Loading reported materials and source evidence.
Each property selection has its own source, conditions and result identity. Expand a value to inspect them. Observed and Computed describe the source report; catalogue eligibility and a clear anomaly check do not establish scientific validity. Different properties need not describe the same sample or state.
Missing pressure is not ambient pressure. Text structure claims remain separate from validated coordinates. A source-linked value does not override a material review hold. Source recovery candidates and external calculated references do not replace selected measurements.
Not reported. A legacy catalogue value is not substituted without its contributing result.
Selection: none. Catalogue property only, not a joint observation.
Not reported. A legacy catalogue value is not substituted without its contributing result.
Selection: none. Catalogue property only, not a joint observation.
Unknown, not reported, reported false and not applicable are distinct states. A scoped negative report does not establish universal absence. Reported classifications are source assertions, not scientific approval or a joint Tc/state observation.
| Property | Reported status / value | Evidence and conditions |
|---|---|---|
| Pairing symmetry | UnknownNot a negative finding Basis: unresolved retained records | Inspect 5 retained reports
|
Each row is a retained extraction with its own conditions and source.
Tc type and lexical criterion remain separate retained fields.
Retained values and catalogue eligibility do not establish scientific approval. Operational anomaly checks flag records for review; no findings is not scientific validation. Repeated reports are not independent replications. Open each row’s review details or the retained-record Archive to inspect the supplied policy metadata.
| Retained Tc (K) | Record origin / role | Review | P (GPa) | Sample | Method | Pairing | Year | Source tier | Paper |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| —Criterion not supplied | Observedprimary source role | Review detailsPolicy: anomaly-review/1.0.0. No findings is not scientific acceptance. A format issue means the parser or metadata needs review, not that the physics is impossible. Result: legacy-result:896f0ccba1b66ac5ea3c327c327f31517342aa8a50abba4c71f603ebc23bdf63 Operational references are review triggers, not physical upper limits. Values are not clipped or replaced by this display; source corrections require separate evidence-backed revision. |
Catalogue eligible — not scientific approval
Catalogue eligibility is a read-policy decision, not experimental confirmation or permission to use every property for ML.
Policy: material-visibility/1.0.0 · source status: active · review revision: 627455df26e79005214ed28ce65b1ed60672070701e30be788783199c558bcf7
Only scientific fields authorized by the server for this material are shown. This is not a full historical archive, the complete source document or a guarantee that all previously excluded data can be recovered. Restricted or quarantined data is not retrieved through another route.
Policy: anomaly-review/1.0.0 · scope: retained material records · field policy: scientific allowlist, not full source
Showing 6 returned records. Raw means the retained extraction representation; it is not necessarily a verbatim source quotation or an accepted scientific result.
Download authorized Archive with review metadata (JSON)Textual phase, crystal and space-group claims remain proposals until their material, sample/state and source revision are reviewed. Literal text matching is not scientific approval. No validated coordinates or structural descriptors are supplied by this view.
Retained proposals: 0 · Unassigned mentions: 0. Counts are not independent structures or accepted results.
Not reported. A legacy catalogue value is not substituted without its contributing result.
Selection: none. Catalogue property only, not a joint observation.
Not reported. A legacy catalogue value is not substituted without its contributing result.
Selection: none. Catalogue property only, not a joint observation.
Not reported. A legacy catalogue value is not substituted without its contributing result.
Selection: none. Catalogue property only, not a joint observation.
Not reported. A legacy catalogue value is not substituted without its contributing result.
Selection: none. Catalogue property only, not a joint observation.
Not reported. A legacy catalogue value is not substituted without its contributing result.
Selection: none. Catalogue property only, not a joint observation.
Notes: legacy summary missing not recomputed
These are retained proposals, not public-eligible headline selections. Some may require anomaly review; numerical display does not approve them for scientific use.
AFM · record origin: Observed · not the headline selection
See which fields are retained, which need source review, and where missing information can be recovered.
Checking linked source chunks…
Materials Project structures with the same fixed composition. Phase, sample and pressure correspondence require separate review.
