,ScTc2 andZrRe2 haveindependentTc gains;othermixed/contraryternarycomparisonsretained. Force0/path0/Gammaopt+ withstress .261GPa supportsfinite sourceC15basin. Primaryphase-levelEhull29meV/atom forC15ZrTc2 providesboundedmetastabilitycontext, not currentexactenergytransfer. Tc radioactivity andC14competitorremain risks.",
        "novelty": "ExperimentalZrTc2/Tc2ZrC14isknown; sourceSG227C15model isdifferent. SourcepaperhighprecisionC15ZrTc2phaseknowncomputedprior; sourcecurrentobjectnewtocatalogueonly.",
        "decision": "Compare exactC15sourcegeometry/modes andknownC14 phasecompetitionwithouttransferringhull/Tc. Favorable: distinctaccessiblelocalphaseandcontrolledgain; adverse: exactbenchmarkalias/phaseconversion orsuppression; ambiguous: no comparable retention evidence."
      },
      "risk_tags": [
        "metastable_phase",
        "residual_force_stress",
        "technetium"
      ],
      "countercontrols": [
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 245,
          "control": "batch-a/ScTc2_agm003198926",
          "target": "batch-a/ZrTc2_agm003203155",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.28,
            0.6544000000000001
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            27.084542464693367,
            51.33756962422532
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 20.576,
          "Tc_control_K": 14.29,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 6.286000000000001,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.011344411382918,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.0179346913436019e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003198926",
            "dyn0_source_record": 9453,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 9460,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 9461,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 9462,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 9463,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.28,
            0.6544000000000001
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 267,
          "control": "batch-a/ScZrTc4_agm003195954",
          "target": "batch-a/ZrTc2_agm003203155",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.21819999999999995,
            -0.07759999999999989
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -10.1615982862199,
            -5.577116573235583
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 20.576,
          "Tc_control_K": 18.415,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 2.1610000000000014,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": false,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.0062462038240714,
          "control_path_negatives": 14,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.3988466370001736e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 14,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -5.2679,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003195954",
            "dyn0_source_record": 3701,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 3708,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 3709,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 3710,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 3711,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.21819999999999995,
            -0.07759999999999989
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 273,
          "control": "batch-a/Tc2Hf_agm001631318",
          "target": "batch-a/ZrTc2_agm003203155",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.2761,
            0.4991000000000001
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            26.606919148116024,
            36.17453069507865
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 20.576,
          "Tc_control_K": 16.968,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 3.6080000000000005,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.0145279890328787,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.2231348741446305e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": 0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001631318",
            "dyn0_source_record": 4785,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 4792,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 4793,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": false,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 4794,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 4795,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.2761,
            0.4991000000000001
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 275,
          "control": "batch-a/Tc2Lu_agm001631328",
          "target": "batch-a/ZrTc2_agm003203155",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.4638,
            -0.3756999999999997
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -26.09135913591359,
            -16.837818696883847
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 20.576,
          "Tc_control_K": 15.43,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 5.146000000000001,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9629734187466442,
          "control_path_negatives": 6,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.0260953212887805e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 6,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -2.6365,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001631328",
            "dyn0_source_record": 8253,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 8260,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 8261,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 8262,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 8263,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.4638,
            -0.3756999999999997
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 391,
          "control": "batch-a/ZrRe2_agm003200022",
          "target": "batch-a/ZrTc2_agm003203155",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.25070000000000014,
            0.28400000000000003
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            14.936844613918026,
            27.578170518547292
