Comment on "Origin of correlated isolated flat bands in copper-substituted lead phosphate apatite"
Michael W. Swift, John L. Lyons
arXiv:2308.08458 · 2023-08-15
Active bibliographic source — not scientific approval
Bibliographic access preserves source history; it does not approve extracted materials or validate reported claims. Review warnings on each occurrence separately.
Abstract
In this comment on "Origin of correlated isolated flat bands in copper-substituted lead phosphate apatite" (arXiv:2307.16892 [cond-mat.supr-con]), we discuss the flat half-occupied two-band manifold that appears in $\mathrm{Pb}_9\mathrm{Cu}(\mathrm{PO}_4)_6(\mathrm{OH})_2$ when using a semilocal DFT functional. We argue that the flat band is an artifact of the functional's overestimation of the energy of the oxygen p states in the valence band. When using the HSE hybrid functional, the energy of the oxygen p states is reduced, and the copper-derived manifold splits into one fully occupied and one empty band. While these results do not rule out the possibility of superconductivity in doped LK-99, they do predict that stoichiometric $\mathrm{Pb}_9\mathrm{Cu}(\mathrm{PO}_4)_6(\mathrm{OH})_2$ is an insulator, not a superconductor. Furthermore, we have shown that future first-principles studies of these materials should employ hybrid functionals or other advanced methods to ensure that the oxygen-derived valence-band energies are correctly described.
Similar papers
Electronic correlations in promising room-temperature superconductor PbCu(PO)O: a DFT+DMFT study
similarity 0.92Dmitry M. Korotin et al. · 2023 · arXiv:2308.04301
Source status unknown — claims are unverified
Different phase leads to different transport behavior in PbCu(PO)O compounds
similarity 0.90Ran Liu et al. · 2023 · arXiv:2308.08454
Source status unknown — claims are unverified
Electronic structure of the putative room-temperature superconductor PbCu(PO)O
similarity 0.90Liang Si & Karsten Held · 2023 · arXiv:2308.00676
Source status unknown — claims are unverified
Berry curvature and quantum metric in copper-substituted lead phosphate apatite
similarity 0.90Wei Chen · 2023 · arXiv:2308.05124
Source status unknown — claims are unverified
Deciphering the Enigma of Cu-Doped Lead Apatite (LK-99): Structural Insights, Electronic Properties, and Implications for Ambient-Pressure Superconductivity
similarity 0.90Jun Li & Qi An · 2023 · arXiv:2309.07928
Source status unknown — claims are unverified
Edge-sharing quasi-one-dimensional cuprate fragments in optimally substituted Cu/Pb apatite
similarity 0.90Katherine Inzani et al. · 2023 · arXiv:2312.14236
Source status unknown — claims are unverified