On themomagnetic effects due to the supeconducting fluctuations: Reply to arXiv:1012.4361 by Serbyn, Skvortsov, and Varlamov

Andrei Sergeev; Michael Reizer; Vladimir Mitin

On themomagnetic effects due to the supeconducting fluctuations: Reply to arXiv:1012.4361 by Serbyn, Skvortsov, and Varlamov

Andrei Sergeev, Michael Reizer, Vladimir Mitin

arXiv:1101.4186 · 2011-01-21

Active bibliographic source — not scientific approval

Bibliographic access preserves source history; it does not approve extracted materials or validate reported claims. Review warnings on each occurrence separately.

Abstract

In a recent Reply [arXiv:1012.4361] to our Comment [arXiv:0906.2389, accepted to PRL], Serbyn, Skvortsov, and Varlamov raised a question of microscopic description, which we did not touch in Comment, and criticized our work [Phys. Rev. B 77, 064501 (2008)]. They hopefully agreed with one of our key result that the effective heat current vertex for fluctuating Cooper pairs (the Aslamzov-Larkin block in the diagram technique) is modified in the magnetic field, so "the heat current is proportional to the gauge-invariant momentum". However, they stated that we have overlooked the same correction to the electric current vertex and in this way we lost their huge thermomagnetic effect that does not require any particle-hole asymmetry and, therefore, prevails over the ordinary thermomagnetic effects by at least five orders in magnitude in ordinary superconductors near T_c and strongly dominates in the temperature range up to ~ 100 T_c. Here we address their criticism with all details and show that our calculations are correct.