Comment on "Ballistic Majorana Nanowire Devices" by Gul et al. Nature Nanotechnology 2018
S. M. Frolov, V. Mourik
arXiv:2407.18623 · 2024-07-26
Active bibliographic source — not scientific approval
Bibliographic access preserves source history; it does not approve extracted materials or validate reported claims. Review warnings on each occurrence separately.
Abstract
This work re-analyzes Gul et al. Nature Nanotechnology 2018 "Ballistic Majorana nanowire devices" using fuller data from the original experiments released in 2023 on Zenodo. The authors have prepared a correction to their article that appeared in Nature Nanotechnology in 2024. However, the correction does not address the concerns we identify here. We demonstrate that the fuller data contain extensive evidence for quantum dots and disorder that are completely inconsistent with the authors' conclusion that they have achieved ballistic devices containing zero bias peaks of likely Majorana origin. We show how data selection, data cropping and undisclosed data processing played a role in composing the figures of the final published paper.
Similar papers
Crystalline Symmetry-Protected Majorana Mode in Number-Conserving Dirac Semimetal Nanowires
similarity 0.82Rui-Xing Zhang & Chao-Xing Liu · 2017 · arXiv:1708.01367
Source status unknown — claims are unverified
On controlling the bound states in quantum-dot hybrid-nanowire
similarity 0.82Andrzej Ptok et al. · 2017 · arXiv:1710.06387
Source status unknown — claims are unverified
Exposing impostor Majorana zero modes through atomic-scale shot-noise
similarity 0.81A. Maiti et al. · 2026 · arXiv:2604.26002
Source status unknown — claims are unverified
Substrate-induced Majorana renormalization in topological nanowires
similarity 0.81S. Das Sarma et al. · 2015 · arXiv:1503.00594
Source status unknown — claims are unverified
Transport features of a topological superconducting nanowire with a quantum dot: Conductance and noise
similarity 0.81Leonel Gruñeiro et al.
Source status unknown — claims are unverified
Diabatic error and propagation of Majorana zero modes in interacting quantum dots systems
similarity 0.81Bradraj Pandey et al. · 2025 · arXiv:2501.06288
Source status unknown — claims are unverified