Does the Meissner effect violate the second law of thermodynamics? Comment on "The Law of Entropy Increase and the Meissner Effect" by A. Nikulov
J. E. Hirsch
arXiv:2410.14704 · DOI 10.1016/j.physc.2024.1354618 · 2024-10-07 · Physica C: Superconductivity and its Applications
Active bibliographic source — not scientific approval
Bibliographic access preserves source history; it does not approve extracted materials or validate reported claims. Review warnings on each occurrence separately.
Abstract
In Entropy 24, 83 (2022) [1], titled "The Law of Entropy Increase and the Meissner Effect", A. Nikulov claims that the Meissner effect exhibited by type I superconductors violates the second law of thermodynamics. Contrary to this claim, I show that the Meissner effect is consistent with the second law of thermodynamics provided that a mechanism exists for the supercurrent to start and stop without generation of Joule heat. The theory of hole superconductivity provides such a mechanism, the conventional theory of superconductivity does not. It requires the existence of hole carriers in the normal state of the system.
Source-reported materials — not catalogue approval
| Formula | Reported Tc (K) | Pressure (GPa) | Type |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tl Archive — visibility unverified Source-occurrence policy only; no material identity or catalogue acceptance is inferred from the formula. | — | Pressure not reported | unknown |
| Sn Archive — visibility unverified Source-occurrence policy only; no material identity or catalogue acceptance is inferred from the formula. | — | Pressure not reported | unknown |
Similar papers
Towards an understanding of hole superconductivity
similarity 0.90J. E. Hirsch · 2017 · arXiv:1704.07452
Source status unknown — claims are unverified
Alfven-like waves along normal-superconductor phase boundaries
similarity 0.90J. E. Hirsch · 2019 · arXiv:1906.03083
Source status unknown — claims are unverified
On a recent explanation of the dynamics of the Meissner effect within the conventional theory of superconductivity
similarity 0.90J. E. Hirsch · 2026 · arXiv:2512.16938
Source status unknown — claims are unverified
Momentum of superconducting electrons and the explanation of the Meissner effect
similarity 0.89J. E. Hirsch
Source status unknown — claims are unverified
Dynamics of the normal-superconductor phase transition and the puzzle of the Meissner effect
similarity 0.89J. E. Hirsch · 2015 · arXiv:1504.05190
Source status unknown — claims are unverified
Momentum of superconducting electrons and the explanation of the Meissner effect
similarity 0.89Hirsch, J. E. · 2017 · arXiv:1609.08451
Source status unknown — claims are unverified