Loading calculated reference data…
Published crystal metadata matched by composition. These references are separate from this material’s retained properties; sample and phase correspondence need review.
Open private field cases for this material · Authorized workspace; source proposals remain pending.
not reported or not extracted unresolved
Retained report: Unavailable
Source assertion only; not a verified material property.
Result: legacy-semantics:896f0ccba1b66ac5ea3c327c327f31517342aa8a50abba4c71f603ebc23bdf63 · revision: Unknown
Retained occurrences: 2 · repeated records are not replications.
arxiv:2506.16869Identifiers: paper_id: arxiv:2506.16869
Source status: active · origin: Observed · role: primary
Method: STM · evidence status: unknown
{
"sample_form": "thin_film",
"substrate": "Ta",
"pressure": {
"state": "not_reported",
"relation": "unreported",
"value": null,
"lower": null,
"upper": null,
"uncertainty": null
}
}not reported or not extracted unresolved
Retained report: Unavailable
Source assertion only; not a verified material property.
Result: legacy-semantics:9540b567abe75ebe131a68df6dce1b33dc84fb9c954931c53ae26c6165825dab · revision: Unknown
Retained occurrences: 1 · repeated records are not replications.
aps:10.1103/cvnq-glw1Identifiers: paper_id: aps:10.1103/cvnq-glw1
Source status: active · origin: Observed · role: primary
Method: STM · evidence status: unknown
{
"sample_form": "thin_film",
"substrate": "Nb(110)",
"pressure": {
"state": "not_reported",
"relation": "unreported",
"value": null,
"lower": null,
"upper": null,
"uncertainty": null
}
}not reported or not extracted unresolved
Retained report: Unavailable
Source assertion only; not a verified material property.
Result: legacy-semantics:ceaa4c0bc55ae7d765627f9339e11a6a608439b9ba4013be5b258fbbf992e6f0 · revision: Unknown
Retained occurrences: 1 · repeated records are not replications.
aps:10.1103/PhysRevB.105.L100406Identifiers: paper_id: aps:10.1103/PhysRevB.105.L100406
Source status: active · origin: Observed · role: primary
Method: STM · evidence status: unknown
{
"sample_form": "thin_film",
"substrate": "Nb(110)",
"pressure": {
"state": "not_reported",
"relation": "unreported",
"value": null,
"lower": null,
"upper": null,
"uncertainty": null
}
}not reported or not extracted unresolved
Retained report: Unavailable
Source assertion only; not a verified material property.
Result: legacy-semantics:d0591406abbd12c3d03a608b27cc668090bb4c275fcffb6bd0c7c4d165e3acc6 · revision: Unknown
Retained occurrences: 1 · repeated records are not replications.
aps:10.1103/PhysRevB.109.L121301Identifiers: paper_id: aps:10.1103/PhysRevB.109.L121301
Source status: active · origin: Observed · role: primary
Method: Not reported · evidence status: unknown
{
"sample_form": "thin_film",
"substrate": "Nb(110)",
"pressure": {
"state": "not_reported",
"relation": "unreported",
"value": null,
"lower": null,
"upper": null,
"uncertainty": null
}
}not reported or not extracted unresolved
Reasons: no eligible reported value
| Unconventional classification | UnknownNot a negative finding Basis: unresolved retained records | Inspect 5 retained reports
Reasons: no eligible reported value |
|---|
| Competing-order report | Reported trueSource-reported · not verified Basis: consistent eligible reported occurrences | Inspect 5 retained reports
Reasons: legacy summary not source supported |
|---|
Priors are assumptions for research context. They do not populate reported-property cells or classification filters, and are not observed labels for ML.
No priors supplied in this response.
Not detected by this check
Count: 0
Variation across Tc values or state metadata is not itself a scientific dispute.
Not detected by this check
Count: 0
An extraction inconsistency needs source inspection; it does not adjudicate the underlying physics.
No dispute report in this metadata
Count: 0
No report is not proof of consensus. An explicit dispute remains unadjudicated.
DOI, arXiv and catalogue identifiers may refer to the same work. Legacy paper links may include parent rollups or a different catalogue policy, so these counts need not match. Multiple occurrences or papers do not establish independent experimental replication, agreement, or scientific validity.