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 20.576,
          "Tc_control_K": 16.476,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 4.100000000000001,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": true,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9771502438215894,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.0535056350827616e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm003200022",
            "dyn0_source_record": 5453,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 5460,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 5461,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 5462,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 5463,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.25070000000000014,
            0.28400000000000003
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 392,
          "control": "batch-a/ZrTc4Hf_agm001177851",
          "target": "batch-a/ZrTc2_agm003203155",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            0.15400000000000014,
            0.2795000000000001
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            13.278151405414738,
            17.476395923216415
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 20.576,
          "Tc_control_K": 18.96,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 1.6159999999999997,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": true,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": false,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 1.0071797667032014,
          "control_path_negatives": 0,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.1274324923852392e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 0,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": 0.0,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001177851",
            "dyn0_source_record": 2863,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 2870,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 2871,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 2872,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 2873,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            0.15400000000000014,
            0.2795000000000001
          ]
        },
        {
          "frozen_contrast_index": 393,
          "control": "batch-a/ZrTc4Lu_agm001177853",
          "target": "batch-a/ZrTc2_agm003203155",
          "sigma_tokens": [
            "0.0050",
            "0.0100",
            "0.0150",
            "0.0200",
            "0.0250",
            "0.0300",
            "0.0350",
            "0.0400",
            "0.0450",
            "0.0500"
          ],
          "sigma_unit": null,
          "lambda_delta_range": [
            -0.2014999999999998,
            -0.06359999999999988
          ],
          "lambda_pct_range": [
            -9.457429831972204,
            -4.617395092202692
          ],
          "Tc_target_K": 20.576,
          "Tc_control_K": 17.879,
          "independent_source_Eli_Tc_delta_K": 2.696999999999999,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_favorable": false,
          "all10_lambda_and_Tc_adverse": false,
          "three_tol_graph": false,
          "target_volume_ratio_over_control": 0.9821412061040061,
          "control_path_negatives": 8,
          "control_Gamma_optical_min": 1.2508272712601737e-06,
          "geometry_only_causality": null,
          "control_raw_path_minimum_and_negatives": {
            "negative_printed_values": 8,
            "minimum_printed_mode": {
              "value": -0.7935,
              "column_index_zero_based": 1
            },
            "frequency_unit_header": null,
            "state_link_verified": null
          },
          "control_q_status_summary": {
            "source_ID": "agm001177853",
            "dyn0_source_record": 4265,
            "configured_q_mesh": [
              3.0,
              3.0,
              3.0
            ],
            "observed_q_index_records": [
              {
                "q_index": 1,
                "source_record": 4272,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 2,
                "source_record": 4273,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 3,
                "source_record": 4274,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              },
              {
                "q_index": 4,
                "source_record": 4275,
                "JOB_DONE_seen": true,
                "routine_error_count": 0,
                "last_printed_convergence_value": true
              }
            ],
            "full_BZ_stability": null,
            "native_exit_status": null
          },
          "lambda_target_minus_other_range": [
            -0.2014999999999998,
            -0.06359999999999988
          ]
        }
      ],
      "physical_summary": null,
      "evidence_pins": [
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-02-eleven-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1219201,
          "sha256": "ee658cb8e6309178e268b736f8aeb6429c030a92019c068963e2d64ca51cbb17",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "tranche-03-fifteen-specific-source-finite-cases.json",
          "bytes": 1347056,
          "sha256": "1be9342cb74006b2542e9351fc2de310967f1a31a5ee9f1909ae730b9a11476a",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        },
        {
          "artifact": "ROOT-remaining-transition-owned-review-cache-v1.json",
          "bytes": 5381838,
          "sha256": "62f4910578c7b65392d26619cf81b31afd6142f38aa49834a70bb147e7ab222d",
          "availability": "digest_reference"
        }
      ],
      "newness_scope": "New to the reviewed candidate mechanism catalogue, source prediction already published; not first discovery.",
      "formal_RPS": null,
      "rank": null,
      "success_probability": null,
      "human_scientific_review": null,
      "experimental_superconductivity": null,
      "room_temperature_support": null,
      "quantified_physical_bandwidth": null,
      "quantified_mobile_carrier_density": null,
      "whole_BZ_stability": null,
      "global_thermodynamic_stability": null
    }
  ]
}