Count basis: bibliographic identifiers in assessed raw occurrences; legacy total papers can include parent rollups or other catalogue policy
| Pressure not reported |
| thin_film |
| STM |
| — |
| 2025 |
| — |
| 2506.16869 |
| —Criterion not supplied | Observedprimary source role | Review detailsPolicy: anomaly-review/1.0.0. No findings is not scientific acceptance. A format issue means the parser or metadata needs review, not that the physics is impossible. Result: legacy-result:896f0ccba1b66ac5ea3c327c327f31517342aa8a50abba4c71f603ebc23bdf63 Operational references are review triggers, not physical upper limits. Values are not clipped or replaced by this display; source corrections require separate evidence-backed revision. | Pressure not reported | thin_film | STM | — | 2025 | — | 2506.16869 |
| —Criterion not supplied | Observedprimary source role | Review detailsPolicy: anomaly-review/1.0.0. No findings is not scientific acceptance. A format issue means the parser or metadata needs review, not that the physics is impossible. Result: legacy-result:9540b567abe75ebe131a68df6dce1b33dc84fb9c954931c53ae26c6165825dab Operational references are review triggers, not physical upper limits. Values are not clipped or replaced by this display; source corrections require separate evidence-backed revision. | Pressure not reported | thin_film | STM | — | 2025 | T1 | DOI: 10.1103/cvnq-glw1 |
| —Criterion not supplied | Observedprimary source role | Review detailsPolicy: anomaly-review/1.0.0. No findings is not scientific acceptance. A format issue means the parser or metadata needs review, not that the physics is impossible. Result: legacy-result:666ba5c2fd471f8ed82b77b71ce0ffb3af8630bb9af18da41946488cff304499 Operational references are review triggers, not physical upper limits. Values are not clipped or replaced by this display; source corrections require separate evidence-backed revision. | Pressure not reported | thin_film | STM | — | 2025 | T1 | DOI: 10.1103/cvnq-glw1 |
| —Criterion not supplied | Observedprimary source role | Review detailsPolicy: anomaly-review/1.0.0. No findings is not scientific acceptance. A format issue means the parser or metadata needs review, not that the physics is impossible. Result: legacy-result:d0591406abbd12c3d03a608b27cc668090bb4c275fcffb6bd0c7c4d165e3acc6 Operational references are review triggers, not physical upper limits. Values are not clipped or replaced by this display; source corrections require separate evidence-backed revision. | Pressure not reported | thin_film | — | — | 2024 | T1 | DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevB.109.L121301 |
| —Criterion not supplied | Observedprimary source role | Review detailsPolicy: anomaly-review/1.0.0. No findings is not scientific acceptance. A format issue means the parser or metadata needs review, not that the physics is impossible. Result: legacy-result:ceaa4c0bc55ae7d765627f9339e11a6a608439b9ba4013be5b258fbbf992e6f0 Operational references are review triggers, not physical upper limits. Values are not clipped or replaced by this display; source corrections require separate evidence-backed revision. | Pressure not reported | thin_film | STM | — | 2022 | T1 | DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevB.105.L100406 |
Returned record index: 0. This index is not a persistent scientific identity.
Policy: anomaly-review/1.0.0. No findings is not scientific acceptance. A format issue means the parser or metadata needs review, not that the physics is impossible.
Result: legacy-result:d0591406abbd12c3d03a608b27cc668090bb4c275fcffb6bd0c7c4d165e3acc6
Operational references are review triggers, not physical upper limits. Values are not clipped or replaced by this display; source corrections require separate evidence-backed revision.
{
"confidence": 0.8,
"evidence_type": "primary_experimental",
"formula": "Mn",
"measurement": "unknown",
"paper_id": "aps:10.1103/PhysRevB.109.L121301",
"sample_form": "thin_film",
"substrate": "Nb(110)",
"tc_type": "unknown",
"year": 2024
}Returned record index: 1. This index is not a persistent scientific identity.
Policy: anomaly-review/1.0.0. No findings is not scientific acceptance. A format issue means the parser or metadata needs review, not that the physics is impossible.
Result: legacy-result:ceaa4c0bc55ae7d765627f9339e11a6a608439b9ba4013be5b258fbbf992e6f0
Operational references are review triggers, not physical upper limits. Values are not clipped or replaced by this display; source corrections require separate evidence-backed revision.
{
"confidence": 0.9,
"evidence_type": "primary_experimental",
"formula": "Mn",
"measurement": "STM",
"paper_id": "aps:10.1103/PhysRevB.105.L100406",
"sample_form": "thin_film",
"substrate": "Nb(110)",
"tc_type": "unknown",
"year": 2022
}Returned record index: 2. This index is not a persistent scientific identity.
Policy: anomaly-review/1.0.0. No findings is not scientific acceptance. A format issue means the parser or metadata needs review, not that the physics is impossible.
Result: legacy-result:896f0ccba1b66ac5ea3c327c327f31517342aa8a50abba4c71f603ebc23bdf63
Operational references are review triggers, not physical upper limits. Values are not clipped or replaced by this display; source corrections require separate evidence-backed revision.
{
"confidence": 0.9,
"evidence_type": "primary_experimental",
"formula": "Mn",
"measurement": "STM",
"paper_id": "arxiv:2506.16869",
"sample_form": "thin_film",
"substrate": "Ta",
"tc_type": "unknown",
"year": 2025
}Returned record index: 3. This index is not a persistent scientific identity.
Policy: anomaly-review/1.0.0. No findings is not scientific acceptance. A format issue means the parser or metadata needs review, not that the physics is impossible.
Result: legacy-result:896f0ccba1b66ac5ea3c327c327f31517342aa8a50abba4c71f603ebc23bdf63
Operational references are review triggers, not physical upper limits. Values are not clipped or replaced by this display; source corrections require separate evidence-backed revision.
{
"confidence": 0.9,
"evidence_type": "primary_experimental",
"formula": "Mn",
"measurement": "STM",
"paper_id": "arxiv:2506.16869",
"sample_form": "thin_film",
"substrate": "Ta",
"tc_type": "unknown",
"year": 2025
}Returned record index: 4. This index is not a persistent scientific identity.
Policy: anomaly-review/1.0.0. No findings is not scientific acceptance. A format issue means the parser or metadata needs review, not that the physics is impossible.
Result: legacy-result:9540b567abe75ebe131a68df6dce1b33dc84fb9c954931c53ae26c6165825dab
Operational references are review triggers, not physical upper limits. Values are not clipped or replaced by this display; source corrections require separate evidence-backed revision.
{
"confidence": 0.9,
"evidence_type": "primary_experimental",
"formula": "Mn",
"measurement": "STM",
"paper_id": "aps:10.1103/cvnq-glw1",
"sample_form": "thin_film",
"substrate": "Nb(110)",
"tc_type": "unknown",
"year": 2025
}Returned record index: 5. This index is not a persistent scientific identity.
Policy: anomaly-review/1.0.0. No findings is not scientific acceptance. A format issue means the parser or metadata needs review, not that the physics is impossible.
Result: legacy-result:666ba5c2fd471f8ed82b77b71ce0ffb3af8630bb9af18da41946488cff304499
Operational references are review triggers, not physical upper limits. Values are not clipped or replaced by this display; source corrections require separate evidence-backed revision.
{
"confidence": 0.9,
"evidence_type": "primary_experimental",
"formula": "Mn",
"measurement": "STM",
"paper_id": "aps:10.1103/cvnq-glw1",
"sample_form": "thin_film",
"substrate": "Ta(110)",
"tc_type": "unknown",
"year": 2025
}Not reported. A legacy catalogue value is not substituted without its contributing result.
Selection: none. Catalogue property only, not a joint observation.
Not reported. A legacy catalogue value is not substituted without its contributing result.
Selection: none. Catalogue property only, not a joint observation.
No association-complete EPC input is established here. Separately selected λ and ω_log must not be combined as paired calculation inputs.
A shared structure, state and compatible run protocol or an explicit reviewed match is required. Missing run/state association is not inferred from formula, pressure or paper alone.
Association notes: independent property selections are not an epc pair · allen dynes applicability not assessed
Record-level classification does not independently establish how each property was measured, computed or inferred.
Policy: anomaly-review/1.0.0. No findings is not scientific acceptance. A format issue means the parser or metadata needs review, not that the physics is impossible.
Result: legacy-result:ceaa4c0bc55ae7d765627f9339e11a6a608439b9ba4013be5b258fbbf992e6f0
Operational references are review triggers, not physical upper limits. Values are not clipped or replaced by this display; source corrections require separate evidence-backed revision.
One source record; not a reconstruction from independently selected lattice and symmetry fields.
Not reported. A legacy catalogue value is not substituted without its contributing result.
Selection: none. Catalogue property only, not a joint observation.
Not reported. A legacy catalogue value is not substituted without its contributing result.
Selection: none. Catalogue property only, not a joint observation.
Not reported. A legacy catalogue value is not substituted without its contributing result.
Selection: none. Catalogue property only, not a joint observation.
Not reported. A legacy catalogue value is not substituted without its contributing result.
Selection: none · catalogue median. Catalogue property only, not a joint observation.
Notes: catalogue statistic not joint observation
Record-level classification does not independently establish how each property was measured, computed or inferred.
Policy: anomaly-review/1.0.0. No findings is not scientific acceptance. A format issue means the parser or metadata needs review, not that the physics is impossible.
Result: legacy-result:666ba5c2fd471f8ed82b77b71ce0ffb3af8630bb9af18da41946488cff304499
Operational references are review triggers, not physical upper limits. Values are not clipped or replaced by this display; source corrections require separate evidence-backed revision.
One source record; not a reconstruction from independently selected lattice and symmetry fields.
Selection: legacy exact support. Catalogue property only, not a joint observation.
Notes: state structure association incomplete
These are retained proposals, not public-eligible headline selections. Some may require anomaly review; numerical display does not approve them for scientific use.
thin_film · record origin: Observed · not the headline selection
Record-level classification does not independently establish how each property was measured, computed or inferred.
Policy: anomaly-review/1.0.0. No findings is not scientific acceptance. A format issue means the parser or metadata needs review, not that the physics is impossible.
Result: legacy-result:896f0ccba1b66ac5ea3c327c327f31517342aa8a50abba4c71f603ebc23bdf63
Operational references are review triggers, not physical upper limits. Values are not clipped or replaced by this display; source corrections require separate evidence-backed revision.
One source record; not a reconstruction from independently selected lattice and symmetry fields.
thin_film · record origin: Observed · not the headline selection
thin_film · record origin: Observed · not the headline selection
thin_film · record origin: Observed · not the headline selection
Record-level classification does not independently establish how each property was measured, computed or inferred.
Policy: anomaly-review/1.0.0. No findings is not scientific acceptance. A format issue means the parser or metadata needs review, not that the physics is impossible.
Result: legacy-result:9540b567abe75ebe131a68df6dce1b33dc84fb9c954931c53ae26c6165825dab
Operational references are review triggers, not physical upper limits. Values are not clipped or replaced by this display; source corrections require separate evidence-backed revision.
One source record; not a reconstruction from independently selected lattice and symmetry fields.
Selection: legacy exact support. Catalogue property only, not a joint observation.
Notes: state structure association incomplete
These are retained proposals, not public-eligible headline selections. Some may require anomaly review; numerical display does not approve them for scientific use.
Ta(110) · record origin: Observed · not the headline selection
Not reported. A legacy catalogue value is not substituted without its contributing result.
Selection: none. Catalogue property only, not a joint observation.
Not reported. A legacy catalogue value is not substituted without its contributing result.
Selection: none. Catalogue property only, not a joint observation.
Not reported. A legacy catalogue value is not substituted without its contributing result.
Selection: none · catalogue median. Catalogue property only, not a joint observation.
Notes: catalogue statistic not joint observation
Not reported. A legacy catalogue value is not substituted without its contributing result.
Selection: none. Catalogue property only, not a joint observation.
Not reported. A legacy catalogue value is not substituted without its contributing result.
Selection: none. Catalogue property only, not a joint observation.
Not reported. A legacy catalogue value is not substituted without its contributing result.
Selection: none. Catalogue property only, not a joint observation.
Record-level classification does not independently establish how each property was measured, computed or inferred.
Policy: anomaly-review/1.0.0. No findings is not scientific acceptance. A format issue means the parser or metadata needs review, not that the physics is impossible.
Result: legacy-result:9540b567abe75ebe131a68df6dce1b33dc84fb9c954931c53ae26c6165825dab
Operational references are review triggers, not physical upper limits. Values are not clipped or replaced by this display; source corrections require separate evidence-backed revision.
One source record; not a reconstruction from independently selected lattice and symmetry fields.
Record-level classification does not independently establish how each property was measured, computed or inferred.
Policy: anomaly-review/1.0.0. No findings is not scientific acceptance. A format issue means the parser or metadata needs review, not that the physics is impossible.
Result: legacy-result:ceaa4c0bc55ae7d765627f9339e11a6a608439b9ba4013be5b258fbbf992e6f0
Operational references are review triggers, not physical upper limits. Values are not clipped or replaced by this display; source corrections require separate evidence-backed revision.
One source record; not a reconstruction from independently selected lattice and symmetry fields.
Record-level classification does not independently establish how each property was measured, computed or inferred.
Policy: anomaly-review/1.0.0. No findings is not scientific acceptance. A format issue means the parser or metadata needs review, not that the physics is impossible.
Result: legacy-result:d0591406abbd12c3d03a608b27cc668090bb4c275fcffb6bd0c7c4d165e3acc6
Operational references are review triggers, not physical upper limits. Values are not clipped or replaced by this display; source corrections require separate evidence-backed revision.
One source record; not a reconstruction from independently selected lattice and symmetry fields.
Record-level classification does not independently establish how each property was measured, computed or inferred.
Policy: anomaly-review/1.0.0. No findings is not scientific acceptance. A format issue means the parser or metadata needs review, not that the physics is impossible.
Result: legacy-result:666ba5c2fd471f8ed82b77b71ce0ffb3af8630bb9af18da41946488cff304499
Operational references are review triggers, not physical upper limits. Values are not clipped or replaced by this display; source corrections require separate evidence-backed revision.
One source record; not a reconstruction from independently selected lattice and symmetry fields.
Ta · record origin: Observed · not the headline selection
Record-level classification does not independently establish how each property was measured, computed or inferred.
Policy: anomaly-review/1.0.0. No findings is not scientific acceptance. A format issue means the parser or metadata needs review, not that the physics is impossible.
Result: legacy-result:896f0ccba1b66ac5ea3c327c327f31517342aa8a50abba4c71f603ebc23bdf63
Operational references are review triggers, not physical upper limits. Values are not clipped or replaced by this display; source corrections require separate evidence-backed revision.
One source record; not a reconstruction from independently selected lattice and symmetry fields.
Nb(110) · record origin: Observed · not the headline selection
Record-level classification does not independently establish how each property was measured, computed or inferred.
Policy: anomaly-review/1.0.0. No findings is not scientific acceptance. A format issue means the parser or metadata needs review, not that the physics is impossible.
Result: legacy-result:ceaa4c0bc55ae7d765627f9339e11a6a608439b9ba4013be5b258fbbf992e6f0
Operational references are review triggers, not physical upper limits. Values are not clipped or replaced by this display; source corrections require separate evidence-backed revision.
One source record; not a reconstruction from independently selected lattice and symmetry fields.
Nb(110) · record origin: Observed · not the headline selection
Record-level classification does not independently establish how each property was measured, computed or inferred.
Policy: anomaly-review/1.0.0. No findings is not scientific acceptance. A format issue means the parser or metadata needs review, not that the physics is impossible.
Result: legacy-result:d0591406abbd12c3d03a608b27cc668090bb4c275fcffb6bd0c7c4d165e3acc6
Operational references are review triggers, not physical upper limits. Values are not clipped or replaced by this display; source corrections require separate evidence-backed revision.
One source record; not a reconstruction from independently selected lattice and symmetry fields.